Rankings of India’s states on health, how UP is last & also 1st, winners, losers & brilliant Mizoram
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 гру 2021
- #IndianHealthSystem #HealthCareReport
NITI Aayog has released its report ranking states & UTs based on health index. Shekhar Gupta looks at this data filled report and how have various states performed. Episode 907 of CutTheClutter also brings out few surprises in Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka & others in health terms
Brought to you by @KiaInd
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the report here: www.niti.gov.in/sites/default...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
![ЛЕБЕДЕВ у ДУДЯ: муху не обманешь 😁 [Пародия]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/E74h5fvVrqs/mqdefault.jpg)
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s UA-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ua-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
8u8
ua-cam.com/video/Q1tU3Mcba4U/v-deo.html
This is what makes The Print different than mainstream media.
People are fed up with mainstream TV media.
The Print should start TV channel. I know it is easier to say than doing.
Main stream news channel are another kind of entertainment business.
Majority of people will get headaches from data, thus the prefer "dar ka mohol hai" and "arnab"
To start a channel you need millions
No, in 24 hr news business, you'll run out of news. The cycle of cranking out news at breakneck speeds leads to the downfall in quality and increase of entertainment fillers.
But will government give approval that's a big question
Niti Ayog has done a tremendous job over last 7 years. Modi changed its core role from allocating funds (as planning commission used to do earlier) to creating programmes and tracking progress.
Best thing about Niti Ayog has to be the fact that I puts a heavy emphasis on how states within India rank with each other
@@tomriddle4110 plus so unbiased
@@tomriddle4110 ever seen the rank in which indore was declared cleanest?
See the no of categories in that rank
Too many states and too many rank?
Does it really do great
Where is west Bengal
@@AUSHRUSH I think they would have not shared their data.
As India marches deeper into this century it will also be interesting, if the supposedly developed states start aiming for tougher benchmarks. For e.g. States like TN, KL can start comparing themselves with developed countries in our neighborhood like Malaysia, China etc and see how we compare against them. And strive to achieve their levels within a period of 10 to 15 years. While the remaining states should set targets of achieving higher scores within the country. This is what will really push India to the next stage.
Problem is that those high development group are sharing their wealth through cgst with all the other lagging states too. So this metric also wouldn't be equalizing enough.
Omicron ka naya funda
ua-cam.com/video/RCZC6WV-6dA/v-deo.html
My doc in kerala who got fellowships from US and Australia is trying hard to undo the damage done by a nasty US surgeon. Healthcare is ridiculously good in kerala. Awesome Healthcare workers catering to the average joe.
Where is West Bengal Mr Gupta? So west Bengal refuse to give Data is this not Hitler Ship or not Or Fascist Mamta Bannerjee wants to Make Indians this is type Governance she is Emulating
West Bengal has liberal privileges. No one can question.
WB was excluded for unmentioned reasons so don't jump to conclusions.
And it is not the only state excluded either.
@@aranyasadhukhan9899 you give didi too much benifit of doubt
The best thing about this govt is it has started to make comparisons amongst different states on different parameters like health..infra... logistics etc. Once you have data,you can measure it and what can be measured can be improved..just like corporate culture which is how a country should be run with the PM being the CEO and CM's being the head of different business units
Earlier it did not happen?
@@ST-oh6zw no never
If govt gives some incentives to the states which are doing best in those parameters,then it will become more competitive.
Massaging data and changing baseline characteristics to suit your narrative should not be mistaken with good governance. Modi bhakts make it sound like there was no governance before 2014. No doubt Modi is doing a good job in the eyes of the people cause he wouldn't come back with greater majority in 2019. It is critical to point out specific steps taken by the govt in terms of regulation to boost the economy and states in various parameters. UP needs to divided into at least 2 if not 3 states. UP does not contribute monetarily to the Indian economy and holds a too many 80 seats in the Lokh Sabha.
@@sujitdsouza no UP cannot e divided. The development in UP has been very lopsided. If divided the eastern UP will become Bihar 2.0. Only recently the eastern UP has started getting its due attention.
But why was Chandigarh with such a staggering decline? Pandemic should have boosted public Healthcare expenditure but the deterioration is an abomination for such a rich UT.
Entire data is pre-pandemic.
@@RaameshGowriRaghavan That is even worse. Why would there be such tremendous decrease in ratings in a normal year?
A lot of schemes have been introduced by PM after the pandemic. I think we'll see a difference in the next year data.
@@murarikarmhe2322
You ain't gonna see any huge differences, the standings would be more or less similar.
@@sabugeet ???
NDTV : UP last
Republic TV : UP No. 1
Print : Last yet first
😅
Most people who keep saying BJP government manipulates data must see how the data is clean. Karnataka, and haryana are ruled by BJP and yet they highlighted the detoriation.
Omicron ka naya funda
ua-cam.com/video/RCZC6WV-6dA/v-deo.html
Most of the NITI aayog data I have seen are fair and impartial
@@badass6954 which of the data has government manipulated?
West Bengal would score the worst in most fields: crime, health, etc. That is the Government of West Bengal rarely shares any data with the Government of India.
wb is not include because they are not showing correct data they also dont trust central also
@@coolboi1621 that's why BJP ruled state are at bottom of the list
@@anikasrivastava3320 there are many BJP state which did better than non BJP state
@@Bengal2923 Name them 😎
@@harikittu143 karnataka, Gujrat🤐
There is the third India, namely, West Bengal, the North Korea of India playing by its own rules. And it is not just the Government but the private health care sector as well. Recently, the state authorities found out that its prestigious hospitals were charging much more than Vellore but, at least in one case, with worse outcomes. A patient went to Vellore and saved his leg after having been told that amputation was necessary and showed the two bills, one from Kolkata and the other eye-poppingly lower from Vellore. All West Bengal needs is the nuclear bomb.
Private health-care sector works more like a hyper-aggressive profit making industry rather than actually acting like a care-giver institution. This is partly because most of them for a majority of time cater to foreign populations.
I remember 2-3 years back Apollo Kolkata charged Rs.3500 for an ultrasonography which was charged at Rs.750 by Apollo Chennai!!
Btw, why so much hate for Bengalis?!!
Keep crying chomu bhakt
@@spyboy0076 plzz check the performance of west bengal in economics and infra from the last 20 years..
@@anikasrivastava3320 You will not find any data. Any kind of data. Not even registered crime rate.
@@ChoCoMoCo69 yeahhhhh.....
It's sad to see downfall of Bengal
Mizoram have shown to all the hill states that geographical disadvantage is not an excuse for poor healthcare.
People and government in Uttarakhand needs to learn from this.
We are busy, predicting the next CM :P
I think there is problm in local doctors. Most UK people joins govt jobs or defence. There are less in medical field. Doctors from other states don't wants to work on remote places cuz opening a clinic in a metro city is more profitable thn going deep inside hill state and waiting for patients. Been to a govt hospital and it's totally empty.
I appreciate the fact that the numbers in this report were decluttered but a bit of decluttering of the methodology of the survey would've been better. Like how is Delhi which is a metro city with super speciality hospitals like AIIMS etc only as good as Jharkhand.
Thanks for your honest journalism🙏
Where is west bengal
@@AUSHRUSH they refused to share data.
Maybe Delhi's ranking is low because of the accessibility to healthcare. I mean considering almost over 2 crore population, I don't think Delhi has enough affordable hospitals. Infact, no major Indian cities might have.
Probably because of affordability issues. And also overburdened. Our country's health system is creaking, but no place is as overburdened as Delhi. I saw a woman going into labour as well as two dead bodies placed out in open right in front of the AIIMS's entrance gate and that was just within a 15 min visit on a casual Tuesday.
Viraj, I agree we need decluttering and better understanding of this data.
Ironically Southern states get back much less money from their own tax incomes for being disciplined. It is time that Central Govt. give more money to Southern states. This is becoming like there no incentive for performance, but more pain. The more data comes in like this, the divide would be seen in the polls as well.
@@tony-pc4kd Yeah, and this when Delhi is populated almost exclusively by Bhaiyya log! Just imagine what it would've been like if there'd been any Madrasis in Delhi! It would've been like British Raj loot!
That is the case with Bengal too.
@@tony-pc4kd Your adjacent state 🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣😅😂
That's how democracy works. State who don't earn much cuz of their geography or other reasons got money from other states to improve. Sadly thy have more uneducated and Poor population and it will take a lot of time.
@ahs pm where west?? Where capatlist rules?? Bro you need to understand a simple fact socity and democracy works like that having more and Sharing with the people who need it. A lot of western countries population lives near ocean and water where trade and industry grown coz of better connectivity. India is not diffrent from them. States who are near Ocean has more industrial zones and and connectivity go trade. And it makes them better. Just increase the population of southern state by 10x will it will look same?? No. And federalism comes with one election will everyone will agree having one election in five yr and winner will run the whole country?? Don't act like an Educated uneducate.
At least we have to praise central government for unbiased reporting.
NITI AAYOG's reporting have been perfectly fine and unbiased most of the time. Should appreciate Arvind Subramaniam for running this institution incredibly well
Yeah, we should appreciate the fact that trains were running on time during emergency.
@@rajkamal5092 infact even Aravind subrahmanyam had to run away from this incompetent administration
True
According to this data, UP has improved a lot.. wonder how bad the situation was earlier.
The data is from 19-20, one can only guess what happened in 20-21, and the pandemic certainly provided the incentive to develop rapidly
Akhilesh was busy looting the state.
No govt before modi-yogi thought about people. All they cared about was CORRUPTION and hoarded hundred and crores with people like Piyush Jai
@@rahulitrc Why is Gujarat still not No 1?
@@sgn9754 Because of BJP
These statistics remind me the words of Nobel laureate Dr. Amartya Sen stating
" If Tamil Nadu and Kerala had been separate nations they would have competed with advanced nations of the world in development"
True
They can still compete
If Tamil Nadu becomes an independent nation, give it 10-20 years it will become one of the few top-ranked nations in the same league of East Asian countries.
@@lordshiva1958 Only twist is that it will never happen:)
@@kirankoti6316 Never Say Never…. USSR the country with worlds largest Army split into 26 pieces in a matter of 11 years
This survey is for year 2019-20. I have a feeling the BIMARU states will continue progressing and will grade out much better when the next report comes out. Whether you like them or not, for India to progress, these laggard states needs to atleast come to the mean while the top performing states need to continue aiming for perfection...
As long as BJP is there and Samajwadi Mayavati and cong. Does not get in and ensure these states remain divided based on castes.
@@sudipbhattacharjee9 Agreed. This report has really piqued my interest to see what the data says in the next report. If I were a betting person, I will put my money on UP moving towards the mean in the next report. Caveat being, UP continue having a stable government.
@@pratikdave9138 Yeah, I also think no other party can replace BJP in UP as they've done a lot of work there. I'm very curious about future developmental projects in UP.
@@murarikarmhe2322 I can only hope. The thing is UP people are obsessed with government jobs. Which are very few in the state. There is like a private hiring wave in UP. My firm has setup a factory there but they are facing a problem in hiring labour in UP
@@unofficial4650 I think these guys are paid activists. Why the hell will anyone go and protest for jobs when there is a huge vacancy in private jobs. And if these guys are really protesting for jobs, they are either lazy or shouldn't deserve to get a job as jobs changes with time, you have to skill up according to requirement of the market.
Karnataka's health score was 59.73 in 2014-15 and now it's decreased to 57.93 also rank decreased by 2 spots compared to Health index 2014-15 while health Score of AP, TN, MH grown by 9. Karnataka is sliping down in most of the Social indices recently Karnataka's slipped to 6th from 3rd spot in Good Governance Index.
Until and unless Karnataka gets it’s full majority government it will keep on slipping the spots ..
Thanks to congress and Siddaramaiah who ruled Karnataka from 2013 to 2019
CREDIT TO THE BJP RULE
@Joe Xavier stupid we r the silicon Valley of India which state r u from we r much more educated than u
@@theanthropologist6589 both parties to blame
Kerala yet again securing that number one rank , no surpise in that..
"Jaya Kerala Dharani" to that.
Yeah, God's own country always tops the list.
kerala rocks as always... North India should send a deligation to kerala and replicate the system in their states
@@chinammadath but in reality the central govt tries to replicate what’s in UP to southern states
@@chinammadath it's very difficult task in Northern states bro
UP and Bihar are everyone's favorite punching bags. Bihar lost almost 15 years to JUNGLE RAJ while UP too was on a "vanvaas" since 1947. It is important to give these states some time and some political stability.
Some of these biased media keep barking how bad UP and Bihar are, but they never ask who was responsible for their state of affairs. Shaker Gupta is among them in BJP bashing.
UP has made so many PMs. Why was it on a vanvaas. It's because people don't vote on development. And they continue to do so unfortunately
@@SHIVANKURSHARMA-fm2yd At lowest base, it's very easy to make improvements. That's never an achievement.
It's all about people's mindset and priorities, U.P. will never come out of Bimaru status because it's priorities are different.
But UP's GDP is in decline since Yogiji came to power. So it is sinking further
Karnataka is becoming bimaru state of Southern states
Mizoram is one of the best state in North East
not one of its actually the best
No, Mizoram is not among the best states but Mizoram is the best of all in North East
BIMARU states dragging down the health Index of India significantly due to their large population. It may help to split the states into smaller ones for better governance. Smaller states with population around 3-5 crores seem to do better in healthcare and other development indices and surprisingly TamilNadu with a population more than 8 crores bucks this trend.
No. It will lead to further chaos and more river dispute. Which will turn into sub national jingoism like Tamil karnataka maharashtra kerala. UP is developing fast since last 15 years i.e the time we started having 5year fixed term govt. Irrespective of how you see us, we haven't elected same party again in last 5 elections. That shows people are vying for development. Western uttar pradesh is already performing better than kongu nadu region and bangalore. Eastern and bundelkhand are lagging and they will catch soon.
Mostly because they are hardcore vegetarians, I think. Malnutrition is rampant for the same.
@@ayonbiswas4186 you stupid or what?? acc to you WB should have been dominating nutritional index with fishes
@@ayonbiswas4186 never lose your mind completely. shame.
Omicron ka naya funda
ua-cam.com/video/RCZC6WV-6dA/v-deo.html
Heartland states should start questioning themselves why they are not doing as well as south india .
Because they had a late start.
In 1947, these states were already overpopulated, and corruption ridden.
When there is poverty, people try to survive by any means necessary, which gives rise to lawlessness.
Lack of urbanisation.. Bihar's 80% population live in villages.. That's the main reason... Due to lack of urban centers people get settled down in urban centres of other states.. This way we are loosing our talents.. Just look at any office and try to find guys from Bihar.
I would say because they had a lower start. We all learn about the forced opium plantation by the British, debt trap, and etc etc, but we don't realize that mainly the ganga region suffered from this, mainly UP, bihar and bengal. A lot of other states were either princly state, trade centres or places were the brits lacked much interest. And as for why they didn't develop in the 70 years, well that can be said for all of India
Without good economy,health care can't be improved.
Not just southern india OTHERS like Gujrat, Maharashtra,Haryana ,Himachal &North eastern states are also doing Good
Shekhar, many thanks for highlighting and sharing the report on health of the nation. It will be excellent if Print can discuss topics such as health, education, employment, environment, etc., as this is what politics should be about rather than religion and caste. It will be useful if Print can bring in experts in these areas and have healthy debates and discussions. Thank you.
Hi Tarun
Always here to discuss relevant social issues. Thanks for appreciating our work.
-SG
@@ThePrintIndia really is it Shekhar Gupta responding?
This was a good episode, and hats off to India Government for enhancing a data based governance, I don’t remember the data has ever been used so extensively in India. On UP issue though the improvement must be seen as credit of existing government, but current state is result of negligence of past 70 years , however, Yogi ji needs to give some more focus on it.
Nonsense. Just because you are in days of internet and you came to know about these things, you conclude this happened just now. It's always known where each states stand. There are enough info in recent history about most of the social indicators of the states. You are making your own fools paradise.
In last 30 years most of Hindi states are ruled mainly by BJP. So cut the crap.
Unemployment data bhi de do,
What is measured can be improved. This synopsis of Niti Aayog makes a lot of sense. let us hope that this is taken up by the state governments, and implement programmes to improve the various indices.
I'm doing my masters in IR from Central University of Kerala and I've traveled a lot in Kerala so being a UP guy I can tell the Stark difference clearly . Per capita consumption in Kerala is very high. Basic health facilities are lot better. You can't find anyone begging or doing manual labor .
Karnataka is declining in important indicators! We sent 25 out of 28 MPs to BJP. Modi has to take special care of Karnataka and start something substantial!!
it will decline more if you keep on voting bjp...hahahah
Money will go only to North India. South won't get anything. It has always been the policy of Hindia
@@va-ro 700 million people without toilets after voting Congress for six decades. Modi did it. So keep making an ass of yourself you nincompoop
@@ownerspride8305 hahaha....heeee...name-calling is the last resort of bigoted bhakts without arguments....
Most of them, like that idiot of an MP from South Bangalore, are busy playing communal politics. Karnataka may continue to slide.
How dare PM called kerala is Somalia while Niti Ayog claims kerala is in par with the most advanced countries in the world
To be honest, the Modi Govt has released some spectacular data. The same govt was criticized for manipulating data a few years back.
And, this data is actually a slap for the Congress, if we analyze closely. This is debt to be paid for the past mistakes/corruption.
Well Abhilash, Data is data and it often speaks for itself.
-SG
It's always known who are the laggards and who does better. In fact the Bhimaru word was coined back in 80s. It's the same states even now, 30 years down the line. So just because you have internet and found a video today, it doesn't mean world started today. Data was already there, it is all about what politics has to offer in these states. And these hindian states are having same politics what they were in last 30 years, looking for temples, castiesm, bigotry, lawlessness etc. And, to your rude shock most of these states where ruled by bjp multiple times in last 30 years.
So cut the right wing crap and the propoganda.
@@sujithkumar2041 oh you mean the perception was already there and there was no data confirming it!!
I get it!!
@@AbilashS Looking at your reading and comprehension skills, I doubt any amount of data would help you to change your perception.
@@sujithkumar2041 right... Looking at the data, I change my perspective. The common perception doesn't determine my perspective
Maharashtra has achieved SDG target of U5MR, MMR & likely to achieve the SDG NMR target of 12 soon currently it is 13 neonatal deaths per 1000 live births.
Thanks to Niti Ayaoh for capturing and publishing data without politics. This will help the country moving forward 🙏
Surprised to see Karnataka lagging behind the other Southern state by such a big margin. I expected it to be top 3 or 4 nationally.
The BJP effect.
Yes when your mp is busy raiding bbmp as. An excuse to spread his communal agenda and is busy commenting on conversions and not on work
@Tha Thomasi but he is correct in pointing out the fact that the only bjp ruled southern state is lagging behind other southern states.
@@kaavi1391 but gujrat did do well, and by development rate, even UP did well. You can't just isolate one region of the country and pretend that the other part as a neighbor or outside entity. I know certain Lemurian politicians want to push that narrative
@Tha Thomasi If the person you are confronting is being illogical, it doesn't mean you also have to be as stupid as them.
Why no real mention of kerala. Forget covid era, in cbse text of 90s, kerala is compared to Europe on many basic parameters.
Arum ille ivide. Adi like machane
Dear SG- Could you please do a cut the clutter on Modi's new PLI scheme of 76,000cr for semiconductors and how is it different from different schemes in the past where India failed to gain the trust of manufacturing giants.
Yes this is very important
This data validates what many talked about during the second wave in India. Delhi, UP and the other northern states fared so much worse because of their lack of quality healthcare compared to the southern / western states.
States like Kerala, Maharashtra always topped the charts when it came to covid infections but were able to manage the wave much better because of their infrastructure.
Kerala, maharshtra and Bombay were the most affected states despite good healthcare facilities
@@aryankumarjha4274 I think its not just that they were the most affected, it is more that they had the facilities to detect covid the most. So for example if 10 people got covid, lets say 6-7 would be detected in maharashtra/kerala etc but in UP/Rajasthan etc this same number would be close to 2-3 out of 10 would be detected. This same phenomenon was reported during all the national sero surveys done by the indian ministry of health. So its not that Kerala/Maharashtra were the most affected despite thier facilities but rather becasue of thier facilities they detected the most covid cases
@@aryankumarjha4274 these regions appears most affected because it has finest infrastructure to detect COVID cases. Totally different scenarios for so called Hindi heartland, where infrastructure is so worse that they could not able to cremate people. Dead bodies were floating in the rivers.
Speak volumes how national resources are wasted on these states.
@@aryankumarjha4274 bombay isn't a state man . It was a presidency like madras which included gujarath (accept sauranshtra ), western maharashtra amd konkan prior 1956 state reorganization .
@@JosephStalin-io5fp sorry I was about to write delhi by mistake I've written Mumbai .. my mistake 🙏
This should be a wake-up call for states in the Hindi belt. If they don´t start voting for development politics the southern states will leave them far behind!! This economic disparity could be disastrous for the union of India.
"Hindi states" have made the biggest progress you idiot.
@@siddharthdutta2946 Conveniently forgot about the 'low base' part, didn't ya? 😂
@@appukuttanj low base was from the congress era ,bjp has only comerecently to the picture ,up will improve a lot more.
@@DibyarupRoy And who exactly is denying that please? This survey is about last year's data. And that UP is rising from a very, very low base compared to others is an undeniable fact established with data to back it up. If anyone has any objection to this fact, they can raise it cordially. What's with calling others names, "idiot" and such?! Can't be civil in public, mate?
@@appukuttanj Brother Bihar ,up ,madhya pradesh , rajasthan were in chaos, invasions , lootings , rampant superstition , destruction of there agricultural economy and local industries by britishers etc and these land lock states have one side Pakistan and other china , bangladesh. After independence frieght subsidies from government snatched the opportunity to set-up factories in Bihar(chattisgarh) which was mineral rich state that time government did nothing to improve infrastructure of these region.
In last 20 years these states are showing improvement .
We have to learn from China to develop these states . Up and mp are showing improvement in industrialization and urbanization.
Northern states are the hands and legs of this country . These cheap labour had helped in the development of other states now cheap labour cost will be the boon for these states. 🙏🙏 Sorry for grammatical mistakes.
the people at the print are doing such a fine job of breaking down the data into such a compact 20 min video. it is aboslutely remarkable to see how the interent has changed media
Hi friends, I think UP is too big state to handle. Just look at the population of UP. Will breaking UP into 4 part can help?
If that happened than east UP will become another Bihar n west UP will become another Haryana with Islamist control.
@@MaheshPatel-zu6jp more Muslims live in east UP. Atleast get your data right.
@@तरबुज_खाने_वाला_राक्षस
Get your data correct. Check district wise .
phela uttarkhand ko divide kar diya kya aaj woh finaland ban gya
Thank god for Niti ayog.
They produce such great data.
Ideal replacement for planning commission, planning commission had become more like pay commission.
This data might be a christmas gift for Shekharji who"s always digging for data. 😃 excellent job NITI Ayog.
Dead bodies float in ganges, but still UP is No.1 as per northie media and UPyogi govt 😂😂😂
That was a fake news , there is a ritual in people living near ganga to bury dead bodies near the river coast and there is an article on that also in Dainik Jagran in 2018 , dead bodies were not because of covid but since the water level rose body started floating
@@aryankumarjha4274 such a lame excuse 😂😭
@@ajaybeast_7461 bhai lame excuse nhi h , literally articles h even 2015 ke v us buried dead bodies ki , mai deny nhi kr rha ki covid m death nhi huyi but Mai ye keh rha hu ki ganga m body wali fake news thi 🙏
Thanks alot sir😄i read about this in the newspaper today but couldn't understand it! Didn't give it a second read because I knew you'll be explaining this soon😅You are a savior 🙏
Hi Ratnesh. Do keep watching #CutTheClutter
Appreciate the class. We deserve it.
What a wasted episode. Instead of repeating the data on the graphs which I can see for myself, tell me the reasons why Delhi is behind or Kerala is ahead. And what steps need to be taken.
Uskeyyy liyee hiiii toh sarkar chunii jaati haii naa
Well it might be because of inflows from up and bihar...probably
Okay, so now you expect journalists to give you governance solution. That's real pathetic.
Sir, could you please dedicate some of your time to speak on the NEETPG 2021 counselling issue.
Thousands of candidates (doctors) including myself have cleared the exam, but the central government has been issuing apathetic one-sided decisions which has been delaying the counselling process for many months.
This could have a grace implication because there would be severe dearth of specialist doctors in the upcoming months. This could be disastrous to the Health system of India with the third wave looming large.
You could do a great benefit to the nation by giving the general population a deeper perspective to this topic.
In a nutshell it is like :- We lost the match but boys played well 😂😂
Pakistani motto! Isha allah boys played well
Really enjoy your episodes on NITI Aayog reports.
CutTheClutter makes statistics interesting
Happy to hear that, Prakash! Keep tuning in.
UP is last thanks to SP, BSP last 25 years of rule. It is now performing best improvements because of last 5 years of BJP. UP vl be completely transformed in next 10 years under BJP
@@tony-pc4kd what UP improved the most.
@@tony-pc4kd bro appreciate up state even im from developed state but i can see up improving in education health care infrastructure manufacturing but time lag jayega
This is a very important and interesting topic to discuss. Thanks Shekharji! Bring out more such objective analysis. If it's followed up by interviewing the health ministers of the poorly ranked States and listen what they have to say, would perhaps complete one loop.
"What you measure you can control". The very basis of Management.
Most government provided services such as power supply, waste management, health care, public transportation has hardly any monitoring and therefore no control on quality.
AP during C. NAIDU 2016 created a ERP system for government to have real time management of govt and exactly same would be possible for few states based on their e govenerance network capabilities. KERALA, Gujarat, could do that but in KERALA Govt employees resist and now wait for better bandwidth to have KFON, govt broadband network.
KERALA real time management would be more effective as instead of CM or PM, Local Self Governments, the panchayat Raj would be own most of Government establishment so they could manage better as like PHC etc.
Data analysis and explanation by Guptaji is something that adds greatly to this show. Great Job.
The worst of all is KARNATAKA. We have been going thru political squabbles for sometime now and our progress has suffered quite a bit in all spheres of governance. Only the label of IT capital for Bangalore holds but I feel even that is slipping away. The new label for KA "The UP of South India" is looking more and more apt as newer data comes in.
i think that bjp govt is more interested in changing chief minister's than governance , last time they had 3 chief ministers this time two up till now ,
but what worries me is why? just why ? is delhi doing not so well , at about 48%
score , it should be doing much beatter than haryana , is it politics ........
I have always noticed that Mr.Gupta spends the least amt of time talking about Maharashtra, even thou state is doing really well on many dimensions, irrespective of a political mess , it’s still going strong.
That's because it got Mumbai and Pune and money those cities generates , Kerala and Andhra Pradesh left with no big cities still doing wonderfully well , just FYI..Hyderabad was allocated to Telangana
@@Deveshi.A. Mumbai and Pune doesn't make up all of Maharashtra. Besides that every state has their metro cities banglore, Chennai, hyd etc. So you means these cities don't generate money?
@@Deveshi.A. Lol, what a silly excuse.
@@Deveshi.A. Other States don't have Metropolitan cities? This Index is based on indicators like NMR , U5MR ,Sex Ratio at Birth, Mortality rate, institutional births etc. How can 20% population in these cities affects rest?
Well, what's a surprise if Maharashtra is doing well, I mean isn't it expected?... Surprise would've been Maharashtra not doing well...
Great Analysis!!!
Any benchmark data available with world standard?
Communal harmony is lowest in Karnataka since BJP came into power 😞 and now this news about declining progress in healthcare made it even worse. They should work on real issue instead of passing shit law like Anti- conversion and all !!
Bro out of 44 , 32 Unicorn 🦄 is from banglore.
Karnataka is economy driven state.
Kerala is good in healthcare but highest Unemployment in state.
Data is from 2019-20 whereas congress was ruling from 2013-2019 mid and then this unstable gov came .....!! So data is mostly during upa period
Two Indians
People who come for jobs to south India
People who left india for jobs
As usual very knowledgeable CTC, bottom five states need a massive work.
Disappointed by Maharashtra. The state has pretty good administrative capacity and business model to improve healthcare but they are squandering it away in gundaraj. Maharashtra should have been around the 80s.
Telangana, Andhra and Maharashtra have got very *nice* marks, if you get my drift :D
Divide UP and Bihar
Its the only way forward
also
i actually suggest
divide
Rajasthan and MP too
" With Great Powers comes great responsibility "
but in the case of bimaru states its actually opposite
No
Affection No Love only scientifically proven Solution
I would agree, not only on utilitarian basis, but cultural as well. Bihar consists of two cultures, mithila and bhojpur. And let me tell you, the people from mithila aren't fond of being generalised with the bhojpuris. Up can also be divided into kosla, kashi and panchala
I think this data is creating a case of breaking up large states.
Creating more number of districts can also solve the problem, decentralization of power and little bit sub nationalism is needed in these state's only than they can develop
India should have 130 state's (1 crore population each) central government should give economic autonomy to state's, if any scheme get successful in one state than other will copy it
@@PP-mv2yk
Bihar, up, mp are more or less same in their identity makeup given that britishers created these states for administrative convenience and since then, they are like that only.
So, a subnationalism is very difficult to generate in these states.
Ever since people from these states were started getting ridicules then only they got some sense of their own native states.
What does deterioration in health score mean? Does it mean that growth in health infrastructure is not keeping pace with the growth in population?
Realised that such good quality discussions hardly ever happen on our regular news channels.
I think The Print should come out with a 'Daily News Bulletin', a video of maybe 15 to 30 minutes which talks of the relevant news of the day.
If that were to happen, many of us would be spared from news channels completely!
I'm maharashtrian staying in UP. The health care condition in UP is really horrible.
This was a great CTC but I got a bit lost in the numbers 😅
A suggestion: pls explain the significance & the meaning of these score when going from one state to another, otherwise it gets a bit messy :)
Thanks for the feedback, Shantanu.
Incredible Journalism....!
🙏🏻🙏🏻
Always excited analysis by you sir
Shekharji, it would be really wonderful if you could discuss the indicators as well..this will make us understand the analysis better.
This is brilliant. Many thanks for bringing this to us and making it so interesting and informative. We want to know why WB was left out :) Also could you possibly try a softer entry/exit music for CTC, at least for a limited time. Thanks again.
Hi Ginza. Thanks for writing in with your review.
Divide UP in 2 or 3 parts
It would be great if the actual parameters on which ranking was done could be shared...
North sucks😂
"You can prove anything with statistics, even the truth"
Will be interesting to add the actual religiousness & education (not literacy) of people of all the states and compare it with..
PS: IMHO BiMARU and hindi land is high on religiousness (bigotry, hatred), low on education is a reflection of their respective positions on various indicators
So there is no religious bigotry in southern states because there are no Hindus there and just temples like Tirupati Sabrimala Meenakshi temple or thousands of other important hindu temples. The fact of the matter is that leaders mostly in central Government used the people fir vote bank politics of divide and rule since independence. It is said that the seat to power at the centre is through UP. Incidentally both. UP and Bihar have a sizable ' progressive, open minded and then secular' muslim population perhaps not religious bigots like the Hindus according to you.
@@rajendrakumarduggar1835 wrong , the fact of the matter is the curse of casteism where majority of the people are made to feel inferior. In kerala that is very difficult. The majority are low castes but higher castes cannot rule like in north lndia. A great reason for this was the Hindu reform my movements led by Sree Narayan’s guru etc, the educational sector opened for the lower castes at least 200 years before. The strong communist movement protected the lower castes and helped them to be aggressive to demand equality. Also the missionaries played a stellar role . If all the above were not there kerala would have been worse than Bimaru. If you go 200 years back , it was hell for the backward castes. The Bhramns were ruling most ruthlessly and treating others like animals. Now that’s history and that’s why Bjp cannot step inside Kerala
@@sunilambat9982 tell me any big buisness house from kerala any starts up any unicorn any big university people from kerala move around country for higher education, and which central exam their student top from upsc, medical ,iitand iim and opportunities same as bihari and up ...only you people are good in mind washing youth and converting them into radical terrorist...
Atleast they are not vaccine hesitant and anti science 🙄
And. Not joining terrorist ranks like the best state🙄
Superb overview!
Tamil Nadu and Kerala have total 8 international airports. Very impressive.
Communism is an ideology that will survive in a place that is surrounded by non communist.
They concentrate on capacity building but gives up on development....less businesses and less job creation these literate people who couldn't find jobs will migrate to other countries...mostly the gulf(literacy doesn't mean highly qualified)....high demand for international flights and hence more number of international airports. More international airports isn't always impressive
@@MJ2.0 Gurajarthies are the highest number when it comes to migrating other countries, followed by panjabis and then keralities.
@@MJ2.0 Centre needs to take major initiatives in developing Kochi as a major international port city like Bombay. Bombay plays an incremental role in the big Maharashtra state's GDP. Kerala is not suited for industries, historically we've been merchants and our port cities were internationally famed, so if a city like Kochi was to be developed in a major scale it would heavily affect the economy in a good way. I believe this could drastically improve Kerala and reduce dependency on foreign remittances.
@UC6SrJBomaBz2fVAxw8wGTjw You misunderstood that. TN has 4 international airports, not just 4 airports overall. 4 international airports is more than enough for TN. Kerala has more airports for a smaller state because to cater to the 'gelf' exodus and expat economy.
@@vishalkrish6425 but if you focus on US immigrants, it's telugus followed by Gujaratis , AP and Telangana got highest number of migrants to US
KERALA REALLY HAS GOOD GOVT HEALTHCARE SYSTEM AND GOOD PRIVATE HOSPITALS AS WELL.. THEY NEVER SUFFERED FROM OXYGEN CRISIS LARGELY UNLIKE REST OF INDIA...
Small state with second highest in COVID throughout the pandemic only after Maharashtra.
@@rujuta4427 I think they are testing very well. If you compare with developed countries, all developed countries have very high numbers because they are testing well.
@Neil Bajwa oh shut up. see they will come to hospitals in karnataka due to extremely good private hospitals plus the distance factor.. only ppl from kasargod come there
@@rujuta4427 and the state with highest testing rate per million.. population density of kerala is 800 plus which is way higher than many states.. and kerala is the state with least under reporting of cases meanwile gujarat and up tops under reporting of covid stats
@Neil Bajwa and also mangalore hospitals are having more number of malayalee doctors
That smile we all share when we get our minds into some crunchy new Data. 😎
UP is at the top in logistics ranking. It has improved in health ranking. Yogiji is doing a great job and I hope he gets re-elected.
The reason behind ap and telangana, tamil nadu and Kerala are way ahead of rest of the nation is because of large expenditure on healthcare and programs that are implemented in these states are way better and ahead of ayushmaan bharat and these state uses ayishman bharat fund to use in state run health care exuberantly and yet these states very few of aiims and nationally recognized institutions they are well enough to go ahead of rest of the nation
I have been convinced about the non-hyphenated journalism of 'The Print' for some time. Now, you have convinced me to become a paid member as well with your quality and consistency. I hope 'The Print' becomes the much-needed revolution of the Indian media at least in the digital domain.
Thanks Arpan, appreciate your faith in our work. -Shekhar
Your closing remarks were the best!
KA has to come within top to make southern states proud.
I would say development, of any kind, must be commended. But we have a way to go
This shows what happens to people who only give a damn about their religion and caste above everything else...for these hindi heartland states to improve, their people's mindset must change..
U don't know about politics of india then.
Caste politics is a reality of all indian states but southern states got the benefit of being coastal states and certain govt. policies ensured non-availability of industrial facilities in hindi heartland for decades.
Things have started to changes in last 1 or 2 decades in these states.
@@kumarabhishek1064 Southern states have been ignored by central govts . If you win UP and Bihar or MP it’s enough to rule India . TN is Detroit of India inspite of central government backed Maruti Suzuki based in Manesar . South Indians value education ..All Nobel laureates in science of Indian origin are South Indians … let it be chess or anything the results speak for themselves. North Indians from the Hindi belt have a problem inspite of having a language language advantage ,water/ river advantage , politics advantage under perform
@@pradeepdj1
I would say the most neglected region is eastern India.
Just search freight equalisation policy then u will know wt discrimination was met out to eastern Region.
Jharkhand, chattisgarh, westbengal despite being mineral rich state couldn't get the benefit of industries because central govt. ensured same cost for industries all across India so they set up industries in coastal states only so that they could trade their product through sea routes easily without getting stuck in logistics.
Bihar, assam, eastern UP every year faces big loss due to floods and making agriculture along these flood plains a loss making job forcing smaller land owning people to move out as labourers.
Only in last 10-15 yrs, eastern states are catching up with the help of digitization and big ticket infra projects which was long due since independence.
Setting up bengaluru and hyderabad as IT hubs would not have been possible without center's help whereas no such cluster for eastern India.
Congress ruled southern states and hence favoured them and neglected eastern states since they were driven out of power post economic liberalisation in 1991.
That's how things have been.
@@pradeepdj1 That's not True. I'm all praise for the people of Southern states progress but few facts here are needed. All states are south are coastal states, and that gives them easy access to global trade route, so they obviously will be richer, it's same for every other country in the world. Just take US, both the East and West Coast states are much richer than continental states. Also, as far as government spending in concerned, yes on total basis North gets more fund than South, but on per capita basis Southern states receive more fund than North. Another thing owing to the coastal location, and also due to policies like freight equalisation, Southern states have gone much more investment in it's infrastructure and such than the northern states, not to mention none of the Southern states suffer from natural disasters as heavily as Northern States (or Eastern States) for that matter. So yes, while I do agree that all Southern states deserve praise for achieving this result, and surely the social reforms brought about by their own leaders have helped, but that is not all there is to it. It's both a combination of self-discipline and lot of lucky breaks.
@@kumarabhishek1064 I know that the caste is integral part of day to day life in southern states but they don't elect just random idiot who talks shit about other people. Also, can you pls explain how southern states got benefitted from being coastal states and which govt policies favored these states? It is heartland states who have more natural resources and have always been at the centre of the policies and voting power to elect govt. There is no excuse for the heartland states to remain under developed, other than people themselves.
We need parliament seats reforms. As AIM once said, "We are an apartheid state which gives more seats to rural than urban when our urban population is much more than rural now". We should divide seats among states not only based on population but on human development indexes too
That will deprive representation of poor states
UP has more populatiin than entire population of south India. Comparing Kerala of 3.5 crores, just breathing on foreign remittances , with UP is not fare.
But UP has opertunities, water,rivers,very fertile land, and proximity to Delhi. With in 25 years it will nu. 1
UP is as large as entire south india. So comparision is fair and logical
Opertunities.. ??! Time to install autocorrect in your keyboard
@@syogamurthy I am a chaiwala. I dont speak english
Love niti aayog for its reports
So it means if the TMC wins in Goa, it will not feature in the next survey.
WITHOUT A DOUBT NO 1
Going by this and the recently released poverty parameters, India seems to have a serious coronary condition😇
Is it possible to show the chart for a longer time and not change so often? It would help immensely to assimilate the data. Thank you.
NITI should conduct a parallel district wise assessments.
Hi Shiv
If there is any such data which is ever released you will find it on website with an insightful analysis. Keep tracking. -Shekhar
Sir, I would suggest that whenever you present such useful ananlysis based on data, you should begin with giving the criteria based on which these rankings have been determined and importantly, your view on whether you fully or partially agree with the criteria.
Very poor performance by karnataka. I assume the rankings are down because of north karnataka as coastal karnataka and mysore-Bangalore region are as good as kerala or TN.
The current govt here more or less sucks.
Andhrapradesh got rayalaseema ,,Maharastra got Vidharbha , Gujarath got Shourastra , Tamilnadu got dry areas , north Karnataka should not be the excuse , Bangalore spininng money from last 3 decades how long north Karnataka will be blame boy ,,something went really wrong in governance in karanataka
Kudos to Telangana for being at 69, nice
Is this the UP model which Yogi asked kerala to copy 🤣🤣🤣