I was in love with Shirley when I was 10, I was in love with Shirley when I was 20, I'm still in love with Shirley in my 30s. What a woman! The band is awesome too.
always brilliant live,i like the way she half sings half talks in the middle bit ,you always get something special with Shirley, A TRUE STAR ,ALL WE GOT TODAY IS ON RADIO IS MAINLEY PLASTIC POP SLUSH, I heard Shirley say in an interview at the famous scot exhibition a few weeks ago that she is getting the itch to perform and sing again soon. i am hoping she will be releasing her solo cd later this year ..something exciting to look forward too, we missing you Shirley ,YOU KEEP IT REAL HUN XX
Case in point: the first Garbage album came out 11 days before her 29th birthday. Version 2.0 came out when she was 31, going on 32. Bleed Like Me (the album this is on) came out in 2005, the year of her 39th. It's safe to say she was 39 by the time of this performance. She was already in her 40s when they released "Tell Me Where it Hurts", yet is still a total smokeshow in the music video.
She certainly did say that, I heard her with my own ears. She's gonna be focused on music the rest of the year, and she's in London with one of the most succesful songwriter/guitarist/producers of the last two years and they are writing new material. I got the impression Shirley has moved on from the material judged as "noir" as it is 2-4 years old now. But she says she might post some of it on her Facebook like she did with "In the Snow". :P
Сначала начал писать на английском, потом подумал - а ебись оно конем. Короче тут песни под минусовку. Единственное, что живое - вокал Ширли, а возможно барабаны. Вы посмотрите, там даже шнуры в гитары не воткнуты. какие там радиосистемы и тем более живой звук)
Субтитры-то и убрать можно было. Чикнуть их, и разжать картинку обратно в 16:9 Subtitles could have been removed. Cut out them, and push the picture back to 16:9
@@ABSOLUTgarbage Shirley’s live. A lot of these shows aren’t even set up for a live band, they may not have had a choice. TOTP for instance made everyone mime, on such shows the most they can do is allow live vocals
@@JC-yy8iv Indeed. I'm just sick of comments under the videos of them on TV shows criticising that they are miming or playbacking, a lot of these comments tend to come from the USA - which is interesting because even though their TV shows have live performances, they always sound SHITE because the TV engineers mixed the audio. Most UK TV shows don't have a proper live setup, unless it's a late night show.
I am obviously a big fan of your group, not just one of you. If you, though I am proud youd always keep the whole band un your videos. If want to follow our group, I wrote many of the musical lines for this music, please check out 5htmusic or 5ht the band and experience it for true enjoyment. We are not trying to make it big, we just do music because we love music.
![Garbage "Why Do You Love Me" [Traffic Musique, 2005]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VCvJdMYGicc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Garbage "Why Do You Love Me" [Traffic Musique, 2005]](/img/tr.png)
This band ALWAYS sounded killer live.
This is not live, other than Shirley's voice.
The guitar bends are not live
I was in love with Shirley when I was 10, I was in love with Shirley when I was 20, I'm still in love with Shirley in my 30s. What a woman! The band is awesome too.
Cool, i was in Love whis her when i was 50, still in Love now i´m 63.....
I'm 27 and I'm in love with her now
COME BACK TO AUSTRALIA 🇦🇺 LOVE YOU GARBAGE! And Shirley dayuuuum I’m in loooveee! ❤❤
Shirley owns the stage and the audience. She’s, IMHO, a rare performance artist who exemplifies what musical art really is.
One of the few bands that sound just as good live... truly great musicians and Shirley is an incredible singer
"why do I love you?" Because you're Shirley Manson! 🔥 😍 🎸
Pure power on stage
Shirley muñequita hermisa ❤😍🍒
Please never let die this kind of live garbage presentations
One of my favourites bands 👍😎❤️🥰
Love the edginess to this song.
I can KEEP listening to his song, and I play on doing just that.
This is Attitude. Bravo. to Infinity & Beyond !!!
wow, what a performance
I love shirley's outfit!
Absolutely brilliant
oooh shirley, your driving me crazzzzzyyyyyy
Espectacular !!! Garbage siempre suena de mil !!! 👏👏👏👏. Los sigo desde 1998
Sounds just like the recording, Excellent and fantastic job! Kudos!
Te amo shirley, que mujer mas estilosa y que voz me encanta garbage.
Playing this live, they sound pretty good. And an attractive front of band looks pretty good too.
Einer der besten Songs aller Zeiten!
Why do you love me? Because you are Shirley♡
I LOVE HER...AND THEM
always brilliant live,i like the way she half sings half talks in the middle bit ,you always get something special with Shirley,
A TRUE STAR ,ALL WE GOT TODAY IS ON RADIO IS MAINLEY PLASTIC POP SLUSH,
I heard Shirley say in an interview at the famous scot exhibition a few weeks ago that she is getting the itch to perform and sing again soon. i am hoping she will be releasing her solo cd later this year ..something exciting to look forward too, we missing you Shirley ,YOU KEEP IT REAL HUN XX
i love her!!.
Exquisite Woman!!
Soooooo good!
Awesome performance!!!
Me encanto suena como si fuera el CD.....Grandes como siempre Garbage
Stunning
TE amo Shirley ,I really love you !!!!!
fabuleuse shirley, Scottish voice absolument magnifique "et sexy" j'adore, like she!!
COOL
ya i like her here
Most women who were pretty in their 20's get hotter in their mid/late 30's. Shirley is the perfect example of that.
Case in point: the first Garbage album came out 11 days before her 29th birthday. Version 2.0 came out when she was 31, going on 32. Bleed Like Me (the album this is on) came out in 2005, the year of her 39th. It's safe to say she was 39 by the time of this performance. She was already in her 40s when they released "Tell Me Where it Hurts", yet is still a total smokeshow in the music video.
Saw Garbage last year She’s still incredible
Brilliant
Ширли бесподобна
Linda shirley, lindas piernas x dios!!
Just amazing.
Talent and a wicked body yum.
and we do you know why we love you?
"And I am not as pretty as those girls in magazines".... You sure about that, Shirley? 🙂
The most gorgeous woman I've ever seen
Почти дискотэка ёпти, не истаскалась ещё.
Awesome, can't wait to here it.
I would like Garbage to put an end to the indefinate hiatus and make some music and do some gigs :)
❤️🇲🇽Garbage 🇲🇽❤️
I wait for their FIRST Concert in St. Petersburg. I hope it will be great.
She certainly did say that, I heard her with my own ears. She's gonna be focused on music the rest of the year, and she's in London with one of the most succesful songwriter/guitarist/producers of the last two years and they are writing new material.
I got the impression Shirley has moved on from the material judged as "noir" as it is 2-4 years old now. But she says she might post some of it on her Facebook like she did with "In the Snow". :P
🤩🤩🤩 .....This is #Garbade
❤❤❤❤❤❤🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
good !
vivement le transbordeur a Lyon le 23/11/2012 !
She sings better than studio recording in this live
👍😎🎼🎼🎼2018🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼
Сначала начал писать на английском, потом подумал - а ебись оно конем.
Короче тут песни под минусовку. Единственное, что живое - вокал Ширли, а возможно барабаны.
Вы посмотрите, там даже шнуры в гитары не воткнуты. какие там радиосистемы и тем более живой звук)
girl protect the Stephanie's
Wow ...ouch! think I hurt something..:)
Субтитры-то и убрать можно было. Чикнуть их, и разжать картинку обратно в 16:9
Subtitles could have been removed. Cut out them, and push the picture back to 16:9
Sharlin my love!?!??
Mdr ! Où sont les micro HF sur les grattes pour un soit disant Live ! 😂
I'm sorry, I love this band, but this is NOT live, anyone picked up on the fact the guitars aren't even plugged in! Who ficken mimes in 2005???
Their equipment was at the venue, rather than the studio, hence the playback. It's not a big deal, it's only a TV show.
@@ABSOLUTgarbage Shirley’s live. A lot of these shows aren’t even set up for a live band, they may not have had a choice. TOTP for instance made everyone mime, on such shows the most they can do is allow live vocals
@@JC-yy8iv Indeed. I'm just sick of comments under the videos of them on TV shows criticising that they are miming or playbacking, a lot of these comments tend to come from the USA - which is interesting because even though their TV shows have live performances, they always sound SHITE because the TV engineers mixed the audio. Most UK TV shows don't have a proper live setup, unless it's a late night show.
Yeah, you are as pretty as those girls in the maga.. hey wait, you are in the magazines!
Really
She's dressed like the street walkers outside kings cross station plying for punters
What the fuck the drummer is playing, which song?:-7
I am obviously a big fan of your group, not just one of you. If you, though I am proud youd always keep the whole band un your videos. If want to follow our group, I wrote many of the musical lines for this music, please check out 5htmusic or 5ht the band and experience it for true enjoyment. We are not trying to make it big, we just do music because we love music.