👟 Embrace Summer cool splash with Vessi! Discover comfort and versatility at vessi.com/rockstars for an instant 15% off your first order upon checkout!
I don't think Vernestra tortured Qimir, I think those scars are from a fight they had after Qimir turned to the dark side, and Vernestra thought he was dead until he sensed him in this episode.
Totally agree, and yesterdays episode he states the same. WHIP = TORTURE? small minded thinking and funny he put more emphasis on it tonight, after I commented about it being attack scars
This makes the most sense. The writers like making direct comparisons to lore we already know, and it seems like a parallel to the outcome of the battle between Obi-Wan and Anakin right after his turn to the dark side. Obi-Wan "scarred" Vader in self-defense, reluctantly left him for dead, but was later surprised to learn he was still alive.
THANK YOU!!! This is why I take very few of these angry tirades seriously from "fans" now. They complain over the most minute things that aren't even an issue. Owen and Solo have referenced *hell*, but it's such an issue now?
@@alexanderthegreat5649 Exactly. There are countless cultures throughout the Galaxy Far, Far Away and probably countless cultures that have concepts of hell to the point where the idea has spread as a metaphor for many, the way it is for us.
Although Han Solo did refer to HELL in ESB, Uncle Owen first referred to HELL in ANH when he was talking to Aunt Beru about what would happen if Luke didn't have the droids out and working soon ".......or there will be HELL to pay".
Can we all agree that Basil is a little s**t? xD First he completely abandons everyone while tracking May in the forest, then offers 0 help during the fight and just leaves. Then proceeds to sabotage everything the jedi are doing. Get this little gremlin away form everyone xD
Qimir uses the force to fly. the same way he floated down like a vampire during his "Day" entrance. Thats how he was able to get into the Witches strong hold with out the use of the elevator.
What I love about your channel is that you're not judgemental, you just break down facts and let people enjoy without fear of listening to more hatred towards these big shows that have received so much attention lately. This is a haven for us nerds to just have a good time when consuming fantasy/sci-fi. Kudos, sir.
I always thought the "See you in Hell" line from Empire was funny. I just imagined the reaction of the other dude. "Huh? What did I do to deserve Hell???"
Why always assuming that Qimir's scars are from whip torture and not just a battle? That's like looking at Vader and assuming that Anakin was drawn and quartered by Kenobi.
It may be that they assume so because a lot of this series it showing that the Jedi aren't really the good guys. I agree that it's likely just a combat wound but it does fit the overall theme of the series.
I don't feel like Qimir's actually trained by the Sith and is most likely unassociated w/ Plagieus. His actions feel more akin to General Grevious in that he relies on the element of surprise, fear, and some form of deception (for Grevious, it's just the fact he wields 4 lightsabers). When Qimir fought the jedi squad, he relied on his cortosis helmet to short circuit and confuse some of his opponents and then defeated Jecki w/ the reveal of the 2nd blade. When he was out of tricks, Sol confidently slammed him twice I could be horribly discounting Sol but it rly feels like Qimir's inferiority to Sol is is supposed to suggest this. He may have called himself sith bcuz he equated using the dark side as being a sith and felt he could adopt the title because he assumed all the sith were long dead. In comparison, other sith we've seen like Maul and Dooku are incredibly composed and adept duelists gaining the upperhand on every jedi except Anakin in rots. In most cases, Sith usually have the upperhand in duels only to lose it because of carelessness like how Kenobi usually wins and how Ahsoka defeated Maul. Although an alternative is that Sol is incredibly strong and I shouldn't discount his strength
Makes sense. I think Qimir is the canonization of Venamis, but I don't think we will hear his name because they've established in Canon only 2 siths can be lords, everyone else has been an assassin like Ventress or Savage or an inquisitor but not given a sith name. I feel like this makes his words "I don't have a name, but a Jedi like you may call me sith" less vague, and an almost literal explanation of what he is. Can't help but think his mouth and teeth on his helmet are meant to symbolize something, and I feel like they look Venamis and a friend of mine pointed out that it almost looks like Venom himself in his opinion. It's probably horribly wrong, but it just makes sense to me.
@@jacobmerritt2518well wasn't it the whole point that Venamis was breaking the rule of two by being Tenebrous' apprentice at the same time as Plagueis? Besides the rule of two hasn't really ever been followed in canon or in legends.
@@elpenguinoofmexico1388 you forgetting the fact he force pushed all the jedi away? And killed majority of them. On top of invading their minds with visions. He didn’t look phased when seeing the force choke/the corruption of the kyber crystal or when Sol was talking about how the Mae/Osha were created through the force and talks about the way of the sith with Mae multiple times. He’s either partially trained by the sith (an current or old sith acolyte or apprentice) or went through extensive training with Vernestra and him embracing the darkside has made him much stronger but wouldn’t explain his other capabilities. E.g mind corruption/the ability to fly / levitate
Was it ever stated that Qimir was a child when he got those scars? We don’t know what happened in the events he got those scars. It’s an assumption it was torture. He could have done something to deserve it. He did just recently kill a bunch of innocent Jedi.
Agree. Way more likely it was self defense or an accident than torture. And the way the writing tends to go these days, Qimir misinterpreted something that fueled some immature anger and doomed him for life.
Isn't it inconsistent for it to be believed Sol committed all 4 murders? He was on Coruscant teaching younglings when Indara was killed and plenty of Jedi had their eyes on him as Torbin was killed.
Sure, and that question might get raised at some point. The story isn’t over. But if the senate was also happy to accept the face value lie as an excuse not to have to dig too deeply, that’s also something that can work.
One of the most amazing things in the fight scene between Sol and Qimir was the force cancelation that Sol performed. I had to rewind that a couple of times.
I didn't notice the first time I watched, but Sol used Trakata. He turned his saber off right before it hit Qimir's helmet, then he reignited it and slashed his saber in half.
@bradleyduke4503 Jedi see it as dishonorable, while Sith see it as cowardly. In this instance though I don't think he had much choice as the alternative was bonking Qimir on the head and losing access to his saber in a crucial moment and leaving Qinir with 2.
One detail I haven’t seen anyone mention: when Sol disarms that shorter lightsaber from Qimir, Qimir goes to force pull it back to his hand but Sol seems to “cut” the force pull with his lightsaber
Yeah, but he wasn't exactly a jedi, i mean he wasn't following all the rules... He was emotional, attached and even love the kid as a father, so a bit of the dark side was on him.
I love this channel so much! I know i can watch details being explained without the "disney ruined star wars" rant. Thank you so much to the team that bleed hours into this analysis!
Just a wild speculation, but what if they're toying with the idea that Darth Sidious has been cloning himself longer than we thought, or maybe he is older than we imagined. When he was fighting Mace Windu, he looked like had aged like 200 years. We'll see.
I never thought about it that way, maybe you're onto something there. Instead of Sidious becoming disfigured by Mace Windu reflecting the force lightning back at him, what if that was his true appearance and it just deactivated some form of "force disguise" thing he had going on? Then he was like, no need to hide it any more. It's a fun fan theory anyway.
I really enjoyed The Acolyte and consider it one of the better Disney+ live action shows. I did notice Sen Rayencourt's medallion and it looks similiar to Maul's medallion in Solo. Could Sen. Rayencourt be working for a syndicate? Reardless of Qimir's relationship to Plagueous, I believe Aimir anf Osha are going to be spun by The Jedi as fallen Jedi that turned to the dark side with no links to the Sith.
@@Xeta_ why? they left things open for a season 2 , we know osha is the acolyte , qimir is suspected as being venestras ex padawan. the only things we are unsure of is plageuis
The blocks in the water look to be more of an erosion barrier than ruins. You them a lot in parts of the East Coast of the US protecting the inhabited coasts from further erosion.
what if qimir is darth venamis, the illegitimate sith apprentice tenebrous trained parallel to plagueis in violation of the rule of two? tenebrous kind of manipulated them to kill each other and plagueis did end up killing him in bal´demnic, and found out that venamis was looking for an apprentice before that
15:10 Occam’s razor. If it *is* Ian’s voice, it could have just been a nod as a little cameo. It *could* be a relative to Palpatine. I think the former is more likely, but I really don’t think it’s anything to dig too deep into
Those aren't necessarily carved blocks on the mystery planet. Rocks often form large crystals or fracture along planes giving the illusion of being shaped or carved. See, for instance, the Devil's Postpile.
I’d love to be a Jedi but he’s 100% right. 😂 you can do what the Jedi do while also having emotions. And cutting that off will lead some to the dark side or becoming a grey Jedi.
Luke Skywalker i believe in Legends was Jedi who believed in emotions. Maybe not decisions based in emotions but compassion and such are still emotions
It seems we are getting more into the flaws of Jedi. We have seen Masters hint at letting go of attachments (emotions?) to be in control of one self. I think what is shown is the more we believe in what we do, the less likely we will have "control" in our actions.
Those "columns" are an ancient lava flow; in this case, basalt, that slowly cooled as an undisturbed mass. The geometric columns occur as the rock cools and solidifies slowly and are eventually exposed to the elements when softer rocks around them are eroded away. The columns on the ground are the upper sections of the formation that tumbled away from the rest due to erosion or earth movement. The geometric surface they were walking on are columns whose tops are all that is exposed. There are a few such formations along the coast of the British isles and similar ones can be found in Yellowstone in Wyoming, Devil's Postpile in North Eastern California and even in San Diego County, made out of another volcanic rock.
A theory I had over the weekend: Tenebrous trained Qimir. Plagueis had no knowledge of this but somehow found out. That is why he was spying on them, lurking in the shadows.
How would anakins lightsaber stay blue as he slaughtered a whole tribe of tusken raiders, or killing younglings, or battling obi wan. Hasn't it always been a conscious effort and decision to bleed a crystal, since the crystal fights against being bled/bleached?
My theory would be that Anakin was not fully turned yet. The killing of the tusken raiders was a temporary fall, and the younglings were killed out of desperation, trying in his mistaken way to save Padme. It's not until he is fully Darth that he gives in fully to the dark and intentionally bleeds his crystal.
Hel - if Skol and Hati made it then Hel, being a cold place where snowballs have more of a chance than we would think these days, is a perfect place to find a Tauntaun
Totally confusing. Also he/they 😅 should know that Sol did not kill the other Jedi. He should have been around while Mae (which he wanted to kill the scene before)was evil.. it is poor writing
I could be wrong but I’m pretty sure in one of the wider shots of the planet osha and qimir are on the shoe island from the last jedi can be seen in the background, potentially confirming that this planet and ach to are one and the same
I think Ravencourt is connected with the Sith. He knows too much about the Jedi and their faults. It would be some symmetry to how Palpatine comes to power through the Senate. It would make sense if Plageus was training Qimir at some point to over throw his Master. But he just seems to want to do his own thing with some company. Not necessarily take out the Jedi, as long as they don’t get in his way.
I don't think the scar on Qimir's back is supposed to indicate that Vernestra tortured him, but had tried to kill him when he fell to the Dark Side, hence Vernestra's surprise at sensing his presence.
I wanna do a poll real quick. Would you rather: 1. Plagueis learns how to create life from the witches Or 2. Plagueis taught the witches how to create life
2. But I don’t think he gave them the full recipe, hence the one person split into twins. He feared having one being would be too powerful. So he divided the power between two beings.
What do you mean... sure Yoda doesn't say anything when Ki-Adi-Mundi says the Sith have been extinct a thousand years, but not long after when talking to Mace, he reveals he knows about the rule of two, which was put into place AFTER the jedi thought the sith defeated, meaning he knows that the sith have been active after Ki-Adi-Mundi thinks they were extinct, and not only that knows something of how they operate.
@@KardiacKid45 it was put in place a 1000 years before by the survivor of the war where Jedi thought the Sith had been wiped out... thus Ki-Adi Mundi's saying they had been extinct a thousand years... if the Sith had truly not been seen by the Jedi in that thousand years, then there is no way Yoda or any other Jedi could possibly have known about the rule of 2.
I stand by that Sol did do the right thing with the information he had available to him at the time. Mae literally told him they were going to be sacrificed, why would he not think he did the right thing?
👟 Embrace Summer cool splash with Vessi! Discover comfort and versatility at vessi.com/rockstars for an instant 15% off your first order upon checkout!
@@NewRockstars making fun of Asoka now after hyping it up huh 😭
Them gift bags you were given must of had gold in them
No joke every time you talk about this show,I report the video for promoting terrorism,if I could claim on the videos I would. Have some class
I don't think Vernestra tortured Qimir, I think those scars are from a fight they had after Qimir turned to the dark side, and Vernestra thought he was dead until he sensed him in this episode.
🎯🎯🎯😎
Totally agree, and yesterdays episode he states the same. WHIP = TORTURE? small minded thinking and funny he put more emphasis on it tonight, after I commented about it being attack scars
yeah, jumping straight to torture is a huge stretch.
My thoughts as well
This makes the most sense. The writers like making direct comparisons to lore we already know, and it seems like a parallel to the outcome of the battle between Obi-Wan and Anakin right after his turn to the dark side. Obi-Wan "scarred" Vader in self-defense, reluctantly left him for dead, but was later surprised to learn he was still alive.
Episode 4, Owen Lars "If those Units aren't in the south ridge by mid-day they'll be hell to pay."
THANK YOU!!!
This is why I take very few of these angry tirades seriously from "fans" now. They complain over the most minute things that aren't even an issue.
Owen and Solo have referenced *hell*, but it's such an issue now?
My allegiance is to the Republic! TO DEMOCRACY!
@@alexanderthegreat5649 Exactly. There are countless cultures throughout the Galaxy Far, Far Away and probably countless cultures that have concepts of hell to the point where the idea has spread as a metaphor for many, the way it is for us.
@@MeanMrMustard1I'd forgotten there was actual examples but this was my theory anyway. Entire galaxy, someone developed a concept of hell. Nbd
And “what the hell do you think you’re doing?” on the Death Star…
Although Han Solo did refer to HELL in ESB, Uncle Owen first referred to HELL in ANH when he was talking to Aunt Beru about what would happen if Luke didn't have the droids out and working soon ".......or there will be HELL to pay".
Mando said, "What a hell" in ep 4 s1
Hell is literally mentioned earlier than the Force :)
@@lilac951also in an episode of The Clone Wars, one of the clones says, “What the hell is that??!”
Also happens with Poe in The Last Jedi.
Lol you're right!
14:52 maybe that’s palpatine’s father or grandfather since we know his family was pretty powerful/important on Naboo
Agreed!
Yeah that’s what I’m thinking is happening here
Well this aged incredibly poorly lol
Can we all agree that Basil is a little s**t? xD First he completely abandons everyone while tracking May in the forest, then offers 0 help during the fight and just leaves. Then proceeds to sabotage everything the jedi are doing. Get this little gremlin away form everyone xD
lol
Bazil appears to be most loyal to Mog and Vern's team. When he is trapoed with Mae and Sol, he trusts neither one.
FOR NO GOOD REASON.
The tragedy of darth plagueis starts now
Fr
plagueis died in his sleep because he lied to palps about the twins
Lol
Darth Jakus.
Tragic indeed
Qimir uses the force to fly. the same way he floated down like a vampire during his "Day" entrance. Thats how he was able to get into the Witches strong hold with out the use of the elevator.
That entrance was dope asf
I thought he used the secret door vernestra used?
@@blackE1114 Vernestra used the same door as osha, which by that time works again because Osha just fixed it
What I love about your channel is that you're not judgemental, you just break down facts and let people enjoy without fear of listening to more hatred towards these big shows that have received so much attention lately. This is a haven for us nerds to just have a good time when consuming fantasy/sci-fi. Kudos, sir.
Agreed.
What is it you say?... May the force be with you..
this series redefine it as "go ... yourself"
Mae the force be with you 🤔
@@husslehard8005Oh sha t!
Cold
@@arvid3
Just because he used it like that doesn't mean the series totally redefined it as such.
The helmet has the same toothy smile the picture of The Mother has...
Yo wait that’s actually a good idea I never thought about that
I always thought the "See you in Hell" line from Empire was funny. I just imagined the reaction of the other dude. "Huh? What did I do to deserve Hell???"
From Hans perspective they’re all rouges, fighting for the right thing but not necessarily doing it in a completely good way.
Knights of Ren is your Mephisto of this series😊
I honestly thought the voice on the communicator sounded more like David Tennant/Huyang.
Why always assuming that Qimir's scars are from whip torture and not just a battle? That's like looking at Vader and assuming that Anakin was drawn and quartered by Kenobi.
They wouldn’t be featured as much if they wouldn’t like us to think SOMETHING about them
It may be that they assume so because a lot of this series it showing that the Jedi aren't really the good guys. I agree that it's likely just a combat wound but it does fit the overall theme of the series.
its in an s shape and venestra has a lifht whip which isnt common in current canon @@Blasted2Oblivion
Why jump to the idea that he was tortured??? What if he was hit like that because he was running, turning on Venestra and finding his own path?
Yeah that was a weird take honestly.
😂😂😂😂
I suspect the assumption comes from the fact that this series has been hammering how how the Jedi are not the good guys most assume them to be.
@@Blasted2Oblivion The series has been hammering how SOME of the Jedi are fallible
I don't feel like Qimir's actually trained by the Sith and is most likely unassociated w/ Plagieus. His actions feel more akin to General Grevious in that he relies on the element of surprise, fear, and some form of deception (for Grevious, it's just the fact he wields 4 lightsabers). When Qimir fought the jedi squad, he relied on his cortosis helmet to short circuit and confuse some of his opponents and then defeated Jecki w/ the reveal of the 2nd blade. When he was out of tricks, Sol confidently slammed him twice
I could be horribly discounting Sol but it rly feels like Qimir's inferiority to Sol is is supposed to suggest this. He may have called himself sith bcuz he equated using the dark side as being a sith and felt he could adopt the title because he assumed all the sith were long dead. In comparison, other sith we've seen like Maul and Dooku are incredibly composed and adept duelists gaining the upperhand on every jedi except Anakin in rots. In most cases, Sith usually have the upperhand in duels only to lose it because of carelessness like how Kenobi usually wins and how Ahsoka defeated Maul.
Although an alternative is that Sol is incredibly strong and I shouldn't discount his strength
Love your explanation
Makes sense. I think Qimir is the canonization of Venamis, but I don't think we will hear his name because they've established in Canon only 2 siths can be lords, everyone else has been an assassin like Ventress or Savage or an inquisitor but not given a sith name. I feel like this makes his words "I don't have a name, but a Jedi like you may call me sith" less vague, and an almost literal explanation of what he is. Can't help but think his mouth and teeth on his helmet are meant to symbolize something, and I feel like they look Venamis and a friend of mine pointed out that it almost looks like Venom himself in his opinion. It's probably horribly wrong, but it just makes sense to me.
Venomous* sorry auto correct changed it to the characters name because I had already changed it previously.
@@jacobmerritt2518well wasn't it the whole point that Venamis was breaking the rule of two by being Tenebrous' apprentice at the same time as Plagueis? Besides the rule of two hasn't really ever been followed in canon or in legends.
@@elpenguinoofmexico1388 you forgetting the fact he force pushed all the jedi away? And killed majority of them. On top of invading their minds with visions. He didn’t look phased when seeing the force choke/the corruption of the kyber crystal or when Sol was talking about how the Mae/Osha were created through the force and talks about the way of the sith with Mae multiple times.
He’s either partially trained by the sith (an current or old sith acolyte or apprentice) or went through extensive training with Vernestra and him embracing the darkside has made him much stronger but wouldn’t explain his other capabilities. E.g mind corruption/the ability to fly / levitate
Was it ever stated that Qimir was a child when he got those scars? We don’t know what happened in the events he got those scars. It’s an assumption it was torture. He could have done something to deserve it. He did just recently kill a bunch of innocent Jedi.
I thought the same thing
Agree. Way more likely it was self defense or an accident than torture. And the way the writing tends to go these days, Qimir misinterpreted something that fueled some immature anger and doomed him for life.
Exactly
I could see it being an accident somehow and he holds deep hatred towards the jedi for it
He probably just thought Vernestra's saber whip was a back scratcher.
Seems pretty obvious that Vernestra was trying to get a message to Yoda, not someone in the Senate.
Huh? Makes no sense!
@@austinvieira8720She does end up talking to him
Isn't it inconsistent for it to be believed Sol committed all 4 murders? He was on Coruscant teaching younglings when Indara was killed and plenty of Jedi had their eyes on him as Torbin was killed.
Weren't all those same Jedi killed in the following episode?
Sure, and that question might get raised at some point. The story isn’t over. But if the senate was also happy to accept the face value lie as an excuse not to have to dig too deeply, that’s also something that can work.
Yeah, but all the Jedi that knew that are basically dead. The only one that’s left with the true information is basically just Vernestra
The Senate doesn't know that. I thought this episode made it clear that the Senate has no idea what goes on in the Temple.
@@TheAlexcassunnot the ones on the actual planet, the that guarded the temple
I got the impression that Qimir was hearing the truth about the twins for the first time in the moment sol told Mae.
Thank you for positive coverage for us that are actually curious about where "lore" is going to go, not how they're "destroying legends"
Can’t destroy non canon, that’s not how canon works 🤣
One of the most amazing things in the fight scene between Sol and Qimir was the force cancelation that Sol performed. I had to rewind that a couple of times.
Master Sol was just incredible. That scene was amazing.
I didn't notice the first time I watched, but Sol used Trakata. He turned his saber off right before it hit Qimir's helmet, then he reignited it and slashed his saber in half.
Don't the Jedi consider that dishonorable?
I was waiting for it once he switched stances so nasty
@bradleyduke4503 Jedi see it as dishonorable, while Sith see it as cowardly. In this instance though I don't think he had much choice as the alternative was bonking Qimir on the head and losing access to his saber in a crucial moment and leaving Qinir with 2.
@@bradleyduke4503Sol didn’t give me much “honorable” vibes
@@Juggtacula Qimir does it all of the time, so we could think Sol is forced to do the same thing to have a chance on him.
My theory is thy at Plaguies created Osha & Mae & has nothing to do with Mr. Buffguywithteethhelmet
Or at least had a hand in the creation
The hooded person in the background of the witches definitely could be plagueis
Muuns are very tall and that figure was at least 7 feet
Maybe it’s like an experiment he doing in multiple places
This shows writing is so bad you never know.
Orrrrrr this is how he discovers how? He would still have to learn how to manipulate midi-chlorians.
One detail I haven’t seen anyone mention: when Sol disarms that shorter lightsaber from Qimir, Qimir goes to force pull it back to his hand but Sol seems to “cut” the force pull with his lightsaber
They did sol dirty
Hella
Totally
Definitely
Agreed.I didn't want him to die.
For real
Sol was a great tragic character and powerful! Great demonstration of what the Jedi could do before they become diminished.
Yeah, but he wasn't exactly a jedi, i mean he wasn't following all the rules...
He was emotional, attached and even love the kid as a father, so a bit of the dark side was on him.
I think it’s interesting that Plagueis really blends into the rock wall, almost like he’s been there the whole time observing from the background
I love this channel so much! I know i can watch details being explained without the "disney ruined star wars" rant. Thank you so much to the team that bleed hours into this analysis!
Just a wild speculation, but what if they're toying with the idea that Darth Sidious has been cloning himself longer than we thought, or maybe he is older than we imagined. When he was fighting Mace Windu, he looked like had aged like 200 years. We'll see.
I never thought about it that way, maybe you're onto something there. Instead of Sidious becoming disfigured by Mace Windu reflecting the force lightning back at him, what if that was his true appearance and it just deactivated some form of "force disguise" thing he had going on? Then he was like, no need to hide it any more. It's a fun fan theory anyway.
Plagueis helped the witches make the twins.
or backwards, could be any
lol at anyone complaining about “see you in hell”, do your homework
Just shows haters don’t care about the original trilogy either, they just want to find something to be triggered about
Apparently hating comes with some dopamine, hating became so strong lately everywhere.
Why? I never liked it in the OT either…
@@Xeta_ that’s fine.
You don’t need to like everything about the franchise but it is still as much as part of it as the force is.
I really enjoyed The Acolyte and consider it one of the better Disney+ live action shows.
I did notice Sen Rayencourt's medallion and it looks similiar to Maul's medallion in Solo. Could Sen. Rayencourt be working for a syndicate?
Reardless of Qimir's relationship to Plagueous, I believe Aimir anf Osha are going to be spun by The Jedi as fallen Jedi that turned to the dark side with no links to the Sith.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
But Vernestra was definitely setting up a meeting with Yoda, right?
My allegiance is to the Republic! TO DEMOCRACY!
Totally loved your commentary! Personally, I’ve been enjoying the Acolyte pretty much alone. So happy to have found this channel!
You’d probably thank someone for shxting in ur cereal bc it was still edible
@@LocallightskinnnJ you probably never enjoy any cereal because it isn't the specific brand of lucky charms from 2006
Left more questions than answers.
season 2
@@harrisonplott4674 I doubt it gets a s2. This shit cost $180M to make and the ratings were atrocious. It didn't cause anyone to sub to disney+
@@harrisonplott4674bad writing since it should’ve answered most in season 1 as stand alone
@@Xeta_ why? they left things open for a season 2 , we know osha is the acolyte , qimir is suspected as being venestras ex padawan. the only things we are unsure of is plageuis
The best shows will always give answers and create questions
The blocks in the water look to be more of an erosion barrier than ruins. You them a lot in parts of the East Coast of the US protecting the inhabited coasts from further erosion.
We are all guilty of justifying our own actions as being righteous, if not convincing ourselves it's right even if they're are not.
It is why it is said righteous anger is the worst anger.
This Senator is definitely working with the SiTH maybe Plagueis. It's just the words he uses
It would make sense..
The irony of both the Acolyte and the boys having a fight between identical ladies in their final episodes
"May the force be with you" is essentially thoughts and prayers
For folks making meme about PalpAtine telling this to Anakin
Palps wasn't even born yet
He was born in 82 BBY
Seriously hope we get a second series, so much more to discover!
what if qimir is darth venamis, the illegitimate sith apprentice tenebrous trained parallel to plagueis in violation of the rule of two? tenebrous kind of manipulated them to kill each other and plagueis did end up killing him in bal´demnic, and found out that venamis was looking for an apprentice before that
15:10 Occam’s razor. If it *is* Ian’s voice, it could have just been a nod as a little cameo. It *could* be a relative to Palpatine. I think the former is more likely, but I really don’t think it’s anything to dig too deep into
Those aren't necessarily carved blocks on the mystery planet. Rocks often form large crystals or fracture along planes giving the illusion of being shaped or carved. See, for instance, the Devil's Postpile.
I’d love to be a Jedi but he’s 100% right. 😂 you can do what the Jedi do while also having emotions. And cutting that off will lead some to the dark side or becoming a grey Jedi.
Luke Skywalker i believe in Legends was Jedi who believed in emotions. Maybe not decisions based in emotions but compassion and such are still emotions
Its about not letting emotions rule over you. I don't understand where Jedi have no emotions idea comes from.
@@robertbell6230this made me imagine Spock as a Jedi. I bet he'd make a kick ass Jedi.
Most Jedi have displayed emotions. Not allowing them to control them is a different matter.
It seems we are getting more into the flaws of Jedi. We have seen Masters hint at letting go of attachments (emotions?) to be in control of one self. I think what is shown is the more we believe in what we do, the less likely we will have "control" in our actions.
can we also mention how plagueis's skin blends into the cave walls
Lightsaber blades are drawn to each other (see Kanan training Sabine in rebels) so you can't just flip your wrist.
Those "columns" are an ancient lava flow; in this case, basalt, that slowly cooled as an undisturbed mass. The geometric columns occur as the rock cools and solidifies slowly and are eventually exposed to the elements when softer rocks around them are eroded away. The columns on the ground are the upper sections of the formation that tumbled away from the rest due to erosion or earth movement. The geometric surface they were walking on are columns whose tops are all that is exposed. There are a few such formations along the coast of the British isles and similar ones can be found in Yellowstone in Wyoming, Devil's Postpile in North Eastern California and even in San Diego County, made out of another volcanic rock.
Rayencourt's amulet looks like Maul's from the end of Solo.
It was awesome seeing a bleeding of the lightsaber in live action for the first time
Except it isn't supposed to be that easy. It took Darth Vader a lot more effort in the comics.
@@vanillajack5925thank you for pointing this out.
@@vanillajack5925 Darth Vader is no match for the power of many /s
@vanillajack5925 the twins are witches. They aren't Jedi. We can't look at them the same as Vader
I think Vader was conflicted about turning to the dark side, a reason he was saved by Luke in the end.
A theory I had over the weekend: Tenebrous trained Qimir. Plagueis had no knowledge of this but somehow found out. That is why he was spying on them, lurking in the shadows.
Till they canonize tenebrous, that isn’t backable
Loved this series
Sol/Qimir fight >>>>>>>>>>
How would anakins lightsaber stay blue as he slaughtered a whole tribe of tusken raiders, or killing younglings, or battling obi wan. Hasn't it always been a conscious effort and decision to bleed a crystal, since the crystal fights against being bled/bleached?
To be fair, anakins saber never cracked open after gently hitting a rock…
My theory would be that Anakin was not fully turned yet. The killing of the tusken raiders was a temporary fall, and the younglings were killed out of desperation, trying in his mistaken way to save Padme. It's not until he is fully Darth that he gives in fully to the dark and intentionally bleeds his crystal.
If i may, i think that Osha and Mae are created by Plageus (i butchered the name i know :) ).
Loved that this story took Star War's famous villain's redemption story and turned it on its head:
the hero's condemnation.
What? Georges Star Wars was simple, good vs bad, fall and redemption now it’s bad vs bad where’s the drama in that?
@David-hc4xh you're right. You've changed my mind. Thank you.
Quimir just pulled a Batman move. I don’t think he turned into smoke.
Can someone explain to me why Mae had to stay behind? They had plenty of time to escape together
The amount of reaching done with these theories isn’t even funny
We got Darth plaguesis in a film before gta 6
Hel - if Skol and Hati made it then Hel, being a cold place where snowballs have more of a chance than we would think these days, is a perfect place to find a Tauntaun
I bet ya Plagueis was whispering in Osha's head when the Kyber Krystal turned red: "Give in to your anger."
The ring chase/battle reminded me of the Titan AE
The damage control this page does to defend Disney 😂😂😂
No one cares. No one over 12 anyway. There's real problems to deal with.
It all made sense when he revealed that his wife works for Disney 😂
I think Bazil, who works for Jedi, realized that Sol was going off the rails and needed to be stopped before he could do more damage.
Or he just thought he was gonna kill then both
Or it makes no sense because it makes no freaking sense lmao
😂😂
Totally confusing. Also he/they 😅 should know that Sol did not kill the other Jedi. He should have been around while Mae (which he wanted to kill the scene before)was evil.. it is poor writing
These are the weakest Jedi masters ever. Not very High Republic
I could be wrong but I’m pretty sure in one of the wider shots of the planet osha and qimir are on the shoe island from the last jedi can be seen in the background, potentially confirming that this planet and ach to are one and the same
Same way Mae knew how to use Pip , same person
🤦♂️
WOW great pickup with Palpatine's voice
My allegiance is to the Republic! TO DEMOCRACY!
Master Yoda 🔥
Tales of the Empire shows different Dathomir witch covens.
That’s true
What if Plagueis actually conceived the twins and just made the witches think they did it.
The witches knew the true origin of the twins, meaning they'd know if Plagueis was involved and probably collaborated with him.
Serious question. What the actual heck were the sisters even fighting for? For WHAT!?
I think Qimirs and Maes sudden disappearances are just the use of force speed like what we saw in The Phantom Menace
Im just saying, look at Abeloth and Qimirs helmet.... not a coincidence i think.
This video handled the work that Star Wars Theory used to do. I am grateful, thank you
Yep, swt is a hack nowadays
Thanks for breaking down this season
I think Ravencourt is connected with the Sith. He knows too much about the Jedi and their faults. It would be some symmetry to how Palpatine comes to power through the Senate. It would make sense if Plageus was training Qimir at some point to over throw his Master. But he just seems to want to do his own thing with some company. Not necessarily take out the Jedi, as long as they don’t get in his way.
It seems like a Star Wars tradition to use notable actors' voices over the radio
when else does this happen?
Or couldnt Kymeer move his head towards the blade?
Real like we literally saw him headbutt a lightsaber earlier
I think Qimir wanted to keep Sol alive so he could have either Osha or Mei kill him to complete his test
At first I thought the May and Osha fight was meh, but you're right....same person, same moves. The Sol and Qimir fight was amazing. Cool edits too
What’s that tower on Coruscant that in front of the Jedi Temple, was crawling with Jedi and where Senator Rayencourt met up with Master Vernestra?
Maybe the "offices" are separate from the Temple?
Well Wikipedia ain’t telling me Jack so I’m relying on y’all to answer this but that sounds more likely than not
Might be part of Jedi Village or the Jedi Neighborhood
Lmao
My Star Wars on D+ Top 9. 1) Mandalorian. 2) Mandalorian 2. 3) Mandalorian 3. 4) Visions. 5) Ahsoka. 6) Boba Fett. 7) Andor. 8) Acolyte. 9) Obi-Wan
So happy I didn’t watch a minute of this series 🙂↕️
😂😂😂 thanks for admitting you added to the problem
8 episodes for a “full season” is kinda wack
I don't think the scar on Qimir's back is supposed to indicate that Vernestra tortured him, but had tried to kill him when he fell to the Dark Side, hence Vernestra's surprise at sensing his presence.
Anyone feel like the splitting of one person would be linked to how Revan did it during the Old Republic Game ?
The rings around the moon of Brendok reminded me of the similar ring around Peridrea
I love that we saw Osha bleed a kyber crystal, but it looked so easy. Why didn't Anakin's saber turn red on Mustafar? Or in the temple?
Bad writing
@@Xeta_ yeah I know
@@Xeta_ 😂😂 does it feel good to lie
@@huiba1you get paid to make stuff up?
Someone was way too giddy on this.
I wanna do a poll real quick. Would you rather:
1. Plagueis learns how to create life from the witches
Or
2. Plagueis taught the witches how to create life
2.
I think Plagueis taught them and they made a deal with him and it ended badly.
2. But I don’t think he gave them the full recipe, hence the one person split into twins. He feared having one being would be too powerful. So he divided the power between two beings.
1. I think he sees something that he wants to recreate, to no avail.
He does create life, but he is far less in control of this process than the witches seem to be
2
I think Plagueis used his abilities to keep Qimir young. He keeps saying he is very old.
The beginning totally made me think of Spaceballs. "I can't breathe in this thing!"
If yoda is complicit in the cover up that is the most egregious retcon disney has ever put to screen.
What do you mean... sure Yoda doesn't say anything when Ki-Adi-Mundi says the Sith have been extinct a thousand years, but not long after when talking to Mace, he reveals he knows about the rule of two, which was put into place AFTER the jedi thought the sith defeated, meaning he knows that the sith have been active after Ki-Adi-Mundi thinks they were extinct, and not only that knows something of how they operate.
@@KardiacKid45 it was put in place a 1000 years before by the survivor of the war where Jedi thought the Sith had been wiped out... thus Ki-Adi Mundi's saying they had been extinct a thousand years... if the Sith had truly not been seen by the Jedi in that thousand years, then there is no way Yoda or any other Jedi could possibly have known about the rule of 2.
Disney hasn’t retconned anything, you can’t retcon non canon that’s literally not how it works
@@cwslyclgh you refer to non canon there, that info doesn’t apply to canon
23:08 correction, first time we’ve seen it in any form in canon 😉
I stand by that Sol did do the right thing with the information he had available to him at the time.
Mae literally told him they were going to be sacrificed, why would he not think he did the right thing?
I respect someone's ability to have an opinion but killing their mother just to get his way is not allegedly what the Jedi are about.
@@robwo1821but taking kids from people like they’ve always done is 😂