Honestly don’t get some of the negative comments here. Video too long? What do you expect when you’re doing a 4-car comparison? Sure, some aspects could have been better but at least we were provided with a comprehensive overview of all the viable contenders in this price bracket in ONE video. My personal choice would be the Honda City as well. Each car has their merits and I know this because I recently test drove all of them aside from the Almera. You just can’t beat it’s interior quality, comfort, spaciousness, and looks especially in that RS trim. But of course, to each their own. Buy whatever makes you happy most, it’s your money anyway 🥳
Bought Almera last year because S70 took so long to launch. Was very skeptical with 1.0 engine but I was amazed with its transmission.. So smooth & quite compared to city & vios. Test drive my brother's s70 it was cool too 😍 but i feel like the cabin space a bit small maybe because of the centre console & the steering as well.. Nevertheless, never regretted buying Almera despite how people been talking shit about it 😂 it's an entry level car. Not so much different with the rest.
rear design, the winner is s70, confortable winner is honda city, durable winner is vios, my selected is honda city because it meets all the customer's needs.
User almera here (compare to vios and city) Pro: Fuel consumption can go up to 600km for one full tank (RM65) The best acceleration. Large bootspace Clean interior setup Cvt that doest feel like cvt. Rare car, so feel special. Con: Driver low visibility (cannot see the extand of front) Second row passanger space quite limiting No fancy system like acc. Fuel consumption can be worst if maintain top speed due to turbo Lack customisation & mod Questionable spare part (not many user)
@sheffieldgeek I write "," not "=" totally different meaning if u know the symbols. Anyway, s70 lose in bad after sales and fuel consumption, Malaysian most concern bout this.
@@sheffieldgeek depends on everyone's preference. i wouldnt like everything i do to be controlled on a screen and i wouldnt want my back passengers to be uncomfortable and as well as i wouldnt want my car to sound like it runs on a diesel engine. so yes the city wins compared to s70
Recent buyer of the Honda City in Brazil here. Watching reviews videos from around the world. And it's fascinating how Honda has a consistent good quality B segment car. It's a good purchase anywhere in the world (and it's also the most expensive of the segment everywhere). The Versa (Almera) is also one of the contenders here, and it's just not quite there in terms of tech, quality, comfort and reliability. It's nice to know I have a consistent product. Toyota doesn't sell this Vios here (it's stuck in the last generation. and it's called Yaris in the Americas). I wish the City already had the LSF package here, but apparently it's only on the Thai City. But the Honda Sensing package overall is the best ADAS package in the category.
Actually, main selection comes from how the user going to use the car. 1. A-B solo mostly, then get the cheapest 2. Sales person - expenses is covered by company. Need to be comfortable and reliable for long distance 3. Family trips mostly - need better space and comfort 4. Multi purpose and sharing with family member like wife - need a mutual understanding on each person needs. 5. Choose because of feature, power, speed or design - follow your wallet and desire.
@@AreQymiy For your information, this video shows the Honda City RS Petrol variant not the hybrid variant. Petrol variant has the largest boot space among the 4.
I would wonder if is it a rs petrol or ehev.. but once that guy came into that car i know from the handbrake.. it is petrol bro.. not rs hybrid.. @AreQymiy
@@jessccy yeah. Very elegant and timeless design. Wondering how the facelift model would be. Really want AC included as current model won't be getting any except for X70 recently launched facelift.
Each car has its own perks and non are better than the other. I test drive all the car except the Almera because of the smaller displacement engine and CVT but I have driven the last gen 1.5L(it's okay la). When comparing all 3 cars (City, Vios and S70) in a test drive, these are my 2 cents: 1. City Pros: Good fuel mileage, comfortable, nice pickup from start, NVH is good Cons: CVT noise highspeed, suspension a bit hard when hitting potholes, interior design don't attract me 2.Vios Pros: Good fuel mileage, comfortable, NVH is very good Cons: CVT noise is worse than Honda at low/highspeed, takes forever to get to 100, the backend pulls you when cornering (100kmh) 3. S70 Pros: Good fuel mileage (driven respectfully), comfortable, NVH is very good, 0-100 can tapau all those cars in the list, Cons: the backend pulls you when cornering (140kmh+), gas mileage is bad when paddle to metal, suspension too soft and need to be stiffen if you want better comfort and handling, harsh engine noise when outside and yeah, it's a 3-cylinder if you think it's bad. Regardless of brand, I chose S70 than the other 2. I don't mind the nick-picky part from electronics and also 3-cylinder is relatively easy to work on. Bear in mind the after-sale service from some service center but there are good ones (if you can find them). Gas mileage for me is good by getting 600kmh full tank city driving. Been using the car for 6 months and the only complain is the AC noise (glug2) but can be fix at the SC (when provide evidence of course). Sekian my 2 cents.
For the noise and vibration, 1 of my friends tested with a less viscous engine oil (0W-20) and the sound just turn down considerably. For long term usage is still under observation but the engine feels a lot smoother and less noise compared using 5W-30.
For me I will pick the proton s70 because of it design it is nice for me I like the rear light show when you lock and unlock the car I just wish there was keyless entry on the passenger side and it is the sensor type and the price is a good as well for the interior I like the design the materials everything looks nice and the sunroof I like it as well but I just wish the s70 had a auto rear mirror and lights in the sun visors aside from that it is a nice car . In terms of engine I don’t mind the sound of the 3 cylinder engine but the fuel consumption i wish it was better but other wise the proton is a good choice for me. Second choice for me will be the Honda city looks very nice very simple and good looking though the car has been in the market for about 4 years it’s still good looking but I wish there was auto folding side mirror but other wise is nice in terms of interior it is nice the seats feels very nice and plush to the touch and the materials used in the car is nice I just wish they can add things like electronic parking brake with auto hold for all variants electronic adjustable driver seat , the glove box will have soft opening , auto up and down for all four windows, tyre pressure monitor system and auto wipers, the semi digital cluster maybe from the v spec, auto rear view mirror and lights in the sun visors but aside from all this things the Honda city is a good car but for me if I want to buy the Honda city I will buy the v spec because not really a fan of the rs touches just like the v spec feels elegant and more like a luxury car and it does not miss out much from the rs spec aside from the black touches and the dual tone rims and the interior only the black roof and the read stitches so this are the two cars I can choose but I lean to the s70 but if not the Honda city is my second choice.my third choice is the vios I like the exterior so nice and striking for me does led lights in the front and back wow but the interior they are some things I like and don’t like the things I like is the screen so clear and nice , the electronic parking brake (EPB) and auto hold so nice and premium the auto hold is very useful during traffic situation. The things I don’t like is the materials in the car the materials from perodua at least Toyota should have their own materials instead of bringing in perodua materials and I hope the next facelift they will change all the perodua materials into thier on materials especially the digital screen they should bring the digital screen from the Corolla altis to the vios and the wheel in the car should be changed the ac control and the ac vents should also be changed and they should bring back the ac vent that is on the dashboard and they should bring back the auto rear view mirror and the sun visors they should add mirror in the passenger side and light in both side the seats should have electronic adjustments and they should bring back the soft opening for the glove box and bring back 60:40 split folding for the seats and armrest and the spare tyre and add features like auto wipers and tyres pressure monitor system and the door cart I don’t like it at all I like the previous generation door cart to this they should bring in a new door cart I hope in there next facelift and the car key they should have there on key instead of taking from perodua and add the function of if you hold unlock on the key for few seconds the windows will come and hold lock for the windows to go up and auto up and down windows for all for windows in the safety department they should add back the seven airbags like the previous generation instead of six and put back the rader in the badge and get a single camera like other safety systems like Honda instead of having a dual camera like perodua I just hope all this things can be changed during thier facelift . The 4 car is the almera the exterior is nice but the interior is not going for me I don’t know why the interior is small no rear aircond vent no and etc but to round everything up my favourite car is the s70 the design is nice and beautiful it has the right proportions and the interior is nice .
S70 + for performance fresh design in our market all others in this comparison insanely boring lol! (except Almira) , negative part, thirsty for city drive , start off from stationary really need refinement that sudden surge in power/torque can be a bit dangerous .
I have been using Honda City RS petrol for 6 months now. At first I was quite sceptical about the price. However, after months of doing the comparison, watching reviews and asked the owners, I finally bought a city. And so far, I love the car very much. Eventhough city is not the best, but it has the overall winning package.
Great comparison. I own s70 because of the comfort. Its weird because im a 140kg gorilla and of all 4 cars, i feel a lot spacious in the proton. It is a c-segment tho.
Honda City is one of largest boot space in B segment. 519 liter. Pls kindly do refer to the specification from Official Honda Malaysia. The information given in the video as 410L is for the hybrid version which was not use here in this comparison.
I really don't like the body shapes of the Almera, City or Vios. Granted, the design of the Vios is nice but it still stubby in design. The S70 has really nice proportions. The interior is really nice, it has a lot of good tech and I will always take dual clutch over a CVT. Proton did pretty well with the S70. Second favourite would be the Vios cause the handling of the chassis is really nice and its still good looking even though its kind of stubby. Third would be the City for me cause performance and lastly would be the Almera. But if you have any of them, you're doing pretty well. Nice comparison video and especially love the Tiny Tim segment as its really helpful to judge the space in the back seats👍
Agree with you regarding the s70 it has nice proportion and the interior is nice but I put honda second and vios third and the last almera if possible I will like to put the vios second but can’t la because of the materials used in the car aside from the vios would have been second for me.
@pistonmalaysia thanks for this video covering the differences between the cars, it sure must have been a challenge trying to recall the differences across the board. However i think you could improve with your script, there are moments where your statements are contradictory - for example you started the review of the vios with a pretty unimpressive personal view of the car, and then when you stepped inside you said that it was an impressive car, and this particular behavior continues throughout this review. Looking forward to more of your vids sir 👍
On the other hand, not scripting means raw opinion...which is what we want isn't it?...mainstream TV is already heavily scripted and screened, come on.
Persona is a reliable car if you can invest on the tires. Mine already clocked 150k km, never broke down, never let me down. The only complaint i have is the rims is too soft and tires less favourable. Switched the tires to michelin xm2 and changed raxer rims 15 inch, now its smooth glider.
If you taking finance or loan then might want the Jap cars may be considered if cash diff story . Assuming you take a 7-9 yr loan on local car better then go Jap la.
Honda city has 519L boot space. The 410L is for the hybrid only due to the battery. As the city has a handbrake, i believe that is the rs petrol variant with 519L space.
I am biased towards Almera, the seat and comfort is great for me at least, although it's sad that the rear headroom is lacking. Fuel economy wise, at least you still can achieve it on the lowest spec model. Honda City, only the RS model if im not wrong. Toyota, anyone who buys them generally don't care for it's looks. Honda nothing to say, good all rounder, just minus any steering feel. Proton S70, cant deny, it's a good car too, if you have no issues with paying for more fuel.
S70 is like B+ segment for me 😅 The size stuck in B segment but for the performance more to C segment car. I think Proton nowadays is more reliable and practically. We can see x70 since 2018 until now already get more (+) feedback from Malaysian. I believe Proton is trying the best. So if someone who need feel good performance + luxury, s70 might be the good one. Value money, for long term like I said Proton is trying to deliver the best. City + Vios still the best for their own durability, they have their own fans same goes to Almera.
Honda City ftw, best overall package. boot space, interior space, fuel efficiency, reliable no ping pong ADAS, only beaten by s70 for engine performance.
Interesting comparisons although rather long video.. I own the Almera and it serves me well, easy to drive and very good fuel economy, lacking in power? Not for me, on highways can easily reach 120kmph on a 2K rpm with fuel economy not sacrificed.. my wife owns the S70.. haha that’s a different type of driving feel altogether.
Which car would you say is better in comfort and fuel efficient while cruising on the highway @~110km/h? When I say comfort, it includes seats support and NVH level.
@@loserman007I can’t really comment on city and Vios as I don’t have those cars.. all I can say is the Almera can easily achieve around 22km/l and above on a cruising speed of 110kmph. But the NVH is not top class. Can hear road noise. The S70 is much quieter and smoother drive but won’t achieve the fuel efficiency of the almera. I find the Almera seats offer better support than the S70. Just my personal view. I guess there is no perfect car.
@@cocobos im so sorry to ask this but are you guys rich people? im no rich but i really want it to be my first car 😮💨 im also still quite young so should i reconsider buying a much more affordable one? the proton sales im contacting is due by next week, could you help me with this decision... huhu
@@anggwn_ It depends on your salary. I'm a middle aged man, and already retired (early) but still do some freelance jobs (soft/game dev). My 1st car was a second hand, paid lump-sum, so it won't put much burden. Though I have low salary at that time. It's all up to your budget.
Please compare the s70 with the c segment cars like civic,Corolla altis and mazda 3 and if possible the b segments suv like the proton x50 , Honda hrv, cherry omada 5 and the Toyota Corolla cross.
The proton X70 3 cylinder engine has mounting issues due to its harsh vibration. This Proton S70 basically the same setup so most probably the current owner will face this silly premature mounting failure in the near future.
I'm more incline towards city, but compared to others like s70, the interior look like old car, with less gadget and accessories compared to others. So its hard for me to choose
Kuro already means black. So kuro is the new black edition. Tomei is just the kit they're using. So kuro edition is essentially Tomei's kit which is blacked out. 5:46
@@haarrvingvraj5500wrong, s70 actually in C segment... close compare with Altis Corrola not Civic Fe.... Same size, powerful engine, premium interior.etc
I drove all 4 in a harsh manner and i think the almera is the sportiest handling of the lot. The s70 has a fun gearbox but not very comfy. The vios is literally the worst one compared to the past two generations, its underpowered, poor nvh and not comfortable at all. The city is literally overall better. Comfortable, good nvh, handling is alright, decent power and i felt that the fuel consumption is better during jam as compared to the rest. Could be better on corners and agility but that can be modified in the long run. Eventually decided to get a city, i hope that decision is not gonna bite me while i wait for my car to be delivered 😅
@@lplp7656 almera has the most sportiest drive but the engine is not great. After my test drive i could barely hold the bonnet and open it, too hot. Also this one u will 100% know its 3 cylinders. It vibrates like crazy
kuro is black, black edition = kuro edition. tomei is the brand that is used for the bodykit. nothing confusing about kuro or tomei is used for almera.
Get a car based on your primary wan, sometime we are too concerned with distractions (including offer and discounts) and ended up dreading their decision; after all it is a huge investment.
All car is good.. but for me 2nd value is no 1.. i has preve and get excident total lost after use 3 year.. insuren just cover haft.. balance i must topup..😢. Settle this.. my choice after this vios/city only .. no more proton.. full stop.
My only problem with honda cars r the quality of the car is getting worst. If you watch any cvt gearbox problems video it must be from honda cars. This does not happen only in malaysia. Other countries also facing the same problem with honda's cvt.
comparing all 4 cars and describing each of them is crazy amount of work. Details are bound to be missed like the city RS petrol actually has the biggest boot size at 519L, beating the s70 (410L is for ehev). Also, low speed follow is only available in ehev as well. Great video nonetheless, it certainly is not an easy feet to pull.
alhamdulillah.. tak menyesal beli vios keli variant G dgn interior warna cream yg dah tak keluar lg dah lepas tu.. seat belakang yg blh lipat dgn middle armrest.. single vvti tapi lebih hp dr dual vvti
Well done bro, 👏🏾.You did an amazing job and I can see your review is too honest unlike other paid reviewer's. Anyway send my regards to Tiny Tim🤗 Oh ya I'm Vishnu from Proton can pm anyone interested in S70 🤣
No spare tyre is a big concern to me. Hence toyota vios is a no go to me. Almera design is outstanding and better than his own old almera which looks very dumb. But a 1.0 is a small car engine no matter how it clarified himself a turbo or not. With the price of this segment, almera seem not a really worth for me. City and s70 is the first two runner for me as well. But, for design, I prefer s70 more.
City no doubt that have the biggest interial and much comfortable to be, talk about engine it have the most powerful 1.5 NA in the market. Vios like feel like Daihatsu instead like previous model. Nissan Almera totally not in my list because it has the worst interial to be and much smaller than Axia, this car totally no power although with the turbo engine. S70 have the most powerful and best handling, but definitely not C segment car and as you say B+ segment. For me totally will chose Honda, I chose a car that have better reliability and for long term use, not to regret later.
Bought vios 3 months ago. Driven 11k km already. Put simply, Its perodua quality at higher price. Definitely, previous gen was better. Daihatsu is not toyota
Selepas pertimbangan kesemua ini, sy memilih Nissan Almera Turbo Kuro GT Edition , boleh katakan sempurna untuk segmen B, sportier looks lagi2 sy memilih glacier grey, x perlu modify lg da,huhu highway 180 masih tegap steady..
yes tegap steady even pakai tayar stndrd 205/55/16 rse stabil je and cut off 192km walaupn engine sama axia tpi cpt naik speed dia n rasa ringan mcm feeling 1.8cc
Almera on glacier grey and bodykit looks best to me. The rear spoiler stuck to the boot looks to sporty, there is another low profile spoiler which is flushed to the top of the boot, that one looks better than this to me. No doubt the Almera has less power than the rest but as what the reviewer found, it is most comfortable, fun and easy to drive with good nvh. This review forgot to mention that Honda City comes with rattling sound inside the cabin due to poor fit and finish. The City is the worst among Honda models to show rattling sound even though it is less than 1 year old.
Honestly don’t get some of the negative comments here. Video too long? What do you expect when you’re doing a 4-car comparison? Sure, some aspects could have been better but at least we were provided with a comprehensive overview of all the viable contenders in this price bracket in ONE video.
My personal choice would be the Honda City as well. Each car has their merits and I know this because I recently test drove all of them aside from the Almera. You just can’t beat it’s interior quality, comfort, spaciousness, and looks especially in that RS trim. But of course, to each their own. Buy whatever makes you happy most, it’s your money anyway 🥳
My pick too the City but now S70 is around with more robust gearbox, I' sway too S70. Cheaper & turbo engine are the bonuses.
Bought Almera last year because S70 took so long to launch. Was very skeptical with 1.0 engine but I was amazed with its transmission.. So smooth & quite compared to city & vios. Test drive my brother's s70 it was cool too 😍 but i feel like the cabin space a bit small maybe because of the centre console & the steering as well.. Nevertheless, never regretted buying Almera despite how people been talking shit about it 😂 it's an entry level car. Not so much different with the rest.
Just change your cvt fluid regularly. Even before the due date or mileage
Proton S70 look so much better compare to others. But still looks are subjective..
For me Nissan Almeera looks more Handsome... but the price is overprice..
Yeah, looks are subjective
for me Best to worst looking is S70 > City > Vios > Almera
for me im not look on Exterior cuz i want drive the car Everyday... so s70 was good choice ngl with soft touch, smooth Head unit.etc
@@kauaku4424road tax lebih priceless mahh 😅
@@tendopain8554 ha'ah lupe.. 1.0 turbo... road tax like axia...
The new Vios is just a waste of money. It doesn’t worth the price. It’s just like buying a Perodua for 100k
no spare tyre oso
Agreed.😢
Is reliable and is japanese
@@chikinhsieh1503 its thailand based and rawang made 🙂
no spare tyre n unfolded rear seat 60:40
rear design, the winner is s70, confortable winner is honda city, durable winner is vios, my selected is honda city because it meets all the customer's needs.
User almera here (compare to vios and city)
Pro:
Fuel consumption can go up to 600km for one full tank (RM65)
The best acceleration.
Large bootspace
Clean interior setup
Cvt that doest feel like cvt.
Rare car, so feel special.
Con:
Driver low visibility (cannot see the extand of front)
Second row passanger space quite limiting
No fancy system like acc.
Fuel consumption can be worst if maintain top speed due to turbo
Lack customisation & mod
Questionable spare part (not many user)
Almera- fuel consumption
vios- quality
s70- technology, premium interior, powerful engine and gearbox
city- largest interior, overall winner.
S70 declared as c segment not a b segment
largest interior = overall winner? you make me laugh. Proton S70 is the overall winner if you take price into the equation.
@sheffieldgeek I write "," not "=" totally different meaning if u know the symbols. Anyway, s70 lose in bad after sales and fuel consumption, Malaysian most concern bout this.
@@ranceng6560 Honda fuel consumption is not any better. AFter sales is too early to say S70 is much worse.
@@sheffieldgeek depends on everyone's preference. i wouldnt like everything i do to be controlled on a screen and i wouldnt want my back passengers to be uncomfortable and as well as i wouldnt want my car to sound like it runs on a diesel engine. so yes the city wins compared to s70
Recent buyer of the Honda City in Brazil here. Watching reviews videos from around the world. And it's fascinating how Honda has a consistent good quality B segment car. It's a good purchase anywhere in the world (and it's also the most expensive of the segment everywhere). The Versa (Almera) is also one of the contenders here, and it's just not quite there in terms of tech, quality, comfort and reliability. It's nice to know I have a consistent product. Toyota doesn't sell this Vios here (it's stuck in the last generation. and it's called Yaris in the Americas). I wish the City already had the LSF package here, but apparently it's only on the Thai City. But the Honda Sensing package overall is the best ADAS package in the category.
Actually, main selection comes from how the user going to use the car.
1. A-B solo mostly, then get the cheapest
2. Sales person - expenses is covered by company. Need to be comfortable and reliable for long distance
3. Family trips mostly - need better space and comfort
4. Multi purpose and sharing with family member like wife - need a mutual understanding on each person needs.
5. Choose because of feature, power, speed or design - follow your wallet and desire.
The bootspace of Honda City is 519 liters. It’s not the smallest of the 4. It’s actually the largest. Kindly add corrections to the video.
For your information, honda city hybrid boot space only 410 litres. Only the petrol ones 519 litres.
@@AreQymiyin this video, City RS (Petrol version).
@@AreQymiy in the video is not hybrid
@@AreQymiy For your information, this video shows the Honda City RS Petrol variant not the hybrid variant. Petrol variant has the largest boot space among the 4.
I would wonder if is it a rs petrol or ehev.. but once that guy came into that car i know from the handbrake.. it is petrol bro.. not rs hybrid.. @AreQymiy
I personally will lean more toward Proton... Unsure why...
@@wongkoewei9829 probably you like it for it's value for money, looks aint bad either.
@@jessccy yeah. Very elegant and timeless design. Wondering how the facelift model would be. Really want AC included as current model won't be getting any except for X70 recently launched facelift.
Each car has its own perks and non are better than the other. I test drive all the car except the Almera because of the smaller displacement engine and CVT but I have driven the last gen 1.5L(it's okay la). When comparing all 3 cars (City, Vios and S70) in a test drive, these are my 2 cents:
1. City
Pros: Good fuel mileage, comfortable, nice pickup from start, NVH is good
Cons: CVT noise highspeed, suspension a bit hard when hitting potholes, interior design don't attract me
2.Vios
Pros: Good fuel mileage, comfortable, NVH is very good
Cons: CVT noise is worse than Honda at low/highspeed, takes forever to get to 100, the backend pulls you when cornering (100kmh)
3. S70
Pros: Good fuel mileage (driven respectfully), comfortable, NVH is very good, 0-100 can tapau all those cars in the list,
Cons: the backend pulls you when cornering (140kmh+), gas mileage is bad when paddle to metal, suspension too soft and need to be stiffen if you want better comfort and handling, harsh engine noise when outside and yeah, it's a 3-cylinder if you think it's bad.
Regardless of brand, I chose S70 than the other 2. I don't mind the nick-picky part from electronics and also 3-cylinder is relatively easy to work on. Bear in mind the after-sale service from some service center but there are good ones (if you can find them). Gas mileage for me is good by getting 600kmh full tank city driving. Been using the car for 6 months and the only complain is the AC noise (glug2) but can be fix at the SC (when provide evidence of course).
Sekian my 2 cents.
For the noise and vibration, 1 of my friends tested with a less viscous engine oil (0W-20) and the sound just turn down considerably. For long term usage is still under observation but the engine feels a lot smoother and less noise compared using 5W-30.
Was just thinking about this comparison and saw this video was posted 1 day ago. Excellent video and thanks for doing this comparison
Glad you liked it.
For me I will pick the proton s70 because of it design it is nice for me I like the rear light show when you lock and unlock the car I just wish there was keyless entry on the passenger side and it is the sensor type and the price is a good as well for the interior I like the design the materials everything looks nice and the sunroof I like it as well but I just wish the s70 had a auto rear mirror and lights in the sun visors aside from that it is a nice car . In terms of engine I don’t mind the sound of the 3 cylinder engine but the fuel consumption i wish it was better but other wise the proton is a good choice for me. Second choice for me will be the Honda city looks very nice very simple and good looking though the car has been in the market for about 4 years it’s still good looking but I wish there was auto folding side mirror but other wise is nice in terms of interior it is nice the seats feels very nice and plush to the touch and the materials used in the car is nice I just wish they can add things like electronic parking brake with auto hold for all variants electronic adjustable driver seat , the glove box will have soft opening , auto up and down for all four windows, tyre pressure monitor system and auto wipers, the semi digital cluster maybe from the v spec, auto rear view mirror and lights in the sun visors but aside from all this things the Honda city is a good car but for me if I want to buy the Honda city I will buy the v spec because not really a fan of the rs touches just like the v spec feels elegant and more like a luxury car and it does not miss out much from the rs spec aside from the black touches and the dual tone rims and the interior only the black roof and the read stitches so this are the two cars I can choose but I lean to the s70 but if not the Honda city is my second choice.my third choice is the vios I like the exterior so nice and striking for me does led lights in the front and back wow but the interior they are some things I like and don’t like the things I like is the screen so clear and nice , the electronic parking brake (EPB) and auto hold so nice and premium the auto hold is very useful during traffic situation. The things I don’t like is the materials in the car the materials from perodua at least Toyota should have their own materials instead of bringing in perodua materials and I hope the next facelift they will change all the perodua materials into thier on materials especially the digital screen they should bring the digital screen from the Corolla altis to the vios and the wheel in the car should be changed the ac control and the ac vents should also be changed and they should bring back the ac vent that is on the dashboard and they should bring back the auto rear view mirror and the sun visors they should add mirror in the passenger side and light in both side the seats should have electronic adjustments and they should bring back the soft opening for the glove box and bring back 60:40 split folding for the seats and armrest and the spare tyre and add features like auto wipers and tyres pressure monitor system and the door cart I don’t like it at all I like the previous generation door cart to this they should bring in a new door cart I hope in there next facelift and the car key they should have there on key instead of taking from perodua and add the function of if you hold unlock on the key for few seconds the windows will come and hold lock for the windows to go up and auto up and down windows for all for windows in the safety department they should add back the seven airbags like the previous generation instead of six and put back the rader in the badge and get a single camera like other safety systems like Honda instead of having a dual camera like perodua I just hope all this things can be changed during thier facelift . The 4 car is the almera the exterior is nice but the interior is not going for me I don’t know why the interior is small no rear aircond vent no and etc but to round everything up my favourite car is the s70 the design is nice and beautiful it has the right proportions and the interior is nice .
S70 + for performance fresh design in our market all others in this comparison insanely boring lol! (except Almira) , negative part, thirsty for city drive , start off from stationary really need refinement that sudden surge in power/torque can be a bit dangerous .
Should do your own video channel
Ngl! This is what I've been waiting for. All my options in one video. Thank You !
I have been using Honda City RS petrol for 6 months now. At first I was quite sceptical about the price. However, after months of doing the comparison, watching reviews and asked the owners, I finally bought a city. And so far, I love the car very much. Eventhough city is not the best, but it has the overall winning package.
Sedan or hatchback?
I test drive honda,vios and S70, i feel S70 is the best for me, Smooth, Power full, Voice command, The best Handling
tapi kan bang.. handling persona saya sekarang much better..s70 belakang rasa membuai..
@helmyhassan9666 persona mmg best handling dia... Proton handling mmg ok punya...ya S70 klu tukarkan suspension blkg baru stabil...
Great comparison. I own s70 because of the comfort. Its weird because im a 140kg gorilla and of all 4 cars, i feel a lot spacious in the proton. It is a c-segment tho.
Honda City is one of largest boot space in B segment. 519 liter. Pls kindly do refer to the specification from Official Honda Malaysia. The information given in the video as 410L is for the hybrid version which was not use here in this comparison.
And here i am, waiting patiently for the facelift version of S70, hoping that Proton will do whatever necessary from the feedbacks. I'm so excited.
Good effort to organize and to the review the 4 cars. Very comprehensive and and a detailed video. Thanks for the effort.
thanks a million for the review.just what im looking for! city for sure now for me with that 8k rebate
I really don't like the body shapes of the Almera, City or Vios. Granted, the design of the Vios is nice but it still stubby in design. The S70 has really nice proportions. The interior is really nice, it has a lot of good tech and I will always take dual clutch over a CVT. Proton did pretty well with the S70. Second favourite would be the Vios cause the handling of the chassis is really nice and its still good looking even though its kind of stubby. Third would be the City for me cause performance and lastly would be the Almera. But if you have any of them, you're doing pretty well. Nice comparison video and especially love the Tiny Tim segment as its really helpful to judge the space in the back seats👍
Agree with you regarding the s70 it has nice proportion and the interior is nice but I put honda second and vios third and the last almera if possible I will like to put the vios second but can’t la because of the materials used in the car aside from the vios would have been second for me.
S70 rear light display reminds me of the Knight Rider lights. I wonder if the Chinese designers took some inspiration from KITT.
Also the design of a new kia. This year kdrama, almost all of them feature a car that has that kind of taillight.
For now i wan trade my car..honda city to almera..looks nice sporty
Bravo, for a good presentation, will order a S70 flagship x
Thank you!
Driving about 5 month of honda city rs petrol, so far so good, upgrade from persona 2017(premium) , honda city petrol boots space 410 litre? 😅
410 liter is for rs ehev..the rs petrol has 500l +
A little bit correction.... Boot space for Honda City RS Petrol is 519 liter, 410 liter is for Honda City RS eHEV (hibrid)...
@pistonmalaysia thanks for this video covering the differences between the cars, it sure must have been a challenge trying to recall the differences across the board. However i think you could improve with your script, there are moments where your statements are contradictory - for example you started the review of the vios with a pretty unimpressive personal view of the car, and then when you stepped inside you said that it was an impressive car, and this particular behavior continues throughout this review. Looking forward to more of your vids sir 👍
He doesn't like the exterior (especially the front) of Vios but there are other area of Vios that he likes. Don't think that's contradictory.
I appreciate this comment. Thank you for pointing out areas where I can improve.
On the other hand, not scripting means raw opinion...which is what we want isn't it?...mainstream TV is already heavily scripted and screened, come on.
I did my fair share of comparisons as well and ends up buying proton persona. 😂 Can’t beat the massive price gap.
Persona is a reliable car if you can invest on the tires. Mine already clocked 150k km, never broke down, never let me down. The only complaint i have is the rims is too soft and tires less favourable. Switched the tires to michelin xm2 and changed raxer rims 15 inch, now its smooth glider.
If you taking finance or loan then might want the Jap cars may be considered if cash diff story . Assuming you take a 7-9 yr loan on local car better then go Jap la.
@@azharhamzah7034are you referring to persona vvt?
@@azharhamzah7034mine is 160k km… no major issue, only small thing like aircond condenser and heat exchangers… but upgraded to x70 soon…
Thanks for ur video.. really appreciate it...the way u explain so professional.i have better clarity after watching this... மிக்க நன்றி 🙏
Honda city has 519L boot space. The 410L is for the hybrid only due to the battery. As the city has a handbrake, i believe that is the rs petrol variant with 519L space.
Bro pls do review China SUVs. Comparison which better? Value for money?
I am driving GN2 honda city for 3 years... Closing to 4 years.. Love it. Fuel efficient. Reliable and confortable
Any rattling sound? Mine 1 Yr plus and lots of rattle at dashboard area
Very detailed video bro. Please make this kind for SUV as well ❤
Will try
Is there any comparison between mg5 with these?
Nice review sir...
Keep up the good work, ignore the negative comments below. Love the channel. Would be great if you added timestamps :)
tq boss review yg amat menarik.baru blh bt keputusan nk beli keta pada anak😊😊
I am biased towards Almera, the seat and comfort is great for me at least, although it's sad that the rear headroom is lacking. Fuel economy wise, at least you still can achieve it on the lowest spec model. Honda City, only the RS model if im not wrong.
Toyota, anyone who buys them generally don't care for it's looks.
Honda nothing to say, good all rounder, just minus any steering feel.
Proton S70, cant deny, it's a good car too, if you have no issues with paying for more fuel.
I like ur review man. Honestly, i'm just looking for sub 100k car with the most spacious rear passenger. Tq
Sedan or are you open to MPV?
nissan almera 🙌🙌, this car fun to drive ,minyak pun manyak jimat
S70 is like B+ segment for me 😅 The size stuck in B segment but for the performance more to C segment car. I think Proton nowadays is more reliable and practically. We can see x70 since 2018 until now already get more (+) feedback from Malaysian. I believe Proton is trying the best. So if someone who need feel good performance + luxury, s70 might be the good one. Value money, for long term like I said Proton is trying to deliver the best. City + Vios still the best for their own durability, they have their own fans same goes to Almera.
Honda City ftw, best overall package. boot space, interior space, fuel efficiency, reliable no ping pong ADAS, only beaten by s70 for engine performance.
Excellent video. ❤
Thank you!
Interesting comparisons although rather long video.. I own the Almera and it serves me well, easy to drive and very good fuel economy, lacking in power? Not for me, on highways can easily reach 120kmph on a 2K rpm with fuel economy not sacrificed.. my wife owns the S70.. haha that’s a different type of driving feel altogether.
Which car would you say is better in comfort and fuel efficient while cruising on the highway @~110km/h? When I say comfort, it includes seats support and NVH level.
@@loserman007I can’t really comment on city and Vios as I don’t have those cars.. all I can say is the Almera can easily achieve around 22km/l and above on a cruising speed of 110kmph. But the NVH is not top class. Can hear road noise. The S70 is much quieter and smoother drive but won’t achieve the fuel efficiency of the almera. I find the Almera seats offer better support than the S70. Just my personal view. I guess there is no perfect car.
@@ericng7511 the last sentence was what i thought of as i was reading it til the end. Couldnt agree more.😔
Bought S70 2 months ago. Good car
Nope, it's a great car! Just bought one too 😊
@@cocobos 👍
@@cocobos im so sorry to ask this but are you guys rich people? im no rich but i really want it to be my first car 😮💨 im also still quite young so should i reconsider buying a much more affordable one? the proton sales im contacting is due by next week, could you help me with this decision... huhu
@@anggwn_ It depends on your salary. I'm a middle aged man, and already retired (early) but still do some freelance jobs (soft/game dev). My 1st car was a second hand, paid lump-sum, so it won't put much burden. Though I have low salary at that time. It's all up to your budget.
@@cocobos do you think paying 1/3 just for car monthly is too much?
Playback speed x1.5 is your friend
Agreed
Recommended
Good review on all cars but Admin comments more on city😅My all time choice b4 retirement.Power of dreams for sure.
Please compare the s70 with the c segment cars like civic,Corolla altis and mazda 3 and if possible the b segments suv like the proton x50 , Honda hrv, cherry omada 5 and the Toyota Corolla cross.
because everyone know s70 just a b+ segment car.
Price segment lah. Those cars are in a different category
This is price segmentation. I too feel S70 is not in this car category.
Compare dengan B segment pun belum boleh menang dalam beberapa perkara. Macam mana nak compare dengan C segment.
@@ranceng6560 What's the deal with B+. Is B+ it even exist? Mazda 3 is even smaller but nobody calls it B+
The proton X70 3 cylinder engine has mounting issues due to its harsh vibration. This Proton S70 basically the same setup so most probably the current owner will face this silly premature mounting failure in the near future.
Pls do comparison Proton S70 with Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla Altis
Will try.
I'm more incline towards city, but compared to others like s70, the interior look like old car, with less gadget and accessories compared to others. So its hard for me to choose
And the camera quality is worst than myvi 👎
Is that an MTG B1000?
Kuro already means black. So kuro is the new black edition. Tomei is just the kit they're using. So kuro edition is essentially Tomei's kit which is blacked out. 5:46
Thank you.
@@PistonMalaysia welcome 🤗
Correction. City's bootspace is the biggest if its class at 519 litres.
Yes. pls compare the S70 against the C-segment.
It's still b segment. Apple to apple
@@haarrvingvraj5500wrong, s70 actually in C segment... close compare with Altis Corrola not Civic Fe.... Same size, powerful engine, premium interior.etc
@@amadakun5659 Altis loses in performance, slow car from Toyota
My personal view..
space, comfort, practicality and safety - the City is my choice!
Wonder how MG5 gonna compare to these
It's more like a vios
I drove all 4 in a harsh manner and i think the almera is the sportiest handling of the lot. The s70 has a fun gearbox but not very comfy. The vios is literally the worst one compared to the past two generations, its underpowered, poor nvh and not comfortable at all. The city is literally overall better. Comfortable, good nvh, handling is alright, decent power and i felt that the fuel consumption is better during jam as compared to the rest. Could be better on corners and agility but that can be modified in the long run.
Eventually decided to get a city, i hope that decision is not gonna bite me while i wait for my car to be delivered 😅
What variant do you get bro
@@zest1989 V spec
how about the almera. turbo preggy preggy and pretty good looks. build up quality been alot better than previous almera
@@lplp7656 almera has the most sportiest drive but the engine is not great. After my test drive i could barely hold the bonnet and open it, too hot. Also this one u will 100% know its 3 cylinders. It vibrates like crazy
Honda city has 519 liters of boot space, it's the largest amomg them all
Reviewer said 410 Litre is the hybrid version.
Rs petrol @@lohwencheun552
If you're the type who can't handle a little uncertainty, Grab is your golden ticket. Trust me, all these 4 will turn out into Grab car soon.
😅😆
Good review...
Thank you 🙂
Please do a b segment hatchback comparison.
Honda famous cvt gbox problems and also the steering rack kaput put off me from buying the City... Vios all the way for reliability and better RV 😊
Please do one for C-segments!
Will try. Thanks.
Proton s70 design so aerodynamic look and smooth
Previously owned vios 2015..Test drive vios 2024..feels like perodua..Exterior better than city 24.
Finally decided to buy city EHEV..powerfull.engine + jimattt minyak..to 25.7km/l.But comfort menang vios😊
bang .klau compare vios vs s70..mana ok?
@helmyhassan9666 S70 xpnh try n trpaksa tolak tepi..sbb beli kete ckup 5 thun nk jual balik..
Proton is my last choice because of their after sales service...my first choice is honda city..
Honda RS Petrol have the biggest boot space among these 4 (519 litres), 410 litres is hybrid version 😅
eh, 410 litre boot space? tu rs hybrid bang. rs petrol 519l.Biggest of them all, even bigger than civic
kuro is black, black edition = kuro edition. tomei is the brand that is used for the bodykit. nothing confusing about kuro or tomei is used for almera.
Thank you.
Get a car based on your primary wan, sometime we are too concerned with distractions (including offer and discounts) and ended up dreading their decision; after all it is a huge investment.
All car is good.. but for me 2nd value is no 1.. i has preve and get excident total lost after use 3 year.. insuren just cover haft.. balance i must topup..😢. Settle this.. my choice after this vios/city only .. no more proton.. full stop.
vios/city if total lost, insurance will cover more than half?
Could still happen to any car you own in the future if you still don't understand market value vs agreed value for car insurance.
My only problem with honda cars r the quality of the car is getting worst. If you watch any cvt gearbox problems video it must be from honda cars. This does not happen only in malaysia. Other countries also facing the same problem with honda's cvt.
From my observation, quality is not the only factor to blame.. seriously, the driving behaviour also remain the factor.
Well... my money goes on the honda city too👍🏻
please do comparisons for C-segments SUV
C70 vs CRV vs CX-5 vs the Chinese SUV
Will try.
S70 minyak ok ke? Biasa proton ni minyak mcm air hujan
Waiting my S70 to be delivered.. S70 win..
comparing all 4 cars and describing each of them is crazy amount of work. Details are bound to be missed like the city RS petrol actually has the biggest boot size at 519L, beating the s70 (410L is for ehev). Also, low speed follow is only available in ehev as well.
Great video nonetheless, it certainly is not an easy feet to pull.
Thank you and yes it was tedious but worth it. I enjoy sharing opinions but sometimes details can be missed.
alhamdulillah.. tak menyesal beli vios keli variant G dgn interior warna cream yg dah tak keluar lg dah lepas tu.. seat belakang yg blh lipat dgn middle armrest.. single vvti tapi lebih hp dr dual vvti
My pick S70
Vios appearance looks so cool
Well done bro, 👏🏾.You did an amazing job and I can see your review is too honest unlike other paid reviewer's. Anyway send my regards to Tiny Tim🤗 Oh ya I'm Vishnu from Proton can pm anyone interested in S70 🤣
Thank you so much 🙂
@vishnuvasnathan159
No spare tyre is a big concern to me. Hence toyota vios is a no go to me. Almera design is outstanding and better than his own old almera which looks very dumb. But a 1.0 is a small car engine no matter how it clarified himself a turbo or not. With the price of this segment, almera seem not a really worth for me. City and s70 is the first two runner for me as well. But, for design, I prefer s70 more.
Almera all way because im the owner 2++ years 😁😁
Proton car seats are generally lower. head room no issue. but the s70 really very sempit backseat la
Kuro is black in japanese language. No confussion there. So, kuro edition = black edition.
City no doubt that have the biggest interial and much comfortable to be, talk about engine it have the most powerful 1.5 NA in the market. Vios like feel like Daihatsu instead like previous model. Nissan Almera totally not in my list because it has the worst interial to be and much smaller than Axia, this car totally no power although with the turbo engine.
S70 have the most powerful and best handling, but definitely not C segment car and as you say B+ segment. For me totally will chose Honda, I chose a car that have better reliability and for long term use, not to regret later.
imo if you want the best resell value go for city/vios
s70 overall best performance
fuel save city ride low maintance almera
Bought vios 3 months ago. Driven 11k km already. Put simply, Its perodua quality at higher price. Definitely, previous gen was better. Daihatsu is not toyota
How is it in long distance drive bro?
Selepas pertimbangan kesemua ini, sy memilih Nissan Almera Turbo Kuro GT Edition , boleh katakan sempurna untuk segmen B, sportier looks lagi2 sy memilih glacier grey, x perlu modify lg da,huhu highway 180 masih tegap steady..
yes tegap steady even pakai tayar stndrd 205/55/16 rse stabil je and cut off 192km walaupn engine sama axia tpi cpt naik speed dia n rasa ringan mcm feeling 1.8cc
Almera hensem
Proton okey tapi servis center proton sangat-sangat tidak bagus🤮
Hg pii tgk review SC honda ka toyota ka sama ja semua.. hahaha
betul kete kira ok tapi aftersales mcm taikkk
nissan la very sporty look
No way city has the smallest bootspace. Check your info. Its over 500 litres
Almera on glacier grey and bodykit looks best to me. The rear spoiler stuck to the boot looks to sporty, there is another low profile spoiler which is flushed to the top of the boot, that one looks better than this to me. No doubt the Almera has less power than the rest but as what the reviewer found, it is most comfortable, fun and easy to drive with good nvh.
This review forgot to mention that Honda City comes with rattling sound inside the cabin due to poor fit and finish. The City is the worst among Honda models to show rattling sound even though it is less than 1 year old.
S70 for sure
Proton S70 feel like a conti car, at that price it’s a steal, on the road S70 will outpace the others