The #1 Secret of Ear Training
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 гру 2023
- 🌟 In this video, I dive into the essential role of 'feelings' in ear training, a component often overlooked but crucial for truly understanding music. I'll share with you how feelings bridge our comprehension of music and why neglecting them can lead to a complete failure of traditional ear training methods.
🔍 But that's just the tip of the iceberg. I’m also revealing a much bigger and lesser-known secret involving 'musical feelings.' This secret will not only alter your perception of popular ear training exercises but also show you why they can be harmful for beginners and intermediates, yet beneficial for advanced students.
🎸 After developing a unique, science-based ear training method and attracting over 2000 students who left extremely positive feedback, I understand the intricacies of this craft. I’ll take you through my own struggles, the turning point in my ear training journey, and the groundbreaking insights I discovered.
✨ Expect to uncover:
- Why feelings are paramount in music understanding.
- How the most popular ear training exercises, while beneficial for advanced students, can be extremely detrimental to beginners and intermediate learners.
- Personalized advice and techniques that cater to your current skill level.
🧠 This video is more than just a lesson; it's an invitation to rethink ear training and embrace a method that aligns with our natural musical intuition. Whether you're a beginner struggling to make sense of notes and chords, or an intermediate looking to elevate your ear training skills, this video is tailored for you.
🚀 Join me in this enlightening video and start transforming your musical journey today. Don't forget to check out the link in the description for our Free Ear Training Workshop, where you can further hone your skills and join a community of passionate musicians.
-----------------------------------------
Free Ear Training Workshop
www.useyourear.com/free-works...
This is a free 3-hour long workshop full of actionable content and proven exercises that you won't find anywhere else.
-----------------------------------------
** USEFUL LINKS **
The different stages in the development of Ear Training skills
• Ear Training Milestone...
How our students go from zero to recognizing melodies by ear in a few months!
• How our students go fr...
How our students learn to recognize chord progressions by ear in a few months (starting from zero)
• How our students learn...
Book a 1 on 1 Lesson
www.useyourear.com/book-a-lesson
Testimonials & Opinions
www.useyourear.com/testimonials
Use Your Ear Video-Course
www.useyourear.com/use-your-e...
-----------------------------------------
Register to our Free Ear Training Workshop
www.useyourear.com/free-works...
This is a free 3-hour long workshop full of actionable content and proven exercises that you won't find anywhere else.
Excellent video. And your explanation of exactly why interval training can be beneficial for a person with advanced ear-training skills (but detrimental for a person with only beginner or intermediate skills) is crystal clear.
Thank you!
The "gravitational field" was a wonderful analogy; we need to somehow continue the analogy using F=m1*m2/d**2 (for those of you who remember your elementary physics).
Your method is really great, i think you should write a book covering this method so that it can reach many musicians and schools. Thanks for saving my time from being destroyed❤️❤️
Thanks
This method is already really popular in many musicians mind as I kept practsing I kept seeing this tonality and made this observation onmy own. Also this is taught in carnatic music too by various ragas.
Wishing the whole team at Use Your Ear a very merry Christmas and best wishes for 2024. 🥳
Hi Mike, Thank you! Wishing you a merry Christmas and happy new years as well! 😉
@@UseYourEarby chance did you secretly purchase a African americans patreon, and giving it out here for free?
@@venusspacey9685 Can you please tell me more about this? I don't exactly understand your message. Please clarify if you can.
Thank you so much!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤ much appreciation for your wonderful contents!!!😁
Thank you
I’m loving this channel and will be following you. Music Therapy is my path.
Thank you
Wow very good video! I assume I got recommended this video because I just uploaded a video speaking of the same thing, though on a simpler level, not as in-depth and great as you do it here! Thanks for this video, you got a new subscriber!
Thank you for the compliment. I wish you good luck with your channel!
Just a thought. This feels like an informercial to me. Im aware of the functional harmony approach and tonal center. And im glad people are building a conplete program around it. But your pitch feels a bit stiff and dishonest. Why not just spend time teaching and walking us through a few cool concepts nd actually teaching us. And once we realize it works and were learning, boom. Then youve got the program for us.
I appreciate your feedback and want to address your concerns directly. Firstly, is offering a free training really seen as a sales pitch? The fact that I'm offering you a FREE training at the end of the video is meant to be a helpful resource. What's dishonest about offering a FREE TRAINING that's designed to supplement the content I'm already providing?
Regarding your suggestion to spend time teaching and walking through concepts, I want to ask: Am I not teaching anything in this video? I've aimed to show why many are practicing ear training incorrectly and how to adjust your routine for better results. If you're looking for exercises and more in-depth guidance, that's exactly what's included in the FREE TRAINING. It's challenging to cover everything in a single UA-cam video, which is why the training exists-to provide a comprehensive learning experience.
Also, regarding exercises, it's important to note that there isn't a one-size-fits-all approach. The same exercise can be incredibly beneficial for one student while being detrimental for another, depending on their skill level and goals. That's why, in the free training, you'll be guided to self-assess your level and identify which exercises are most suitable for your specific situation.
I also want to clarify that ear training skills develop over time and through consistent practice. One exercise in a video won't drastically improve your skills. It's about the cumulative effect of regular, focused practice, which is what the method is designed to help with. Have you checked out the other 100 videos on my channel? They cover various topics and some offer exercises that might be of interest to you. I hope this clarifies my intentions and the value I'm striving to provide.
Wasn't trying to be rude. I know first hand producing content is no small order. But there werent any exercises or lessons provided at the end of the video. That's why I said it feels dishonest. Yes, there was a workshop you had to register for, with a countdown timer only giving you 3:30 to do so. Ugh. It's just a marketing ploy that makes it feel like an infomercial. And I'm only saying this cause I bet your content is actually pretty good! And if it didn't have this gimmicky feel to it maybe more people would give it a go. But, I'm also just some dude on the internet.
I'm just saying it doesn't "feel" honest and genuine. Why not offer some of the lessons and exercises right off the bat and rope us in? That's it. God bless and good luck. I'm really not trying to troll but offer some helpful criticism.
@@UseYourEar I support what @mikemolaro4198 said. That whole webinar is extremely pushy. Setup like a crypto scam from those "get rich quick" people. We are musicians who just want to learn something from trust-worthy people. I genuinely think you have something valuable to share, but I am hesitant to give you money, seeing that you don't take feedback seriously here. I hope you remember what music is for and not get blinded by the business side of things.
@@mikemolaro4198 thanks for your message. Let me share my personal opinion: based on your reply, it seems you are actually not very interested in ear training. If a timer on a landing page (which shows the time left before the next training session starts) that asks you to opt in into a FREE training is a deterrent to watching the training, it means you don't actually feel the need for training your ears that much. That said, I wish you could understand that not everything can be totally free. It certainly wasn't free for me to create and develop the method I'm discussing in this video, it literally required years and years of efforts and dedication. Nor it was free for me to produce this video. If I ask for your email in exchange of a FREE lesson, it shouldn't be seen as if I'm trying to take advantage of you, but rather as a fair negotiation for the value you get from the FREE lesson.
@@UseYourEar I know. I have another youTube channel that I've put 4 years of daily effort into. I know everything can't be free. That's not at all my critique and feedback. Apologies, man. Was trying to be helpful but I'm not sure you found my critique constructive. Moving on. God bless and good luck. I'm confident your program will help a lot of people.
this gravitational field comparison actually opened my eyes and unlocked a new way of thinking it, one day when i become so good and having relative pitch, ill come back to this video and edit this comment, thank u a lot bro
Thank you very much!
Thanks for sharing.
Thank you!
I've been floundering on guitar for 30yrs, when i was a teenager I peaked because i have no ear, kids i taught guitar would take off and be able to play anything and i stayed the same
Thanks for your comment. I hope this video clarifies what might have gone wrong in your past experiences.
Thank you
Thank you Patrick!
Would love to do this course but with the exchange rate being so high not possible, for now Interval training will have to do
Just don't do interval ear training, that's the worst you could do.
Does the 12 degrees sound the same in any key or scale?
Thank you for this. Most ear training exercises (at least in US institutions) is heavily flawed because it ignores training the intuitive sense of gravity within an instant tonal environment. Instead it emphasizes isolated interval practice.
Moving from isolated intervals to intermediate or advanced dictation is a very difficult bridge to gap for the average musician.
Thanks for your comment. What you are saying is so true. That said, melodic dictation is far easier when approached from a tonal perspective instead of an intervallic one.
I enjoyed this entry level lesson a lot and would to know more but cannot afford the ongoing lessons
Thanks for your reply. You can access the free ear training workshop from our website www.useyourear.com - Have you registered to it already?
There are 2 apps named Meludia and Functional ear trainer… they don’t train ears through intervals.
Can you please tell me are those apps good enough to train my ears.
Hi, this is a common question we often get. Unfortunately, the apps you mentioned offer limited exercises and don't outline a complete training system that includes all the sub-skills required to develop a great ear. The results is that most often than not students are left with significant gaps in their skills that need to be filled before they can apply their skills to real music. I invite you to check out this video where one of our students talk about his experience with the functional ear training system ua-cam.com/video/3uYbG0srGJw/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
I love this video! :)
Thank you!
Do you have an actual complete course on singing intonation or will that be covered in the ear training course?
Hi, Intonation is a byproduct of a having a refined perception of pitch (which means: having a great musical ear). The course allows you to fully develop your ear, no matter your current level. So the answer is, the course covers what you need to develop your intonation.
@@UseYourEar I mean advanced level of intonation like actual keys switching songs… does it covers that?
@@I-is-me in my experience when a student has solid foundation and a great intonation in a simple tonal context they won't have issues in keys switching songs. That said, our course deals with key shifts and complex topics in the advanced units.
Very interesting! I just disagree at 10:15 when you talk about G major. When I heard that little melody with C-D-E-F#-G I hear in my head C lydean. I know it is relative to G major, but I mean that I hear C as th tonal center, not G. So I think it depends on the type of music. If you check out Hermeto Pascoal, for example, 99% of the times his songs relies on this lydean feel (#11 over a major chord).
Hi, thank you for your comment. If you perceived C lydian, you are perceiving the exact same gravitational field of G major. You are just watching it (or experiencing it) form a different perspective. Indeed, C would still have the sensation of the 4th degree of a major key (the lydian sensation, as you call it), not the Ionian sensation of the the first degree, which belongs to G (at that point in the example). This is to say that you don't disagree on the feelings, you just disagree on the nomenclature. My pylosophy is that music isn't about nomenclature it's about feelings, none cares how we call it. People just feel the same things whether we call it C Lydian or G Major. Personally keeping things simple when it's possible works best for students.
@@UseYourEar
Not everyone percieves music in the exact same way, so I don't believe that's true. Sometimes people do legitimately disagree on what the tonal center of a piece is.
@@Persun_McPersonson That's note true! People might disagree on the tonal center if there isn't enough musical information to establish a univocal tonal center. i.e. I play only C, F and G - the tonal center is ambiguous because you can perceive either C or F as the tonal center. The moment I play B, the tonal center is clearly C. Because the tritone between F and B clearly establishes a univocal tonal center. That said, situations like this very very rarely happen in music where the arrangement combined with the main melody line immediately lays out enough musical information to outline a univocal tonal center in the first seconds of the song.
That said, I wanna clarify that perceiving 2 different tonal centers relative to each other, like C major and A minor, does not mean disagreeing on the tonality. The tonality is actually the same because C major and A minor are just relative keys (same for D dorian, F lydian, etc.). So if I say I'm perceiving C major and you say you are perceiving G mixolidian, we are actually perceiving the same key (the same set of notes are making up the gravitational field).
So it's not a disagreement.
Most 'disagreement' cases other than the 2 outlined above are just due to not being skilled enough to recognize the tonic properly.
Lastly, people do perceive music in mostly the same way. It's not that subjective as you think it is.
@@UseYourEarThis sounds really strange to me. If there definetly is a sensation related to the tonic of a tonality (which I think I can feel and recognize), and that sensation is different for G major and for C lydian (in which I feel respectively those notes as the tonal center), this makes no sense. Of course it also has to do with what notes you play and what harmony you imply because, having the same notes, it's easy to end up sounding like other mode, and usually Ionian wins that battle. But there are definetly times when I heard and felt, for example, a lydian tonal center, as opposed to a IV feeling relative to another tonic. Is there any research about perception of modes and this issue that you could share?
@@matiasusabiaga9198 There is no research I'm aware of that highlights anything on that. But in my experience with a lot of students and in the experience of our teachers with a lot of students (We are talking about hundreds of students at this point) the tonic of each mode has a comparable to the feeling of the respective scale degree in its relative major key. The 1st degree of the relative major key has always the strongest pull and feeling of resolution. If you perceive the lydian tonic feels that way its very likely that you momentarily shifted the tonality in your mind. These are complex abstract topics, and it's quite difficult to explain them here. I hope you can get the point of my reply.
OMG this is intuitive for me as I instinctively refused to move on until I have all the major key totally down. Then the sharps and move onto chords. But as a self taught pianist was too hard to put into words, I just feel what is right. This makes absolute sense. However, am I missing something as can’t find the website to do the free course. However, I’ve just the seen the price of the course and I guess it’s another one for the wealthy. Why so expensive?! It’s not very inclusive!😢 I will be doing the freebie of course.😊
Hi @11kwright, just to clarify. The course includes 8 hours of video lessons, tons of audio and pdf files to practice with and it's the best and most through representation of our method. It required years of research, testing and development to create our method and one entire year to produce this course and put it together. This is by far the best ear training method available, especially when it comes to developing perception and understanding of musical pitch. It's not comparable to anything else in terms of effectiveness, clarity and depth of explanations, specific instructions on exactly how to think when performing each ear training task, etc. Most people learn to recognize chords and melodies by ear alone in just a few months of following the course. It only costs the equivalent of 2 or 3 months of music lessons with a private teacher who, best case scenario "doesn't know anything about ear training", worst case scenario "will make you frustrated and waste a lot of your time and energy in practicing the wrong exercises". For what our course offers, holding off on lessons with your private music teacher for two or three months and investing that money in a serious ear training course seems like a no-brainer to me, as what you learn here will fundamentally change how you interact with and connect to music for the rest of your life. However, if you are not prepared to allocate any funds towards a private music teacher, then this course might not be for you. It is specifically designed for individuals who are deeply committed to their musical skills. I'm sorry if this reply seemed a bit aggressive, I just wanted to clarify.
So are you saying that those students who are very familiar with all 12 scales will do well compared to beginners who may not?
Why the 12 scales? It's mostly about knowing the major scale, which also encompasses the minor scale. That said knowing the major scale very well is one of the first steps of our method, so yes, it's absolutely foundational; You can't have great ear training skills without it.
Where's the link?
Hi, here is the link to the workshop www.useyourear.com/free-workshop-optin-organic
I've just checked and it's also available in the video description.
TOP del TOP 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
grazie!
But you're not mentioning that the consevratories all over the world have been teaching solfege which is the best way also based on degrees and not on intervals
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. However, I believe your perspective might not fully represent what's happening in all the conservatories all over the world. While it's true that solfège is taught in some conservatories, suggesting it's the predominant approach worldwide, might not be entirely accurate. I can attest that it's not. Especially in Europe and other countries than USA. In the United States, there might indeed be a slightly higher number of institutions favoring solfège, but even there, a significant number of conservatories continue to emphasize interval-based ear training. It's also important to note that many institutions that do teach solfège often combine it with interval-based methods, which, renders it ineffective. Check out this video where I talk about this point ua-cam.com/video/8PV9Oe3WE6I/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
Lastly, I wouldn't say solfège is the ultimate approach to ear training. While it has its advantages, it also has many limitations. Indeed, I would hardly describe solfege as an ear training method. It's just a very broad idea on how to approach ear training, which is often misinterpreted. A method should have a series of clear instructions, should be step-by-step and show you a clear path from beginner to advanced. This is just a small point, I have an entire video where I discuss about the issues with solfege you can check it out here ua-cam.com/video/Wt58XfybL08/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
Yea the first and most contentious bugaboo with solfegio is deciding whether to use fixed or moveable Do! People are often fiercely fixed in their positions on which is superior.
I think the phrasing that it's not about intervals but feeling is misleading, because that feeling does partly derive from intervals. When you compare a note's feeling in relation to a tonal center, that itself uses an interval. So the truth is that it's a combination of intervals and the tonal center that you're basing them on that creates a given feeling. I think you should try to be more clear about this instead of using "intervals" to mean intervals without any tonal context; instead, be up front and say that practicing intervals without a tonal context is ineffective and that you need to base intervals on keys.
The feeling doesn't derive from intervals. It derives from your perceived tonal context. It's the concept underlying the entire video. I believe it's explained clearly enough here and I suggest you re-watch the video cause this point is very important. That said, I have other videos on this channel where I show the scientific evidence behind this claim.
Aside all of the above, I think there is an important point to clarify: Not only intervals are ineffective but they are also unnecessary to recognize most melodies, and chords. I know that, cause I do that all the time and I don't think about intervals ever. I think about single notes and chords and their sensation in the given musical piece. I have thousands of students that learn how to do so quite quickly and effectively. There are videos on our website showing their skills.
So it's not misleading at all to say that 'intervals are ineffective'. You don't need them to develop a pretty good musical ear. They are also ineffective because 99% of interval-based exercises are setup without any tonal context. So since 'practicing intervals with a tonal context' is the exception, a very rare exception actually. I think it's not misleading at all to say that 'intervals are ineffective'. That said, thinking of intervals within a tonal context, still is ineffective. By far not the best way to recognize music by ear. I actually ask my students to avoid thinking of intervals, and to your surprise they learn quite well.
So I'm afraid only one of us is wrong here.
The feeling does not derive from the interval itself, but from the position of the two notes within the scale or key. If you are in C major, moving from E to F and moving from B to C feel very different, but the interval is the same (a minor second). Of course, the scale itself is defined by an initial note (eg C) and a pattern of intervals (eg TTSTTTS). Still, you don't ask how does C feels or how does a minor second feels. You ask "how does the tonic feel?" and "how does moving from the leading note to the tonic feel?"
All the best
@@user-zp6kt6ni2l thanks for clarifying this further
@@UseYourEar My pleasure.
@@user-zp6kt6ni2lwell said,
UA-cam has become a nonstop infomercial..
What exactly is 'infomercial' about this video? The fact that I'm offering you a FREE training at the end of it? Is offering a FREE training seen as a bad thing today? I'm honestly surprised. This video required weeks of work and thousands of dollars to be created, the FREE training I'm offering required months of work and thousands of dollars to be created. You're getting all of this FOR FREE, and you are complaining about it? There is essential information in this video, that alone can help you avoid wasting decades of your life on practicing the wrong things, like it happened to me and hundreds (if not thousands) of my students. You are complaining about the fact that I'm disclosing this? It just seems like you are not interested in ear training, otherwise you would say thank you or leave a like! Like most people are doing.
😂
Imagine unironically using AI to generate video descriptions xD
I'm not getting the point, feel free to explain.