Everything WRONG With Pokémon Scarlet/Violet
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
- Pokémon reminds us yet again of how stagnant the mainline series of games is with another mediocre entry. So let's have a big ole moan about the things it got wrong
⌛TIMECODES⌛
0:00 Intro
0:55 1. The Game Runs Like Ass
2:21 2. Horrifically Bad Game Balance
5:10 3. The AI is Dumb!
7:29 4. Team Star Bases Are Dumb Too
8:24 5. Tera Raids Are a Pain in The Ass
10:03 6. Dex Completion is So Monotonous
11:46 7. The Tacked On Legendaries
13:31 8. No Voice Acting
14:53 9. Wild Pokemon Are Annoying
15:47 10. EV Training is Still a Bore
18:41 11. The Game is Slow!!!
19:58 12. Gym Challenges Are a Right After Thought
21:30 13. Manual Box Management
22:16 14. Lack of Customization Options
24:42 15. The Cities Are So Dull
26:39 16. No Battle Tower Equivalent
27:49 17. The Overworld is Bland
29:59 Outro / End Screen
_________________________________________________________
And here's where you can follow me!
Facebook: / rjsuspect
Twitter: / rjsuspect
Patreon (for Reviews): / theunusualsuspect
Patreon (for Mashups): / unusualsuspectmashups
Discord: discordapp.com/channels/36456...
Unusual Suspect SubReddit: / theunusualsuspect
#pokemon #pokemonscarletandviolet #pokemonscarlet #pokemonviolet #review #gamereview #pokemonreview #pokemonscarletandvioletreview #everythingwrongwith - Ігри
Hey guys! Good to be back! So this is a slightly different format this time around; definitely more critical, but shooting on a green screen allows some fun edits to be thrown in here and there. Feedback's always super appreciated :)
Welcome back man!
Mate a suspect upload is a suspect upload, I watch religiously no matter what. If you don’t mind me asking, what’s the current movie review being worked on (if there is one)?
This was a good new take I love it
Welp, not buying that crap
YES
It's really nostalgic seeing you do a full video, because I remember discovering your channel through the Spider-Man trilogy and Harry Potter reviews
I love how quick this feels, I know it’s 30 mins but it doesn’t feel like that! Love the fast paced style of your editing.
Thank you so much :)
At this point, no matter what you do, be it short skits, top t0 reviews, or movie reviews, you will bring the best quality there is. Good to see you again
Thanks for the support! Good to be back! :)
Also, Sword and Shield had the best EV Training. You had NPCs in Hammerlock who could reset your Pokémon’s EVs for you. Then you could go to Pokéjobs for Training Seminars. Then have the game train them for you by having your Pokémon attend the Seminars for specific timeframes. Sure it took a bit, but that meant you could focus on other things while your Pokémon were being trained! It was such a good quality of life change!
There's also a few things I've noticed about Scarlet & Violet.
The options menu no longer has the battle style feature so you can no longer swap between switch or set styles.
Important trainer battles i.e. gym leaders, elite four etc no longer carry healing items.
This one may be down to the games performance, the switch itself or both but the load times can feel horrendous.
There may be more but these are the ones I could think of at the time of writing this.
28:27 Suspect, what are you talking about?! You found the first ever Water type Houndoom, I'd say that ought to make the cave VERY special!
Haha, I actually only saw this when I began editing. I shoulda mentioned it in hindsight.
Great review as always, I would love to see you do more reviews like this with either TV shows or movies again. I really do miss them
Regarding movies, I'm actually working on a new type of movie review right now. Where instead of doing a review of one movie, I choose a theme and do several mini reviews of films around that theme. Hoping you guys will like it.
My problem with auto battling is that it doesn't give EV's. So if your Pokemon levels up after an auto battle, well it sucks to suck. Like sure, you still get EV's earned in previous battles prior to the level up but that's not the point.
The last Pokemon game I played was HeartGold and I intentionally made the game more difficult by roleplaying as a flying-type training, using a roster of only flying-types and flying adjacent (like Scizor whom evolved from a flying type). I mean since the game seems to revolve around trainers focused on one theme in their roster, the game is sort of begging the player to pick a theme and stick to it.
I agree with some of the critiques you mentioned, however two of my personal biggest issues with these games is how hunting for Shiny Pokemon is somehow both very easy, and yet very difficult at the same time, and how this generation has some of the laziest evolutions I've ever seen in a long time.
With the former, I've encounter several Shiny Pokemon without really doing anything. I've caught a Male Combee, Rockruff, Primeape, Slowbro and that Dung Beetle Pokemon with using the sandwich mechanic. However, for reasons that utterly baffle me, none of the Shinies make that sound effect to let players know that a Shiny is nearby. I honestly wouldn't be surprised that I passed by many Shiny Pokemon without me knowing because the Shiny Sound is missing. Plus, there are plenty of Pokemon that either are really tiny, or have a Shiny Form that's barely different compared to the regular form. The Paldean Tauros, those mice that are somehow a family and yet are treated as one Pokemon and of course some older Pokemon that have terrible Shines.
As for the laziest evolutions complaint, while not all of the Pokemon don't have this problem, I couldn't help but noticed that a lot of the evolution seen in Scarlet and Violet, well, they barely change. The worst examples are the Pawmo line and that family of mice Pokemon. And then there are some Pokemon who I swear should've had a second evolution.
Suspect's one of those UA-camrs who never stops improving the format of his videos
I've been a pokemon fan for nearly my entire life. Blue was the first video game I ever played at like 4 years old
It's such a shame to see it in the state it's at. At a point j began saying they could release it in a glitchy state and people would still forgive it and buy it en masse. With these last 2 gens, it hurts that that is 100% true. Game Freak needs to do better; any other IP would have been dragged thru the mud for such shortcomings
The things that bother me the most are the choppy animations of characters or Pokémon at a distance. Honestly at first I thought it was just a hardware issue. Then there’s also the fact that the outfit options might as well not exist because of terrible uniform options.
I did like the fact that as long as you could reach the objective it didn’t matter which one you did first, at least until you skipped over an early area and come through later and just blow through the whole thing.
Glad to see youre doing well and still uploading mate
I know the Bisharp evo is pretty dumb but there's a cool reason explained in Kingambit's dex entry which explains that a Bisharp defeats the leading Bisharp of a group and takes command of that Bisharp's Pawnard's and eventually evolve into Kingambit and leads a army
23:32 To add to that point, in Pokemon Battle Revolution you can even create people of various ages. That's before getting to the kinds of outfits you get for them.
This video was so good! I like the new format. The green screen bits were hilarious! It’s made my week to see another review :D
Thank you!
Yup. I expected this level of ripping into it, and was not disappointed in the level of entertainment you provided while doing it.
I suppose the one good thing about this year is that - if it follows the same structure as generation 8 - this is DLC year. So no new game.
Here's the real problem with EV training: they kinda DID overhaul it back in Generation 6, with Super Training! It was available in both X and Y, and Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire. But then they got rid of Super Training afterward. Why? D:
You aren't wrong about wild pokemon being annoying sometimes, or that completing the pokedex is tedious... But that has always been the case.
Completing the pokedex has never been fun (for me at least) adding new (weird) evolution methods doesn't change that.
And there is a reason Zubat gets so much hate. Because you can't walk 5 steps without running into one in a cave. It wouldn't be pokemon if you didn't find yourself running into pokemon unexpectedly from time to time. That is the quintessential pokemon experience. Most of the time, if you take you time, you can avoid all encounters in a route. You can just flee or sneak around them. Yes there instance where lots of Pokemon appear and you can't avoid running into them, and it can be annoying... But let's not pretend this is a problem unique for this game. Its something that we have had to deal with since gen 1.
I always love coming to this channel. Whether it boils down to the editing, the legit humor that doesn't feel forced in any way, and you pretty much nailed all the valid criticisms and complaints with this disasterpiece. I'll keep recommending your channel to my friends.
Side question - What did you make of the Ed Sheeran song they slapped at the end?
And finally - I view the dull city/gym segments the same way I do with modernized/simplified logos: Soulless.
Honestly, I really enjoyed looking for those staves all on my own. I didn't google their locations and found them all by myself. I usually love to explore like literal 100% of the playable area in any given game and find and collect everything that's not bolted down. That's the whole point of an open world game for me. Besides, they were in pretty obvious places. Pretty easy to find. But most of people just want to Speedrun games through in 2 hours without seeing so much as 5% of its content. Even in blind playthrough they just spam A and not read anything.
horrible argument
@@heavenshound6775 That wasn't an argument? 😅 First was my personality experience and then was my observation of other people playing.
exploring the map for stakes that unlock imprisoned legendries known as the disaster Pokémon is far more interesting than, enter that random cave this legendary likes to hang out in or keep entering random zones and hope you run into a legendary. seafoam islands had some interesting puzzles, but you showed the cave of origins where you literally just keep going down till you walk up to them.
I agree in principle. It would be nice if they offered some clue as to where they all were, and/or a counter to tell you how close you were to finding them all.
Sucks that gym challenges are so boring now. I loved the idea of gyms that incorporated HMs into their puzzles. But Game Freak saw the 'HMs make team-building too restrictive' complaint and took the nuclear option of binning them entirely, so we'll never get those again. Also, certain moves and abilities take up slots unnecessarily, harming the Pokemon that uses them. Hydreigon can clearly fly but Game Freak already gave it two types, so it's stuck with Levitate. And while Salazzle can learn Sweet Scent, a move with a potentially useful effect outside of battle, you either need to sacrifice a move slot to use it or carry around a disposable Pokemon purely for that move.
I would rather see a 'secondary abilities' section that include HMs and more passive abilities (also Pickup, Heavy/Light Metal, Run Away...) so they're not taking up combat ability/move slots. A lot more Pokemon could use HMs if they were built-in rather than needing to be taught. Each gym should require a Pokemon capable of using that HM and teach the player how to use it through the puzzle before letting them use it in the overworld. And some mini challenges could teach players about less important field moves such as Flash or Defog.
Heck, since Pokemon Ranger is a dead series (why is there not a mobile game??), borrow the Capture Styler and have it as a way to temporarily tame a roaming wild Pokemon if you don't have a Pokemon capable of traversing a particular obstacle. You can't use the Pokemon in battle but you get to use one field ability.
Great video. Love seeing something more long form. Even tho I really do enjoy the greenscreen videos
I used to watch you in year 10 man its so cool to see how far your videos have come!
Geeta was hyped so much by the characters in game you would think we were going up against Cynthia. But nope. We got someone who got the reputation of Cynthia, but not the power. Not even close -_- The Elite 4 in MOST games is harder than that fight was.
A few more things to add:
TMs are single use.
Pikachu has its old cry in the modern setting game instead of Ikue Otani (Eevee is okay with its cry kinda).
No Champion Cup and just have to face the Elite 4 to get to Champion.
Honestly prefer that they stick with the old cry instead of the anime voice in the games. It never made sense that Pikachu (and later Eevee) was the only Pokémon to say its name with other Pokémon just making noises (even Pichu and Raichu)
In love with suspect reviews, always drop everything to watch new ones
The nice thing with these games is that it may look like they're making lots of money, but when you look at the ratio of how much Pokémon usually makes and the sales of switch games in comparison to other Nintendo franchises, it's not actually that much. I really hope TPC take a step back and slow the fuck down, because this is inexcusable.
Great review, loved seeing you back at it.
Small note, BW2 does have a challenge mode
Ahh, BW2's challenge mode. Unlocked only after beating the game on Normal difficulty. And for whatever reason, so was *easy mode*.
My personal pet theory is that the game director was dead against having difficulty modes, but was forced to implement it by his bosses. However, there was some loophole that said "if the collected data from online users shows that nobody uses the alternate difficulty modes, you don't have to implement them in future games". Cue the most obnoxious implementation of game difficulty ever conceived.
@@Codraroll I mean, still better than no option. At least when you’re playing it on an emulator you can just hack it in straight off the bat.
The cracks were showing, to me anyway, at Sun and Moon. Fewer new Pokemon, lackluster intro, slower speed, too many old Pokemon too close to the beginning (didn't give us enough time to feel like we were in a new region, imo).
That and while the Team in SM was intentionally a joke, they were basically a holding pattern from the unintentional lameness of Team Flare.
Sad to see I was right to fear the future of the games.
I thought this was Scott the Woz with a new border. Other than that little mishap, great video! Nice to see you back
Pokemon Pathways is still, to this day, the best Pokemon fan game I've played. Just wished it was finished.
I miss random grass patches, and trainer battles, and a lot of other stuff that isn't in the game.
22:00 No I don't do living dex in my box cause that's just too tedious, I just catch what I catch and then sort which ones I love and then use the search system for certain pokemon I need.
As for the walking evolutions, there is an exploit for them. In the bug type city, you can jump on the roof of one of the Pokemon centers. If you set your Pokemon out on the ground before you went up, they'll run in circles. If they stopped running, just shift your position a bit. There, I just saved a bunch of you hours of time. But you should really thank polygon, which is where I found this trick. That said, step evolutions are still one of game freak's most dumbass decisions.
I think this is a very good video style to go forward in the future! Looking forward to more in the future
Good to see this format make a return, I remember this from the Mighty Ducks video. Very good, hope to see more
Good to have you back
I really like the new format. It’s a perfect blend of everything you’ve done. Thanks suspect !!
"Can you imagine a fan game beating an officially licensed game?!"
Sonic the Hedgehog: *hold my rings*
😂 FR great conclusion so glad you uploaded it’s been awhile 😁
“You look awful” from Aunt May 😂😂😂
7:11 Meanwhile Sonic fan games ended up being so good that sega officially hired devs with experience in fan game development to make ports of the classic games and Sonic Mania
I quite liked the games (played Scarlet myself), but these criticisms are all very fair. There's a lot of stuff SV can be criticized for. However, the gameplay loop at the core is still rock-solid (it honestly has carried the games for several installations now), the 'mon designs are still very good for the most part, and the quality of these games is leaps and bounds ahead of the absolute crap show that was SwSh or the cutscene hell of Gen VII.
Still, there's just so many times where you see some game feature and think "Man, this would have been absolutely *amazing* if they had just ..." Pokémon's persistent problem is that the gulf between what you get and what you imagine is so wide and so clearly visible.
I feel like the paradox pokemon are really under used during the main game as most they get is the Donphan variant which you face as a boss encounter 3 times.
If I was to work them in more, maybe have the evil team be a versus team like Magma & Aqua where their ideology comes downs to is technology making us weaker with the past team fighting to destroy technology to strength people while the future team believes technology is needed or some other cause that pits past and future agaisnt each other.
I love this idea, I'm not really a fan of the silly evil teams, skull gets a pass because they get serious alot more than yell or star does tbh
Loving the format of the video, Ross. Would love to see some more critical reviews like this one. Seeing as you briefly mentioned it here, do you think you'd ever take a look at Elden Ring? It's definitely different than past games you've reviewed, but it'd be great to see your take on the whole thing.
Don't have much to say on Elden Ring that others haven't said already; so no plans on a video there. I also don't feel too qualified to talk about it anyway, as I haven't beaten it.
@@TheUnusualSuspect Yeah that's fair. Either way, it's good to have you back! :)
Hey I'm probably already asked this question again do you still have all the trophies in tekken 7.
With fast making of the games, launching before the holidays, books of many bugs, glitches, and graphic errors, it's like Sonic '06 all over again.
They should use ILCA for making building interiors and to give the battles challenge
Very much liked the style of the video, but since I don't give a fuuuuk about Pokemon, I could not watch this till the end. Still good to have you back bro ❤
Omg I am so glad these types of videos are back ❤️
That moto-glider is a pokemon? Or just a really advanced vehicle?
Here's my solution for the VAs and games in general.
Step 1.
Remake Gen 1 BotW. Run about an open-world Kanto with non-linear paths and a FULL dex worth of wild Pokmon to find and catch.
Step 2. Hire the VAs from the regional anime with additional actors for the player to choose for themself.
Step 3. Profit.
Step 4. Remake Jhoto. Same deal.
Step 5. WHEN Jhoto is out, SS Anne arrives in Kanto to take players TO Jhoto. OR, you can start a New game in Jhoto with a fresh dex then go to Kanto if you want.
This would mean if you're a dedicated Gen player, you can start your Pokémon life in that region and explore the others at your discretion.
Step 6. Profit more.
I made votes that you can choose the style for Yellowstone
Open world is a bad idea for pokemon. Pokemon has always been linear. Opening it up would require a MASIVE overhaul.
what was your team in the end game?
Love the new format! Kinda like Angry Joe meets your hilarious editing style
These recent Pokémon games sound so barren and boring. I’ll just hang on to the nostalgia from my DSI/game boy years lol
Hey at least we got Ed Sheeran in the end credits, can't go wrong with that
These games suffer from minimal effort more than they do a lack of time. Someone who wants to do good work isn't gonna put crap like these out in the same time frame. You can see it in the work itself if you also play other games and know what passion and care for making a game actually looks like. It might have still been buggy and incomplete but I would be a bit more forgiving if they had tried to make things look good. I watched 2 brothers making their own pokemon game and produce results within a week that Gamefreak with more people and 3 years couldn't do. There's a reason the Fan games are better, it's cause the people making them like pokemon, and like making games that are good. There is a huge difference between them and Gamefreak.
Feels like the 2010s in here.
That's not a dig at Pokémon, it's more about how you doing reviews again reminds me of the heyday of reviewer channels.
Haven't played a Pokemon game since 2015 but I love watching your reviews so I'll be tuning in for this one nonetheless!
I hate these games more and more. Ugly, glitchy still, no level scaling so there is actually no point to the open world, slow, the camera is a disaster, the insane pop-in, raids are a nightmare between bugs, awful mechanics, no level scaling again or way to stop players from bringing Pokemon that are weak to the boss, yet they have the audacity to release raid exclusives Pokemon, not to mention competitive teams are hard locked behind rare drops from raids since you have no other way to get tera shards or ability patches. It's an unbelievable mess. And the nerve to promote DLC when the base game is still in this state is insane to me.
Will have to watch this later but oh boy this'll be fun.
14:38 worst part in games like that is that you don't even notice the subs and miss half the plot
at least they need basic barks beeps and boops
"Can you imagine any other gaming franchise where the fangames are better than the real ones"
Actually yes, I can, and it's one of the most beloved series, super smash brothers. A game called PMEX Remix is a game that's similar to Project M has the content of Brawl and the gameplay of Melee, but it also has a roster that unironically rivals Ultimate and, most importantly, has by far the best accessibility. You see Melee is a game that is one of the most immersive and beautiful fighting games to play because it's lack of input buffer allows for complete control of your character, the tradeoff being that it's excruciatingly difficult to get into, also there's no customizability with the controls, so if you dislike tap jump like I do, well tough shit. With PMEX, not only can you customize your controls like the later games (with the added ability of doing it in character select screen, making it easier to modify than ever), but in the new codes menu, you can customize your input buffer, so if you don't want to play with zero input buffer but still want a nice generous 3-5, hell even if you're used to Ultimate and it's disgusting 10 frames, you can do that. Not even project M or even project+ have that, and it's beautiful. As for the roster, while it doesn't have EVERYONE from Ultimate, it has a majority of the super popular additions like Ridley, Banjo Kazooie (both of which play better than their official counterparts while being in production beforehand too), King K Rool, Cloud, Bayonetta, the belmonts, Sephiroth, and even Sora. They even have some super requested characters that aren't officially playable yet like Waluigi, Geno, Bandana Waddle Dee, and Isaac, and with the exception of maybe Isaac, they're all incredibly well made and polished. They even have popular echo fighter requests like Dark Samus and Black Shadow who play unique to their counterparts.
There's also examples like Gmod being better than Half Life and Render 96 being tied with galaxy for the best Mario game, but I'm not sure those count. Point is, Pokémon being outdone by fangames isn't the most outlandish thing. There's a quote by a youtuber techrules that's essentially "no amount of developer effort will beat years of passionate fans".
Also I don't really think the magikarp run by Jrose11 is an example of the game being too easy. Not only were his strategies incredibly crafty to combat the difficulties of the run that most people wouldn't ever think of, but it was a VERY difficult run. Champion Geeta is considered a joke of a boss, but in that run it was actually super hard, bordering on almost impossible, even with the scientifically best possible magikarp. Even if he somehow got passed the Annihilape, he probably wouldn't get passed the actual final boss or maybe even penny, because in his fuecocco run, a competent Pokémon in comparison, could barely beat the A.I professor. Hell even when I did a Gardevoir run, a much better Pokémon in comparison to the other two, while it wasn't difficult or anything, there was still some difficult moments like Poppy and her tinkaton that was fairly hard to solve without overleveling. They're still easy games for sure, but it's more of an issue with the franchise overall and not just this game, afterall in red and blue, without a held item you could beat the games with almost anything and you didn't even have to be level 100, not even close.
I honestly really enjoyed Pokémon Scarlet, I was highly engrossed in the titan story line and the team star story line. I haven't enjoyed a main line Pokémon game since generation 6. Didn't enjoy sun/moon and sword/shield
I don't even like pokemon and this was an awesome, fun video to watch. Great job suspect!!
Thanks so much for making a video like this again. It was awesome.
Thanks Mark!
"No voice acting." While I haven't played any Pokémon games, I know what you mean, as voice acting is a fun way to rewatch the cutscenes, and no voices makes it just awkward.
Unusual Suspect you are awesome as always. Keep up the awesome content.
Thanks for the support; that means the world! :)
Welcome back mate!
Also the terastallize mechanic is TRASH. Like seriously there just Goofy ass elemental Hats ☠️💀 and the game literally forces you to Terastal during the second Phase of the IA professor fight ☠️💀
It still is pretty dang ridiculous that the mainline games had still lacked voice acting since arriving in Switch, but it’s even more insulting when it’s shown that it COULD be accomplished! New Pokémon Snap made that very clear and it just shows Game Freak incredibly reluctant when it comes to actually taking the time to spend some money on voice overs.
I really liked this vid, and I'm excited for the next one
This is a pretty good format for your game reviews, keep it up Suspect!
“It’s good to have you back spider man”
For me, this game had me having so many Mixed feelings. All it’s predecessors had minor hiccups here and there but they were all great games, despite what the toxic boycotters would tell you. But these games? Absolutely should have been delayed, there is no reason a Pokemon that’s 9 feet away should be having frame rate issues. Also f**k the raids in this game, you cannot tell what’s happening half the time.
Absolutely buzzing to see this in my sub feed!!
For a moment I thought you were gonna do a traditional everything wrong with video
Favourite Things Ever:
1. Suspect Upload
2. Everything Else
I am glad that more people are understanding how jarring it is that despite being 9 generations in, there is still no voice acting which could have helped a little bit for this game. And the sad thing all of the updates and ideas of how they could have improve it sound really good........but sadly Game Freak will never incorporate those ideas because no matter what, the series will STILL rake in the big bucks no matter how mediocre, lacking or shallow the games are. That is the power of a big franchise but honestly, they need to do a LOT more instead of half assing. Oh and glad to see you again!
The pacing of this vid is FLAWLESS. Super brisk and well delivered.
I agree with you dude but in the game you can't change out of your school uniform and your have the rediculos stake quest to release the 4 treasure Pokémon and your have 5 star plus raid battles which is why I hate this Pokémon game series .
Talking of Legend of Zelda, I feel Pokémon would benefit from following that series's release schedule, releasing a new game every other year. Look up the release dates for Zelda games and you'll find that there's a year long gap between most titles. This, honestly, works better for the developers as it allows them to iron out all the details and issues and ensure that the gameplay experience is fun for players. Pokémon's insistence nowadays on releasing a new title every year is severely harming their quality. If a franchise like Zelda can do a bi-yearly release of a new game and still bring in the big bucks and praise from fans and critics, then Pokémon with its multiple revenue pools, such as the anime, trading card game, and merchandise can do the same.
You do know your vid title can easily be mistaken for a cinemasins vid, right?
Iv been waiting for your pokemon scarlet video
I do wish GameFreak would be give or be given another year of production for their games. Each game since X&Y has lacked content and tuning more and more, especially with the post game (poor Battle Frontier) and now the Pokémon roster. It just seems that GameFreak and/or The Pokemon Company just push them out a year sooner because, like you mention, it’s Pokemon and it will still make bank.
Return of the king
2:15 is that from 2013-2023?
He's out of line, but he's right.
He’s finally back!
Nice to see you back for game reviews again!
Like to see for your Hogwarts Legacy review next since you predicted a Harry Potter RPG game in one of your old HP video's :)
7:09 And then those projects get C&D.
7:11 Me: a Sonic fan.
I mean... *sweating*
Good to see you back king
can we please just have some sort of 2D pokemon games back?
It's clearly what the responsible studios are more capable and comfortable with
The unusual subject man it's been a bit lol