I guess her son has some sort of illness where she could really use the money but can't be away from him for too long. It would be great to see her play again
thing is, her strategy wouldn't really fly anymore. she played the game when it was still being learned and everyone fell for the helpful girl in the kitchen lol. don't get me wrong, she was super smart but she would have to change her strategy drastically in order to survive
Imo Felicia and Tiffany are much bigger legends than Jag and Xavier. Even though they won, they are not nearly as big of characters, and not nearly as hilarious. Felicia and Tiffany are absolutely legends no doubt!!
Felicia isn’t necessarily a legend but she was def the most memorable of BB25. I don’t see anyone from that season achieving legend status. Tiffany I agree 100%!
Felicia is WAY too old, she’s got no shot at winning any comps so she basically a waste of a spot Either a goat to drag to the end or she might best Victoria’s record
Winners bring legacy, literally making them legends. Unfortunately Tiffany and Felicia don't have as much of a legacy as Jag and X, especially when you consider they're both first of their race/religion winners (Jag=Sikh, X=Black) which just adds to their legacy. Also Jag holds a record, which adds another layer of legacy (most comp wins)
Oh, hell, yes! It's been too long since we seen Mr. Pectacular. He got burned twice right? America's player and the coup detat? We absolutely need Jesse!
You picked Russell. You picked Kc over Tyler... YOU PICKED JAG INSTEAD AMERICA OR CORY, MATTS A BETTER PICK. Peridiam I love you, but I'm so happy you aren't the board at CBS.
Also, hard agree on casting BB16 Derrick but NOT anybody else from his season. I always hate it when BB casts multiple BB16 people together just so they can team up and dictate the narrative of the season. If Derrick wants to be the best of the best, make him play with different completely different people. 😈
Please, no more Jag. My God. We've seen him in almost every position possible, and aside from the first few weeks, he was an incredibly meek and unexciting player. The same is true for Kaycee. Also, no more competition beasts. Either everyone should be a comp beast, or nobody should be. I can imagine Jag and Kaycee just owning the entire endgame of this season and that would be an absolute nightmare scenario. Lmao
I understand why you wouldn't include Kaysar but I would want to see him on a Legends season because I want to see him make jury for the first time on a Legends season, or he makes that "not making jury" record even more unbreakable.
I’d put him in a Legends season on the condition Janelle is not on the cast with him because in all three of his seasons he’s never played BB without Janelle in the house as well. I’d like to see how he fares without her and see whether or not he can make the right connections to take him further into the game.
@@AshRektum He did have that one amazing veto competition! Plus, he’s the only person anybody remember from season one minus the Eddie Jay cause he won!
I know Russell is a hot take as a player, but I loved him on BB11, and he was my personal favorite from that season. I wish he had been brought back just once. Him calling out Jeff's homophobia gave him my respect. He's kind of a WTF pick, but since there's no Evil Dick, Russell would be a great person for drama. He knows how to fight, and he's an expert at pushing peoples buttons.
My list for a hypothetical Legends season using the same criteria as Peridiam: -Will Kirby -Danielle Reyes -Jun Song -Eric Stein -Dan Gheesling -Daniele Briones -Hayden Moss -Britney Haynes -Andy Herren -Derrick Levasseur -Vanessa Rousso -Tyler Crispen -Taylor Hale -Tiffany Mitchell -Derek X
@@Edge439 yeah, I admittedly didn’t really do this as true “Legends” as much as I just picked the people I most wanted to see again lol. If I took the “Legends” label super seriously then Dick and Janelle would be there instead of Dani & Eric. Rachel and Jeff (as much as I dislike him, he’s undoubtedly a legend to the casual fanbase) would be there over Hayden & Andy. Vanessa and Tyler would be out and Paul & Nicole would be there instead. And Tiffany & Derek would be replaced by Xavier and Jag. But I don’t like that cast lol. So I picked who I wanted moreso. And while I like Janelle, I haven’t loved her on the show since BB7 and I’ve seen her enough.
As a fellow Jacob, I'd just like to point out that between Survivor and Big Brother there have only been two Jacobs between those shows, and they both flamed out spectacularly.
Do a video about Janelle's phenomenon. I just finished BB7 and she was insanely beloved, I never saw something like that except for Juliette in Big Brother Brasil.
Have you thought about making a fictional All-Star Big Brother season using BrantSteele? Takes a little bit to set up but I think it would be a fun long video to watch
I just want to say Reindeer Games is one of my top favorite Reality Seasons ever. It was incredible to see who won and the villains were Cookout 2 and this time the person who worked it until she won it against two of the nastiest bigtime gameplayers ever. The begging for her life by Britney not to be put into a challenge was one of the most crazy grim things I have ever seen. Also Reindeer Games innovated Big Brother in many impactful ways I am hoping CBS notices. Challenge Design was vastly improved with many different types of challenges, it finally experimented with trivia for example. I enjoyed the Coaches idea and the ways some challenges were super skillful and needed both brains and brawn, like that one heavy pieces challenge and went down to literally 8 seconds difference really tested the players. It was still always done in a way where both women and men could win. I hope to see the next BB season takes the lessons learned from Reindeer Games and runs with them.
ZACH RANCE IS A LEGENDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD PLEASE HE IS SUCH AN ICON OML. No joke, my friends know nothing about BB but they know Zach Rance lol
I like how he picked Jag as one of legend picks, and then immediately followed him up with the guy who conceptualized the Backdoor plan - you know, the biggest hurdle for competitors like Jag. Hmm... Can't imagine what could happen, between those two. 🤔
I appreciate that you recognize that the best option would be to just bring back BB7 and let them play again. Because when I saw this video that was my only thought. It honestly is the only thing that would bring me back to BB
He may not excite people, but id be adding Cody. The man never got evicted, won an allstar season and runner up to Derrick. To think we had a stretch of Derrick / Vanessa / Paul, would have loved them in that all star. Would definitely have made it far more exciting than it was.
The Janelle, Britney, and Rachel alliance would be the most successful women’s alliance of all time. It would be legendary to say the least. Derrick wouldn’t last long with these three aligned.
I'd literally rather put Cameron on a legends season than Paul. Paul was nothing if it weren't for production pushing for Paul to win & using Cameron as that first stepping stone.
The hating on Jag is wild tbh. Yeah his winning game isnt the best, its below average for a winner, but calling him a non-legend? Just mindless tbh. Jag is a winner, the first Sikh winner, and the single season comp record holder. Thats 3 seperate statutes of legacy that, unlike a lot of other legacy points, are objectively true. Then you can add on other things, such as having one of the more dominant single weeks ever (his secret HOH week where he took out CAmerica whilst guaranteeing everyone else has him in their best graces and then won HOH the next week, literally having more than 100% control for 2 weeks) The disrespect needs to stop
My BB Legends Cast would look like this: Dr Will, Daniele, Alisson Janelle, Dani Donato, Dan Jessie, Rachel, Britney Amanda, Andy, Derrick Vanessa, Paul, Nicole F. Josh, Davonne, Taylor, Michael
Dude she played AWFUL all 3 times she played. Getting eliminated second her first season and then getting played TWICE by Nicole, that’s horrible gameplay.
The lack of Jessie Godderz, despite being a mainstay cameo on the show AND the most screwed player of BB history (2 seasons, two “America’s interference” eliminations) is concerning.
People can talk down on Jag all they want, but he did what nobody else has done and that simply makes people mad. I'm just sick of people talking down on him like he's a bad person, people called him a bully but he was just real.
He wanted to psychlogically mess with Felicia and cirie. Kinda rich from someone who made a big deal about playing with honor and integrity, and being one of the "good" people in the house ( the mafia weren't)
I think Russell is a great pick I’m actually shocked we’ve never seen him back, he’s great tv & such a great villain Some other really great people I’d love to see back are Jonny Mack, Brett, Jessica, Felicia, Derek X, Holly (I’ve always liked her for some reason) Sharon (massively screwed over)
While Season 22 was a crappy all star season I look at it like this. Was during the middle of the pandemic and they got whatever alumni that was willing to do it for the money they were offering
fun that we're far enough away from BB22 that we can enjoy fantasizing about another all star season like we used to
👀👀👀
they're gonna make sure they get things right before they do it again. we're definitely not getting another until at least BB30
Part of me wants Zach ngl. Fruit Loop Dingus lives in my head rent free
He’d be great, but CBS will never let him play again.
Same here.
@@olivermensinger6022if Survivor is willing to look at Russell Hantz for Survivor 50, I think they can overlook Zach’s antics.
@@olivermensinger6022 He got the call for all stars but declined it. Can we get fruit looped dingus on the Traitors?
@@olivermensinger6022 Why?
Here so early that Julie hasn’t even had the chance to say “BUT FIRST”
damn that's early
Damn, just like the twists in the BB17 premiere.
I believe Jun has said she wants to play again too!
yeah, ive also heard that she was asked to be on the second all stars but that might've been a rumor..
Yes! If you watch the exclusive with sharon, she interviews june and she said she'd come back in a shortened season.
I guess her son has some sort of illness where she could really use the money but can't be away from him for too long. It would be great to see her play again
thing is, her strategy wouldn't really fly anymore. she played the game when it was still being learned and everyone fell for the helpful girl in the kitchen lol. don't get me wrong, she was super smart but she would have to change her strategy drastically in order to survive
@@carm700 that's what it was!!!
Janelle also held the comp win record when there weren’t nearly as many comps as there is now
I would’ve done Michael over Jag, but otherwise great list!
The jag sneak is crazy
up until bowie jane: no sneaks
after bowie got cut: one sneak
Imo Felicia and Tiffany are much bigger legends than Jag and Xavier. Even though they won, they are not nearly as big of characters, and not nearly as hilarious. Felicia and Tiffany are absolutely legends no doubt!!
Tiffany, absolutely, Felicia, no thanks. I would love to see an alliance of tiff and Daniele reyes
Felicia isn’t necessarily a legend but she was def the most memorable of BB25. I don’t see anyone from that season achieving legend status. Tiffany I agree 100%!
Felicia is WAY too old, she’s got no shot at winning any comps so she basically a waste of a spot
Either a goat to drag to the end or she might best Victoria’s record
Felicia, like Renie, was iconic. But she is dead weight in an all-star cast with many winners included.
Winners bring legacy, literally making them legends. Unfortunately Tiffany and Felicia don't have as much of a legacy as Jag and X, especially when you consider they're both first of their race/religion winners (Jag=Sikh, X=Black) which just adds to their legacy. Also Jag holds a record, which adds another layer of legacy (most comp wins)
Mr. Pectacular was one his way to winning until production stepped in. Jesse for Legends! Make it right!
He would be most random three time player ever!
Oh, hell, yes! It's been too long since we seen Mr. Pectacular. He got burned twice right? America's player and the coup detat? We absolutely need Jesse!
I'm sorry, but I honestly think it would be super funny if Mr. Spectacular played again only to get screwed over by yet ANOTHER twist. XD
Well we at least will get him for House of Villains 2. Hopefully he did well.
I need Dan vs Will vs Derrick. I don’t want them to team up. We need good strategy and drama.
Peridiam please never pull that bowie jane prank again
Jag wasn’t a much better choice
No Franzel is crazyyyyyy
Agree franzel is a legend. I believe she said reindeer games was her last time on reality tv unless production convinces her to come back.
I think it's very fair to say we've seen enough of her. Janelle is a different story because her run on 14 wasn't very long.
He mentioned he was trying to avoid as many BB22 as he could but she would be on the shortlist for sure
You picked Russell. You picked Kc over Tyler... YOU PICKED JAG INSTEAD AMERICA OR CORY, MATTS A BETTER PICK. Peridiam I love you, but I'm so happy you aren't the board at CBS.
I don't mind the russel pick personally you want some villans. But America, Cory, Felicia or hisam would be better picks for legends than Jag
@@SeanMcD-gn2cl or even just Cirie. Id take so many more people than Jag
You can’t swap Kaycee for Tyler because Kaycee fills a female spot (every cast is 50/50).
@@infinityquartz4744 yeah cirie would be better pick, I just didn't include her because I don't know if she would play again
@@theunitedkingdom Swap KC for America. Swap Russell for Tyler. I'm not having KC again. She's gonna form something with someone and just comp beast.
Great video Peridiam, you nailed like every pick. The Bowie Jane fake and Jacob bit were hilarious
Also, hard agree on casting BB16 Derrick but NOT anybody else from his season. I always hate it when BB casts multiple BB16 people together just so they can team up and dictate the narrative of the season. If Derrick wants to be the best of the best, make him play with different completely different people. 😈
He already is the best of the best lol
Not the Jag Glaze
i think andy deserves a spot 100% i would love to see him again
A world where paul got second place a third time would be crazy
Please, no more Jag. My God. We've seen him in almost every position possible, and aside from the first few weeks, he was an incredibly meek and unexciting player. The same is true for Kaycee. Also, no more competition beasts. Either everyone should be a comp beast, or nobody should be. I can imagine Jag and Kaycee just owning the entire endgame of this season and that would be an absolute nightmare scenario. Lmao
I understand why you wouldn't include Kaysar but I would want to see him on a Legends season because I want to see him make jury for the first time on a Legends season, or he makes that "not making jury" record even more unbreakable.
I’d put him in a Legends season on the condition Janelle is not on the cast with him because in all three of his seasons he’s never played BB without Janelle in the house as well. I’d like to see how he fares without her and see whether or not he can make the right connections to take him further into the game.
2:35 Chicken George. I mean he should play one last time.
nonono I love george but lol he was just awful at everything
@@AshRektum He did have that one amazing veto competition! Plus, he’s the only person anybody remember from season one minus the Eddie Jay cause he won!
Raven Walton would win yup
she is a mastermind after all
Can't have a legends season with Raven! She's one of the greatest contestants ever! 🤣
8:31 Yes. I would love to see him come back.
I know Russell is a hot take as a player, but I loved him on BB11, and he was my personal favorite from that season. I wish he had been brought back just once. Him calling out Jeff's homophobia gave him my respect. He's kind of a WTF pick, but since there's no Evil Dick, Russell would be a great person for drama. He knows how to fight, and he's an expert at pushing peoples buttons.
Love the Marvin add at the end!
Marvin deserves to return so badly.
That would be an epic season!
That Bowie Jane line had me cackling lmfao
AMAZING Casting! CBS take notes!! I needa see Taylor Hale again and Dan! Wow so good. Also I would give anything to see Vanessa and Jun play again.
My list for a hypothetical Legends season using the same criteria as Peridiam:
-Will Kirby
-Danielle Reyes
-Jun Song
-Eric Stein
-Dan Gheesling
-Daniele Briones
-Hayden Moss
-Britney Haynes
-Andy Herren
-Derrick Levasseur
-Vanessa Rousso
-Tyler Crispen
-Taylor Hale
-Tiffany Mitchell
-Derek X
Not having the face of big brother (Janelle) is crazy
@@Edge439 yeah, I admittedly didn’t really do this as true “Legends” as much as I just picked the people I most wanted to see again lol.
If I took the “Legends” label super seriously then Dick and Janelle would be there instead of Dani & Eric. Rachel and Jeff (as much as I dislike him, he’s undoubtedly a legend to the casual fanbase) would be there over Hayden & Andy. Vanessa and Tyler would be out and Paul & Nicole would be there instead. And Tiffany & Derek would be replaced by Xavier and Jag.
But I don’t like that cast lol. So I picked who I wanted moreso. And while I like Janelle, I haven’t loved her on the show since BB7 and I’ve seen her enough.
another season with jag.... i dont think i can handle that tbh
yea i wouldn’t wanna watch
As a fellow Jacob, I'd just like to point out that between Survivor and Big Brother there have only been two Jacobs between those shows, and they both flamed out spectacularly.
Do a video about Janelle's phenomenon. I just finished BB7 and she was insanely beloved, I never saw something like that except for Juliette in Big Brother Brasil.
I’d love nothing more than Paul coming back and getting second place 😂
such a good cast ngl
MICHAEL!!!!! ❤ favorite player ever!!!! (S 24)
Amazing cast, make it happen CBS
New Peridiam vid? We eating good tonight 😳
I think Blue Kim is an underrated legend the way she used the cameras to play to the public and stuff was iconic!
Have you thought about making a fictional All-Star Big Brother season using BrantSteele? Takes a little bit to set up but I think it would be a fun long video to watch
at the end the rules ran away faster than nick ran away from ginamarie
Wow I’m so glad you put Russel on this list… he was such an incredible player! Andy needs a spot as well 🙊
Glad to see Andy included even if it’s just at the end, he’s a top 4 winner ever imo
My mouth dropped at your BB25 pick hahaha
I just want to say Reindeer Games is one of my top favorite Reality Seasons ever. It was incredible to see who won and the villains were Cookout 2 and this time the person who worked it until she won it against two of the nastiest bigtime gameplayers ever. The begging for her life by Britney not to be put into a challenge was one of the most crazy grim things I have ever seen.
Also Reindeer Games innovated Big Brother in many impactful ways I am hoping CBS notices. Challenge Design was vastly improved with many different types of challenges, it finally experimented with trivia for example. I enjoyed the Coaches idea and the ways some challenges were super skillful and needed both brains and brawn, like that one heavy pieces challenge and went down to literally 8 seconds difference really tested the players. It was still always done in a way where both women and men could win.
I hope to see the next BB season takes the lessons learned from Reindeer Games and runs with them.
This season would’ve been so much better if Kaycee and Josh were there over Kesha and Memphis
I love the big brother content 🙌🙌
ZACH RANCE IS A LEGENDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD PLEASE HE IS SUCH AN ICON OML. No joke, my friends know nothing about BB but they know Zach Rance lol
You pissed me off with that Russell pick I can’t lie bestie
I like how he picked Jag as one of legend picks, and then immediately followed him up with the guy who conceptualized the Backdoor plan - you know, the biggest hurdle for competitors like Jag.
Hmm... Can't imagine what could happen, between those two. 🤔
Only for Jag to immediate come back in. *Imagine* the look on Marvin's face.
A Legends Season would be my dream! Here’s to dreaming!
BB16-BB20 could easily have 6 people in the legends house
I would watch the hell out of this! Easily the makings of the best season ever!!!
The Russell Pick is amazing
Day is missing from this list, and justice for Andy
I appreciate that you recognize that the best option would be to just bring back BB7 and let them play again. Because when I saw this video that was my only thought. It honestly is the only thing that would bring me back to BB
They need to make this now omg
Ooh, could you make a video on a theoretical Big Brother: Game Changers cast?
Franzel deserves this
He may not excite people, but id be adding Cody. The man never got evicted, won an allstar season and runner up to Derrick. To think we had a stretch of Derrick / Vanessa / Paul, would have loved them in that all star. Would definitely have made it far more exciting than it was.
Solid
Jag would not last in a legend season lmao
sheila from bb9 is so underrated
The Janelle, Britney, and Rachel alliance would be the most successful women’s alliance of all time. It would be legendary to say the least. Derrick wouldn’t last long with these three aligned.
When you said less than 100 days, I was with you; then you said Jag…ew.
jag deserved his win
@@mymaynee5963probably the worst winner of all time. Him or evil dick
@@mymaynee5963 He was awful television. Idk who wins what, if it’s not fun to watch, I don’t want to see them back.
no sound for me wtf xD
Yes Andy~
I'd literally rather put Cameron on a legends season than Paul. Paul was nothing if it weren't for production pushing for Paul to win & using Cameron as that first stepping stone.
I would love this cast! Except Jag. You aren’t a legend when the twists hand you a win.
Should’ve thrown America in from last season instead of Kacey. Then a perfect cast
The hating on Jag is wild tbh. Yeah his winning game isnt the best, its below average for a winner, but calling him a non-legend? Just mindless tbh. Jag is a winner, the first Sikh winner, and the single season comp record holder. Thats 3 seperate statutes of legacy that, unlike a lot of other legacy points, are objectively true. Then you can add on other things, such as having one of the more dominant single weeks ever (his secret HOH week where he took out CAmerica whilst guaranteeing everyone else has him in their best graces and then won HOH the next week, literally having more than 100% control for 2 weeks)
The disrespect needs to stop
I would love to see Frankie and Michael as well!
Skipping Andy and Ian was crazy
My BB Legends Cast would look like this:
Dr Will, Daniele, Alisson
Janelle, Dani Donato, Dan
Jessie, Rachel, Britney
Amanda, Andy, Derrick
Vanessa, Paul, Nicole F.
Josh, Davonne, Taylor, Michael
RIP BBCan 😭
Agreed. Hopefully they start bringing in Canadians like survivor. Give me a legends season and include Kevin Jacobs.
I know it’s so weird to me that BBCan acknowledges the other BB franchises but BBus pretends like they’re the only one
you lost me at Jag
Jag is a massive no from me
No Baller lol. He went through quite a transformation
I was hoping your list would be more interesting. This is just the run of the mill legends cast draft that people have made countless time.
Problem is a short legends season can’t have 18 people lol
Taking Tyler over Paul for sure, but I’d also love to see Zach rance back in the house even though it’ll probably never happen
Switch out Russell for Josh and I'm so all in.
I would have picked the exact same group with the exception of Russell. Great list!Bring it on! Thanks for skipping 15and 21.
NO DAVONNE….foul
she wouldnt come back
She said she would never play again
Legend ?
Ya...she's not a legend barely made jury
Dude she played AWFUL all 3 times she played. Getting eliminated second her first season and then getting played TWICE by Nicole, that’s horrible gameplay.
The lack of Jessie Godderz, despite being a mainstay cameo on the show AND the most screwed player of BB history (2 seasons, two “America’s interference” eliminations) is concerning.
🐐🐐🐐🐐
God I want Eric to play again so bad
Thank you for including Paul
People can talk down on Jag all they want, but he did what nobody else has done and that simply makes people mad. I'm just sick of people talking down on him like he's a bad person, people called him a bully but he was just real.
He wanted to psychlogically mess with Felicia and cirie. Kinda rich from someone who made a big deal about playing with honor and integrity, and being one of the "good" people in the house ( the mafia weren't)
I think Russell is a great pick I’m actually shocked we’ve never seen him back, he’s great tv & such a great villain
Some other really great people I’d love to see back are Jonny Mack, Brett, Jessica, Felicia, Derek X, Holly (I’ve always liked her for some reason) Sharon (massively screwed over)
Davonne > Kaycee and Michael > Jag and I’ll take it
Dani isnt even a consideration? Id put Nakomis in there as well because they had to change the way Veto is played because of her.
Sheila from BB9 needs to come back. I’d love to see Renny or Libra from BB10, Felicia from BB25
A legends season? Peridiam bb19 already happened
jag doesn't deserve to come back
Swap out Jag, put in Cameron.
My cast :
Dr. Will Kirby (S2)
Danielle Reyes (S3)
Jun Song (S4)
Janelle Pierzina (S6)
Kaysar Ridha (S6)
Dan Gheesling (S10)
Rachel Reilly (S12)
Britney Haynes (S12)
Andy Herren (S15)
Zach Rance (S16)
Nicole Franzel (S16)
Derrick Laveuseur (S16)
Derek Xiao (S23)
Tiffany (S23)
Taylor Hale (S24)
3 ADDITIONAL PICKS : Mike Boogie (S2), Frankie Grande (S16) & Da'vonne Rogers (S17)
Crazy how bb16-20 produced so many awesome legend potential. Snubbed josh tho
Unironic clear choice from BB9 is Sheila!!
While Season 22 was a crappy all star season I look at it like this. Was during the middle of the pandemic and they got whatever alumni that was willing to do it for the money they were offering