Jeffrey Sachs, Ilan Pappe & Gideon Levy: One state vs Two State

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 124

  • @turanamo
    @turanamo 3 години тому +4

    Channel's growing fast! Good work

  • @Cécile-v3m
    @Cécile-v3m 3 години тому +5

    Thank you for this platform!

  • @amgguy4319
    @amgguy4319 12 годин тому +42

    If Israel is relocated out of the Middle-East, Palestinians can move into the empty homes and operate businesses from the empty buildings as they rebuild Gaza. This is the easiest and most compelling solution. Tents can be set up in the new location for Israel citizens until they can bud their new home on land property bought or voluntarily given to them. Everyone will be happy 😊

    • @RAFIJAH
      @RAFIJAH 10 годин тому +4

      JJJ.... The US gave FREEDOM to her slaves but remained APARTHEID as Israel is right now! It was only until The US gave EQUALITY that PEACE finally came to the land. Thank you Dr. Martin Luther King R.I.P.

    • @armandogavilan1815
      @armandogavilan1815 7 годин тому

      here´s another one, israhell can f itself, and take their european nazi arses back to europe or usa where people seem to worship this band of psychopaths.

    • @websitemartian
      @websitemartian 7 годин тому +1

      Israel is heavily armed.😕

    • @Cécile-v3m
      @Cécile-v3m 4 години тому +4

      I love this idea!

    • @ahmedsayid4466
      @ahmedsayid4466 Годину тому +1

      Free Free Palestine from the river to the sea ⛵🌊😅😅😅

  • @sagsc2025
    @sagsc2025 8 годин тому +9

    Good compilation

  • @mysticjoy2924
    @mysticjoy2924 Годину тому +3

    A FREE INDEPENDENT STATE OF PALESTINE 💪🇵🇸🕊️✌️

  • @ebflegg
    @ebflegg 12 годин тому +23

    The fatal weakness of the UN system on the question of Palestine is that Israel claims its legitimacy as a state - its 'right to exist' - on the basis of its admission to the UN in 1948 by a two-thirds majority, albeit opposed by all its Arab neighbours (therein the sign of all trouble to come).
    1948 was an important moment. India had gained its independence the previous year and decolonisation was beginning to gain momentum. Two developments bucked this trend: the establishment of Israel and the election of the white nationalists in South Africa, who set out to establish apartheid.
    Less than a generation later, say about 15 years, UN membership had trebled; the USSR and satellites had also changed their position on support for Israel. In this changed world, a motion brought to the UN to establish a Jewish settler colony on a British mandate territory in Arab lands could never have gained a two-thirds vote: for a 'Jewish state' could only be established by driving out the indigenous inhabitants.
    From this stems also the flawed project of the 'two-state solution', which is neither just nor viable: it's premised on Israel's membership of the UN as a legitimate state.
    International law is hoist on this petard. All fair-minded people can see that ethnocracy is wrong, and that it was misguided to make reparations to European Jews for the Holocaust by allowing them to settle in the Middle East and start the Zionist project of ethnic cleansing.
    The only solution that meets contemporary criteria of human rights and democratic values is for Israel/Palestine to become a single, secular, democratic state with equal rights for all. The so-called 'international community' needs to recognise that those powers who imposed Israel on the Middle East in 1948 were wrong to do so, and that the vast majority of current UN member states were excluded from the decision. Bad decisions of the past should not all be immutable or freeze the possibility for the righting of historic wrongs.

    • @michellenorris8471
      @michellenorris8471 10 годин тому +7

      Well said.

    • @AggieL48
      @AggieL48 6 годин тому

      When you know that the czio’s bribed/blackmailed/threatened hesitant UN members to acquire the necessary votes, you know izreal’s membership is illegitimate.

    • @Bettina-mb2xr
      @Bettina-mb2xr 2 години тому

      Israel must be stopped‼️Netanyahu must be arrested‼️free free Palestine 🇵🇸

  • @yolandagarzabirdwell7188
    @yolandagarzabirdwell7188 10 годин тому +11

    Thanks for good information.

  • @drghulamqadirlone922
    @drghulamqadirlone922 5 годин тому +14

    The land belongs to Palestine

    • @Bettina-mb2xr
      @Bettina-mb2xr 2 години тому

      👍🏽♥️🇵🇸✌🏽

    • @johnerispe2953
      @johnerispe2953 50 хвилин тому

      No such thing as Palestine mentioned in the Quran and who is the Palestinians.

  • @TheMadmacs
    @TheMadmacs Годину тому +1

    truth and reconciliation was a powerful peacemaker. peace means peace for all. one state, one vote, one peace, free palestine. make the holy land holy again.

  • @nevillesmith426
    @nevillesmith426 Годину тому +2

    One state (call it The Levant to be neutral) that enfranchises all, no superior race or ethnicity, equal protection under the law. Truth and justice boards set up to redress grievances as in South Africa and Northern Ireland. No other solution will be possible.

  • @tafadefi6738
    @tafadefi6738 10 годин тому +15

    I am very worried about the safety of Jeffrey Sachs hope he has a solid protection of security people. 🙏🙏

    • @aneurindavies5943
      @aneurindavies5943 Годину тому

      How can anyone possibly trust the 'security apparatus' of the United States of America 🤔?

  • @brentriley4911
    @brentriley4911 7 годин тому +7

    A creative Constitution, guaranteeing minority, religious, and civil rights and a truth and reconciliation process could make the existing one-state workable.

  • @ronalds8597
    @ronalds8597 11 годин тому +17

    Three Jewish scholars giving their views... did nobody came up with the idea of asking a Palestinian??

    • @brendasmart553
      @brendasmart553 11 годин тому +2

      Is Jeff also Jewish??? 😐

    • @ronalds8597
      @ronalds8597 11 годин тому

      ​@@brendasmart553 To my knowledge he is

    • @brendasmart553
      @brendasmart553 11 годин тому +11

      These guys and other sincere Jews are among the strongest of Palestinian supporters!! There are many & I honor them for their hearts & work!! 🙏☯️❤️

    • @ronalds8597
      @ronalds8597 10 годин тому +11

      ​@@brendasmart553 I fully agree, but that was not my point. The people directly involved are the most obvious to be asked. They should speak for themselves.

    • @brendasmart553
      @brendasmart553 10 годин тому +6

      @ronalds8597 Yes. I understood and agree, but so far not the reality on the ground, sadly. 🤢💔😢

  • @arimagoo4687
    @arimagoo4687 13 годин тому +16

    Spellcheck: ISNTREAL

  • @cngreen2950
    @cngreen2950 8 годин тому +6

    Teşekkürler 🇹🇷🌷🌹

  • @arimagoo4687
    @arimagoo4687 13 годин тому +14

    🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

  • @gevaeilan3132
    @gevaeilan3132 Годину тому +2

    Israel 🇮🇱 should build new settlements in gaza

  • @RAFIJAH
    @RAFIJAH 10 годин тому +8

    The US gave FREEDOM to her slaves but remained APARTHEID as Israel is right now! It was only until The US gave EQUALITY that PEACE finally came to the land. Thank you Dr. Martin Luther King R.I.P.

    • @rossauce8896
      @rossauce8896 7 годин тому +2

      lol peace came to the land? When did this happen I must have been asleep

  • @marcellaagesilas3375
    @marcellaagesilas3375 45 хвилин тому +2

    50 pour cent pour les palestiniens et pareil pour les israeliens

  • @SavePlanetPlease
    @SavePlanetPlease 13 годин тому +6

    Ty

  • @AftabKhan-lg8uc
    @AftabKhan-lg8uc 13 годин тому +7

    Welcome

  • @sitiruhanaruhana3808
    @sitiruhanaruhana3808 4 години тому +2

    👍👍👏👏❤️❤️🙋🙋

  • @billyo54
    @billyo54 12 годин тому +11

    The two state system that everyone seems to back will never work. Look at Northern Ireland. Now that Republican Nationalists have a majority, some Loyalists are toying with the idea of reducing the number of counties in order to maintain a Loyalist majority in a reduced Northern Ireland. The two state system always winds up in gerrymandering.

  • @hamzamahdi104
    @hamzamahdi104 12 годин тому +10

    Already 1967 5 June internationally recognised Palestinian atate existence so its on usa EU and zionists and UN to practically implement this

    • @aneurindavies5943
      @aneurindavies5943 Годину тому

      Realistically the existence of a Palestinian Sovereign State should have been given official international recognition back in 1917!

  • @gevaeilan3132
    @gevaeilan3132 Годину тому +2

    Thet tried to steal the land of Israel 🇮🇱 and got punished by god

    • @marksvenson1886
      @marksvenson1886 34 секунди тому

      @@gevaeilan3132 Palestinians are the descendants of Caananites and Samaritans and Judeans, mostly who survived the invasion of the Hebrew tribes. Many were formerly Christians or Jews, and for many their heritage extend back well before the invasion by the Hebrew tribes. Know history or be an ass.

  • @laurenth7187
    @laurenth7187 13 годин тому +12

    Sure, once Israel is gone, palestinian state can really bring stability to the region. In 10 years or so.

  • @arman6119
    @arman6119 4 години тому +1

    just on YT "Sabatical" land in west bank is cheaper......if one nation wud they need a military ?

  • @AftabKhan-lg8uc
    @AftabKhan-lg8uc 13 годин тому +5

    To my understanding and knowledge of the world, two state is not a solution but will create more problems. First point is that the boundaries of each state, its constitution and the last, most important how to keep rule of law effectively implementable.

  • @johnerispe2953
    @johnerispe2953 46 хвилин тому

    Only 1 Jewish state.

  • @StraightPolitics-193
    @StraightPolitics-193 11 годин тому +5

    Idk why Jeffrey Sucks keeps insisting for a 2-state solution?

    • @Jinx-z2g
      @Jinx-z2g 9 годин тому

      Bias

    • @alicerose9140
      @alicerose9140 7 годин тому +1

      Could you share a house with someone who had, or may still want to keel you?

  • @reedmadden354
    @reedmadden354 12 годин тому +2

    that AI cover is disgusting, the text doesnt even make sense. I'm considering unsubscribing

    • @Jinx-z2g
      @Jinx-z2g 9 годин тому +2

      Not that deep 😭🙏

  • @johnerispe2953
    @johnerispe2953 48 хвилин тому

    No such thing as Palestine mentioned in the Quran and who is the Palestinians.

    • @ilanafitzgerald9000
      @ilanafitzgerald9000 11 хвилин тому

      Hmm, and quite possibly there was no mention in the Quran of the countries we now know as Jordan, Libya, Yemen, Iraq or Sudan - doesn't mean there weren't local indigenous populations living there for thousands of years. Not sure what point you're trying to make referencing the Quran?
      I do know Palestine was mentioned by the English author Shakespeare in the 1600's.

  • @navit4369
    @navit4369 12 годин тому

    Arabs in Judea Samariaare from Jordan. Gaza Arabs from Egypt

    • @Jinx-z2g
      @Jinx-z2g 9 годин тому +3

      Radecki family from Palestine since 1927 😂

  • @mahad4088
    @mahad4088 7 годин тому +2

    Shame on you defending terrorist against your own people

    • @marksvenson1886
      @marksvenson1886 5 годин тому

      We're not all living in a tribe where we rob others to support our tribe.

    • @JensPeterLiljegren
      @JensPeterLiljegren 2 години тому

      Supporting genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, illegal occupation & Apartheid - and shaming others for defending terrorists🤡

  • @navit4369
    @navit4369 12 годин тому

    There is no such thing “Palestine “

    • @Jinx-z2g
      @Jinx-z2g 9 годин тому +2

      "isreal" is real since 1948 😘

    • @christinetaia8735
      @christinetaia8735 9 годин тому +7

      You should educate yourself on history Palestine does Exist ISREAL State was created in 1948 history does not lie

    • @christinetaia8735
      @christinetaia8735 9 годин тому

      ​@@Jinx-z2g
      Absolutely correct 💯

    • @fuckbankers
      @fuckbankers 7 годин тому +3

      Tell that to the Romans

    • @marksvenson1886
      @marksvenson1886 5 годин тому

      Know history or sound like you, ignorant.

  • @mahmoodbahrani7804
    @mahmoodbahrani7804 9 годин тому +5

    2 STATE SOLUTION, IS GOOD IF IT IS ACCORDING TO 1948 =
    AT LEAST %48 OF PALESTINE LAND;FOR PALESTINIANS.
    OTHERWISE, THERE WILL NOT BE DIFFERENCE TO CURRENT SITUATION;
    IMAGINE ALL EXILED PALESTINIANS , DECIDE TO COME BACK TO THEIR LAND;
    + 2 MILLIONS + X MILLIONS MORE PEOPLE, IN #%20 OF LAND ?

  • @patrickparker1696
    @patrickparker1696 3 години тому +1

    To rive to sea for the people land been taken by Israel. It’s not there country.

  • @hamzamahdi104
    @hamzamahdi104 12 годин тому +2

    Of course yes