Just imagine, you’re alone, floating on the surface of the deep blue Panthalassa, and below your depth is the foreboding shadow of an Ichthyotitan, eating another smaller but still enormous ichthyotitan. I swear, it’s like Subnautica in real life.
My main takeaway from this video is that a blue-whale sized macropredator is utterly terrifying. Nature’s final boss. Great work as always. Ichthyosaurs are basically what we thought mosasaurs were as kids.
I had seen about the new surangular by PdLS. This is a new bone but still no teeth so far, because of this I'm still suspicious about toothed macropredation in ichthyosaurs above 20 m. Also, even with robust teeth, the snout reconstructions I see of S. popularis look really slender, I have a hard time seeing one ingesting a 20 t prey as suggested by Vividen. I'd also like to see more evidence of Himalayasaurus having such a robust skull, it seems to me the skull was hardly preserved. Isn't Thalattoarchon rather the most robustly skulled ichthyosaur ? I'm still very suspicious of this Temnodontosaurus bite force estimate from a non reviewed article, I have a hard time to believe it would bite harder than a large, more robust skulled Basilosaurus (20kN) or Kronosaurus with a 1.8 m skull (27 kN). Overall, for now I don’t see more firepower from those guys, even at 25 m×, than in what we see in the Livyatan skull and what we project from the Otodus megalodon dentitions.
@@ahmedshaharyarejaz9886 Nature's final boss remains probably the large Otodus megalodon, for now those giant shastasaurids appear more like 25 m reptilian small toothed or toothless dolphins. There is excessive hype regarding their alleged trophic level, shastasaurids are mostly cephalopods eaters based on stomach contents but everyone seems to want to make them real life counterparts to the BBC Liopleurodon.
It’s quite unfortunate that the smaller, mesopredatory ichthyosaurs ended up being the iconic image and the view both the public and until recently academia applied to all ichthyosaurs. That would be like if Halisaurus or Phosphorosaurus was the default public image of mosasaurs.
While I'm always hyped to hear about potentially titanic fossils, I think there is something special about the largest animal ever existing happening to exist alongside us. That we can still go out and study it and that we can protect it from going extinct. That not everything huge and badass was in the past - we're living alongside monsters too.
Well, we can never find all the fossils, nor does every species fossilise, so the blue whale being the largest animal confirmed is closely linked to it being the one we live alongside today.
I love that idea too. It's sad how unlikely it is though, and I'm sure you know but what are the chances that the largest animal to ever exist just happens to exist in this past four to ten million years when we have hundreds of millions of years of animals that existed before it that we'll never know about because of how rare the fossilization process is. I hate that we probably only have around one percent of all animals that ever existed in the rocks for us to find.
I’m so glad my and Diocles’ work on Hector’s ichthyosaur could be featured in this. We don’t know how big it was, how old it was, or much of anything about it. But I will say, if the centra measurements are correct, it would easily be an animal over 100 metric tons. Beyond that, though, the size is very uncertain, and NO reconstruction should be taken as fact. I really hope that more remains can be found or the large centrum can be rediscovered for more information on what could be one of the largest animals that existed and would close the case on a mystery in paleontology that’s 150 years old.
Your guys' work really is incredible, and part of that effort is establishing what we do and don't know. Hopefully more information comes to light soon!
@@GoodrichthysEskdalensis It didn't get lost with the Matoaka. The Matoaka vanished in 1869. The giant centrum was discovered in 1877. Ergo, it is literally impossible that the centrum was on the Matoaka.
Amazing work! Awesome to see new material and work come to light! Also I agree about the reconstructions. I like what George E.P. Box said, “all models are wrong, but some are useful.”
@@bkjeong4302 ichthyosaurs kept becoming apex predators after mass extinctions, it's really funny. It happened in the triassic, jurassic, and cretaceous.
Imagine being transported back in time to the Triassic in the middle of the ocean and seeing a huge ichthyosaur coming right at you...only for a far larger one to surface, grab it in its jaws, and drag it to the depths. There's always a bigger fish.
Ichthyosaurs are quite underrated in my opinion. These specimens are proof that there were other predators besides the more famous ones, like mosasaurs, that could rival them in size and power.
yes about time! Im just sick of people saying that megalodon was the biggest sea predator of the past. I just love representatives from the dinosaurs age
@@TheVividen I'm can tell you one my question:If biggest sauropods can outsized biggest whales,they should or would be likely Titanosaurs rather than other sauropods
@@ЕрсултанСапаргали-ц3ьIf they did, (which based on the reliable fossils we have in our possession does not currently seem likely), the titanosaurs would be the ones to do it
Only less than 1% of the the life that has existed in the past has been fossilised and from that percent it’s likely that we might never discover more than 5% of these fossils. Makes me wonder what else might have existed in the past which we might never know about.
yeah, the vast majority of life that once existed is indeed lost to us, and the fossil record represents just a tiny fragment of Earth’s biological history
@AncientWildTV and probably if we include protozoans,number of species ever existed possible approach to several trillions or higher like tens of trillions species ever existed,because bacteria and microbes are more diverse than any other life forms on the Earth
Shastasairid icthyosaurs are really awe inspiring to think about, I honestly wish we still had some remnants of the icthyosaurs around so we could have a point of reference for these goliaths. Or just to have in general, marine reptiles come back!
Honestly, I wouldn't mind a Subnautica playthrough from you. (That random pic of Hemsworth threw me off lmao) Welcome back, Viv. BBC should definitely consider one of these giants in the new WWD.
What's with the surangulars? Why don't we find other bones from ichthyosaur jaws or skulls? (Although IIRC Lomax speculated that Aust 'bone shafts' might be premaxilla).
The fact that we only now start to understand what the ecology of late triassic shastasaurs is, is wild as we know of them since over 100 years. I do have to say this regarding the smaller taxa Guizhouichthyosaurus and Besanosaurus: 1) the bromalite Guizhou-specimen reaks of an accidental ingestion to me, given the early state of digestion and the subsequent death. I think we need a few more specimens to say for certain if reptiles were on the diet. 2) I have seen the Besanosaurus holotype myself and can confirm that the internal content is fetal, so yes a pregnancy rather than diet. Lastly, the Rutland specimen is definitely not the best preserved specimen of T. trigonodon to date. Stuttgart has two complete specimens, both including a better preserved cranium and Hauff museum has a complete specimen as well. The Banz cranium remains the largest specimen for which a size estimate is plausible, but I have seen humeri and vertebrae which do tentatively suggest individuals that approximate that sperm whale size...
I had seen about the new surangular by PdLS. This is a new bone but still no teeth so far, because of this I'm still suspicious about toothed macropredation in ichthyosaurs above 20 m. Also, even with robust teeth, the snout reconstructions I see of S. popularis look really slender, I have a hard time seeing one ingesting a 20 t prey as suggested by Vividen. I'd also like to see more evidence of Himalayasaurus having such a robust skull, it seems to me the skull was hardly preserved. Isn't Thalattoarchon rather the most robustly skulled ichthyosaur ? I'm still very suspicious of this Temnodontosaurus bite force estimate from a non reviewed article, I have a hard time to believe it would bite harder than a large, more robust skulled Basilosaurus (20kN) or Kronosaurus with a 1.8 m skull (27 kN). Overall, for now I don’t see more firepower from those guys, even at 25 m×, than in what we see in the Livyatan skull and what we project from the Otodus megalodon dentitions.
oh so now you tell me that my 80 foot Liopleurodon wasn’t the largest marine creature in prehistory 😢 Edit: Yeah I know that WWD was exaggerating but it still hurts
What the Hell were these monsters eating? Were they strictly cannibals? I haven't heard of any animals that shared their environment that would sustain them at such massive sizes.
Also, small correction: the giant centrum wasn’t sent aboard the Theresa Cosulich in 1876 as it was discovered in 1877 and described in 1878. It may have been sent later, though. Only time will tell.
Aren’t predators often 1/10th the size of the animals they eat? So what filter feeding animals were they eating? Were they like 500 ton filter feeding squids that haven’t been preserved?
i wonder if those colossal sized ichthyosaurs hunted even preys bigger then they are... possibly some giant filter feeding ichthyosaurs. knowing that relatives like hupesuchus are now considered to be filter feeders it might be possible that some shastasaurids would've evolved the same adaptations but scaled to huge sizes.
Good question! While it's possible, Motani concluded that based on the eye structure of large ichthyosaurs it was unlikely that any of them were deep sea carnivores.
@@tamaltarudey8912hmmm, then that might be possible! We don't have any indication that ichthyosaurs possessed jaw structures in any way comparable to baleen whales, however
Y'know Kinda interesting that the mosasaurs got big quick too Wonder what would've happened if maybe the asteroid missed Another video idea: real life Kaiju. Just the biggest of critters past or present.
@@sunmoonstar9125 This is such a sigma wolf alpha male moment. I have never seen a better gigachad moment. I returned from Skibidi land and I sang: "Skibidi dop dop yes yes" for hours and hours, it was for sure fire, but now, when I saw this video, I sticked out my gyat for the rizzler and I said: "SHEESH", but today, my dad owns Roblox. 1 day later after this happening, I finally got the Grimace Shake, they all say to not drink it but I did, I became such a rizzler and got all the girls with my sigma wolf alpha male rizz. This day was so Banban moment in Ohio, I couldn't resist to play Minecraft and I ate pizza from Oklahoma with Nathanel B. I griddied so hard while it that the among us imposter started flexing his 1 2 buckle my shoe, 3 4 buckle some more, 5 6 nike kicks! This day was so sigma that Speed Mcqueen walked in and started doing the griddy with me, he started singing: "Swag in Ohio, down in Ohio" for hours until the skibidi toilet haunted us, but then Flamingo playing Roblox has saved us, the giant cameraman started gridding and we won, Flamingo is so sigma wolf alpha male. He will do everything to punch a girl to be sigma, Lankybox is so sigma too, they love Skibdi Toilet and Grimace Shake, that they drink every day. This day was so Fanum Tax that I died while screaming: "GYATT!". Now, I'm in Heaven and I'm singing so hard: "Skibidi toilet, skibidi skibidi toilet" that God said: "No way, fatherless." and he sent me to Hell, where the Devil was gridding so hard with Flamingo playing Roblox, but then, a sigma wolf alpha male entered in Hell just like a Giga sigma Chad. We all bowed to him and then the sigma wolf alpha male started talking: "This was for sure a sigma Giga wolf alpha Chad male ban ban day.", but then, someone entered in and said: "Uhmm, actually, it's a sigma wolf alpha male Gigachad skibidi ban ban from Ohio day.", but then, the Devil tortured the nerd so hard that he gone to the sigma L+Ratio Oklahoma moment. After some days, the Devil sent me back to Earth. I was so sad and I wanted to kill the Devil so I got into a mission to kill him. I have travelled to the Oklahoma's sigma Pizza Tower, I defeated all the sigma Gigachads, it was for sure hard, but I didn't give up. After a day, I have finally come to Ohio.Then someone walked in with a sigma smile and said: "Swag in Ohio, Down in Ohio, oh wait, I'm not a dumb, I'm a sigma." and then I said: "No, I'm a sigma." then he said: "Fight me kid." and then I said: "Bet" then he whispered to himself: "He didn't put a dot at the end of "Bet(.)"! I should... No... I must correct him before he does!" then he says: "Bet.*" then I said: "" then he got defeated and he exploded with a: "Pop!". After a while, I've saw something. It's Patrick Bateman! The most sigma wolf alpha Giga male Chad from Ohio, he is drinking Grimace Shake and coming to me while gridding and singing: "Blue coems, white coems, original coems! If your girl is angry, she wants your black pencil! If your boy is angry, he wants your black pencil!". It is too much sigma skibidi Ban Ban from Ohio that I can't resist. I have to defeat him, but I couldn't, so he killed me and now I'm in Hell again and I got my revenge on the Devil. I'm currently crying so hard right now, I will live for eternity with the sigma Flamingo playing Roblox. Thank you, young man!
The ocean is still "glitched", my man forgetting about whales and especially the mighty largest animal of all time which can weight over 270 tonnes, the blue whale
You can't use the largest individuals out of a sample size of tens to hundreds of thousands of individuals to compare to prehistoric animals with a sample size of maybe 3. The average blue whale is 110 tons. If you picked 3 blue whales at random, there is a very low probability that any would exceed maybe 150 tons. Any animal over 100 tons on average is a possible competitor, and if an individual of 200+ tons is known from a very small sample size, it becomes more likely than not that the animal exceeded the blue whale. If you had a sample size of every saltwater crocodile ever recorded and three black rhinos, there is a good chance that the absolute largest crocodiles (~2 tons) would outweigh the any of the black rhinos. However, the rhino is bigger; its average of 800-1400 kilograms exceeds the croc's 400-770 kilograms for males. If you had equal sample sizes, the rhino would also win in maximum size at ~2800 kilograms. Also, 270 tons is a really high end estimate, and no measurements of blue whales over 30.5 meters are considered reliable. I've seen papers putting ~33m as an absolute limit, which could have been anywhere from 252-273 tons, which I wouldn't really consider as it definitively weighing over 270 tons. Really, the notion that the blue whale was for sure the largest animal of all time is more popular wisdom than science. Up until recently (and possibly even now) there have been no animals discovered that were larger, but that doesn't mean that they could not have existed. There is no known biological reason why an animal could not have grown larger than a blue whale. Even if the Aust Colossus does turn out to be smaller than current estimates suggest, and all of the other contenders currently known go the same way, than the blue whale still might not be the largest animal of all time. We only know a tiny fraction of all extinct species; statistically, it is highly unlikely that we know of the largest ever.
@@TheWigglergler well an predator bigger than a blue whale would be *slow* most likely it's the largest animal ever because prehistoric animals are really overatted
@@লবণহানটারman "Superior" is subjective, I suppose, but there is a good chance that it was quite a bit smarter and faster than you think. A lot of prehistoric animals (notably Tyrannosaurus) were most likely much smarter than people tend to assume. We simply don't know because we haven't found a braincase and can't observe it in the wild.
you'd think people who study these things could actually use more common sense with scaling these creatuers up but half the time you guys are circle jerking some estimate that is super off in 5 years time
The people who are studying these ichthyosaurs are using the most common sense available. According to the information scientists have, these animals did get this big. I don't know what you would propose the alternative to be. And sure, there might be a lot of sensationalism around these creatures, and sure, their size estimates are a bit finnicky especially for the largest like ichthyotitan, but vividen is presenting the most up to date info. I don't know what kind of circle jerking you're even trying to describe here.
@@rh_4m your average paleo community circle jerk, the same trends you bash in the early 2000s like giganotosaurus's sizing are the exact ones that occur now even with more 'accurate' methods. Its yap fest of going back to square one. Essentially meaningless and the other half of paleo fans are just closet scalies with bad deviantart accounts. Your community
I don’t think you used that metaphor correctly here 😂 they spend a lot more time arguing with each other than they do egging each other on. The Triassic was a time of massive biological experimentation, and while they probably wouldn’t make it in today’s oceans, back then they were just what was around, and for a long time they had nothing to challenge them but each other. It is also important to remember that for a good while, every time we found a sauropod that was the biggest ever we found another one, sometimes even before the paper for the “newest biggest” had even been fully published. Some of those were wrong, but some of them were correct lol. But sometimes when your job is this, you have to make guestimations and just hope that someday someone finds another specimen to prove you wrong or right.
@@sharkladyindisguise mate you ain’t seen r/paleo or any dinosaur subreddit. Went there once and it was full autism kumbaya that everything had feathers because some guy wrote paper on it
Tf do you expect them to do lol? Go find an actual specimen? Most remains of these animals are fragmented, so we have to guess a little bit on its size. But as we learn more about these creatures, our estimates get more accurate. Also, you act as if science changing is bad. Thats like the whole point lol. As our understanding of something gets better, we change it to be more accurate.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code VIVDEN for an extra 4 months free at surfshark.deals/vividen
The Great Dying: *happens*
Icthyosauriformes: Oh no... anyway *becomes kaiju*
They filled the niche of super predator that was left empty by the mass extinction. That why they were grew super big fast and were so successful
Just imagine, you’re alone, floating on the surface of the deep blue Panthalassa, and below your depth is the foreboding shadow of an Ichthyotitan, eating another smaller but still enormous ichthyotitan. I swear, it’s like Subnautica in real life.
People keep overusing the Mosasaurs when the giant Icthyosaurs are just as or even more terrifying than them.
😨 unironic fear 😰
Like?
Oh GOD, STAAAHP
Hi
My main takeaway from this video is that a blue-whale sized macropredator is utterly terrifying. Nature’s final boss. Great work as always.
Ichthyosaurs are basically what we thought mosasaurs were as kids.
The big ones acted like sperm whales do the smaller ones are the scary ones they were pure hunters are acted like orcas do
I had seen about the new surangular by PdLS. This is a new bone but still no teeth so far, because of this I'm still suspicious about toothed macropredation in ichthyosaurs above 20 m.
Also, even with robust teeth, the snout reconstructions I see of S. popularis look really slender, I have a hard time seeing one ingesting a 20 t prey as suggested by Vividen.
I'd also like to see more evidence of Himalayasaurus having such a robust skull, it seems to me the skull was hardly preserved.
Isn't Thalattoarchon rather the most robustly skulled ichthyosaur ?
I'm still very suspicious of this Temnodontosaurus bite force estimate from a non reviewed article, I have a hard time to believe it would bite harder than a large, more robust skulled Basilosaurus (20kN) or Kronosaurus with a 1.8 m skull (27 kN).
Overall, for now I don’t see more firepower from those guys, even at 25 m×, than in what we see in the Livyatan skull and what we project from the Otodus megalodon dentitions.
or pliosaurs
I hear you man, but We are nature's final boss, dude. We would have eventually hunted this thing for sport.
@@ahmedshaharyarejaz9886 Nature's final boss remains probably the large Otodus megalodon, for now those giant shastasaurids appear more like 25 m reptilian small toothed or toothless dolphins. There is excessive hype regarding their alleged trophic level, shastasaurids are mostly cephalopods eaters based on stomach contents but everyone seems to want to make them real life counterparts to the BBC Liopleurodon.
It’s quite unfortunate that the smaller, mesopredatory ichthyosaurs ended up being the iconic image and the view both the public and until recently academia applied to all ichthyosaurs. That would be like if Halisaurus or Phosphorosaurus was the default public image of mosasaurs.
While I'm always hyped to hear about potentially titanic fossils, I think there is something special about the largest animal ever existing happening to exist alongside us. That we can still go out and study it and that we can protect it from going extinct. That not everything huge and badass was in the past - we're living alongside monsters too.
Well, we can never find all the fossils, nor does every species fossilise, so the blue whale being the largest animal confirmed is closely linked to it being the one we live alongside today.
And luckily this monster isn't aggressive at all too !
It's entirely possible that these macropredatory ichthyosaurs outgrew it. We just haven't figured that out for certain yet.
I love that idea too. It's sad how unlikely it is though, and I'm sure you know but what are the chances that the largest animal to ever exist just happens to exist in this past four to ten million years when we have hundreds of millions of years of animals that existed before it that we'll never know about because of how rare the fossilization process is. I hate that we probably only have around one percent of all animals that ever existed in the rocks for us to find.
What do you think are the biggest challenges facing modern giants like the blue whale?
I’m so glad my and Diocles’ work on Hector’s ichthyosaur could be featured in this.
We don’t know how big it was, how old it was, or much of anything about it. But I will say, if the centra measurements are correct, it would easily be an animal over 100 metric tons. Beyond that, though, the size is very uncertain, and NO reconstruction should be taken as fact.
I really hope that more remains can be found or the large centrum can be rediscovered for more information on what could be one of the largest animals that existed and would close the case on a mystery in paleontology that’s 150 years old.
Your guys' work really is incredible, and part of that effort is establishing what we do and don't know. Hopefully more information comes to light soon!
Hector's icthyosaur probably dwarfed the blue whale but guess we'll never know till we get an update :/
@@GoodrichthysEskdalensis It didn't get lost with the Matoaka. The Matoaka vanished in 1869. The giant centrum was discovered in 1877. Ergo, it is literally impossible that the centrum was on the Matoaka.
@@frost7463Oh yeah I didn't get to that part. I was just coming back here to delete the comment.
Amazing work! Awesome to see new material and work come to light! Also I agree about the reconstructions. I like what George E.P. Box said, “all models are wrong, but some are useful.”
It’s amazing that at one time ichthyosaurs were the top predators of the Triassic and Jurassic
They also held niches as apex predators in the early Cretaceous, they just weren’t as big as their nightmarish predecessors.
@@frost7463
Chad Longirostria eating birds and sea turtles
@@bkjeong4302 ichthyosaurs kept becoming apex predators after mass extinctions, it's really funny. It happened in the triassic, jurassic, and cretaceous.
@@frost7463et surtout les mosaur et les pliosaur avait déjà pris les places des super prédateurs des mer aux crétacé supérieure et inférieure
Well, for parts of the Jurassic at least. Then the pliosaurian Plesiosaurs hit the block
SOURCES
Darius Nau calc on Ichthyotitan and Aust: www.deviantart.com/theropod1/art/Giant-ichthyosaurs-of-the-Upper-Triassic-961320408
Sperm whale suction feeding: www.nature.com/articles/srep28562#:~:text=Strong%20and%20sudden%20changes%20in,during%20post%2Dacquisition%20prey%20handling.
Shonisaurus teeth: www.cell.com/current-biology/pdfExtended/S0960-9822(22)01761-4
Ichthyosaur integument: www.idunn.no/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1502-3931.2001.tb00058.x
Ichthyosaur speed: www.researchgate.net/publication/247855454_Swimming_speed_estimation_of_extinct_marine_reptiles_Energetic_approach_revisited
Ichthyosaur blubber: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012825222000496
Welsh Giant: www.app.pan.pl/archive/published/app60/app000622014.pdf
Temnodontosaurus bite force: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/3gBPbbRKVJQxRMwYkkPqPGM/big-jaws-big-bite#:~:text=With%205000%20cm%C2%B3%20of%20muscle,a%20great%20white%20shark%20too.
Cymbospondylus youngorum: faculty.umb.edu/liam.revell/pdfs/Sander_etal_2021.Science.pdf
Shonisaurus group behavior: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960982222017614
Shonisaurus coprolites: gsa.confex.com/gsa/2016AM/meetingapp.cgi/Paper/284943
Darius Nau Shastasaurus GDI: twitter.com/darius_nau/status/1781728382729801922
Swiss Tyrant description: www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02724634.2021.2046017
University of Bonn Ichthyotitan: www.uni-bonn.de/en/news/072-2024
Huene’s Giant www.cambridge.org/core/journals/geological-magazine/article/abs/palaontologie-und-phylogenie-der-nideren-tetrapoden-by-fried-rich-von-huene-pp-xii-716-with-690-text-figures-gustav-fischer-jena-1956-price-dm-88/40D12838DD3FA7557BDFE48CF8887DCD
Ichthyotitan Histology: peerj.com/articles/17060/
Hector’s Ichthyosaur: paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/periodicals/TPRSNZ1873-6.2.4.1.52/1
End-Triassic Extinction onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9780470015902.a0001655.pub3
Upper Triassic paleobiota sjpp.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s13358-023-00269-3/figures/6
Ichthyosaur hydrodynamics royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2018.2786
Jiang et al. 2020 (Guizhouichthyosaurus macropredation) www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7520894/
You're wrong. My source is that I made it the fuck up
Imagine being transported back in time to the Triassic in the middle of the ocean and seeing a huge ichthyosaur coming right at you...only for a far larger one to surface, grab it in its jaws, and drag it to the depths. There's always a bigger fish.
Ichthyosaurs are quite underrated in my opinion. These specimens are proof that there were other predators besides the more famous ones, like mosasaurs, that could rival them in size and power.
Rival? More like surpassing them at times.
yes about time! Im just sick of people saying that megalodon was the biggest sea predator of the past. I just love representatives from the dinosaurs age
The lost fossil of Hector's Ichthyosaur reminds me of the legend of the Amphicoelius vertebrae!
It's not for something that it's been referred to as Sea Amphi!
All the Mesozoic sea monsters are awesome. So yes, more please :)
Love this video, and I loved especially knowing more about Himalayasaurus! It's my favourite Ichthyosaur
Thank you! I think it's my favorite too
@@TheVividen I'm can tell you one my question:If biggest sauropods can outsized biggest whales,they should or would be likely Titanosaurs rather than other sauropods
@@ЕрсултанСапаргали-ц3ьoui je pense que soit c’est brachiosauridea ou un titanosauridé
@@laseriedeladilophosaure9246 you can write this on English?
@@ЕрсултанСапаргали-ц3ьIf they did, (which based on the reliable fossils we have in our possession does not currently seem likely), the titanosaurs would be the ones to do it
This was really fun to help you work on. Even if my contribution was just providing a couple seconds of footage.
Thank you for helping out! It really helped ground the Aust section, I think
@@TheVividen whether it did or didn’t, I’m happy to help!
Only less than 1% of the the life that has existed in the past has been fossilised and from that percent it’s likely that we might never discover more than 5% of these fossils.
Makes me wonder what else might have existed in the past which we might never know about.
Probably that biggest extinct taxa including Titanosaurs are far bigger than biggest living organisms includes blue whales
yeah, the vast majority of life that once existed is indeed lost to us, and the fossil record represents just a tiny fragment of Earth’s biological history
@AncientWildTV and probably if we include protozoans,number of species ever existed possible approach to several trillions or higher like tens of trillions species ever existed,because bacteria and microbes are more diverse than any other life forms on the Earth
Shastasairid icthyosaurs are really awe inspiring to think about, I honestly wish we still had some remnants of the icthyosaurs around so we could have a point of reference for these goliaths. Or just to have in general, marine reptiles come back!
Very nicely done! There’s a reason I’ve watched all your videos and anxiously await the next. Entertaining as well as informative.
As I always say, Ichthyosauruses are mosasaurs running a dolphin software with a blue whale main frame.
It’s been quiet so I might be able to watch this today.
"It's time to dig up a kaiju!" Well said my friend!
How unbelievably lucky is it that the animals that occupy these nieches now seem to actively like us.
Honestly, I wouldn't mind a Subnautica playthrough from you. (That random pic of Hemsworth threw me off lmao)
Welcome back, Viv. BBC should definitely consider one of these giants in the new WWD.
Recording this clip actually had me thinking about it haha
These things have got to be about the scariest critters nature ever concocted…that we know of…real life monsters
What's with the surangulars? Why don't we find other bones from ichthyosaur jaws or skulls? (Although IIRC Lomax speculated that Aust 'bone shafts' might be premaxilla).
18:10 possibly the hardest line ive heard from a paleotuber in a god damn while
The fact that we only now start to understand what the ecology of late triassic shastasaurs is, is wild as we know of them since over 100 years. I do have to say this regarding the smaller taxa Guizhouichthyosaurus and Besanosaurus: 1) the bromalite Guizhou-specimen reaks of an accidental ingestion to me, given the early state of digestion and the subsequent death. I think we need a few more specimens to say for certain if reptiles were on the diet. 2) I have seen the Besanosaurus holotype myself and can confirm that the internal content is fetal, so yes a pregnancy rather than diet. Lastly, the Rutland specimen is definitely not the best preserved specimen of T. trigonodon to date. Stuttgart has two complete specimens, both including a better preserved cranium and Hauff museum has a complete specimen as well. The Banz cranium remains the largest specimen for which a size estimate is plausible, but I have seen humeri and vertebrae which do tentatively suggest individuals that approximate that sperm whale size...
This video was great..Also when something related to Yellowstone hyperpredator will be released??
I loved your surfshark ad LOL. I am terrified of those ichthyosaurs stealing my identity
Great job u make good works for science development
Dragons? More like Kaiju!
Imagine a large whale sized snake with the speed of dolphins
I had seen about the new surangular by PdLS. This is a new bone but still no teeth so far, because of this I'm still suspicious about toothed macropredation in ichthyosaurs above 20 m.
Also, even with robust teeth, the snout reconstructions I see of S. popularis look really slender, I have a hard time seeing one ingesting a 20 t prey as suggested by Vividen.
I'd also like to see more evidence of Himalayasaurus having such a robust skull, it seems to me the skull was hardly preserved.
Isn't Thalattoarchon rather the most robustly skulled ichthyosaur ?
I'm still very suspicious of this Temnodontosaurus bite force estimate from a non reviewed article, I have a hard time to believe it would bite harder than a large, more robust skulled Basilosaurus (20kN) or Kronosaurus with a 1.8 m skull (27 kN).
Overall, for now I don’t see more firepower from those guys, even at 25 m×, than in what we see in the Livyatan skull and what we project from the Otodus megalodon dentitions.
Love your videos, pls do could megalodon survive the Triassic seas.
oh so now you tell me that my 80 foot Liopleurodon wasn’t the largest marine creature in prehistory 😢
Edit:
Yeah I know that WWD was exaggerating but it still hurts
Would love to see a video on mosasaurs sometime :) fantastic stuff! Thanks for all the hard work.
What the Hell were these monsters eating? Were they strictly cannibals? I haven't heard of any animals that shared their environment that would sustain them at such massive sizes.
Considering Sperm Whales hunt Colossal Squid perhaps the Ichthysaurs were doing the same.
Also, small correction: the giant centrum wasn’t sent aboard the Theresa Cosulich in 1876 as it was discovered in 1877 and described in 1878. It may have been sent later, though. Only time will tell.
Good point!
imagine seeing ichthyotitan on ur local oceanarium💀
These things are even more insane than I imagined!
real life large sized lizard dolphin
4:25 im sorry mate, but i dont think a surfing shark will cut it against a shastasaurus
The reaper leviathan actually scared the hell out of me 😭🙏
Why you do deez to mee
Everyone must pay the Reaper Leviathan tax
Aren’t predators often 1/10th the size of the animals they eat? So what filter feeding animals were they eating? Were they like 500 ton filter feeding squids that haven’t been preserved?
3:56 Bro I'm a dinosaur enjoyer not a PhD holder in aquatic dinosaur gynecology
The single most goated animal group of all time-THE SEA BLIMPS
This is Peak. Not related, but do you still keep the Google Doc files containing the estimate sizes of many T. rex specimens?
Great maps!!!
i wonder if those colossal sized ichthyosaurs hunted even preys bigger then they are... possibly some giant filter feeding ichthyosaurs. knowing that relatives like hupesuchus are now considered to be filter feeders it might be possible that some shastasaurids would've evolved the same adaptations but scaled to huge sizes.
Is it possible that Shastasaurus was a benthic feeder like the Gray Whale?
Good question! While it's possible, Motani concluded that based on the eye structure of large ichthyosaurs it was unlikely that any of them were deep sea carnivores.
Actually the Gray Whale is a coastal water Benthic feeder
@@tamaltarudey8912hmmm, then that might be possible! We don't have any indication that ichthyosaurs possessed jaw structures in any way comparable to baleen whales, however
Lez goo more of the vividen
Y'know
Kinda interesting that the mosasaurs got big quick too
Wonder what would've happened if maybe the asteroid missed
Another video idea: real life Kaiju. Just the biggest of critters past or present.
what if icthyotitan was just a really old icthyosaurus
Thank you for saying Nevada correctly
Surely there are some who survived
Bubbles(PPG) would sure wanna cuddle with those SEA beasts.
Bigthyosaur
Can you discuss the giant carcharodontosauridae from Thailand? PRC 61
I haven't heard about it--which study was it published in?
@@TheVividen I don't know, because information about Theropods is very difficult to find
It's 5 tons and 11 meters
@@TheVividenBuffetaut and suteethorn 2012
@@Tyrant678I'll have to look into it!
Bigger 🌊, bigger sea life.
I can’t access ur discord for some reason
Is the one they found in England
blue whale still cooler
being 200 million years ahead of something is epic 🤑
blue whale sucks
blue whale sucks bland whale is so bland
@@sunmoonstar9125 This is such a sigma wolf alpha male moment. I have never seen a better gigachad moment. I returned from Skibidi land and I sang: "Skibidi dop dop yes yes" for hours and hours, it was for sure fire, but now, when I saw this video, I sticked out my gyat for the rizzler and I said: "SHEESH", but today, my dad owns Roblox. 1 day later after this happening, I finally got the Grimace Shake, they all say to not drink it but I did, I became such a rizzler and got all the girls with my sigma wolf alpha male rizz. This day was so Banban moment in Ohio, I couldn't resist to play Minecraft and I ate pizza from Oklahoma with Nathanel B. I griddied so hard while it that the among us imposter started flexing his 1 2 buckle my shoe, 3 4 buckle some more, 5 6 nike kicks! This day was so sigma that Speed Mcqueen walked in and started doing the griddy with me, he started singing: "Swag in Ohio, down in Ohio" for hours until the skibidi toilet haunted us, but then Flamingo playing Roblox has saved us, the giant cameraman started gridding and we won, Flamingo is so sigma wolf alpha male. He will do everything to punch a girl to be sigma, Lankybox is so sigma too, they love Skibdi Toilet and Grimace Shake, that they drink every day. This day was so Fanum Tax that I died while screaming: "GYATT!". Now, I'm in Heaven and I'm singing so hard: "Skibidi toilet, skibidi skibidi toilet" that God said: "No way, fatherless." and he sent me to Hell, where the Devil was gridding so hard with Flamingo playing Roblox, but then, a sigma wolf alpha male entered in Hell just like a Giga sigma Chad. We all bowed to him and then the sigma wolf alpha male started talking: "This was for sure a sigma Giga wolf alpha Chad male ban ban day.", but then, someone entered in and said: "Uhmm, actually, it's a sigma wolf alpha male Gigachad skibidi ban ban from Ohio day.", but then, the Devil tortured the nerd so hard that he gone to the sigma L+Ratio Oklahoma moment. After some days, the Devil sent me back to Earth. I was so sad and I wanted to kill the Devil so I got into a mission to kill him. I have travelled to the Oklahoma's sigma Pizza Tower, I defeated all the sigma Gigachads, it was for sure hard, but I didn't give up. After a day, I have finally come to Ohio.Then someone walked in with a sigma smile and said: "Swag in Ohio, Down in Ohio, oh wait, I'm not a dumb, I'm a sigma." and then I said: "No, I'm a sigma." then he said: "Fight me kid." and then I said: "Bet" then he whispered to himself: "He didn't put a dot at the end of "Bet(.)"! I should... No... I must correct him before he does!" then he says: "Bet.*" then I said: "" then he got defeated and he exploded with a: "Pop!". After a while, I've saw something. It's Patrick Bateman! The most sigma wolf alpha Giga male Chad from Ohio, he is drinking Grimace Shake and coming to me while gridding and singing: "Blue coems, white coems, original coems! If your girl is angry, she wants your black pencil! If your boy is angry, he wants your black pencil!". It is too much sigma skibidi Ban Ban from Ohio that I can't resist. I have to defeat him, but I couldn't, so he killed me and now I'm in Hell again and I got my revenge on the Devil. I'm currently crying so hard right now, I will live for eternity with the sigma Flamingo playing Roblox. Thank you, young man!
nice
permian icthyosaur 🗣
ichyotitan fans tap in
WELSH GIANT‼‼‼‼‼‼ YDDDWWWWWW🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴💪
I could imagine a drunk blue whale drowning his sorrows because he lost the title of the biggest animal to have ever lived on earth
To a big lizard 😂😂
The ocean is still "glitched", my man forgetting about whales and especially the mighty largest animal of all time which can weight over 270 tonnes, the blue whale
it's also almost infinitely smarter than prehistoric reptiles and sharks 💀
You can't use the largest individuals out of a sample size of tens to hundreds of thousands of individuals to compare to prehistoric animals with a sample size of maybe 3. The average blue whale is 110 tons. If you picked 3 blue whales at random, there is a very low probability that any would exceed maybe 150 tons. Any animal over 100 tons on average is a possible competitor, and if an individual of 200+ tons is known from a very small sample size, it becomes more likely than not that the animal exceeded the blue whale. If you had a sample size of every saltwater crocodile ever recorded and three black rhinos, there is a good chance that the absolute largest crocodiles (~2 tons) would outweigh the any of the black rhinos. However, the rhino is bigger; its average of 800-1400 kilograms exceeds the croc's 400-770 kilograms for males. If you had equal sample sizes, the rhino would also win in maximum size at ~2800 kilograms. Also, 270 tons is a really high end estimate, and no measurements of blue whales over 30.5 meters are considered reliable. I've seen papers putting ~33m as an absolute limit, which could have been anywhere from 252-273 tons, which I wouldn't really consider as it definitively weighing over 270 tons.
Really, the notion that the blue whale was for sure the largest animal of all time is more popular wisdom than science. Up until recently (and possibly even now) there have been no animals discovered that were larger, but that doesn't mean that they could not have existed. There is no known biological reason why an animal could not have grown larger than a blue whale. Even if the Aust Colossus does turn out to be smaller than current estimates suggest, and all of the other contenders currently known go the same way, than the blue whale still might not be the largest animal of all time. We only know a tiny fraction of all extinct species; statistically, it is highly unlikely that we know of the largest ever.
@@TheWigglergler well an predator bigger than a blue whale would be *slow*
most likely it's the largest animal ever because prehistoric animals are really overatted
@@TheWigglergler anyways some modern cetaceans may not be bigger than an aust HOWEVER they're still far more impressive and superior 🤑
@@লবণহানটারman "Superior" is subjective, I suppose, but there is a good chance that it was quite a bit smarter and faster than you think. A lot of prehistoric animals (notably Tyrannosaurus) were most likely much smarter than people tend to assume. We simply don't know because we haven't found a braincase and can't observe it in the wild.
Wouldn’t be shocked if we find a bigger one with spikes and atomic firepower
who the frick gave caseoh swimming lessons?
you'd think people who study these things could actually use more common sense with scaling these creatuers up but half the time you guys are circle jerking some estimate that is super off in 5 years time
The people who are studying these ichthyosaurs are using the most common sense available. According to the information scientists have, these animals did get this big. I don't know what you would propose the alternative to be.
And sure, there might be a lot of sensationalism around these creatures, and sure, their size estimates are a bit finnicky especially for the largest like ichthyotitan, but vividen is presenting the most up to date info. I don't know what kind of circle jerking you're even trying to describe here.
@@rh_4m your average paleo community circle jerk, the same trends you bash in the early 2000s like giganotosaurus's sizing are the exact ones that occur now even with more 'accurate' methods.
Its yap fest of going back to square one. Essentially meaningless and the other half of paleo fans are just closet scalies with bad deviantart accounts.
Your community
I don’t think you used that metaphor correctly here 😂 they spend a lot more time arguing with each other than they do egging each other on. The Triassic was a time of massive biological experimentation, and while they probably wouldn’t make it in today’s oceans, back then they were just what was around, and for a long time they had nothing to challenge them but each other.
It is also important to remember that for a good while, every time we found a sauropod that was the biggest ever we found another one, sometimes even before the paper for the “newest biggest” had even been fully published. Some of those were wrong, but some of them were correct lol. But sometimes when your job is this, you have to make guestimations and just hope that someday someone finds another specimen to prove you wrong or right.
@@sharkladyindisguise mate you ain’t seen r/paleo or any dinosaur subreddit. Went there once and it was full autism kumbaya that everything had feathers because some guy wrote paper on it
Tf do you expect them to do lol? Go find an actual specimen? Most remains of these animals are fragmented, so we have to guess a little bit on its size. But as we learn more about these creatures, our estimates get more accurate. Also, you act as if science changing is bad. Thats like the whole point lol. As our understanding of something gets better, we change it to be more accurate.
Are Ur saying that the leedsichys is not big😢