Mr. Asheer, I personally believe that your this series on Balochistan must be made compulsory to be played in training sessions of Civil Service Academy and PMA. Being a Mengal, first time I am seeing a man delivering such a depth knowledge of our sense of tribalism. Keep it up!
It ha to been n understood by present policy makers in Rawalpindi n Islamabad. If you want this to be seen n understood at grass root level n top people don't agree to this, these kids will forget all this when they will be policy makers 20-30 years later. We need top down education today.
Assalamu Alaikum, Ashir Azeem sahab. I am a Brahvi who has relatives in Balochistan and i love my culture my people and my Balochistan. I have lived my whole my in Karachi but i have same feelings for Balochistan as other Baloch people have. first of all i want to thank you for starting this series and i have got to say something for my culture and my people. No doubt we love Pakistan and i remember when Raheel sharif was the CAOS people of Balochistan celebrated 14th of augest by their will but unfortunately the situation of Balochistan is same as it was before General Raheel Sharif. Pakistanies from other provinces do not understand why this all is happening in Balochistan because they haven't been there as you said. People of Balochistan do not have the facilities that other provinces people have from infrastructure to education system, from judicatory to local governance. In fact in Balochistan the products you get aren't Pakistani. I found only 2 things common between other provinces and Balochistan and those are the Currency and the Mobile networks. Coming to the point. Back in 2014 i was at my khala's place spending my vacations with my family i met a guy (aged 16) who was working in a shop and we became friends he told me its been 3 years i haven't seen my parents i asked him why he said my family lives in khuzdar and there people of my age get disappeared and later their bodies are found in streets so that is ehy i cannot go there. I am not saying its our army ( pak army ) behind it because RAW have always been active there and trying their best to make the situation worse for Pakistan and Balochistan so... But still it was happening and whose responsibility was to control it? Its still happening but again the families do not get justice and also our sardar Akhtar mengal mentioned it many times in assembly to fix this issue but its still there. On this Eid i went to my nanu's place and there i got to know some Baloch people were smuggling diesel and got caught in the middle of mountains and Army took their vehicles and left the drivers there in the mountains as you said its a dry place and they didn't have tools to survive and they died. I have talked to the people there and they said we do not have jobs and we are not that educated so we cannot survive if we do not smuggle irani products ( and its true the general stores wont have anything if they stop smuggling irani products because as i said there are many where there are no Pakistani products so.. ) What i think is Pakistan only cares about CPEC and want gawadar to develop and no doubt the people of Balochistan will get the ultimate benefit from it but they cannot see it in s big picture because gawadar will take sometime to develop and till what will Baloch people do to survive? What i feel Pakistan should take care of Baloch people and give them their rights and make them feel they are being treated the same way the other provinces people being treated. I am totally against BLA and there is no doubt they are being funded by the enemies of Pakistan and doing all these terrorist activities. Balochistani people seeks their rights and if they get their rights trust me terrorist organisations like BLA wont succeed in their missions. And i want you all to understand who are reading this. People of Balochistan love Pakistan the problem is they do not get justice and they do not have the basic rights which other provinces have. I am creating a scenario and want you guys to put yourself in it and tell me what would you do if it happens to you. You are a 14 year old guy working somewhere to support your father to feed your family and you have a brother who is around 17-19 and doing the same thing but suddenly he gets disappeared and next day you find his body next to your door step and you get to know before disappearing people saw him being taken by Armed forces in Uniform. ( You are at the age you can easily get brainwashed and as you are already hurt and broken from inside its the right time organisations like BLA make you feel join them and fight with them ) And who knows it was them who killed his brother to get him and his family on their side? ) If Raheel Shareef made the situation better it can be done again. Long live Pakistan long live Balochistan. Pakistan zindabad.
Whether it's biased or unbiased, but still we need to open dialogue and give some freedom to express their thoughts. I love tribal culture and their traditions. ❤️ From a Pakistani 🇵🇰
@@9114meer some freedom mtlb if u live in Pakistan outside Balochistan, have u ever heard about any tv program, seen any newspaper article or a proper coverage of this issue? Why it's always NATIONAL SECURITY LEVEL THREAT with such issues? May be my coverage is bad but I haven't heard of any such thing . We need to approach them at public lvl, my opinion.
As a Baloch I do respect your thoughts & freedom, so in such a discussion why don't you as a Pakistani ask your military or head of your defence institution a simple question, " What did Your Founding father Mr M.A Jinnah & Your Military both do with Balochistan on 27th of March 1948 ? Thank You
@@yanb1173 So what. No tribal princedom would have survived in the 21st century. If not us than it would have been Afghans or Iran. It was just a matter of time. What makes you think that society would have survived in the 21st center with Bugti's and Murri killing each other. Tribal society needs a thumb for it to grow out of it. No matter what you say tribal system is a primative system which has run its course. Whatver happened on 28th march was for your own good. In an alternate scenrio Balochistan would have been a tribal civil war zone. Get educated educate your children integrate in Pakistan and advocate for provincial rights (for which there is a a chance which the regular paksitani society will accept and go along with it.) Any armed struggle will fail]. Balochistan simply do not have the population to resist the state. If you are going for bangaldesh model than it is not isolted where the military cannot reach them. Only peaceful resistance will bear fruit.
میرا خیال درست ثابت ہوا اور اس پر نہ میں خوش۔ ہوں اور نہ ہی ناراض، کیونکہ دیکھنا یہ ہوتا ہے ک سامنے والا کس کا بیانیہ آگے بڑھایا ہے اور کیوں ؟ جہاں تک بلوچ قبائل کی بات ہے تو اس پر ہم بلوچ فخر کرتے ہیں کہ ہم ہمارے بلوچ معاشرے میں نہ صرف خاندانی نظام کے مالک ہیں بلکہ قبائلی نظام کے بھی مالک ہے کیونکہ ہم بلوچ ایک مکمل قوم ہے اور دنیا میں کسی بھی قومی تشکیل بغیر قبائلی نظام کے ممکن نہیں، یہاں ایک بھائی نے مجھے مسیج میں مری و بگٹی قبائل اور ہمارے ان قبائل کو لے کر مجھے ڈرانے کی کوشش کی ہے، تو عرض یہ ہے کہ بگٹی، مری، ڈومکی، مینگل ، زہری,رند ، لاشاری، مگسی ،لغاری ، مزاری اور ہمارے دوسرے قبائل ہمارے اپنے ہیں اور بلوچ قوم کے خوبصرت بچے ہیں،آپ کو ہمارے ان خوبصورت قبائل کے بارے میں فکرمند ہونے کی کوئی ضرورت نہیں ، جناب
@@AshirAzeemGill sir I belong to District kashmore and we know the tribal culture there but sir how these balochi living in Kandh kot ,jacobad ,and other parts of Sindh are different from the Baloch who are from Balochistan we have all same tradition As I myself being a sindhi Baloch and they are pro state Some of them are landlord,sardars but are pro state.it is clear the problem don't lies on Baloch culture or in their attitude it is because of the land (Balochistan) and resources share which they are deprived of.
Mai Punjab se hu or mujy ye sun kr boht herangi ho rhi ha ye sab mere liye boht new hai Lkin mai next video ka wait Abhi sy kr rhi ho Ashir sir you are great
I was born in Quetta n stayed as part of my professional life in Sui n Dera Buggti in 2006, I can relate to some things but still it's a huge eye opener for me. Thanks Ashir Sb, you have been a visionary from start, I hope to see more creative marvels from you for our youth. Thanks for this effort.
Ashir Azeem Jisne aapki taareef ki hai usko aapne reply kardiyaa hai menay jo upar baat ki hai uskaa jawaab dain plzzzzzzzz k baaki mulk k log as a tourist balochistan jaain tou wo kesay rahay gaa
@@AshirAzeemGill Really appreciating your content about Pakistan and its people. It greatly increased my understandings. What the Britishers said about the punjabis and sindhis ? I am not finding it on Google.
What a great explanation of Baloch tribe Sir make more videos like this Pakistani people need to know about the facts .. Thank you so much sir I am Baloch as well and belong to Rind tribe ❤️
bullshit very nice you try to defend baloch leaders actually there is no difference between baloch sardar and punjabi Chaudhry say openly you are supporting BLF to hell with all baloch sardar which are anti Pakistan and anti country
Ashir bhai ap Allah ka ek khas gift hoo hmare leye, stay blessed apko buhat psand kerta hon ma I am from lahore but Blochistan k keye mera dil buhat dukhta ha buhat psand ha mujhy blouchistan and wahn k log
Sir, i considered myself to be a bit better informed individual, but the way you explained the nomadic life, its impact the consequential forming of tribalism, and the loyalty to the tribe and concept of religion among them, it's astonishing. I didn't know that. Thank you so much, Sir. You're the only who has awakened and shapes my consciousness, my conscience, and my understanding. Whatever i know, it's because of you. I could never learn so much without listening to you, i listen to you everyday with my every meal. Thank you so much.
Sir, Baloch tribal system had been strong till early 70,but today we see a very different reality on the ground in Balochistan where sense of Baloch Nation & Baloch Nationality is much more stronger than any Pakistani imagine & yes there are yet a fewer clans which do move from one place to another in a search of water & Greenery,but due to that it does not mean that Baloch are nomadic any more, the nomadic era has gone due to somehow seizing the opportunity of getting education from very literate Baloch Youths, that's why we on the ground in Balochistan see people of Balochistan being leaded by highly educated & literates Youths of Baloch Nation,
Mr you've earned my respect ! I as a baloch and balochistani cant explain things this well. Keep it up wating for the next video. And you go with the resources on which the baloch is fighting reko diq, saindak and cpec. 👍❤
Aoa I have been watching your videos when you started talking on Balochistan. In this video I honour you as a very good teacher, which reminds me of your dear mother who was our teacher in grammar school. Stay blessed and prosperous sir.
Well elucidated the dynamics of Balochistan. Being local inhabitant of Quetta attracts me to understand the evolution of Quetta from past to present, keeping in view all aspects and opportunities. Kindly made comprehensive video about Quetta earlier at your childhood and teenage and how cold war had impact on beauty of Quetta in different ways. Culturally, economically and ethically. The major reason behind shifting of punjabi settlers to Punjab and Capital, and the status quo of Quetta. Regards
Excellence personified...Ashir Azeem Sir, what a masterpiece in-depth analysis of Baloch society.. I must say these facts must be taught in every education sector of Pakistan
Sir baki batain tw chorain ye jo musical instrument add kiya hai aap ne start aur akhar mn it is amazing👍👍.. Jokes aside sir really getting entertained by the amazing discussion on Balochistan...Much needed discussion... Balochistan should be taken seriously by Army and Parliament both.May God bless you.Fiaman illah🌻🤍💚♥️🇵🇰
As a Pakistani who born n grew up in middleeast i understand about the nomad tribal system, whatever you are saying is 100% correct. Thats how a tribesmen thinks and carry out social life.
Fascinating insights into the Baloch culture. It is a culture that we know so little about. Please keep uploading these videos on aspects of Baloch culture.
I wish the Sardars of Balochistan had tried to use their voice and explained us these concepts. Great work sir. Keep going. Now I can’t wait for the next part. Also the educated people of balochistan must use social media to spread the word across about their cultures and heritage just like Ashir bhai. People underestimate the power of social media but if used correctly it can shape narratives and achieve results far better than any war or insurgency.
It's a pleasure to have across your videos. I love how you think and the clarity in your approach. There are few thing's I'm sure can provide a different prospective, in how thing's could be viewed. But I just want to absorb your view's, because this talk has been a pure pleasurable experience. Stay blessed. Love Balochistan, Love Pakistan.
Jab se Gaddar aur chor iqtedar me ayeh han har us shaks ki yaad ati he jo mukhlis he is mulk se, ap bhi unlogon me shamil han jinhe dil se yaad kiya jaye, khair se rahain duniya me jaha rahain
@@Ali-ld6tg ٹرائبل بن کر بھی رہنا ہے تو لازمی ہے ترقی بھی نہیں ہو گی اور پھر پنجاب کو گالیاں بھی دینی ہے اپنی محرومیوں کا الزام بھی پنجاب پر لگانا ہے خود کچھ نہیں کرنا.
@@faisalazeem4074 janab think tank bankar beth jayein ap pm ke pas, aesi batien bahir ap jesi wohi karta ha jiski koi sunta nahi, magar each to their own.
@@mh3558 and @Shahzada Fahad: You may search by yourself but just for sake of proof, Just read first page of book by Paul Titus "Honor the Baloch, Buy the Pushtun" Published by Cambridge. Else read the book "Pakistan And The Emergence Of Islamic Militancy In Afghanistan" OR read "A History of Pashtun Migration 1775-2006" by Robert Nichols.
Hum Srf Azadii Chahte Hain ,Chaye Sardars Humaray Sath dein ya na dein , Balochistan ki Logon Ab Important hai woh hai Azadii. #AzadBalochistanZindgbaat❤️💙💚
I'm Faheem Baloch here I appreciate you for this series Baloch are Victim's Baloch are not secure even in every place in pakistan not only in Balochistan
Sir, Please me say one basic thing that Baloch is an agricultural nation, its basic economy is based on sea foods , " Fishing, Agriculture & livestocks,it was Britisher which hit Baloch unity, Society & economy by dividing Baloch Nation into three parts in the name of Forward policy & then Backwards policy,
While doing balochistan dairies, please do invite zafar mairaj sahib and ayub khoso sahib. They might not represent sardars of balochistan but they and people like them describes balochistan in best ways. They and people like them(from media) are exceptions from the same society and culture. And they represent that culture really well from their way of communication to their body language. The intellect and beauty in their words(specially zafar mairaj sahib) is something that actually pushed me to learn about balochistan. I hope you will invite people like them to explain "balochistan "
may allah bless you for spreading the truth. may allah bless balochistan with peace and prosperity. may the balochs be the most educated and richest people of pakistan.
AOA, Thanks for bringing up most needed talk for BALOCHISTAN. All those who never visited this wonderfully awesome land, can consult the book "BALOCHISTAN" ( conflict of narrative) by Fida Hussain Malik, for better understanding of this beautiful province.
Aoa. Sir zbrdst speach apki ,but mera question ye hy k , province k pass jo powers hain wo kis trah kam kr rhi hy , jasa k ap ny Punjab ki bat k yahan pr 2013-18 tk shabaz sharif ki govt thi tu us ny Punjab ma bhut si development krwai, federal sy b ziada us ny province ma kam kia. Ub ap ye b btain jo province ki upni strength hy after 18 amendment , uska qsoor war ap kis ko qrar dain gy,
Proud 👏 of you Balochistan k best man Ham Balochistan sy hy Mujy kabi job nahi mili May abroad a gai But may socti ho k System ko change kerna chye Jo k Ab slowly slowly ho raha hy But meri life k best time may ny Gawa diya
Brilliant 👏👏👏. Being a Pathan and being apart of some small "jirgas" for the first time in recent past, ur interpretation of the the Baloch and pashtoon cultural system is simply the best. It will b easier for those whom r belong to such backgrounds to understand those points. For those who are not Baloch/Pathan, while writing this I really want to use the word "Sir" for the speaker but a power from my roots doesn't allow me to use it. I'm not able to explain that state of mine but it is a fact. Couldn't understand, why people of ur caliber are not in the country on the position which they actually deserve. This is first time I'm listening to u cause of Shari Baloch's incident and cause of I really like Baloch from childhood due to their level of confidence and bravery
Excellent. A sincere and neutral explanation of issues towards understanding the relationship between real issues and our stereotypical thinking about Baluchistan and others too. We think the way we had been indoctrinated over the time throughout the short history of our country. We have to realise and recognise that there are nations within the nation that aspect must be respected and every nation should get a fair share in every situation. BTW, I watched your both episodes and will continue watching till the end of the series on Baluchistan.
Eid Mubarak to you & your Family ...... Also ,,,,, May God shower you with blessings, love, and peace this Easter. Have a blessed holiday filled with happiness, love, and faith.
Good about you is that you lift the subject from basic history and conceptual level that is very pertinent Your feeds have started pouring in my Notification 🔔 I found these interesting 🤔 and intelligent 🧠 I broadly agree with you and suggest a full research work for you as PhD dissertation or even Book Your views on establishment Blochistan and basic sociality and life style are simple and well explained You do nice 👍🙂 logical and meaningful talk
Bohat achi discussion lekn afsos k sun bohat kam loag rahe hen. Sir mostly logon ko specially punjab se unko smjhana mushkil hota hai k ap Balochistan ko punjab k dynamics ki tarha mat dekho. Phr bhe unko smjh nhe ati aur bari baat k unko interest he nhe Balochistan ko smjhne ki ma siwa Gawadar jese mega projects k. Bara Acha laga apki ye video dekhne se.
AP ya kesa keh sakhta ho hum Punjabi kabi baloch ko hud sa alag nahi samjata likin ap bi too dekho huma aj thek ek news bi baloch ka bara ma nahi batai gai
Good initative to explain the history and culture of Balochistan first as many people in Pakistan don't even know the name of the capital of Balochistan or understand the geography of Balochistan and Baloch tradition.
I googled it but didn't found content like British thoughts about Sindhis and punjabis .but found your quoted statement only .can you elaborate or give me reference.
Ashar Sahib, i appreciate your effort and absolutely agree, pls bring them ffwd and let them speak so that we hear their narrative. it's been always difficult to source it properly. being from central Punjab and raised in end 80's-early 90's it was hard to decide what is the actual issue. keep it up.
Ashir bhai you are right Balochs are more secular than punjabis. I have spent my days of university with Balochi students very nice and loving people. But I think punjabis adopt the change rapidly. That has been going on even before the British raj. Many rulers came into India and the resistance they faced from punjab is low if compared to other states. Thats probably the reason the kings and british used to appoint punjabis on high ranked jobs. And developed the infrastructure.
Yes that's what he mentioned when he said that briritsh had different ways to buy different nations of the region , they bought pakhtun by money , Baloch by owner and punjabi's by buying there loyalties . . . Punjabi's were not much the part of beurocracy by education but they secured their interest by giving the loyalties to new raj Mughal or British or modern age . . .
Dear sir Aoa! First of thank you so much for telling everybody about baluchistan it's highly needed! As I am also the aspirant of css/pcs from khuzdar baluchistan and its really helpful to understand the current issues! My question to you is where punjab and other provicses talk about the economical development strengthen the country etc why baluchistan specially its district are still in need of basic necessities of life? All those sardars or nawab who have became part of government multiple times are not equal responsible for this deprivation, Why the development factor for baluchistan was missing in their leadership?
He has some sardar/nawab friends he keeps mentioning throughout his videos. He is glorifying the sardari nizam to please them even if that flares up racist tensions in the country. He has nothing to lose anyway because he isn't in Pakistan anymore.
When there are multiple stake holders then even nawabs and sardars can’t do anything consider example of kashmir. They don’t have great leaders still they are suffering because of multiple stake holders. None of them wants to lose it and results in underdevelopment of the area.
Balochistan ka area bohat large ha aur sab log aik city me ni rehte isliye development kar na bohat mushkil ha gove ko chahiye large city bane jaise lahore, karachi takhe development karna easy ho
In my personal prospective i highly request that this should be ask to any of guest speaker who had been part of Government that why the people to so called rich province are so much poor and still figting for the basic necessities? What was contribution of their regime in the development of province?
@@faizaarslan288The whole of Pakistan is poor, there isn't much difference. Often facts are manipulated facts to shape a certain narrative. Only thing keeping people backward in Pakistan is backward thinking. Here are the facts. 1. 20% of the whole population of Pakistan has access to safe drinking water, so 15% in Baluchistan is not a big difference. 2. 32% of Pakistani children are out of school with 47% in Baluchistan, 44% in Sindh which is quite small compared to 60% in Kohistan region in KP. 3. If 47% children are stunted in Baluchistan the it is 37% in Punjab, 41.3% in Sindh and 48% in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. 4. Hospital beds per 1000 people in Pakistan are 9 in Federal, 389 in Punjab, 473 in Sindh, 277 in KP and 134 in Baluchistan. Which again isn't much of a difference considering the bulk of the population in the province is nomadic. And by the yardstick foreign agents are justifying the terrorists, people living in the Federal territory should start blowing them up because they are the most deprived in hospitals.
Pushtons arrived in Balochistan after the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan very few pushtons normads used to come and go from Afghanistan and Balochistan. So technically by and large Balochistan was inhabited by Balochs.
Mr. Asheer, I personally believe that your this series on Balochistan must be made compulsory to be played in training sessions of Civil Service Academy and PMA.
Being a Mengal, first time I am seeing a man delivering such a depth knowledge of our sense of tribalism. Keep it up!
bcz He is a True Pakistani & Also from Balochistan ❣️🇵🇰
It ha to been n understood by present policy makers in Rawalpindi n Islamabad. If you want this to be seen n understood at grass root level n top people don't agree to this, these kids will forget all this when they will be policy makers 20-30 years later. We need top down education today.
I recommend this statement fully
Assalamu Alaikum, Ashir Azeem sahab.
I am a Brahvi who has relatives in Balochistan and i love my culture my people and my Balochistan.
I have lived my whole my in Karachi but i have same feelings for Balochistan as other Baloch people have. first of all i want to thank you for starting this series and i have got to say something for my culture and my people.
No doubt we love Pakistan and i remember when Raheel sharif was the CAOS people of Balochistan celebrated 14th of augest by their will but unfortunately the situation of Balochistan is same as it was before General Raheel Sharif.
Pakistanies from other provinces do not understand why this all is happening in Balochistan because they haven't been there as you said.
People of Balochistan do not have the facilities that other provinces people have from infrastructure to education system, from judicatory to local governance.
In fact in Balochistan the products you get aren't Pakistani.
I found only 2 things common between other provinces and Balochistan and those are the Currency and the Mobile networks.
Coming to the point.
Back in 2014 i was at my khala's place spending my vacations with my family i met a guy (aged 16) who was working in a shop and we became friends he told me its been 3 years i haven't seen my parents i asked him why he said my family lives in khuzdar and there people of my age get disappeared and later their bodies are found in streets so that is ehy i cannot go there.
I am not saying its our army ( pak army ) behind it because RAW have always been active there and trying their best to make the situation worse for Pakistan and Balochistan so...
But still it was happening and whose responsibility was to control it?
Its still happening but again the families do not get justice and also our sardar Akhtar mengal mentioned it many times in assembly to fix this issue but its still there.
On this Eid i went to my nanu's place and there i got to know some Baloch people were smuggling diesel and got caught in the middle of mountains and Army took their vehicles and left the drivers there in the mountains as you said its a dry place and they didn't have tools to survive and they died.
I have talked to the people there and they said we do not have jobs and we are not that educated so we cannot survive if we do not smuggle irani products ( and its true the general stores wont have anything if they stop smuggling irani products because as i said there are many where there are no Pakistani products so.. )
What i think is Pakistan only cares about CPEC and want gawadar to develop and no doubt the people of Balochistan will get the ultimate benefit from it but they cannot see it in s big picture because gawadar will take sometime to develop and till what will Baloch people do to survive?
What i feel Pakistan should take care of Baloch people and give them their rights and make them feel they are being treated the same way the other provinces people being treated.
I am totally against BLA and there is no doubt they are being funded by the enemies of Pakistan and doing all these terrorist activities.
Balochistani people seeks their rights and if they get their rights trust me terrorist organisations like BLA wont succeed in their missions.
And i want you all to understand who are reading this.
People of Balochistan love Pakistan the problem is they do not get justice and they do not have the basic rights which other provinces have.
I am creating a scenario and want you guys to put yourself in it and tell me what would you do if it happens to you.
You are a 14 year old guy working somewhere to support your father to feed your family and you have a brother who is around 17-19 and doing the same thing but suddenly he gets disappeared and next day you find his body next to your door step and you get to know before disappearing people saw him being taken by Armed forces in Uniform.
( You are at the age you can easily get brainwashed and as you are already hurt and broken from inside its the right time organisations like BLA make you feel join them and fight with them )
And who knows it was them who killed his brother to get him and his family on their side? )
If Raheel Shareef made the situation better it can be done again.
Long live Pakistan long live Balochistan.
Pakistan zindabad.
Very nice, an eye opening analysis
Your videos are always enlightening. You are a teacher. Huge respect for you. Stay safe and blessed!
Whether it's biased or unbiased, but still we need to open dialogue and give some freedom to express their thoughts. I love tribal culture and their traditions. ❤️ From a Pakistani 🇵🇰
Define somefreedom
@@9114meer some freedom mtlb if u live in Pakistan outside Balochistan, have u ever heard about any tv program, seen any newspaper article or a proper coverage of this issue? Why it's always NATIONAL SECURITY LEVEL THREAT with such issues? May be my coverage is bad but I haven't heard of any such thing . We need to approach them at public lvl, my opinion.
As a Baloch I do respect your thoughts & freedom, so in such a discussion why don't you as a Pakistani ask your military or head of your defence institution a simple question, " What did Your Founding father Mr M.A Jinnah & Your Military both do with Balochistan on 27th of March 1948 ?
Thank You
@@yanb1173 So what. No tribal princedom would have survived in the 21st century. If not us than it would have been Afghans or Iran. It was just a matter of time. What makes you think that society would have survived in the 21st center with Bugti's and Murri killing each other. Tribal society needs a thumb for it to grow out of it. No matter what you say tribal system is a primative system which has run its course. Whatver happened on 28th march was for your own good. In an alternate scenrio Balochistan would have been a tribal civil war zone. Get educated educate your children integrate in Pakistan and advocate for provincial rights (for which there is a a chance which the regular paksitani society will accept and go along with it.) Any armed struggle will fail]. Balochistan simply do not have the population to resist the state. If you are going for bangaldesh model than it is not isolted where the military cannot reach them. Only peaceful resistance will bear fruit.
میرا خیال درست ثابت ہوا اور اس پر نہ میں خوش۔ ہوں اور نہ ہی ناراض، کیونکہ دیکھنا یہ ہوتا ہے ک سامنے والا کس کا بیانیہ آگے بڑھایا ہے اور کیوں ؟
جہاں تک بلوچ قبائل کی بات ہے تو اس پر ہم بلوچ فخر کرتے ہیں کہ ہم ہمارے بلوچ معاشرے میں نہ صرف خاندانی نظام کے مالک ہیں بلکہ قبائلی نظام کے بھی مالک ہے کیونکہ ہم بلوچ ایک مکمل قوم ہے اور دنیا میں کسی بھی قومی تشکیل بغیر قبائلی نظام کے ممکن نہیں، یہاں ایک بھائی نے مجھے مسیج میں مری و بگٹی قبائل اور ہمارے ان قبائل کو لے کر مجھے ڈرانے کی کوشش کی ہے، تو عرض یہ ہے کہ بگٹی، مری، ڈومکی، مینگل ، زہری,رند ، لاشاری، مگسی ،لغاری ، مزاری اور ہمارے دوسرے قبائل ہمارے اپنے ہیں اور بلوچ قوم کے خوبصرت بچے ہیں،آپ کو ہمارے ان خوبصورت قبائل کے بارے میں فکرمند ہونے کی کوئی ضرورت نہیں ، جناب
You're a man of wisdom par excellence. I'm a speech disabled person yet i love to listen to you.
Thank you Hadees. I am humbled.
@@AshirAzeemGill Much respect for you Dear Aashir Azeem Gill bhai.
@@AshirAzeemGill
British formula:
“Rule the Punjabis, intimidate the Sindhis, buy the Pakhtun, and honour the Baloch.”
@@AshirAzeemGill sir I belong to District kashmore and we know the tribal culture there but sir how these balochi living in Kandh kot ,jacobad ,and other parts of Sindh are different from the Baloch who are from Balochistan we have all same tradition As I myself being a sindhi Baloch and they are pro state
Some of them are landlord,sardars but are pro state.it is clear the problem don't lies on Baloch culture or in their attitude it is because of the land (Balochistan) and resources share which they are deprived of.
Mai Punjab se hu or mujy ye sun kr boht herangi ho rhi ha ye sab mere liye boht new hai
Lkin mai next video ka wait Abhi sy kr rhi ho
Ashir sir you are great
I was born in Quetta n stayed as part of my professional life in Sui n Dera Buggti in 2006, I can relate to some things but still it's a huge eye opener for me. Thanks Ashir Sb, you have been a visionary from start, I hope to see more creative marvels from you for our youth.
Thanks for this effort.
We have lost a man like you, it is really a big loss of Pakistan Sir. Thanks for teachings thanks for ur services. Stay blessed Sir.
🙏🏼
Don't think Ashar Azeem as lost anywhere. He is doing better than many of those who r around us.
Ashir Azeem
Jisne aapki taareef ki hai usko aapne reply kardiyaa hai menay jo upar baat ki hai uskaa jawaab dain plzzzzzzzz k baaki mulk k log as a tourist balochistan jaain tou wo kesay rahay gaa
@@AshirAzeemGill Really appreciating your content about Pakistan and its people. It greatly increased my understandings. What the Britishers said about the punjabis and sindhis ? I am not finding it on Google.
@@MuhammadYasir-ld2jv the Britishers said, “Buy the Pathans, rule the Punjabis, intimidate the Sindhis & honour the Baloch.”
Murshid ! Being a Bochistani Ap ny Haq Adda Kar diya 🙏 plzz continue Respect Love Dua from Chaman 🇵🇰🌹
Very well explained Sir! We must understand each other and respect each other …… it’s never too late let’s start now and save Pakistan 🙏
Greetings from Mauritius 🇲🇺, how well explained, I am an expert on baluchistan. Hope it'll help pak government to resolve their issues 🙏
Great... You should also spread awareness
Thank you very much for this video Asher sahab. You are literally grooming us...
What a great explanation of Baloch tribe Sir make more videos like this Pakistani people need to know about the facts .. Thank you so much sir I am Baloch as well and belong to Rind tribe ❤️
bullshit very nice you try to defend baloch leaders actually there is no difference between baloch sardar and punjabi Chaudhry say openly you are supporting BLF to hell with all baloch sardar which are anti Pakistan and anti country
Ashir bhai ap Allah ka ek khas gift hoo hmare leye, stay blessed apko buhat psand kerta hon ma I am from lahore but Blochistan k keye mera dil buhat dukhta ha buhat psand ha mujhy blouchistan and wahn k log
Cannot put in words the enormous respect you’ve earned within my heart🙏🏻🙏🏻 God bless you sir Ashir Azeem, you’re an inspiration to many🙏🏻
My Question!
Agar development barra issue hota tou Balochistan k Pashtun bhe insurgency ki taraf jaate. I am confused!
@@irfanali-nn5xf
Ptm, ttp, taliban ye sub kaun hain pir?
@@irfanali-nn5xf 🤣🤣🤣
@@jibranbaloch7650 یہ سب افغانستان کے ایجنٹ ہیں
@@irfanali-nn5xf ttp and taliban tou sindhis ne banayi? Ya seraiki?
Nice program defining Baloch as Shepherds! Few people must be knowing it!
Ashir bhae Pakistan hv been blessed with great minds including you. Wish you could come back & give back to your country in any capacity.
Sir, i considered myself to be a bit better informed individual, but the way you explained the nomadic life, its impact the consequential forming of tribalism, and the loyalty to the tribe and concept of religion among them, it's astonishing. I didn't know that. Thank you so much, Sir. You're the only who has awakened and shapes my consciousness, my conscience, and my understanding. Whatever i know, it's because of you. I could never learn so much without listening to you, i listen to you everyday with my every meal. Thank you so much.
Humbled 🙏🏼
Sir,
Baloch tribal system had been strong till early 70,but today we see a very different reality on the ground in Balochistan where sense of Baloch Nation & Baloch Nationality is much more stronger than any Pakistani imagine & yes there are yet a fewer clans which do move from one place to another in a search of water & Greenery,but due to that it does not mean that Baloch are nomadic any more, the nomadic era has gone due to somehow seizing the opportunity of getting education from very literate Baloch Youths, that's why we on the ground in Balochistan see people of Balochistan being leaded by highly educated & literates Youths of Baloch Nation,
Mr you've earned my respect ! I as a baloch and balochistani cant explain things this well. Keep it up wating for the next video. And you go with the resources on which the baloch is fighting reko diq, saindak and cpec. 👍❤
Aoa
I have been watching your videos when you started talking on Balochistan. In this video I honour you as a very good teacher, which reminds me of your dear mother who was our teacher in grammar school. Stay blessed and prosperous sir.
Great Episode on Balochistan..... well narrated, and Logical .... thank you sir....
God bless Ashir bhai, I was keenly waiting for this second episode.
Thank you so much sir for deeply observing baloch people and Balochistan issues
You are doing nice work. Rightly said, we are not on the same page. We have to accept the differences to clearly define the issues
Very beautifully explained, especially the differences of Punjabi n Balochistani sardars
Khair Mubarak. Informative. You always provide different angle to understand all the concepts. Ashir brother Red Salute to you. ❤❤🇵🇰
Well elucidated the dynamics of Balochistan.
Being local inhabitant of Quetta attracts me to understand the evolution of Quetta from past to present, keeping in view all aspects and opportunities.
Kindly made comprehensive video about Quetta earlier at your childhood and teenage and how cold war had impact on beauty of Quetta in different ways. Culturally, economically and ethically.
The major reason behind shifting of punjabi settlers to Punjab and Capital, and the status quo of Quetta.
Regards
excellent sir
Excellence personified...Ashir Azeem Sir, what a masterpiece in-depth analysis of Baloch society.. I must say these facts must be taught in every education sector of Pakistan
Sir baki batain tw chorain ye jo musical instrument add kiya hai aap ne start aur akhar mn it is amazing👍👍..
Jokes aside sir really getting entertained by the amazing discussion on Balochistan...Much needed discussion... Balochistan should be taken seriously by Army and Parliament both.May God bless you.Fiaman illah🌻🤍💚♥️🇵🇰
As a Pakistani who born n grew up in middleeast i understand about the nomad tribal system, whatever you are saying is 100% correct. Thats how a tribesmen thinks and carry out social life.
The set is amazing and the warmth coming out is really enjoyable.
This is Ashar from Lahore. Lot of love from me to you great Ashir Azeem..Take Care
Fascinating insights into the Baloch culture. It is a culture that we know so little about. Please keep uploading these videos on aspects of Baloch culture.
I wish the Sardars of Balochistan had tried to use their voice and explained us these concepts. Great work sir. Keep going. Now I can’t wait for the next part.
Also the educated people of balochistan must use social media to spread the word across about their cultures and heritage just like Ashir bhai. People underestimate the power of social media but if used correctly it can shape narratives and achieve results far better than any war or insurgency.
It's a pleasure to have across your videos. I love how you think and the clarity in your approach.
There are few thing's I'm sure can provide a different prospective, in how thing's could be viewed. But I just want to absorb your view's, because this talk has been a pure pleasurable experience. Stay blessed.
Love Balochistan, Love Pakistan.
Be honest I feel ashamed because we lost such kind of amazing mind.stay blessed sir 😊
Sadly Majority of Pakistanis can't tolerate sincere and intellectual people
Thank you for enlightenment, that Dark blue sky is my favorite.
Ashir sir please continue the 2nd part of overseas voting rights.very interesting discussion that was
Always love to listen to you sir! Glad to know that you are also from Quetta,A true son of of soil
You are the very best,I don't want another one. God bless you sir
Sir great initiative!
You are doing a wonderful job!
Jab se Gaddar aur chor iqtedar me ayeh han har us shaks ki yaad ati he jo mukhlis he is mulk se, ap bhi unlogon me shamil han jinhe dil se yaad kiya jaye, khair se rahain duniya me jaha rahain
Very informative! I never knew about the structure of Baloch tribes. Farmers vs the nomads. Feudal differences. Thank you sir.
Sab log pehle tribal hi the bus yeh log apne ap ko transform ni kar pahe
@@Ali-ld6tg 😂😂😂😂ایسی باتیں نہیں کرتے ان لوگوں کو پیچس لگ جاتے ہیں
@@Ali-ld6tg ٹرائبل بن کر بھی رہنا ہے تو لازمی ہے ترقی بھی نہیں ہو گی اور پھر پنجاب کو گالیاں بھی دینی ہے اپنی محرومیوں کا الزام بھی پنجاب پر لگانا ہے خود کچھ نہیں کرنا.
@@faisalazeem4074 janab think tank bankar beth jayein ap pm ke pas, aesi batien bahir ap jesi wohi karta ha jiski koi sunta nahi, magar each to their own.
@@Ali-ld6tg 🤦🏻♂️
I have no words to express my respect and thanks to you
Love meeting u just for Gossips n understating
Aphorism (believed to be a British formula): “Rule the Punjabis, intimidate the Sindhis, buy the Pakhtun, and honour the Baloch.”
I was curious and couldn't find it on google. Thanks for sharing it.
Assalamu aliakum Thanks for sharing brother
Proof please
@@mh3558 and @Shahzada Fahad: You may search by yourself but just for sake of proof, Just read first page of book by Paul Titus "Honor the Baloch, Buy the Pushtun" Published by Cambridge. Else read the book "Pakistan And The Emergence Of Islamic Militancy In Afghanistan" OR read "A History of Pashtun Migration 1775-2006" by Robert Nichols.
@@shahzadafahad3412 you are wrong bro he is right word by word read the book by Paul titus and please Don't disrespect sindhi they are lovely people
Ashir Azeem Shb ko regular sun'nay walla banda yahan Pakistan main kasi be choti moti University ka easily lecturer lag sakta hai.
Love & Respect
Great stuff..
What's heartening to know that even without main stream media the public are still interested and want to help and understand..
Hum Srf Azadii Chahte Hain ,Chaye Sardars Humaray Sath dein ya na dein , Balochistan ki Logon Ab Important hai woh hai Azadii.
#AzadBalochistanZindgbaat❤️💙💚
I'm Faheem Baloch here I appreciate you for this series Baloch are Victim's Baloch are not secure even in every place in pakistan not only in Balochistan
Sir,
Please me say one basic thing that Baloch is an agricultural nation, its basic economy is based on sea foods , " Fishing, Agriculture & livestocks,it was Britisher which hit Baloch unity, Society & economy by dividing Baloch Nation into three parts in the name of Forward policy & then Backwards policy,
While doing balochistan dairies, please do invite zafar mairaj sahib and ayub khoso sahib. They might not represent sardars of balochistan but they and people like them describes balochistan in best ways. They and people like them(from media) are exceptions from the same society and culture. And they represent that culture really well from their way of communication to their body language. The intellect and beauty in their words(specially zafar mairaj sahib) is something that actually pushed me to learn about balochistan. I hope you will invite people like them to explain "balochistan "
may allah bless you for spreading the truth. may allah bless balochistan with peace and prosperity. may the balochs be the most educated and richest people of pakistan.
Brilliantly explained. Loving this series on Balochistan! Please keep uploading more frequently.
AOA, Thanks for bringing up most needed talk for BALOCHISTAN.
All those who never visited this wonderfully awesome land, can consult the book "BALOCHISTAN" ( conflict of narrative) by Fida Hussain Malik, for better understanding of this beautiful province.
Aoa. Sir zbrdst speach apki ,but mera question ye hy k , province k pass jo powers hain wo kis trah kam kr rhi hy , jasa k ap ny Punjab ki bat k yahan pr 2013-18 tk shabaz sharif ki govt thi tu us ny Punjab ma bhut si development krwai, federal sy b ziada us ny province ma kam kia. Ub ap ye b btain jo province ki upni strength hy after 18 amendment , uska qsoor war ap kis ko qrar dain gy,
Sir khairmubarak from my and your's PAKISTAN.
Sir God bless you 🙏 . I am truly realy inspired from your thoughts and vision for country.
Beautiful examples you give sir,we need to understand Pakistan's other provinces as well, very good rewiew
#Most patriotic & beautiful son of Pakistan 🙌❣
Miss you in Pakistan 😥
Proud 👏 of you
Balochistan k best man
Ham Balochistan sy hy
Mujy kabi job nahi mili
May abroad a gai
But may socti ho k
System ko change kerna chye
Jo k Ab slowly slowly ho raha hy
But meri life k best time may ny Gawa diya
Pak be konsi job ha koi
Brilliant 👏👏👏. Being a Pathan and being apart of some small "jirgas" for the first time in recent past, ur interpretation of the the Baloch and pashtoon cultural system is simply the best. It will b easier for those whom r belong to such backgrounds to understand those points.
For those who are not Baloch/Pathan, while writing this I really want to use the word "Sir" for the speaker but a power from my roots doesn't allow me to use it. I'm not able to explain that state of mine but it is a fact.
Couldn't understand, why people of ur caliber are not in the country on the position which they actually deserve.
This is first time I'm listening to u cause of Shari Baloch's incident and cause of I really like Baloch from childhood due to their level of confidence and bravery
We all are Muslims, We all should stay together and help each other without judging.
Excellent. A sincere and neutral explanation of issues towards understanding the relationship between real issues and our stereotypical thinking about Baluchistan and others too. We think the way we had been indoctrinated over the time throughout the short history of our country. We have to realise and recognise that there are nations within the nation that aspect must be respected and every nation should get a fair share in every situation. BTW, I watched your both episodes and will continue watching till the end of the series on Baluchistan.
Eid Mubarak to you & your Family ...... Also ,,,,, May God shower you with blessings, love, and peace this Easter.
Have a blessed holiday filled with happiness, love, and faith.
You are True pakistani... Pakistan na apki Qadar ni ki.. per phir bhi ap Pakistan k liye bth krty hein.. Love u Ashir Azeem.. You are True Pakistani..
Excellent coverage ! Very good job Sir !
Khair Mubarak sir apko or apki family ko bhi bhtt bht mubark ho.
Well explained, Concise and detailed. looking forward to the next episode. Keep it up
Excellent analysis💯👍 🌹❤🌹
Reality based talks 💯💯💯👍
Good about you is that you lift the subject from basic history and conceptual level that is very pertinent
Your feeds have started pouring in my Notification 🔔 I found these interesting 🤔 and intelligent 🧠
I broadly agree with you and suggest a full research work for you as PhD dissertation or even Book
Your views on establishment Blochistan and basic sociality and life style are simple and well explained
You do nice 👍🙂 logical and meaningful talk
❤ AoA Sir hope all well an excellent program 👍 stay always blessed with Aafiyat with your family Ameen
EXCELLENT PRESENTATION WITH COMPLETE GRIP.
Bohat achi discussion lekn afsos k sun bohat kam loag rahe hen. Sir mostly logon ko specially punjab se unko smjhana mushkil hota hai k ap Balochistan ko punjab k dynamics ki tarha mat dekho. Phr bhe unko smjh nhe ati aur bari baat k unko interest he nhe Balochistan ko smjhne ki ma siwa Gawadar jese mega projects k. Bara Acha laga apki ye video dekhne se.
🙏🏼
AP ya kesa keh sakhta ho hum Punjabi kabi baloch ko hud sa alag nahi samjata likin ap bi too dekho huma aj thek ek news bi baloch ka bara ma nahi batai gai
According to British:
“Rule the Punjabis, intimidate the Sindhis, buy the Pakhtun, and honour the Baloch.”
Love and respect from Pakistan sir.
I like your way of given accurate knowledge about Balochs.
Good initative to explain the history and culture of Balochistan first as many people in Pakistan don't even know the name of the capital of Balochistan or understand the geography of Balochistan and Baloch tradition.
Humanity matters . We must respect all the human beings. I pray for peace and prosperity of the region and world 🌍
عاشربھائی ! کشمیر ایشو پہ بھی بات کریں کسی دن ۔ آ یا اس کا جامع اور قابل قبول حل کیا ہو سکتا ہے ؟ اس کے نہ حل ہونے کی وجوہات کیا ہیں ۔
Behtreen.
May Allah halp you.ameen
Bahut acchi video. Very informative video.
I googled it but didn't found content like British thoughts about Sindhis and punjabis .but found your quoted statement only .can you elaborate or give me reference.
I want the reference too
“Rule the Punjabis, intimidate the Sindhis,
@@Ali-ld6tg thanks 😊
Big fan of your’s sir… all the way from india 🙏
Waiting for next episode
How the deserted honoured Baloch Lovely people can be digested in Pakistani parliamentary setup
Ashar Sahib, i appreciate your effort and absolutely agree, pls bring them ffwd and let them speak so that we hear their narrative. it's been always difficult to source it properly. being from central Punjab and raised in end 80's-early 90's it was hard to decide what is the actual issue. keep it up.
Sir I think Balochistan need food, energy, water, business and justice for missing People.
Ashir bhai you are right Balochs are more secular than punjabis. I have spent my days of university with Balochi students very nice and loving people. But I think punjabis adopt the change rapidly. That has been going on even before the British raj. Many rulers came into India and the resistance they faced from punjab is low if compared to other states. Thats probably the reason the kings and british used to appoint punjabis on high ranked jobs. And developed the infrastructure.
Yes that's what he mentioned when he said that briritsh had different ways to buy different nations of the region , they bought pakhtun by money , Baloch by owner and punjabi's by buying there loyalties . . . Punjabi's were not much the part of beurocracy by education but they secured their interest by giving the loyalties to new raj Mughal or British or modern age . . .
Baloch are more seculars because beside muslims how many non muslims were in Balochistan like in Punjab around 40% ( sikhs, hindus)
@@hamzamehmood1976 nope can't say that without a consensus. . .
Sir, Is "The Balochistan conundrum by Tilak Devasher" a reliable book ?
Khair Mubraq apko b sir Eid Mubaraq
Dear sir Aoa! First of thank you so much for telling everybody about baluchistan it's highly needed! As I am also the aspirant of css/pcs from khuzdar baluchistan and its really helpful to understand the current issues! My question to you is where punjab and other provicses talk about the economical development strengthen the country etc why baluchistan specially its district are still in need of basic necessities of life? All those sardars or nawab who have became part of government multiple times are not equal responsible for this deprivation, Why the development factor for baluchistan was missing in their leadership?
He has some sardar/nawab friends he keeps mentioning throughout his videos. He is glorifying the sardari nizam to please them even if that flares up racist tensions in the country. He has nothing to lose anyway because he isn't in Pakistan anymore.
When there are multiple stake holders then even nawabs and sardars can’t do anything consider example of kashmir. They don’t have great leaders still they are suffering because of multiple stake holders. None of them wants to lose it and results in underdevelopment of the area.
Balochistan ka area bohat large ha aur sab log aik city me ni rehte isliye development kar na bohat mushkil ha gove ko chahiye large city bane jaise lahore, karachi takhe development karna easy ho
In my personal prospective i highly request that this should be ask to any of guest speaker who had been part of Government that why the people to so called rich province are so much poor and still figting for the basic necessities? What was contribution of their regime in the development of province?
@@faizaarslan288The whole of Pakistan is poor, there isn't much difference.
Often facts are manipulated facts to shape a certain narrative. Only thing keeping people backward in Pakistan is backward thinking. Here are the facts.
1. 20% of the whole population of Pakistan has access to safe drinking water, so 15% in Baluchistan is not a big difference.
2. 32% of Pakistani children are out of school with 47% in Baluchistan, 44% in Sindh which is quite small compared to 60% in Kohistan region in KP.
3. If 47% children are stunted in Baluchistan the it is 37% in Punjab, 41.3% in Sindh and 48% in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
4. Hospital beds per 1000 people in Pakistan are 9 in Federal, 389 in Punjab, 473 in Sindh, 277 in KP and 134 in Baluchistan. Which again isn't much of a difference considering the bulk of the population in the province is nomadic. And by the yardstick foreign agents are justifying the terrorists, people living in the Federal territory should start blowing them up because they are the most deprived in hospitals.
Assalam walikum Ashar Bhai hope you and your family members are in good health
Nice work. Pakistani need to know this perspective too.
Very nice Ashir SB excellent work
You’re a brilliant teacher.
Thanks for continuing the burning issue
I am a great admirer of u .make such video which r unbiased.
Pushtons arrived in Balochistan after the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan very few pushtons normads used to come and go from Afghanistan and Balochistan. So technically by and large Balochistan was inhabited by Balochs.