Which Loquat is BEST? Seedling vs Grafted

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 65

  • @teter129
    @teter129 7 місяців тому +5

    I’ve watched a ton of Loquat videos, this one is by far the best and most informative. Nice job bro!

  • @ZonaFigs
    @ZonaFigs Рік тому +7

    I've got 4 seedlings in the ground and a few more in pots, all from seeds from different peoples trees and at different stages, so I'm very excited to see what I get. 2 of them are on their 3rd year, so I think definitely this year I should see some fruit. And I agree that lowquats are way better grown from seed. Thanks Allen great video, as always.

    • @waynekitchen7134
      @waynekitchen7134 9 місяців тому

      I'm in Jacksonville Florida and I think your Loquat trees in the Carolinas will do far better there even though it gets extremely hot here...Can you tell me what type of fertilizer you use ?

  • @BLCustoms
    @BLCustoms Рік тому +2

    Another great honest video of advice. I have read that seedlings only produce after 7-12 years. This advice helped me make a loquat decision. Thank you much.

  • @AmzBackyardOrchardandVineyard
    @AmzBackyardOrchardandVineyard Рік тому +2

    we want to add loquats to our orchard. thanks for he tips and tricks!

  • @borracho-joe7255
    @borracho-joe7255 Рік тому +1

    Ordered some seeds a week ago; thanks for the knowledge!

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому +1

      Propagation video coming up. Make sure your seeds are fresh. If they go dry, they won't sprout.

  • @melindaxbc5605
    @melindaxbc5605 9 місяців тому +1

    Great info. THANK YOU!

  • @vnxettitw4879
    @vnxettitw4879 8 місяців тому +1

    Wow you made a great case for seedlings! I was debating between them but was also impatient for fruit lol. I think I'll get 1 of each to test the theory.

  • @yulduzrakhimova4376
    @yulduzrakhimova4376 Рік тому +3

    I have 3 seedlings planted in ground 2 years ago (I grow them from seeds). I saw info that they usually start flowering in 4-6 years and I was thinking I need to graft them in some point. After watching your video it seems I don't need to graft them and they might flower this winter. I am in California zone 9b and think it is one of the best climate for them.

    • @MontereyPhoto
      @MontereyPhoto Рік тому

      I'm in zone 9b as well (Monterey Bay) I have 6 seedlings which I started under grow lights but now they're outside in small pots. I eventually want to graft them with other loquat trees in the neighborhood.

  • @rebeccaryan6229
    @rebeccaryan6229 Рік тому +1

    Great video!

  • @margaretmarshall3645
    @margaretmarshall3645 11 місяців тому +2

    Seems like an air layered loquat would give you the best of both worlds. Are those available?

  • @TheChenny73
    @TheChenny73 8 місяців тому

    Seedlings that are started in the actual ground will always have a better root structure than a plant started in a pot. I’ve been to too many nurseries where their stock almost useless and waste of money because the trees are so root bound there’s no saving them. Good video.

  • @danielfisch655
    @danielfisch655 Рік тому +1

    Great information, thank you for sharing.

  • @thehillsidegardener3961
    @thehillsidegardener3961 7 місяців тому

    Some great tips. Loquat is definitely not native to my area, I only heard of them when my wife brought some fruits back from Israel. I have now planted out a 3-year-old seedling in our hot, dry but temperate climate, it's doing great for now, hoping for some fruit in a couple of years. I really don't care about named varieties, I just hope it survives our sometimes harsh winters.

  • @trito408
    @trito408 7 місяців тому

    My seedling took almost 7 years to flower. When it flowered it was about 12 ft tall.

  • @sheckydiamond7533
    @sheckydiamond7533 8 місяців тому +2

    I'm lucky. My loquat from seed have good fruit.

  • @curtsheldon2655
    @curtsheldon2655 2 місяці тому

    Do you have to plant a seedling in a starter pot first? Or can you plant the seedling in the ground? Thanks

  • @skycloud41
    @skycloud41 Рік тому

    Superb video man

  • @geriannroth449
    @geriannroth449 7 місяців тому

    Agreed! Do you have any White Sopote trees? I'd love to purchase some seeds.
    I just planted out over 40 loquat seeds from a Big Jim variety. Gotta wait & see what they produce. Two to three years ain't bad thought considering some fruit trees can take 8 - 15 years to fruit from seed for example a seed grown Mangosteen.
    Here in Barbados we don't get those extreme high temperatures you get in Arizona but if you forget to water your potted grafted plants the first thing to go is that grafted section, the rootstock bounces back with fresh new growth but the grafted scion withers & usually dies off.😢

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  6 місяців тому

      i have grafted trees no seeds though. Keep the seeds moist to wet for the loquats.

    • @geriannroth449
      @geriannroth449 6 місяців тому

      ​@@qctropicalsthanks for the tip

  • @KR-by3es
    @KR-by3es 8 місяців тому

    Wathing from India..I planted a seedling plant which starts fruit bearing after 4 yrs.. not in large in numbers..but good.

  • @LostInThisGardenofLife
    @LostInThisGardenofLife Рік тому

    Awesome video. Loquats are such beautiful trees, definitely one of my favorites in the garden.

    • @azgardener79
      @azgardener79 Рік тому +2

      I agree. The foliage is beautiful. Almost unreal

  • @kimoamadal4626
    @kimoamadal4626 Рік тому

    Mon Néflier du Japon a germé à partir d'une graine. Il a huit mois et semble avoir de petites feuilles !

  • @daveaz9962
    @daveaz9962 Рік тому

    Allen, I won’t be back to Phoenix until mid July. Would it be okay to plant a seedling loquat say mid September?

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому +1

      ofcourse, just shade it for this summer. I'll ever hook you up with some shade cloth!

  • @jasminhohaia9608
    @jasminhohaia9608 Рік тому

    Which way do you plant loquat seed

  • @nezpierce_
    @nezpierce_ Рік тому

    Do you sell seeds? I have a huge seed starting area I made and I would love to try to sprout about 10 of these

  • @cesarbiscarr3604
    @cesarbiscarr3604 9 місяців тому +1

    Does anyone know of anybody that has grown or is growing a Loquat on Long Island, NY?

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  9 місяців тому

      too cold, your soil freezes.

    • @nesq4104
      @nesq4104 8 місяців тому

      Too cold

  • @stephenking4170
    @stephenking4170 5 місяців тому

    Loquat is called Biwa in Japan.

  • @trip8263
    @trip8263 Рік тому

    I bought a Vista White from a seedling . I was told it is self fertile, but I read online that it is not self fertile. Do you know if that variety is self fertile?

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому

      self-fertile but will produce more with others around. Remember, it's also a seedling so variations are to be expected.

  • @tlc8386
    @tlc8386 2 місяці тому

    Loquats grow very well in Southern California---just an fyi

  • @Pamsgarden213
    @Pamsgarden213 Рік тому

    I checked the website and did not see loquats. I would like to buy one of the seedlings. Do you have any avilable and are you still at the same place or did you move everything to the new nursery already?

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому +1

      website will be updated shortly!. Still at same place, new nursery once I get $ to build a parking lot we'll move there :)

    • @Pamsgarden213
      @Pamsgarden213 Рік тому

      @@qctropicals , I will try to stop by over the next few weekends.

  • @ZE308AC
    @ZE308AC Рік тому

    I like the Japanese loquats fruit which is big

  • @orangetuono38
    @orangetuono38 Рік тому

    You might have the only non-religiousy tropical's channel for us here in Phoenix.

  • @JesseChoupique
    @JesseChoupique Рік тому +1

    Great video. Here in Louisiana, we call it "mispilusse" or "Mrs. Police". hahahahahah They are great. Makes great wine.

  • @chosen2030
    @chosen2030 Рік тому

    If your seed came from a self fertile tree, is there any chance the seedling won't be self fertile?

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому

      homie, loquats are self-fertile. I keep seeing this question being asked everywhere about loquats. In all these years, I haven't had an issue getting fruit out of any of the varieties we sell here at the nursery. But to answer your question, seeds will vary, it can go either way whether it be a loquat or any other not true to type seed.

    • @chosen2030
      @chosen2030 Рік тому

      @@qctropicals really, I've read in several places that Vista White loquats are not self fertile, but I'm glad that's incorrect because that's the variety I have!

  • @tlc8386
    @tlc8386 2 місяці тому

    Have you ever grown from a branch---?

  • @peter320vn
    @peter320vn 4 місяці тому

    Seedling tree also live longer than grafted one.

  • @bertbert2725
    @bertbert2725 Рік тому +1

    grafted to quince rootstock gets you a smaller tree with a deeper root system

  • @pierreboyer9277
    @pierreboyer9277 4 місяці тому

    Seedlings are still a bit of a lottery. You don't know what you get. If you haev a big land and can put 10 then it makes sense. If you can have only 1 though... You risk waiting for 5-7 years and have nothing or very few fruits. You also may have a super-good tree.

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  4 місяці тому

      not my experience.

    • @pierreboyer9277
      @pierreboyer9277 4 місяці тому

      ​@@qctropicals That's good to hear. In my town (near Paris France), all but one loquat that I see in the garden have very poor fruit quality (very few and very small). I thought it was because they were seedlings used mostly for their easthetic.
      I'll try my luck anyway :)

  • @bonholio0o
    @bonholio0o 7 місяців тому +1

    I have a gold nugget grown from seedling given to me by a friend, it's 5 years old standing at only 3 feet tall and hasn't produced a single fruit. Avoid seedling at all cost for every trees out there. I think I'll need to wait another 3 more years to get anything out of this guy. Whereas my Big Jim grafted onto quince rootstock produces 8 fruits within 2 months of purchase, it was already standing at 3 feet tall. Always always buy air layered or grafted varieties where grower took a mature branch that has already beared fruit so you don't end up waiting.

    • @inchristalone25
      @inchristalone25 2 місяці тому

      3 ft tall after 5 years???? Sounds like it is failure to thrive.

  • @harrysollmer1644
    @harrysollmer1644 7 місяців тому

    In 2 second's i xan tell you if any seed will be lifeless/needing attention/or a bumper growth plant 😅 wont tell you how thats my secret..

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  7 місяців тому

      i can do that in 1 second. I did tell you my secret in the video.

  • @LostInThisGardenofLife
    @LostInThisGardenofLife Рік тому

    Some of my seedlings have reached over 10ft in a few years here in NC. Hopefully with climate change, I’ll get some fruit. 🤣

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому

      how many years?. Have you had flowers yet?

    • @LostInThisGardenofLife
      @LostInThisGardenofLife Рік тому

      @@qctropicals I currently have a grafted variety that flowers but it always gets nipped by the cold. My seedling trees haven’t flowered yet but I know they will soon. Unfortunately 6 years ago I had to cut down my grandfather’s loquats because they were too close to the house, the family wanted me to. I would have kept them because the flowers had the whole garden smelling amazing during the winter. The 3 trees I cut down were over 15ft. I’m still upset about it. :(

    • @LostInThisGardenofLife
      @LostInThisGardenofLife Рік тому

      Honestly I think one of them was maybe 25ft tall and at least 10 years old.

    • @qctropicals
      @qctropicals  Рік тому +1

      @@LostInThisGardenofLife that's too bad. I see people planting massive trees right next to their houses here all the time.