Seriously Westman. Make your damn refills for god’s sake. I want to invest in this product but won’t until I see refills available. Thanks for sharing.
I have the WA for my face as setting powder on matte foundations. It goes strong since 2 years. I just repurchased the PMG powder in the light shade - it is by far the best as under eye setting powder as it is marketed. It is a pitty that brands are not following their own intentions... with rhe refill. I will try the Prada setting powder next - which already is available aa refill.
Yes! We were promised refills! I got the color crème which oxidizes on the skin. And I wish I got the pink or translucent. I thought I would buy the refill to replace creme. I find this powder doesn’t do what I need it to do though. It doesn’t blur, and it doesn’t hold back shine. So I don’t know if I should even bother with replacements.
Oh no! I'm so sorry the creme color oxidizes on you - that's like one of my worst fears with any makeup product. I'm so lucky that I had figured out my undertone a bit better when I got this powder, otherwise I probably would have gotten creme as well. Although this is a nice powder, it's kind of a great powder among other great powders that are half the price, you know? And the fact that it seems to go off in a year AND they don't have refills yet is just insulting. I'll have a first impressions of the new pink PMG powder up once I get it. If you are looking for blurring + shine control, I think it's a great option. It's marketed as an undereye powder, but I use it all over the face. You might also want to check out Hot Mess Tom's channel - they have done lots of reviews on blurring powders (including both the westman atelier and PMG powder). Might be a good way of seeing what other options are out there! I say this because I'm very partial to the PMG powder and have been literally begging them to come out with a pink powder for a long time - but I know the formula isn't for everyone! edit: omg, it's hautemess tom not hot mess tom 😅
@@blathering. I love the PMG setting powder, I have it in every colour except the pink one. I saw Morgan review it recently, it’s not very pink. It is identical to the translucent shade on the skin. Which works for my under eyes, but may not work for u (u mentioned it was too light?).
@@nkurdy288 Yes, I have been watching every review I can on the new PMG pink powder since it came out, and I did hold out on buying it for that very reason - it looked almost white in the pan in most people's early reviews. I was so disappointed 😭. However, after seeing it in lots of different lighting, I think it's going to be more like the PMG yellow powder: muted and neutral. Which in the lighting that most youtubers use, will make it look white. My issue with the PMG light powder is it's just too stark white for my saturated skin tone, so it looks powdery on my skin. I think the pink one might have enough color (and not so much white base) so that is blends properly into my skin tone. What makes this decision difficult is out of all of the reviews I have seen, I haven't seen anyone who can't use the white one review whether they are able to use the pink one. I might very well be talking myself into a powder that's too light for me 😅, but the PMG powder is my favorite formula, and I've been waiting for it in pink for years. So I have to try it. But it may very well be too light for me - we shall see!
I have a lot of pink in my skin too - what foundation do you like? Hard to find for me! Also: check out Sisley (same price range as Westman or close). . . They have lovely pressed and loose pink powders! I like those better than WA - I find WA too dry 😮
@@cattiedoggie8 Oooh, I've heard such good things about Sisley's powders. I would def consider picking one up once I've finished my WA powder. As for foundation, the only foundation I've ever really been able to tolerate on my skin is the bareminerals powder foundation (medium is my best match, although I think it's a little dark). I've tried a variety of foundations, bb creams, tinted sunscreens etc, and the only other thing that was a good color match was Australian Gold tinted sunscreen, which looked really nice, but still had that mask-like feel as it dried down, which is my usual issue with liquid foundation-like products. Everything else I've tried looks too light or too orange. However, my struggle comes from having lots of pink in my skin plus having a very strong olive tone (lots of green in my skin), which means I need products with a high saturation of pink BUT also basically no orange/peach pigment. If you just have lots of pink but no green in your skin tone, you'll have a wider range of products to choose from. If you have the same color match issues as me but want a liquid foundation, I'd recommend Haus labs. I was impressed at the color match I got from the concealer, although in the end I still preferred the formula from my Bobbi brown color corrector (probably since it's a cream formula and haus labs is liquid).
I'm so happy this works for you! It is a very nice powder that doesn't cake or dry/dehydrate my skin (like so many other powders do), but for the price point I think I was hoping for more.
Seriously Westman. Make your damn refills for god’s sake. I want to invest in this product but won’t until I see refills available. Thanks for sharing.
I have the WA for my face as setting powder on matte foundations. It goes strong since 2 years. I just repurchased the PMG powder in the light shade - it is by far the best as under eye setting powder as it is marketed. It is a pitty that brands are not following their own intentions... with rhe refill. I will try the Prada setting powder next - which already is available aa refill.
Thank you this is a good review!
Thank you so much for watching 🥰
Yes! We were promised refills! I got the color crème which oxidizes on the skin. And I wish I got the pink or translucent. I thought I would buy the refill to replace creme. I find this powder doesn’t do what I need it to do though. It doesn’t blur, and it doesn’t hold back shine. So I don’t know if I should even bother with replacements.
Oh no! I'm so sorry the creme color oxidizes on you - that's like one of my worst fears with any makeup product. I'm so lucky that I had figured out my undertone a bit better when I got this powder, otherwise I probably would have gotten creme as well.
Although this is a nice powder, it's kind of a great powder among other great powders that are half the price, you know? And the fact that it seems to go off in a year AND they don't have refills yet is just insulting.
I'll have a first impressions of the new pink PMG powder up once I get it. If you are looking for blurring + shine control, I think it's a great option. It's marketed as an undereye powder, but I use it all over the face.
You might also want to check out Hot Mess Tom's channel - they have done lots of reviews on blurring powders (including both the westman atelier and PMG powder). Might be a good way of seeing what other options are out there! I say this because I'm very partial to the PMG powder and have been literally begging them to come out with a pink powder for a long time - but I know the formula isn't for everyone!
edit: omg, it's hautemess tom not hot mess tom
😅
@@blathering. I love the PMG setting powder, I have it in every colour except the pink one. I saw Morgan review it recently, it’s not very pink. It is identical to the translucent shade on the skin. Which works for my under eyes, but may not work for u (u mentioned it was too light?).
@@nkurdy288 Yes, I have been watching every review I can on the new PMG pink powder since it came out, and I did hold out on buying it for that very reason - it looked almost white in the pan in most people's early reviews. I was so disappointed 😭. However, after seeing it in lots of different lighting, I think it's going to be more like the PMG yellow powder: muted and neutral. Which in the lighting that most youtubers use, will make it look white.
My issue with the PMG light powder is it's just too stark white for my saturated skin tone, so it looks powdery on my skin. I think the pink one might have enough color (and not so much white base) so that is blends properly into my skin tone. What makes this decision difficult is out of all of the reviews I have seen, I haven't seen anyone who can't use the white one review whether they are able to use the pink one.
I might very well be talking myself into a powder that's too light for me 😅, but the PMG powder is my favorite formula, and I've been waiting for it in pink for years. So I have to try it. But it may very well be too light for me - we shall see!
I have a lot of pink in my skin too - what foundation do you like? Hard to find for me! Also: check out Sisley (same price range as Westman or close). . . They have lovely pressed and loose pink powders! I like those better than WA - I find WA too dry 😮
@@cattiedoggie8 Oooh, I've heard such good things about Sisley's powders. I would def consider picking one up once I've finished my WA powder.
As for foundation, the only foundation I've ever really been able to tolerate on my skin is the bareminerals powder foundation (medium is my best match, although I think it's a little dark). I've tried a variety of foundations, bb creams, tinted sunscreens etc, and the only other thing that was a good color match was Australian Gold tinted sunscreen, which looked really nice, but still had that mask-like feel as it dried down, which is my usual issue with liquid foundation-like products. Everything else I've tried looks too light or too orange.
However, my struggle comes from having lots of pink in my skin plus having a very strong olive tone (lots of green in my skin), which means I need products with a high saturation of pink BUT also basically no orange/peach pigment. If you just have lots of pink but no green in your skin tone, you'll have a wider range of products to choose from.
If you have the same color match issues as me but want a liquid foundation, I'd recommend Haus labs. I was impressed at the color match I got from the concealer, although in the end I still preferred the formula from my Bobbi brown color corrector (probably since it's a cream formula and haus labs is liquid).
I purchased WA powder. Is there a refill?
I have not yet seen a refill for this powder.
I was disappointed at first but it brightens nicely, easy to use, blurring.. not all that but something
I'm so happy this works for you! It is a very nice powder that doesn't cake or dry/dehydrate my skin (like so many other powders do), but for the price point I think I was hoping for more.
@@blathering. absolutely.