I plugged the AMD Radeon RX 6700 XT into a Raspberry Pi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 тра 2024
- It's not clickbait if it's the truth.
I bought an AMD Radeon RX 6700 XT. I plugged it into a Raspberry Pi. This is what happened.
I would give you a link to where you can buy one, but... you basically can't. I'm thanking my lucky stars I could buy one at MSRP, because if not, I don't think I'd be able to afford the keyboard I'm typing this on!
If you like what you see, and want me to continue doing insane things with Pis and other devices-and maybe someday get an external GPU working on the Pi, please consider supporting the channel:
Support me on Patreon: / geerlingguy
Sponsor me on GitHub: github.com/sponsors/geerlingguy
Merch: redshirtjeff.com
Mentioned in this video:
- Pi PCI Express Database entry for RX 6700 XT: pipci.jeffgeerling.com/cards_... (GitHub issue is also linked there.)
- Gamers Nexus' RX 6700 XT teardown: • Tear-Down: AMD RX 6700...
- How to enable the USB 2.0 ports on CM4: www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/202...
- Pi PCI Express Database entry for older Radeon 5450: pipci.jeffgeerling.com/cards_...
- How to cut the PCIe x1 slot on the CM4 IO Board: TODO
Products I mentioned / used in this video (some are affiliate links):
- AMD Radeon RX 6700 XT: Good luck. Out of stock everywhere.
- Redragon 700W PSU: TODO
- x1 to x16 PCIe riser cable: TODO
- SanDisk Extreme 128GB microSD card: TODO
- Noctua 4-pin PWM fan: TODO
- Molex to floppy power adapter: TODO
#RaspberryPi #AMD
Contents:
00:00 - How much did it cost?
00:50 - Unboxing
04:05 - Pi Problems
05:40 - Plugging it in
09:59 - No explosions, yay!
12:18 - Needed: a Driver
12:40 - Compiling the kernel
20:09 - Something goes wrong
22:03 - Not all is lost! - Наука та технологія
"So could I run Skyrim?"
Asking the real questions here
I mean, Skyrim will run on linux under Proton, with some issues (because of Skyrim). I did it on x86 though, it is highly likely ARM changes the calculus substantially.
But can it run crysis?
I actually got skyrim running on a i5 8gb RAM with intel graphics card on
Tod Howard will rerelease to every platform eventually. It's science
@@abyssalreclass what is he install windows 11 arm with amd graphics ? xD
High spec graphics card, expensive.
Having a missus that laughs at your nerdy jokes, priceless!
That's my sister, and my missus often just rolls her eyes. Good to have both reactions 😂
@@JeffGeerling oops!
(Resists making comment about Alabama)
@@juststeve5542 is h
@@joshuagavaghan224 h
@@JeffGeerling Such is the life of us nerds, destined to be judged by our significant others for how crazy nerdy we are.
“Production raspberry Pi”. That cracked me up.
me too :-)
I think it is relative to the size of the business and how mission critical the purpose. A pi cluster might actually meet production requirements for some small companies. I would think that one could use a pi for a Soho printer server as an example.
Sure! a cuda accelerated pi for cuda heavy applications on ARM :)
A HA setup using Pi might be more production ready than the equivalent priced 'proper' server.
If that's all you can afford, why not? I know some businesses use mini corp PCs in clusters as edge nodes, because it does HA for a cost that can't be beat in the enterprise hardware space.
well, Pis are being used for embedded purposes
there are companies who sell products with Pis (be it CM or not) in them
such companies are actually the biggest customers of the Raspberry Pi Foundation these days
is "red-shirt Jeff" "no shirt Jeff" currently after buying that
"well I still have the shirt on my back".what did you do with red shirt Jeff? Lol
He sold it to a starfleet recruit!
He is currently in the market for a shirt.
@@JeffGeerling - I thought that was the lead-in for doing the rest of the video showing off some rock solid pecks!
@@gristlevonraben as a person that's watched a lot of star trek i love this
>Another 20+ minute rpi+gpu video that ends with no gpu on an rpi
"HE CAN'T KEEP GETTING AWWWAYYYY WIIIITH IIITTTT"
Fuck i wasted 20 minutes of my life... jk skipped to the video XD
Thanks a lot, you save me a lot of time
Every time Jeff says "I could just cut this slot" I imagine red-shirt Jeff somewhere screaming "DO IT" in Palpatine's voice.
Days since recompiling the kernel: 0
Edit:
Hours since recompiling the kernel: 0
LOL.
- recompiles kernel
Two and a half hours later, finding out compiled kernel is 1.45MB....
@@Xiph1980 I'm glad he does this stuff, so I'm not tempted to ! I'm living vicariously through Jeff !
What is the over/under on recompiles since the original air date?
I’ll say 28, and I’ll take the over.
@@Xiph1980 lmao u forgot the kernel modules
A word of caution: never interchange modular power supply cables from different manufacturers.
Not even different models! That will let the blue smoke out of your components.
If it fits, it should be able to carry the rated amount for that connection.
@@CTimmerman the pinout on the PSU itself might be different and you may end up shorting something out
@@FeuerToifel Sounds like an Apple move. CTIA vs OMTP.
It’s wire gauge. Not all adaptors use the same thickness of wire, especially between manufacturers and definitely between models of the same manufacturer. If it’s too thin a gauge, you get to see the blue smoke. That “if it fits” comment is like; sure I’ll put 0-20w oil in my 10-30w spec vehicle, it’s oil! 🤪🤦♂️ and you can definitely fit a 4 gauge in an amp that requires 00… you’ll start a fire. Know your ohm’s laws.
Imagine buying this on the store
Cashier: Cool, what kind of pc are you pairing it with?
Jeff: A pi
"Not the one you eat, the raspberry one"
Bruh nobody should call it a gooey
Edit: wait what, how did this comment switch sections?
Imagine ... buying one ... period!
@@goeland4585 Also Not the one you eat..
@@goeland4585 Cashier: Ah so you eat raspberry flavored pie? Me too!
This is the first of your videos I've ever seen. Nice work toward getting the big card to work on a pi, and the effort you've put into your set shows as well.
I really love everything you do and has inspired me to work with raspberry pi's on my free time ! Thanks a lot
( Hello from Belgium )
Really love the raspberry pi wizardly levels you're getting into
Greetings from Colombia :)
I love this project, legit had this exact idea a year ago. Realizing driver support issues is a major problem when it comes to unsupported architecture was the end for me. I Have hope now tho
As for enabling ssh on the pi, you could also go onto the machine and just run raspi-config and enable ssh under the configure interface which takes about 2 second and a lot fewer keystrokes. Just as an alternative.
Nice video. I especially liked your walk through for the kernel recompiling.
This is exciting!!! I can’t wait for the next episode!!!
In terminal graphical interfaces are normally called TUIs. (too-ee as opposed to goo-ee) fun little word.
TIL
@Shubhkarman Sandhu Why not? Or is that just the toxic masculinity/homophobia coming through?
@@JeffGeerling No, TUI
@@andrewmanthey5759 Damnit, beat me to it
Bruh nobody calls it gooey it's " gee you eye "
interesting as always 👍😀
great first try, looking forward to seeing progress.
Thanks for sharing your experience with all of us 👍😀
Love your videos, it's contributions like these that keep me loving the raspberry pi!
I was going to ask why you went with AMD over Nvidia, but then I remembered Linus Torvalds video to them, so I'm not going to ask that 😂
Drivers! Nvidia is insanely hard to work with if you have problems. Nouveau is valiant reverse engineering but nothing beats getting the source code itself.
@@JeffGeerling Nvidia is just shooting itself in the foot by doing that, but money has this blinding effect when you are on top
itwas alreadydonewithunsuccessful results
My question is why is Nvidia just the assumed choice... This gen, AMD matches or bests them in rasterization... If prices were MSRP, AMD would be a far better value too
@@post-leftluddite Well if you could grab a Founders edition of the 3070 or 3060 ti then value would probably trend toward the nvidia card at msrp. However, since nividia has pulled back on production to artificially keep prices up through to their next launch.. It's really hard to run across nvidia cards that are reasonable priced even at retailers. I was in the market for the 3070 but eventually was able to buy a rx 6700 xt for msrp. I'm perfectly happy with my card and considering how much the nvidia cards have continued to go up.. I feel I got the better deal for my pocketbook
Glad to read you got the GPU at MSRP that would be my only problem with this video if not, good on you for not helping scalpers besides that this is an awesome video man.
always good to watch a video of something that I'm interested to do, but have neither the time nor the willpower to follow through. Looking forward to an update on this :D
Although you are probably not even beyond compiling the driver; given the amount of power that card can consume, once you can try to boot check if the powerrails are stable. The PI might not consume enough 5v, for the power supply to stabilize.
19:45 I did something extremely similar to redirect my starbound saving to my pi so that I could seamlessly jump between my pc and laptop. Worked great, actually. I should make myself a script to automate most of the process and back it up somewhere so that I can quickly set it up on w/e I please, or if I distro hop. I'm tempted to try putting an entire steam library on it so that I can access my games OTA without worrying about my actual devices space and updating on both, but I'm worried about the Pis limitations, and how steam could/would act up with it...
Jeff! You may require a powered riser to provide the 75 watts over the pcie slot; (I'm not 100% sure though, that specific card may be built to work without it) But several cards I own use the 75 watts from the board in combination with the extra 6/8 pin; just something to consider.
Love your channel, keep up the amazing work!
Lol power the riser
Great video Jeff, you lost me few times but really like what you are doing, hope to see this card working soon. 👋
I'm literally in awe with your desktop setup!! would like to have something like that one day!!! :)
Big fan of your videos, you represent our shared home St. Louis well! Keep it up!!
now if you see him, say hi
"I have to justify this purchase..." aaaaahhh good ole' tax write-off. I see what you did there, haha!
Thanks Jeff, never tried compiling a kernel (Except on an old DRS6000 server I used to work on....), so going to have a play with your setup, many thanks
Definitely liked what I saw and was engaged through out. Liked and subbed 👍🏼
Awesome work on this! Can't wait to run Crysis on my Pi.
"Its built in Mali GPU core" it's a VideoCore, broadcom's own thing though isn't it?
It is.
Yeah, slip of the tongue there. oops!
Does anyone know if there's any acceleration in the kernel "lima" driver yet? I am desperate to get a Gentoo Linux build working properly on an old dual-core Banana Pro board with Mali graphics -as well as on the Pi.
@@terrydaktyllus1320 Mali GPUs should be supported very well by Panfrost, no idea about VideoCore.
@@JeffGeerling I paused the video and immediately came here to the comments to check if I wasn't the only one to notice this.
HA! Another great video Jeff! I'll see you around town! (also in St. Louis Area) 🙌
You're such a tease! I was thinking I would finally see you get it working. I know you will, just a matter of time.
1:05 - relate, last time I bought a new GPU was 5 years ago when the GTX 1060 launched and am still using it, but for almost everything else I buy used.
I do love how AMD GPUs have open source linux drivers though im guessing you'll have pi issues. will be neat to GPU accelerate some things off of a pi, I cant think of what I'd do so its probably not useful to me.
I have never bought a new GPU. Had a used 970, and it died. Running a used 980 ti currently 😋
AMD's drivers are not fully Open Source - there are still a lot o binary blobs in their drivers. But they are far more Open Source than NVIDIA.
@@guiorgy No one has released a new game in the last 10 years (with the exception of Fallout 4 in 2015) that is worthy of any kind of GPU upgrade. I have (and am still happily using) a GTX960, a GTX50ti and an AMD R9 380 - they all handle the games worthy of my play time.
@@terrydaktyllus1320 Not everyone wants to play games on low setting.
@@nadirjofas3140 You clearly did not read my comment above. Go read it again, then you'll realise your response above is entirely irrelevant.
You like modern games, I do not - they are derivative, expensive, packed with DLC and buggy upon release. I therefore do not want to "invest" in such a poor quality experience. As I stated above, if you had read it.
AMD: I have cpus with pretty powerful gpus inside them.
2021: you could make a gpu with an integrated computer
Very interesting, Jeff. Thank for the video.
Really enjoyed this video style, nice job
Could you plug your Starlink and your cable ISP and some 4G+/5G modems in one raspberry pi and aggregate these connections into one super fast and super reliable using MPTCP (especially from Kernel)?
these are the real questions
"Well, at least I still have a shirt on my back". However, Red....Jeff, wont be allowed on camera any time soon.
Nice video, that is some really some cool stuff in there, I always wondered if Pi did anything really? Looks like a fun project. Holy mother of god that looks like a headache twister storm of massive proportions....have fun buddy...lol
Yes I've been waiting for this!
you plugged it in and it failed. . . roll credits
Check out the linked issue on GitHub. Progress is slow, but visible.
"What if I wanted to run crysis on my rpi?" THAT is the spirit I'm here for :D:D
The real question is: can it run Doom?
@@micahlindley7515 it can run Quake III, so I imagine Pi can run Doom.
In contrast to using a Ryzen for typing up documents...
Fantastic. Still remember some kernel building on Linux in the very early 2k's. This is awesome.
I agree with a Raspberry Pi version, being equipped wit a standard ATX feed.
Namasté.
Second I heard you payed OUT OF POCKET I subbed with notifs and liked :)
And I will continue to like your videos
0:43 "at least i still have shirt on my back"
well, seems that's not the case for Red Shirt Jeff
Thank you Jeff for all the work you've put into the Pi and creating invaluable resources and pleasant videos to watch!
I started this year with Raspberry Pi. That means I google a a lot of stuff related to the Pi and Linux generally.
It has become something regular to see questions asked and answered by Jeff online. I really enjoy seeing the same questions I have being asked by the person who in my eyes is one the most knowledgeable on raspberry and programming in general. It really motivates me to look for solutions and try new things out in ways not done before and learning by trial and error.
I am far from one of the most knowledgeable, I just am lucky to be able to share the little bits of knowledge I have more widely :)
Thanks for explaining everything the way that you do.
Congratz on the progress of plugging egpu into the pi.
Hi Jeff, thanks for the work done. Such questions:
1) Is the Gigabyte Radeon RX 6600 EAGLE 8G card suitable for these purposes?
2) If so, where can I find drivers for it?
3) If not, what chips are suitable for these purposes? I looked at your site and I think that the video card that I suggested should be suitable for these purposes.
Thanks Jeff!
The main reason for multiple cables isn't the conductors from the PSU -- it's multiple *pins* on the connectors that matter. Those connection points are where the majority of the resistance occurs (and thus resistive heating).
..well actually thats in part correct, 1. a conductor has a limited surface area (perpendicular to the flow of electrons), 2. at higher frequencys the self impedance of any none super conductor will increase, 3. electrons will be forced outward in the cables, 4. at 6GHZ ther is about zero electrons, passing trough the center of the cable regadless of load, wich means more cables (and more fine threaded) the more surface area to conduct it will be to even out load at higher frequencys, even if the main clock itself isent 6GHz ther is more clocks..and together they are not 100% synced wich adds higher frequency ripple in the cables (the electrons move considerbly faster than the PSU can compensate)
Thanks for the awesome content!
Excellent! Keep up the good work!
If you have one of your monitors die, you could take it apart and remove the dark parts and use it as a led light for more lighting, I’ve done this with a 40” TV. Nice video.
Speaking of Rage 128, I really wish somebody could get full AGP acceleration in Linux, on the old iMac G3's, which use the Rage 128.
nice for tutorial and I loved to subscribe.
could you make playlist about step by step tutorial mining using raspberry pi and which GPU properly suitable.
and which mining pool should our choose 2miners, nicehash or etc.
I cant wait for this ....
Great Dude
Hey nice video as always. Btw you forgot to cover your air vent 😬😬😂😂
nice to see your vent open
I did an experiment during filming; with two people in the office it got up past 1700 ppm after only 20 minutes with the vent closed! with it open, stayed under 800 ppm the whole time.
@@JeffGeerling It's not as bad as you think - please leave it open, I'm jumping the gun a bit, but I imagine a large part of your demographic watches on a phone anyways, so it wouldn't be visible for most people.
Besides, if you leave it open permanently, you'll think clearer and have more content :)
do this IO board have some special pcie slot? normal x1 slot can provide just 25W max...
Oops, you're right! PCI Express 'normal' x16 can supply 75W. High power x1 can do up to 25W.
Is the graphics card able to run only getting 25W from the pi? Can the pi even supply 25W? I know the card also receives power also from the 8 pin and 6 pin connectors, but could it be dependant on getting those first 75W from the PCI? I guess I'm saying, maybe it will be mandatory to have a powered PCI riser, because the one in the video doesn't look powered.
@@weekendtech I would guess that AMD adheres to the PCIe spec and only draws 25w when it detects the x1 connection. The fact that the fans spun up is a good indicator that the 6700 thinks thinks are ok; I've yet to meet a GPU card that did anything at all when given insufficient power sources (other than angry LED flash patterns). Jeff might want to put an ammeter on the power leads to the Pi and see if it the number is reasonable...
@@weekendtech It’s kind of annoying how there’s no real answer for this question yet, I always think the same thing but with rack servers and pci cards
Great video, looking forward to seeing whether you get it running at some point! One thing I noticed that could be done more easily is instead of using SSHFS to copy over files, you could just pipe the output of `tar` over SSH, this allows you to run `sudo` on the other side without needing to login as root: tar c . | ssh user@host sudo tar x
Or just scp over the files
@@randomfish42 you would then need to enable root login again
Dude, after 4 months there is no news about this? your videos are awesome. liked and subscribed.
There's some news, but I need a little more time to brush it up in video form :)
Jeff is such a great motivation for me on my own UA-cam journey, I am glad I was motivated by this man.
That compile error could be fixed with one line of C, it just needs to declare the function before it tries to call it. This might indicate a larger issue, but at worst it will move the error into the linker stage.
Your videos and I have spent so many lunch breaks together 😁😁😁
I really respect this man , Keep uploading!
"The first step is getting it unboxed."
SUCCESS!
Usually that kind of errors happen when there is missing a required kernel feature or component, but there is a bug in config generator that don't notice your or autoselect that required feature so you must guess which one is by yourself
That bug would be in the config description files provided with the module or base kernel.
мужик, обожаю твои видео, так рад что начинает получаться с amd, успехов тебе, буду наблюдать и плюсовать)
very interesting. good job Jeff
Note: an alternative to sshfs to copy the files across is to set up sshd on the pi as shown, then use the scp command for copying between machines.
It's a matter of taste which you prefer.
I would say that scp or sftp is way better if you're just copying over a couple files, but sshfs is great if you want to interact with several files, like edit one here, copy over that there, etc
Or rsync :)
Hey Jeff, have you thought about using manjaro for your testing, they have newer linux kernels being arch based and might show different results.
Congrats on the sub's I was watching you at 40 thousand :) Not 199 thousand well done. Its great content to watch and If I wasnt a student and short on money myself I would sponsor. Maybe in the future when get a good computer science job I will . Great learning from you God bless
No problem at all! I'm just glad you can learn with me!
Your setup is sick
"It's a pretty hefty card" - You haven't met the triple slot chonker, the FTW3 3070.
I've only heard of that one. I imagine I'd have to do a workout regimen to be able to lift it!
@@JeffGeerling it’s massive. Barely fits in my case. Weighs like 3 pounds.
Good lord.
Quad slot 3080 Master.
@@JirayD and then there is that card. It physically cannot fit in my pc.
"So they don't include a user manual anymore. That's fine because i don't read it anyways".
The user manual 3 seconds later: *Bonjour*
Jeff. Your a madman. Sub well earned
Just watched something a bit scary and I saw your video so I clicked, definitely made me feel a lot better.
Jeff is milking it that pci gen 2 1x for as much as UA-cam is worthy
You know it!
He's got to pay for the toys somehow!
You can't hide your excitement in your face when unboxing your GPU 😁
That grin when he picked up the box--priceless.
First I used your ansible roles and then I found your UA-cam channel which is very interesting. Wow!
"...so could I run Skyrim?"
Yes - and with mods and a mod manager - just like in Windows - even with online multiplayer (with SkyrimTogether)! And it works perfectly 👌
I also recently found out that support for many controllers are available right out of the box. Pretty handy.
Here i was expecting to see you connect the Radeon RX 7600 XT and see it work with the raspberry pi and then you ran into a bug and the video stopped, refreshing. Looking forward to the follow up.
WOW! You MUST be from the future! Tell me how well the 7600XT works? WHat are the specs? Here I am stuck with the ancient 6800XT that I got wayyy back in 2021 and yYOU have the 7600xt. Now I'm jealous! Also, could use some stock tips? How's bitcoin doing in 2023? Reply ONLY if it won't break the time-space continuum.
@@ITS-ME-EVERLY wait you dont have the Radeon RX 42069 XT Max Super??
@@baregen forgot the TI version bro
@@ruizfuentebella51 damn i forgot about the TI version... what about the TI Ultra Max version??
@@baregen yeah i think thats better
The recent interest in Linux GPU support on non-x86 platforms has done wonders for my 16-year-old PowerMac G5 Quad running Gentoo. I stuck an HD 5450 in it a long while back just because I had it laying around and while FB console has worked on it for many years, it's now (as of about a month ago) pretty much fully functional beside some console spew about unsupported texture formats and runs Gnome really nicely. I had been tempted to try a newer AMD GPU with HDMI 2.0 so I can run my UHD monitors at full resolution, but obviously current GPU pricing makes buying even a low end one as an experiment a bit futile.
This guy's asking the right questions in life.
I'm gonna buy that shirt for every gentoo user i know
I wanted to get into pies and you are the first channel that has caught my eye a new subscriber to you sir
When you run this docker container on the mac, are you running an x86 (or 64 or whatever) image via some kind of emulator?
Proton/Wine seem to be pretty intimately tied to x86/64.
Well, I'll write my own Proton then! :)
qemu userspace emulation is a thing though. Performance likely won't be good, but it should work.
Kernel 5.14 was released with Pi 400 support so there's non zero chance it will work just fine with CM4, have you tried going vanilla kernel or the pi fork and it's rpi-5.14.y branch?
btw once your kernel build fails, you can just re-run make and it will skip already built parts and gets you all the errors, no need to scroll though initial build log, glory of the incremental build systems.
True on both accounts. And I'm building off the rip-5.14.y branch, though it's literally upstream, just usually a few days behind. No custom patches on it like the 5.10 branch.
@@JeffGeerling you should give arch Linux arm a try in combination with the upstream kernel, this should give you a more recent mesa stack
@Rishi R Debian ist great if you rely on stability (I like referring to it as "digital concrete"), arch is my preferred distro for up-to-date software versions though
I have the 5700XT reference model, and that is such a better cooler lol. Its a decent card but this last generation was a decent jump, id love to upgrade for a better cooler and raytracing - wont be going AMD this time just because of driver issues tho. Cool vid!
.. 0 days since kernel compile .. love it!
I'd love to see a Google TPU on a compute module
20:47 - oh, that chuckle in the background is cute :3
Clearly she understands the pain.
not just with the AMD GPU driver on ARM. I had compile failures galore with the AMD GPU driver on AMD as well. kernels from 5.11 and up were much less hassle.
" ... Usually i buy things used ..." This is very good for multiple reasons and may let me hit the subscribe button in the future ;-) good attitude please keep it like that!
"Until next time I'm Jeff Geerling..." Planning a rename soon?
He used to be Jeff geerling, he still is but he used to be, too.
Apologies to Mitch.
From a kid of the pre always-on internet era where the fortune command on unix terminal was hours of entertainment before we had endless content