Vectorworks is more ‘parametric’ and uses the IFC format for team collaboration better than Revit. Each of the benefits you claim for Revit also apply to ArchiCAD and Vectorworks.
@@steedlei1 but Vectorworks has various built in (rather than add-on extras) that perform the same role as does ArchiCAD. Both are more cost effective than Revit as well. AutoDesk software is NEVER the only option and neither should it be.
@John Kellett but sadly online learning options are very much limited.I learned revit by youtube videos and using few reference book but that's not the case for Vectorworks.Vert few online courses are there which are very much expensive and no reference books.I gave a try for vw to switch from revit but couldn't because of above reasons.
Sadly, none of the programs are up to date on what you would expect a 2022 BIM tool to do.. No wood framing in Archicad and Revit unless you buy the extra ArchiFrame/AgaCad package. The 3d tool Revit got the ability to measure in 3d in last years version. Archicad got the ability to hide one item and not the whole layer in last years version. It takes forever to generate a schedule in Archicad on a small project. We expect too little from the software we pay an arm and a leg for :/
Vectorworks has framing tools for walls floors and roofs. The schedules are just there when they are created if you use one of the templates. It is only creating different templates that takes time and whilst neither Vectorworks nor ArchiCAD need Excel they can import and export to it if needed, and in 20 years I never have.
Interesting list, but in my experience Tekla is the only software on this list which quickly and easily produces LOD 400 models. This is not surprising since the steel business has been into BIM from the beginning. Architectural software only seems to produce generic models, with LOD 300 at best (usually only 200). To me, that's a pretty picture but not true BIM.
hi, nice video ^^... I want to ask your opinion... Are software like intergraph PDS, Aveva PDMS, SP3D, E3D, Autocad Plant 3D, etc. considered as BIM Software also? thanks ^^
i dont know these softwares but in general, BIM stands for building information model, meaning that 3d geometry has added information to it, such as cost, material, structural importance, element ID, etc. so if the programs you listed have 3d objects that have added meaning then yes they technically are bim programs. if they function like rhino on the other hand where a surface is just a surface and a box is just a box then they are not, hope this helps
@@TheQuantixXx thank you for your input ^^ i think you should explore these softwares also just for infirmation^^ they are good also but they are for plant design... and yes they have databases for the data and collaborates with most of other engineering softwares as well^^
I worked with many Programs and Allplan is the best of all.
No it's not. I can't even understand it when I open it. Show us some reasons why you think this!
One of best for drawing reinforcemnt
@@a.d.9729 All in one! No other licence needed! Very fast results + BIMs and Kost!
Vectorworks is more ‘parametric’ and uses the IFC format for team collaboration better than Revit. Each of the benefits you claim for Revit also apply to ArchiCAD and Vectorworks.
ArchiCad has no Dynamo.. :)
@@steedlei1 but Vectorworks has various built in (rather than add-on extras) that perform the same role as does ArchiCAD. Both are more cost effective than Revit as well. AutoDesk software is NEVER the only option and neither should it be.
@John Kellett but sadly online learning options are very much limited.I learned revit by youtube videos and using few reference book but that's not the case for Vectorworks.Vert few online courses are there which are very much expensive and no reference books.I gave a try for vw to switch from revit but couldn't because of above reasons.
@@ambarnkm , Vectorworks University is full of tutorials and webinars. I’ve most definitely not found them to be limited :-)
@@johnkellett7797 Thanks I will check it out.
Archicad my favorite
Sadly, none of the programs are up to date on what you would expect a 2022 BIM tool to do.. No wood framing in Archicad and Revit unless you buy the extra ArchiFrame/AgaCad package. The 3d tool Revit got the ability to measure in 3d in last years version. Archicad got the ability to hide one item and not the whole layer in last years version. It takes forever to generate a schedule in Archicad on a small project. We expect too little from the software we pay an arm and a leg for :/
" It takes forever to generate a schedule in Archicad on a small project." quite a good news for revit user :)
Vectorworks has framing tools for walls floors and roofs. The schedules are just there when they are created if you use one of the templates. It is only creating different templates that takes time and whilst neither Vectorworks nor ArchiCAD need Excel they can import and export to it if needed, and in 20 years I never have.
Everything you said is true. Revit had great extension in 2015 wood framing but they gave it to 3rd plug-in agacad have no idea why...
Allplan is so far away from the others that when the company is forcing us to use Revit is like working with pencils.
And Bentley Microstation? Open Building Design? For me Vectorworks is the best!
thank you for this valuable sharing
only archicad for architects
Interesting list, but in my experience Tekla is the only software on this list which quickly and easily produces LOD 400 models. This is not surprising since the steel business has been into BIM from the beginning. Architectural software only seems to produce generic models, with LOD 300 at best (usually only 200). To me, that's a pretty picture but not true BIM.
How about BricsCAD BIM?
Good post
What about VisualARQ in RINO?
By far Allplan.
hi, nice video ^^... I want to ask your opinion... Are software like intergraph PDS, Aveva PDMS, SP3D, E3D, Autocad Plant 3D, etc. considered as BIM Software also? thanks ^^
i dont know these softwares but in general, BIM stands for building information model, meaning that 3d geometry has added information to it, such as cost, material, structural importance, element ID, etc.
so if the programs you listed have 3d objects that have added meaning then yes they technically are bim programs. if they function like rhino on the other hand where a surface is just a surface and a box is just a box then they are not, hope this helps
@@TheQuantixXx thank you for your input ^^ i think you should explore these softwares also just for infirmation^^ they are good also but they are for plant design... and yes they have databases for the data and collaborates with most of other engineering softwares as well^^
Do tekla software have a scope in future?
Hi,
which of these software has an api? I would like to push external data into it and build the construction with these data
good question. I think none of them. There are import and export functions and scripts but I never hear them speak about api's.
As long as the import is structured in a way that allows me to create generic content, it should work.
Tekla has an API.
I don't understand why Halo Chief is your profile picture of your channel...
ua-cam.com/users/InspirationTuts . This is our main channel, and it is all about 3D!
@@inspirationTutsCAD You are UE5 guys..haha
No Bentley software???? That's a major oversight.
great channel
Thank you
which one has all 4D 5D 6D 7D 8D in one?
None
What about Navisworks?
Navisworks is very bad and slow.
@@alleskaese Okay BIM Manager hahaha
I know the Software
@@alleskaese Me too bro ;)