As a non-American kid, I used to view the Wild West through rose-colored glasses, seeing only the romanticized ideals of Cowboys and Indians. The videogame, Red Dead Redemption 1 (and 2) made me fall in love passionately with the Wild West’s History. Good and Bad, I find delight in learning it’s history passionately. Thank God for UA-camrs like this who take the time to create such informative yet highly entertaining videos. If ever I get to visit the US, I wish to travel the lands west of Mississippi on a Wild West History tour on a motorbike roadtrip.
As someone's who's taken a few westward road trips across the United States, it cannot be recommended enough! Here's to hoping you have that chance one day.
Same here! Heres to hoping we'll both achive our goals of seeing the old west of america (though id go in a van or something over a moterbike) good luck to u my dude!
As a US Citizen of pennsylvania, there are a lot of sights to see. A lot of cliff sides, beautiful pine and oak forests. a lot of history if you go to specific places. like for me, i have a gas station / diner nearby called the conestoga wagon. It started out as a wagon and became what it is today. there's a lot of really interesting history for every square inch of land.
Take it from an American born and raised in the American Deep South, who has been deeply fascinated with Wild West & Southern US History. I believe everyone American or not should take a road trip across the American Southwest at least once in their life. Starting in Northwestern Texas on through New Mexico to Arizona & Nevada, then Up to Colorado where you pass the Continental Divide and continue on up to the Great Plains and Black Hills In South and North Dakota. It’s truly an unforgettable experience, and you will lay eyes on some of the most stunning and beautiful Wild country you’ll ever see.
The old west is made to look glamorous, adventurous and glorious in movies, novels and comic books. But in reality, it was ruled by poverty and was horrible. Scarcity of food and water, poor sanitation, low moral values, fear of Bandits and results of poor education, administration and law and order were an everyday activity. The wild west also had many women who lost their husband, son or brother either in the American Civil war or at the hands of unruly and merciless outlaws. Gold was a highly coveted item.
The West is a lot more complex concept than a lot of media portrays it as. A lot of people think of things like cowboys and cattle drives. It also includes things like mountain men, coureurs de bois, voyageurs, people like Davy Crockett, Daniel Boone, Lewis & Clark, etc.
As an English person who knew very little on this subject, I found this documentary very well made and informative and I feel like I understand the subject alot better now. Great job.
@Pa Gall we are not educated in the American Frontier. But we are very well educated. I can understand your somewhat bitter. But the above person lives 100+ years after the fact.
It's actually horrible and filled with half truths, and paradoxes. Idk if he's bad at narration, editing, or studying, or all 3. But it's a solid c- for highschool history
I just left a comment on your "Stuart's Stranglers" video about an ancestor of mine who traversed the Oregon Trail at age 13. I have a 3rd great grandma on my mom's side. Margaret Ellen White, born 1849, Morgan, Missouri. There is a remarkable written history about her family having set out from Princeton, MO on May 4, 1862. They left with 150 other wagons. Margaret, age 13, and her brother, age 11, drove behind the herd of oxen that her mother and step-dad were leading. Their party was attacked on the Snake River, but my family made it all the way to Walla-Walla, WA. Margaret was married that year. My 3rd great grandpa left for Montana to prospect. She stayed and gave birth to their first son. The following August, she hired two boys about age 18 to travel with her to Montana. She drove 17 head of cattle while carrying her son in the saddle in front of her. From Waitsburg, WA. to Beartown, MT., making the trip in 18 days. She was living in Deer Lodge, and one day when my 3rd great grandpa was out prospecting, a group of settlers came and told her to take her kids to the fort because Indians were coming. She refused to leave her home. When 12 men rode up, she went out to invite them in for tea. They obliged. They asked for "tobaccy." She smoked a pipe with them. One man was so impressed with her daughter, my 2nd great aunt, he patted her on the head and called her "Skookum Papoose," good girl. Margaret outlived her parents, siblings, and my 3rd great grandfather, who died from being kicked in the stomach by a horse. She had 14 children and had 79 grandchildren by the time she was 71. She died in 1931 at the age of 82. She spent her last few years keeping house for family in Washington and Montana.
@@footprintsofthefrontier I just thought it seemed fitting as it elaborates on what it was really like for people in the time and place relevant to the story.
The wild west is my absolute favorite era in history closely followed by the medieval era. I play Red Dead Redemption 2 almost everyday bc of my love for that era and this was an amazing video to listen to
the historical research that went into making that game is one of the aspects that makes it so entertaining and fascinating to play, you really are transported to another world and its so interesting
Aussie living in the USA stack at home with Covid falling down rabbit holes! Thank you so much for this great documentary! I appreciate the reverence you show towards the native Americans and their plights.
Especially with documentaries about the West, ONCE I start noticing clips and excerpts from known films used to aid the narration, I'm out of there within the first 2-3 minutes. However, this presentation was well done. Perhaps, because it sort of came across as a book-report-- and that's certainly not me taking a jab at the production. I really enjoyed the presentation and would be interested in viewing more from 'Footprints'. Thank you :)
Custer's Last Stand took place near the Greasy Grass River (as the Natives called it) . . . not the Grassy Grass, as the doc calls it. Better known today as the Little Bighorn River.
He had it coming. If you go out there, the headstones are not in rows as it is in other National cemeteries. That’s because each man was buried where he fell.
@@BryanChandler1905 Yes. I was there. I could see where the women, children and elders were still at the camp (in my mind's eye of course) and I actually cried. It was a beutiful place but of great sadness.
THE BATTLE OF THE LITTLE BIG HORN. THE HEROES WERE THE NATIVE AMERICANS. Custer was the pathetic fool that didn't listen to his scouts. Custer's wife made a fuss and made it about her husband.
A much better documentary than others I've found on the subject. You finally enabled me to get a grasp on the basic outline of events that had been proving elusive in an engaging way. Thanks!
I'm from North Dakota we have a pretty big native population kind of where they made their last stand where the government pushed them but you go 300 400 mi and you don't see a native American we're around here you see them all the time I travel from here to California and only saw one or two only saw a few reservations as well it's just crazy lot of history a lot of people died to get where our country is today no matter how dark the history is at least it's not forgotten and we can be grateful for the life we live today it's sad so many people lost their land and their way of life history ain't pretty all the time also traveling so far from the plains to the Rocky mountains to the desert I just imagined people traveling on wagons and white people and Indians fighting when you travel west there's still a great sense of adventure and freedom and you really know how small you are compared to the Earth and how big America is Great documentary thank you
*Based on the History Books accounts, one of the most exciting successful achievements in this country's History, post European migration, is, hands down, the "Lewis and Clark Expedition".* What that group accomplished, still stuns me. To make that trip, the miles, over the terrain, and encountering a variety of different Native Peoples (with all that had to mean to both the Expedition and the Native Peoples), and to make the "return trip", all with only the tools, supplies, medical and first aid supplies, available at the time. These considerations, and their success, with limited issues and loss, has to have been an unbelievable achievement when reported to the Public at that time. With the tasks assigned for the purpose of the Expedition, there were supplies necessary that required additional burden upon their efforts. Having been so successful at this challenge leads me to question the reported situations surrounding the final trip for Lewis, who was making his way to Washington DC from Louisiana, ending in Tennessee, close to the Alabama line.
Excellent documentary, very well put together with superb editing. Your documentary is actually much better quality than some stuff I've seen on cable, which is supposedly more professional. The only minor critique I'd make on your documentary, would be the exact same critique I'd have to level at any other documentary covering the same subject: too little time to cover such a complex and chronologically long subject. This is very well done and gives as good a "thumbnail sketch" as it would be possible to give the history of the Western Frontier in American History in a too-short 55 minutes! Thank you for publishing this video.
Their land was stolen and that is the honest truth. Sometimes one wonders how one claims to fight for global freedom yet he stole the freedom of another person, because stealing someone's land is taking away their freedom. Ironical!
Equally tragic how they treated each other. It wasn't rainbows and unicorns before the white man. They were brutal to each other and towards enemies, children included
The amusing thing here is the claim that the 'wild' west was not as 'wild' as portrayed in novel and film, and then go on to say it was exactly as portrayed; you cannot have it both ways...
It's what happens when you have non professionals upload these videos...they try but often get it wrong.....NOONE really knows what EXACTLY happened back then because everyone is DEAD,smh
Something I didn't hear when you're speaking on the native Americans as that a lot of native American tribes had seen white people way before Columbus ever arrived. Lots of tribes talk about the pale skin or the white man. So I believe in what history is starting to show is the Scandinavians and Europeans were probably in America way before Christopher Columbus and also they can show the Chinese were in America before Columbus. But what says everybody else wasn't there already. History is told by the victors. That doesn't mean history is right
I live in Oklahoma and we are learning Oklahoma History and we learned that it was possible Vikings came through because they found tunes from a Nordic language from the Viking times in a cave in Oklahoma
52:35 as someone from California, I agree that the Wild West ended around the 1910’s and in some places as late as the year 1920. Of course mountain towns like Bodie stayed old but they’re an anomaly.
A very good documentary. With regard to the Sioux uprising, you said "grassy grass". I believe it should be "greasy grass". The native Americans called the Battle of the Little Big Horn the Battle of the Greasy Grass
Additional comment on 'vanishing Native Americans - US Census, 10 year intervals, LA, Ca. A man, at the same address, with the same name and birth date first identified himself as 'Indian', 10 years later, he Identified as 'Mestizo', and for the following census he Identified as 'Spaniard'. He didn't vanish, he changed his listed heritage.
I think the fact that during the settling of the West there were a host of organizations of White Americans that supported Native Americans and the rights the should have been afforded. A quick check of historical records will bare me out. I find it very curious how these type of "HERE'S THE TRUTH" documentaries always leave this fact out of their production.
"History ain't what it is. It's what some writer wanted it to be." ~ WILL ROGERS That's what my Cherokee Cousin had to say about history, and old WILL ROGERS was a pretty wise man. As a Native, the idea that the lands acquired in the Louisiana Purchase were empty, is seriously questionable, as some of my Native cousins were living there already. Ah well, that's a long time ago and I don't anticipate that the Native movement of "LAND BACK" will prove terribly successful. Regardless of all of that, this was a very comprehensive and excellent video. Well done, very well done.
I remember spending one night going down the American frontier rabbit hole starting from wikipedia and going from there and it was one of the most fascinating thing I had ever read
Thank you so much for making these videos! I've only recently discovered your channel but I am thoroughly enjoying every video that I watch! I've always been fascinated by the wild west (and slightly bitter that my great grandparents didn't make the journey across the pond back then haha!). Your narration, editing and delivery are excellent and you've clearly put in a lot of time researching your content. Keep up the great work! P.s - I'd like to echo what others are saying in these comments, that this particular documentary is better than any I've seen on "TV"
Great documentary, thank you. Your matter-of-fact method of telling what happened is refreshing. I didn't feel as though you were trying to influence my opinion. This is what needs to be taught in our schools. The truth with a calm voice. Again. thank you.
Absolutely LOVE the documentary. We grew up on western movies building our curiosity and imagination, intriguing us into learning about the American Frontier. We love traveling to the West Coast and visiting ghost towns and places touched by the Wild West History. Our passion went as far as us building a short term rental property (located in the beautiful Poconos, PA) inspired by the American Frontier.
I find this period of time fascinating, my father was born in the year of 1891. He lived to be 102 years old. And the stories he would tell me were fascinating. This is an excellent documentary about the old west. I thank you for posting it. Now I have learned even more! My heart is buried in Wounded Knee. Geronimo was a great warrior, Red Clouds, Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull, all great warriors. I often think that the Iron Horse was the cause of the Indians losing the war. That fact makes me feel such sadness for the Indians, because after all is said n done, We were the ones who were the invaders. We discovered, then took their lands, killed them and stuck the surviving onto reservations. Anyway.. thank you again for this excellent documentary. Very accurate and a pleasure to watch!!! ❤
actually the first cowboys in the Americas were in Brazil. also called Vaqueiros. but unlike Mexico, because there's no historical connection with Brazil and the U.S , it obviously gets very little attention
@@bconni2 no sir the first cowboys came from Mexico to be exact in central Mexico, the state of Hidalgo way before Mexico became a country when it was still considered ~Nueva España~
@@cherylT321 it’s very good and I’ll have to watch that then..they are two new series coming out one is horizon made my Kevin Costner set in the 1800s and then another from the sons of anarchy creator called the abandons.
Thank you bro, this is sick. Always been in love with the wild west and the year 1947 specifically, thanks to rockstar I got L.A noire for my 1940's obsession and RDR1 and RDR2 for my wild west obsession, and now I find this sick documentary, sick.
We declared our independence on July 2nd. It was announced publicly on July 4th. It wasn't officially signed until August 2nd. Just to get the facts straight.
Just a note: The main reason of the wagon-trains being in the circle comes from the fact that every night, when the wagon-train set up camp, they would put them in a circle to help keep their precious cattle from wondering off.🐂
I started watching this hoping there may be a knob of truth, but alas no. No mention of the Indians assisting the people crossing the rivers, There is no writing referring to wagons forming a circle. Attacks were rare. People forget diaries from these people are extant.
Geronimo which was not his real name.. received his name when he attacked a Mexican village during the feast of St Geronimo.. that's why people used to yell Geronimo and he used to attack..
Lost their lands? Most Indians lived in Central America. Guess what? To this day central America has the highest native population. They still "own their land"
@@YouLoseGoodDay most. so the rest of them in surrounding areas were ok to kill and torture? typical white people tryna justify 10 wrongs with 1 right.
The problem with judging so called white - Indian interactions is that we today were not there at the time and did not have a dog in the fight.. For the record, the Sioux, conquered the Black hills from the Cheyenne, who conquered the black hills from the Kiowa.. The Sioux ended up moving to the west from Minnesota and upper michigan because they were forced to by the Chippewa who being closer to the British and French had better access to guns.. No where was it ever recorded that any native tribe ever- set aside land reserves- i.e. reservations for any of the other tribes they fought against ever.. Nor did they ever sign treaties with them ever. Sitting Bull, Tecumseh, Geronimo- all recognized the right of conquest and all of them lived by it too, as did the Commanche, Ute, Cheyenne, Kiowa, and on and on.. So you can stop with the indians were innocent fawns in nature b.s. So yeah it turned out bad for the Indians but not as bad as they turned out against their own enemies.. Best Bruce Peek
You keep trying to justify if it if you can An entire race and their cultures was crushed in less than 100 years by people that were supposedly civilised
Notice how these tribes are still around today. These conquered lands from indigenous people couldn't have been that bad since entire tribes weren't wiped out. Unlike what happened after 1492 with disease and betrayal from the European and French settlers
@@air9777 You're not making any sense at all. "couldn't have been that bad"? How the hell would you know? Plenty of Indians were murdered for nothing. And this "betrayal" nonsense? Try and make some sense not just mixing up disease with some vague notion of betrayal.
The conflicts between Native Peoples and the Settlers was so influenced by the Government manipulating the Native Peoples, White Settlers and Miners, and the Calvary, (blamed for following orders, and still thought to have been the cruel factor, when in FACT, even George Armstrong Custer *"was following orders on that fatal day".* ... and post his death, the Government and Journalists made the statements they wanted the Public to believe. *Point that remains FACT is, "We have a Mainstream Media owned by the 1% of the 1%, elite, and information remains the most Powerful Tool for Power and Managing the Public.* *This movie s NOT a Free Press, there are No Regulations ruling the Media Industry, no repercussions for intentionally misleading the Public, for blatant false statements, nor for any situations that result from their Produced Accusations.* A Democracy REQUIRES a Free Press, it is dependant upon the Public having facts, from which to make Conscious Choices at the Poles. The Government has basically evolved into "the Clerical Staff and OR Guys" from r the Individuals whom are the Corporate Owners, the actual Decision Makers and that best understood by understanding the actual top of that Pyramid, the Owner of the Federal Reserve Bank *Corporation* - a Privately a wned Corporation that fully runs this country, through Ownership of all Central Banks, Dictating Federal Interest Rate, initiating the economic conditions and each fall of Wall Street, controlling all Financial Institutions and Owning or Contracting countless Agencies, including:. IRS, CIA, NSA, Inland Security, etc. The rest is Rhetoric. Thus, the Public might as well be discussing a Soap Opera, for that about the value of what they think is going on. It requires an Awakening and realizing the "Universal Law of Attraction" is Absolute, and taking it upon themselves to gain a Mastery of their own Ego Mind (which is how they maintain their Power over the Public) and getting *"Conscious in Thought" + "Applying Higher Mind"* and Creating the Desired Reality for Self and thus affecting the Collective"s Reality, positively. If you focus on the subject that is undesired, you creat more of the same. That's how they manipulate for their continued power. Focus on the desire. Google Search any subject point mentioned from r details, for through a nes own actions they find the value of the Facts. Begin with the "Balfour Declaration " then go to "For where of the Fed", but remember, focus of n the Desire, avoid pausing long in the Undesired. *Best journey outcomes ...* 💖
While I appreciate the work done on this doc, and that it does not reek of political correctness:, the only people who know real history are the people who lived during that time. Romanticizing different ethnic groups through food music dress and art help people to understand one another and to get long and avoid bitterness and prejudice. People would never marry or do anything good with out romantic notions. The mindset and cultural differences between Settler Americans and indigenous American people varied from tribe to tribe. Early on, the Cherokee soon acquired their own written alphabet and translated the Bible into their own language. An insightful book , is entitled, I fought with Geronimo, by Jason Betzinez. The book and others like it describe real history by people who lived it. Outside the box. (Annie Oakley and Sitting Bull were good friends)
The Conestoga wagons were way too heavy for the western trails and rivers. At least in the early days before there was road maintenance. Most were much smaller wagons and most people walked most of the way alongside the wagon to lighten the load on the oxen but mostly because they were bumpy and uncomfortable to ride on. Some even push hand carts or wheelbarrows. There was another option that no one ever talks about it going by ship either around the bottom of S America or taking a ship to Panama and riding across on the railroad and continuing on another ship up to the west coast I assume it was much more expensive but I have never seen a comparison.
@@donaldbarnes1144 Brother Donny, the French were actually the best at getting along with the Injuns because they always had a loaded pipe and would sit around smoking out with the Natives. The chief would cough and say, "This is really good shit." At this point, they might offer you their daughter. No matter even if she was butt-ugly and reeked of buffalo dung, you better accept his offer or they would string you up and stuff your nuts in your mouth and leave your sorry ass right next to an anthill..DOH!
@@donaldbarnes1144 Ain't nothing like an arrogant redneck, being proud of things he has nothing to do with and chatting s*it about places he's never been to.
He failed to mention several Indigenous native tribes were completely wiped out . In cold blood everyone . Every man , women and child even the infants by the United States military .
@@Dagothownsneravar You’re right, I’m a dunbass. I’m not sure what exactly that is, but I’m sure since your response is to immediately start hurling insults, that you’re very smart, so I’ll assume you’re right.
As a non-American kid, I used to view the Wild West through rose-colored glasses, seeing only the romanticized ideals of Cowboys and Indians. The videogame, Red Dead Redemption 1 (and 2) made me fall in love passionately with the Wild West’s History. Good and Bad, I find delight in learning it’s history passionately. Thank God for UA-camrs like this who take the time to create such informative yet highly entertaining videos. If ever I get to visit the US, I wish to travel the lands west of Mississippi on a Wild West History tour on a motorbike roadtrip.
As someone's who's taken a few westward road trips across the United States, it cannot be recommended enough! Here's to hoping you have that chance one day.
Same here! Heres to hoping we'll both achive our goals of seeing the old west of america (though id go in a van or something over a moterbike) good luck to u my dude!
As a US Citizen of pennsylvania, there are a lot of sights to see. A lot of cliff sides, beautiful pine and oak forests. a lot of history if you go to specific places. like for me, i have a gas station / diner nearby called the conestoga wagon. It started out as a wagon and became what it is today. there's a lot of really interesting history for every square inch of land.
Take route 66 all the way to San Bernardino California.
You'll be entertained more than just watching empty fields go by.
Take it from an American born and raised in the American Deep South, who has been deeply fascinated with Wild West & Southern US History. I believe everyone American or not should take a road trip across the American Southwest at least once in their life. Starting in Northwestern Texas on through New Mexico to Arizona & Nevada, then Up to Colorado where you pass the Continental Divide and continue on up to the Great Plains and Black Hills In South and North Dakota. It’s truly an unforgettable experience, and you will lay eyes on some of the most stunning and beautiful Wild country you’ll ever see.
The old west is made to look glamorous, adventurous and glorious in movies, novels and comic books. But in reality, it was ruled by poverty and was horrible. Scarcity of food and water, poor sanitation, low moral values, fear of Bandits and results of poor education, administration and law and order were an everyday activity. The wild west also had many women who lost their husband, son or brother either in the American Civil war or at the hands of unruly and merciless outlaws. Gold was a highly coveted item.
That's how alot of movies portray it
it was built on the genocide of the indigenous people
low moral values?
@@SI-cd7xs yea,low moral values like killing innocent native Americans to take their land
The West is a lot more complex concept than a lot of media portrays it as.
A lot of people think of things like cowboys and cattle drives.
It also includes things like mountain men, coureurs de bois, voyageurs, people like Davy Crockett, Daniel Boone, Lewis & Clark, etc.
As an English person who knew very little on this subject, I found this documentary very well made and informative and I feel like I understand the subject alot better now. Great job.
I agree this is a very good documentary that doesn't include the lies and propaganda normally regurgitated by most Americans.
Read Lonesome Dove. It could have only happened in America.
@Pa Gall we are not educated in the American Frontier. But we are very well educated. I can understand your somewhat bitter. But the above person lives 100+ years after the fact.
Respect to you, what school did you attend Sir?
It's actually horrible and filled with half truths, and paradoxes.
Idk if he's bad at narration, editing, or studying, or all 3.
But it's a solid c- for highschool history
I just left a comment on your "Stuart's Stranglers" video about an ancestor of mine who traversed the Oregon Trail at age 13.
I have a 3rd great grandma on my mom's side. Margaret Ellen White, born 1849, Morgan, Missouri.
There is a remarkable written history about her family having set out from Princeton, MO on May 4, 1862. They left with 150 other wagons. Margaret, age 13, and her brother, age 11, drove behind the herd of oxen that her mother and step-dad were leading. Their party was attacked on the Snake River, but my family made it all the way to Walla-Walla, WA. Margaret was married that year. My 3rd great grandpa left for Montana to prospect. She stayed and gave birth to their first son. The following August, she hired two boys about age 18 to travel with her to Montana. She drove 17 head of cattle while carrying her son in the saddle in front of her. From Waitsburg, WA. to Beartown, MT., making the trip in 18 days.
She was living in Deer Lodge, and one day when my 3rd great grandpa was out prospecting, a group of settlers came and told her to take her kids to the fort because Indians were coming. She refused to leave her home. When 12 men rode up, she went out to invite them in for tea. They obliged. They asked for "tobaccy." She smoked a pipe with them.
One man was so impressed with her daughter, my 2nd great aunt, he patted her on the head and called her "Skookum Papoose," good girl.
Margaret outlived her parents, siblings, and my 3rd great grandfather, who died from being kicked in the stomach by a horse. She had 14 children and had 79 grandchildren by the time she was 71. She died in 1931 at the age of 82. She spent her last few years keeping house for family in Washington and Montana.
It’s a beautiful family history.
This is really incredible memoir. Thank you for sharing a bit of your family's legacy.
@@footprintsofthefrontier I just thought it seemed fitting as it elaborates on what it was really like for people in the time and place relevant to the story.
@@nepaliyoddha3840 thank you so much. I was almost scared to share it for fear of hearing the typical "who cares" shut down. 😢
Awesome thanks
Absolutely tragic the way humans have treated each other and continue to do so
Not really.
Try observing the behavior of any given other animal.
The wild west is my absolute favorite era in history closely followed by the medieval era. I play Red Dead Redemption 2 almost everyday bc of my love for that era and this was an amazing video to listen to
this is the same for me
the historical research that went into making that game is one of the aspects that makes it so entertaining and fascinating to play, you really are transported to another world and its so interesting
🤡
@@DaveMcIroy Why are you showing me a picture of yourself?
@@Voltage256, quite a good comeback for a 3 year old.
Aussie living in the USA stack at home with Covid falling down rabbit holes! Thank you so much for this great documentary! I appreciate the reverence you show towards the native Americans and their plights.
I come here because rdr2
Goated game , i go online time to time just to drink coffee ingame and watch the scenery
I come here because of RDR2 two😂
Same
Me too
me too
Amazing content!! Straight to the point and no dramatic music or corny jokes. Seriously you're amazing!
Especially with documentaries about the West, ONCE I start noticing clips and excerpts from known films used to aid the narration, I'm out of there within the first 2-3 minutes. However, this presentation was well done. Perhaps, because it sort of came across as a book-report-- and that's certainly not me taking a jab at the production. I really enjoyed the presentation and would be interested in viewing more from 'Footprints'. Thank you :)
I think he did it to show how the legacy of the Wild West endures today.
Wild West
@@katherinetutschek4757 That makes sense.
Custer's Last Stand took place near the Greasy Grass River (as the Natives called it) . . . not the Grassy Grass, as the doc calls it. Better known today as the Little Bighorn River.
He had it coming. If you go out there, the headstones are not in rows as it is in other National cemeteries. That’s because each man was buried where he fell.
@@BryanChandler1905
Yes. I was there. I could see where the women, children and elders were still at the camp (in my mind's eye of course) and I actually cried. It was a beutiful place but of great sadness.
I usually watch Grit tv on 66.4 westerns around the clock westerns!
Old West gun
THE BATTLE OF THE LITTLE BIG HORN. THE HEROES WERE THE NATIVE AMERICANS. Custer was the pathetic fool that didn't listen to his scouts. Custer's wife made a fuss and made it about her husband.
A much better documentary than others I've found on the subject. You finally enabled me to get a grasp on the basic outline of events that had been proving elusive in an engaging way. Thanks!
I agree. This is presented in a fair light unlike others that skip facts for one reason or another.
I'm from North Dakota we have a pretty big native population kind of where they made their last stand where the government pushed them but you go 300 400 mi and you don't see a native American we're around here you see them all the time I travel from here to California and only saw one or two only saw a few reservations as well it's just crazy lot of history a lot of people died to get where our country is today no matter how dark the history is at least it's not forgotten and we can be grateful for the life we live today it's sad so many people lost their land and their way of life history ain't pretty all the time also traveling so far from the plains to the Rocky mountains to the desert I just imagined people traveling on wagons and white people and Indians fighting when you travel west there's still a great sense of adventure and freedom and you really know how small you are compared to the Earth and how big America is Great documentary thank you
sound and artistic scenery plus nice soft narration adds up to well stages scenario.....compliments
Amazing video. Thank you for this!
This is a fantastically put together and well researched documentary. Bravo, very very good.
*Based on the History Books accounts, one of the most exciting successful achievements in this country's History, post European migration, is, hands down, the "Lewis and Clark Expedition".*
What that group accomplished, still stuns me. To make that trip, the miles, over the terrain, and encountering a variety of different Native Peoples (with all that had to mean to both the Expedition and the Native Peoples), and to make the "return trip", all with only the tools, supplies, medical and first aid supplies, available at the time. These considerations, and their success, with limited issues and loss, has to have been an unbelievable achievement when reported to the Public at that time.
With the tasks assigned for the purpose of the Expedition, there were supplies necessary that required additional burden upon their efforts.
Having been so successful at this challenge leads me to question the reported situations surrounding the final trip for Lewis, who was making his way to Washington DC from Louisiana, ending in Tennessee, close to the Alabama line.
My favorite time in American history is from 1800 to 1840 .
Equivalent to the moon missions.
Amazing, right?!
Well someways. Lewis and Clark found Indians on horses that some could speak French.
@@karlfonner7589 Some of the Natives gave them alot of help along the way.
If all docus were narrated like this I'd watch them all!!!
Excellent documentary, very well put together with superb editing. Your documentary is actually much better quality than some stuff I've seen on cable, which is supposedly more professional. The only minor critique I'd make on your documentary, would be the exact same critique I'd have to level at any other documentary covering the same subject: too little time to cover such a complex and chronologically long subject. This is very well done and gives as good a "thumbnail sketch" as it would be possible to give the history of the Western Frontier in American History in a too-short 55 minutes! Thank you for publishing this video.
Absolutely tragic how the Native Americans were treated.
Their land was stolen and that is the honest truth. Sometimes one wonders how one claims to fight for global freedom yet he stole the freedom of another person, because stealing someone's land is taking away their freedom. Ironical!
Equally tragic how they treated each other. It wasn't rainbows and unicorns before the white man. They were brutal to each other and towards enemies, children included
@@AnthonyGerardiAndroidWare that did not grant permission to the arrivistes to subdue them. Their lands
The Indians lost the Europeans won. It has worked like this since the beginning of time.
@Anthony Gerardi that did not provide justification for Europeans to come invading and claim that territory.
An exceptional documentary. Thank you !
The amusing thing here is the claim that the 'wild' west was not as 'wild' as portrayed in novel and film, and then go on to say it was exactly as portrayed; you cannot have it both ways...
💯
It's what happens when you have non professionals upload these videos...they try but often get it wrong.....NOONE really knows what EXACTLY happened back then because everyone is DEAD,smh
@@BryantBrothers-gm1qxbruh it’s not ancient history there are written records of these things it was only like 150 years ago
Yes you can have it both ways.
@@BryantBrothers-gm1qx What a dumb comment. lol 🤦♂
Something I didn't hear when you're speaking on the native Americans as that a lot of native American tribes had seen white people way before Columbus ever arrived. Lots of tribes talk about the pale skin or the white man. So I believe in what history is starting to show is the Scandinavians and Europeans were probably in America way before Christopher Columbus and also they can show the Chinese were in America before Columbus. But what says everybody else wasn't there already. History is told by the victors. That doesn't mean history is right
Columbus was European
Thanks John Madden
I live in Oklahoma and we are learning Oklahoma History and we learned that it was possible Vikings came through because they found tunes from a Nordic language from the Viking times in a cave in Oklahoma
Can you cite any sources?
@@drizzo4669 look up Spanish exhibitions in 1541 and there were possibly Vikings because there are relics of em in Oklahoman caves
52:35 as someone from California, I agree that the Wild West ended around the 1910’s and in some places as late as the year 1920. Of course mountain towns like Bodie stayed old but they’re an anomaly.
Part of my reasoning with some strong holdover culturally from the Victorian era in society
Tell me about Bodie Brodie🤔
Well I think the west is still very much wild evan today.
@@coryondreako8227 there are still many western towns today.
Bodie is a state park that's why it's an anomaly.
A very good documentary. With regard to the Sioux uprising, you said "grassy grass". I believe it should be "greasy grass". The native Americans called the Battle of the Little Big Horn the Battle of the Greasy Grass
Fabulous. Really enjoyed watching that thank you.
Additional comment on 'vanishing Native Americans - US Census, 10 year intervals, LA, Ca. A man, at the same address, with the same name and birth date first identified himself as 'Indian', 10 years later, he Identified as 'Mestizo', and for the following census he Identified as 'Spaniard'. He didn't vanish, he changed his listed heritage.
One of the most enjoyable documentaries I’ve seen.
I read or saw somewhere that the settlers didn't use the Conestoga wagons because they were too heavy. They were mainly used to haul freight.
prairie schooners.
A well put together documentary. Well done!
exceptional documentary and well narrated.Thank you !😊👍👍
Japanese restaurant
Amazing video, i learned a lot, more people should watch it
Great documentary..thx👍🇸🇪😀
This is this man’s first video and it’s his best video. That’s wild
Just saw your comment, and I couldn't say it better myself
🥁
Very interesting. Thx
I think the fact that during the settling of the West there were a host of organizations of White Americans that supported Native Americans and the rights the should have been afforded. A quick check of historical records will bare me out. I find it very curious how these type of "HERE'S THE TRUTH" documentaries always leave this fact out of their production.
very nice documentary
I was thinking to myself, "This documentary could branch out to so many others." And then I went to your page! Thank you! Subbed!
I love the wild west era its so interesting!! Thank you for this video
Wow! Such a great documentary. I'm Kenyan and I love it!❤️
"History ain't what it is. It's what some writer wanted it to be." ~ WILL ROGERS
That's what my Cherokee Cousin had to say about history, and old WILL ROGERS was a pretty wise man.
As a Native, the idea that the lands acquired in the Louisiana Purchase were empty, is seriously questionable, as some of my Native cousins were living there already.
Ah well, that's a long time ago and I don't anticipate that the Native movement of "LAND BACK" will prove terribly successful.
Regardless of all of that, this was a very comprehensive and excellent video.
Well done, very well done.
From which documentary did you get the footage ? Please answer soon
There were no hero’s or villains, only winners and losers and the winners got to write the history.
Lol shut up dude
Not always, they just tend to get the better opportunity
I remember spending one night going down the American frontier rabbit hole starting from wikipedia and going from there and it was one of the most fascinating thing I had ever read
Thank you so much for making these videos!
I've only recently discovered your channel but I am thoroughly enjoying every video that I watch!
I've always been fascinated by the wild west (and slightly bitter that my great grandparents didn't make the journey across the pond back then haha!).
Your narration, editing and delivery are excellent and you've clearly put in a lot of time researching your content.
Keep up the great work!
P.s - I'd like to echo what others are saying in these comments, that this particular documentary is better than any I've seen on "TV"
I was born and raised in New Mexico. Red Dead Redemption sparked my interest in old west history
Great documentary, thank you. Your matter-of-fact method of telling what happened is refreshing. I didn't feel as though you were trying to influence my opinion. This is what needs to be taught in our schools. The truth with a calm voice. Again. thank you.
Exactly!
Absolutely LOVE the documentary. We grew up on western movies building our curiosity and imagination, intriguing us into learning about the American Frontier. We love traveling to the West Coast and visiting ghost towns and places touched by the Wild West History.
Our passion went as far as us building a short term rental property (located in the beautiful Poconos, PA) inspired by the American Frontier.
Great video.
What are the shows/movies depicted in the background?
He won't tell unless you write what a fantastic documentary this allegedly is.
The bridging of the divide between the east and west is when this county started to go down hill.
What is the name of movie in 21:56??
Great storytelling.
I love this thank you man.
I find this period of time fascinating, my father was born in the year of 1891. He lived to be 102 years old. And the stories he would tell me were fascinating.
This is an excellent documentary about the old west. I thank you for posting it. Now I have learned even more! My heart is buried in Wounded Knee. Geronimo was a great warrior, Red Clouds, Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull, all great warriors. I often think that the Iron Horse was the cause of the Indians losing the war. That fact makes me feel such sadness for the Indians, because after all is said n done, We were the ones who were the invaders. We discovered, then took their lands, killed them and stuck the surviving onto reservations. Anyway.. thank you again for this excellent documentary. Very accurate and a pleasure to watch!!! ❤
😢😢😢
It's true
It was inevitable
It was inevitable
Very interesting thank you.
Jefferson set two expeditions, one up the Missouri River (Lewis and Clark) and one up the Upper Mississippi River (Zeb Pike)
Impressive documentary .
You forgot to talk about the Mexican vaqueros… who were the first cowboys.
actually the first cowboys in the Americas were in Brazil. also called Vaqueiros. but unlike Mexico, because there's no historical connection with Brazil and the U.S , it obviously gets very little attention
@@bconni2 no sir the first cowboys came from Mexico to be exact in central Mexico, the state of Hidalgo way before Mexico became a country when it was still considered ~Nueva España~
Wrong again. Everyone knows the first real cowboys were the Vaqualualuas in Waikiki
@@jasoncampos2933Cabeza de Vaca and them were exploring before the Anglos, that's for sure
Meanwhile the Old World had cowboys for ten thousand years before Europeans stepped foot in the new world.
As 1/2 native and Mexican I feel great to say that both native and Mexican roots have influenced some of the Wild West’ style
Thank you, very well done team, truely enjoyed this film.🤠 little political in some of the comment’s of the notation.
I've replayed this 3xs. I am fascinated by the Wild West. Can you provide a few sources?
What film or series are the Native American scenes from?
All sorts of films. I thought I saw clips from The Last of the Mohicans in there!
@@cherylT321 yes I’ve seen that many times..have you watched the 6 part series into the west?
@@haroldshipmen9715 No. I’m hooked on watching Wagon Train right now. I just discovered it. Thank you for the recommendation, though!
@@cherylT321 it’s very good and I’ll have to watch that then..they are two new series coming out one is horizon made my Kevin Costner set in the 1800s and then another from the sons of anarchy creator called the abandons.
@@haroldshipmen9715 👍
Wild West is my favorite historic period to research, it’s such a small yet fascinating window I’m American history.
Documentrys using people not pictures are great viewing it shows the time spent on them .
Thank you bro, this is sick. Always been in love with the wild west and the year 1947 specifically, thanks to rockstar I got L.A noire for my 1940's obsession and RDR1 and RDR2 for my wild west obsession, and now I find this sick documentary, sick.
We declared our independence on July 2nd. It was announced publicly on July 4th. It wasn't officially signed until August 2nd. Just to get the facts straight.
It's observed on July 4th, so that's a minor discrepancy.
A lovely overview of the topic with great art and visuals and exemplary editing. ❤
Saloon
Awesome!!!!!
Just a note: The main reason of the wagon-trains being in the circle comes from the fact that every night, when the wagon-train set up camp, they would put them in a circle to help keep their precious cattle from wondering off.🐂
I started watching this hoping there may be a knob of truth, but alas no. No mention of the Indians assisting the people crossing the rivers, There is no writing referring to wagons forming a circle. Attacks were rare. People forget diaries from these people are extant.
Very well made video. So good.
Geronimo which was not his real name.. received his name when he attacked a Mexican village during the feast of St Geronimo.. that's why people used to yell Geronimo and he used to attack..
His name was Goyaałé - in Athapascan pronunciation: kòjàːɬɛ́ - meaning 'the one who yawns'.
Happy to see clips of Deadwood here ❤
Phenomenal video. Thank you
Awesome presentation 👏👏👏🙂
20:20 those poor women not being allowed down the mines 🙄 as if they’d want to anyway.
Time to binge
RIP to the natives who lost their lives and lands✊🏽
Lost their lands? Most Indians lived in Central America.
Guess what?
To this day central America has the highest native population.
They still "own their land"
@@YouLoseGoodDay most. so the rest of them in surrounding areas were ok to kill and torture? typical white people tryna justify 10 wrongs with 1 right.
watched this halfway through then realized i was supposed to be taking notes, gotta restart now
The problem with judging so called white - Indian interactions is that we today were not there at the time and did not have a dog in the fight.. For the record, the Sioux, conquered the Black hills from the Cheyenne, who conquered the black hills from the Kiowa.. The Sioux ended up moving to the west from Minnesota and upper michigan because they were forced to by the Chippewa who being closer to the British and French had better access to guns.. No where was it ever recorded that any native tribe ever- set aside land reserves- i.e. reservations for any of the other tribes they fought against ever.. Nor did they ever sign treaties with them ever. Sitting Bull, Tecumseh, Geronimo- all recognized the right of conquest and all of them lived by it too, as did the Commanche, Ute, Cheyenne, Kiowa, and on and on.. So you can stop with the indians were innocent fawns in nature b.s. So yeah it turned out bad for the Indians but not as bad as they turned out against their own enemies..
Best
Bruce Peek
You keep trying to justify if it if you can
An entire race and their cultures was crushed in less than 100 years by people that were supposedly civilised
And the Victim Culture remains strong in the USA.
Notice how these tribes are still around today. These conquered lands from indigenous people couldn't have been that bad since entire tribes weren't wiped out. Unlike what happened after 1492 with disease and betrayal from the European and French settlers
@@air9777 You're not making any sense at all. "couldn't have been that bad"? How the hell would you know? Plenty of Indians were murdered for nothing.
And this "betrayal" nonsense? Try and make some sense not just mixing up disease with some vague notion of betrayal.
The conflicts between Native Peoples and the Settlers was so influenced by the Government manipulating the Native Peoples, White Settlers and Miners, and the Calvary, (blamed for following orders, and still thought to have been the cruel factor, when in FACT, even George Armstrong Custer *"was following orders on that fatal day".*
... and post his death, the Government and Journalists made the statements they wanted the Public to believe.
*Point that remains FACT is, "We have a Mainstream Media owned by the 1% of the 1%, elite, and information remains the most Powerful Tool for Power and Managing the Public.*
*This movie s NOT a Free Press, there are No Regulations ruling the Media Industry, no repercussions for intentionally misleading the Public, for blatant false statements, nor for any situations that result from their Produced Accusations.*
A Democracy REQUIRES a Free Press, it is dependant upon the Public having facts, from which to make Conscious Choices at the Poles.
The Government has basically evolved into "the Clerical Staff and OR Guys" from r the Individuals whom are the Corporate Owners, the actual Decision Makers and that best understood by understanding the actual top of that Pyramid, the Owner of the Federal Reserve Bank *Corporation* - a Privately a wned Corporation that fully runs this country, through Ownership of all Central Banks, Dictating Federal Interest Rate, initiating the economic conditions and each fall of Wall Street, controlling all Financial Institutions and Owning or Contracting countless Agencies, including:. IRS, CIA, NSA, Inland Security, etc.
The rest is Rhetoric.
Thus, the Public might as well be discussing a Soap Opera, for that about the value of what they think is going on.
It requires an Awakening and realizing the "Universal Law of Attraction" is Absolute, and taking it upon themselves to gain a Mastery of their own Ego Mind (which is how they maintain their Power over the Public) and getting *"Conscious in Thought" + "Applying Higher Mind"* and Creating the Desired Reality for Self and thus affecting the Collective"s Reality, positively.
If you focus on the subject that is undesired, you creat more of the same. That's how they manipulate for their continued power.
Focus on the desire.
Google Search any subject point mentioned from r details, for through a nes own actions they find the value of the Facts.
Begin with the "Balfour Declaration " then go to "For where of the Fed", but remember, focus of n the Desire, avoid pausing long in the Undesired.
*Best journey outcomes ...* 💖
Is there a list of the movies portrayed here?
While I appreciate the work done on this doc, and that it does not reek of political correctness:, the only people who know real history are the people who lived during that time. Romanticizing
different ethnic groups through food music dress and art help people to understand one another
and to get long and avoid bitterness and prejudice. People would never marry or do anything good with out romantic notions.
The mindset and cultural differences between Settler Americans and indigenous American people varied from tribe
to tribe. Early on, the Cherokee soon acquired their own written alphabet and translated the Bible into their own
language.
An insightful book , is entitled, I fought with Geronimo, by Jason Betzinez. The book and others like it describe real history by people who lived it.
Outside the box. (Annie Oakley and Sitting Bull were good friends)
Great comment; I thought this was just a boring and generic program.
Try reading 500 Years of Indigenous Struggle. That’s the real story of the filthy settlers who couldn’t survive on their own without native help.
@@borninvincible So says the simple minded anti white leftist.
@@lilajagears8317 lmao anti white leftist? why are Americans so slow ?
@@lilajagears8317 what was the last book you read concerning the topic? instead of attacking my position, you attack my character. ad hominem.
Anyone know what movie this is at 7:43
They did not use Conestoga wagons. They were called prairie schooners. They were small farm wagons.
Thanks for ur history info
The Conestoga wagons were way too heavy for the western trails and rivers. At least in the early days before there was road maintenance.
Most were much smaller wagons and most people walked most of the way alongside the wagon to lighten the load on the oxen but mostly because they were bumpy and uncomfortable to ride on.
Some even push hand carts or wheelbarrows.
There was another option that no one ever talks about it going by ship either around the bottom of S America or taking a ship to Panama and riding across on the railroad and continuing on another ship up to the west coast
I assume it was much more expensive but I have never seen a comparison.
26:52 which movie is this?
Great video just maybe some work on understanding names noticed a few simple that where mispronounced.
I found your channel today and subscribed to it today 👍
No you didn't
@@dionst.michael1482 oops, now I did 😉
I have always lived in Wyoming and Montana in my 82 years.
I have always lived in Washington State and Alaska in my 51 years, with a little bit of New Mexico. Howdy part'ner! 🤘
Good job on this video
One group i didnt see mentioned are mountain men
Love your channel...
Red dead 2 really got me into the wild west
Ong💀
Really well done! Thank you from Texas.
Was there a ”Canadian frontier” in Canada? Were there cowboys and saloons there as well? - a Finn who’s not sure 🇫🇮 Great video!
Yes, Canada has a West
Canada is a communist country so who cares.
@@donaldbarnes1144 Brother Donny, the French were actually the best at getting along with the Injuns because they always had a loaded pipe and would sit around smoking out with the Natives. The chief would cough and say, "This is really good shit." At this point, they might offer you their daughter. No matter even if she was butt-ugly and reeked of buffalo dung, you better accept his offer or they would string you up and stuff your nuts in your mouth and leave your sorry ass right next to an anthill..DOH!
@@donaldbarnes1144 Ain't nothing like an arrogant redneck, being proud of things he has nothing to do with and chatting s*it about places he's never been to.
@@donaldbarnes1144 I heard of Texas. Heard ya only find steers and queers there. I don’t see no horns so what are YOU? Hahaha!
Your channel is dope...thanks
The Spanish term 'Vaquero' was transmogrified to the Anglicized term 'Buckaroo'.
True.
Vaca=cow.
Vaquero=cowman.
Great channel. Super interesting.... Thanks
He failed to mention several Indigenous native tribes were completely wiped out . In cold blood everyone . Every man , women and child even the infants by the United States military .
Left off the Whites mudered too. SO what?
Awfully inconsiderate of you to assume this person’s gender. I mean, since you’re going down that road, you have to Check all the boxes…
correct them by naming them yourself. I'm truly interested.
@@mcwilliams4546 tf? What does gender have to do with historical accuracy? Dunbass
@@Dagothownsneravar You’re right, I’m a dunbass. I’m not sure what exactly that is, but I’m sure since your response is to immediately start hurling insults, that you’re very smart, so I’ll assume you’re right.