10 Eyeshadow Palettes I'm Glad I DIDN'T Buy!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 331

  • @tammybrock5366
    @tammybrock5366 5 років тому +59

    The controversy palette is so ugly. I personally would never buy it.

  • @XDTini
    @XDTini 5 років тому +62

    THANKS, I thought I was the only one who thought the Conspiracy palette was ugly 😂

  • @Stacey_LaValley_Lambert
    @Stacey_LaValley_Lambert 5 років тому +11

    Glad we are on the same page. Norvina colour schemes were too bright, Urban Decay bores me, Jeffree Star scares me, and Tati just doesn’t need my money. That’s my truth.

  • @andreasamudio7272
    @andreasamudio7272 5 років тому +139

    I really appreciate what you said about jefree star and shane dawson. I don’t get why suddenly people are soo into jeffree star. I don’t even keep up with his drama but he seems overall an awful person to support. I feel like a lot of youtubers, even ones I used to really enjoy (jen luvs reviews is a clear example) have too many double standards, and now that everyone is on the jefree star train, they are ok with reviewing hid stuff while they refuse to showcase kat von d for example. I find it extremely hypocritical of them. They just support jefree star because everyone forgot about his shit and suddenly he’s cool. If suddenly kat von d gets cool again they’ll just forget all about their morals and get back on that train.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +14

      That's a really good point. I think, unfortunately, J* is so overwhelming popular and seems to dominate a section of the beauty community. People want in on that.

    • @ftcmua
      @ftcmua 5 років тому +19

      At the end, I stopped Purchasing from JS for the same reason I stopped purchasing from KVD lol. They both have a long history of attacking their followers and customers when they don’t agree with them, which I find very concerning. If you cannot handle customers, stay away from them. Even though customers are not always write, calling them out by name on your platform when you have millions of followers is never right

    • @andreasamudio7272
      @andreasamudio7272 5 років тому +11

      Js just seems like the worst type of reality show celebrity. I used to enjoy jen luvs reviews but I agree that she seems to be sucking up to js, and it’s lame. She’s a hypocrite.

    • @MrsYasha1984
      @MrsYasha1984 5 років тому +14

      Jen rubs me the wrong way sometimes. Nothing serious, nothing to 'cancel' her over, but I don't trust her completely either. It's little things, nothing to invoke the wrath of cancel culture or something lile that. But I seldom watch her vids anymore

    • @jessiwave8
      @jessiwave8 5 років тому +10

      I'll never support him, couldn't pay me to. Everytime I turn around he's been so mean and backstabbing, just a repeat offender. There are so many other make-up lines that have integrity and excellent quality that do get my coins. How we treat each other matters and if you don't stand for something then you'll fall for anything!

  • @Mdi223
    @Mdi223 5 років тому +23

    I would love to see a duping the vive type video or series! I think it would fit your channel theme so very well and it would definitely inspire me to actually use what I have. Those two melts palettes are so beautiful, though!

  • @celestecelestial90
    @celestecelestial90 5 років тому +92

    I’m glad I didn’t buy the Tati palette! I don’t trust glitter on my eyes. I hate mattes with glitters and the colors are too similar for my taste. Also, I have those colors in my collection already so it wasn’t a good purchase for me personally.

    • @LamaMerhi
      @LamaMerhi 5 років тому +6

      I don't mind Tati. I got the palette since I don't have that many neutrals , and I'm really picky about my purchases, and objectively? It's really good. The sequins look really pretty on the eyes and I don't mind a little glitter fallout. It's a strange palette , sort of an acquired taste kind of thing. The more you use it the more you like it. Makeup tastes are different ofcourse, though

    • @celestecelestial90
      @celestecelestial90 5 років тому +2

      Lama Mer I was almost going to buy it, but told myself no because I wanted to buy another product more. Plus, I had the colors in my collection so it wouldn’t make sense for me. I’m happy that you enjoy the Tati palette! 😁I heard it’s good quality overall. I think how much we like a palette depends on our makeup style and if a product fills a void in our collection. I definitely have gone back to loving neutrals
      again in 2019, but I still use color. I feel most beautiful in barely there makeup, but I like to use pastels and colorful bright eyeshadow as artistic expression. 🌈

  • @thecadets1031
    @thecadets1031 5 років тому +32

    I love the dupe you did for the Melt palette. I thought you did a great job with it.

    • @daisycate
      @daisycate 5 років тому

      EverydayRuth Me, too! Lols beautiful all together but most of those colors aren’t flattering on my eyes, IMO.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      Thank you! It was fun to put it together

  • @zazaxoxo
    @zazaxoxo 5 років тому +77

    The JSC palette is straight up ugly. No one would ever buy it if it wasn’t for J* 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • @tiffprendergast
      @tiffprendergast 5 років тому +1

      Fati Machrou yup

    • @leahmommy7711
      @leahmommy7711 5 років тому +8

      That palette is hideous! I kept thinking to myself, am I missing something? Why are people going crazy about this? It’s ridiculous

    • @Sara-jc6oo
      @Sara-jc6oo 5 років тому

      Lol that's true cuz I ready got both of them for collection purposes

    • @shannonreynolds6507
      @shannonreynolds6507 5 років тому

      I love the outside but when they finally showed the inside i was like no way! The ugliest weirdest palette scheme. I didn’t like it at all. No way id ever buy it!

    • @JoeysMagGoth
      @JoeysMagGoth 5 років тому +3

      False!
      Not for J, but for Shane...

  • @AC-ff1cn
    @AC-ff1cn 5 років тому +34

    Tati was ok being friends with a racist because he was always nice to her so she just straight up sucks as a person.
    Mercury Retrograde is a beautiful palette, I’m quite glad I bought it. And UD Honey’s quality is so good, I wish all the others were as good.
    All the Norvina palettes looked like a mess.
    I’m glad I never got sucked into Natasha Denona and Pat McGrath. I refuse to pay those prices.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      Do you have the Naked Heat palette from UD? If so, how would you compare that to the Honey? Or any other of the UD Naked palettes if you have those- just curious!

    • @sashabee2012
      @sashabee2012 5 років тому +1

      @@shadowsmoked88 I have both... I like the Naked Heat mattes better than the the Honey ones, which seem to fade after a few hours, nevertheless the shimmers in the Honey palette are stunning, especially gold and honey, and I also like the Honey palette color range better than the Heat one. I had a few doubts about picking up the Honey palette, so I decided to buy it only when it would be on sale and that's what I did. Now I'm happy with my decision.
      I also own Naked, Naked2, Naked3 and Naked reloaded. Matte colors are the best in these palettes, but I'm not happy anymore with the original Naked, because of its color story. I like the Naked Reloaded very much for both mattes and shimmers, except for that greysh shimmery eyeshadow (I don't remember its name) which always ends up crumbling in a mess

    • @AC-ff1cn
      @AC-ff1cn 5 років тому

      @@shadowsmoked88 ​ I have all the Naked palettes except Reloaded and Naked 2. I find Honey is a vast improvement in the formula. I love Heat but if I apply it in the morning, it's gone by late afternoon. The dark colours are patchy and just don't have staying power. Honey is smooth and buttery (I know people hate that word but it fits here), very blendable and has great lasting power.

  • @elainebines6803
    @elainebines6803 5 років тому +7

    I always feel JS is laughing at us women. Derogatory naming of some shadows, hand mirrors of pigs - hey ho 🤔

  • @ambrosinemariya
    @ambrosinemariya 5 років тому +12

    can you do a video on products that didn’t age well? the most disappointing thing is when i buy something(like liquid shadows, for example) and it doesn’t last or the quality changes or it develops hardpan too quickly.

  • @ValentineLissar
    @ValentineLissar 5 років тому +25

    I like this kind of video because it’s nice to counteract the numerous videos taking about products they wished they bought or wanted to buy.

  • @hayleypflug7384
    @hayleypflug7384 5 років тому +26

    I loved what you said about how if someone compliments your eye look, and asks what's in your eyes, they aren't going to be disappointed by your answer. Weirdly enough, my looks that get any compliments at all are always colourpop palettes. Works for me lol.

    • @hannahroebem2820
      @hannahroebem2820 5 років тому +5

      They never give you compliments in the netherlands, they are sooo scared you're getting to vain if they do so, ridiculous, that's why I love Australians and americans

    • @janelle009
      @janelle009 5 років тому +2

      @@hannahroebem2820 I have actually heard that before! That's truly a bummer. If only there was a good happy medium! 💜💜

    • @hannahroebem2820
      @hannahroebem2820 5 років тому +4

      @@janelle009 that's right, I am trying to change that by giving people well meant compliments

    • @janelle009
      @janelle009 5 років тому +2

      @@hannahroebem2820 I love that ☺

  • @SisterWendy03
    @SisterWendy03 5 років тому +26

    It’s good to know that other people don’t like the Anastasia eyeshadow formula. I had modern Renaissance and Prism but gave them away. Great video! I’m on my second year long low/no buy and love these types of vids.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      Congrats on the second year!!

    • @nixfb8576
      @nixfb8576 5 років тому +1

      thankyou, i bulk bought 5 of them at once thinking they'd be amazing.... they are so dry. i use them but they aren't worth all the hype they receive

  • @graciesan9058
    @graciesan9058 5 років тому +6

    I only purchased 3 palettes this year. The Tati palette, Pat McGrath bronze seduction, and Charlotte Tillbury vintage vamp. Love them, and they are all I wear

  • @blueshoes915
    @blueshoes915 5 років тому +8

    I’m so glad that you stand your ground and stay true to your morals by not supporting people who do not share your morals. Sooo refreshing and I highly admire that. You just gained a new subscriber. I wish more people would do that. I’m not saying no one can make a mistake and learn from it. I mean the people that have proven to be racist, anti-Semitic, a narcissist, or of just general low ethical behavior. Being able to spot these types is also something important, not just online, but in real life.

  • @munbun75
    @munbun75 5 років тому +6

    “It doesn’t mean I’m right I just have so many feelings.”
    Mood.

  • @darklausal23
    @darklausal23 5 років тому +28

    You truly are an inspiration to keep my spending and makeup under control 😊

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +2

      That means a lot- thank you!

    • @heydanmonhawk
      @heydanmonhawk 5 років тому +1

      I agree. I have two obsessions, makeup & paper crafting, of which I do not need anymore of. I’m actively searching no buy/low buy content. Elle does help to reinforce my stance on not buying in 2020.

  • @calliegirl6710
    @calliegirl6710 5 років тому +1

    I have never liked any of the ABH palettes either until the 3 Norvina Pro Pigment palettes - might just be me but the formula is so vibrant and seems totally different than regular ABH formula...enjoying your channel so much!

  • @Cynni393
    @Cynni393 5 років тому +30

    **Also my Huda Desert Dusk palette aged terribly as well and I'm like wtf but it was so expensive so I am trying not to declutter it until the last minute** I have the Jackie Aina and the Norvina mini vol 2(got with a coupon and a gift card) and lots of Colourpop palettes this year. But ABH honestly went crazy this year and didn't give Jackie or Carli time to shine and it sucked for them cause they're great creators

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +7

      I agree about Jackie and Carli! I wish they had more time with their palettes in the spotlight.

    • @startracie
      @startracie 5 років тому +2

      Ugh. I hate that it aged poorly for you. I think she has my favorite eye shadow formula and totally didn’t have those experiences. So weird.

    • @emilyrebekah1
      @emilyrebekah1 5 років тому +1

      Yes totally!

    • @janelle009
      @janelle009 5 років тому

      @@startracie I've been wanting to try Huda forever! I swatched one of the palettes in Sephora that got quite crappy reviews and it felt so beautiful to me!

    • @Cynni393
      @Cynni393 5 років тому

      @@startracie I bought the Desert Dusk last 2017 and mid 2018 it stopped working well for me and the other day I repressed all the shimmers because I want to pan that palette completely this year 2020

  • @MishkaMeshel
    @MishkaMeshel 5 років тому +25

    I love ABH shadows. I actually find their mattes to be really good! I've never had issues even with the subculture palette. And I haven't hit pan on any of them and use them quite a bit! I guess I'm not as heavy handed as others. But I totally agree with you on Tati. I don't trust her and would never support her. But her shadows didn't look interesting to me.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +4

      Subculture is one of the ABH palettes I have and I like it! But it's definitely the colours I like more than the formula.

    • @MishkaMeshel
      @MishkaMeshel 5 років тому +1

      @@shadowsmoked88 the formula for that one is definitely very soft! I agree that their metallics are better!!!

    • @TracyD2
      @TracyD2 5 років тому

      I really like the ABH shadows as well but I am tiring of them. They lost me 6 months ago. Too too much.

  • @Mdi223
    @Mdi223 5 років тому +5

    Ha! I've just finished watching your previous video and just now you opload another one. Thank you for keeping me company during my work night

  • @basicindiebro
    @basicindiebro 5 років тому +1

    off topic but i’ve been watching your channel for a while and i have to say that your general aesthetic is goals~

  • @skylilly1
    @skylilly1 5 років тому +65

    No to anything Tati. I kinda liked her channel pre Emily video. LOL Easy unsub after that and her other drama was atrocious and handled so very poorly, yikes. I will probably end up getting the Smoke Show before the new year. I have a few Anastasia palettes, but haven't purchased any in a good while. With you tube it's a lot easier to pass on palettes, and the fact I'm bursting at the seams with palettes already.

    • @MelsLife570
      @MelsLife570 5 років тому +10

      skylilly1 it was never anything to hurt Emily. Makeup Rev is hit & miss. And they’re one if my fav brands. As a sub to Tati & Emily, I’d have been disappointed if Tati said lied.

    • @ValentineLissar
      @ValentineLissar 5 років тому +3

      It’s definitely easier to pass on palettes now that I know how long it takes to pan one. I’m probably not going to buy any for another year or two.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      If you get Smoke Show I'd love to hear your thoughts!

    • @tatianafraserA
      @tatianafraserA 5 років тому +10

      I also unsubscribed after that because for me the issue was with the way she said it more than anything else and then playing poor Tati afterwards.

    • @cecileganel
      @cecileganel 5 років тому +2

      I got the smoke show set when it released. It was my first experience with colourpop palettes (or SSS, those were included in the set as well). I am very happy with the palette. I am a self described grey queen. I love the cool tones and I think the Smoke show is MY “neutral” palette and perfect for day to day wear. The greys have different undertones (purple/neutral/blue) and there is a true black and white which is perfect for creating a gradient with greys. It was a great purchase for me and my collection.
      Oh also I purchased the Lime Crime Venus Immortalis palette shortly before Smoke Show was released. Those two often get compared due to “similar” color stories. The LC palette is horrid and was twice the price of CP Smoke Show. I wish I would’ve saved my money.

  • @stampinprn
    @stampinprn 5 років тому +3

    I like these videos. They help to reaffirm my resolve to not buy as much anymore.

  • @susanstetson3435
    @susanstetson3435 5 років тому

    Melt is my new urban decay. I think they do pretty colorful palettes. It’s where I thought urban decay would be today but instead they got on the naked train and forgot to get off. Back in the day the naked palettes were more companions to add some neutrals to go with all the bright fun but sadly they took over.
    Loved this! Also loved your vibe dupe for melt and you did say it correctly!

  • @lemondropn
    @lemondropn 5 років тому

    Great video! I agree so much with so many of your thoughts, vids like this are sooooo needed in the makeup community

  • @LCx829
    @LCx829 5 років тому +18

    I’m glad I haven’t bought any Anastasia palettes either because it’s powdery and you’ll hit pan really fast. I’d still like that kvd palette on sale because I can’t afford $49 but I certainly don’t need it. I have an old flower beauty gray quad and it’s a great dupe for the smoke show. Tati is a grown woman but doesn’t handle things well. Many brand owners keep using social media to call people out and it’s just not professional imo.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      Yeah, it's ridiculously easy to hit pan on ABH shadows from my experience.
      And totally agree re: brand owners + social media!

    • @zazaxoxo
      @zazaxoxo 5 років тому

      I bought subculture almost two years ago and it was my only palette for almost a year and still haven’t pan any shade. I have 9 ABH palettes right now and they’re extremely pigmented so you can go light handed with em. Not my favorite formula but it’s definitely not that easy to pan.

    • @LCx829
      @LCx829 5 років тому +1

      Fati Machrou I’ve panned a abh palette in less than 6 months. You don’t get a lot of product in the pan and they’re powdery.

  • @bridgetnorris3025
    @bridgetnorris3025 5 років тому

    I’m glad you mentioned you like the abh shimmer formula. I like the mattes but I agree that to me the shimmers stand out and I wish they added more shimmers in their palettes- especially subculture! I think cool toned eyeshadows actually would make your eyes stand out even more with your eye color! I feel the same with Tati I think she’s still a cool person but those two incidents seemed immature for someone like her! I do like her palette- I think the pink glitter shades are stand out shades! The viseart palette is so pretty but seems so expensive maybe when I’m rich!

  • @prettyacct
    @prettyacct 5 років тому +1

    I've been over Tati since she got on YT and accused JC for being a sexual predator. Those are serious unfounded allegations that can ruin someone's life. She looks 40 acts 16 and I'm tired of her and her drama.

  • @zusamy20
    @zusamy20 5 років тому +5

    I love these videos :3, I mostly wait till the hype is done, then I decide
    If I want something. Btw you look like a greek goddess snow white. :)

  • @ghoultiful
    @ghoultiful 5 років тому +4

    Please dupe the vibe of the Muerte palette. I really want the mint, dark red, and dark blue the most.

  • @littlereddress82
    @littlereddress82 5 років тому +8

    I bought the smoke show from colour pop only because I didn't have those colors in my collection. I wanted some more cool toned shadows.

  • @MakeupwithMariela1
    @MakeupwithMariela1 5 років тому +2

    Only palette I have that you mentioned was the muerte palette loved your version of singles you created 👌🏼 so pretty!!

  • @TracyD2
    @TracyD2 5 років тому

    Thank you for voicing your opinion on these palettes and the people behind them. It’s nice to hear someone with similar viewpoints.

  • @TaraFye1
    @TaraFye1 5 років тому +6

    What are you wearing on your eyes and what lipstick is that? I LOVE that vampy, 1920s look!

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      It's the Too Faced Chocolate Gold palette and the lipstick is Stevie from ABH!

  • @JuliaHarrisx
    @JuliaHarrisx 5 років тому

    I wish i had found and listened to you before. I would have saved a fortune! I do like the Abh formulas but I didn’t go for the Norvina Pro Palettes. I also didn’t go for the UD Honey palette either! I’m with you. I have so many golds smattered among many palettes so meh. I think 2020 may be the year i seriously cut back on makeup as I’ve learnt no palette is more powerful than my need to save cash! Thanks for this video. Liked and subscribed because of it 💋 xx

  • @yahainHotPink
    @yahainHotPink 5 років тому +3

    Yes, we were on the same page in not buying the same palettes but for different reasons. 😉😊🎨 But I did purchase the Carli Bybel palette and the Norvina Vol 1 & 2 minis. Only of the palettes that you mentioned or alluded to. 😊😀 Love them.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      The mini Norvina palettes look really pretty!

    • @yahainHotPink
      @yahainHotPink 5 років тому

      @@shadowsmoked88 Thank you, they are. A little powdery but fun to use. 😉😊

  • @lolaphearse3688
    @lolaphearse3688 5 років тому +2

    Excellent Muerte dupe! Love dupe the vibes videos-will definitely watch!

  • @TrueSugar
    @TrueSugar 5 років тому +6

    I want a dupe the vibe video from you always

  • @clevername763
    @clevername763 5 років тому +2

    Seriously agree on the Tati drama. It felt to me that she was willing to turn the other way on James Charles being inappropriate and creepy until she was mad about endorsements. That really bothered me and I do think she is smart enough to know what she's doing at all times with business and perception. I do still want to try the Melt eyeshadow formula though. But I know not to buy until I get more honest with myself about what colors I actually wear vs just what I find beautiful to look at.

  • @amandawaldron715
    @amandawaldron715 5 років тому +1

    I loooove the Tati palette and the Amor Eterno palettes. No regrets on buying them!

    • @corachristel
      @corachristel 5 років тому

      I never wore orange eyeshadows until I got Tati’s palette. Something about the undertone of her orange is so flattering. Orange is one my favorite eyeshadow colors to incorporate now 🤗

  • @naomikman
    @naomikman 5 років тому +5

    Kelly gooch does amazing duping the vibes videos and i got a lot of inspiration from her for shopping my stash :) definitely recommend her channel!!

  • @tarribedford8388
    @tarribedford8388 5 років тому +18

    The tati palette is so amazing tho. I own an absurd amount of palettes and the tati is my fav, even out of the PM, ND, viseart, abh etc

    • @Kyaniteacres
      @Kyaniteacres 5 років тому +4

      Agreed, I love the Tati palette and am so thrilled with the purchase, the quality compares to my Natasha Denona palettes.

    • @Ieat2much
      @Ieat2much 5 років тому +2

      I am sure...the glitter fall out scared me. But I am def going to buy it at a later date. It’s beautiful

    • @cherylmaclean4349
      @cherylmaclean4349 5 років тому +3

      I have about 40 palettes and still want to buy Tati’s palette. It’s the only one I want to buy this year. Otherwise I’m on a no n]buy for at least 6 months.

    • @sincerelyfelicity2273
      @sincerelyfelicity2273 5 років тому +5

      I love my Tati palette too! I reach for it all the time and have zero regrets picking it up.

    • @amandawaldron715
      @amandawaldron715 5 років тому +3

      Tarri Bedford I agree! One of my favorite palettes!

  • @PalsLivesLife
    @PalsLivesLife 5 років тому +1

    Agree with so many of your thoughts. Actually had the exact same reaction with the KVD palette.

  • @sassybanjo3586
    @sassybanjo3586 5 років тому

    I agree with your no-buy choices. Have you seen the Berlin Underground palette by Nomad Cosmetics? It is so unique in neutral, grunge shades and nice texture.

  • @emilyrebekah1
    @emilyrebekah1 5 років тому +4

    PAT MCGRATH ALMOST GOT ME WITH STAR WARS BUT THE PRICE TAG 😭

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      RIGHT!??! I would do anything for that R2D2 balm

  • @dorottyazsofia
    @dorottyazsofia 5 років тому +9

    That is the exact reason I unsubbed from Tati - it truly shows her colors that she only called out James Charles after he promoted a rival company, sitting on these secrets forever...

    • @stacyketner
      @stacyketner 5 років тому +1

      I haven't watched her much since the Thrifthick stuff a year or so before the EmilyNoel stuff.

  • @gloryv855
    @gloryv855 5 років тому +4

    Wow... i feel the same way about tati

  • @yoursweetie1955
    @yoursweetie1955 5 років тому +2

    You look just gorgeous today! I have noticed that while I LOVE my Anastasia Beverly Hills palettes, they do really age poorly. The Tati palette is an interesting concept, but I don't need it at all. I love the Colourpop monochrome palettes that have purchased, and I will probably purchase the Smoke Show palette.As for the Friends palette...I LOVE Peachy Queen, but as Angelica Nyqvsit says, "the rainbow has already been curtated!" LOL!

  • @janelle009
    @janelle009 5 років тому +1

    Love this video so much! New subscriber! I love when UA-cam gets the recommendation right 😁

  • @HunterBoyleReacts
    @HunterBoyleReacts 5 років тому +18

    Totally concur on Tati.

  • @OhLanie
    @OhLanie 5 років тому +2

    I'm interested in your thoughts on the Pat McGrath Star Wars. I thought they were poorly done. She could have done SO much with that concept and it felt like a thrown together mis match cash grab to me.

  • @RedCupBookClub
    @RedCupBookClub 5 років тому +1

    I really like the ABH singles, but HATE the palette formula. I have gotten rid of all mine except the Soft Glam... and i've only used it twice.

  • @venusinblu
    @venusinblu 5 років тому

    I love ABH shadows (based on the one Jackie Aina palette i own), i used some last night without a base and it blended like a dream, i usually use conceler but i was rushing to get ready. I have smoke show but Im a bit intimidated to use cool tone shadows but I do love their formula so i know ill eventually get to it

  • @KuinKuu
    @KuinKuu 5 років тому +1

    I'd be interested in watching some kind of a Duping the vibe of the palette video/series. I try to do that with my palettes as well. I have 10 palettes and so far those have been enough to dupe all the other palettes I've wanted.
    P.S. I agree with everything you said about the Jeffree x Shane palettes.

  • @AFFTFOMSICHTS
    @AFFTFOMSICHTS 5 років тому

    I Sooo agree about the muerte palette! I thought it was gorgeous and still do but realistically i will never wear those shades enough to justify the purchase.

  • @clarinetpride55
    @clarinetpride55 5 років тому +5

    Idk why you have to have a disclaimer. If people give you a hard time for obvious opinions, then they're the sad ones that need to move along.

  • @MsMouthy
    @MsMouthy 5 років тому

    Oooh your lips matching your top is sooooooo pretty!

  • @doctorajaguar
    @doctorajaguar 5 років тому +8

    Love that you made a similar color story of the MELT Muerte palette!! Elle can you share wich singles did you choose for it?? Specially the reds and the grey.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +4

      I'll do a video soon and list everything!

  • @gailbook70
    @gailbook70 5 років тому +3

    Yay! Glad your video popped up. Luv your lipstick color. You are entitled to your opinion and how you feel about things. I enjoy hearing all about it. Your recent videos have been awesome. Keep them coming.
    Ok. That is it. . . get out of my brain woman. Lol. You have picked 99.9% of the same palettes that I am happy that I did not purchase and I have no regrets.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      Thank you so much!
      What was the palette you purchased/want to purchase?? I'm curious!

    • @gailbook70
      @gailbook70 5 років тому +1

      @@shadowsmoked88 I am such a sucker for the Urban Decay Naked palettes. Although I only have the Naked Heat and Naked, I always play with Naked Honey when I am at Ulta. Since I have the Uh Huh Honey palette from Colourpop, I am not purchasing Naked Honey yet. I need to use up more of my Colourpop or finish it before I go spend $54 on a palette. Not a moment sooner :)

    • @tiffprendergast
      @tiffprendergast 5 років тому

      gailbook70 same

  • @jamiecrucefix4078
    @jamiecrucefix4078 5 років тому

    Thank you Elle S.
    I really liked the that you shopped you singles to recreate the vibe of a palette on your wishlist please do it more!

  • @ValentineLissar
    @ValentineLissar 5 років тому +10

    Viseart giant palettes sound like a bad idea and are way too expensive for the average consumer. The mercury retrograde was very pretty but also skipped on it.

    • @ValentineLissar
      @ValentineLissar 5 років тому +5

      They’re like 250 to 300$? I feel like that’s a lot to invest compared to a 50$ palette that you’d use everyday. Unless you’re a makeup artist doing very avante garde looks, when are going to use those bold colors on the daily?

    • @nairabee245
      @nairabee245 5 років тому +9

      Carlie Morgan the average makeup consumer is in their early to mid twenties, I don’t know that many 20 yr olds (especially in this massive debt climate) that can afford to drop almost hundreds on one makeup item. I might be wrong tho.

    • @ValentineLissar
      @ValentineLissar 5 років тому +3

      Carlie Morgan ok maybe I was thinking of some other palette but looking online some retailers were listing it at $175. Either way, as someone who could afford $150-175 a palette I still wouldn’t because I don’t think it’s worth that much to me and I still think it’s too expensive for the average consumer who casually does makeup. I mean I’m not going to tell anyone how they spend their money but that’s just my two cents. 😉

    • @ValentineLissar
      @ValentineLissar 5 років тому +2

      Carlie Morgan that’s great and I’m happy you enjoy it. It’s true that they market them for consumers but as I said I don’t find them to be worth it for the price. I do go back and forth with wanting to get a ND and PM palette (most because of the allure of having one and the nice packaging) but the viseart palettes again just turn me off. Especially the last volume as it’s not practical. Like, I love wearing blue and purple eyeshadow and I only wear them on weekends since I can’t wear that to my super conservative office job. For me it’s a bad idea to spend that much money on something that doesn’t get daily use.

    • @nairabee245
      @nairabee245 5 років тому +4

      Carlie Morgan the heaviest makeup buyers are 18-24 yr olds. Middle aged women use makeup more frequently but they aren’t the demographic that buys it the most. And the demographic of middle class consumers purchasing makeup are on the rise but the late teens to mid twenties, as well as minorities make up the people who buy it the most.
      cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/544043/2017_Webinars/2017%20Cosmetics/White%20Paper/11-21-17%20Cosmetics%20Survey%20FINAL.pdf?t=1511794533245
      not sure if this is relevant but Hispanic and African American women by faaaar outspend their white counterparts multiple times over when it comes to makeup and the beauty industry in general. And on a macro level, if you’re looking at income disparities between groups of people, what I’ve seen says that for the people who’re actually buying the most makeup I don’t think it’s accurate to say the average makeup consumer can afford to pay $130-$200+ for a single palette.
      www.google.com/amp/s/www.socialstandards.com/blog/cosmetics-consumer-demographics%3fhs_amp=true

  • @infishort0187
    @infishort0187 5 років тому

    Love this vid! You popped up on my recommendations, I’m very glad that I clicked, and I just subscribed ☺️

  • @stephanied6711
    @stephanied6711 5 років тому +7

    Naked honey I thought I'd like it but when I took a closer look at it in store I would never use it

    • @chillytoes1
      @chillytoes1 5 років тому +2

      Lol, you and I are the only two who have that opinion. I didn't see what everyone else loved about it

    • @karensnailstudio7171
      @karensnailstudio7171 5 років тому +1

      Steph D same!!

    • @xamyx2205
      @xamyx2205 5 років тому +2

      I was the opposite, LOL! As someone who has never been a big fan of gold eyeshadow (on me personally), something about it appealed to me. For some reason, the gold tones seem to work on me, whereas other golds I've tried don't...

    • @EarthIncompatible
      @EarthIncompatible 5 років тому

      That was me too. I was convinced to buy it, but when I got to Ulta, I was underwhelmed and passed on it.

  • @lizbethluna6253
    @lizbethluna6253 5 років тому +6

    You said it correctly the "muerte" word 😀

  • @felicial7628
    @felicial7628 5 років тому +5

    Love the dupe the vibe concept! 👍. We all need to adopt the “Pretty but No” motto more often with so many eyeshadow releases.

  • @cjgem80
    @cjgem80 5 років тому +1

    I purchased the Kat Von D Lolita palette. I love it... love her eyeshadows.

  • @misscurlygirl17
    @misscurlygirl17 5 років тому +1

    Your makeup look is fabulous!

  • @kailebrogan447
    @kailebrogan447 4 роки тому

    If you type in the color pop shadows into amazon there are cruelty free options that are cheaper. In case you guys need more smokey eye looks

  • @alisonmiller7445
    @alisonmiller7445 5 років тому

    I really love the lipstick you are wearing! The color is beautiful.

  • @haxan.
    @haxan. 5 років тому +1

    i understand that these are ur opinions and that's all fair and alright. however, insinuating that Beauty News is shady and have a "weird relationship" is taking it a bit too far. Beauty News is more than a drama channel. Kat and Haley work very hard to collect all the information for weekly releases and all the details. if they happened to receive pr from shane doesn't mean it's something bad.

    • @CrownFlowerCreations
      @CrownFlowerCreations 5 років тому

      Beauty News is definitely not a drama channel and Shane sent them the palette for a Makeup Breakup segment because he loves that series on their channel. Nothing weird or weird "relationship" whatsoever with them going on.

  • @DominaLacus
    @DominaLacus 5 років тому +1

    I'd love to see a video of you duping the vibe of the Muerte palette! I did a similar thing and found I could only get one or two looks from it.

  • @geewizlana
    @geewizlana 5 років тому +1

    Makeup Revolution duped the KVD palette if you're still interested or like their formula.
    Also....I will be shocked if KVD is still in sephora in 2021 lol, as many brands I've seen hit the door as soon as the first quarter in sales did poorly, I'm already surprised that she's still there. Ain't no way she's making sephora enough to sustain that aisle and advertising. The "sale" page and TJ max stores are filled up with her stuff....and i don't see any influencers promoting new releases....she had her chance to redeem, but instead publicly assured her stance. That was the end.

  • @sashabee2012
    @sashabee2012 5 років тому +1

    I thought I was the only one in the world who didn't like Anastasia's formula! Thank you! I feel less alone now! 😂

    • @sashabee2012
      @sashabee2012 5 років тому

      And I totally agree with you about Tati! After years I unsubrcribed to her channel, just after that Emily Noel drama...

    • @staceyclark5020
      @staceyclark5020 5 років тому

      I always thought I was the only one, too!😄

  • @littlereddress82
    @littlereddress82 5 років тому +6

    Love your lipstick. What is it?

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +9

      It's an ABH lipstick called Stevie!

    • @sher3196
      @sher3196 5 років тому +6

      @@shadowsmoked88 So it was made for you, I see!! 😁

  • @aniwiggles
    @aniwiggles 5 років тому +1

    Yes, to the Grande Pro 3. It's singing its siren song to me. 👀🎵🎶

  • @shandysawh3071
    @shandysawh3071 5 років тому +1

    Yea the Viseart large palettes don't last. I bought the first on and it's kind of faded now. I like this vid. You look really lovely.

  • @natfast5382
    @natfast5382 5 років тому +41

    Tati was an easy pass for me. After story with Emily Noel, I did not watch here. And I am not interested in here brand period.

    • @haleyps6929
      @haleyps6929 5 років тому +7

      You're mad about her being honest about a low quality palette? I love Emily, but after testing her palette, I thought it was bad quality and not super great colors.

    • @erinstettner1
      @erinstettner1 5 років тому +6

      Tons and tons of people on UA-cam said the EXACT same thing about the Emily palette. Tati got attacked because she is a large UA-camr. Nobody should be afraid to be honest about their thoughts.

    • @janelle009
      @janelle009 5 років тому +3

      I quit watching her after her perfectly timed James Charles fiasco then conveniently gained millions and released a new vitamin. I feel shes extremely narcissistic. The channel "without a crystal ball" has great videos with facts about her. She was then promptly sent a "cease and desist" letter threatening to sue. A few youtubers who spoke out saying she was wrong for what she did got copy write and C&D letters.

    • @janelle009
      @janelle009 5 років тому +5

      @@erinstettner1 I honestly think it was about how she came across and seemed to not even give it a chance. Still to this day, it's the one and only time I've ever seen her put a shimmer in her crease and she chose strange colors. Many got that vibe. She later said she was cramping and not feeling well so that could be part of it as well.

    • @haleyps6929
      @haleyps6929 5 років тому +3

      @@janelle009 No, it was just a bad palette. The color story was uninspiring and the quality was bad. Even before I saw her review, I had these thoughts about the palette. I love Emily, but Makeup Revolution really screwed her over with it.

  • @asquaredmorrisdancer
    @asquaredmorrisdancer 5 років тому +1

    I will say that the Norvina palettes have a totally different formula from normal ABH. They remind me a lot more of when Too Faced is really good. More silky than velvety.

  • @keyoniayates3447
    @keyoniayates3447 5 років тому

    That melt Cosmetics palette is beautiful it was a mistake not buying it I have that palette in the performance is beautiful the colors are amazing and melts formula is beyond reproach

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому

      I only have one eyeshadow stack from Melt and it is pretty good! It's good to hear the palette performs well!

  • @Pippsissewa
    @Pippsissewa 5 років тому +1

    I don’t like the ABH formula either! Except for me the worst is the shimmers! I hate their shimmers. I can get the mattes to work ok. I’ve given away most of my ABH palettes because I got so sick of trying to make them work.

  • @ginnyburley9552
    @ginnyburley9552 5 років тому

    I have 2 very popular ABH palettes and never use either. Maybe the issue is also for me that I don’t do well with the formula even though I never realized that. It took me a stupidly long time (and a load of money) to figure out what eyeshadows I like and use.

  • @MelsLife570
    @MelsLife570 5 років тому +4

    Tati didn’t attack Kiki. Kiki put that video out using clips of Tati crying to make fun of her and those were of her crying because she couldn’t get pregnant. Kiki hit below the belt. I was glad tati have an honest review as it’s not just Emily’s palette as it’s also MUR and they are hit & miss. My Emily palette had mildew on the bottom shade. Ulta exchanged it. And as far as James goes, she was his mentor and leg stuff slide since they were so close and had finally had enough and blew up. Tati’s palette is really really good.

  • @heatherhernandez5561
    @heatherhernandez5561 5 років тому +6

    I’m glad I didn’t buy the Tati eyeshadow palette it just didn’t catch my eyes and some I heard weren’t pigmented

  • @jessicarabbit2267
    @jessicarabbit2267 5 років тому +2

    Hahaha 😂 what’s with the shrimp? 🍤 made me laugh

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому

      Just because it made me laugh too, haha.

  • @tazzie2shoos
    @tazzie2shoos 5 років тому

    Had to comment because a) the video resonated with me as to why you didn't buy these palettes and b) everything I am uncomfortable with concerning Tati you spoke about.

  • @RikkiSpanish
    @RikkiSpanish 5 років тому +1

    Oh my goodness! I didn't even know there was a Friends palette. I'm so glad I didn't know, because I would have bought it and not used it. My husband and I are the world's biggest Friends fans. We play all 10 seasons in order and then we watch all 12 seasons of The Big Bang Theory in order(we know everything there is to know about that show too lol), and then go back to Friends. We know every bit of trivia about the show lol. I know that not only do I not wear pretty much ANY of the colors in that palette, I also know that those colors have almost nothing to do with that show. With the exception of a few of Phoebe's outfits, those colors were not in style back then. I already have a black sweatshirt with the word "Pivot" on it over a couch, printed in the colors and style of the Friends logo. It's the kind of memorabilia that only true Friends fans get lol.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому +1

      THAT SWEATSHIRT SOUNDS LIKE PERFECTION

  • @Thestashdowndiaries
    @Thestashdowndiaries 5 років тому

    I considered buying the Conspiracy palette when I first saw it but, as with most things, I slept on it because I don't want to spend money impulsively. I came to the conclusion that I wouldn't use it much because it's ugly. I did end up buying the Tati palette and do use it regularly. I might not get much use out of the glitter (used one once) but am getting a lot of use out of the rest of it. I think, at the end of the day, it's good to sleep on purchases and not fall for the FOMO.

  • @angelapennington4724
    @angelapennington4724 5 років тому

    I love these types of videos. Even though we have different opinions on some things, I respect your opinion and your respect mine. I like that you share your opinions.

  • @thevioletrevolution
    @thevioletrevolution 5 років тому +5

    I watched the first few Shane and J* episodes and was sucked in by their friendship and the sob story that they tried to depict. It’s rare that I react that way to Influencer stuff. I planned to get the palettes, but then pulled my head out of my ass and realized it was just a giant drawn out commercial. Neither of those people give a shit about me or how I feel about their friendship and boo hoo Shane could be more of a millionaire but nobody showed him how. They kept talking about how hard he worked on it, but that didn’t really come through for me in the series. It seemed more like he just came up with names and then J* already had some colors ready to go.

  • @sophiegolden
    @sophiegolden 5 років тому

    I hate the controversy palette! But I falled in love with the 2 yellow of the year honey UD and honey Colorpop, I started to use the UD and I love it really, for me it s the perfect palette to travel but I add the Dior rosy canvas to have a little more pink, for my next trip I will bring the dark Colorpop, I m blond with brown eyes so no problem... But I payed the real UD half price! Also the cherry... I don't like the other palettes that you show...
    Sorry for my English I'm French

  • @NaturalhairwithTati
    @NaturalhairwithTati 4 роки тому

    I think the Jackie Aina ABH palette is a superior formula to the other ABH formulas, I think you wouldn’t be disappointed if you gave it a try

  • @Alix_L
    @Alix_L 5 років тому

    I feel the same way about drama surrounding anything, girl!
    A palette I’m debating is jeffree’s highlighter palette based on Alaska. Buuuut I know all the drama surrounding him and I’m not even sure if the highlighters are worth it 🤷‍♀️
    I’m already overwhelmed with the amount of palettes I have at the moment though haha

  • @GonzGirlDeni
    @GonzGirlDeni 5 років тому +14

    The controversy palette is hideous.

  • @JustSheilz
    @JustSheilz 5 років тому +1

    I was never interested in the Tati palette. I was only interested in the green shade on the Conspiracy palette but once it was taken out, I was no longer interested.

  • @margaretromans2345
    @margaretromans2345 5 років тому

    I love Jeffree Star products because they perform really good but I didn't buy the controversy one either because it had maybe 3 colors in it that I would use.So many people buy mystery boxes and new releases and certain brands just for the name on it and I don't understand why???I won't throw my money away on stuff I cannot use even if I could afford it.I would rather just pay for the colors I know I will wear instead of trying to throw my money away just because it is the it thing at the time💟

  • @angelicalyremar
    @angelicalyremar 5 років тому

    I really enjoy this video, fun to watch!💖😀

  • @westworldemployee7
    @westworldemployee7 5 років тому

    I love critiques!

  • @wendyxkuma
    @wendyxkuma 5 років тому +2

    I really don’t like the Anastasia eyeshadow formula either. They’re patchy, hard to blend, and lackluster. I’ve used different eyeshadow primers, synthetic and natural hair brushes, set my shadow base, left it tacky. I just don’t like it. I never understood the hype and I’m so glad I don’t own any Anastasia shadows anymore.
    Also I believe Hannah’s last name is pronounced Pp- OOOH- st -en. Like a light post.

    • @EarthIncompatible
      @EarthIncompatible 5 років тому +1

      I seriously thought I was the only person on the planet who didnt like the ABH formula. The only palette I've kept is Subculture, oddly enough. I'm not sure why I cant declutter it.

    • @shadowsmoked88
      @shadowsmoked88  5 років тому

      Sounds like we have similar shadow preferences!
      And thank you!

    • @manonlescaut569
      @manonlescaut569 5 років тому +1

      I can't tell if my soft glam just got old and doesn't perform that well anymore (although it's just a bit over a year old) or I have been blind and it's never performed well. But for some reason I love this palette so much, I won't ever get rid of it. I've recently purchased modern renaissance and it performs much better than soft glam, I think ABH formula might just really be expiring very fast

    • @wendyxkuma
      @wendyxkuma 5 років тому +1

      Manon Lescaut i work at Sephora and we get nearly every new ABH release and I haven’t liked any of them, even with their formula being brand new and fresh. The only one I liked enough to keep was the Jackie Aina one. I just think they are always dry!