"Civil War Uniforms of Blue & Grey - The Evolution" Volume 2

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 197

  • @Brainwashed101
    @Brainwashed101 6 років тому +391

    This is a great reminder that a lot of the Confederate uniforms weren't quite grey, but more of a butternut color. Cool!

    • @fawkeeenset
      @fawkeeenset 6 років тому +46

      Charles Wang "our uniforms looked like autumn grass" actual qoute from a 17 year old member of the North Carolina Junior reserves called up in 1865

    • @frankperkin124
      @frankperkin124 6 років тому +47

      The brown and butternut colors came from simple home made type dyes. Different parts of the uniform could be different colors.

  • @bradforddean1
    @bradforddean1 6 років тому +79

    My great Grand Uncle Benjamin Dean died in 1862 in service to the Union's 16th Wisconsin Regiment H Company. He was 19 years old.

  • @Kokopilau77
    @Kokopilau77 6 років тому +149

    The surgeon looks like a Wild West gunslinger

  • @travismeta3727
    @travismeta3727 5 років тому +70

    The men really look like they could be from the Civil War, very handsome and authentic I must say.

  • @TheWeatherbuff
    @TheWeatherbuff 6 років тому +61

    I had the grand experience of doing "hard core" duty for about six years, (back in the late 90s). What a way to learn this particular part of history. Both the Union and Confederate units in which I served were utterly intolerant of anything not authentic. We made our own uniforms, slept in the open air and marched for six or seven miles per day (easy duty) during some re-enactments. I must say, while on "campaign" I kept asking myself why I do this, because it was intensely miserable. After each event, I'd yearn to do it again. Eventually I made it to the rank of Corporal, so I had a pretty easy life.

    • @galoon
      @galoon 6 років тому +14

      My experience in a hard core unit was pretty much the same! When the weather was lousy I'd think "what the hell am I doing out here?" but after the event was over I'd conveniently forget that I ever asked myself that question--glad to hear I'm not the only one! We were active in the hobby at about the same time :-)

  • @gazza9463
    @gazza9463 6 років тому +14

    I hope this is of interest. Most of the cloth for the uniforms of both sides was manufactured in Morley near LEEDS, West Yorkshire, England. Virtually all of the mills that made the cloth no longer exist. Most made way for housing or were turned into apartment blocks. One mill about 200 yards from my home still stands. It is now an auction house and also a martial arts club.

  • @joshuaescopete
    @joshuaescopete 6 років тому +72

    Would’ve liked to have seen a Cavalry officers uniform. Love seeing those yellow sashes and garish hats.

  • @imacoolkid721
    @imacoolkid721 6 років тому +13

    That bushwhacker looked so cool

  • @OxfordPatriot
    @OxfordPatriot 6 років тому +24

    I've been so excited for this next volume. I admire your attention to detail and preserving one of the most important parts in our nation's history. Thank you.

  • @Hinkel84
    @Hinkel84 6 років тому +84

    Some good references for the PC game War of Rights - featureing the Maryland Campaign of 1862 :) Good job!

    • @fawkeeenset
      @fawkeeenset 6 років тому +6

      If that damn game uses any of our likeness we better get royalties.

    • @SarisTX
      @SarisTX 6 років тому +5

      When are we going to get that 1st Texas uniform for war of Rights?

    • @thegunslinger8806
      @thegunslinger8806 6 років тому +5

      I hope they ad the Cherokee Indian soldiers. Should be fun seeing people know about that little fact.

  • @n.i.t.f919
    @n.i.t.f919 6 років тому +96

    The Next Video you should make is U.S Marines Uniform History combat and dress uniforms

  • @hijackmaniac
    @hijackmaniac 6 років тому +40

    i love that grey and black combo the texans had

  • @jasonhendrix3548
    @jasonhendrix3548 6 років тому +6

    Stupendous. The best online Civil War uniform presentation I've seen. Simple and basic, but overflowing in accurate detail. Aka...Stink'n Awesome. Great job!!

  • @woffus
    @woffus 6 років тому +17

    Another wonderful video. It’s total living history. The guys look totally authentic and are absolutely fabulous. I’ve been hooked on the Civil War since the 60s when I collected all the Topps Civil War cards. Unfortunately I’m on the other side of the pond in Britain or I’d love to be a reenactor too. Huge respect for the men who fell. RIP.

    • @Becca-cs5cb
      @Becca-cs5cb 6 років тому +1

      woffus there’s reenactors overseas too!

  • @juhall
    @juhall 5 років тому +3

    Great series, the 5th NY (Duryees Zouaves) was the unit that was engaged with my great grand uncles’ unit ( 1st Palmetto Rifles) at Gaines Mill in 1862. RIP Isaac Livingstone Grier.

  • @scottmaltzberger7881
    @scottmaltzberger7881 6 років тому +1

    Love the dramatic music playing along with the video. It puts a more realism feel to this history!

  • @vinniemigliano4203
    @vinniemigliano4203 5 років тому +2

    Very fascinating. Not trying to poke fun or anything because I’m a huge civil war buff, but that Missouri Bushwacker uniform looks like something Mr. Furley from Threes Company would have worn. Joking aside, the attention to details on all these uniforms was amazing. I would imagine that with the mishmash of so many styles and colors on both sides, it would have led to much confusion, especially early in the war.

  • @Oscarhobbit
    @Oscarhobbit 6 років тому +15

    I love this !! I would have loved to a North Carolina frock coat. THE OLD NORTH STATE! Maybe in vol 3. Can we please have some more.

  • @galoon
    @galoon 6 років тому +3

    Awesome job on these videos! I like seeing the use of Federal buttons on some of the CS shell jackets/frocks--it's been under-represented in the re-enacting community.

  • @Jacob-yg7lz
    @Jacob-yg7lz 6 років тому +16

    >20 minutes
    >only 70 views
    this is an autrocity

  • @KevlarX2
    @KevlarX2 6 років тому +2

    The guy with roses all over his shirt. Missouri bushwhacker? LOL!

  • @abwihamwinkin
    @abwihamwinkin 6 років тому +15

    Oh yes, forgot to mention that now I can tell the Sharps and the Spencer carbine apart! Now I won’t be wrong in the future! Hahaha

  • @frenchfan3368
    @frenchfan3368 6 років тому +7

    Very well done guys! Very well done!

  • @coletonhelms7830
    @coletonhelms7830 6 років тому +57

    My great great grandfather was a confederate soldier thank y’all

  • @Xarcht
    @Xarcht 5 років тому +1

    A very well done series. Please accept my Thank You.

  • @actiongiraffe
    @actiongiraffe 6 років тому +5

    The 'Texas General' is actually wearing Colonel's collar insignia. Robert E. Lee and Jimmy Kemper both preferred the Colonel's insignia. Most Confederate generals wore the standard patch with 2 small stars flanking a larger one circled by a wreath.

  • @georgea.567
    @georgea.567 6 років тому +123

    I don’t care what anyone else thinks, I think Zouave uniforms are awesome looking.

    • @pierrepapon5240
      @pierrepapon5240 6 років тому +11

      were US zouaves regiment inspired by french zouaves ?

    • @cogadhturtar8408
      @cogadhturtar8408 6 років тому +21

      yes they were pierre

    • @baneofbanes
      @baneofbanes 6 років тому +2

      pierre papon Yep.

    • @ulrichkalber9039
      @ulrichkalber9039 6 років тому +5

      I would say that they were believed to be awesomelooking in the day as well, hence there were several Regiments of them.

    • @whilryke
      @whilryke 6 років тому +15

      It reminds me of a joke on the pontifical zouaves: "It is really a idea of french to dress the defenders of the Pope as Mohammedans !"

  • @Clarkecars
    @Clarkecars 5 років тому +7

    Great instructional video on the many uniforms worn by both sides. I am struck by the many immigrant units from Europe the Federal Government employed against the Southern American forces to accomplish their invasion of nation-states inhabited by their peaceful neighbors.

  • @142jwilliams
    @142jwilliams 6 років тому +23

    VOLUME 3 PLEASE BUT WITH WESTERN THEATER UNIFORMS PLEEEEEEEAAAASE!!!!!! good job guys, these are awesome.

  • @SFRTA
    @SFRTA 6 років тому +1

    superdly done!! Awesome video!! I myself last year visited Appomattox court house amazing experience.

  • @bigboiraisin6540
    @bigboiraisin6540 6 років тому +56

    I wanna see some Confederate Marines

  • @silentgroyper5069
    @silentgroyper5069 6 років тому +1

    Thank you for showing the uniforms of the two Zouves units and the Iron Brigade, my favs. I was hoping there would be the 1st Louisiana Special Battalion "Wheat's Tigers" or Louisiana Tigers featured as well as I think it is a counterpart to the Union Zouves. Alas, it is not to be. I hope you folks would included in your later Civil war uniform series videos!

    • @LionHeartFilmWorks
      @LionHeartFilmWorks  6 років тому +4

      Take a look at the first Volume - Tigers are represented: ua-cam.com/video/n8MAlu2NEps/v-deo.html

  • @monkeyship74401
    @monkeyship74401 6 років тому +7

    Looking forward to volume 3 and 4. Someone has been looking at a lot of period photos to get their details ironed out.

  • @buckhendrix
    @buckhendrix 6 років тому +9

    Fashion show for reenactors. I love it!!!

  • @trojanette8345
    @trojanette8345 5 років тому

    VERY NICELY SHOT AND SHOWCASED!! In the future for those of us that are not all that versed in war battle gear please consider narration or some sort of additonal visual explanation of what we are seeing. Also, consider slowing down the visual pace of the video. Thank You. Overall, I liked it. I am in awe of what you've done. Thank You for sharing it.

  • @yankeedoodle7365
    @yankeedoodle7365 6 років тому +15

    And if you do any more can you do a part III can you add a North Carolina Uniform, just for say because North Carolina provided the most men about 1/8 of the Confedrate army.

  • @yankeedoodle7365
    @yankeedoodle7365 6 років тому +51

    I love these evolution of different Uniforms, how do you do this, get other Reanactor's? Or just same people but you have them wear different Uniforms

    • @jayhallman6666
      @jayhallman6666 6 років тому +28

      These are all hard-core reenactors. That make sure the impressions they are pretraining is 100% correct. They got it down to where you would think they stepped out of a time machine.

    • @carltonferrell4062
      @carltonferrell4062 6 років тому +17

      legoboy 300001 I can attest to these guys being the best at what they do. They're what I like to call Living Historians. They put the time and effort into researching the units they portray and they all take pride in what they do. I've fielded personally with the gentleman who does the Zouaves and the gentleman who does the Irish Brigade, they are definitely top notch and know who and what they are portraying

    • @davisjacobs5748
      @davisjacobs5748 6 років тому +19

      As one of those hardcore reenactors, I can back up what Jason said. We try our absolute hardest to get as correct as possible and it doesn't just stop at our uniforms either. We carry and bring period correct rations and person items as well. We create a persona of somebody in the 1860's and act like we're really from the time. It's a lot of fun and there are literally moments that you think "Wow! So, that's what it must've looked like!" It's an experience you can't get from reading a book or watching a documentary. It's easy to read about it, but to actually act it out, it really gives you a whole different level of understanding!

    • @carlhicksjr8401
      @carlhicksjr8401 6 років тому +14

      I'm a Civil War reenactor in Washington State. My impression [portrayal, persona, what have you] is of a Regular Army soldier in the Eastern Theater in the 4th Infantry Reg't, 2nd Div. Vth Corps.
      Now, out here we didn't have any direct conflict regarding the War. But several of men who became famous served here in the decade prior [Grant and Pickett among others]. We focus not only on visual authenticity, but also *teaching* well. The Civil War can seem rather distant when you're 1200 miles from the nearest battle site, so it's up to us to explain the War to people who don't know how much it actually matters.
      My personal uniforms include: fatigue 1850, dress 1856, and fatigue 1861 regulation uniforms. It ain't cheap. But we all put forth the effort because history is a perishable skill. And forgetting history is one of the most dangerous things a nation or a society can do to itself.

    • @baneofbanes
      @baneofbanes 6 років тому +7

      Jason Hallman Hell, some will even wear the correct underwear.

  • @mikekifer1665
    @mikekifer1665 5 років тому +9

    I had an unidentified ancestor who fell at Gettysburg for the union,!

  • @tennesseeridgerunner5992
    @tennesseeridgerunner5992 6 років тому +9

    I think these are wonderful portrayals, but can't help wonder why the dearth of unis from the Western Theater? The War was won (or lost, for me) in the West. In keeping with this time frame I woulda like to have seen uniforms from Forts Henry and Donelson Campaigns, Pea Ridge, and lets not forget Shiloh. How bout the early stages of the Vicksburg Campaign as well? That said, I really do enjoy these LionHeart Productions. Deo Vindice!

    • @LionHeartFilmWorks
      @LionHeartFilmWorks  6 років тому +5

      Allot of Western looks will be featured in Volume 3 & 4.

    • @galoon
      @galoon 6 років тому +3

      For Forts Henry and Donelson and Shiloh, the 1st Texas infantryman shown in this video would be a good match. He's wearing commutation clothing that predominated in all theaters before the Confederate depot system went into operation. A black, brown, or buff slouch hat would have been more common than the forage cap shown here, though. I love these videos!

    • @fawkeeenset
      @fawkeeenset 6 років тому +3

      galoon yes your right replace the blue on the collar and cuff and you have most of the Tennessee units. The hat was specific to the 1st Texas which is why we chose that look . A slouch would.have been a little to generic for what we wanted to portray.

    • @galoon
      @galoon 6 років тому

      That's an awesome forage cap! Who made the one you used in the video, by the way? I've seen a very similar original one in the Confederate volume of the Echoes of Glory books (which of course are a gold mine of genuine items!)

    • @galoon
      @galoon 6 років тому

      I also like the frock coat he's got--it looks like it's seen some hard use! I have a favorite one that Nick Sekela made a long time ago; it's a brownish-greenish grey with plain brass "Paris" buttons and dark blue worsted wool tape on collar/cuffs. It's been through the ringer, too--I'm the third or fourth owner...

  • @ggousier
    @ggousier 6 років тому +1

    Thank you for these videos.

  • @Starwarsfreak101st
    @Starwarsfreak101st 6 років тому +3

    Simply amazing.

  • @jadonberg9364
    @jadonberg9364 6 років тому +24

    Hey can we see the 79th New York Highlanders?

  • @luismariaberger5055
    @luismariaberger5055 6 років тому

    What a lovely video to watch during breakfast :D thanks guys

  • @PrinceChaloner
    @PrinceChaloner 6 років тому +14

    Wow they look way better than reenactment uniforms.

    • @RocketMan47719
      @RocketMan47719 6 років тому +8

      Chaloner they are reenactment uniforms albeit of the highest accuracy that you don't see at a lot of local events

  • @SarisTX
    @SarisTX 6 років тому +37

    I fought with the 1st Texas guy at Port Hudson 2018 Reenactment

  • @yotan85
    @yotan85 6 років тому +8

    the best uniform is 79th kilted New York Cameron highlanders, wasnt included in this video

  • @FallCarrot
    @FallCarrot 6 років тому +6

    I just love the fact that the last battle of Civil War was Confederate victory with battle of Palmito Ranch

    • @baneofbanes
      @baneofbanes 6 років тому +8

      wildly caoytoe I mean winning a few battles is well in all but counts for naught when you lose the war.

  • @t.dasher8491
    @t.dasher8491 6 років тому +6

    Awesome to see the 45th New York with rolled great coats in their packs. Someone did their research!

    • @galoon
      @galoon 6 років тому +1

      Definitely! I liked seeing the SNY buckle, NY state buttons, and NY state shell jacket he was wearing, too.

  • @kalebmoon2517
    @kalebmoon2517 5 років тому +4

    ok guys finally found the name of the background music its Heros and Legends by Tim Brown

  • @buckplug2423
    @buckplug2423 6 років тому +1

    can't wait for volume 3

  • @buddyollie7400
    @buddyollie7400 6 років тому +1

    I love these civil war vids

  • @Grandmaster-uj2zg
    @Grandmaster-uj2zg 6 років тому +23

    What's the music at 3:35 ?

  • @madeinAmericasince-rz9cp
    @madeinAmericasince-rz9cp 5 років тому +1

    i absolutely loved these videos, you had me nerding out the whole time. thank you very much

  • @HyperK7
    @HyperK7 5 років тому +1

    You guys gonna finish this series? It’s really cool and it would be a shame if it stopped halfway through.

  • @ulrichkalber9039
    @ulrichkalber9039 6 років тому +7

    you should add detailed descriptions, like: this "2" means ist the second Regiment, that is the rank insignia of a corporal, this weapon is a sharps, the canteen is Standard issue that canteen is private purchase etc. some Viewers that are not from the US would also have a hard time knowing wich is a confederate and wich is a Union uniform(as it is not always Grey=confederate and blue is Union)
    I for example could not identify wich state is part of the confederation and wich is not.(at least not for all states) this would be the case for many history-interested ppl from outside the US, like me.

    • @LionHeartFilmWorks
      @LionHeartFilmWorks  6 років тому +7

      The grand plan, after all four Volumes of this series is posted - is to create shorter, more detailed videos about various impressions seen here - focusing on all parts of the uniforms with narration and text on screen pointing things out.

    • @ulrichkalber9039
      @ulrichkalber9039 6 років тому

      sounds great, so this Videos will serve as an overview, with links to the more detailed versions?

    • @fawkeeenset
      @fawkeeenset 6 років тому +3

      Hopefully it will spark interest into independent research. We could make an hour long video to explain each individual look trust me. This gives you a glance at a variety of noted units and equipment

  • @karnevalsjeck1984
    @karnevalsjeck1984 6 років тому

    I love your Videos. You make history so much more realistic. Great. Can you do a Video like this about uniforms of other nations of the 19th century, like prussia for example?

  • @shadowtornado7778
    @shadowtornado7778 6 років тому +16

    These videos are amazing you should do a complete ww1 video for american uniforms

    • @ggousier
      @ggousier 6 років тому

      WW1 it's not very interesting. But the evolution of US army since 1885 till 1918 would be more interesting. The last indian wars to modern warfare. :)

    • @RPM1776
      @RPM1776 6 років тому +5

      WW1 is interesting! They should do British uniforms evolution also.

  • @kevincooper814
    @kevincooper814 6 років тому +2

    The tx volunteer uniform you show is not correct. Black sleeves and black trim in the uniform is NC. North Carolina uniforms always maintained black trim in some form or fashion through out the conflict. Texas volunteer troops primarily wore what is called butternut (a bright brownish tan) uniforms and we're primarily made from jeancloth (a fabric mixture of wool, cotton and sometimes hemp). However in late 1863 Confederate uniforms often we're often mix matched and many replaced there pants with those of federal dead. As 1863 progressed and uniforms became less available, it was common to see eastern theater troops wearing grey jackets and sky blue trousers. However 1861 upon the first call up for state troops in the Confederacy. Many volunteers wore there fathers and grandfather's uniforms from the revolution and Mexican war. Resulting any many different designs colors in styles. But as production increased for the war effort, this issue was resolved.

  • @patrickm946
    @patrickm946 6 років тому +22

    Next time include the army of Tennessee and the trans Mississippi dept uniforms

  • @RasscalGaming
    @RasscalGaming 5 років тому +5

    Should do revolutionary war uniforms

  • @danielhoneycutt3100
    @danielhoneycutt3100 6 років тому

    Great looking kits! I need to check out the braces the ambulance coro feller has on!

  • @robertmoore8632
    @robertmoore8632 6 років тому +1

    A job well done

  • @user-bh4rx8mf8g
    @user-bh4rx8mf8g 6 років тому

    Very interesting videos. Is all the uniform and kit replica/reenactment gear or are they modelling original uniforms from a museum collection?

  • @petitsoldat1497
    @petitsoldat1497 6 років тому +3

    franchement trés bonne vidéo

  • @chris93703
    @chris93703 5 років тому +1

    Wikipedia states the 45th New York Volunteer Infantry was formed in 1861. Why are there no uniforms for them shown before 1863?

  • @rw0341
    @rw0341 6 років тому

    Great work guys

  • @stubby1954
    @stubby1954 5 років тому

    Outstanding work👍

  • @kb4xley
    @kb4xley 6 років тому +1

    simply awesome

  • @uliuli1603
    @uliuli1603 5 років тому +1

    Sehr interesannt wie viele Uniformen es gab !!!War bestimmt nicht leicht sie alle zu sammen zu stellen

  • @sharingtimeagain
    @sharingtimeagain 6 років тому

    It feels like there should be a Volume three but I don't see one. I know they get repetitious. Thanks!

  • @royharel2147
    @royharel2147 6 років тому +2

    Will you present the uniform of Gen. Nathaniel Banks and his ridiculous Chapeau?

  • @chadwickmacarthur4760
    @chadwickmacarthur4760 5 років тому

    My great great granddaddy fought with the 59th northern VA heavey artillery and fought from the beginning to the end ..brave brave man and my grandmomma her daddy's daddy fought as an ambulance driver

  • @MrJsshattuck1103
    @MrJsshattuck1103 6 років тому

    Are the uniforms and poses based on the coloring book from Peter F. Copeland “Civil War Uniform: Coloring Book”? If not this is exactly what it reminds me of. Bravo! Nice work on this.

  • @markaaron8607
    @markaaron8607 6 років тому

    Looks great everyone!

  • @Cole-ui8bi
    @Cole-ui8bi 6 років тому +4

    I want to see the new york Highland regiment

  • @gotonin
    @gotonin 6 років тому +1

    More more please ! Where can i find good sutlers please ?

  • @morganreeves715
    @morganreeves715 6 років тому +2

    Need some western theater a lot of diversity.This video makes me want to always better my impression!

  • @CHORDMARTIN
    @CHORDMARTIN 6 років тому +2

    Some information please. At 5.55 we have a black (coloured) infantryman wearing the blue of the Union Army but belonging to the 1st South Carolina Volunteers. South Carolina was a Confederate state. Could someone explain the the apparent contradiction.

    • @ArkadiBolschek
      @ArkadiBolschek 6 років тому +2

      Dude, google search is your friend: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1st_South_Carolina_Volunteers

    • @baneofbanes
      @baneofbanes 6 років тому +7

      The 1st South Carolina Volunteers was a Union regiment made up of escaped slaves.

    • @CHORDMARTIN
      @CHORDMARTIN 6 років тому +1

      Thanks to you all for your replies. It makes a little more sense now.

  • @Tanakun09
    @Tanakun09 6 років тому

    Awesome, say wasn't their more units and uniforms too. I know you cover 2 parts of the north and south uniforms. Weren't their more from the other states that join in the war

  • @golfingfool777
    @golfingfool777 6 років тому

    Amazing how they ever managed to distinguish friend from enemy on the battlefield! I suppose regimental battle flags were the main identifiers.

  • @jazrobean1
    @jazrobean1 5 років тому

    Thanks

  • @richhoule3462
    @richhoule3462 5 років тому

    This is great!

  • @SteveAubrey1762
    @SteveAubrey1762 5 років тому +2

    The 69th New York! Erin go bragh!

  • @refugeeca
    @refugeeca 5 років тому

    0:38 The 5th NY at 2nd Bull Run: www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/destruction-5th-new-york-zouaves
    4:57 They wore that in their caps because their Irish regimental were getting re-made at the time of the battle and they still wanted to be identifiable.

  • @rejmons1
    @rejmons1 5 років тому +2

    Yours, Americans history is pretty interesting. But I think about something different: 150 years "gone with the wind" and I still can find the hot differences between Southrners and Yankees in US. Blood did not dried completely... So, it was the conflict with the realy important causes! For me, the slavery do not explain the all circumstance and all of the reasons of this conflict.

  • @colarisaka
    @colarisaka 6 років тому

    Beautiful!

  • @countryboy-bu4ek
    @countryboy-bu4ek 5 років тому

    Are some of the bits and bobs of those uniforms original some of those hats look old

  • @KS51ABCAN
    @KS51ABCAN 6 років тому +1

    Awesome.

  • @Dean-jj9qw
    @Dean-jj9qw 6 років тому

    Does anyone know where you can get that 69th NY Cap Device from? I've been scouring all around for one..

  • @romainleblanc1050
    @romainleblanc1050 6 років тому

    Awesome !

  • @samonellauniversity1182
    @samonellauniversity1182 5 років тому +1

    Damn NY of 1862, you were out there😂

  • @dewisant775
    @dewisant775 5 років тому

    I read that Jefferson Davies' father was from Wales. Can any of you incredible re-enactors confirm this?

  • @scotty1464
    @scotty1464 6 років тому +30

    Technically speaking the United States Civil war was not actually a civil war. By definition a civil is, a war between citizens of the same nation, and to secede is to withdraw membership from a federal union or religious organization. You see once the south seceded, they would no longer be considered U.S citizens because, legal or not, they left the Federal Union, thus creating the Confederate States of America, a separate entity with its own laws and government, as well as currency, and army. Now lets go back to the term civil war, now if the southern states never actually left and decided "lets overthrow the government and put in a government that is more in favor of our beliefs!", and then the Northern States opposed that idea, and the two sides went to war, then yes that would be true to the definition of civil war, not to be confused with a revolution, in which the citizens rebel against the government itself. However since the Southern states left the Union, whether legal or not, and formed their own country, it would not, by definition, be a civil war, in fact it would be just a normal war, in which the Union invaded the Confederacy using the claims the secession is illegal, even though there is not really anything solid said in any written law on whether it is legal, at least at that time, and thus wrongfully invaded a country that simply wanted to go about its own way, and leave the Union alone. Understanding this, this would then imply that since the South lost this war, the entirety of the Confederate States, have technically been under occupation of the U.S since the end of the civil war, but you could argue, since there was a formal surrender, that it is not an occupation, but still technically it was not a civil war, but just a normal war between two very similar countries.

  • @rednek666
    @rednek666 6 років тому

    Where do you keep all those costumes guys lol? You are great.Greetings from Ukraine.

  • @AryaWibu
    @AryaWibu 5 років тому +1

    I like this but I really want 6th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry Regiment uniform in this list but it's okay.

  • @Doc_Tar
    @Doc_Tar 6 років тому

    Was there much difference in uniforms between Western and Eastern troops?

  • @35thinfantry14
    @35thinfantry14 6 років тому +1

    Did I miss the confederate Irish brigade or was it not in there

  • @woodlandcreature8857
    @woodlandcreature8857 5 років тому +1

    Why is the South Carolina volunteer wearing Union belt buckle and straps? That's a Confederate unit

  • @houseblacksmithing9836
    @houseblacksmithing9836 5 років тому

    I could have sworn a couple of the Confederates were portrayed by BirdDogg.

  • @Bianconero-ce2ky
    @Bianconero-ce2ky 6 років тому

    i'm surprised you guys didnt do 54th massachusetts...in addition to the 1st north carolina