《鯨落》是Ian 第一首詞曲原創,而Feanna 是受邀合唱，當年18歲的Feanna, 26歲的Ian 才第一次見面和合作。 Hins 唱這cover 是41歲，已出道22年， 用2022年Music Panda 獨唱cover (tuned) 和2020年的 男女Duet合唱KKBOX Live 舊版本比較，沒有apple to apple 意義 Ian & Feanna 合唱輕快作品《猜猜我是誰》很dynamic-ua-cam.com/video/sxUfXN5fzmg/v-deo.htmlsi=ggNGOp93LhQi-nEl 記得淑蔓妹妹合唱後，去了英國讀書2年。 淑蔓18 VS Ian 26 VS 軒叔41 😂 大十幾廿十年喎，軒叔出道時，Feanna 還未出世，Ian 在讀小學 個人比較喜歡Ian 獨唱MV 或Live 版本（音色及演繹） Feanna 24年唱作 -I am all alone, vocal 亦已經大不同 ua-cam.com/video/y09kn7rVsOY/v-deo.htmlsi=T86X6EcrInoN2Lpw Feanna 輕鬆Live 唱Loving U 海豚音, 唱浮誇，亦可以search 下
To be honest, Ian’s performance of this video is in a higher key than the usual This song is called鯨落and is one of the song of his own He wrote it by himself and he had preformed a lot of times after the recording of this video We could see his improvement between each performance of this song There are a bunch of performance better than the one recording at that time which I guess is at least 3 years ago Hins is a singer with great capability I think everyone could admit But Ian’s improvement these years have been seen and admitted with lots of award in Hong Kong I am hoping that you can judge after listening to more performance that Ian brought these few years This one video that is included is only pawns in a bigger game🙏🏻
This song is actually wrote by the first guy - Ian Chan. He is really talented. If you could watch his solo concert to make the comparison, he had improved a lot on his singing technique. Anyway, thank you guys to put his song on this channel👏🏻
Great to have more Hins reaction videos as he’s a really good vocalist and the reference value is high. But it would be more respectful if you can focus when listening and filming the video:)
being a non native cantonese speaker, to me, (gong dong wa) is my freaking most favourite asian language of all time. Must be the emotional attachment i have to all the tvb and cantopop i watched and listened to as a teen til now =) I honestly feel that rozette needs to take basic canto lessons in order to understand and better appreciate canto pop. It's starting to irk me how she constantly criticises how canto songs are being sung. You're too narrow minded and just focus too much on what you're used to instead of bringing an open mind to the table. Thank god for Jay but he caves in under the immense pressure to agree with you sometimes and that's tragic really.
Can't agree more. Especially this one..."You're too narrow minded and just focus too much on what you're used to instead of bringing an open mind to the table. "
@viviennehmlai everytime she judges how the singers enunciate during a canto song I just want to scream in frustration, woman this is HOW the song is meant to be sung, it is part and parcel and beauty of the language!! It's because she's so disconnected to the songs that she only sees the so called technical *errors*. I'm not even cantonese ( I'm hakka) yet I totally get it. She should just stop reviewing all cantonese singers and songs henceforth. To spare my heart from breaking further.
@@fennlynn7675 As a Cantonese, it is my mother tongue. I share your same feeling too... Canton pop still have a lot of good singers indeed. Also, no points to do this kind of comparisons through. Just my view.
This was filmed in Ian's second year as a solo singer and he wrote this song using Whale Fall as a metaphor for sacrifice for love. Maybe check out some of his more recent live performances to see whether he has improved? Please go easy on Feanna, this was 4 years ago when she was 19. This is Ian's song and she sings in a male key, and bass is not her strength. Maybe check out her rendition of "Vampire" by Olivia Rodrigo. She is one of the better young pop singers in HK. She is 23 now and she released her first song at the age of 14. After a hiatus of a few years when she studied in the UK, she returned to the HK music scene in 2023. Of course, there is always room for improvement. Hins has over 25 years' experience as a professional singer and his rendition of this song is undoubtedly (and not surprisingly) better.
In this chanel, video made 4 years ago is considered new because they are benchmarking jacky cheung’s old video 😂. How about recent songs like 緊急聯繫人？ boyfriend materials? Recent cantopop market stresses more on new song creation, expressing their views beyond love while in mainland ppl are increasingly focused on perfection of technique and repeatedly sing old songs 😂 like JJ that they love, most reactions are on his cover only. Hins is still putting a lot of his thoughts in new songs that resonate with ppl.
I find it fascinating that the review content is based on performance from local artists across Asia, and yet the two hosts with Asian backgrounds that chose and provided the material to the voice coach wouldn’t bother to do some basic research and provide a bit more background of the artist, who wrote the music etc. A quick Google search would have confirmed Ian Chan was indeed the composer of this song and also the lyricist, instead of just saying “I think he wrote it”. We don’t expect you to promote each singer but at least give credits where it’s due. As for the female singer, her name is Feanna Wong who debuted in HK when she was 14 back in 2015. I didn’t know this information until 2 mins ago but I find it a bit disrespectful that when the vocal coach asked “who’s the girl”, the other 2 hosts just responded with “I don’t know her” when you picked this piece of performance to be reviewed to begin with, at least find out who she is? This isn’t the first time I’ve noticed this pattern, it’s happened consistently that if it’s an artist the hosts like, they can go on and on about them (which is nostalgic and I personally enjoy tbh), but when basic questions such as who [insert less known artist] is, when was this song released, who wrote it, etc were asked, it’s often to hear “we don’t know/ not sure/ I *think* it’s so and so” with little to no effort to verify. Keep up the great content but a little extra effort goes a long way, especially it’s difficult enough as it is to release original canto pop nowadays.
The duet between Ian and Feanna was from 4 years ago. Please watch a newer version of this song if you really want to judge someone’s singing ability. Hin’s version was from last year and Hins he has been in the industry for over 20 years. He’s lot older and much more experienced. It’s really not a fair comparison at all. I don’t know who this vocal coach is but I feel like she’s being very disrespectful and obviously knows nothing about Hong Kong or Cantonese music. The fact that they keep talking about Jacky Cheung who is a singer from the 90’s is very telling. Come on it’s 2024 already! I don’t think the western way of singing will work on a cantopop song at all and will just sound wrong. Open your ears and your eyes and then maybe your mind won’t be so narrow. Your way is not the only way.
Thank you for this review. Really enjoyed watching it. I think Feanna Wong is a good female singer in Hong Kong today. She deserves more recognition. I hope you guys can create more reviews about her!🌟
I think its related to their choice of the version of Ian. His solo version is cleaner. How spoken Cantonese sound? referring to Jacky cheung, pls show his “食屎啦你” video 😂😂
omg....下集預告的騷靈情歌，是我認為軒其中一首最得最好的live，你地好識揀片👍🏻
超愛軒仔唱的鯨落, 好空靈好舒服
More HIns!! So enjoyable
smh nah, she was not even paying attention. She was busy with her phone. Let them move on to other singers and don't bother Hins.
直白點說就是Ian Chan & Feanna Wong的唱功需要加強，推拉可以說是技巧，但沒有選擇地使用，或不受控地使用，就是需要進步的地方
《鯨落》是Ian 第一首詞曲原創,而Feanna 是受邀合唱，當年18歲的Feanna, 26歲的Ian 才第一次見面和合作。
Hins 唱這cover 是41歲，已出道22年，
用2022年Music Panda 獨唱cover (tuned) 和2020年的 男女Duet合唱KKBOX Live 舊版本比較，沒有apple to apple 意義
Ian & Feanna 合唱輕快作品《猜猜我是誰》很dynamic-ua-cam.com/video/sxUfXN5fzmg/v-deo.htmlsi=ggNGOp93LhQi-nEl
記得淑蔓妹妹合唱後，去了英國讀書2年。
淑蔓18 VS Ian 26 VS 軒叔41 😂
大十幾廿十年喎，軒叔出道時，Feanna 還未出世，Ian 在讀小學
個人比較喜歡Ian 獨唱MV 或Live 版本（音色及演繹）
Feanna 24年唱作 -I am all alone, vocal 亦已經大不同
ua-cam.com/video/y09kn7rVsOY/v-deo.htmlsi=T86X6EcrInoN2Lpw
Feanna 輕鬆Live 唱Loving U 海豚音, 唱浮誇，亦可以search 下
@@cloudycloudy2766 其實樓主沒說錯。他就是說出基於這影片裡的Ian和Feanna的表現。他們的唱功和演繹歌曲的成熟度確實不如Hins。但並沒有說他們倆不好。畢竟還有很多機會成長。
@@kwoo24 知道老師的評論很客觀、溫和，「有錢落袋」
只是評論區對某些fans 喜歡拿前輩cover 後輩創作，還是tuned 的錄播版本，拉踩比較4年前duet
演繹風格固然各有喜好，合唱與獨唱，年資和嗓音高中低音的聲底分別，也是尷尬
純粹提供更多角度、資料，向路人解釋個全貌full picture
90、00新生代（台灣說是草莓族），在娛樂圈抗壓能力，網絡🛜傳播是universe,
Feanna 14歲出道，過去9年仍然摸索奮斗中；
Ian 也曾承受越少機會唱live, 越怕出錯的困局，出道第六年，今年終於有第一次萬人Solo Con
這個duet 是4年前的新生代合作，如果拿今年Ian concert live 去評論，可以檢視技巧或演繹
對Feanna 18歲時的一次性合作，這個評核需要給個remark
@@cloudycloudy2766 好多人未夠26歲或者even 18歲都可以有好好嘅基本功/ 唱功 所以拎年齡講冇乜意思 有天賦嘅人好後生都已經好掂
比人差就要承受批評無話好唔好，你係fans玻璃心咪唔好，歌手吸收到咪好，而且兩者本身係best frd唔會好介意架咋
Hins's singing is more than comfortable ;)
無對比無傷害😂
To be honest, Ian’s performance of this video is in a higher key than the usual
This song is called鯨落and is one of the song of his own
He wrote it by himself and he had preformed a lot of times after the recording of this video
We could see his improvement between each performance of this song
There are a bunch of performance better than the one recording at that time which I guess is at least 3 years ago
Hins is a singer with great capability I think everyone could admit
But Ian’s improvement these years have been seen and admitted with lots of award in Hong Kong
I am hoping that you can judge after listening to more performance that Ian brought these few years
This one video that is included is only pawns in a bigger game🙏🏻
Would love another review of Ian but of a song from his solo concert as he has improved so much since this video.
thank you teacher❤ 軒既聲音可以令到老師想睇電話時都被吸引去望🥰
多謝vocal coach指出好多廣東歌歌手發音都有嘅問題, 而呢個問題我地成日用"呢個係個歌手嘅特色"or"廣東話係會咁", 而忽視左呢個其實係錯誤, 聽眾又盲目接受嘅話, 歌手更加唔會自覺需要改善呢個問題, 所以支持指出呢個問題. 希望廣東歌歌手都可以越唱越好!
@@Arther0309 就因為主流同埋西洋音樂唔會咁樣唱，所以廣東歌唱法就係錯？
@@floron3106 因為係用發音去掩飾技巧不足, 唔係主唔主流, 而係你知道自己有樣野做得唔好, 但係你用另一樣野去遮左
如果果D歌手一直唱落去, 終有一日佢要面對呢個問題, 如果唔係永遠進步唔到
每行每業都有呢個現象, 有D野你短期可以唔去面對, 但如果你想發展落去, 你一定要逐個問題去改. 張敬軒都係咁樣逐個問題去改先去到而家呢個地位
推拉唱法對氣息不穩既人比較易，利用推拉去調控音色@@Chris-nn6to
more hins please!
軒仔唱歌，直接將首歌推去另一個層次，好聽好多
That video of Ian was 4 years ago. Please see another videos of Ian solo concert in July 2024. Ian has made a significant improvement in his vocals.
终于等到了！
Feanna debuted at 14. She just became adult in this video. She just uploaded her live performance in canton, English and japanese.
Hins！！！keep hear his song, I'm sure you will love him
希望有更多人注意到Feanna，今年出的單曲都好好聽！
坐等老師聽王傑❤❤❤
😂
相信老師會buy王傑的push。個人Signature
hins is really a brilliant and talented singer, support him forever 🍒
希望可以制作更多廣東歌🙏🏻
+1
+1
佢哋講咗咁多集都冇了解過廣東話 就知佢哋做廣東歌只係rage bait comments
踴躍的粉絲留言真的令我卻步，留言有佢參考的價值，只能講粉絲們好愛Ian。
推 c allstar 留下來的人 live版冇得輸
軒公真係👍
Hins ❤ Keen to hear rozette's opinion on more of his songs. Agree with everything you said here 😂 Hins' version is wayyyy superior
老師們經常對粵語推拉感作討論，建議做個找不同香港歌手唱英文歌做主題給老師看看,或者又有另外一些見解呢!
This song is actually wrote by the first guy - Ian Chan. He is really talented. If you could watch his solo concert to make the comparison, he had improved a lot on his singing technique. Anyway, thank you guys to put his song on this channel👏🏻
I love her comment “it is so comfortable to listen”. Thank you she love this song wrote by Ian!
Re 下側田啦，香港數1數2男歌手!
支持，呢個真係實力歌手
如果講渾然天成 真心數一不能數二了🥲
側田都有呢種維拉唱法，好多時都會每個字chok出嚟咁，仲嚴重過ian
@@aespactzen880 但缺乏support而斷開同可以選擇某d位刻意做出黎，係兩回事
@@AlexChauPhotography 而家講緊維拉唱法喎，如果片中Ian嘅所謂維拉唱法對於呢位聲樂老師嚟講已經算係誇張，咁側田嘅維拉會唔會更誇張呢？對於我嚟講，至起碼Ian唱法算自然，聽落冇乜太唔舒服同刻意。如果要講維拉，側田肯定更維拉，好似每一隻字刻意chok出嚟咁
I think it's best to text after the video, respect hins😢
對耶，也想聽你們講一下王杰，他唱歌技巧很特别
Great to have more Hins reaction videos as he’s a really good vocalist and the reference value is high. But it would be more respectful if you can focus when listening and filming the video:)
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
For 騷靈情歌, I prefer the one of 2010 concert.
為什麼每次點評張敬軒都是幾個人對比
而不像其他歌手 整集一個
听张敬轩唱歌耳朵会怀孕
Could you please text after listening to the whole song? It’s kinda disrespectful to Hins Cheung.
@@hinson-y6t she's just plain rude.
@@fennlynn7675cannot agree more with you
終於有人注意到軒公唱這首了❤❤❤這首我無限loop❤❤老師最後唱的open arms也是我很愛的歌，也可以聽Mariah Carey 的版本～老師也可以點評，老師忘記MIRROR了嗎?我記得之前看她點評姜濤，那集我快笑死哈哈哈
還有可不可以敲碗鄭中基! 他2006演唱會唱的都滿好聽的
being a non native cantonese speaker, to me, (gong dong wa) is my freaking most favourite asian language of all time. Must be the emotional attachment i have to all the tvb and cantopop i watched and listened to as a teen til now =)
I honestly feel that rozette needs to take basic canto lessons in order to understand and better appreciate canto pop. It's starting to irk me how she constantly criticises how canto songs are being sung. You're too narrow minded and just focus too much on what you're used to instead of bringing an open mind to the table. Thank god for Jay but he caves in under the immense pressure to agree with you sometimes and that's tragic really.
Can't agree more. Especially this one..."You're too narrow minded and just focus too much on what you're used to instead of bringing an open mind to the table. "
@viviennehmlai everytime she judges how the singers enunciate during a canto song I just want to scream in frustration, woman this is HOW the song is meant to be sung, it is part and parcel and beauty of the language!! It's because she's so disconnected to the songs that she only sees the so called technical *errors*. I'm not even cantonese ( I'm hakka) yet I totally get it. She should just stop reviewing all cantonese singers and songs henceforth. To spare my heart from breaking further.
@@fennlynn7675 As a Cantonese, it is my mother tongue. I share your same feeling too... Canton pop still have a lot of good singers indeed. Also, no points to do this kind of comparisons through. Just my view.
i wish that rozette can see your comment and take the advise.
軒公唱歌係勁，老師有眼光。但個女仔成日嫌軒公唔好😢。
真 你都發現
她有一集說自己不喜歡張敬軒的聲音
係喎 老師讚 佢都死話因為佢經驗多出道耐
之前老師知佢唔鐘意 讚下都好似要睇佢面色咁
but我好appreciate Jay明知佢唔鐘意都繼續揀
@@Mirrlo幾集都話唔係自己杯茶
@@minyoongistan5852 所以咁少出點評
隔離個女仔欣賞水平有限
终于等到了
第二段片應該也要聽靈魂相認
服了
Can we do a special video about Hins? Just need more Hins, thanks.
廣東話是1音1字，英文是多音1字，旋律根本就唔同。香港人用廣東話講野本身就會係咁，有呢個habit好正常，我哋耳朵無違和感。老師耳朵慣性唔同，調番講，英文一個字分開拉十多個音，對我黎講會有違和感，我聽唔明，辨識唔到係咩字。王菲母語普通話，佢廣東話發音帶普通話慣性mix。我唔係護航/評論唱得好唔好，只係指出「違和感」。
睇黎你先係讀聲樂果個
覺得係品味/表達方法>語言嘅習慣
最好例子係,林家謙
勁多字,但唔會斬到一舊舊
或者聽下鄧小巧,都唔會甘
原来如此，有道理👍
佢講緊個push/pull, 唔係淨係個音節, 廣東話唱歌係會易d有呢個問題, 但唔係正常, 好多廣東話歌手都無, e.g. 林家謙/hins/馮允謙
好既push/pull就係style黎, 張學友果種, 但已經好少人咁唱, 差果d係幾影響聽感, 好似Ian/Jer果種, 下下好重漏氣聲, 連帶埋抖氣聲
@ 見到你提jer，覺得搵到知音人😂
唔敢同人講jer唱歌style瘋狂push/pull
嘩！張敬軒呀🤩🤩
This was filmed in Ian's second year as a solo singer and he wrote this song using Whale Fall as a metaphor for sacrifice for love. Maybe check out some of his more recent live performances to see whether he has improved?
Please go easy on Feanna, this was 4 years ago when she was 19. This is Ian's song and she sings in a male key, and bass is not her strength. Maybe check out her rendition of "Vampire" by Olivia Rodrigo. She is one of the better young pop singers in HK. She is 23 now and she released her first song at the age of 14. After a hiatus of a few years when she studied in the UK, she returned to the HK music scene in 2023. Of course, there is always room for improvement.
Hins has over 25 years' experience as a professional singer and his rendition of this song is undoubtedly (and not surprisingly) better.
More hins pls
Why don't use Ian's solo version instead?
This is how the song should be sang
In this chanel, video made 4 years ago is considered new because they are benchmarking jacky cheung’s old video 😂. How about recent songs like 緊急聯繫人？ boyfriend materials? Recent cantopop market stresses more on new song creation, expressing their views beyond love while in mainland ppl are increasingly focused on perfection of technique and repeatedly sing old songs 😂 like JJ that they love, most reactions are on his cover only. Hins is still putting a lot of his thoughts in new songs that resonate with ppl.
I find it fascinating that the review content is based on performance from local artists across Asia, and yet the two hosts with Asian backgrounds that chose and provided the material to the voice coach wouldn’t bother to do some basic research and provide a bit more background of the artist, who wrote the music etc.
A quick Google search would have confirmed Ian Chan was indeed the composer of this song and also the lyricist, instead of just saying “I think he wrote it”. We don’t expect you to promote each singer but at least give credits where it’s due.
As for the female singer, her name is Feanna Wong who debuted in HK when she was 14 back in 2015. I didn’t know this information until 2 mins ago but I find it a bit disrespectful that when the vocal coach asked “who’s the girl”, the other 2 hosts just responded with “I don’t know her” when you picked this piece of performance to be reviewed to begin with, at least find out who she is?
This isn’t the first time I’ve noticed this pattern, it’s happened consistently that if it’s an artist the hosts like, they can go on and on about them (which is nostalgic and I personally enjoy tbh), but when basic questions such as who [insert less known artist] is, when was this song released, who wrote it, etc were asked, it’s often to hear “we don’t know/ not sure/ I *think* it’s so and so” with little to no effort to verify.
Keep up the great content but a little extra effort goes a long way, especially it’s difficult enough as it is to release original canto pop nowadays.
Well said
So so well said. Wish the two hosts would show a bit more respect across the board
not fair for this comparison.. not apple to apple...the presented video: Ian 1yr experience vs Hins 21yrs experience....
永遠的Hins❤
有張敬軒一定看❤
係咪我錯覺，點解好似揀親歌都搵啲以前嘅，唔係應該用近期嘅表現先公道啲？
The duet between Ian and Feanna was from 4 years ago. Please watch a newer version of this song if you really want to judge someone’s singing ability. Hin’s version was from last year and Hins he has been in the industry for over 20 years. He’s lot older and much more experienced. It’s really not a fair comparison at all. I don’t know who this vocal coach is but I feel like she’s being very disrespectful and obviously knows nothing about Hong Kong or Cantonese music. The fact that they keep talking about Jacky Cheung who is a singer from the 90’s is very telling. Come on it’s 2024 already! I don’t think the western way of singing will work on a cantopop song at all and will just sound wrong. Open your ears and your eyes and then maybe your mind won’t be so narrow. Your way is not the only way.
lol you guys reviewed quite a lot of times of Hins performance🤣🤣
the truth is Ian Chan and Miss Wong really need to develop more basic skills
為什麼不念一段歌詞給老師，讓她聽聽看。
Serrini Please.
好奇老師聽林家謙會怎樣🤣🤣🤣
好期待下一集的骚灵情歌❤❤❤❤❤❤
Can listen to Gin Lee’s singing please!!!
Thank you for this review. Really enjoyed watching it. I think Feanna Wong is a good female singer in Hong Kong today. She deserves more recognition. I hope you guys can create more reviews about her!🌟
Jay Fung and MC are great HK male singers
期待老師看張敬軒唱“俏郎君“在節目唱的live影片！
Where is Joey Yung please…? ❤
直接把原唱秒的一塌糊涂了，hins真系正。
Ian把聲係好聽,特別是唱慢歌,但認同老師說法Ian唱歌缺乏 support, vocal foundation 唔夠,所以由其是唱live好明顯唔入咪,唱廣東話係比較容易有push感,cus it’s Cantonese pronunciation. 軒公當然同Ian冇得比較,軒公功力深厚！
你係咪兩個歌手名？掉轉咗啊？
Ian段片係好多年前，如果聽可以試下聽返今年佢演出鯨落😊
@@leungkwansinqueenie3856 但佢今年聽落都係有呢個問題
I Love Ians . And i Love his voice
後者唱呢首歌連貫性係好好多，聽落係會想繼續聽落去，本來唔太好張敬軒既歌，但咁樣對比法太多細節上既野處理得好好，以後會多d聽佢live
皇上冇得頂👍
點解唔用近期既vedio評ian , tears concert 2024 咁多場都唔簡...
係咪以爲個個都鏡粉😂
@攞陳卓賢早期唱歌嘅片比近年軒公唱歌嘅片確實係搞笑😂
@@silverchim youtube睇到上載日期，拎一條4年前嘅片又話近期🤣
用邊條片都係差唔多㗎啦，唔通換過另外一條片老師就會讚到佢上天咩，實力係咁上下就係咁上下㗎啦
@@Appleeeee666 用年資經驗嚟比較 軒公係一定勝！軒公經歷過咁多👍👍所以佢都好支持陳仔🙏🙏將來lan都一樣👏👏👏💪💪💪加油！呢條片又真係陳仔初出道 以佢又唔係有正式訓練而出身.. 我覺得已經不錯！
Ian呢個合唱版已經係4年前，依家唱歌已經進步好多，如果可以聽Ian7月演唱會版都有進步，Ian最新歌 #鑿 高低音情緒都好大挑戰好唔同。都可以請老師評music Panda Ian唱櫻花樹下，謝謝。
垃圾鏡粉 2024仲MIRRO 好嘔心
又唔需要解釋禁多嘅。
佢地拎肥姜首掃掃掃黎講都唔拎啲正常嘅live黎評論啦😅
唔係bor 人地有評過 First Take 首Rumour，但係。。。。都係有待改善
@@wingchung9272 班傻粉邊識聽歌 識鬼咩叫唱功咩
都係唔好浪費老師時間啦，聽過 Thank You Postman 除夕 live，以孤獨命名 同 玩偶奇遇記 嘅叱咤 live，鑿 嘅 live 都從來無唱過，兩個字講曬，唔掂，謝謝。
轩❤
I think its related to their choice of the version of Ian. His solo version is cleaner. How spoken Cantonese sound? referring to Jacky cheung, pls show his “食屎啦你” video 😂😂
No compare no despair...Hins upgraded the song.
感覺旁邊個兩位華人主持對香港樂壇不熟悉, 只知道如張學友那些舊一輩的歌手, 或者是現時比較有話題性的歌手, 其實香港還有其他好歌手啦...e.g. 小肥, c allstar, 林奕匡等等
p.s. SoulJase 版的騷靈情歌 也是一流的
dear my friend的reaction可以安排了
其實老師有講過一點唱歌應該要好似平時講野咁 而ian chest voice比較弱 係氣唔夠既情況下咪要加力去唱歌 做成推拉既感覺
介紹番香港新一代男歌手：林家謙，Jay Fung，陳健安，Gareth T，MC，周殷廷。 謝謝🙏🏻 期待你地點評林家謙😆😆😆😆
林家謙就算啦，😂佢都唔係賣唱功
@@whywhysayso賣唱功先值得被推介？btw 我唔覺得單單用唱功就可以評斷一個歌手既價值
@@bckck918 咁老實講佢唱功真係below standard, 但係我無懷疑過佢有才華
@@whywhysayso閱✅
算吧啦
Really should listen to MIKA. He sings beautifully
😍軒公
入嚟聽軒公❤
請問老師會否喜歡黃博的我歌故我在？
Why not compare the two (Ian and Hins) in the duet sang in this music panda episode?
Did the coach forget Hins’s ngoi ngoi ngoi song already? 😂
可以說一下香港新生代的曾比特嗎
7:20 haha... that expression :)
其實我真係唔識分邊句係push邊句唔係push😂 係咪我問題
完全不明白，Ian那麼多個鯨落版本，為何要找一個和一個女生合唱的早期版本…之後卻找來張敬軒唱的版本來比較😅真的搞不懂你們的用意是什出…張敬軒唱功當然非常之好，但你們找一個剛出道的Ian版本去比較（你們知道這首歌是他自己作曲填詞吧？！為什麼找一個合唱版本）感覺不被尊重😔
還有一點，你地找歌給老師去評論之前，為何不做資料蒐集，老師問你們的時候，經常都說不知道，這樣怎樣叫老師去了解這歌曲或歌手呢…☹️
@@look_91 這頻道就是不會預先做資料蒐集，主要是看當下聽到的感覺，不在乎是誰唱或什麼背景
感覺不被尊重....同感☹
@@ykli2847可是老師問Jay這是不是舊影片的時候，他很明確的說no, this is actually new，可是明明是好幾年前的舊片
@ 你得想想他們年齡層，對比張學友，是挺new的了吧。。。
算把啦，無論係佢啱啱出道定而家咪一樣唱得差😂係得你哋班mirror粉聽唔出㗎啫
投軒公一票🤣聽軒公唱歌就是舒服❤
解釋一下為什麼有些人會覺得Ian和黃淑蔓唱得不好，想平反一下。
1.本身歌曲不是設計做為合唱歌，為了合唱他們做了升2 key的改動，對兩人都不是最好的key，尤其是對女生而言，這個key是偏低，會唱得比較「平淡」。這種情況而言跟張敬軒版本比較是不公平的，因為張敬軒可以選自己最佳的key去唱。（但無論如何我認為張是唱得更好，一貫地唱得很好）
2.Ian 和黃淑蔓的版本明顯地沒多大修音，你會聽到一些輕微走音和甚至聽到聲音在顫抖。在這個世代，這種呈現真實的片段是非常難能可貴。而且我可以說，大部份粵語音樂節目的製作，在真實性上都比內地、西方、日本、韓國的製作強很多，很多演唱都很真實地暴露歌手缺陷，這是整個粵語歌大環境最要去珍惜的風氣之一，別個地區的歌手你甚至沒有聽過他真實的聲音，因為所有片段都是精修的，那些歌唱節目唱功看起來很強的歌手，其實跟Ian也是差不多程度的唱功，這是事實。你說fan cam能作準？fan cam都不算什麼，舞台聲音的輸出本身就有大量reverb和可能的即時autotune，真實性根本比不過這種把聲音收得超清然後又不怎麼去修音的音樂節目。
我完全不理解為何港樂現場錄影大部份都不做精修，事實就是這樣，當今世界的清泉。
我覺得他們真的唱得不錯，但如果你聽慣味精／cd，這些香港歌手現場你是不會聽慣的。
Ian 強項係作曲
@@KK-xu7ld
你咩行內人咁巴閉呀！開名呀！
亂抹黑！
@@tomwong5082 難聽就係難聽
唱腔同技巧都唔夠好
專業嘅cm都係睇返呢段片啦
天真 你以為獨唱就好？
@@KK-xu7ld 咩行內人咁巴閉呀！開名囉！
齋抹黑邊個唔識
Hins version is heavily edited.
The singer is lacking the foundation of support. For sure😂😂😂
想睇林家謙 Terence Lam
想聽佢講林家謙
If you are going to show 誰明浪子心 by Dave wong, please also compare it with G.E.M and Hubert Wu's version.
張生！！！
對，香港市場是廣東話為主，母語就是廣東話。發音就是有這個習慣。張敬軒比較資深，唱功無用致疑。Ian Chan 陳卓賢Mirror 成員之一，亦有出Solo . 大部份歌曲也是自己創作。香港粤語樂壇需要培養更多有理想的新血，繼續發展。 咸魚青菜，各有所愛🙏
就算張敬軒出道都贏左十條街啦 到底有冇聽過架