PM-EAC paper shows South & West lead post-1991 growth, Mandal-Mandir politics link to Bimaru states
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 вер 2024
- A new paper from the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister reveals a growing economic disparity among Indian states. Southern states like Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, and Telangana alongside Gujarat and Maharashtra in West are driving post-liberalisation growth, while once-dominant states like Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and West Bengal face stagnation. The report, authored by Sanjeev Sanyal and Aakanksha Arora, points to agriculture and identity politics as major hurdles to growth. Dive into the regional trends shaping India’s economic future. Watch episode 1521 of #CutTheClutter
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To read TCA Sharad Raghavan's article: theprint.in/ec...
To read PM-EAC working paper: eacpm.gov.in/w...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@arvindmenswear66
This Season, Embrace Royalty & Legacy with our New Season Launch of Luxury Primante Collection Fabrics.
Discover our latest showcase featuring the esteemed People's Prince, Dr. Lakshyaraj Singh Mewar.
Own your day, visit your nearest Arvind Store and craft your perfect look.
#TheArvindStore #OwnYourLegacy #OwnTheMoment
tinyurl.com/3w...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Mainly Bengal is almost destroyed under the cpm and Mamta regime.....
By nehru because of freight equalisation policy
@@yashashsgowda6662foolish
So, basically the rich states remain rich and poor states remain poor. But Bengal and Punjab are the 2 states who were among the most rich and now are becoming poor as time passes. We can blame Khalistan terrorism in 80's and 90's for Punjab's performance but there was no insurgency in Bengal , they have themselves to blame. Once the best city in India Kolkata has been ruined.
Punjab still a power house
Gujarat wasn't rich at the time of Independence (5% contribution) now it is 8.2%. United Bihar had 7.8% contribution, now Bihar has 2.8 and Jharkhand 1.5.
@@BroInPunjabreally by claiming free electricity in name of farmer 😄😄😄
You are living under which rock West Bengal was the home of communist insurgency and west bengal biggest problem is it still gets 5% less in taxes than it gives, more over west bengal was essentially a land locked state as it didn't have any port to dock even the medium sized ship and is heavily plagued by local goons
WB & Punjab people wants to be spoon fed. First subsidized ration ... then free ration ... than home delivery ration .... Next may be cooked food
Modi effect is very clear in Gujarat. From early 2000s to 2020 there is growth and then there is growth plateau.
The biggest case study is the decline of eastern state of WB which happened to be the firebrand region on Independent India... Even Bihar and UP is doing better than WB now.
Sanjeev Sanyal
brilliant economist having given up a hugely lucrative position within Deutche bank and joined late Arun Jaitley’s finance team .
This paper ought to be taken seriously .
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
We know about post-1991 story. Would like to know the post-2014 story. Post-1991, all those with pre-existing strengths capitalised on them.
Same happened in case of private sector. Pre-existing corporates from License Raj era, were the first to benefit as they had easy access to credit and could get around restrictive labour laws.
Please do a story on why labour reforms are important. Also, please talk about reforms in accessing credit. Your previous episodes, done a few years ago, were not as popular, as you are today.
And decline of UP/Bihar seems to have plateaued in recent years.
In our textbooks we were always taught how agriculture has the maximum workforce in the country but contributes far lesser to its economic output. 16% is about the same from what I had studied
Mandir politics was pretty much there in Gujarat and Maharashtra. We did well. Only states not doing better are the ones who do left politics.
@@bhavyamankad479 anything bad Shekhar is quick to blame Mandir.
Hindhi is not mother tongue. That's why MH and Guj developed.hindhi ruins all
Kerala has one of the best Human Development index and also does much better in per capita income.
It seems cosmic justice happened instead of "Social Justice"
Draw a diagonal from Gujarat/Rajasthan border to Andhra/Orissa border.
With the exception of Haryana and Delhi-NCR, these are two different countries economically.
UK, Jammu, HP, Rajasthan, Punjab are completely incomparable to so called BIMARU States. Punjab has 5.3% multidimensional poverty rate, much lower than even Karnataka. Even Uttarakhand has lower multidimensional poverty rate than Gujarat.
Please improve your graphs shown in video .
A shame that with 13 crore people Bihar has just 1 million plus city!
Same with Bengal
The Eastern states are the ones which are to be developed now..... Personally I am rooting for our Uttara Karnataka..........Guys, we must demand some tax exemption for the industries there......
It should be a separate state, in my opinion. Bangalore, the capital and business center of the state is too far from Uthara Karnataka.
Also most districts in Uthara Karnataka are a burden to other districts of Karnataka.
@@noneoftheabove666better create more countries why stop at states
@@sriramsakurathat's BS.
Smaller countries in the Indian Subcontinent aren't doing well
Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Nepal are examples
We need leaders like Chandrababu Naidu and Gadkari who are visionaries and focus on Development and quality of work free from petty politics
Up is doing well , bit skewed in western up with Noida driving the most economic growth, their are upcoming centre like Hardoi for textiles, Lucknow if state capital region plan go through, over the time this growth will trickle in other part of state, just like Maharashtra developed on the back of Mumbai or Karnataka on Bengaluru, Noida will become that engine for up, almost all top it companies have their offices at Noida now, if yogi continue for another 10, up will be one of the most industrialised state, he is bringing industry to most remote part like bundelkhand, defence corridor work has already started in jhansi, for Bihar nobody can do anything, it is so much factionalism on basis of caste and their is no visionary leader across party line, opposite of nda is lalu and his family with 9th fail Tejaswi yadav, unless bihar get shock therapy and find someone who can rise state above caste politics nothing will change
what about maharashtra......
Being a malayali watching this video, i couldnt help but wonder why Shekhar Gupta thinks that Kerala is an exception to the South Indian growth story while it contributes almost the same percent to the National GDP as Haryana.
Also, by his own definition Haryana is not a small state, it had a population of 2.5 Cr in 2011 could easily be around 3Cr by now.
Kerala's population has plateaud
Uttar Pradesh is hopeful of major economic boom for next 5 years
Wait till 2027
How Yogi has fared
@@parvadhami980 till 2027 UP isn't going to be 1 trillion economy it will require atleast 8 to 9 years more to achieve this by 2035 instead
UP, Bihar get their remittances from these state workers working in southern states.
My hopothesis is this doesn't paint the accurate economic picture, I would argue, high industrial development around and in certain pockets in certain states led to the some states manifesting above national average PCI but in contrast peripherical districts of those states have not benefited from this fruit of growth of the states. For example western Maharashtra has industrial clusters therefor economically developed, but the same is not true for middle and east Maharastra. I understand here the context was socio-political enviorment but still, there is some degree of truth to what I am saying, we need to understand what are the factors at play here.
Blaming Mandir politics?? How about Gujarat and Maharashtra?
They did Mandir politics but also did Dhandomaxxing
What is new.. this has been going on for decades because of the political dominance of north means parties are promoted and encouraged to stay in power at the center. So instead of performance political support has been given priority
Why did you bring Sharad you could have monologued, you never anyone to express
Mr. Shekar, why don't you do an episode on Sitaram Yechury and Buddhadeb
They don't deserve even a minute of public discourse.
Waste of time and energy
Traitors
Bihar, Jharkhand, WB will never develop because of communist policies. And dumb politicians belonging to lower caste ruling it. They just want to be in power and the cost for it is rampant illiteracy and poverty. People of these states based on caste of the leader not his capabilities to uplift them. Just imagine OBC CMs ruling both UP and Bihar and destroying a state completely. Failure of Kolkata as a port and the communist policies of WB has cost the entire eastern India. With decline of Bhadralok from politics of WB we saw a rise of communists and a steep decline in the intellectual awakening that was taking place in WB.
UP is seeing hope under Yogi with manufacturing industries being set up in the state, and better law and order due to relative decline in criminal elements within politics.
In short ideology matters and guides a state to a certain economic trajectory. But much of Indian voters r dumb to understand all this. They will continue to vote for unyielding freebies and communist policies of instant gratification. We will never see rapid growth in Bihar, WB , Jharkhand just because the people at large are not of sound intellectual capabilities.
So, the rape capital (UP) governed by HalfChaddi R@tard@d terrorist is model for good governance? Bravo. 👏
What is Arvind is it your sponsor 😂
My North and East Indian brothers and sisters will get angry and get their feelings hurt when I say this, it's not coming from a "Superiority" complex but based on facts and reality.
Needs social change before economic change. Don't vote on Hindu Muslim issues, don't vote on mandir masjid issues, get your head out of religion and caste politics, focus on education, education and education. Focus on poverty alleviation. Your states are dragging down Bharat/India. India would have become a middle income economy if BIMARU states performed at par with South and West States of India.
Sorry, but I have to correct you. Sensible guys vote on development not on caste or religion/ secularism lines. You guys will understand the deep rooted impacts of division and recurrent invasions.
WB doesnt vote on mandir masjid still it its going down same with Punjab,why?? Gujrat boomed since 2001 during modi and now India is growing economically under modi, even Yogi is taking UP to betterment...they all came to power doing mandir masjid, so whats your point?
Ever heard of states like Gujrat , Maharashtra and Haryana. They also vote much on the basis of religion like UP , Bihar and Gujrat is top in that list. Remember in 90's during the peak of Ram mandir movement BJP lost most of the elections in UP , Bihar. It's the caste based politics which destroyed these states where all castes are pulling down each other so that no one will get ahead of them, as a result everyone remains backward and no one gets ahead in life. People very easily mention Hindu-Muslim politics but fail to mention caste politics which shows a clear bias in their analysis.
I agree. Hence, no to SP in UP. We don't want to go back to people's caste determining their jobs and worse state of law and order than it already is. Whatever stride UP made under BJP, the momentum should continue. I want the Yogi govt to enforce law and order even more and kick out the Brij Bhushans and zamindar netas who know nothing other than Hindu Muslim Dalit OBC. We need better young leaders focussed on overall development of the state and creating revenue streams to fund planned projects.
nitish destroyed bihar economy
Add Laloo as well
coastal states have bigger advantages over landlocked states when its comes to commerce and trade. For example, any exports from India will be done by businesses operating in such states. Indian govt. is business-minded, its policies work well with industrial and commercial sectors. i agree that vote bank politics harms central-northern states. As large population of India lives in north, political parties try to appeal their sentiments for quick gains, which has inverse effect on economy and society. India is called krishi pradhan desh because of how many people agricultural sector employed in comparison to other sectors.
That's such a cope 😂
The Gangetic belt is one of the most fertile and flat regions of the world. Establish FD industries, corridors, IT parks
Use the waters of Ganga as inland navigation
Speaking hindhi is the reason for backwardness
Kerala should have done much better economically but for the anti-private industry attitude of the present Communist government. Given the large amount of inflow of foreign exchange from overseas Malayalees, a government more hospitable to small medium private business would have registered much better economic performance.
I think the changing point was in late 90ties when a foreign car company was about to be built it's manufacturing plant and communist part took protest too far. It ended up in tamil nadu and boomed the car manufacturing cluster in tamil nadu that was a big miss. Again benefit of communist party is human development index is highest I wonder in Kerala. It's all about balance, without the remittance from NRI this could not have happened with such strong anti private sentiments. Which is ironic as in the end they are working in private corporation just in different country. Which also created the present low employment rates in Kerala. So many well educated people but no jobs.
The reason for Tamil Nadu's lag before the boom was because the Dravidian parties were laying the ground for it. The improvements in educational opportunities and policies empowering various castes eventually powered growth when economy liberalized.
It continues to benefit from this diversified growth. If not for the lag in IT sector and slowdown of textiles in the last decade TN would have retained it's educated youth who are now going to Bangalore and low skill workers from moving to services jobs.
The current push for manufacturing will hopefully help the low skill worker families and built a strong local consumer economy.
The Telugu Desam Party (TDP) has claimed that lab reports of samples sent from Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanam show that the world renowned consecrated sweet Tirupati laddus contain “beef tallow, fish oil" and other substandard ingredients, a claim that has triggered a controversy in the state and among the devotees. I hope Shekar Gupta has the balls to cover this. People would have been lynched if other religion.
Proud to be from south India Telangana Hyderabad ❤ we didn’t have bjp hatred politics here all the communities live peacefully !!
WB PUNJAB and KERALA also didnt hv BJP, why are they falling? See Gujarat since 2001 and now UP improving under BJP, whats your point?