One thing I would like to mention that I am envious of is Bro Imrans sabr. Ma sha Allah... I make dua to Allah(swt) to bless me with this kind of sabr. The man is just a very patient brother. JazakAllahu khair for the chat and the share of knowledge. Could listen all day. Stay safe my brothers. BarackAllahu feek
4 роки тому+2
Lol only bob the donkey could make him lose his temper
You know what's wild about Jack? He will say nothing to counter what Hijab said, just ramble and totally elude the questions and when the brothers get tired of not getting a reply and they cut him off they will counter that with "Oh you guys are dodgey and clever cutting people off before theycan explain" these guys seem like psychos to be honest. Man poses question. Man 2 wants clarification Man readdresses the question Man 2 still needs more clarification Man rewords question for 3rd time. Man then begins to elude initial question with long winded story. At the end of the day it all hinges on knowledge, confidence in what you believe and sincerity and personally it seems like Jack is totally insincere. I listened to him expecting to get some sort of feedback and all he did was kick up dust.
@@guystryke3966 Well the reason why they like him is because he cannot be refuted because he doesn't have a position. Hahahaha I mean its brilliant really. Enter debate, get asked questions, open a dialog but you don't believe in anything, you don't have a position on anything and when the opposition grows tired not getting off the starting block and leave they say "why are you running away". Hahaha Its brilliant! 🤣🤣🤣 Pure unadulterated madness.
@ Just laugh bro lol. Its truly hilarious. I love all yall for the sake of Allah. May Allah keep us upright, sincere and steadfast and make us all die as Muslims. Ameen🤲🏼
I’m glad I didn’t skip the “Jack” part, even though my brain hurts from listening to him, but it was worth it for the laugh at 23:40 where Hijab rusted him hh Also isn’t “Jack” called Brenda now I think it’s the same Being called Brenda from recent livestreams.
Jack's supporter doesn't have a view on anything other than that there is no creator. He doesn't know what infinity is...."an arbitrarily large number😂😂😂😂"
@Hamza. I couldn’t believe the ear bleed I got from this guy Jack. So I looked him up on Google. It turns out that he’s a professional troll and he behaves this way on all streams that he visits. I also learnt that he lives on an inheritance and just trolls live streams all day.
did no one notice that this 'some guy' is the same guy as 'ask yourself' ? pay attention to his voice and the way he talks. it's highly likely they're the same person and he just changed his name to come back again for whatever reason.
I think Jack, in asking for a syllogism first or asking for a argument later, was trying to get Mohammad Hijab to give a strawman of his own argument so the guy could destroy it but he never did so he turned into a broken record
@Aes Oup diverting from the topic by ignorant insults. If you can't give the references to what you're accusing then I would request you get off the comment section.
1.Al-Hijr 15:19 وَٱلْأَرْضَ مَدَدْنَٰهَا وَأَلْقَيْنَا فِيهَا رَوَٰسِىَ وَأَنۢبَتْنَا فِيهَا مِن كُلِّ شَىْءٍ مَّوْزُونٍ And the earth - We have spread it and cast therein firmly set mountains and caused to grow therein [something] of every well-balanced thing. Where do you find flat earth here?
A message to those who challenge Islam Do you ever wonder why there are so many religions out there but the only religion people work so hard to prove wrong and to oppose is Islam? There are a lot of other religions which may seem wrong, and illogical too but from what I see, Islam receives the most opposition. The more you want to prove it wrong, the more right it is, isn't it? You watch Islamic videos even though you're not a muslim - and then you put comments to prove Islam wrong. What's your point?? You're not a muslim, but you read Quran, trying to prove Islam wrong. What's your point? You comment on other people's comments, trying to prove their wrong. What's your point? Why do you have to work so hard to prove Islam wrong? You can just walk away and be like, "OK whatever you know I'm just going to go on with my life. I can just leave muslims as they are, just like how I don't try to prove other buddhists or christians wrong." But you didn't do that, do you? You didn't leave muslims as they are. You go on every Islamic videos on UA-cam and work hard to prove the videos wrong. You go on each comments, and work hard to prove people wrong. What's your point? Why can't you leave Islam as it is? Why can't you leave muslims as they are? Why can't you leave us alone? Why do you have to work so hard to PROVE ISLAM WRONG? Because, the truth is, the problem lies in YOURSELF. There is that little voice inside your head, whispering to you, "Islam sounds like a true religion..." but you hated that voice! You clenched your fists, gritted your teeth, and denied it! You watched Islamic videos and you were close to be convinced, but you shake your head, clearing the images away. You read Islamic comments, and you were close to be convinced, but you bit your lip and yelled, "No!". The problem lies in yourself. YOU WANT TO PROVE ISLAM WRONG BECAUSE YOU DON'T WANT TO BE CONVINCED THAT ISLAM /IS/ THE TRUE RELIGION. Your ego, man. Your ego..
Their argument for the sniper basically based on the definition of infinity is an arbitrary large number, which is ridiculous because any number, regardless of how big it is, is still finite. They are the one have to prove this.
جزاك الله شيخ همزة ...... الله يبارك في عمرك باخير و السعادة ...... سلامي وتحياتي للشيخ همزة ..... أنا في كردستان- العراق ............ سلاو رێز بۆ ماموستا همزە ... من لە کوردستانم .... Salamuhalaikum,, hello , how are ? I love you .... and I wish I can to speak to you .... by online ....... but how I can .....
@@drewdrake9130 Me personally? I don’t. But what I know is that Allah will show EVERYONE signs, and the message will reach almost everyone. The day someone dies is the only day that, we know, his test has ended and the signs were shown to him as in Chapter 17 verse 15: “Whoever is guided is only guided for [the benefit of] his soul. And whoever errs only errs against it. And no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another. And never would We punish until We sent a messenger” And only then, the trial will be waiting for everyone.
@@hebt9mlk Thank you for your answer. But, since you have no way to tell whether someone has indeed been Guided by Allah, I have to ask... When someone tells you they've been Guided by Allah, do you just believe them even though you have no way to tell? What I'm trying to figure out is how it can be determined that someone has indeed been Guided by Allah, and that they're not just honestly mistaken, or worse yet, just imagining things.
@@drewdrake9130 If someone came and said to me “Allah has guided me to Islam, I’m Muslim now” i would believe him because we believe that Islam is the guiding path, but we can’t be for sure if someone will STILL be on that path.
@@hebt9mlk Yes, you would believe this person was actually Guided by Allah, even though you admit you have no way to tell if they've actually been Guided by Allah, because you believe Islam is the guiding path. Did I represent what you said correctly? If so, I can't really see how this could ever be considered a method to confirm that someone has indeed been Guided by Allah. Is there a way to confirm that someone has indeed been Guided by Allah? If so, please tell me what step one would be. Please understand I am just trying to confirm the claim that someone has been Guided by Allah, and just believing that someone has been Guided by Allah doesn't get us any closer to confirming the claim.
I feel like the infinite chain of permissions smuggles in the premise of time, which the atheist doesn't really have to deal with. Supposedly, the chain of causes for the universe has to be, at some point, timeless. The only example of a timeless domain I can think of is found in pure mathematics. For example, there's an infinite amount of real numbers between 0 and 1. So just because there's an infinite amount of reals from zero to get to 1 doesn't mean that somehow the concept of 1 is thus impossible. Again, within this timeless domain, we can logically prove all sorts of mind boggling things (e.g: some infinities being larger than other infinities).
but nowdays with movies people expect more . for example if someone fall from a building and survived he wont belive cuz there are alot of movies shows this might happen. we have to edcuate people and than start telling them how to goes
Jack and his cheerleader some guy are immature just like any atheist is. Yes we muslims got a bit excited hearing there nonsense and may be some of us have mocked them silently. But at the end of the day, let us pray for their guidance from Allah. we want good for all to meet in jannat.
Yes it is possible for the sniper to take the shot without permission. Sometimes there is no time to wait and they have to make a decision on their own.
@@furioustacowarrior1489 His actions are not necessarily dependent on authority because other possibility's exist. The analogy doesn't even reflect causation in our universe since there are no infinite steps between cause and effect.
Brothers, you should have said: "If there is infinite regress, this means that nobody in the chain has the self-sufficient power to permit. Therefore, nothing in the chain has this power. Hence, this chain does not contain this power. Therefore, the permission to shoot cannot be given as a result of this infinite chain". Then the atheists would be able to say nothing.
Putting aside the many philosophical and theological arguments, there remains this, if a god/gods existed, there would only be one religion, because everyone would know about the god or gods, yet instead we see thousands of gods and millions of demigod religions/stories that are different. As Hitchens i think it was that said, all religions cannot be right, they can all be wrong.
And if you read Quran you would have known this answer .GOD send us with One religion But with Choice thats why we will be hold Accountable . If we were act as GOD Programmed us then Judgment would be unfair . These are people who changed the one religion into many .Personal desire , benefits , Power etc made human to change the law of GOD and GOD let it be because it was the test But GOD send His Prophets one after another to bring Human back on track . I am giving you a link of videos which shows how human changed one Monotheistic religion in to Polytheistic etc Start from Adam Pbuh and Slowly goes on SO watch every Prophet ua-cam.com/video/dB6KZc9Y9ZI/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/ee6qv9oOkyA/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/60Q-nQsJhTM/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/xZoBB8TsPNw/v-deo.html
@@rajababy2009 i have read some it, and i listen to believers like here, the problem with that argument is, other religions say the same thing and believe as much as any other believer does in their religion or with their god/gods.. I know no way of testing ones beliefs against another's. They have to be seen as equal or faith loses meaning. Logically, if there was a being that could grant prayers and eternal life most if not all people would follow it, why wouldn't you? I would. The fact that all religions are in a minority against the global population puts believers in no better a position than other believers or non believers. All are in a minority. If there were a few people who didint follow the one religion, logically it would seem it must be true, some are just missing the point or whatever, when the majority rejects every religion, logically if you look at it from the outside, there must be a problem beyond what the believer accepts yet also rejects at the same time when its their belief versus another.
@@davespond9176 If you sit lazy and dont research then it is your fault ? this is the question of your existence why you are here ? In Islam we believed that GOD is Just So he will give equal opportunity to every Human being to defend him or herself ? SO research at least you would have reason that you try with Open mind . In Islam GOD will deal Justly with those who did not receive Islam Message or distort version of Islam message . the First word of Quran was "Iqra" means read So you must read to find the correct path and also do at least Skeptic prayer that God if you are there and exist Guide me . www.quran.com
@@rajababy2009 ive been studying beliefs for forty years. if you want to try and insult me rather than a reason why one belief is more than valid than another its one more reason on my list to dismiss beliefs as all equal in their validity. Ghosts, monsters in lakes and forests, palm readers, gods, ufos, all equal in their validity.
Okay I think what Jack meant with the whole infinite sniper thing. If the sniper needs infinite permission can he take the shot? Jacks answer that he can still take the shot is valid if you assume the sniper has FREE WILL. He can still take the shot in that case. If the sniper doesn't have FREE WILL, then you are right he cannot take the shot.
I’m surprised young guy can even use the phone for his level of intelligence, he has zero logic so trying to have him understand he can’t it’s impossible for him. But Alhoumdulilah your being kind to him and he is being arrogant with his stupidity.
"black belt" jack - you just displayed why atheism is an utterly illogical belief system (at best) . When cornered, all you could do, as Bro Hijab stated, is act in a "fully ignorant" manner.
Hello. I am an atheist. I define atheism as suspending acknowledgement of the existence of gods until sufficient evidence can be presented. My position is that *_I have no good reason to acknowledge the existence of gods._* And here is the evidence as to why I currently hold to such a position. 1. I personally have never observed a god. 2. I have never encountered a person whom has claimed to have observed a god. 3. I know of no accounts of persons claiming to have observed a god that were willing or able to demonstrate or verify their observation for authenticity, accuracy, or validity. 4. I have never been presented a valid logical argument which also employed sound premises that lead deductively to a conclusion that a god(s) exists. 5. Of the 46 logical syllogisms I have encountered arguing for the existence of a god(s), I have found all to contain multiple fallacious or unsubstantiated premises. 6. I have never observed a phenomenon in which the existence of a god was a necessary antecedent for the known or probable explanation for the causation of that phenomenon. 7. Several proposed (and generally accepted) explanations for observable phenomena that were previously based on the agency of a god(s), have subsequently been replaced with rational, natural explanations, each substantiated with evidence that excluded the agency of a god(s). I have never encountered _vice versa._ 8. I have never experienced the presence of a god through intercession of angels, divine revelation, the miraculous act of divinity, or any occurrence of a supernatural event. 9. Every phenomena that I have ever observed has *_emerged_* from necessary and sufficient antecedents over time without exception. In other words, I have never observed a phenomenon (entity, process, object, event, process, substance, system, or being) that was created _ex nihilo_ - that is instantaneously came into existence by the solitary volition of a deity. 10. All claims of a supernatural or divine nature that I have encountered have either been refuted to my satisfaction, or do not present as falsifiable. ALL of these facts lead me to the only rational conclusion that concurs with the realities I have been presented - and that is the fact that there is *_no good reason_* for me to acknowledge the existence of a god. I have heard often that atheism is the denial of the Abrahamic god. But denial is the active rejection of a substantiated fact once credible evidence has been presented. Atheism is simply withholding such acknowledgement until sufficient credible evidence is introduced. *_It is natural, rational, and prudent to be skeptical of unsubstatiated claims, especially extraordinary ones._* I welcome any cordial response. Peace.
@@cleverzoro7069 How would I _know?_ I _believe_ the universe to be an eternal realm within which all phenomena occur. And I have never encountered any evidence that suggests our cosmos (if not universe) had a beginning. In fact I have never encountered any evidence that any phenomena has a beginning. Each and every phenomenon (object, event, process, substance, entity, system, or being) that I have encountered seems to EMERGE from necessary and sufficient antecedents over some finite amount of time no matter how brief or epoch the interval. Hope that answered your question. I will gladly answer any other question you have a out my position of atheism.
@@theoskeptomai2535 Well it's been scientifically proven that the universe had a beginning and one of the theory's is big bang etc etc. The universe began 13.8 billion years ago so it had to be caused since it has a beginning. Jazakallah.
because the Qur'an is for all mankind as a guide to life in the world, as a source of knowledge and as a guide to be loved by Allah SWT (the only God) & Prophet Muhammad (last prophet) it will not be possible that (God) Allah will mislead / deceiving all humans (his creation so the accusation is all nonsense. That is why Allah SWT maintains the authenticity of the Quran until the Day of Resurrection to be used by all mankind. Alhamdulillah.
I didn't know jack was in ignorant mood until hijab started to explain..... I also dont think the problem is jack.. I think the problem is the Shaytan that keep whispering in jack ear he know jack weak point and he keep dragging him to a dead end I wish if jack can see what hijab was trying to help him to see Hamza please if you saw jack again give him another chance.. And If u have enough time try to explain to the man in a different and easier way Dont give up on him I have a good feeling about jack, thank you all 4 the effort.
This is probably the best atheist smack down I’ve seen/heard in a long time. Jack is the ‘black belt’ in word games and dodging questions.
Childish atheists being childish. They're literally just trying to waste your time to prevent any meaningful discussion.
Mr big boy pants who studied some maths knows better, lol
Love the answering atheist series, just shows how deluded these people are Subhan Allah.
ua-cam.com/video/S7FzlO8x-R4/v-deo.html
‘BLACK BELT’
hahahahaha
😂😂😂😂 Jack’s friend, “some guy” threw Jack, and the professor under the bus.
15:28 based on their logic I think Jack was his professor...😂😂😂
One thing I would like to mention that I am envious of is Bro Imrans sabr. Ma sha Allah... I make dua to Allah(swt) to bless me with this kind of sabr. The man is just a very patient brother. JazakAllahu khair for the chat and the share of knowledge. Could listen all day. Stay safe my brothers. BarackAllahu feek
Lol only bob the donkey could make him lose his temper
@ even that would be questionable.
You know what's wild about Jack? He will say nothing to counter what Hijab said, just ramble and totally elude the questions and when the brothers get tired of not getting a reply and they cut him off they will counter that with "Oh you guys are dodgey and clever cutting people off before theycan explain" these guys seem like psychos to be honest.
Man poses question.
Man 2 wants clarification
Man readdresses the question
Man 2 still needs more clarification
Man rewords question for 3rd time.
Man then begins to elude initial question with long winded story.
At the end of the day it all hinges on knowledge, confidence in what you believe and sincerity and personally it seems like Jack is totally insincere. I listened to him expecting to get some sort of feedback and all he did was kick up dust.
@@guystryke3966 Well the reason why they like him is because he cannot be refuted because he doesn't have a position. Hahahaha I mean its brilliant really. Enter debate, get asked questions, open a dialog but you don't believe in anything, you don't have a position on anything and when the opposition grows tired not getting off the starting block and leave they say "why are you running away". Hahaha Its brilliant! 🤣🤣🤣
Pure unadulterated madness.
@Alp Arslan caucasia?
@ Just laugh bro lol. Its truly hilarious. I love all yall for the sake of Allah. May Allah keep us upright, sincere and steadfast and make us all die as Muslims. Ameen🤲🏼
@Alp Arslan LOOOOL! Ameen.
@@guystryke3966 Excellent analogy.
How can infinite means large number? Large number is countable. Infinity is unlimited.😎
But my teacher is wrong ? Lol
There are different types of infinities. I guess that's what they use as a loophole to beat around the bush.
@@xenomorphisisdilage472 infinity has no beginning and no end, it's not measurable, therefore it cannot be a number
@@gamerkits9697 literally that simple . but hey cheerleader's will cheer
Depends on the context used for math or philosophy. Infinity is defined by the context of the statement.
I’m glad I didn’t skip the “Jack” part, even though my brain hurts from listening to him, but it was worth it for the laugh at 23:40 where Hijab rusted him hh
Also isn’t “Jack” called Brenda now I think it’s the same Being called Brenda from recent livestreams.
Kermit the frog - "Sorry I wasn't actually done talking"
You should've asked him to come on only after counting to infinity that would've saved us all some time.
love this!
Your comment deserves a nobel prize 😂😁
Sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry ERROR 404 😂
جزاك الله خير شيخ حمزه
The "Black Belt" atheist just got "KHABIBED". 😂😂😂 The cheerleader "Some Guy" seems to have given up his UA-cam account too.
Jack's supporter doesn't have a view on anything other than that there is no creator. He doesn't know what infinity is...."an arbitrarily large number😂😂😂😂"
Jacks cheerleader made me 😂
12:26 Br Imaran: That's not even entering the dojo" This basically sums up the atheists when pressed.. blackbelt wafflers!
Sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry..... infinity plus 1 😂
@Hamza. I couldn’t believe the ear bleed I got from this guy Jack. So I looked him up on Google. It turns out that he’s a professional troll and he behaves this way on all streams that he visits. I also learnt that he lives on an inheritance and just trolls live streams all day.
جزاكم الله خير الجزاء وبارك الله فيك وفقك لما يحب ويرضى
Jack fell down and broken his crown and someguy came tumbling after !
Why is Hijab always in his car
Look how emotional these atheists get
did no one notice that this 'some guy' is the same guy as 'ask yourself' ? pay attention to his voice and the way he talks. it's highly likely they're the same person and he just changed his name to come back again for whatever reason.
I’m pretty sure he’s the same guy, Jack can’t possibly have more than one hype man/ cheerleader hh
I am so proud of my 3 brothers...they speak so intelligently...I wish atheists would have more integrity.
Thank you for your kind words
I dont know why you guys entertained this "jack angstreich" guy when he is clearly playing games. The definition of Intellectual dishonesty.
I think Jack, in asking for a syllogism first or asking for a argument later, was trying to get Mohammad Hijab to give a strawman of his own argument so the guy could destroy it but he never did so he turned into a broken record
احبك في الله اخي حمزة، اللهم صلي وسلم على خير من مشى على هذه الأرض سيدنا محمد
Do 1+1 = 2 ?
Jack = Do you have an argument that it's 2 ??
Salam Hamza, can anyone take part on the stream since I have some questions regarding Islam?
"MaTh PrOfeSsOR" told you a wrong definition of infinity? **Facepalm**
This Jack guy is a troll. "Do you have a argument? What's your argument? What do you meant counting?"
OMG ! Can somebody give him some brain cells ?
@Aes Oup Are you sure buddy? That's good. Cause your athiest buddy up there isn't sure about anything. LoL 😂
@Aes Oup seems like you got your feelings hurt because the Atheist “black belt” got obliterated.
@Aes Oup wtf are you talking about? Give references.
@Aes Oup diverting from the topic by ignorant insults. If you can't give the references to what you're accusing then I would request you get off the comment section.
1.Al-Hijr 15:19
وَٱلْأَرْضَ مَدَدْنَٰهَا وَأَلْقَيْنَا فِيهَا رَوَٰسِىَ وَأَنۢبَتْنَا فِيهَا مِن كُلِّ شَىْءٍ مَّوْزُونٍ
And the earth - We have spread it and cast therein firmly set mountains and caused to grow therein [something] of every well-balanced thing.
Where do you find flat earth here?
A message to those who challenge Islam
Do you ever wonder why there are so many religions out there but the only religion people work so hard to prove wrong and to oppose is Islam? There are a lot of other religions which may seem wrong, and illogical too but from what I see, Islam receives the most opposition. The more you want to prove it wrong, the more right it is, isn't it? You watch Islamic videos even though you're not a muslim - and then you put comments to prove Islam wrong. What's your point?? You're not a muslim, but you read Quran, trying to prove Islam wrong. What's your point? You comment on other people's comments, trying to prove their wrong. What's your point? Why do you have to work so hard to prove Islam wrong? You can just walk away and be like, "OK whatever you know I'm just going to go on with my life. I can just leave muslims as they are, just like how I don't try to prove other buddhists or christians wrong." But you didn't do that, do you? You didn't leave muslims as they are. You go on every Islamic videos on UA-cam and work hard to prove the videos wrong. You go on each comments, and work hard to prove people wrong. What's your point? Why can't you leave Islam as it is? Why can't you leave muslims as they are? Why can't you leave us alone? Why do you have to work so hard to PROVE ISLAM WRONG? Because, the truth is, the problem lies in YOURSELF. There is that little voice inside your head, whispering to you, "Islam sounds like a true religion..." but you hated that voice! You clenched your fists, gritted your teeth, and denied it! You watched Islamic videos and you were close to be convinced, but you shake your head, clearing the images away. You read Islamic comments, and you were close to be convinced, but you bit your lip and yelled, "No!". The problem lies in yourself. YOU WANT TO PROVE ISLAM WRONG BECAUSE YOU DON'T WANT TO BE CONVINCED THAT ISLAM /IS/ THE TRUE RELIGION. Your ego, man. Your ego..
christians say the same thing, y'all should have a meeting and get your stories straight
@@davespond9176 Trouble is Christianity cant prove itself right and Islam can! Point blank period
@@kconsidine313 christian apologists say the same thing. Others say you are both wrong. My stance is religions are outdated. That i can prove.
@@davespond9176 Well im impressed your willing to investigate!! Mashallah I hope you investigate sincerely. May you have peace in your decisions!!
@@kconsidine313 Namaskar
You can't have an infinite amount of anything finite.
Infinity is a process not a quantity.
@Aes Oup lol you can’t have an infinite past chain of events. It is something a high school kid can understand but these adult atheists have no clue
@Aes Oupexplain and we'll discuss then
@Aes Oup
Idiotic reply as predicted
@Aes Oup
Bye
Mashallah hidayatallah jazakallah ❤️❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍👍
Their argument for the sniper basically based on the definition of infinity is an arbitrary large number, which is ridiculous because any number, regardless of how big it is, is still finite. They are the one have to prove this.
جزاك الله شيخ همزة ...... الله يبارك في عمرك باخير و السعادة ......
سلامي وتحياتي للشيخ همزة ..... أنا في كردستان- العراق
............ سلاو رێز بۆ ماموستا همزە ... من لە کوردستانم ....
Salamuhalaikum,, hello , how are ?
I love you .... and I wish I can to speak to you .... by online ....... but how I can .....
This live was extremely funny 😅
Man, it really pains me to know that these kind of people really exist. May Allah guide us all.
How exactly would you know if someone had been Guided by Allah?
@@drewdrake9130
Me personally? I don’t.
But what I know is that Allah will show EVERYONE signs, and the message will reach almost everyone. The day someone dies is the only day that, we know, his test has ended and the signs were shown to him as in Chapter 17 verse 15:
“Whoever is guided is only guided for [the benefit of] his soul. And whoever errs only errs against it. And no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another. And never would We punish until We sent a messenger”
And only then, the trial will be waiting for everyone.
@@hebt9mlk
Thank you for your answer.
But, since you have no way to tell whether someone has indeed been Guided by Allah, I have to ask...
When someone tells you they've been Guided by Allah, do you just believe them even though you have no way to tell?
What I'm trying to figure out is how it can be determined that someone has indeed been Guided by Allah, and that they're not just honestly mistaken, or worse yet, just imagining things.
@@drewdrake9130
If someone came and said to me “Allah has guided me to Islam, I’m Muslim now” i would believe him because we believe that Islam is the guiding path, but we can’t be for sure if someone will STILL be on that path.
@@hebt9mlk
Yes, you would believe this person was actually Guided by Allah, even though you admit you have no way to tell if they've actually been Guided by Allah, because you believe Islam is the guiding path.
Did I represent what you said correctly?
If so, I can't really see how this could ever be considered a method to confirm that someone has indeed been Guided by Allah.
Is there a way to confirm that someone has indeed been Guided by Allah?
If so, please tell me what step one would be.
Please understand I am just trying to confirm the claim that someone has been Guided by Allah, and just believing that someone has been Guided by Allah doesn't get us any closer to confirming the claim.
Well that Jack dude was a total waste of time to debate with lol
Infinity is a really large number 🤦♂️
Proof .. my teacher to me 🤣
Anyone want to debate Matt Dillahunty about religion and God. He is an Atheist and he has UA-cam and Facebook. He is accepting anyone in his show.
Send him the link 😎
Jack is just a prank caller
But he is the black belt. 😀
masha ALLAH
This is hilariously comical 😂😂😂
Some guy is on drugs I think 😂
Its the vegan sophist "ASK YOURSELF" LOL HILARIOUS
so where is jack ?
Wow, some guy has difficulty understanding what "Permission" means, someone, lend him a dictionary.
Even if the sniper is immortal he'll never get the permission to shoot.
Ay look! It's me!
Hi
I joined your discord
Iam in waiting list
Found you! Lol
I feel like the infinite chain of permissions smuggles in the premise of time, which the atheist doesn't really have to deal with. Supposedly, the chain of causes for the universe has to be, at some point, timeless. The only example of a timeless domain I can think of is found in pure mathematics. For example, there's an infinite amount of real numbers between 0 and 1. So just because there's an infinite amount of reals from zero to get to 1 doesn't mean that somehow the concept of 1 is thus impossible. Again, within this timeless domain, we can logically prove all sorts of mind boggling things (e.g: some infinities being larger than other infinities).
@10:00 The only thing you can learn from "Some guy" is that how to promote your UA-cam channel by saying nonsense things.
This kid is definitely drunk!
I'm literally pulling my hair right now!😭
Me being a layman i can understand the question but this Jack guy is still in limbo
Love brother Muhammad for the sake of Allah, but he should really let br Imran answer Hamza addressing him directly at 36:05
Seriously this guy trying to get his friend on the phone couldn’t argue with my 6 year old niece even she would say he couldn’t take the shot 😂
but nowdays with movies people expect more . for example if someone fall from a building and survived he wont belive cuz there are alot of movies shows this might happen. we have to edcuate people and than start telling them how to goes
Jack and his cheerleader some guy are immature just like any atheist is. Yes we muslims got a bit excited hearing there nonsense and may be some of us have mocked them silently. But at the end of the day, let us pray for their guidance from Allah. we want good for all to meet in jannat.
It's an atheist named Ask Yourself
@@helsharidy123 sorry?
@@r.rahman12 his cheerleader is a popular Atheist with a UA-cam channel. His name is:
Ask Yourself.
@@helsharidy123 but here both ask yourself and some guy came. Are they same?
Wow, canadians must be really bad at math; "my professor said so" 😂🤣😂🤣
i'm not good in english but i know what is infinity,,he speaks very good english but dont know what is infinity
Jack seems like a robot
Yes it is possible for the sniper to take the shot without permission. Sometimes there is no time to wait and they have to make a decision on their own.
@@furioustacowarrior1489 Not if he decides to take the shot without authority.
@@furioustacowarrior1489 It's actually not since he can always choose to shoot, the shot could also be taken by accident.
@@furioustacowarrior1489 His actions are not necessarily dependent on authority because other possibility's exist. The analogy doesn't even reflect causation in our universe since there are no infinite steps between cause and effect.
Brothers, you should have said: "If there is infinite regress, this means that nobody in the chain has the self-sufficient power to permit. Therefore, nothing in the chain has this power. Hence, this chain does not contain this power. Therefore, the permission to shoot cannot be given as a result of this infinite chain". Then the atheists would be able to say nothing.
تحية للإخوة، محمد حجاب و حمزة و الاخ الاخر لا اعرف إسمه تحية لكم من 🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦 عمران
Putting aside the many philosophical and theological arguments, there remains this, if a god/gods existed, there would only be one religion, because everyone would know about the god or gods, yet instead we see thousands of gods and millions of demigod religions/stories that are different. As Hitchens i think it was that said, all religions cannot be right, they can all be wrong.
And if you read Quran you would have known this answer .GOD send us with One religion But with Choice thats why we will be hold Accountable . If we were act as GOD Programmed us then Judgment would be unfair . These are people who changed the one religion into many .Personal desire , benefits , Power etc made human to change the law of GOD and GOD let it be because it was the test But GOD send His Prophets one after another to bring Human back on track . I am giving you a link of videos which shows how human changed one Monotheistic religion in to Polytheistic etc Start from Adam Pbuh and Slowly goes on SO watch every Prophet
ua-cam.com/video/dB6KZc9Y9ZI/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/ee6qv9oOkyA/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/60Q-nQsJhTM/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/xZoBB8TsPNw/v-deo.html
@@rajababy2009 i have read some it, and i listen to believers like here, the problem with that argument is, other religions say the same thing and believe as much as any other believer does in their religion or with their god/gods..
I know no way of testing ones beliefs against another's. They have to be seen as equal or faith loses meaning.
Logically, if there was a being that could grant prayers and eternal life most if not all people would follow it, why wouldn't you? I would.
The fact that all religions are in a minority against the global population puts believers in no better a position than other believers or non believers. All are in a minority.
If there were a few people who didint follow the one religion, logically it would seem it must be true, some are just missing the point or whatever, when the majority rejects every religion, logically if you look at it from the outside, there must be a problem beyond what the believer accepts yet also rejects at the same time when its their belief versus another.
@@davespond9176 If you sit lazy and dont research then it is your fault ? this is the question of your existence why you are here ?
In Islam we believed that GOD is Just So he will give equal opportunity to every Human being to defend him or herself ? SO research at least you would have reason that you try with Open mind .
In Islam GOD will deal Justly with those who did not receive Islam Message or distort version of Islam message .
the First word of Quran was "Iqra" means read So you must read to find the correct path and also do at least Skeptic prayer that God if you are there and exist Guide me .
www.quran.com
@@rajababy2009 ive been studying beliefs for forty years. if you want to try and insult me rather than a reason why one belief is more than valid than another its one more reason on my list to dismiss beliefs as all equal in their validity. Ghosts, monsters in lakes and forests, palm readers, gods, ufos, all equal in their validity.
@@davespond9176 I did not insult you but encourage you to research if you felt insult then i am sorry . did you read Quran ? from start to end ?
Omg who doesn’t know what infinity means omg omg omg
Sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry ArE yOu GuYs GoNnA lEt Me SpEaK
Some guy AKA *ASK YOURSELF (how embarrassing SMH) you're out of league here, this ain't Vegans that you are preaching too LOL*
I think Jack was trolling, can't be that ignoramus lol
Jack seems like he just wants a good old banter.. the question is ABC.
I had to get medical attention after listening to Jack.
I think Some Guy needs to learn how to behave well and respect others when talking to them.
Black belt......😆
Okay I think what Jack meant with the whole infinite sniper thing. If the sniper needs infinite permission can he take the shot? Jacks answer that he can still take the shot is valid if you assume the sniper has FREE WILL. He can still take the shot in that case. If the sniper doesn't have FREE WILL, then you are right he cannot take the shot.
I’m surprised young guy can even use the phone for his level of intelligence, he has zero logic so trying to have him understand he can’t it’s impossible for him. But Alhoumdulilah your being kind to him and he is being arrogant with his stupidity.
He could never get permission duh
"black belt" jack - you just displayed why atheism is an utterly illogical belief system (at best) . When cornered, all you could do, as Bro Hijab stated, is act in a "fully ignorant" manner.
Hello. I am an atheist. I define atheism as suspending acknowledgement of the existence of gods until sufficient evidence can be presented. My position is that *_I have no good reason to acknowledge the existence of gods._*
And here is the evidence as to why I currently hold to such a position.
1. I personally have never observed a god.
2. I have never encountered a person whom has claimed to have observed a god.
3. I know of no accounts of persons claiming to have observed a god that were willing or able to demonstrate or verify their observation for authenticity, accuracy, or validity.
4. I have never been presented a valid logical argument which also employed sound premises that lead deductively to a conclusion that a god(s) exists.
5. Of the 46 logical syllogisms I have encountered arguing for the existence of a god(s), I have found all to contain multiple fallacious or unsubstantiated premises.
6. I have never observed a phenomenon in which the existence of a god was a necessary antecedent for the known or probable explanation for the causation of that phenomenon.
7. Several proposed (and generally accepted) explanations for observable phenomena that were previously based on the agency of a god(s), have subsequently been replaced with rational, natural explanations, each substantiated with evidence that excluded the agency of a god(s). I have never encountered _vice versa._
8. I have never experienced the presence of a god through intercession of angels, divine revelation, the miraculous act of divinity, or any occurrence of a supernatural event.
9. Every phenomena that I have ever observed has *_emerged_* from necessary and sufficient antecedents over time without exception. In other words, I have never observed a phenomenon (entity, process, object, event, process, substance, system, or being) that was created _ex nihilo_ - that is instantaneously came into existence by the solitary volition of a deity.
10. All claims of a supernatural or divine nature that I have encountered have either been refuted to my satisfaction, or do not present as falsifiable.
ALL of these facts lead me to the only rational conclusion that concurs with the realities I have been presented - and that is the fact that there is *_no good reason_* for me to acknowledge the existence of a god.
I have heard often that atheism is the denial of the Abrahamic god. But denial is the active rejection of a substantiated fact once credible evidence has been presented. Atheism is simply withholding such acknowledgement until sufficient credible evidence is introduced. *_It is natural, rational, and prudent to be skeptical of unsubstatiated claims, especially extraordinary ones._*
I welcome any cordial response. Peace.
Hi Theo.
Can we start by answering the question that was asked in this stream? Is the universe dependent or independent?
@@slsa915 Certainly. Though I am not understanding what you are asking. Can you either rephase or elaborate upon your question?
@@theoskeptomai2535 Was the universe Caused or was it always there?
@@cleverzoro7069 How would I _know?_ I _believe_ the universe to be an eternal realm within which all phenomena occur. And I have never encountered any evidence that suggests our cosmos (if not universe) had a beginning. In fact I have never encountered any evidence that any phenomena has a beginning.
Each and every phenomenon (object, event, process, substance, entity, system, or being) that I have encountered seems to EMERGE from necessary and sufficient antecedents over some finite amount of time no matter how brief or epoch the interval.
Hope that answered your question. I will gladly answer any other question you have a out my position of atheism.
@@theoskeptomai2535 Well it's been scientifically proven that the universe had a beginning and one of the theory's is big bang etc etc. The universe began 13.8 billion years ago so it had to be caused since it has a beginning. Jazakallah.
because the Qur'an is for all mankind as a guide to life in the world, as a source of knowledge and as a guide to be loved by Allah SWT (the only God) & Prophet Muhammad (last prophet) it will not be possible that (God) Allah will mislead / deceiving all humans (his creation so the accusation is all nonsense. That is why Allah SWT maintains the authenticity of the Quran until the Day of Resurrection to be used by all mankind. Alhamdulillah.
Hijab needs to come out of his car
I didn't know jack was in ignorant mood until hijab started to explain..... I also dont think the problem is jack.. I think the problem is the Shaytan that keep whispering in jack ear he
know jack weak point and he keep dragging him to a dead end
I wish if jack can see what hijab was trying to help him to see
Hamza please if you saw jack again give him another chance.. And If u have enough time try to explain to the man in a different and easier way
Dont give up on him I have a good feeling about jack, thank you all 4 the effort.
Sorry Jack go home