Modern Nuclear Submarines: What We're Allowed to Tell You

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 461

  • @rootbeerpoptart
    @rootbeerpoptart Місяць тому +178

    USS Newest* Jersey

  • @notacleverman9438
    @notacleverman9438 Місяць тому +134

    The idea of "videogameifying" war is a tale as old as war. Back in the day kids all were playing baseball so we made grenades in the same shape as a baseball to make it easy to train soldiers to throw. It makes sense to simplify training by adopting whatever is popular amongst the youth into your military tech

    • @scottfw7169
      @scottfw7169 Місяць тому +13

      That's a point, but what's really interesting is that sources document the history of grenades which are sized to thrown by hand dating back to the Byzantine Empire when it was realized the components of Greek fire could be thrown by hand in stone, ceramic, or glass containers, & stone spheres a bit bigger than a softball, maybe grapefruit size?, and filled with explosive have been found in China and turn out to be written about back to the Ming Dynasty; there were at some date some with metal casings too. Some sources say hand grenades were invented in 16th century in Europe then for some reason faded from use by 18th century. Form follows function and ergonomics is ergonomics is ergonomics, there are only so many shapes and sizes of object which can contain an incendiary or explosive charge and be hand-throwable any reasonable distance. So perhaps the truth 😉 is that the American baseball is patterned after the Byzantine grenade.

    • @user-qm1il3gh5z
      @user-qm1il3gh5z Місяць тому

      Yes a grenade looks and feels just like a baseball. ŴOW

    • @trekkie1701e
      @trekkie1701e Місяць тому +8

      They actually tested American football shaped grenades. But it wasn't as common a sport and not everyone can throw a tight spiral.

    • @johnanon6938
      @johnanon6938 Місяць тому +9

      During WW2 new crew members for Tiger tanks were given a comic book for a manual on how to use the Tiger, so that's pretty close in concept.

    • @LordOfNihil
      @LordOfNihil Місяць тому +3

      @@johnanon6938 it made sense, literacy was not quite 100% back then.

  • @emmgeevideo
    @emmgeevideo Місяць тому +29

    I worked for a major computer company in the mid-1990s and was on the Navy base in San Diego doing contract work. We knocked off early one day and had some time on hour hands, so we asked for a suggestion of what to do. Our Navy host suggested going down to the docks where the nuclear subs were tied up. We decided to give it a try. I'll be darned if we weren't welcomed on board and given a tour by one of the senior officers. We went from stem to stern, although he apologetically said we couldn't tour the engine room because it was classified. That was a rare moment...

  • @simoncauxbarge
    @simoncauxbarge Місяць тому +35

    i hope he said "Give me a ping, Vasili. One ping only, please." when he was at the periscope 😀

  • @skovner
    @skovner Місяць тому +68

    I forgot which book I read it in, but the earlier nuclear subs were refuelled. When the Nautilus was being designed, the question was to use a bolted reactor cover with o-ring seal or welded. The latter would require cutting and re-welding, so the bolted cover would make refuelling easier. The person pushing the O-ring and bolted cover had everyone convinced to use it. The Rickover walked in, and asked him "If your son were serving on this boat, would you be comfortable with the bolted and o-ring sealed cover?" His face turned red and they went with the welded one.

    • @justwordme
      @justwordme Місяць тому +20

      @@skovner Rickover and his insistence on the sub safe program is the most amazing beneficial thing ever done for the sub program. Compared to Russia and their lack of emphasis on safety.

    • @Gigaguenther
      @Gigaguenther 26 днів тому

      i don't know if you intentionally made it "the rickover" but if you didn't i think i'd just love it even more xD

  • @leftyo9589
    @leftyo9589 Місяць тому +23

    those light weight easy to deploy ones arent fire boundaries. they wont stop or slow down fire. they are smoke boundaries that allow hose teams etc to pass thru without smoke taking over the entire vessel. on the battleship they would have had them in dc lockers, and they would have been put up with spring loaded clips on the rims of hatches, and water tight doors.

  • @justwordme
    @justwordme Місяць тому +29

    The video game controller reminds me of the 1984 movie “The Last Starfighter” where a kid plays a video game so well that he is recruited to fly a spaceship to save a civilization as the arcade game console was a recruiting tool.

    • @sibhuskyguy
      @sibhuskyguy Місяць тому +3

      Ironically there is folklore that says the video game was real and actually existed in arcades at the time, but only the prototype game, made by Atari, from 1984 was ever made. There are people working on a reproduction of it, but I do not know if the project was ever completed.. There is also a fan made last starfighter game floating around on the internet somewhere, but the last times I found it, i couldn't open and run it because it had a virus embedded in it every time.

    • @LordOfNihil
      @LordOfNihil Місяць тому +4

      @@sibhuskyguy there was something like it. had 2 sides, one was for the pilot and one for the gunner. though the gameplay was nothing like the movie. im not sure if it was related (really dont remember it that well) but i thought it was a cool cabinet.

    • @sibhuskyguy
      @sibhuskyguy Місяць тому +2

      @@LordOfNihil down in seaside heights back in the early 90's there was a sit in console at an arcade on the boardwalk that wasn't branded as the last starfighter but it was blatantly obvious it was at least partly based on the movie... I wish i remembered the name of the arcade or the game... never saw a 2 seat space game.....

    • @LordOfNihil
      @LordOfNihil Місяць тому +1

      @@sibhuskyguy its possible it came in a one player config.

    • @sibhuskyguy
      @sibhuskyguy Місяць тому

      @@LordOfNihil it's possible but not likely as there would probably be records of the game going into production from Atari if it had.

  • @F-Man
    @F-Man Місяць тому +164

    I know they’re more strategically viable in just about every way, but…these nuke boats just don’t have nearly the “ooooo! ahhhh!” appeal as a battleship.

    • @freedomisntfree_44
      @freedomisntfree_44 Місяць тому +24

      Until it silently disappears after turning a country into a parking lot 😅

    • @TurboSnail8734
      @TurboSnail8734 Місяць тому +6

      It's carrying the "ooooh ahhhh" 😂 she might be ugly and bland but she puts on one hell of a show

    • @jimtalbott9535
      @jimtalbott9535 Місяць тому +3

      The “Ooooo ahhhh” of the sub extends further than 25mi. A LOT further. Though the BB did get those.

    • @DJJohnson-zw1xu
      @DJJohnson-zw1xu Місяць тому +6

      I’m sure whoever’s fishing when suddenly a missile blows out of the sea will probably “ooooo! And ahhhhh!”

    • @christiantroy3034
      @christiantroy3034 Місяць тому +6

      Yea thats because they are so highly classified looking at the outside is almost a violation

  • @KiithnarasAshaa
    @KiithnarasAshaa Місяць тому +33

    The X-box controller for the photonics mast will never not be funny

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому +1

      Yeah - it shouldn't be... the recent history of submarines using x-box controllers to control mission-critical software/hardware packages isn't great *cough* Titan submersible *cough*

    • @KyklopCZ-DaTrueOne
      @KyklopCZ-DaTrueOne Місяць тому +12

      ​@@Joseph55220 The difference being:
      1. the navy uses exclusively wired controllers so any risk of connection failure is significantly reduced and no problems with batteries + I'm sure they keep a couple spares around
      2. Even if all of the controllers onboard fail somehow, not being able to turn the photonics mast around won't cause the submarine to sink

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому

      @@KyklopCZ-DaTrueOne I was more just trolling the Navy for using the same technology as Titan. I can't say anything for sure because I've never been aboard a nuclear sub and the Navy plays real hard-ball with their sub-fleet - but I know about the procurement requirements for that sort of stuff so, whenever the Navy converted to the new stuff (again, I could be wrong but I don't think the original Virginias put to sea with the current setup) I'm certain that they had to buy and warehouse 130% the number of controllers that they projected they would need to service the entire fleet for the entire length of their projected lives. I'm sure that, in a minimum of TWO locations (probably one near the East-coast and one on the West) the Navy has hundreds and hundreds of xbox360 controllers each with serialized paperwork demonstrating that it has been function-tested and is certified for use. And the way you phrased your reply - did Titan use wireless??? I'm almost certain that it was a wired controller. I think they used it for the same reasons I imagine the Navy adopted them - it output via USB1.0 and was really, really easy to code for... if they were using wireless they were even more criminally negligent than I knew about...

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому +7

      @@KyklopCZ-DaTrueOne Obviously they didn't have the same setup at first - 360 didn't drop until more than 5 years after Virginia came down the slipway. But, again, I'm just poking fun at the Navy. The DoD, I believe, certified xbox controllers for use for flying certain drones as well. I believe they cited cost, reliability, availability, the fact that Microsoft was already a major, vetted DoD supplier, obviously MS is (on paper) US based (even though most of their hardware is manufactured in Asia and most of their programming is done in India), and the extensive research that Microsoft had poured into the ergonomics of the design, and that a significant percentage of military-aged men were already highly-proficient with the device. Anyways - I know the DoD officially cleared the x-box controller for use in military applications.

    • @LordOfNihil
      @LordOfNihil Місяць тому

      at least put the thing in a cnc metal case with state of the art hall sensors. ive been converting old military surplus joysticks (the pcbs had parts that looked 50s-60s ish) to heli-sim controllers. doing something like that.

  • @Knight6831
    @Knight6831 Місяць тому +55

    USS New Jersey -three for your information, Ryan, she is the 5th ship in the Block 4 and the 22nd ship of the Virginia Class SSN Submarine

  • @funnyrabbitflyer6855
    @funnyrabbitflyer6855 Місяць тому +48

    Smartereveryday did great series of videos on this topic, excluding, of course, many of the technical specs of the subs capabilities. You don’t tour these boats for lengthy physics lessons, but it is worth learning the principles ahead of time, for those curious enough.

    • @marvinnicorode1209
      @marvinnicorode1209 Місяць тому +9

      I love that at some points during that video series, there is a jump cut forward to Dustin saying "Okay, I guess we'll have to cut out those last 5 minutes" because they geeked out too much about the technologies and veered into confidential information.

    • @doctorscoot
      @doctorscoot Місяць тому +3

      @@marvinnicorode1209when I was in my navy (not USN) training they took us on a tour of a boat in an attempt to get volunteers for the silent service. There was stuff on that boat which would have been my rating to operate and maintain but they wouldn’t show it to us! lol. I stuck with the surface fleet. 😅

    • @wtmayhew
      @wtmayhew Місяць тому +5

      I came here to recommend the same thing. To a neophyte like me, that was a fascinating and entertaining series. The air candle was a mind blower. You burn a candle-like thing to get fresh oxygen - seems so backwards!

    • @zxggwrt
      @zxggwrt Місяць тому +1

      @@wtmayhewYES the oxygen candle was wild. Didn’t see that coming!

    • @rodney100100
      @rodney100100 Місяць тому +2

      honestly i wish someone else would have made that series, i want to watch it so badly but i just cant stand the way he narrates a video

  • @TX-biker
    @TX-biker Місяць тому +8

    I love their mato
    “Victory or death”

    • @thomaswilloughby9901
      @thomaswilloughby9901 Місяць тому +2

      That is the motto of the US Army 32nd Armor regiment and goes back to WW2. So is the Navy stealing it?

  • @Synergy7Studios
    @Synergy7Studios Місяць тому +3

    Smarter Every Day has a great series of videos going through one of these nuke subs. The navy worked with him to censor it appropriately.

  • @russellhltn1396
    @russellhltn1396 Місяць тому +8

    You absolutely need to collect an authentic periscope controller. :D I find it amusing but at the same time, it makes a lot of sense. One of the cardinal rules of human interface: embrace standards, don't fight them. And no point in re-inventing the wheel. MS already spent a ton of money figuring out the controller.

  • @cheeseninja1115
    @cheeseninja1115 Місяць тому +29

    The integration of gaming controllers into military hardware has been interesting. It's reminiscent of some tanks using steering wheels to make them easier to train on. By using some control system that recruits already know, not only does it make training faster. It means that servicemembers will already have years of experience in getting the proper muscle memory to operate anything utilizing it.

    • @BlackEpyon
      @BlackEpyon Місяць тому +12

      I imagine the only complaint is going to be "Alright, who the hell inverted the controls!?"

    • @davestenhouse2015
      @davestenhouse2015 Місяць тому +7

      And in terms of gamifying war, remember that the WWII hand grenades were modeled to be similar to baseballs, and for similar reasons.

    • @GeneCash
      @GeneCash Місяць тому +1

      Heck, I just found out the center thing in the controller is an actual button!

    • @Ganiscol
      @Ganiscol Місяць тому +7

      Its not just that alone. Game controllers did not just become the way they are for no reason, a lot of ergonomic thought went into designing them. If they didnt exist for games, they would have to be invented for applications such as this to make the use of systems much more efficient.

    • @BlackEpyon
      @BlackEpyon Місяць тому +3

      @@Ganiscol Having a number of joysticks and game controllers from the 80's and 90's, I can attest to that. Modern controllers are VERY comfortable to use compared to what we had.

  • @BlackEpyon
    @BlackEpyon Місяць тому +12

    ALL the kids serving on subs these days are familiar with gaming controllers, so it only makes sense to use what they're already familiar with! They're fairly reliable as long as you don't abuse them, but the best part is that they're cheap, and interchangeable. Keep them in a drawer, grab an extra, swap the XBOX controller out for a PlayStation controller if that's more your thing! It wouldn't surprise me if they also have an interface to remap the controls with user defined presets!

    • @DistracticusPrime
      @DistracticusPrime Місяць тому +2

      XBOX is after my time; is there an adapter for Atari 2600 paddles?⌨🖱🖲🕹👾

    • @BlackEpyon
      @BlackEpyon Місяць тому +1

      @@DistracticusPrime Personally, I wonder why the Atari and Commodores didn't just use a controller with a D-pad (like the NES) instead of those joysticks with membrane caps. It's an awful lot of hand movement for something you could just do with your thumb.

  • @subman721
    @subman721 Місяць тому +2

    3:03 There is more than 1 watertight door Ryan! Submariners love playing this game! I am no exception

  • @ericwhiting5470
    @ericwhiting5470 Місяць тому +30

    Ryan,
    You're most likely correct that the USS New Jersey (submarine) will never be preserved. I served aboard the USS Alexandria SSN 757 (PLANKOWNER) and I only know of 1 nuclear powered submarine that has ever been preserved. That is the USS Nautilus which is a museum ship up in Groton, CT.
    Sadly the Alexandria will be decommissioned in 2026.

    • @jeffreymcurtis
      @jeffreymcurtis Місяць тому +1

      I heard that the USS DALLAS SSN 700 was in the process of being made into a museum

    • @ericwhiting5470
      @ericwhiting5470 Місяць тому +2

      @jeffreymcurtis I have a friend who lives across the water from where the Navy deconstructs all of the nuclear powered submarines. I will reach out to him and ask if he's heard anything about the Dallas.

    • @ericwhiting5470
      @ericwhiting5470 Місяць тому +3

      @jeffreymcurtis I just did some searching on the web. The Navy said that due to security concerns there was never a chance that the entire submarine would ever have been brought to Dallas for a museum ship. Secondly it would be a logistical nightmare to even get it to Dallas. Not enough deep water.

    • @jeffreymcurtis
      @jeffreymcurtis Місяць тому +1

      @@ericwhiting5470 thanks

    • @jeffreymcurtis
      @jeffreymcurtis Місяць тому +1

      @@ericwhiting5470 that's what I was thinking, I think that I first heard of the Dallas becoming a museum ship may have been on the Battleship Texas channel

  • @jonp761
    @jonp761 Місяць тому +2

    I was lucky enough to get a quick tour of the Virginia herself. Something that I'll remember forever.

  • @bluerocket1096
    @bluerocket1096 Місяць тому +12

    Are there any artifacts that the Navy has taken off BB New Jersey to place on SSN New Jersey?

    • @garywayne6083
      @garywayne6083 Місяць тому +2

      Some pieces of deck teak I think maybe?

    • @phillyphakename1255
      @phillyphakename1255 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@garywayne6083I think I heard something about the officers silverware going to the new ship.

  • @kmbbmj5857
    @kmbbmj5857 Місяць тому +8

    Part of my career was the application of COTS to military use. One of the biggest drawbacks is you are totally at the mercy of the COTS provider. If they want to change the interface, they change it and the next gen isn't compatible with your billion-dollar sub. They do not do significant regression testing to ensure backward compatibility. And as we just saw with CrowdStrike, you don't control the changes they make to their COTS software.

    • @ssl3546
      @ssl3546 Місяць тому +6

      Okay, so you buy 1000 xbox 360 controllers and put them in a warehouse. You're not worried about next generations etc. you have one that works and you buy enough stock for the entire lifetime of the entire production run.

    • @shorey66
      @shorey66 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@ssl3546I think you might be underestimating how much sailors break stuff.

    • @arnieweisbrot9959
      @arnieweisbrot9959 Місяць тому +4

      One other consideration is the environmental condition the controller must endure in the worst case. Assume the control spaces are flooded with seawater. Will that COTS controller work after Damage Control empties the compartment? For the answer, try dunking your own controller in salt water and see if it works after immersion! Perhaps the solution is a bunch of spare controllers sealed in watertight lockers or bags, but then you are faced with replacing the controller while some destroyer is dropping nasty stuff designed to kill you. Basically, COTS versus mil-qualified is always a trade-off. Each is appropriate sometimes, and we can only hope that some equipment engineer did the trade-off studies for this "periscope" controller.

    • @kmbbmj5857
      @kmbbmj5857 Місяць тому +2

      @@ssl3546 However COTS doesn't work that way. The first "belief" is that the COTS industry is your logistics tail, so you don't have to have one. Beyond that is it's not just a controller, but an entire eco system of hardware, software, firmware, middleware, (and probably someone's dirty underwear by the time it's done) that all has to play nice together in harsh conditions. Somewhere in some production run the X123A chip gets replaced with the X123B chip. And suddenly that "plug and play" doesn't. It's more art than science getting all these parts to play together. COTS is one of those terms that sells well but is much harder to do in practice.

    • @phillyphakename1255
      @phillyphakename1255 Місяць тому

      ​@@kmbbmj5857the one good thing about that fragility is that it encourages upgrades. Can't source the X123A? Well, if you can no longer use the Xbox 360 controller, and the kids today have never touched one, might as well upgrade to the Xbox 1080 controller. And while you're at it, replace the camera, and the monitor, and the rangefinder.
      It's like the F-35, designed to be an empty hull that gets new weapons and new computers every 10 years for decades to come.

  • @JohnFromArlingtron
    @JohnFromArlingtron Місяць тому +56

    COTS is "Commercial Off The Shelf Tech"

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому

      Informally there are 3 major categories of re-purposed tech: off the shelf (brand-new), out of the box (outdated but still pretty new), and out of the bin (I'll let your imagination work). Calling these adaptations: off the shelf is, umm... generous

    • @tcoradeschi
      @tcoradeschi Місяць тому

      You are correct!

    • @rearspeaker6364
      @rearspeaker6364 Місяць тому

      COTS was a railroad term also-Clean, Oil, Test, Stencil.

  • @yes_head
    @yes_head Місяць тому +7

    You know you're old when you've never actually used an X-box controller. Or played a video game it was designed for (raises hand).

    • @peter_smyth
      @peter_smyth Місяць тому

      Soon, new recruits will be too young to have used an XBOX 360 controller.

    • @m9ovich785
      @m9ovich785 26 днів тому

      HAHAHAH The last game console I had was the Atari 2600....

  • @ewathoughts8476
    @ewathoughts8476 Місяць тому +2

    Just great, seems like Stockton Russ was there ahead of Ryan. So Ryan, when do you implode?

  • @aland7236
    @aland7236 Місяць тому +47

    Just in case anyone wanted to know how the Nuclear Reactor in a USN Submarine works I am happy to oblige, I was often bored in middle school after I finished my homework.
    Step 1. Find some spicy rocks.
    Step 2. Put those spicy rocks into a special metal box.
    Step 3. Put the metal box with the spicy rocks into a tank of water.
    Step 4. Let the spicy rocks heat the tank of water until it makes the water vaporize into steam.
    Step 5. Collect the steam from the tank of water and direct it's flow into a multi-stage expansion turbine whose output shafts are connected to electrical generators.
    Step 6. Use the generated electricity to protect and serve the United States of America and her interests including things like [REDACTED].
    Robert is a Parent's Sibling, It is as simple as that.

    • @kauske
      @kauske Місяць тому +1

      Just like any other nuclear reactor, except WAY less efficient due to not being as big. The same fuel that runs those subs and carriers would go much farther in a modern land-based reactor and leave much less waste. But to fit a commercial scale reactor like that you'd need a *literal* floating city.

    • @wtmayhew
      @wtmayhew Місяць тому +3

      @@kauske The US Army Corps of Engineers commissioned a floating 10 megawatt pressurized water reactor to be built out of an old Liberty Ship in 1963 for the seemingly impossibly small sum of 17 million Dollars. There was no room for motive power after the conversion, so the ship had to be towed to where it was needed. It was the Sturgis MH-1 and began operation in 1967. Sturgis’ most significant job was to supply supplemental electricity to the Panama Canal Zone when water in Gatun Lake was too low to make enough hydro power in 1968 . Shutting down and decontaminating the Sturgis was a big job and took the Army Corps until some time in 2017 to complete.

    • @aland7236
      @aland7236 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@kauskeI mean the words "Military" and "Efficient" rarely fit well into the same sentence. Given the task at hand the alleged S9G in the Virginia Class seems like it does a pretty good job.
      Decommissioning is pretty straightforward too. Put the reactor compartment in a box slightly larger than the compartment itself. Haul it away leaving it parked in the desert where it is visible for that hypocrite Ivan to see on his satellites then bury it in a mountain somewhere.
      Given that the alternative is Diesel-Electric, I think Nuclear power is fine for this use case.

    • @shaider1982
      @shaider1982 Місяць тому

      I learned that from Drachinifiel first.

    • @christopherpapelino889
      @christopherpapelino889 Місяць тому +1

      the battleship is quite similar! you just light a big fire to make the steam instead!

  • @anickode
    @anickode Місяць тому +3

    The Xbox controller for the photonics mast is just the modern day equivalent of the baseball grenade in WWII.
    Also I laughed at the slightly snarky remark about it not being "one of the cheap knockoff ones". 😂

  • @strickersniper7909
    @strickersniper7909 Місяць тому +2

    With the x box controller you’re saying that sailors are training when they get off of work?

  • @donalddodson7365
    @donalddodson7365 Місяць тому +4

    Thanks!

  • @llloyd4
    @llloyd4 Місяць тому +4

    XBox controller? * LOL! * Like that scene in MiB II when they pulled out a Playstation controller to control the car. :D

  • @ctje1638
    @ctje1638 Місяць тому +2

    There will probably be trinkets given to the crew for each active deployment, those would look great affixed to a tineline type exhibit I think.

  • @byronking9573
    @byronking9573 Місяць тому +2

    Future video idea here --> Get a chunk of the steel they use for submarine hulls and compare it to the steel/armor on BBNJ. Different alloys & production processes. Different strengths in many ways. Different welding requirements. Basic question is, "What do you want your steel to do?"

    • @kevincook1018
      @kevincook1018 Місяць тому +1

      The submarine is made of HY 100 steel (high-yield 100 ksi). The biggest difference is the degree of material pedigree required for submarine pressure hulls. Every heat of metal is tested for chemical and physical properties and results are maintained for the life of the ship. As each plate is cut and formed into structure each piece has physical marking to establish two way traceability from the plate to the installed parts in the ship. Then there are the welding records.....

    • @ryancollyer2046
      @ryancollyer2046 Місяць тому

      ​@@kevincook1018HY-80*

  • @weylinpiegorsch9253
    @weylinpiegorsch9253 Місяць тому +3

    Emcon concerns? Its a giant Farrady Cage, the only underwat concern would be surfaced on the bridge, which is easy to control emcon, or line handlers in/out of port where you're not exactly trying to hide

  • @jaycooper2812
    @jaycooper2812 Місяць тому +2

    You need to aquire an accurate replica of a MK-48 ADDCAP torpedo. One idea for a future video would be to give a rundown of the weapons that the submarine can carry.

  • @bigsarge2085
    @bigsarge2085 Місяць тому +1

    Fascinating, thank you!
    I got to tour U.S.S. Cheyenne SSN-773 at Pearl Harbor ~1998 or 1999.

  • @robertmccracken72
    @robertmccracken72 Місяць тому +1

    Very cool. Save room on your pier, you might be able to have the sail off that boat someday...

  • @chrismaverick9828
    @chrismaverick9828 Місяць тому +12

    Why does that towel at 1:35 have a carrier designation on it?

    • @archannas5805
      @archannas5805 Місяць тому +2

      Lol... thats a good catch

    • @ianmangham4570
      @ianmangham4570 Місяць тому +4

      Should say SSN 😮 796

    • @aland7236
      @aland7236 Місяць тому +1

      That is interesting. For what it is worth, the date is correct for the christening of SSN-796 New Jersey. Maybe it is some sort of inside thing? I remember something on the channel here a while back about the NJ having special permissions for some badge being colored red instead of the normal gold.

    • @timber_wulf5775
      @timber_wulf5775 Місяць тому +1

      Navy based joke about drone control capabilities probably

    • @chrismaverick9828
      @chrismaverick9828 Місяць тому

      @@archannas5805 Yeah, I saw it and then had to back up to confirm it. Maybe the event towels were embroidered wrong across the board and too late to fix it?
      Sounds like a government operation.

  • @Geek-A-Hertz8707
    @Geek-A-Hertz8707 Місяць тому +4

    yup nothing like doing the tango with a real periscope.

  • @whatever8282828
    @whatever8282828 Місяць тому +1

    I believe BB-62 never carried torpedoes. In the SSN-796 part of the museum it might be nice to show a dummy or mockup of the fancy torpedoes that the submarines carry!

  • @kturini
    @kturini Місяць тому +2

    To me the obvious story to be told of the new New Jersey is the story of the people working on the ship and how they eat, sleep, work, and interact with the space. That is what makes it human.

  • @skovner
    @skovner Місяць тому +2

    On a different note, I once worked with someone who had been a submariner. This was when Hunt for Red October came out He said all his shimpates (boatmates?) found the movie hilarious because it was so different from reality.
    That company was a large computer company, and somewhere there is a video of a flat panel display that would have cost $25000 had it gone into production (probably late 1980's). The most likely customer was going to put them in submarines, but the display never went into production. Yellow monochrome electroluminescent display.

  • @bobthecomputerguy
    @bobthecomputerguy Місяць тому +2

    Those joysticks are about the most tested component on the ship. Made to last 1000s of hours with teenagers regularly throwing them in anger when they die in elder ring. And millions have tested them.

  • @devobronc
    @devobronc Місяць тому +2

    I grew up near the Naval Reactor Research Site in Idaho. Many of my friends Parents were Engineers working on those projects.
    Currentn Submarine and Carrier Reactor Tech will last easily 30 years and potentially 40 or so without need or refueling... giving our Navy much better deployment rates and less time needed in Re-fit.
    Things have come a long way; and we now have much smaller & more efficient Reactors that use less fuel, last longer, produce mich more power, and are safer than ever before.
    This is NOT Grandpa's Nuclear Navy... We are now Light-years beyond those days.

  • @hololightful
    @hololightful Місяць тому +5

    A couple things... You showed a picture of an 'Original' Xbox, not an Xbox 360 (which im sure they were using).... Im not all that surprised or impressed that they went that route... Ive seen it done quite a few times over the past 10-15 years, and its kind of obvious if ypu think about it...
    What i really liked was that they were using the 'cell phones' like that...

    • @BlackEpyon
      @BlackEpyon Місяць тому

      That isn't even the original XBOX controller, nevermind a 360 controller. The ORIGINAL was a lot larger, closer in size to the Dreamcast controller! They were never really a big hit. Too awkward.

    • @hololightful
      @hololightful Місяць тому

      @@BlackEpyon if memory serves, the pictured one was after the larger design... After they got laughed out of the room with the first design...

  • @davidm8371
    @davidm8371 Місяць тому +2

    I've noticed a greater number of cuts in this video. No doubt it's easy to trail off into things that simply can't be said.

  • @3.2Carrera
    @3.2Carrera Місяць тому +1

    My friend's Dad was the skipper of a SSN and well after retirement he was very tight lipped about it. I'd throw the obvious questions to him and the answers were "deep enough" and "fast enough", lol.

  • @my1lastword
    @my1lastword Місяць тому +6

    Really missing the Logitech controller for COTS

    • @BlackEpyon
      @BlackEpyon Місяць тому +2

      If it's USB, I imagine you can use whatever controller you want as long as you can remap the controls!

  • @Strykenine
    @Strykenine Місяць тому

    Victory or Death is a great motto.

  • @Joseph55220
    @Joseph55220 Місяць тому +2

    Yeah - just like the x-box controllers, the navy realized it was cheaper and easier to just repurpose the internals of a v3 motorola razr flip-phone from 2010 than it would be to develop something from scratch - so: more technology you haven't used since college.

  • @tomprice5496
    @tomprice5496 Місяць тому +1

    I love you Ryan, you are my hero. Don't ever comb your hair.

  • @erikmutthersbough6508
    @erikmutthersbough6508 Місяць тому +8

    You probably need to get one of those X box style controllers from the NAVY for your collection

    • @BlackEpyon
      @BlackEpyon Місяць тому +2

      Do they have them with a custom silkscreen? They already have them for limited edition game promos, why shouldn't the Navy have one?

  • @MrJamesBanana
    @MrJamesBanana Місяць тому +1

    Oh, The ascom D81. We go trough loads of them at work.

  • @GhostKnightTech
    @GhostKnightTech Місяць тому +2

    Does the Battleship NJ have a Pre -steam ship (i.e a Ship of the Line, age of Sail) For-father?

  • @henrycarlson7514
    @henrycarlson7514 Місяць тому

    So Wise , Thank You for keeping history alive. . Good idea use what WORKS

  • @michealfeeney8920
    @michealfeeney8920 Місяць тому

    To be honest, I cant really think of what might be the best artifacts to gather at the commissioning but I AM thinking it would be something to gift 2 or 3 artifacts of note from both of her predecessors, to remind the crew of the legacy they are now heirs too.

  • @Gen3tx
    @Gen3tx Місяць тому

    At 00:47, is that the guy from smartereveryday deep dive series? The radar tech?

  • @Chodda
    @Chodda Місяць тому

    remember the OceanGate underwater submersible accident? they were using an Xbox controller too :)

  • @mikereinhardt4807
    @mikereinhardt4807 Місяць тому +2

    When they come on the museum New Jersey you should tell them they can't view the engine room as it's top secret and see what they say. 😂😂!...

  • @ataricom
    @ataricom 7 днів тому +1

    Hey Ryan, how much asbestos was on an Iowa-class ship? Has New Jersey been abated?

  • @stevea9604
    @stevea9604 Місяць тому +7

    Served on 637 class subs in the late 70’s…Interesting new stuff but the designers today have never served on one and their thinking reflects that…Visited a Virginia class and there were no manual backups for many of the main systems…it was electrical only…There were so many engineering designs lessons learned from WW-2 that are gone…There were double the number of IC man aboard then Machinist Mates…They had a dedicated IC man who’s job it was to maintain the ships entertainment system…I had an engineer tell me that there were lessons learned in blood that have gone away…Just my observations…

    • @justwordme
      @justwordme Місяць тому +2

      @@stevea9604 Sorry with the navy’s emphasis and history of the lessons learned that brought the birth of the sub safe program. I found it hard to believe what you are saying.

    • @stevea9604
      @stevea9604 Місяць тому +1

      @@justwordme Go visit a Virginia class and ask…It surprised me

    • @ryancollyer2046
      @ryancollyer2046 Місяць тому +1

      I can't think of a critical system that doesn't have a mechanical backup. I have no idea what youre talking about.

    • @stevea9604
      @stevea9604 Місяць тому

      @@ryancollyer2046 The main ballast tank blow is only electrically operated…There is no manual operations… There is lots more like that

    • @ryancollyer2046
      @ryancollyer2046 Місяць тому

      @stevea9604 Main Ballast tank blow is not electrical. It's controlled by the 2 "chicken switch" air valves above the pilot and copilot. The normal main ballast tank system is electrical from the touch screen panels, and have local controls as well.

  • @sibhuskyguy
    @sibhuskyguy Місяць тому +1

    I have a question about the periscope... Where do you put the quarters and how many minutes of play do you get? :P

  • @brendanscullion6218
    @brendanscullion6218 Місяць тому

    I think that each ship should fly a flag from the other ship. The new New Jersey could fly a flag on it's first deployment that also flew on BB New Jersey. That would be a cool artifact.

  • @annieworroll4373
    @annieworroll4373 Місяць тому

    Thinking about your videos on the hypothetical reactivation of your USS New Jersey, what would happen to the name if that happened? Has the US Navy ever reactivated a decommissioned vessel with a commissioned one currently in service?

  • @LordOfNihil
    @LordOfNihil Місяць тому

    im totally a joystick guy, i cant use a game pad. but modern gaming is either mouse+kb or gamepad and i think we lost something. but it does make sense to use something the young recruits recognize and know than to teach them the finer points of control theory.

  • @charlestuozzolo7283
    @charlestuozzolo7283 Місяць тому +1

    Fantastic. As a retired 688 class sailor does the photonics display still have the old periscope telemarks (cross hairs). Do sound powered phones still exist. AND most importantly; what kind of ice cream machine do they have? Great job!

    • @phillyphakename1255
      @phillyphakename1255 Місяць тому +2

      Probably have one or two sound powered phones, it's just good emergency redundancy. Crosshairs are probably an optional setting. Ice cream machine? You could probably FOIA the contract, but 20 bucks says its gonna be redacted because classified.

    • @rearspeaker6364
      @rearspeaker6364 Місяць тому +1

      @@phillyphakename1255 ice cream machine is more classified then the engine room.

    • @ryancollyer2046
      @ryancollyer2046 Місяць тому

      ​@@phillyphakename1255There's the same amount of sound powered phones as old boats, but they're backup only. There are normal landline-esq phones w/ 3 digit phone numbers.

  • @TX-biker
    @TX-biker Місяць тому +1

    A copy of their battle flag would be nice to see beside your WETSU flag😍

  • @christiantroy3034
    @christiantroy3034 Місяць тому +5

    Ok question for New NJ, how are the torpedoes fired. As far as artifacts, challenge coin, baseball cap, name tab from uniforms, copy of a Menu from first cruise, post card, a photo of her in the water next to the BB NJ, meal tray, a piece of the SSN NJ that is not needed or has been removed small piece of metal. Stationary, pen and pencil set, a set of salt and pepper shakers. I had the SSN Miami challenge coin and ball cap, donated it to the Cruiser Museum on Ryan’s side girlfriend USS Salem CA139

  • @chadoakley8505
    @chadoakley8505 Місяць тому

    are there any artifacts from either Battleship New Jersey on the sub? Commissioning silver or any other items?

  • @Axel0204
    @Axel0204 Місяць тому

    As someone who served on a 688I and now works on Virginia-class boats in a civilian capacity, I can confirm that Virginia-class boats are more cramped inside.

  • @barnaclebill1615
    @barnaclebill1615 Місяць тому

    How bout the collection of life saving equipment like inflatable abandon ship vests, life rings, float coats, kapok vests and if possible a life float (chum basket) or even life raft. Nice video! 👍👍😁🇺🇸

  • @QurikyBark32919
    @QurikyBark32919 Місяць тому +4

    This video will have an unusually high number of Chinese and Russian viewers…

  • @rs232killer
    @rs232killer Місяць тому

    Emissions control for hand held devices on a sub is quite easy. Not only does the sub have to be sealed up anyway, the penetration of EM radiation through water is quite poor to non-existent at the frequencies they would be using. You do have to make sure you aren't leaking out the mast when it is poking out of the water, but otherwise shouldn't be an issue.

  • @shadowdog500
    @shadowdog500 Місяць тому +1

    Will the submarine New Jersey carry anything on board from the battleship New Jersey?

  • @Aramis419
    @Aramis419 Місяць тому

    I always look forward to the random jump-cuts like at 2:46.

  • @charlesburns1572
    @charlesburns1572 Місяць тому

    Cool stuff! Thanks for sharing!

  • @bobbenson6825
    @bobbenson6825 Місяць тому

    Ryan I actually use a wired XBox controller for playing RPGs. But I'm an old. And I used to work as a tech at L3's predecessor, Loral Corp., doing product testing.

  • @hfdole
    @hfdole Місяць тому

    How about acquiring a mk48 or a Tomahawk? All for display purposes of course.
    Perhaps at the end-of-career you can get the SSN NJ's sail, kinda like how Parche was memorialized.

  • @waltermcinnis
    @waltermcinnis Місяць тому

    Reckon those muzzle doors are probably on the list of watertight doors, too 😜

  • @divarachelenvy
    @divarachelenvy Місяць тому

    would love to see you on the chow line of the sub..

  • @Jams27
    @Jams27 Місяць тому

    I'm fortunate enough to have snagged tickets to her commissioning ceremony!

    • @garywayne6083
      @garywayne6083 Місяць тому +1

      Me too!

    • @Jams27
      @Jams27 Місяць тому

      ​@garywayne6083 see you there!

  • @whatever8282828
    @whatever8282828 Місяць тому

    I think the C in COTS is usually considered to mean "Commercial" rather than "Civilian" but I suppose it pretty much means the same thing.

  • @nancpatterson5178
    @nancpatterson5178 Місяць тому +4

    When will a New Jersey go into space?

    • @aland7236
      @aland7236 Місяць тому +4

      Right after the B-52Z takes flight.

    • @phillyphakename1255
      @phillyphakename1255 Місяць тому

      ​@@aland7236you really think it'll take 200 years?

  • @neonhomer
    @neonhomer Місяць тому +1

    A photo of both New Jerseys together... BB-62 in the background and SSN-796 in the foreground...

    • @aland7236
      @aland7236 Місяць тому

      @@neonhomer Have you had an opportunity to see the Badge for SSN-796? It's beautiful.

  • @yankee1219
    @yankee1219 Місяць тому

    Awesome video is always Ryan but I have a question. I knew that the New Virginia's were not going to deploy periscopes. In the traditional sense and the photonics mast replace the traditional periscope. So my question is, is what does the captain say when he wants to take a look on the surface? Does he still say periscope? Depth raise the periscope, Or does he say photonic mass depth, Raise the photonic mast?

  • @jon9509
    @jon9509 Місяць тому +1

    Can the sailors invert the Y axis on the controller?

  • @66WDB
    @66WDB Місяць тому

    CVN-796? I think someone made a pretty significant goof in that embroidery on the towel😂

  • @MartysRandomStuff
    @MartysRandomStuff Місяць тому +1

    It was a big deal to turn the Nautilus into a museum, very unlikely any more modern nuclear powered ship will ever become a museum. The Nautilus being relatively small meant they didn't have that much to cut through to remove the reactor and then rebuild the hull and add extra plate in that area of the hull because people were paranoid about contamination of the river from the hull that was around the reactor.
    Been to see it many times, my dad was in the navy in the mid 50s on a diesel sub and had a friend on the Nautilus, one time when they were both in New London he got to go on board for a tour and his friend let him look in the reactor room. He was not supposed to see that and they both got chewed out pretty badly. When it became a museum ship he would go over there probably once a year.

  • @fabiopinciroli4962
    @fabiopinciroli4962 Місяць тому

    The phones are Ascom DECT cordless phones, they work like an office PBX.

  • @JetsMakeWoosh
    @JetsMakeWoosh Місяць тому +2

    Gotta get something from the first weapon fired from the sub

  • @patrickmccarty6953
    @patrickmccarty6953 Місяць тому +1

    An Xbox controller? Give me a keyboard and mouse any day! Long Live the PC Gamer master race! 😆

  • @ChainsawFPV
    @ChainsawFPV Місяць тому +6

    I wish I could drive for 30 years without a fillup. Lol

    • @Tmlong333
      @Tmlong333 Місяць тому +1

      Good news, bad news - one fillup (good news), heap big expensive to fillup/refuel (bad news). End of vehicle life, another heap big price tag to dispose of nuclear power tank (more bad news).

    • @wtmayhew
      @wtmayhew Місяць тому

      Boy, numbers on the Internet are all over the place from 10 to 30 years for the reactor core refueling interval. US EPA says 20 years, which is conveniently in the middle. 😊

    • @phillyphakename1255
      @phillyphakename1255 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@Tmlong333my parents had a truck with a 1000 mile fuel tank. Never had to fill it up, until you did😢. Had the weird realization that, like, there's a finite number of times the truck will be refuelled, and it's a low enough number to be comprehendible by a human brain.

  • @223556762308
    @223556762308 Місяць тому

    I'm glad the military is learning lessons from the titanic sub

  • @aw9680
    @aw9680 Місяць тому

    Get the first installed Xbox controller that is maintenanced out during its tour. It would be really cool to say that "on display is the first conning tower controller... Made by Microsoft."

  • @dennisfariello4852
    @dennisfariello4852 Місяць тому

    Great job as always, Ryan. Couple of things: COTS = Commercial Off-The-Shelf, not Civilian. Second... what's with the blue towel early in the video, the one that says USS New Jersey CVN-796?

  • @peters6366
    @peters6366 Місяць тому

    Is there a video on the channel about all the New Jerseys? If not, can we get one?

  • @williampaddock4863
    @williampaddock4863 Місяць тому +1

    Hello Ryan i recently visited the Battleship New Jersy on july 15 What are the Muzzle loading Cannons sitiing outside under the radar Dish in the parking lot?.

    • @SomeRandomHuman717
      @SomeRandomHuman717 Місяць тому +3

      Those are the Navy's first rifles. They are located next to the navy's last rifle, the 16"/50. ua-cam.com/video/yye1oqCq4bY/v-deo.html (and don't forget part 2 at ua-cam.com/video/ZRInfcrt0nE/v-deo.html )

    • @williampaddock4863
      @williampaddock4863 Місяць тому

      @@SomeRandomHuman717 oh kool ok you should put up a sigh so other would know the staff sure did not know

  • @zonavarbondagoo4074
    @zonavarbondagoo4074 Місяць тому +2

    Our goverment was supposedly looking at acquiring some Virginia class nuclear subs as a
    'pre-cursor' to the so-called Aukus pact ones but I've got no info on what's happening with that since I'm not in the Aus Navy or even in the military or a miltary contractor.

    • @simiamalum5487
      @simiamalum5487 Місяць тому +1

      It's been a while, but last I heard no subs would actually be transferred to Australia until the 2030's; however, Australian submariners are currently being assigned to US boats. By the time the subs are transferred I'm quite certain they'll be among the best crewed in the world.

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому

      Administrations change and ships get stuck in the Suez canal - which unfortunately leads to logistical problems with some consumer electronic goods, without which, the US Navy is unfortunately unable to complete production of certain submarines and aircraft carriers.

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому

      It's a complicated business - especially when it requires the cooperation of China, India, Egypt, Israel, Germany, South Korea, Brazil, Canada, France, Singapore, Vietnam, Mexico, Taiwan and some assorted other countries for us to collect all the little bits and pieces we need to construct our warships and make sure the computers have the software they require.

    • @Joseph55220
      @Joseph55220 Місяць тому

      The silicon and steel is the easy part - we can probably throw enough money at reverse-engineering the physical components we need and we can always invade some countries if we have to go get some rare-Earth metals - but, until we teach more kids to be software engineers - it'll probably take about 10-15 years of lead-time if we find ourselves in the unenviable position of having to write our own source-code.

  • @caseyglick5957
    @caseyglick5957 Місяць тому

    What is the rationale for not having more watertight bulkheads?

  • @WeSRT4
    @WeSRT4 Місяць тому

    No water tight doors??? Does this mean if the hull ruptures on one end or the other the entire thing goes down?

  • @Danbutch24
    @Danbutch24 Місяць тому

    Funny re the Xbox controller, a similar example is in the British Challenger 2 MBT as the gunners control for traversing the turret and elevating and depressing the gun is molded to be the same shape and layout as a PlayStation controller.

  • @gregkarkowsky967
    @gregkarkowsky967 Місяць тому

    Did they use any piece of Battleship NJ to create the new Sub NJ? Like a token or momento?