The reason for the overlap between Star wars and Dune be them intentional or not is that George Lucas took some inspiration from that of the Dune novel. An evil space Emperor, a chosen one on a desert planet, SPICE! But it's clear to see where he diverged.
I didn't read Dune, but I would bet Emperor Palpatine is much more evil and dangerous than Emperor Shaddam IV . I don't really see that Shaddam and Palpatine would be similar characters. If there is a psychopath in Star Wars, that is Palpatine. He is worse than Darth Vader. He is sadist, sociopathic and a big manipulator. I only see some kind of similarity with the Baron Harkonnen, his cunning and plotting nature makes him similar politician to Palpatine, but Palpatine was even more megalomaniac.
@@wil4648 yes, I also think so. Both Palpatine and the Baron are intelligent, but manipulating and cruel people. They are experts of politics and diplomacy. Both of them sacrifice anyone for their purposes. The difference Palpatine is even more selfish. He didn't care about even his own apprentices who could be his heirs. He continuosly replaced them (yes, he planned to do this even with Vader) because he didn't really want to share and pass his power. The Baron Harkonnen cared about his House in a certain degree. Though he considered Rabban as expendable tool, he has his other nephew as his heir. He wouldn't have sacrifice /replace Feyd and planned to save the power for himself somehow. However the Baron didn't have unnatural powers and didn't seek after possible immortality. Palpatine 's final goal was this, so hence he didn't follow the Sith inheritance.
@@sectorgovernor I think the Baron thought of House Harkonnen as his immortality, an extention of himself. He also was a sadistic child predator wish I think makes him a little worse than Palpatine.
I love how diverse and cultural the design is in this movie. A universe of things to explore for the artist or designer or anyone curious. Even anthropologists and biologists with all the insectine influence on the tech.
As a neophyte to all things aesthetic, I am delighted by such a profound, brilliant and insightful analysis of the Dune movie. It is such a breath of fresh air to come across your UA-cam channel. Your insights make me pine for the early days of the internet before social media made everyone’s unfiltered thoughts public. Thank you and I am looking forward to your next analysis.
Very good! I like how you explain and presents the references and their historical contexts. It is also nice that you don't care to say that you can't see the references the designers themselves said to draw from, yet still mention.
Thanks Otavio! I was a bit unsure questioning the movie’s designer who definitely knew what she was doing more than I do, but nevertheless I gave it a shot lol
What a great anaylsis. Everything in the movie feels so familiar in a way that you broke down so accurately. Love the note to the sadukar language at the end there hah.
as a brazilian architecture student i can tell you that im very impressed on how you described the Caladan architecture. Your very talented, keep up with the good work on the next Dune film
Amazing analysis! Thank you so much for showing and explaining all the cultural and historical references of the designs, especially the architecture. Seeing all these different styles meshed together with that futuristic look is such a feast for the eyes. I loved Dune's aesthetic, and you really nailed down all the parts that made it work so well!
This was insanely great! Very illuminating presentation of all the different styles and influences of aesthethics. Thanks to you I now know real-world examples like brutalism, which I find very aesthetic and beautiful. Also the nods to traditional islam culture and mysticism in Dune is made even clearer by this video. Well done. :)
Excellent videos. Regarding pattern-screens / breeze windows, they were also popular in the Middle-East. Since there were modesty-restrictions in society, women's quarters often had screen doors and walls with repeated patterns, so that they can see the outside world through the gaps, but without being seen by outsider men. Also, Islamic Art had restrictions on drawing human and animal figures (due to idolatry accusations) - and thus, relied on complex geometric patterns instead, which were repeated throughout. The reason why it smoothly blends into modern brutalism is because they have primarily used the Art Deco style. Art Deco itself had strong inspirations from non-western cultures, like Islamic cultures, ancient Egypt and meso-American pyramids. Hence, the Islamic style blends into Art Deco, which in turn blends into concrete brutalism.
This is so great, thank you for this! When people ask why i love the Dune film so much, it's often impossible to answer. I might have to include this video (as well as a few others on the sound & score) in my long-form answer from now on. Brilliant stuff
The aesthetics of this movie are why I love the Dune franchise so much. It’s a far-future science fiction with analog technology, futuristic clothes with heavy inspiration from the real-world, and background sets that are futuristically but deeply inspired by early modern-architecture. Denis Villeneuve and his team managed to seamlessly blend real-world aesthetics seamlessly within a futuristic setting.
This video is amazing and interesting, why haven't I seen this before? Most of what you've said I didn't know or think of that way. This has given me a different perspective on dune.
Great content! I’ve become addicted to these Dune analysis videos. Only: any other audiobook listeners who are jarred by the Árrakis pronunciation, as opposed to the Arrákis pronunciation in the audiobook?
I had a visual orgasm when I saw dune the first time, and all that you pointed out made me love it even more, I love brutalism but I didn't noticed about the rest of the references. This video deserve millions of views. So well done, I loved this video, thanks for doing it
Excellent work! I'd love to see more videos covering science fiction, and the kinds of influences that directors use to evoke the future and technology.
What a wonderfully crafted video! I like how you make the viewer notice things that he might have picked up subconsciously but couldn't quite articulate them 😊
Dune (the novel) actually came out quite some time before Star Wars and heavily inspired the latter. So, adapting the book, Dune (the movie) would naturally have some similarities to Star Wars.
My biggest worry regarding movies like this one and Blade Runner 2048 is that every futuristic movie ends up looking the same with that brutalist aesthetic.
Dune hits that weird spot where you think you know where the references are from, but they dont, xd House Atredis looks iranian in looks (Leto's beard and hair) and style (those military-ceremonial sober clothes with high necks) and the fact that bullfighting came from that area (its mentioned that Leto's father liked to bullfight). While you may say that Harkkonen tend to lean more on Russians, historically fighing for control of the middle east/turkestan region with the different iranian states from the XVIII century onwards. While it is true that the Fremen are inspired on the Berber and Tuareg peoples, its hard to avoid thinking about the game Highfleet, centered around desert themes
Your intricate explanations and beautifully edited motion effects really elevated the analysis! As a suggestion, you should add chapters to the video according to the chapters created, overall, a very entertaining analysis as a fan of Dune!
Don't know if anyone noticed the weapons used by each faction and the influences from each, particularly the professional, and modern yet very japanese insoired blades the Atreides used. Reflecting their skill and discipline Harkonen use large cleaver like weapons, identifying them more with raiders and such The Sardukar use large serated swords,providing them at least to me with a kind of professional, yet brutally precise feel The fremen, use the tooth of thr sandworms, showing that they rely on the desert, so much so a piece of it is their weapon
This is really really good content! So interesting to listen to what you think and found! I really hope that more people find this great content and of course that you produce even more videos in the future :)
Great analysis and very entertaining video!!! I still wonder why people don't understand why Dune won so many Oscars whilst being the only awarded ones which make sense to me (except for Cinematography, I loved Wegner's Power of the Dog, she deserved more than just the nomination)... Thanx!!!!
There are absolutely overlaps between Dune and Star Wars. George Lucas said he was influenced by the books by Frank Herbert. I thought it was interesting that the high liner ships looked a bit like the worms
Straight up masterpiece can't wait for the conclusion.. My most anticipated movie by far. It's ridiculous how villeneuve and his team made this movie and tbh its even better when you smoke some weed. It's as if it's made fror that. Nice review btw the harkonnen machinery do resemble ticks. Those crafts with balloons to transport them.. Instant classic
*Possible Spoilers to both Dune and Star Wars* Rather than having a serious argument about the blatant similarities between Dune and Star Wars, I'd rather imagine the two franchises going head-to-head in a ridiculous death match to see who wins. The match-ups in my head canon are... *1v1* Boba Fett vs Duncan Idaho *1,000,000 v 1,000,000* Clone Troopers vs Tleilaxu Face Dancers *Doomed Mining Operation Simulator* Lando Calrissian vs Duke Leto *Galactic RISK Championship* Grand Admiral Thrawn vs Supreme Bashar Miles Teg *Most Convoluted Empire Scheme* Sheev Palpatine vs Leto II *Wormy Sumo Rodeo* Jabba the Hutt & Bib Fortuna vs The God Emperor & Moneo *Weirdly Erotic Eating Competition* Jabba the Hutt vs Baron Vladimir Harkonnen *Good Girl/Bad Girl Battle Royale* Mara Jade & Murbella vs Asajj Ventress & Alia Atreides (Possessed) *Epic Level Dwarf Toss* Yoda vs Bijaz *Spicy Smugglers' Run* Han Solo vs Gurney Halleck *Don't Tell Me What To Do* Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Gaius Helen Mohiam *Blind Man's Bluff* Chirrut Îmwe vs "The Preacher" *Rustiest Sandcrawler* Jawas vs Harkonnens *Synchronized War Crimes* Stormtroopers vs Sardaukar *Biblename Spacehero's Journey-Off* Luke vs Paul *Intergalactic Monopoly* The Trade Federation vs C.H.O.A.M. *Darkest Helmet* Darth Vader vs Shaddam IV *Man vs Machine Trivial Pursuit* C-3P0 vs Thufir Hawat *The Bachelor: Psycopath Edition* Anakin Skywalker vs Feyd Rautha *Moon or Space Station?* Death Star vs Guild Heighliner *Silliest Made-Up Military Rank* Grand Moff vs Supreme Bashar *Best Desert Ambush* Tusken Raiders vs Fremen Fedaykin *Deadliest Golf Hazard* All-Powerful Sarlacc vs Shai-Hulud *Most-Likely to Harm Bystanders* Lightsaber vs Holtzman Shield *Least Valuable Valentine's Gift* Japor Snippet vs Plastic Crysknife *Harshest Friend-Zone* Rose Tico vs Jamis *Most Self-Aware Roomba* BB-88 vs Junction Concierge-bot *Biggest Hairballs* Cathars vs Futars *A Worse Love Story Than Twilight* Queen Amidala & Child-Slave Anakin vs Sheeana Brugh & Child-Ghola Miles *Planetary Fashion Cotillion* Leia Organa vs Irulan Corrino *Worst Job* Oola vs Chair Dog *Fire My Midwife* Padmé vs Chani *Cutest Murder Baby* Baby Grogu vs Little Alia *Iron Woman Competition* Captain Phasma vs Fish Speaker Nayla *Most Questionable Honeymoon* Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser vs Chapterhouse: No-Ship *The Force is Female* Kathleen Kennedy vs Wensicia Corrino *Most Obvious Distaff Moses* Elora Dannan vs Siona Atreides *Who Shot First?* Lucasfilm vs The Herbert Estate
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! RICK OWENS REFERENCES ARE EXCELLENT. Even more so in his 2024 collection, some Dune references, referencing the movie which is referencing Rick lol a ouroboros of design.
I really enjoyed this explains a whole lot a lot of the stuff I came to that conclusion myself but I like to see someone else do it so I can understand someone who speaks my language of beauty having said that is there any chance that you will be doing one on the Ridley Scott Prometheus like there is a very beautiful technical aesthetic that I really liked and I haven't seen anyone do a video on that quite yet
25:35 you have to understand that Frank Herberts dune books came out long before Star Wars. + Dune covers interesting and mind boggling concepts, whilst star wars is just a nice story with nice cinematics.
Hopefully no spoiler. The fish may represent Sand trout (infant sand worms) as there is no fish on Arrakis. Dune history Paul and Alia (Paul's sister born in the desert) Sand Trout fish in the deep desert.
while I appreciate your analysis (I fully admit I am not at all schooled in aesthetics) There is one factor which does explain much in the simplicity of the Dune Universe. That would be the Butlerian Jihad and the absolute prohibition against machine thinking. (computers) Aso much of the nature of Dune is due to the respect which Villineuve holds for Herbert and his original creation. I can only hope that he took a page out of Peter Jacksons book and filmed portions of the sequel(s) at the same time as he was creating the first Dune movie to avoid having characters natural ageing messing with the continuity of the project.
Dunes aesthetic, is like if Star Wars episode 4 and Blade Runner 2049 had a Baby. Analog Casette futurism, from Star Wars and Brutalism. And grittiness of, Blade-Runner 2049.
Atreides refers to Agamemnon and Menelaus. I never hear anyone comment on this. I suppose it suggests that Paul's lineage goes back to the Mycenae, but I don't know what more to make of it. Any suggestions?
![The Hunger Games Aesthetic Analysis [Part 2] - Understanding Design References](/img/n.gif)
The reason for the overlap between Star wars and Dune be them intentional or not is that George Lucas took some inspiration from that of the Dune novel. An evil space Emperor, a chosen one on a desert planet, SPICE! But it's clear to see where he diverged.
I didn't read Dune, but I would bet Emperor Palpatine is much more evil and dangerous than Emperor Shaddam IV . I don't really see that Shaddam and Palpatine would be similar characters.
If there is a psychopath in Star Wars, that is Palpatine. He is worse than Darth Vader. He is sadist, sociopathic and a big manipulator. I only see some kind of similarity with the Baron Harkonnen, his cunning and plotting nature makes him similar politician to Palpatine, but Palpatine was even more megalomaniac.
@@sectorgovernor palpatine has more in common with Baron Harkonnen
@@wil4648 yes, I also think so.
Both Palpatine and the Baron are intelligent, but manipulating and cruel people. They are experts of politics and diplomacy. Both of them sacrifice anyone for their purposes. The difference Palpatine is even more selfish. He didn't care about even his own apprentices who could be his heirs. He continuosly replaced them (yes, he planned to do this even with Vader) because he didn't really want to share and pass his power. The Baron Harkonnen cared about his House in a certain degree. Though he considered Rabban as expendable tool, he has his other nephew as his heir. He wouldn't have sacrifice /replace Feyd and planned to save the power for himself somehow. However the Baron didn't have unnatural powers and didn't seek after possible immortality. Palpatine 's final goal was this, so hence he didn't follow the Sith inheritance.
@@sectorgovernor I think the Baron thought of House Harkonnen as his immortality, an extention of himself.
He also was a sadistic child predator wish I think makes him a little worse than Palpatine.
Yup, it's easy to see for those with eyes.
This is seriously one of the best videos about Dune.
except for the parts where he gets names wrong, like calling caladan "cadalan", and naming the houses and their members as just the name of the house
The likening of the Harkonenn soldiers to Riot Police blew my mind. I never once thought of them like that but it makes so much sense!!
I honest can’t wait for the sequel of this video. 😉😉😉
I love how diverse and cultural the design is in this movie. A universe of things to explore for the artist or designer or anyone curious. Even anthropologists and biologists with all the insectine influence on the tech.
As a neophyte to all things aesthetic, I am delighted by such a profound, brilliant and insightful analysis of the Dune movie. It is such a breath of fresh air to come across your UA-cam channel. Your insights make me pine for the early days of the internet before social media made everyone’s unfiltered thoughts public. Thank you and I am looking forward to your next analysis.
I was looking for an in-depth video like this. Thank you.
26:19 this is solely the reason why i love DUNE. Because exactly this. Very well described.
Very good! I like how you explain and presents the references and their historical contexts. It is also nice that you don't care to say that you can't see the references the designers themselves said to draw from, yet still mention.
Thanks Otavio! I was a bit unsure questioning the movie’s designer who definitely knew what she was doing more than I do, but nevertheless I gave it a shot lol
exactly. It shows and embraces honesty!
One small correction @23:05 : the dune story occurs in 10191 AG, or After Guild. Converting to our time its something like 23,352 A.D.
So many observations! My mind can’t process them! 🤯
❤
We need a part 2 for part 2
What an amazing video! You are very talented, hard-working content creator. Wow! Thanks for the video. I hope you get more subscribers.
I was already crazy about this movie and watching your analysis, breakdown only further increased my fascination for this masterpiece. Amazing work!!!
I think that the breeze blocks were inspired by the mashrabiya that was widely used in hot climates in the middle east.
A beautiful, educational and highly insightful analysis, thank you 😊
Thanks Daniel! Happy you liked it!
What a great anaylsis. Everything in the movie feels so familiar in a way that you broke down so accurately. Love the note to the sadukar language at the end there hah.
Stunning analysis.
I'm so excited about this one! Thank you for your work and dedication!
Thanks!
another awesome analysis. amazing! I really hope you'll make one for part two!
as a brazilian architecture student i can tell you that im very impressed on how you described the Caladan architecture. Your very talented, keep up with the good work on the next Dune film
Vc estuda onde
@@gabri41200 Kkkkkkkkkkkk oi amigo br
Amazing analysis! Thank you so much for showing and explaining all the cultural and historical references of the designs, especially the architecture. Seeing all these different styles meshed together with that futuristic look is such a feast for the eyes. I loved Dune's aesthetic, and you really nailed down all the parts that made it work so well!
Beautiful essay. Well done!
This was insanely great! Very illuminating presentation of all the different styles and influences of aesthethics. Thanks to you I now know real-world examples like brutalism, which I find very aesthetic and beautiful. Also the nods to traditional islam culture and mysticism in Dune is made even clearer by this video. Well done. :)
Excellent videos. Regarding pattern-screens / breeze windows, they were also popular in the Middle-East. Since there were modesty-restrictions in society, women's quarters often had screen doors and walls with repeated patterns, so that they can see the outside world through the gaps, but without being seen by outsider men. Also, Islamic Art had restrictions on drawing human and animal figures (due to idolatry accusations) - and thus, relied on complex geometric patterns instead, which were repeated throughout.
The reason why it smoothly blends into modern brutalism is because they have primarily used the Art Deco style. Art Deco itself had strong inspirations from non-western cultures, like Islamic cultures, ancient Egypt and meso-American pyramids. Hence, the Islamic style blends into Art Deco, which in turn blends into concrete brutalism.
Enjoyable watch, thank you
I love the Dune series, I loved the recent movie and I loved this assessment. Very informative.
Stars wars leaned a whole lot on Herbert’s Dune. The Jedi are even based off the bene gesserit.
Such a better analysis than others of seen
A wonderful video about an amazing movie. Every scene you bring a different reference, truly aspiring !
This is incredible dude! so comprehensive.
I hope you're planning on making more of these, are you?
Beyond incredible
Damn, surprisingly well done video. I'll be here if you end up making more dune vids!
This is so great, thank you for this! When people ask why i love the Dune film so much, it's often impossible to answer. I might have to include this video (as well as a few others on the sound & score) in my long-form answer from now on. Brilliant stuff
THIS IS THE BEST VIDEO I HAVE EVER SEEN THIS YEAR
The aesthetics of this movie are why I love the Dune franchise so much. It’s a far-future science fiction with analog technology, futuristic clothes with heavy inspiration from the real-world, and background sets that are futuristically but deeply inspired by early modern-architecture. Denis Villeneuve and his team managed to seamlessly blend real-world aesthetics seamlessly within a futuristic setting.
one of the greatest videos i’ve seen ever. thank you.
This video is amazing and interesting, why haven't I seen this before? Most of what you've said I didn't know or think of that way. This has given me a different perspective on dune.
Great content! I’ve become addicted to these Dune analysis videos. Only: any other audiobook listeners who are jarred by the Árrakis pronunciation, as opposed to the Arrákis pronunciation in the audiobook?
Well put together. Thank you for all the hard work you put into this. I love Dune!
Thanks!
This is very VERY important, thank you for it.
Oooooh, what a lovely video. Thank you for making this. It is a multi-layered treat of learning and observation, and so enjoyable❤
As a [former] star wars fan ... Dunes style and execution could have been that of prequels we never got. Star Wars failed to grow up.
I had a visual orgasm when I saw dune the first time, and all that you pointed out made me love it even more, I love brutalism but I didn't noticed about the rest of the references. This video deserve millions of views. So well done, I loved this video, thanks for doing it
Thanks Robb, happy you liked the video!
This was so well made and interesting, thank you ☺️
Excellent work! I'd love to see more videos covering science fiction, and the kinds of influences that directors use to evoke the future and technology.
What a wonderfully crafted video! I like how you make the viewer notice things that he might have picked up subconsciously but couldn't quite articulate them 😊
Incredibly well done man! Excited to see your analysis of Part 2 :)
great edit and animations in your vid. thanks for the work. really helps to point out the dimly lit parts!
The Harkonen in every other previous adaption were like the colonial British empire. The Baron (floating fatman) was definitely based on Churchill.
Sublime analysis
im in love with this channel already !
Damn dude, your videos are so good
Dune (the novel) actually came out quite some time before Star Wars and heavily inspired the latter. So, adapting the book, Dune (the movie) would naturally have some similarities to Star Wars.
My biggest worry regarding movies like this one and Blade Runner 2048 is that every futuristic movie ends up looking the same with that brutalist aesthetic.
I am so glad that I found your channel!
Dune hits that weird spot where you think you know where the references are from, but they dont, xd
House Atredis looks iranian in looks (Leto's beard and hair) and style (those military-ceremonial sober clothes with high necks) and the fact that bullfighting came from that area (its mentioned that Leto's father liked to bullfight).
While you may say that Harkkonen tend to lean more on Russians, historically fighing for control of the middle east/turkestan region with the different iranian states from the XVIII century onwards.
While it is true that the Fremen are inspired on the Berber and Tuareg peoples, its hard to avoid thinking about the game Highfleet, centered around desert themes
Great video!
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!
Your intricate explanations and beautifully edited motion effects really elevated the analysis! As a suggestion, you should add chapters to the video according to the chapters created, overall, a very entertaining analysis as a fan of Dune!
Don't know if anyone noticed the weapons used by each faction and the influences from each, particularly the professional, and modern yet very japanese insoired blades the Atreides used. Reflecting their skill and discipline
Harkonen use large cleaver like weapons, identifying them more with raiders and such
The Sardukar use large serated swords,providing them at least to me with a kind of professional, yet brutally precise feel
The fremen, use the tooth of thr sandworms, showing that they rely on the desert, so much so a piece of it is their weapon
Yes, maybe someone has already made an analysis of armor, weapons and fighting styles of Dune.
So well done! Thank you for this in depth analysis.
Wow, I'm very impressed by your style, narration,pace and the your content. Liked and subscribed.
Although I understand the decision, I'm nevertheless saddened by the missed opportunity to say "without further a-Dune."
Exactly
Love this channel. So much.
Thank you for this!
This is really really good content! So interesting to listen to what you think and found! I really hope that more people find this great content and of course that you produce even more videos in the future :)
Great analysis and very entertaining video!!! I still wonder why people don't understand why Dune won so many Oscars whilst being the only awarded ones which make sense to me (except for Cinematography, I loved Wegner's Power of the Dog, she deserved more than just the nomination)... Thanx!!!!
One of the best video on UA-cam imo
Je sais pas comment récompenser ce travail merveilleux
There are absolutely overlaps between Dune and Star Wars. George Lucas said he was influenced by the books by Frank Herbert. I thought it was interesting that the high liner ships looked a bit like the worms
Great watch. This is the best on UA-cam. Love it!
Perfection 👌
amazing work.
Straight up masterpiece can't wait for the conclusion.. My most anticipated movie by far. It's ridiculous how villeneuve and his team made this movie and tbh its even better when you smoke some weed. It's as if it's made fror that. Nice review btw the harkonnen machinery do resemble ticks. Those crafts with balloons to transport them.. Instant classic
*Possible Spoilers to both Dune and Star Wars*
Rather than having a serious argument about the blatant similarities between Dune and Star Wars, I'd rather imagine the two franchises going head-to-head in a ridiculous death match to see who wins.
The match-ups in my head canon are...
*1v1*
Boba Fett vs Duncan Idaho
*1,000,000 v 1,000,000*
Clone Troopers vs Tleilaxu Face Dancers
*Doomed Mining Operation Simulator*
Lando Calrissian vs Duke Leto
*Galactic RISK Championship*
Grand Admiral Thrawn vs Supreme Bashar Miles Teg
*Most Convoluted Empire Scheme*
Sheev Palpatine vs Leto II
*Wormy Sumo Rodeo*
Jabba the Hutt & Bib Fortuna vs The God Emperor & Moneo
*Weirdly Erotic Eating Competition*
Jabba the Hutt vs Baron Vladimir Harkonnen
*Good Girl/Bad Girl Battle Royale*
Mara Jade & Murbella vs Asajj Ventress & Alia Atreides (Possessed)
*Epic Level Dwarf Toss*
Yoda vs Bijaz
*Spicy Smugglers' Run*
Han Solo vs Gurney Halleck
*Don't Tell Me What To Do*
Obi-Wan Kenobi vs Gaius Helen Mohiam
*Blind Man's Bluff*
Chirrut Îmwe vs "The Preacher"
*Rustiest Sandcrawler*
Jawas vs Harkonnens
*Synchronized War Crimes*
Stormtroopers vs Sardaukar
*Biblename Spacehero's Journey-Off*
Luke vs Paul
*Intergalactic Monopoly*
The Trade Federation vs C.H.O.A.M.
*Darkest Helmet*
Darth Vader vs Shaddam IV
*Man vs Machine Trivial Pursuit*
C-3P0 vs Thufir Hawat
*The Bachelor: Psycopath Edition*
Anakin Skywalker vs Feyd Rautha
*Moon or Space Station?*
Death Star vs Guild Heighliner
*Silliest Made-Up Military Rank*
Grand Moff vs Supreme Bashar
*Best Desert Ambush*
Tusken Raiders vs Fremen Fedaykin
*Deadliest Golf Hazard*
All-Powerful Sarlacc vs Shai-Hulud
*Most-Likely to Harm Bystanders*
Lightsaber vs Holtzman Shield
*Least Valuable Valentine's Gift*
Japor Snippet vs Plastic Crysknife
*Harshest Friend-Zone*
Rose Tico vs Jamis
*Most Self-Aware Roomba*
BB-88 vs Junction Concierge-bot
*Biggest Hairballs*
Cathars vs Futars
*A Worse Love Story Than Twilight*
Queen Amidala & Child-Slave Anakin vs Sheeana Brugh & Child-Ghola Miles
*Planetary Fashion Cotillion*
Leia Organa vs Irulan Corrino
*Worst Job*
Oola vs Chair Dog
*Fire My Midwife*
Padmé vs Chani
*Cutest Murder Baby*
Baby Grogu vs Little Alia
*Iron Woman Competition*
Captain Phasma vs Fish Speaker Nayla
*Most Questionable Honeymoon*
Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser vs Chapterhouse: No-Ship
*The Force is Female*
Kathleen Kennedy vs Wensicia Corrino
*Most Obvious Distaff Moses*
Elora Dannan vs Siona Atreides
*Who Shot First?*
Lucasfilm vs The Herbert Estate
Your videos are super-inspiring. Keep going, man!
Thank you 🙏🏻
Not even mentioning Jodorowsky's dune and all of its creative team; firstly Giger and Moebius, makes this very overlooking.
This si the best video on what i was looking for
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! RICK OWENS REFERENCES ARE EXCELLENT. Even more so in his 2024 collection, some Dune references, referencing the movie which is referencing Rick lol a ouroboros of design.
I really enjoyed this explains a whole lot a lot of the stuff I came to that conclusion myself but I like to see someone else do it so I can understand someone who speaks my language of beauty having said that is there any chance that you will be doing one on the Ridley Scott Prometheus like there is a very beautiful technical aesthetic that I really liked and I haven't seen anyone do a video on that quite yet
What a sick video
25:35 you have to understand that Frank Herberts dune books came out long before Star Wars. + Dune covers interesting and mind boggling concepts, whilst star wars is just a nice story with nice cinematics.
Thankyou very much for new video-essау.
Thanks Sierge!
Exceptional video
A comment for the algorithm. You deserve it.
Gonna watch the movie again 😊 tonight
Perfect explanation
You are an incredible voice actor!
Hopefully no spoiler. The fish may represent Sand trout (infant sand worms) as there is no fish on Arrakis. Dune history Paul and Alia (Paul's sister born in the desert) Sand Trout fish in the deep desert.
C'est la meilleure vidéo du siècle
The creature is hinted as being the doctor's kidnapped wife.
while I appreciate your analysis (I fully admit I am not at all schooled in aesthetics) There is one factor which does explain much in the simplicity of the Dune Universe. That would be the Butlerian Jihad and the absolute prohibition against machine thinking. (computers) Aso much of the nature of Dune is due to the respect which Villineuve holds for Herbert and his original creation. I can only hope that he took a page out of Peter Jacksons book and filmed portions of the sequel(s) at the same time as he was creating the first Dune movie to avoid having characters natural ageing messing with the continuity of the project.
Brilliant.
Great analysis. Subscibed.
Thank You for this
Dunes aesthetic, is like if Star Wars episode 4 and Blade Runner 2049 had a Baby.
Analog Casette futurism, from Star Wars and Brutalism. And grittiness of, Blade-Runner 2049.
i need a Giedi Prime rave club scene now
Very good
Atreides refers to Agamemnon and Menelaus. I never hear anyone comment on this. I suppose it suggests that Paul's lineage goes back to the Mycenae, but I don't know what more to make of it. Any suggestions?
excellent