What if Palpatine was injured during his fight with Mace and/or Yoda and required a suit to live? How would the dynamic between Vader & Palpatine be if they both were limited?
If injured against Mace: he would die against Yoda. They were basically on par. Every limitation put onto Sidious would lead to his death. Against Yoda: This could indeed be interesting.
I like that idea. I think the big difference would be quality. The emperor would want the highest quality equipment for himself, maybe even beskar. If Anakin is still burned, the dynamic might be similar, but if Anakin is unharmed, he'll probably overthrow the emperor before the death star is completed
In the second scenario anakin dies since no one would save him. If the Mace fight required a suit anakin would just kill him realizing sidious would be of no use
This is a much more sensible way of Obi-Wan vs. Sidious happening. To me, Sidious tracking down Obi-Wan (rather than the opposite) is the only we could've seen Obi-Wan vs. Sidious happen in ROTS if Yoda had decided to go fight Anakin/Vader. Unless Obi-Wan was significantly stronger at this point, there's no way Yoda in his right mind would send Obi-Wan to fight him. Speaking of Yoda in his right mind, though, I was a little confused at the end. I expected Yoda to reach out with the force and save Anakin from falling in the lava. Interesting idea with him letting Anakin die along with Sidious, but it makes me wonder...why not have Anakin be saved by Yoda while Sidious fell?
I agree. I think yoda should have forced pushed anakin into sidious so he could stab him with his light saber but not over the cliff. He could have went over there to make sure palpatine was killed for good and then pushed him into the lava while letting anakin live with his mistakes so he could do his best to amend them.
Yoga would have definitely killed anakin. Yoda believed that Anakin was forever gone. Plus Palpatine told Vader than Yoda would’ve killed vader if he was on Mustafar. Plus Yoda would’ve wanted to tear vader limb from limb because he killed every jedi in the order
Here’s why obi wan would actually put up a good fight against sidious. In the revenge of the sith novel, obi wan and Anakin were actually clowning Dooku until he used the force to toe obi wan out of the duel. Dooku actually feared for his life in the duel. This isn’t an exact quote but Dooku describes that obi wans defenses are nearly impenetrable, saying that he didn’t move his blade 1 millimeter past where it needed to be. In another part he moves his blade in a defensive motion so fast and perfect that Dooku didn’t even attempt to strike him because he knew they would all be blocked. Remember Dooku is one of the best duelists of this era. I think obi wan would put up a good fight until sidious used the force, where kenobi was much weaker
I think palpatine wouldn’t leave the newly christened Darth Vader alone to confront yoda if he knew Vader was in danger. I also think obi wan was really the only Jedi who could defeat Anakin in that moment because he was fully encased in the dark side and obi wan was the only Jedi who truly understood Anakin’s fighting form.
Na yoda and mace windu would have individually taken him. Also you are saying vader would have needed Palpatine to take yoda so it means vader can't beat yoda without his master.
@@gurmukhsinghbansal479No, he's saying palpatine wouldn't want to risk losing Vader, it doesn't mean he thinks Anakin would lose to Yoda, it just means it would be a close fight and palpatine is a very smart and manipulative person so he'd obviously not want to go through any risks out of his control.
From what I understand while powerful at that moment vader was also very unbalanced in his control of that power as he did not have a full grasp on it yet and was still somewhere between light and dark. I think it was stated in legends or one of the novels that if vader had a few more days to acclimate to the dark side he would have been much more focused and much more powerful. On mustafar he was still between worlds, being able to feel the raw power the dark side promised but unable to fully utilize it. So I'm not sure how he would stack up to say yoda at that exact point in time, as he was stronger in some ways yet weaker in others compared to himself from days prior. But I could be wrong as this is old info and could very well no longer be canon, or just misremembered.
OBI WAN could beat him because anakin wasn't trying to kill him, he wanted to prove himself to him. Anakins force abilities were FAR above obiwans , he didntbuse the force as a weapon in his duel, only to enhance himself in battle against his teacher. Anakin still loved obiwan , anakin never started a single duel with obiwan, obiwan was always the one who ignited his Saber first, ALWAYS! No matter how it looked, anakin wanted obiwan to see as he did , to prove himself and have obiwan trust him.
The _Smart Decision_ would have been for BOTH Yoda and Obiwan to first face off against Sidious, together they could have taken him out of the equation. Once _The Master_ was taken out they could then have taken on Anakin, possibly brought him back out of the darkness, if not they could have eliminated the threat together.
Thanks for making these fights closer and more fun to listen to. A lot of people like to say “so and so stomps so and so,” but that’s boring righting. So I enjoy the suspense and the extended fights. Thanks Galaxy for the great story.
One thing I am pretty sure of , knowing Sidious so far, is that he would have never kept Obi-Wan alive. That's who he is, he would never spare a Jedi, unless he had no choice, even more the likes of Obi-Wan or Yoda. Sparing Padme would make sense a bit in this context though. Other than that, great video, really enjoyed it :)
I have been watching several different what ifs from different narrators, but yours I enjoy the most. Keep up the good work. I hope you're the number one pick for Disney's Star War's What Ifs. I think it could be a gold mine.,,,,
Day 2 of asking: What if Padme Amadala was enslaved during the Clone wars? What if Cal and Merrin had a daughter? What if the Ones survived? What if Ezra and Sabine had a child? What if Luke Skywalker fell in love? (weather this is Mara Jade or an Original character I don't really mind) What if during Han's rescue Luke and all that were able to save Han but Leia was unable to kill Jabba and was left behind? What if Luke and Leia found out they were twins earlier? What if Padme was arranged to marry for the Republic during the clone wars? What if Leia chose to finish her Jedi training? Merry Christmas
13:39 just curious why would palpatine this disappointed with Anakin he genuinely put up a good fight and would have won had the terrain stayed in anakins favours surely he would have sensed that Also I understand padme isn’t too thrilled with what Anakin has done but I feel like she would be furious that yoda basically killed Anakin especially since Anakin didn’t attack her and he killed palpatine Great video I loved the yoda vs anakin fight and the portrayal people don’t give Vader at this point enough credit
Obi wan kenobi was way better then anybody ever gives him credit for. He killed maul and wiuld of killed sideous. Ge was calculated and fearless and never over confident. He was the perfect jedi.
I never understand why people make mon mothma a chancellor this early, I mean she basically just started her galactic political career. If anything I believe there wouldn't be a chancellor for like a couple of years because they would need to do some galactic reforms going over everything palpatine was part of to see how one individual gained so much power to prevent it. I think these what ifs would end better with stating a new election for chancellor had began and leave at that.
Cal Kestis found? Oh sh*t, with the empire not happening, you mean to say he doesn't go to Dathomir, recruit Merrin, and eventually clap his goth GF's cheeks? Unacceptable. Jedi Ed Sheeran x goth witch GF is a canon event. Though I'll support your principle of sticking to the only certainty in swordfights: there is no guaranteed winner. The best swordsman fears the worst swordsman moreso than the second best for a reason. The further the gap in skill, the less the better opponent can predict.
Here's a few free what ifs that I've not seen anyone do.. ANH- Vader senses Leia is his daughter. ANH- Han doesn't shoot first. AOC- Dooku kills Obi-Wan. AOC- Padme is killed during the battle. ESB- Vader comes to the lightside early.
I've been watching a bunch of your videos since Friday. I love your storytelling and agreed that you narrating the fights is a solid move. It gives the story something more. Keep up the good work.
Yoda: Failed you I have Anakin, Failed you I have! Anakin: I should have known the Jedi were plotting to take over! Yoda: Anakin! Evil Chancellor Palpatine is! Anakin: From my point of view the Jedi are evil! Yoda: Well lost you are then! Anakin: This is the end for you grand master! ( Yoda back flips jump onto ash shore ) Yoda: Over it is Anakin, The high ground I have! Anakin: You underestimate my power! Yoda: Try it do not! ( Anakin jumps to ash shore and Yoda slices his legs and left arm off sending him sliding down the ash hill near the lava ) Yoda: The chosen one you were! Supposed to destroy the sith you were, join them not! Balance to the force you bring, leading it to darkness not! Anakin: ( grunts ) Urgh, I HATE YOU!!! Yoda: My grandson you were Anakin, loved you I did! ( Anakin yells and screams in pain as the lava rises up to his body burns up all peaces of his hair and melts most of his body. Yoda looks sad and betrayed seeing one of his Jedi apprentices suffer he uses the force to grab his cane and he sadly walks away )
The question basically boils down to what happens if Obi-Wan fights the much more powerful Sidious but manages to gain the high ground? The answer? The paradox breaks the fabric of the entire space-time continuum of the Star Wars universe.
what if Yaddle didn't follow Dooku to the industrial sector? How would Episode II, III, and the Clone Wars been different with Yaddle alive during that period? Would she have survived order 66 if she had been alive during that time, or would her being alive prevent order 66 from even happening?
New subscriber here, I do like these What If's so keep em' coming. I really loved the Qui Gon importance highlighted in a few of these. Yoda vs Anakin would definitely be an interesting fight but I agree with how the endings of each fight happened. I liked Anakin redeeming himself sort of. The talk at the end of not quite Jedi, not quite Sith, is something I tried tackling in fanfiction as it's an interesting concept. Grey Jedi or Grey Sith? Or would they have another name? I honestly think that True Jedi were one's that were able to see, understand the dark side but know it was wrong. That is why only true masters were allowed to study it or aspects of it - Yoda, Windu (fighting style) and Yaddle? Any how I'm rambling, cheers for giving me the star wars bug again haha.
I agree. Depending on the situation a lightsabre duel can go one way or another. Much like a professional boxing match. One side might have their head in the game more or want it more based on the situation. Also these matches involve the force which is known to intervene on occasions to give an advantage to one side or the other.
Yoda wouldn’t have cared if it was too dangerous for padme. He would have been willing to sacrifice her to get rid of the sith. Him and Obi wan mentioned once that despite their close relationship they would kill each other without hesitation if it meant ending the clone wars even a day early.
So many different channels have this question, yours was an interesting take. Making Anakin confront both Yoda and Sidious (with the former in a duel and the latter being up front of the decision making). I really like and enjoy this video. Day 27. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
What if whilst on his way to mustafar to kill the seperatist council, whilst in hyperspace anakin encounters a hyperspace anomaly/interferance that causes his ship to exit hyperspace, resulting in him crash landing on a planet either in wild space or the unknown regions?
and also on what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself it starts since anakin is born the force guiding him training him and the rest of the original timeline goes as We Know except Anakin is not a Jedi or sith but instead a force wielder he saves his mother he falls in love with Padme and reaches his full potential early quick faster and the rest will we all leave it to you like all the rest of the what ifs okay bro :);)
The seventh video of the campaign: I wonder what you could cook up with this idea - "What if Anakin died in the Battle of Coruscant ?". I was personally interested in seeing what would happen if Anakin crashed into a munitions crate or something, dying in the cockpit of his crashed fighter. How would that affect Obi-Wan and Sidious's plans ? Maybe Dooku could finally convince Obi-Wan to join him, or something else. Perhaps with Dooku arrested, the Jedi order would believe him and stop Palpatine, either killing him or arresting him. For the Jedi, the prophecy of the Chosen One would turn out to have been wrong, but in reality, Anakin not living to join Sidious would've probably been a better fate for the galaxy. Alternatively, Sidious could perhaps still salvage the situation, making his empire stronger. I think it could be another 2 part episode
Now that I think about it, Anakin could have used Force Lightning to "negate" Obi-Wan's high ground. Not sure if he knew how to, but if you played the PS2 game, he was able to
Damn Yoda is such an asshole. Very selfish and acting like a sith. No restraint or consideration for Anakin, even though he’s not a true sith, just like Douku.
Yo ngl that’s out of character of yoda to push anakin to his death like that , it’s not something he would do to get revenge Like that . That’s really a dick move since he redeemed himself
Based on my understanding of star wars the sith Lords are notorious for playing with their food. That is to say they toy with their opponents to show their dominance over them and sometimes it bites them in the arse. That's why the jedi teach patients to their younglings and padawans as a counter to the sith's arrogance. So sidious underestimating obi-wan's lightsaber skills is just par for the course for a sith lord. Since anakin skywalker was willing to kill for padme it stands to reason does it not that he would be willing to die for her and their children. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
What if the SDF 3 (Robotech) made its way into the Star Wars Galaxy? Clone Wars has a lot of potential as I would love to see Alpha and Beta veritechs go up against the separatists. The SDF's main gun would be a game changer. Max and Miria's younger daughter might be a prize Sidious would want given her powers. Can a song bring peace to the galaxy or does the Empire rise even faster? What if the Republic found Eternia? Do the jedi help new allies to succeed or does Greyskull fall to a Sidious/Skeletor alliance? Who will gain the strength, the power to become Masters of the Universe!!! What if GI Joe (a real American Hero) joined the Republic against the Separatists? Does the Bad Batch become even better under Sgt. Slaughter's training? How do the Separatists fair against the Republic's elite fighting force? GI Joe the Republic's elite fighting force brought together to fight the Separatists, an organization determined to rule the galaxy! He never gives up, he'll stay 'til the fights done! GI Joe a real Republic hero! Yo! Joe!
I've always said that in a purely saber to saber fight with no telekinesis or lightning involved, Obi Wan is actually superior to Sidious. Obi Wan's skill with a lightsaber is legendary. Both of them have demonstrated the ability to out-duel the combination of Maul and Savage fighting together. Sidious actually needed to use telekinetic powers to fend off some of their moves, while Obi Wan (when in a balanced mindset) managed to dismantle them with strength and skill alone. In the original novelization of Ep3, Dooku himself also admitted that Obi Wan had surpassed his own skill, forcing Dooku to rely on telekinesis to subdue Obi Wan (I think there's also some implication that Sidious was covertly assisting Dooku there too). The problem with an Obi Wan vs Sidious duel is that like Dooku, Sidious isn't going to ignore his telekinesis/lightning forever. At some point, sooner or later he's going to start throwing out those powers. If Obi Wan keeps a grip on his saber, he could conceivably use it to block the lightning (for a time). But he's not powerful enough to do anything against Sidious ragdolling him. He could even avoid a duel altogether if he starts the conflict with those powers. Sidious only even uses a lightsaber as a way to mock the jedi, he doesn't even like using one. Your scenario presented in this video is plausible though, Obi Wan could hold his own as long as Sidious just treats the fight as a lightsaber duel.
Maul and savage vs sidious obi wan lasts a little longer than they did and anakin seeing how he beat dooku I’d say he’d have Atleast a 50-50 chance of winning with his powers being boosted by the dark side I thought sidious would kill obi wan and padmè saying that yoda did it getting rid of a Anakins attachments to the light other than Ashoka but in that scenario I thought anakin would retreat knowing he couldn’t defeat yoda and get away like dooku did
Kenobi would not have overpowered Sidious and killing Anakin just because he was doing the will of the force is dangerous for the future. If he thought like Payne from Naruto, he would have defeated Yoda by pulling the green troll by force and stabbing him with a sword. They shouldn't have been flattering at all. Anakin is not Palpatine, he could simply be excluded from the order and let him live peacefully with his family. Although the Jedi themselves ran into destruction. Mortals should not contradict the will of the goddess of their world. There can be no good ending if Anakin doesn't fulfill his destiny.
I don't know if Yoda would win. Anakin lost to obi wan because he was angry and overconfident. With Yoda, he would be scared and desperate......and that is by far more dangerous.
I honestly think that Vader/Anakin could defeat Yoda on Mustafar. The only reasons Anakin lost to Obi-Wan was A. Conflict, Anakin was conflicted about killing Obi-Wan despite his dark-side frenzy. B. Obi-Wan knew Anakin's fighting style/moves better than any other Jedi, so he could keep up with Anakin's speed/strength by predicting him. Anakin would not have either of these disadvantages when facing Yoda. For one, Anakin's fighting style directly counters Yoda's Atarru, Anakin's overwhelming offense would keep Yoda moving constantly, draining his stamina quickly. Second, Yoda knew Anakin as a Jedi, but not really as a person, not like Obi-Wan did. Obi-Wan knew Anakin's moveset inside and out, whereas Yoda would've maybe sparred with Anakin a handful of times at best, if that. As a result, while a close fight to be certain, Anakin would have 0 conflict and should have the hyper-focus necessary to either defeat Yoda through skill with a lightsaber, or defeat Yoda through attrition like Sidious did, wearing out Yoda's stamina with telekinesis and quick offensive strikes. This combination, in conjunction with Yoda's already force-taxing acrobatic style, would leave the grandmaster worn out and as a result, would be killed by Vader Tl;dr Obi-Wan counters Anakin, Palpatine counters Obi-Wan, Anakin counters Yoda, Yoda counters Palpatine.
But rememeber, yoda is the best duelist in the order only beaten by plo with electric judgment. Yoda faced dooku on geonosis, assaj on toydaria, sidious on corasaunt. Anakin isnt patient and after yoda knew anakin was lost he would strike him down mercifully killing him in 1 strike or disarming him maybe delimbing like obiwan 3 for 1 deal. Yoda is faster than sidious but sidious can keep pace with Yoda. 2 fighting on solid ground with no escape Yoda would have won. Sidious used home field to give him survivability on his side
@@darthvapor4209A. Pretty sure the clone wars game isnt canon, and to my knowledge, no other source speaks of Plo defeating Yoda in a sparring match or how. B. I did specifically mention that Anakin would have to be hyper-focused if he were to win. And if any Jedi were to shake him out of his arrogance, it would be Yoda. As long as Anakin keeps the environmental advantage, and doesn't over-extend, he should win. Although, I still see this only working on Mustafar specifically. Any earlier, Anakin isn't strong enough in the dark side to fight Yoda. Any later, he's Vader, and was weak for years.
Yoda would wipe the floor with Anakin. Palpatine would wipe the floor with Obi-Wan. I think Yoda would do what Obi-Wan couldn’t and would kill Anakin. Yoda wasn’t as close to Anakin as Obi-Wan was. Yoda is also stronger than Obi-Wan in the force and would defeat Anakin faster. Obi-Wan isn’t as proficient with the force as Palpatine and arguably isn’t a better dualist. Palpatine would easily overwhelm him. I don’t think what happened in this video would ever happen, but I also think Obi-Wan would’ve never went to the apartment and Yoda never would’ve went to Mustafar. It was always going to play out the way it did in the movie.
Hey what if anakin turned Palpatine to the light side started back from episode 1 where Palpatine said that about anakin career can't remember the whole thing
the Star Wars Galaxy great what if like all of them look I asked for a final time when can we see what if Anakin Skywalker went to both the Wellspring of life and ahch to birthplace of the midichlorians and first Jedi Temple with Yoda letting the force beater guide and telling them where to go how to get there come on please man 😢 we really want to see that what if happened you can do it right guys👌
Yoda: Don't try it Anakin, I have the high ground"
Anakin looking Yoda at eye level: "Come on Yoda, at least go up a little higher"
I see a little bit of clone wars anakin's sas has survived
''Enough of your shit, i had''
Grandmaster Yoda
What if Palpatine was injured during his fight with Mace and/or Yoda and required a suit to live? How would the dynamic between Vader & Palpatine be if they both were limited?
If injured against Mace: he would die against Yoda. They were basically on par. Every limitation put onto Sidious would lead to his death.
Against Yoda: This could indeed be interesting.
I like that idea. I think the big difference would be quality. The emperor would want the highest quality equipment for himself, maybe even beskar. If Anakin is still burned, the dynamic might be similar, but if Anakin is unharmed, he'll probably overthrow the emperor before the death star is completed
That's actually a really interesting and good concept
it he was injured and killed yoda during thier fight
In the second scenario anakin dies since no one would save him. If the Mace fight required a suit anakin would just kill him realizing sidious would be of no use
Yoda force-pushing Anakin (not Darth Vader) into Sidious - killing them both in lava is legit insane.
Well, it turned out Yoda wanted revenge after all. He felt the switch but choose to kill Anakin anyway. So much for the infamous "Jedi Way''.
Obi-Wan: It's over, Palpatine. I have the High Ground!
Palpatine: You underestimate my UNLIMITED POWAAAAH!
Nice pfp. En Taro Artanis
This is a much more sensible way of Obi-Wan vs. Sidious happening. To me, Sidious tracking down Obi-Wan (rather than the opposite) is the only we could've seen Obi-Wan vs. Sidious happen in ROTS if Yoda had decided to go fight Anakin/Vader. Unless Obi-Wan was significantly stronger at this point, there's no way Yoda in his right mind would send Obi-Wan to fight him.
Speaking of Yoda in his right mind, though, I was a little confused at the end. I expected Yoda to reach out with the force and save Anakin from falling in the lava. Interesting idea with him letting Anakin die along with Sidious, but it makes me wonder...why not have Anakin be saved by Yoda while Sidious fell?
I agree. I think yoda should have forced pushed anakin into sidious so he could stab him with his light saber but not over the cliff. He could have went over there to make sure palpatine was killed for good and then pushed him into the lava while letting anakin live with his mistakes so he could do his best to amend them.
@@samruhland848right, yoda definitely would have had annikin live and deal with his sins
Yoga would have definitely killed anakin. Yoda believed that Anakin was forever gone. Plus Palpatine told Vader than Yoda would’ve killed vader if he was on Mustafar. Plus Yoda would’ve wanted to tear vader limb from limb because he killed every jedi in the order
I think people forget that at this point Anakin was a mass murderer, who had killed CHILDREN. He was extremely dangerous.
Yoda would fuck Anakin up, and Obi Wan was a master of defensive saber combat, better than Yoda in fact, he could have fought to the same draw.
Here’s why obi wan would actually put up a good fight against sidious. In the revenge of the sith novel, obi wan and Anakin were actually clowning Dooku until he used the force to toe obi wan out of the duel. Dooku actually feared for his life in the duel. This isn’t an exact quote but Dooku describes that obi wans defenses are nearly impenetrable, saying that he didn’t move his blade 1 millimeter past where it needed to be. In another part he moves his blade in a defensive motion so fast and perfect that Dooku didn’t even attempt to strike him because he knew they would all be blocked. Remember Dooku is one of the best duelists of this era. I think obi wan would put up a good fight until sidious used the force, where kenobi was much weaker
I think palpatine wouldn’t leave the newly christened Darth Vader alone to confront yoda if he knew Vader was in danger. I also think obi wan was really the only Jedi who could defeat Anakin in that moment because he was fully encased in the dark side and obi wan was the only Jedi who truly understood Anakin’s fighting form.
Na yoda and mace windu would have individually taken him.
Also you are saying vader would have needed Palpatine to take yoda so it means vader can't beat yoda without his master.
@@gurmukhsinghbansal479No, he's saying palpatine wouldn't want to risk losing Vader, it doesn't mean he thinks Anakin would lose to Yoda, it just means it would be a close fight and palpatine is a very smart and manipulative person so he'd obviously not want to go through any risks out of his control.
From what I understand while powerful at that moment vader was also very unbalanced in his control of that power as he did not have a full grasp on it yet and was still somewhere between light and dark. I think it was stated in legends or one of the novels that if vader had a few more days to acclimate to the dark side he would have been much more focused and much more powerful. On mustafar he was still between worlds, being able to feel the raw power the dark side promised but unable to fully utilize it. So I'm not sure how he would stack up to say yoda at that exact point in time, as he was stronger in some ways yet weaker in others compared to himself from days prior. But I could be wrong as this is old info and could very well no longer be canon, or just misremembered.
Yeah he would ignore Obi-Wan and go straight to Mustafar
OBI WAN could beat him because anakin wasn't trying to kill him, he wanted to prove himself to him. Anakins force abilities were FAR above obiwans , he didntbuse the force as a weapon in his duel, only to enhance himself in battle against his teacher. Anakin still loved obiwan , anakin never started a single duel with obiwan, obiwan was always the one who ignited his Saber first, ALWAYS! No matter how it looked, anakin wanted obiwan to see as he did , to prove himself and have obiwan trust him.
The _Smart Decision_ would have been for BOTH Yoda and Obiwan to first face off against Sidious, together they could have taken him out of the equation. Once _The Master_ was taken out they could then have taken on Anakin, possibly brought him back out of the darkness, if not they could have eliminated the threat together.
Sidious would’ve easily killed obi wan while yoda was knocked out by sidious’s force lightning
Thanks for making these fights closer and more fun to listen to. A lot of people like to say “so and so stomps so and so,” but that’s boring righting. So I enjoy the suspense and the extended fights. Thanks Galaxy for the great story.
One thing I am pretty sure of , knowing Sidious so far, is that he would have never kept Obi-Wan alive. That's who he is, he would never spare a Jedi, unless he had no choice, even more the likes of Obi-Wan or Yoda. Sparing Padme would make sense a bit in this context though.
Other than that, great video, really enjoyed it :)
I have been watching several different what ifs from different narrators, but yours I enjoy the most. Keep up the good work. I hope you're the number one pick for Disney's Star War's What Ifs. I think it could be a gold mine.,,,,
Day 2 of asking:
What if Padme Amadala was enslaved during the Clone wars?
What if Cal and Merrin had a daughter?
What if the Ones survived?
What if Ezra and Sabine had a child?
What if Luke Skywalker fell in love? (weather this is Mara Jade or an Original character I don't really mind)
What if during Han's rescue Luke and all that were able to save Han but Leia was unable to kill Jabba and was left behind?
What if Luke and Leia found out they were twins earlier?
What if Padme was arranged to marry for the Republic during the clone wars?
What if Leia chose to finish her Jedi training?
Merry Christmas
ok ew for the ezra and sabine one..... they are like Siblings thats like incest or somethin
@@seth3k I guess.
The Cal and Merrin would be weird seeing as how we haven't seen their full journey yet.
@@commanderclown8620 we have enough I believe especially after Survivor
Poor Anakin:/ Yoda blinded him and cuts his remaining actual hand off and then refuses to help him. Quite rude.
What if Obi wan went to Dagobah meanwhile Yoda went to Tatooine after the Events of Revenge Of The Sith
Actually that would be interesting.
I can see sidious playing with his food. He's sadistic.
13:39 just curious why would palpatine this disappointed with Anakin he genuinely put up a good fight and would have won had the terrain stayed in anakins favours surely he would have sensed that
Also I understand padme isn’t too thrilled with what Anakin has done but I feel like she would be furious that yoda basically killed Anakin especially since Anakin didn’t attack her and he killed palpatine
Great video I loved the yoda vs anakin fight and the portrayal people don’t give Vader at this point enough credit
Tbf I guess he is a sith
No participation trophies in the Star Wars universe.
@@deerpic yeah that’s fair especially if it’s palpatine
Padme wasn't shown the security footage of Anakin killing the Jedi and the younglings. If she had, she would reluctantly agree to neutralize Anakin.
This was absolutely incredible! I LOVE this video! This is also the most plausible outcome of all the video I've seen on this.
Obi wan kenobi was way better then anybody ever gives him credit for. He killed maul and wiuld of killed sideous. Ge was calculated and fearless and never over confident. He was the perfect jedi.
I never understand why people make mon mothma a chancellor this early, I mean she basically just started her galactic political career. If anything I believe there wouldn't be a chancellor for like a couple of years because they would need to do some galactic reforms going over everything palpatine was part of to see how one individual gained so much power to prevent it. I think these what ifs would end better with stating a new election for chancellor had began and leave at that.
Cal Kestis found? Oh sh*t, with the empire not happening, you mean to say he doesn't go to Dathomir, recruit Merrin, and eventually clap his goth GF's cheeks?
Unacceptable. Jedi Ed Sheeran x goth witch GF is a canon event.
Though I'll support your principle of sticking to the only certainty in swordfights: there is no guaranteed winner. The best swordsman fears the worst swordsman moreso than the second best for a reason. The further the gap in skill, the less the better opponent can predict.
Why not kill Palpatine first together (he is some building away) and THEN kill Anakin together.
What if Hondo Onaca was the chosen one😂
*IDEA:*
What If Dagan Gera joined Cal Kestis and fought against the Empire as a Jedi?
Here's a few free what ifs that I've not seen anyone do..
ANH- Vader senses Leia is his daughter.
ANH- Han doesn't shoot first.
AOC- Dooku kills Obi-Wan.
AOC- Padme is killed during the battle.
ESB- Vader comes to the lightside early.
I've been watching a bunch of your videos since Friday. I love your storytelling and agreed that you narrating the fights is a solid move. It gives the story something more. Keep up the good work.
Do a what if we got married in the Star Wars cinematic universe
???
?????????????? what do you mean!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! huh?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!???????????????????????????????????????!?!?!??????????
Who
Yoda: Failed you I have Anakin, Failed you I have!
Anakin: I should have known the Jedi were plotting to take over!
Yoda: Anakin! Evil Chancellor Palpatine is!
Anakin: From my point of view the Jedi are evil!
Yoda: Well lost you are then!
Anakin: This is the end for you grand master!
( Yoda back flips jump onto ash shore )
Yoda: Over it is Anakin, The high ground I have!
Anakin: You underestimate my power!
Yoda: Try it do not!
( Anakin jumps to ash shore and Yoda slices his legs and left arm off sending him sliding down the ash hill near the lava )
Yoda: The chosen one you were! Supposed to destroy the sith you were, join them not! Balance to the force you bring, leading it to darkness not!
Anakin: ( grunts ) Urgh, I HATE YOU!!!
Yoda: My grandson you were Anakin, loved you I did!
( Anakin yells and screams in pain as the lava rises up to his body burns up all peaces of his hair and melts most of his body. Yoda looks sad and betrayed seeing one of his Jedi apprentices suffer he uses the force to grab his cane and he sadly walks away )
Yoda would have finished him.
waht if Anakin simply blocked Maces blow instead of taking off his hand
The question basically boils down to what happens if Obi-Wan fights the much more powerful Sidious but manages to gain the high ground?
The answer?
The paradox breaks the fabric of the entire space-time continuum of the Star Wars universe.
I definitely think the way you put it was perfect. I love the what if’s series great video man🔥
I've wondered if Palpatine gave Vader a clone body instead , trusting his anger at the Jedi and such be enough to keep him in the Dark Side .
what if Yaddle didn't follow Dooku to the industrial sector? How would Episode II, III, and the Clone Wars been different with Yaddle alive during that period? Would she have survived order 66 if she had been alive during that time, or would her being alive prevent order 66 from even happening?
I think you nailed that Kenobi vs Sidious fight. I expected you to have Kenobi get shredded, but im glad you made it kinda even.
New subscriber here, I do like these What If's so keep em' coming. I really loved the Qui Gon importance highlighted in a few of these. Yoda vs Anakin would definitely be an interesting fight but I agree with how the endings of each fight happened. I liked Anakin redeeming himself sort of. The talk at the end of not quite Jedi, not quite Sith, is something I tried tackling in fanfiction as it's an interesting concept. Grey Jedi or Grey Sith? Or would they have another name? I honestly think that True Jedi were one's that were able to see, understand the dark side but know it was wrong. That is why only true masters were allowed to study it or aspects of it - Yoda, Windu (fighting style) and Yaddle?
Any how I'm rambling, cheers for giving me the star wars bug again haha.
14:20 bro pulled out the Minecraft painting
Was watching a totally different video, this popped up I clicked faster and I could blink...😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉🎉
Really enjoyed this one mate cheers
Excellent video and story telling! I was just checking your other vids and I can't wait to watch a ton of them, you've earned a sub.
I agree. Depending on the situation a lightsabre duel can go one way or another. Much like a professional boxing match. One side might have their head in the game more or want it more based on the situation. Also these matches involve the force which is known to intervene on occasions to give an advantage to one side or the other.
What If Shaak Ti Killed Aankin?, Could She With Cin Drallig, Kelleran Beq, Coleman Kcaj Defeat Sidious With Obi-Wan And Yoda?
Obi-Wan who shut down the power here's a red lightsaber
Yoda wouldn’t have cared if it was too dangerous for padme. He would have been willing to sacrifice her to get rid of the sith. Him and Obi wan mentioned once that despite their close relationship they would kill each other without hesitation if it meant ending the clone wars even a day early.
"What if Palpatine's plan failed" is a fitting name for almost every single Star Wars what if
Why Anakin first? 😂 They are already some building away from Palpatine. And he is much more important
So many different channels have this question, yours was an interesting take. Making Anakin confront both Yoda and Sidious (with the former in a duel and the latter being up front of the decision making). I really like and enjoy this video.
Day 27. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
Love the videos man!
What if whilst on his way to mustafar to kill the seperatist council, whilst in hyperspace anakin encounters a hyperspace anomaly/interferance that causes his ship to exit hyperspace, resulting in him crash landing on a planet either in wild space or the unknown regions?
and also on what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself it starts since anakin is born the force guiding him training him and the rest of the original timeline goes as We Know except Anakin is not a Jedi or sith but instead a force wielder he saves his mother he falls in love with Padme and reaches his full potential early quick faster and the rest will we all leave it to you like all the rest of the what ifs okay bro :);)
I want one of these fanfics for Obi-Wan to "learn" of Padme and Anakin and him ask if that makes her is sister-in-law 😂
The seventh video of the campaign: I wonder what you could cook up with this idea - "What if Anakin died in the Battle of Coruscant ?". I was personally interested in seeing what would happen if Anakin crashed into a munitions crate or something, dying in the cockpit of his crashed fighter. How would that affect Obi-Wan and Sidious's plans ? Maybe Dooku could finally convince Obi-Wan to join him, or something else. Perhaps with Dooku arrested, the Jedi order would believe him and stop Palpatine, either killing him or arresting him. For the Jedi, the prophecy of the Chosen One would turn out to have been wrong, but in reality, Anakin not living to join Sidious would've probably been a better fate for the galaxy. Alternatively, Sidious could perhaps still salvage the situation, making his empire stronger. I think it could be another 2 part episode
I like the way you ended the sith on the lava banks of musfar together ending their rule.
Now that I think about it, Anakin could have used Force Lightning to "negate" Obi-Wan's high ground. Not sure if he knew how to, but if you played the PS2 game, he was able to
What if Palpatine sent Dooku to follow Yoda on his quest to seek answers from the Whills?
Damn Yoda is such an asshole. Very selfish and acting like a sith. No restraint or consideration for Anakin, even though he’s not a true sith, just like Douku.
Yo ngl that’s out of character of yoda to push anakin to his death like that , it’s not something he would do to get revenge Like that . That’s really a dick move since he redeemed himself
Obi wan dead and Anakins ashes blown everywhere.
What is the music you use in these videos?
Based on my understanding of star wars the sith Lords are notorious for playing with their food. That is to say they toy with their opponents to show their dominance over them and sometimes it bites them in the arse. That's why the jedi teach patients to their younglings and padawans as a counter to the sith's arrogance. So sidious underestimating obi-wan's lightsaber skills is just par for the course for a sith lord. Since anakin skywalker was willing to kill for padme it stands to reason does it not that he would be willing to die for her and their children. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
15:15 HEEE'S DA....TRAITORRRRR!
What if the SDF 3 (Robotech) made its way into the Star Wars Galaxy? Clone Wars has a lot of potential as I would love to see Alpha and Beta veritechs go up against the separatists. The SDF's main gun would be a game changer. Max and Miria's younger daughter might be a prize Sidious would want given her powers. Can a song bring peace to the galaxy or does the Empire rise even faster?
What if the Republic found Eternia? Do the jedi help new allies to succeed or does Greyskull fall to a Sidious/Skeletor alliance? Who will gain the strength, the power to become Masters of the Universe!!!
What if GI Joe (a real American Hero) joined the Republic against the Separatists? Does the Bad Batch become even better under Sgt. Slaughter's training? How do the Separatists fair against the Republic's elite fighting force?
GI Joe the Republic's elite fighting force brought together to fight the Separatists, an organization determined to rule the galaxy! He never gives up, he'll stay 'til the fights done! GI Joe a real Republic hero! Yo! Joe!
I've always said that in a purely saber to saber fight with no telekinesis or lightning involved, Obi Wan is actually superior to Sidious. Obi Wan's skill with a lightsaber is legendary. Both of them have demonstrated the ability to out-duel the combination of Maul and Savage fighting together. Sidious actually needed to use telekinetic powers to fend off some of their moves, while Obi Wan (when in a balanced mindset) managed to dismantle them with strength and skill alone. In the original novelization of Ep3, Dooku himself also admitted that Obi Wan had surpassed his own skill, forcing Dooku to rely on telekinesis to subdue Obi Wan (I think there's also some implication that Sidious was covertly assisting Dooku there too). The problem with an Obi Wan vs Sidious duel is that like Dooku, Sidious isn't going to ignore his telekinesis/lightning forever. At some point, sooner or later he's going to start throwing out those powers. If Obi Wan keeps a grip on his saber, he could conceivably use it to block the lightning (for a time). But he's not powerful enough to do anything against Sidious ragdolling him. He could even avoid a duel altogether if he starts the conflict with those powers. Sidious only even uses a lightsaber as a way to mock the jedi, he doesn't even like using one. Your scenario presented in this video is plausible though, Obi Wan could hold his own as long as Sidious just treats the fight as a lightsaber duel.
Maul and savage vs sidious obi wan lasts a little longer than they did and anakin seeing how he beat dooku I’d say he’d have Atleast a 50-50 chance of winning with his powers being boosted by the dark side I thought sidious would kill obi wan and padmè saying that yoda did it getting rid of a Anakins attachments to the light other than Ashoka but in that scenario I thought anakin would retreat knowing he couldn’t defeat yoda and get away like dooku did
People always forget Dooku wasn't trying to win, he was always trying to just Goad Skywalker then lose.
Jedi Master Padme fights Anakin on Mustafar. Grand Master Yoda trained her in secret.
I feel like obi wan being the Master of defense mean something.
Not watched the video, but my guess is Yoda kills Anakin and Palpatine smokes Obi-Wan.
Man i hope ur in the collab with ppsw and fantasyfolklore
I got one. What if anakin got a red crystal on illum.
Yoda should have saved anakin he saved saved the day it was only right to save him yoda lived long enough to become the villian
Before I watch:
Anakin and Obi-Wan both die. lol.
What if Padme ran her own back door deals in her own attempts at manipulation?
What if Padme remained as Queen?
dude, we appreciate all the work put into this, but in some places this scenario is purely ridiculous
5:07 bro the song! i need dis song
I liked Anakin just taking out Sidious and Yoda fighting him was great 😊
Nice Fan Fic
Kenobi would not have overpowered Sidious and killing Anakin just because he was doing the will of the force is dangerous for the future. If he thought like Payne from Naruto, he would have defeated Yoda by pulling the green troll by force and stabbing him with a sword. They shouldn't have been flattering at all. Anakin is not Palpatine, he could simply be excluded from the order and let him live peacefully with his family. Although the Jedi themselves ran into destruction. Mortals should not contradict the will of the goddess of their world. There can be no good ending if Anakin doesn't fulfill his destiny.
What if obi wan cut anakin in half like he did maul
I don't know if Yoda would win. Anakin lost to obi wan because he was angry and overconfident. With Yoda, he would be scared and desperate......and that is by far more dangerous.
Now Vader beats yoda 😂yall crazy
I loved this story
hello there
General kenobi
You are a bold one
I honestly think that Vader/Anakin could defeat Yoda on Mustafar.
The only reasons Anakin lost to Obi-Wan was A. Conflict, Anakin was conflicted about killing Obi-Wan despite his dark-side frenzy. B. Obi-Wan knew Anakin's fighting style/moves better than any other Jedi, so he could keep up with Anakin's speed/strength by predicting him.
Anakin would not have either of these disadvantages when facing Yoda. For one, Anakin's fighting style directly counters Yoda's Atarru, Anakin's overwhelming offense would keep Yoda moving constantly, draining his stamina quickly.
Second, Yoda knew Anakin as a Jedi, but not really as a person, not like Obi-Wan did. Obi-Wan knew Anakin's moveset inside and out, whereas Yoda would've maybe sparred with Anakin a handful of times at best, if that.
As a result, while a close fight to be certain, Anakin would have 0 conflict and should have the hyper-focus necessary to either defeat Yoda through skill with a lightsaber, or defeat Yoda through attrition like Sidious did, wearing out Yoda's stamina with telekinesis and quick offensive strikes.
This combination, in conjunction with Yoda's already force-taxing acrobatic style, would leave the grandmaster worn out and as a result, would be killed by Vader
Tl;dr Obi-Wan counters Anakin, Palpatine counters Obi-Wan, Anakin counters Yoda, Yoda counters Palpatine.
But rememeber, yoda is the best duelist in the order only beaten by plo with electric judgment. Yoda faced dooku on geonosis, assaj on toydaria, sidious on corasaunt. Anakin isnt patient and after yoda knew anakin was lost he would strike him down mercifully killing him in 1 strike or disarming him maybe delimbing like obiwan 3 for 1 deal. Yoda is faster than sidious but sidious can keep pace with Yoda. 2 fighting on solid ground with no escape Yoda would have won. Sidious used home field to give him survivability on his side
Altho plo used anakins same form 5 they specialized in different styles
@@darthvapor4209A. Pretty sure the clone wars game isnt canon, and to my knowledge, no other source speaks of Plo defeating Yoda in a sparring match or how.
B. I did specifically mention that Anakin would have to be hyper-focused if he were to win. And if any Jedi were to shake him out of his arrogance, it would be Yoda. As long as Anakin keeps the environmental advantage, and doesn't over-extend, he should win.
Although, I still see this only working on Mustafar specifically. Any earlier, Anakin isn't strong enough in the dark side to fight Yoda. Any later, he's Vader, and was weak for years.
Can you do the same story but Anakin gets saved and helped the Jedi
what if anakin told mace about what happened on tatooine and mace decided to help him
What if pre-retcon vergere never encountered the yuuzhan vong and trained anakin.
Ok, but what about the clones? Weren't they still executing order 66?
Yoda would wipe the floor with Anakin. Palpatine would wipe the floor with Obi-Wan.
I think Yoda would do what Obi-Wan couldn’t and would kill Anakin. Yoda wasn’t as close to Anakin as Obi-Wan was. Yoda is also stronger than Obi-Wan in the force and would defeat Anakin faster.
Obi-Wan isn’t as proficient with the force as Palpatine and arguably isn’t a better dualist. Palpatine would easily overwhelm him.
I don’t think what happened in this video would ever happen, but I also think Obi-Wan would’ve never went to the apartment and Yoda never would’ve went to Mustafar. It was always going to play out the way it did in the movie.
What if the Clone Wars reached earth in the modern day?
Yoda would have finished Anakin off much more quickly.
Hey what if anakin turned Palpatine to the light side started back from episode 1 where Palpatine said that about anakin career can't remember the whole thing
I don't think Yoda would've killed Anakin at the end.
I think this story’s quite flawed but interesting to hear.
Screwed, Obi-Wan will be.
what if the pykes killed dooku on oba diah
What should have happened is yoda should have gone with obi wan. There would have been a shift in the force and drawn sidious to mustifar.
Why didn’t Sidious kill Padmé and blame Obi wan? He could said he could give Vader revenge and resurrect her
What if obiwan became grandmaster?
Yoda would end up dying Anakin is twice as powerful
Anakin couldn't beat obi-wan, Yoda is more powerful than Anakin at this point
@@AssassinIsAfk correction he did beat obiwan just not in their first battle
@@pinklightninggacha the only time he managed to beat obi-wan was when obi wan threw the fight to let Luke escape.
@@AssassinIsAfk obiwan was old he would have tired and lost anyway he stood no chance against that form no jedi survived him
the Star Wars Galaxy great what if like all of them look I asked for a final time when can we see what if Anakin Skywalker went to both the Wellspring of life and ahch to birthplace of the midichlorians and first Jedi Temple with Yoda letting the force beater guide and telling them where to go how to get there come on please man 😢 we really want to see that what if happened you can do it right guys👌
obi wan is a better duellist than palpatine