Egypt’s ICJ decision a ‘blow to ties’ with Israel: Analyst
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 тра 2024
- Egypt's government has announced it will support the case South Africa filed at the International Court of Justice, accusing Israel of genocide.
Dalia Fahmy, associate professor of political science at Long Island University, says Egypt’s decision to join South Africa’s genocide case against Israel marks an “unprecedented moment in the modern-day history” between the two countries.
“Egypt has been the most important mediator in the region, the first Arab nation to recognise and formalise ties with Israel in 1979. And here is the symbolic moment, where the Egyptian government puts its foot down. The first is a humanitarian one, where the Ministry of Foreign Affairs says the [Israeli] intervention currently comes in increasing severity. And that Israel’s actions in Gaza leading to the death of almost 40,000 individuals violates international humanitarian law and the fourth Geneva Convention,” she told Al Jazeera.
“This moment has deeper implications at the political level, because Israel has not proved itself in the eyes of Egypt as a good faith negotiator. It didn’t sign on to the ceasefire agreement even though it had said it would. Also for months, Egyptian officials have stated that Israeli invasion of Rafah would risk peace ties between the two countries. It’s more than the ICJ ruling, it’s also a blow to the ties between the two countries, because Israel … has actually seized the border and they have taken tactical provisional authority over the border.”
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Egypt #SouthAfrica #Palestine #Gaza #SolidarityWithGaza #SolidarityWithPalestine #GazaAttack #Israel #IsraelHamasWar #GazaWar #IsraelWar #IsraelPalestineWar #IsraelGazaWar #ICJ #UN #ICJHearing #IsraeliOccupation #IsraelPalestineConflict #IsraelGenocideRuling
Opposing genocide shouldn’t be controversial.
Egyptians are puppets of US though. So, this is surprising.
When the world becomes run by organized crime, the truth is a threat to national security and world dominance.
I do not buy Egypt's lip service and symbolic gesture. All Arab countries are too scared to take action against Israeli atrocity and madness.
SISI IS EYGPTS NEW PHARAOH OF COWARDS AND SAUDI ARE RULERS OF ALL THE REST OF THE LAZY COWARD TRAITOR LEADERS
Go to school and one day you will be smart enough to realize that when a population triples there is no genocide.
South Africa is leading the way!
Indeed & has thoroughly shamed these Arab & Muslim hypocrites into action
Thank you, South Africa 🇿🇦❤️🩹🇵🇸
Please go move there
@@kappa82 & what are you bitter about?
@@Contra-mc1yh Shamed also white countries that love to talk about peace and humanity.
"If Israelis don't want to be accused of being like the Nazis, they simply need to stop behaving like Nazis." - Norman Finkelstein
Fighting for their safety are good decision
Well said
The fact that one idiot says something about it is what you rely on, good luck to you
Exactly 💯
They are Nazis just hiding behind a veil of pseudo democracy. They are a dirty racist apartheid colinising people trying to defend their Insidious evil with lies and deception.
Shame to the western regimes for not upholding the international order!
The world agrees - Pstinians have brought it upon themselves. no ceasefire, no evacuation!
@@Michaelxx2inare you the worlds spokesperson? I think that it is quite clear that Israeli support dwindles daily.
Israel's 50+ years of committing mass war crimes brought this about. Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention states: “The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.” Israel (Occupying power) has sent 700,000 Illegal settlers (transfer parts of its own civilian population) into East Jerusalem and the West Bank ( into the territory it occupies). These are war crimes.
@@Michaelxx2insuck on it.
SHAME ON HAMAS , WHO IS RESPONSIBLE
Blinken's statement does not mean anything. They lied every day since the beginning. More countries need to join
The Palestinians need their own state. The US veto prevents a peaceful solution.
👍
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
All Muslim countries must join with Egypt.
@@vaclavkubicek2970😂
Thousands upon thousands of innocent women & children wiped out. Everyone will agree it's unacceptable, besides those who benefit from it.
@@Rabbi_yaakovvyou are a disgrace for humanity.
@@Rabbi_yaakovv diversion tactics & hiding behind religion won't work son. You are biased so you will support your own no matter what. Two wrongs never make a right and no genocide is acceptable, whether big or small.
@@Rabbi_yaakovv okay pa-jeet, time to go to the nearby train track to $hit on 😂
Why must you masquerade as some zew when we all know you're a Paj-eet making comments here while taking a dump on the train track?? 😂😂
@@Rabbi_yaakovv Racist atheist Zionists think Gods on their side. Ok.
@@Rabbi_yaakovvEvil is evil no matter how much you blame it on others. The world didn't know but not they know that the state of Izrahell is made up of human animals
Egypt coming to their senses at their very own convenience. Hypocritical but positive.
After 7 months?
Hypocritical, and they will still not allow palestenian brothers inside, none of them are allowing, all evil.
@@Wahid313. unfortunately
@@user-343-8fx sadly true
@@user-343-8fx
Hasn't Israel stolen enough Palestinian land already?
Enough is Enough!!!!
Free Palestine.....
Way to go Egypt. Isnotreal violated the Camp David Accord. It’s about time to show solidarity with your oppressed neighbor.
FALSEtine 🇵🇸🚽💩🤮
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Egypt locked down her border and fortified her defenses to keep the Palestinians trapped in the most heavily populated warzone on the planet.
If Israel is committing genocide then Egypt made it happen.
Every Israeli accusation is a confession.
- Richard Medhurst
Like their ambassador literally destroying the UN charter.
@luisdavidllense2293 Israel is above any law and no one can say anything
Like the human shield 🛡️ argument
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Iran and Saudi arabia need to do the same. Türkiye and Egypt doesn't get along but they are going to ICJ.
Irán 🇮🇷 Líbano 🇱🇧 Syria 🇸🇾 yemen 🇾🇪 irak ❤ are fighting.what do Egypt?
😂😂😂😂
Iran can't do anything at the moment, but surely they must be on standby in case anything lands in Iran or any important Iranian affiliate gets topped off
It's all lip service for the domestic outrage of their citizens. Egypt is a fail state close to bankruptcy who needs to be bailed out financially, and who controls the World Bank, their neighbor. Turkey is in financial straits too and is business partner with Is-ra-3l and EU. Jordan is dependent on the joos money, the king and family lives in luxury in Europe. Arabia couldn't care less, they just don't want the oil business to be interrupted. It is a very dark situation. Pray for peace, like thousands are going to do tonight 13 of May, to ask the white shining Lady of Fatima, Lady of Peace, to interceed for peace, doesn't hurt and may help.
@@Maya_s1999 iran is the only which attack any impire , us.israeli.
So proud of South Africa for what we did initiating this case. 🇿🇦✨Thank you to all the countries that have supported the fight for Palestine as well.❤️🇵🇸
I'm Indonesian, and I sincerely thanks South African for taking strong stance and recognizing Apartheid characteristic on Israel.
I truly hope for Bright and Peaceful future for South Africa.
@@lonesomefencesitter3186 ✨
Thanks south Africa from Australia
@@sebspataro3331 🌹
Yes you can be proud!
What a shame for my country Germany!
Scholz has to go to jail life sentence
Finally! Where is Saudi, UAE and other Arab countries in support for Palestine and stopping of this genocide?!
Gulf states dont want to ally with losers
Do people that want to commit genocide, feed and warn the people they supposedly want to eliminate to get out of the city before they enter a city, so they don’t get caught in the fighting.
Did Hitler warn the Jews before he was coming ?
Yep. They need to flex their muscles even if it may cost them so temporary slowing of the great wealth they've been gleaning.
Those Arab countries don’t support the Islamic state. That’s why they do nothing.
Well done Egypt. Every country in the world should join in.
THOSE WHO PROFITED SHOULD FACE THE ICJ
That would be the US weapons manufacturers! Haha. Do you really think money ever does not buy justice? Especially in the US.
And they are many!
Especially my country Germany
Protect the civilians !
Where were you last 80 years to say that in support of Israeli population which been targeted by indiscriminate attacks?
Do you really mean what you write or is it substitute to: "stop destroying Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad" groups?
Do you speak in order to help Armenians who faced actual genocide. Which resulted in ~20% of Turkish population to have Armenian great grandmother, but Turkish great grandfather? (Who btw raped her as they were killing all those boys and men.) They took even little girls which suffered that fate later.
How much did you speak for Kurds? 30 millions of them and their land is not their own, no country to their name.
agree
World needs to wake up and take immediate action against the horrors of this ongoing genocide.
The World has woken up. Globally, ordinary people like you and me are doing everything we're able to, to have our voices heard in protest. The political and 1% who are benefitting from this horrific genocide continue enabling this diabolical evil occupying entity called israel. It is not anger that we feel, it is an incandescent rage and helplessness with an underlying sorrow for our Palestinian family.
USA as always is the leading power for genocide!
May Justice be served!!! FREE PALESTINE!!!!!
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
in sha Allah, Palestine will be liberated
This is completely eyewash, Egypt allow Israel to take over the Rafah crossing which is the last life line for Gazans. Shame on Egypt.
Egypt was not going to stand alone and fight the IDF. Not as long as the US backs them. They are going through legal and political means and trying to avoid starting WWIII.
@@coleengoodell7523exactly. Egyptians are not suicidal.
Egypt decision is right
iT'S NOT EGYPT'S FAULT, ISRAEL IS RESPONSIBLE !!!
@@mathiuduanggonmei4428 It's sisi's decision to remain in power, against the will of general Egyptian.
It is genocide!
What genocide?
It is a war , war that Palestinians started.
Israel terrorists state started the war in self-defense
agree
@@user-ye7jp4ho1s "Genocide? what genocide?" The "surprised Pikachu" defence, how refreshing. What's next, Steve Urkel? "Did I do that?"
I would hardly class this as a War, Israel has an Army and an air force dropping 2,000lb bombs. What does Palestine have? 30,000- 40,000 Fighters? Even the Palestinean Police are dying in the line of duty.
Good news. Thank you Egypt.
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Egypt's Action comes a little too late.
To late for what?
@@aquarian-talk Read the lead story again
Well, well, well; finally some courage and sanity.
Egypt must show that it is ready to use some force, especially at crossings.
Too late eh
Slowly but Shorely...
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
It is mind boggling why the US is still delivering any weapon systems to Israel given what has happened last 7 months, and all the violations the world has seen since.....
Unfortunately our United States is a corrupt terrorist country!
They were always like that. Where there's war, there they are. They profit from death and destruction.
Well, it took them long enough...I am proud of South Afrika!
South Africans are embarrassed by their corrupt government doing this. Notice their students didn't protest which speaks volumes.
About time someone getting out of his total numbness
Israel tries only to help with population reduction, eliminating the “lower races first”. Yes, that was so according to Winston Churchill who gave Israel this land in the first place, saying in his own words, the lower laces must leave to make place for a higher race! The same guy who fought the Nazis, yes! Look it up. England and US always working together when it come to white supremacy.
Too late Egypt you have disappointed
Egypt under international law is OBLIGATED TO GIVR SHELTER TO palestinian refugees. Why they built wall number 2 🤔🤔🤔🤔
At least they did something. How about the other arab countries!??
@@Nona-yg4pw like Yemen!?
Greatest bluff of Egypt just to keep in limelight. Plestine needs material support not backstabbing.
Israel:Ashamed of nothing,Offended by everything!!
We will never forget EGYPT, SAUDI JORDAN, UAE, PAKISTAN, BAHRAIN QATAR.....
🇿🇦🇵🇸 thank you to all supporting this cause🇵🇸🇿🇦
Shame on Egypt and Jordan !
What they going to do it not like you are supporting them. What you saying you going raise taxes in you nation so the can go to war. Get real.
I congratulate Jordan and Egypt. Nobody wants to have anything to do with a genocidal state.
@@vaclavkubicek2970 genocidal LOL! supporting islamic extremism.
@@vaclavkubicek2970 They'll join ICJ and play games on behalf of Israel like both did on that day Iran attacked Israel.
@@masud7876 exactly!
Thank you so much Mr. Baca and the guest for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤
Viva Egypt 🇪🇬 you’re now on the right side of the history thank you for standing with Palestine 🇵🇸
Mf know they will be overthrown by their civilians its a political move not moral move
So are we to just forget & forgive?? What abouy 35,000 killed Palestinians ? Egypt has a role in every death & starvation of the Palestinians
Foolish decision
@@keppros57and Hamas ? Do they have a roll in what happens to their Palestinian brothers and sisters in Gaza ?
Shut up egypt is a coward country
Blinken is a disgrace
The gullible UN is a disgrace.
Imagine killing thousands of children and questioning it.
Must Egypt stay strong. Stop genocide !
Egypt has done everything to ensure make this genocide happen. They even sent an army to the border to keep them out.
Courageous decision of Egypt.
This is just for PR. It's a begger state.
Hardly! They must feel the danger to them is far greater.
Egypt should of opened their borders and helped Palestine people they could of saved so many lives they are a big disappointment.
No, Israel must to stop committing genocide and steal land.
Yet Egypt would not accept any Palestinian refugees. Or any of the middle East countries.
Why would Israel stop? Never faced repercussions for their bombing campaigns. Feeble Western parents won't ground them
The Palestinians need their own state. The US veto prevents a peaceful solution.
how about cutting off DIPLOMATIC RELATION????
Exactly
Well done Egypt. Every country in the world should join in.
The entire world should stand against this brutal genocide.
Fantastic interview; good on Egypt for the position it is taking. Also your guest really knew her stuff and did a great job of providing perspective.
No ICC should send your troops there
STOP GENOCIDE
About time Egypt did something! Israel is currently breaching the agreement on the Philadelphia corridor not a perp out of US or Egypt.
The Palestinians need their own state. The US veto prevents a peaceful solution.
Oh Egypt, habibi... we see right through you - you did nothing being their neighbour - shameless... just shameless.
Why did Egypt wait this long to go to ICJ?
Egypt only pretends to care about Palestine. They even reinforced their border with an army to these people trapped in the most heavily populated warzone on the planet.
About time Egypt!!
Egypt should immediately send Armoured columns in proximity of Rafah..they should pressure i&rael also all Arab nations have to pressure i&rael .... specially those who borders i&rael....Saudi Jordan both has to pressure i&rael.
they are not suicidal like you.
@@infidel1948 So Iran and Hezbollah and Houthis are suicidal..?? Such a coward..
If u want Palestinians to be free from the river to the sea.
Might want to bet better Islamic fighters.
These aren’t getting the job done. In fact they only lost more land , homes and lives for their Palestinian brothers and sisters in Gaza
All this what you call Arabs are cowards
@@infidel1948 😂😂
Thete are other countries that have actively taken actions at the International Court Of Justice AND the ICC in the Hague, as early as December 2023.
PLEASE GET INFORMED AND INFORM YOU VIEWERS ABOUT THIS. THANK YOU.
🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦We Shall Overcome
Justice Shall Prevail
Much Love, Respect and Strength to the Resistance
From South Africa.
75 years late? I guess better late than never. egypt needs to work harder not to be taken as a traitor to Palestine alongside sa, uae, jordan.
The pariah state must face justice for all crimes against humanity it has committed since its very inception!
Thank you Egypt 🙏🏼✌️🇬🇧
Israel Court of Justice (ICJ), welcomes Egypt.
Que justice sois rendu A ce peuple innocents ! ❤ AMEN ! AU MON DIEU PUNI TOUS CEUX QUI ONT PARTICIPÉ A CE MASSACRES !!!!!! ET FAIT LES SOUFFRIR AUTANT QUE CE PEUPLE A SOUFFERT !!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wow, it took them this long to figure it out!!!! 😕
Dalia ,well said!
Why don't Egypt take action on its own against israil.
because the yoos have weapons from usakistan.....and egypt doesnt have a very strong offensive capability. their military is mostly defensive.
Egypt doesn't care and only used her army to keep Gazans out.
Dear Egypt,
Lower migration fees from $5,000 to $100. That's more meaningful than a piece of paper.
Right now, no one can get out, including foreign aid workers and nothing can get in at all. The IDF took that border and is in complete control of it. No food aid has been allowed to enter since Sunday. Even seriously injured children that were approved to be transferred out of Gaza for medical care, haven't been allowed to.
If Egypt does this Israel wins because all Palestinians in rafah will enter Sinai and there will be no hope for a future Palestinian state
Is this why Egypt wouldn't let the Palestinians in?
Excellent 👍
Took their time, mind they had to build their wall to stop the Palestinians fleeing south....
😢"Rules-based international order". Why not simply say"international law"?
Finally. Lets hope the other arab countries follow suit.
Thanks for update report about Middle East.
Egypt has to support the will of his own people 🙄 .
That's why Egypt hasn't accept any Palestinian refugee.
Do not equate Israel with Nazis. Israel can teach the Nazis a few more things on Genocide.
Egypt is doing the right thing. Continue the pressure. Camp David agreement does not mean a thing to Israel or the US. Just do whatever can end the war.
The Palestinians need their own state. The US veto prevents a peaceful solution.
Why? Israel literally sent people to South Africa to keep the Apartheid going. Sounds like the spade is a spade.
America taught them both. We're supposed to think that society was different back then but here we are supporting the same thing, even residential schools aren't a distant memory.
Support humanity ❤
Give Palestinians their state.
The Palestinians need their own state. The US veto prevents a peaceful solution.
I don’t think they will give them a state, the Palestinians are divided, which make them an easy prey.
shame on ARAB COUNTRIES. WELLDONE AFRICA WITH SOUTH AFRICA AT THE FOREFRONT AND NOW EGYPT
Egypt is playing politic why they put a wall between
I heard walls work and they weren't about politics.
Too late...too less
Thank God, finally!
its not going to make any difference
@@peterjones4286 Well the trade route being built as well as the red sea project by Saudi have world wide investors.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 Free Humanity
Egypt's eye wash.😢😭😭
So basically they did nothing..
God bless Egypt
Damage control by the Egyptian President... We saw and are still watching what you are doing during genocide.
Keeping the Palestinians trapped for one.
The pain and action will go on day and night as it makes news every other week. The seeds are sewn.
As and when Israel began its Rafah operation , Egypt should have broken all ties with Israel as it had been declaring from first day.
better late than never.
Just want to share another true story about Palestinian fate in Jerussalem through 50+ years. Just won Pulitzer prize for general nonfiction entitled “A Day in the Life of Abed Salama: Anatomy of a Jerusalem Tragedy" by Nathan Thrall
South Africa needs to concern itself with the horrific level of violence and rapes in that country including the "more than" 22,000 annual murders.
This is GREAT news!
Well done Egypt.
They also sent an army to her border to keep the Palestinians trapped in Gaza and they still do.
I'm sorry but that girl has huge beautiful eyes.
A great friend tells you when you're wrong - not hide behind inconvenience.
Or cowardice.
About time, they did something meaningful towards helping Palestinians.
It means nothing at all... Israel is determined to finish their mission... Remember all Arab Nations that surround Israel hate them for their economic power of military strength and Western values... They will prevail
@@HybridAliennumber2-ph3vp🙄
Yes..well done Egypt
The entire world asked them to stop after that case and they didnt..This will be rule of law
Maybe Israel will come to her senses. I hold no hope though; only force has ever stopped a genocide, force or completion.
Sad but how true
thank you South Africa thank you Egypt - England you shame us - please do the right thing 🤲🏽🌹
About time 😢
Late but good!!
About time ...free palestine 🇵🇸
WHERE ARE THE OTHER COUNTRIES/ NATIONS in their unilateral support?
Long Live Palestine 🇵🇸
This happened a long time before Hamas existed:
During the Nakba in 1948, approximately half of Palestine's predominantly Arab population, or around 750,000 people, were expelled from their homes or made to flee, at first by Zionist paramilitaries through various violent means, and after the establishment of the State of Israel, by the Israel Defense Forces. This occurred in the wake of dozens of massacres targeting Palestinian Arabs and the depopulation of 500 Arab-majority towns and villages, with many of these being either completely destroyed or repopulated by Jews and given new Hebrew names. By the end of the war, 78% of the total land area of the former Mandatory Palestine was controlled by Israel and at least 15,000 Palestinian Arabs had been killed.
This is where it started. Followed by many more massacres by the Israeli Army. So every time Palestine has fighted back, it was fighting for freedm and its own land which was stolen by israel. And now Israel is doing what it had always been doing just on a larger scale killing more than 15000 Children and in total more than 35000 people. Israel is a disgrace for humanity and must be stopped immediatly.
U mean 10/7 didn’t free the Palestinians.
Why what happened ?
@@davidmhale521 Oct 7th is Putin's birthday 🥳🥳🥳
@@EdwardPhilips9700 that didn’t answer my question.
@@davidmhale521 So you admit that Isr@el is carrying out a genocide?
Palestinians don't have their own land, they have been squatting on territories claimed by Jordan and Egypt. BTW, the casualty figures on women and children released by the terrorist organization Hamas has been proven statistically impossible, In other words, those are made up numbers.
Thank You Dr. Dalia Fahmy.
What we say in America, "Egypt, day late and dollar short."
Eggyypt - should take military actions immediately. Don't be a begger state for couple of billions. Your tourism industry is in danger and it is irreversible.
Egypt want nothing to do with a terrorist state
@@joemoore7447exactly.
Egypt's tourist industry is not in danger. Tourists including Israelis continue coming into Sinai resorts as well as other places. It would be in danger if thousands of Palestinians, maybe with Hamas militants would come to settle in the Sinai region
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c Your days are numbered. So it does not matter.
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c Lets see how many months Issrahell last.
How about the ICJ object to HAMAS using woman and children as human shields?
Hamas is not an independent state
@@adedejiadebowale9205 Who said the terrorists were an independent state.
Palestine elected them fool!
@@joemoore7447 Hamas and Palestine is not signatory to icj Israel is
@adedejiadebowale9205 Of course they aren't so why is the ICJ defending them?
You espouse total hogwash while trying to get others to take you seriously 😂