I want to say that democracy is the problem of Indian. China's success is mainly due to its unique efficient system. But then I thought every people has their own tradition and way of organize their society. It is that the Chinese think for their own and come up their own way of development but India can't.
@@hotchi1566 In a democracy you cant just force anything ...changes takes time as naturally there are different groups . Let me give you an example . In my city last year the Govt. had decided to clear a small area of forested land for the construction of a shed for the Metro trains ....Now as soon as news of this was heard by some ' Nature Loving ' people a big protest was arranged and they took the matter to court ( In India once any issue is taken up by the judiciary and is pending for hearing the Govt. cannot do anything as far as that particular subject matter is concerned ) ...Later the courts did allow the Govt. to construct the shed there as the small forested area was just too small to be categorized under forests hence the Law which orders the Govt. to protect the forests was not applicable there and more importantly the land was legally owned by the railways anyway ...So the railways was able to construct a shed there BUT do you know how long it took ..Almost two years ...Something which would had been completed in six months took two years to finish and for that the entire Metro rail construction had to suffer as well . This is what happens .
India is hopelessly divided, also western world will not allow an other country with size of China to rise again, they have no more job to give. I have been to India many many times, love the country and people, every intellectual I met with in India can list all the issues India facing, no one has solutions.
@@user-xu6zu5ym8u There is no true communist country. It's more of a socialist country and with "Chinese characteristics" as the Chinese often project themselves. This idea for a revamp of their system stemmed from Deng Xiaopeng's visit to Singapore in 1979. After years of trials and errors and much tweaking, the Chinese govt managed to alleviate hardcore poverty for 700-800 million of its population. The Chinese are not saying that this system is the greatest and that it works for every country and definitely has no plans to shove it down the throat of other countries. Someone in this comment section mentioned that China is no angel...and i agree. Each country works primarily to serve its own interests and China's interests are simple; to have food on the tables of each household and a roof over their heads. Once these 2 basic needs are satisfied would only then you have a stable society. And we have seen what progress can be achieved with a stable society.
China send their best to universities abroad and come back home. While India goes overseas and never return this is why China has the startup companies like the U.S.
@@ninadkadam8570 it is all theoritical things bro... See our education system... Dont compare USA with india... They are 1000 miles ahead ... Its actually USA who should be proud that they are helping the brilliant indians for success..... And those brilliant indians are doing and contributing for the whole world....... Everybody has their own dreams
IMO China is not only a decade ahead of India, they are also progressing faster through aggressive modernization of every aspects of their lives, governance and technology.
@Nikhil Gihar I think that is the beauty of my nation also in vid he left some points like india has support of US European powers quad while world is turning against china examples of antiasian incidents are increasing US and these countries will try to deaccelerate China's growth because US will not allow any other country to take its status of super power Also for india the thing u mentioned Britain gave a super tool to us the power of language Also india is a democracy western countries will try to stop the rise of a communist nation which was all the cause for which cold war happened But according to me most probably two blocks will be formed in future with China Russia and other side western powers and then the stance of india will be important of course this will happen after a decade in late 2030s i guess if india remained non aligned it will be great but i think at that time if india chose china asia will be united for first time if india chose US which I think will happen world will see another cold war
No it's not. Old Vedic scriptures describes the geography of India from the stretch of Himalayas to the forests of South. Your statement is naive and ignorant.
The following is what I borrowed from a Malaysian UA-camr’s comment: I’m from Malaysia. China has traded with Malaysia for 2000 years. In those years, they had been the world’s biggest powers many times. Never once they sent troops to take our land. Admiral Zhenghe came to Malacca five times, in gigantic fleets, and a flagship eight times the size of Christopher Columbus’ flagship, Santa Maria. He could have seized Malacca easily, but he did not. In 1511, the Portuguese came. In 1642, the Dutch came. In the 18th century the British came. We were colonised by each, one after another. When China wanted spices from India, they traded with the Indians. When they wanted gems, they traded with the Persian. They didn’t take lands. The only time China expanded beyond their current borders was in Yuan Dynasty, when Genghis and his descendants Ogedei Khan, Guyuk Khan & Kublai Khan concurred China, Mid Asia and Eastern Europe. But Yuan Dynasty, although being based in China, was a part of the Mongolian Empire. Then came the Century of Humiliation. Britain smuggled opium into China to dope the population, a strategy to turn the trade deficit around, after the British could not find enough silver to pay the Qing Dynasty in their tea and porcelain trades. After the opium warehouses were burned down and ports were closed by the Chinese in ordered to curb opium, the British started the Opium War I, which China lost. Hong Kong was forced to be surrendered to the British in a peace talk (Nanjing Treaty). The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron. The remaining 10% was owned by American merchants from Boston. Many of Boston’s institutions were built with profit from opium. After 12 years of Nanjing Treaty, the West started getting really really greedy. The British wanted the Qing government: 1. To open the borders of China to allow goods coming in and out freely, and tax free. 2. Make opium legal in China. Insane requests, Qing government said no. The British and French (with supports from the US), started Opium War II with China, which again, China lost. The Anglo-French military raided the Summer Palace, and threatened to burn down the Imperial Palace, the Qing government was forced to pay with ports, free business zones, 300,000 kilograms of silver and Kowloon was taken. Since then, China’s resources flew out freely through these business zones and ports. In the subsequent amendment to the treaties, Chinese people were sold overseas to serve as labor. In 1900, China suffered attacks by the 8-National Alliance (Empire of Japan, Russian Empire, British Empire (including India), France, USA, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary). Innocent Chinese civilians in Peking (Beijing now) were murdered, buildings were destroyed & women were raped. The Imperial Palace was raided, and treasures ended up in museums like the British Museum in London and the Louvre in Paris. In late 1930s China was occupied by the Japanese in WWII. Millions of Chinese died during the occupancy. 300,000 Chinese died in Nanjing Massacre alone. Mao brought China together again from the shambles. There were peace and unity for some time. But Mao’s later reign saw sufferings and deaths from famine and power struggles. Then came Deng Xiao Ping and his infamous “black-cat and white-cat” story. His preference in pragmatism than ideologies has transformed China. This thinking allowed China to evolve all the time to adapt to the actual needs in the country, instead of rigidly bounded to ideologies. It also signified the death of Communism in actually practice in China. The current Socialism+Meritocracy+Market Economy model fits the Chinese like gloves, and it propels the uprise of China. Singapore has a similar model, and has been arguably more successful than Hong Kong, because Hong Kong being gateway to China, was riding on the economic boom in China, while Singapore had no one to gain from. In just 30 years, the CPC have moved 800 millions of people out from poverty. The rate of growth is unprecedented in human history. They have built the biggest mobile network, by far the biggest high speed rail network in the world, and they have become a behemoth in infrastructure. They made a fishing village called Shenzhen into the world’s second largest technological centre after the Silicon Valley. They are growing into a technological power house. It has the most elaborate e-commerce and cashless payment system in the world. They have launched exploration to Mars. The Chinese are living a good life and China has become one of the safest countries in the world. The level of patriotism in the country has reached an unprecedented height. For all of the achievements, the West has nothing good to say about it. China suffers from intense anti-China propagandas from the West. Western Media used the keyword “Communist” to instil fear and hatred towards China. Everything China does is negatively reported. They claimed China used slave labor in making iPhones. The truth was, Apple was the most profitable company in the world, it took most of the profit, leave some to Foxconn (a Taiwanese company) and little to the labor. They claimed China was inhuman with one-child policy. At the same time, they accused China of polluting the earth with its huge population. The fact is the Chinese consume just 30% of energy per capita compared to the US. Minorities in China Show me any currency in the world which also prints the language of its ethinc minorities. Chinese bank notes show 5 languages of 5 minorities living in China, including Tibetan and Uyghur. They claimed China underwent ethnic cleansing in Xinjiang. The fact is China has a policy which priorities ethnic minorities. For a long time, the ethnic minorities were allowed to have two children and the majority Han only allowed one. The minorities are allowed a lower score for university intakes. Muslims students get Halal food at the university cafeteria. There are 39,000 mosque in China, and 2100 in the US. China has about 3 times more mosque per muslim than the US. When terrorist attacks happened in Xinjiang, China had two choices: 1. Re-educate the Uighur extremists before they turned terrorists. 2. Let them be, after they launch attacks and killed innocent people, bomb their homes. China chose 1 to solve problem from the root and not to do killing. How the US solve terrorism? Fire missiles from battleships, drop bombs from the sky. During the pandemic, When China took extreme measures to lockdown the people, they were accused of being inhuman. When China recovered swiftly because of the extreme measures, they were accused of lying about the actual numbers. When China’s cases became so low that they could provide medical support to other countries, they were accused of politically motivated. Western Media always have reasons to bash China. Just like any country, there are irresponsible individuals from China which do bad and dirty things, but the China government overall has done very well. But I hear this comment over and over by people from the West: I like Chinese people, but the CPC is evil. What they really want is the Chinese to change the government, because the current one is too good. Fortunately China is not a multi-party democratic country, otherwise the opposition party in China will be supported by notorious NGOs (Non-Government Organization) of the USA, like the NED (National Endowment for Democracy), to topple the ruling party. The US and the British couldn’t crack Mainland China, so they work on Hong Kong. Of all the ex-British colonial countries, only the Hong Kongers were offered BNOs by the British. Because the UK would like the Hong Kongers to think they are British citizens, not Chinese. A divide-and-conquer strategy, which they often used in Color Revolutions around the world. They resort to low dirty tricks like detaining Huawei’s CFO & banning Huawei. They raised a silly trade war which benefits no one. Trade deficit always exist between a developing and a developed country. USA is like a luxury car seller who ask a farmer: why am I always buying your vegetables and you haven’t bought any of my cars? When the Chinese were making socks for the world 30 years ago, the world let it be. But when Chinese started to make high technology products, like Huawei and DJI, it caused red-alert. Because when Western and Japanese products are equal to Chinese in technologies, they could never match the Chinese in prices. First world countries want China to continue in making socks. Instead of stepping up themselves, they want to pull China down. The recent movement by the US against China has a very important background. When Libya, Iran, and China decided to ditch the US dollar in oil trades, Gaddafi’s was killed by the US, Iran was being sanctioned by the US, and now it’s China’s turn. The US has been printing money out of nothing. The only reason why the US Dollar is still widely accepted, is because it’s the only currency which oil is allowed to be traded with. The US has an agreement with Saudi that oil must be traded in US dollar ONLY. Without the petrol-dollar status, the US dollars will sink, and America will fall. Therefore anyone trying to disobey this order will be eliminated. China will soon use a gold-backed crypto-currency, the alarms in the White House go off like mad. China’s achievements and success have been by hard work. Not by looting and plundering the world. I have deep respect and love for China for all the suffering and the hardship they endured, but now I feel happy for them. China is not rising, they are going back to where they belong. Good luck China. --Nihilist
I just have one question to u For all ur lecture Why china has border dispute with so many countries? Including India..why did it occupy Tibet illegally.. why do they claim India's land as it's own and refuse to follow Internationally established boundaries?
@@ms.dentist Similar to the US involvement in Ukraine, the Russia would never have conflicts with Ukraine. The CIA involved in Tibet. China had to stop the US occupation in that region. And Dalai Lama was on the CIA payroll. The chaos was created by the CIA. In regards to India & China the conflict always involve both sides. You need to check out from the India’ side of the story too. Back to Tibet they have more freedom than even in the West. They even have the bullet train that some Western countries do not have😉
@@jng4880 Dalai Lama was on CIA payroll.. really? First of all.. Tibet was an independent nation..for all the development..did china had any right to occupy it in the first place? And the border dispute is not only with India..but japan, Phillipines, Vietnam, and soo many more I mean with every nation china has border dispute. India on the other hand..has border dispute only with china And not other neighbours
@@jng4880 i really want to understand China's perspective But when i see my map and Aksai chin that china illegally occupied when our prime minister trusted china..makes me loose all empathy with them..they are still trying to add more land.. continue their expansionist policy Why??? Why not let neighbours live peacefully and develop together? Why to blame America when it was China that took a part of India in 1962 war
Chinese here now living in Canada. I don't like that Chinese talk ill about Indians and vice versa! both countries have great culture and long traditions. Respect each other and build a symbiotic relationship is the way to go~ no war , no American kind BS~
couldn't agree more as an Indian in fact India and china have a lot in common in terms of culture and civilization and can work really well together, they can seriously challenge neocolonial ecosystem, if not much they should at least work together in historical social sciences and cultural front in terms of decolonizing the discourse in these streams within academia media public etc.
Exactly. The people of china and India are not to blame but the government of china is very provocative. Occupying lands of their neighbours for absolutely no reason and for being expansive to almost everyone is dangerous. I hope democracy can return to China and future can be bright for the people of both nations.
3 роки тому+5
@@sarthakpathania and plz keep your so-called democracy , ur so-called democracy is just a placebo that makes u little bit better.
@ yes India's democracy is flawed. It's not perfect but all i did was criticise CCP which is very bad for China and Chinese people. But I guess if you know better then good day ahead.
You are very very right that can solve it s jobs problem and we need it for Indian market for exports MNCs can help with automation so that when employment problem solves full scale automation could be switched over
to compare India with China is like comparing Haiti with US. the best discussion on India vs. China is from Jayant Bhandari who gives the most insightful analysis on this topic.
@Jazz24 You are absolutely correct..!!! India politicians should learn from ASEAN countries, do not always considered itself is always right, other is wrong
Question: What was China's GDP in 2006? Chinese living overseas bashed china back then and thought it would never succeed. It is fashionable to bash your country of origin. Self criticism is important but self deprecation is unhealthy.
@@uvg319 Chinese overseas you knew were Taiwaneses i think. There are millions of Chinese overseas around the world including Asean, Europe and America
Jayant Bhandari speaks just bullshit. I know India is way behind China and isn't going to grow as fast as China. But the reasons Jayant Bhandari gives are bullshit. He is just trying to make Indians sign RCEP nothing else.
@@likevin3087 honestly I don't think our countries can become ally but atleast we have to make sure our conflicts doesn't grow much that west can take advantage of it to maintain their hegemony.
CCP is more a nationalist party than a communist one. That said, the communism is a key element of the CCP. Check out how CCP has done to lift poorest Chinese out of poverty: ua-cam.com/video/k24-ZhKGjnI/v-deo.html.
Summing up his talk: India and China should team up. Cooperate instead of compete. India needs to remove bureaucratic bottlenecks and improve infrastructure
Get the rich indians to drop their ego first, To China India is not a competitor at all and also dont wish to wake indians up knowing india have great potential 😁. So hilarious to this date ppl still wanna compares India to China. The day will come when India start to show great advancements to beat USA, history will repeat itself like what happen to Japan France and now S.Korea & Taiwan both need to basically surrender all their knowhow n tech (Samsung&TSMC) to USA. USA tried on Huawei but fail simply because China dare to stand up and say fxxk off will India dare or have the power to say no when the time comes? So sometime is better to go slow till the bully is out of the picture.
@@alvino2211 you can see the future...India and china should have more and more cooperation,not the vicious competition . May we can find the problem if the GDP of india reach to 40% of usa.
@@alvino2211 , are you saying India cannot "sit" until US say so? 😁 Sounds like US will never allow India to beat US to be the 2nd largest economy globally.
How does India hold a significant lead in software over China when it doesn't even have its own big websites? Among other applications like gadgets, vehicles, and robots.
India has its software... But those softwares are small and made by the guidelines.... In india innovation is almost 0 .... And in harware and electronics.... Forget china and usa... We are not even a cup of tea to taiwan, Vietnam hong kong also
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 The main problem is lack of interest and funding for research and our education system. Our education system was framed in British era by Sir Macaulay who stated that India should have a utilitarian system of education which simply means a system in which there's no questioning and one should just focus on what's the input and output of a thing so yup it's a mistake at our behalf to not to change the system even after this long.
@@harinramesh3468 those indian companies you've mentioned worked for clients. they don't create innovation or R&D. the are the back office for US and European companies. FB & Google contributed a lot to tech world. creating new frameworks, standards and tools for other IT companies
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 the problem is we have nowhere close to the number of users for those websites other nations do. Compare the number of e commerce consumers in other countries to those on India on a percentage basis. We actually develop and sell alot of software to all the countries you mentioned.
I think ban the Facebook UA-cam Google in Indian to improve software skills. India have more population that can become a super internet market. In US, more Indian work for US internet company, but they didn't get the better salary. In future ，I hope to see India Google Apple Tesla
Having been to India, I think they had massive potential but couldn't control their population growth unlike China. I forsee a massive problem in the future in India because of their population with no real apparent solution. The worst feature of India is that the rich try and insulate themselves from the concerns of the poor (the vast majority) so they see no reason to change the current situation for the average person, if that continues India is in for massive trouble.
@@aalhadbapat3489 Sadly the doors will be shut pretty quickly. We can only hope that Indian leaders start looking after their people, not just themselves and provide a decent life for the majority. The world needs India to get it together ASAP.
@@aalhadbapat3489 The West is collapsing. Too much immigration, cultural collapse, crime, collapse of families, ghetto behaviour. West is becoming third world.
@@mudra5114 oh really... Maybe its not all of the countries..... They will never collapse... Cauz people are hardworking ... People are self confident... I mean look at those little little sized countries eh.... Germany, France,UK .... And in northern side sweden and scandinavian countries are on the rise...... See their healthcare... See their education system mate
@@sparksmacoy your sweet fantasy of immigrants completely stopping going to Europe will not materalise the world leaders has realised that this crisis has to be solved and especially the European leaders are really good there already thousands of Indians going to Canada Russia USA Japan uae to escape poverty.
Well, this year India has added more startups than China yet it's 16 whereas in overall before 2021 India had 28 even tho China has thousand times startups than India. This shows we are moving in a great direction also the infra has majorly improved especially in Urban areas. The government needs to pull up a major campaign for modernizing the agriculture system here. Where China needs 2 employees in the farming sector India needs 20. Another thing that can be done is skill development Indian engineers are called that they aren't skilled enough to be competing with any engineer from developed nations. The great thing is that just 6-8 months of training is enough to make them skilled as they already have theoretical knowledge. Those people from the farming sector can easily be pushed into manufacturing if govt supports them. In India women employees are decreasing day by day previously total of 10-12% women used to work outside but it has come down to 6% in 2021 95% of women in India aren't self-dependent that's literally half of India's population sitting at home where has over 90% of women in China works. India needs to stop seeing the modern world as a sin or curse. Most of the women want to work but culture forces them to take care of their child at home if we push and accept babysitting as something good then not just mothers but other women who will work as a baby sitter can get jobs. Sorry to say but Indian culture has a huge toxic part due to which we aren't able to grow as fast and that's also the reason why so many of Indians leave the country and never come back.
Lmaooo The startups only help top 1% at ground level India is as poor as ever, infrastructure hasn't 'majorly' improved, agriculture stops India from relying too much on global supplies hence India is actually helping the world through the food shortage we're going through right now, training engineers is optimistic at best and daydream at worst and finally the biggest reason why the West is going through this moral crisis with both fall of Christianity, rise of SJW and fall of functional literacy down to 60% all which is more than enough to destroy civilization is mothers not being there for their children. It's the biggest experiment in human history where an entire generation was raised without the affection required for a healthy life and we're seeing results as SJW demands individuals-with-penises-identifying-as-female to give access to the private space of individuals-with-vaginas. Overall, I'm glad you're not running India.
The future of india depended on the calibre of future leaders who must be dedicated and focused on the country's development..they must be corruption free and law abiding..
India has a lead in software development ? Only if all the Chinese E-commerce platforms & apps were done by India, otherwise China is way ahead of India in software.
Both India and China are great countries and can co-exist and work together in a win-win situation. India will catch up quickly due to demographic dividend.
@@badbad-cat It is already doing so with the Quad, turning India and China as rivals instead of partners. The US just wouldn't like to see Russia, India & China as partners and allies.
@Vajra 21 Did I say that? The Quad was created by the US to counter & prevent the rise of Chyna. Indya is part of the Quad. Do you think the intention of the Quad is to promote the cooperation & friendship between these countries?
No David... Not possible in 150yrs also, it is not possible. It is like a joke where the girl is 1 year older than the guy and the guy says I will wait 1 year to get married with you.. In 150 yrs china will also move on 150 yrs ahead.
Kevin, you have mentioned a decade here and a decade there on many areas of infra, edu, etc... to be realistic, a democratic parliament can only pass a big project once every few years. Only if the next government after elections do not cancel or modify the previous projects.. all the decades mentioned is about 100 years in total..🤣 🤣
Maybe not a 100 but at the rate we're going certainly more than 10. Surprisingly many big projects have been passed(and many concluded) by our current govt. The problem at current levels of taxation is we can't keep the growth story going indefinitely without incurring alot more debt.
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 we will see, as long as we have Nithin Gadkari....We need to pull our middle class to a much larger size that should be very important I think.
India is not China, will never be China. India doesn't want to be China. India is unique, it's diversity is unique, innovation is a deep seated cultural value. India's path to greatness will lie in outthinking the world and getting to the top. India's burgeoning IT Industry is a good example of that. All that India needs to do is to put an end to the conflict within. Let the Govt create the infrastructure and not divide people. India's entrepreneurial mindset will ensure the rest.
Yes, by which time India would have probably broken up into several ethnically or religiously defined countries and China would be a superpower, having take over from the USA.
@@worldwatcher9671 no division of Territory in India is not possible because as we grow modern cultural and language difference becomes less. Right now India is in the situation of China 30 years ago that is divided and religious.but it will take some more time to become that is at least 50 years to cope up with china
@@jaiakash3819 Sorry my friend but be honest. Cultural , linguistic and religious tensions in India are getting WORSE not LESS. Never has hate been so prevalent in the Indian society than now. Unless you (Indian people) kill this hate by kicking out Modi and his extremist Hindu policies of BJP/RSS, India is eventually doomed.
As per the title I was expecting something on the future of India & China...... But in that video everything described except the future...... All u talked about is fact...
India has missed the best time for industrialization. India is now beginning to industrialize. When the industrialization is successful, the United States and China will have become informatized and intelligent. China is undergoing industrial upgrading, realizing intelligent automation of industrial and agricultural industries, further reducing labor costs and improving production efficiency. In the high-tech field, China will stand shoulder to shoulder with the United States in the next 10 years. India looks at the key demographic dividend, which may become a population burden. Without a major change in India, it will be difficult for India to continue to develop, let alone catch up with China. In the next 10 years, China's per capita GDP may reach 20,000 U.S. dollars, and India may only have 5,000 U.S. dollars, and the gap may become wider and wider. The current gap in per capita GDP is 9,000 U.S. dollars, and the gap in the future is 15,000 U.S. dollars.
Most people in our country hardly understand the concept of democracy and though it is the best system of government, Indians have more of factional loyalty. We are a country with several nations in it. It was never bound to work well.
To put it simply, India has a lot of obstacles, and challenges it needs to face and overcome and also needs to make changes to things like it’s infrastructure but with its current growth and development, India does have a bright future. But a lot of work still needs to be done.
For domestic problems China: Yes, how to solve these problems? Immediately convene experts and the masses to hold a discussion meeting. Develop a solution. India: We don’t have any problems. Those who say we have problems are all rumors. How can our great India have problems? We are the world’s largest democracy, we will be the world’s most populous country, we will surpass China, we will surpass the United States, and we will lead the world.
@Varadharajan R Software services come under labor. Without a product, it's not software. It's like mechanic servicing car as opposed to producing a car.
I don't understand why people always want to compare India with China, there is no comparison, one is an apple and another an orange, the culture is different, the type of government is different, the history is different, the demographic, the economy structures are totally different, the only thing that is similar is the size of their populations, Taiwan and Australia has the similar population but you don't see anyone wanting to compare the two.
Before heading to a developed country, India must be able to overcome the middle income trap in the future and politically, must be able to face challenges from western countries which will surely try to prevent India from becoming a developed country at the level of China in the years to come as China is facing now.
I have been discussing this with many Indian friends and I believe that the only way for India to have a bright future is to join hands with China. Without India's support, Sooner or later China will also become a developed world, only need a bit more time. But without China's support, the entire Western world could not allow India to industrialize. This is the nature of the human world which has been revealled by entire history of mankind. Indian government is too short sighted to live in the illusion of self-styled democracy for petty profits from West Wold.
If China has become developed in 20 years, how long will India take? 2 times? Whichbis 40 years? India will be developed with or without China. Look at the world GDP since 1AD till 1700AD - India had larger GDP that China. So history is in our favour , maybe you read CCP curriculum? And btw, when you introduce yourself as "Chinese" to the world, please remember everytime that the name "China" was introduced to the world by your big brother India.
@@sampadmohanty8573 What are you talking about? China used to be father country of most of the 'Indian' tribes before British glued them into one 'country' of British Raj(OK, they cut off Pakistan) for hundreds years of continous fxxk, you still don't have a native Indian language but some tribal language and can't communicate without your master's leftover English. You can include USA 1700AD GDP too they are 'Indian', LOL
There are three things you argument that I don't know Agree. The first one is China is better at software than India the advantage is not dressed in hardware it’s a common sense that India is only known for outsourcing and those surface job from those American companies whereas trainer has a lot of its own companies which have invented their own technologies. For example Ali Baba and Tencent.There isn’t any world famous Hi tech companies from India.As a matter of fact China is probably the only country that’s competing with US in terms of high technology. The second thing is diversity diversity isn’t bad and the problem is not all kind of cities will be excepted worldwide and specifically India’s diversity isn’t really admired and a lot of times it’s being looked down upon so I don’t see that that is a advantage of India. The third point is English there at the millions of Chinese who have studied abroad and even more people who have lived abroad there isn’t a shortage of Chinese people who are proficient in English
China >>> Japan and korea. There are Chinese everywhere, chinatowns in every major city in the world, Chinese have been in usa, Australia, Canada etc since their founding in gold rush days. I don't see any Korean or japanese in Australia, my country, but there are 1 million+ Chinese. Chinese can assimilate and succeed anywhere they migrate or move to. You don't see japanese anywhere in the worl(apart from few in Brazil), or Koreans (apart from few in Japan). But Chinese are everywhere, and always successful and always assimilate and can fit into the new countries cultures.
The biggest difference is India has a culture of being a talker bragging, bullshitting and pleasing the boss, and only talk without getting hands dirty and being proud of that. whereas chinese instead are cultural ly more pround of hard working silently and humbly. If u take a look at Indians and Chinese in silicon valley u will understand it. This simple difference can explain every single fact between the two countries
Many of the big tech CEOs are Indians. Is that talking, bragging, bullshiting or pleasing one's boss. Indians are outspoken but they are hard working and smart. They come from a world of free thinking and not from where they are treated like machines. Clean up your head before talking about anyone.
@@viprp Yes Many of the big tech CEOs are Indians. so what? China has 129 of the world's top 500 enterprises . India has only 7 top 500 companies in the world
simply do a simple math, to show you how it is impossible, China's GDP is $14.72 Trillion, India is $2.632 Trillion 14.72/2.632=5.59 to get to the level of China, assume India with growth rage 1% more than China, that will need 173 year, if 2% more than China, that will take 86.5 years, 4% more than China, it will take 43.3 year, 8% more than China, that will take 21 year, etc, Assume China growth rate is 5%, India growth keeps at 6%, India will get the same amount of GDP of China in 173 years. the reality is , India growth in 2021 predicted will be 8.4%, but growth at 2020 was -7.3%, so for 2 years, it is (-7.3 + 8.4 )/ 2 = 0.5%. China in 2020 growth was 2.2 and 2021 (predicted) 6 %, so for 2 years, (2.2+6)/2= 4.1%, China growth is 4.1-0.5=3.6% more than India,
This came across as a solid attempt at being impartial, well-informed and attempting to provide at least some positives from both parties. All-in-all, great commentary. Thank you.
We are actually doing things together, indian engineers are working with Chinese automotive counterparts. One of the areas I know in which they are Co-operating. However with global geopolitical change i see it changing slowly.
Chinese new skyscrapers and infrastructures did not get build overnight. You can accomplish those as long you strive and plan towards the goal no matter how long it takes.
If ever learned about macroecon, poorer countries have higher growth rates. TBH India is 1/5 to China's gdp, so it has a long long way to go. What I believe decides the country's future is always technology and education. India has great IT people and engineers, current layback isn't forever.
I disagree with you in the start but your were right in other points, China invested heavily in manufacturing but they didn't ignore their agriculture sector but if you think should leapfrog it's way from agriculture centric to high technology without going through low level manufacturing with its base weak, India is huge country with strong population so here are the point which needs to be thought of - 1. This hugh population needs employment whereas high tech sector is more demanded on skilled labour and automation for efficiency. If you are aware about India's education it has highest number of engineering graduates who are not skilled enough with this advancing market. 2. With today's geopolitical affair it is very important to be self sufficient, otherwise you are only looking to get strong armed by rich countries and their sanctions.
as a Chinese, I do not want India compares with China, I actually don't want my country compares with any other countries but our self, the yestoday China. I think India should compares with America.
Chinese are also good at building healthcare and education resources for its citizens... apart from industrialization. Has world view... Human values... Helping poor countries in Africa.... And other Asian countries.... Law and order bigger issue in India.
India is ahead of software than CHINA? You are kidding right? Your maybe basing it on BPOs or outsourcing industry which not really entirely equates to software. Based on data alone, CHINA's software industry alone is about at least 400B USD that is about 4x whole india's IT industry. Not to mention, CHINA has gaming & internet industries & services which mostly their exports IT services. Largest gaming company in the world is Tencent, Ant Financial is the world's most valuble startup, Alibaba and its subsidiary is dominating not only in CHINA but also in Southeast Asia, Africa and even india thru paytm. Tech scene in CHINA is now rivaling the west, no wonder why trump is so keen to ban and maligning CHINA's tech companies and related businesses like TikTok, WeChat and even Zoom. 🙄
Very interesting comparison between China and India. At the same time, the relation between hardware and software. He is more cautious about projecting the relationship between the two countries in future.
"Indians had several century tradition of using English as a native language"?? Since when was that? I've never (really never) came across a native Indian with native mastery of the English language, not even close. I suspect Indians may also have a misconception of what being a native speaker of a language means. An anecdote was when I came across an Indian university graduate who indicated in her resume that she is a "native" speaker of English but alas, she in no way spoke or use words a native English speaker would, not even taking into account the very strong Indian accent that she had.
Throughout 5000 years of history China had numerous inventions and scientific discoveries beside the well known four great inventions. What about comparable inventions has India? Culture and tradition and
If India can work with China, the west dominance will end faster. But it is just wishful thinking. The west has the best understanding of how to divide and rule.
India's territory claim is based British colonial expansion, those areas never part of historical India. When Brits left, Burma & Pak reasonably realigned the border with China. But India insisted on grabbing every single inch which led to war. China won, but retreated, preferred diplomatic solution. Who's the greedy land robber? You can never have reasonable debate with Indians, they have no honor, no respect for facts and logic.
Software industry can't lift millions out of poverty like hardware manufacturing can do because working in software and computing industry requires highly educated and skilled workers which are few in India hence it will deepen the income divide in India I want India to develop pharmaceutical industry which is something India can easily excel in and dominate
I have been to India. I don’t understand people’s obsession of China/India comparison. The two countries are diversely different, for India, they need to figure out their own way of development, instead of copycat everything China did because they might not repeat the same success of China, e.g. the world factory.
If I were an Indian I would feel ashamed to compare India with China. The gap in every sector of the two countries where China is very far ahead is just too wide to mention and more so to even want to compare. Please do not ever bring up this subject of comparison again. If you do, it shows you have been living in the jungle for the past 30 years. ndia cannot even build enough toilet as a human basic right for his people as the link provide here {what a shame} #opendefecation Latest report from IMF on China contribution to the world economy.According to the IMF’s World Economic Outlook (WEO) report in October, global economic output is forecast to expand by 3% this year, to which China is expected to contribute 0.9 percentage point, Barnett said. He made the remarks at a launch of the publication in Beijing last Friday. The event was organised by the IMF Resident Representative Office in China and the International Monetary Institute at the Renmin University of China. By comparison, the United States is forecast to contribute 0.3 percentage point while India’s contribution might be 0.5 percentage point, Barnett told China Daily on the sidelines of the event. On 2024, China is forecast to contribute 0.8 percentage point of the 2.9% global growth, just under one-third and still higher than 0.2 percentage point of the United States and 0.5 percentage point of India, he said. The WEO, published lastTuesday, has lowered the 2023 economic growth forecast for China to 5% from 5.2%, citing the pressures brought by the weakness in the real estate sector
Imho, the main, insurmountable obstacle of India to compete with China is its deep religiosity ... Religions are irrational: None is based in logic, common sense, rational arguments China's keys to current success: 1. Its non-religiosity 2. Ethical confucian upbringing, both for family and society 3. Millennia of socio-political learning process, with many ups and downs 4. Social cohesion provided by basically same language and writing for millennia.
No we just use them for scapegoats. Main reasons are: 1) policy paralysis & slow bureaucracy 2) poor infrastructure and slow logistics 3) education without real skills
I'm working with many talents in India. India has good & skilled talents. But the problem is mindset, risk taking. Untill and unless this changes, India can't improve.
All you said is 100% true. But to become like China or any other developed Western countries, there are many aspects which have to be taken into consideration, because of which India still lags behind and will be lagging behind in the future. The main reason behind India lagging behind is lack of innovative minds, bookish knowledge never gonna help them to become like China unless you have a creative mindset. Another important reason is, India may overcome corruption at some point but there is hardly any possibility of overcoming inequalities and intolerance.
No need to compare. India doesnt have what it takes to compare with the world's beater - in its rising economic and military superpower - the X factor. It's its people and ethos , wrought by centuries of both wars and wisdom that sharpen em like you put a blunt tool to the grinder. What didnt kill em have em evolved with so much resilience and enterprising , the spirit of the fittest and cohesiveness of society that manifested itself against the best - given the right government ie the leadership glue that directs and propels em upwards.
@Fahim Rahman you can move out from India its quite easy,.go to either Bangladesh, srilanka, Nepal, Myanmar, Vietnam or Philippines they don't have much restrictions. All the best man.
The highest export of Chinese goods to India is less than US $90 billion a year, accounting for 1.2% of China's export. In 2019, India's exports to China accounted for 5.3% of India's total exports. If Hong Kong is added, the ratio will reach 9%. Who do you think is hurt by mutual resistance?
@@sharduldiwan2009 china has a communist party which makes it easy for them to make democracy on the other hand India is the largest domeocracy and you know india is blessed with such good Neighbour "pakistan" Which helps India so much 😂😂
2:40 Your comparison and argument here is so naive and irrational. Why are you comparing Indian App ecosystem with China's deep tech? As long as we are doing comparisons here, there are various Indian Deep Tech services and Unicorn companies who provide and manufacture "Drones" and even "Robots" and that too on a large scale. I can even show the stats and source if ya want. Please look into topics before stating an opinion.
I think you are right , the biggest problem india faces right now is poor infrastructure that's true 100 percent I agree, but there is also a huge problem regarding religion, I won't blame it all on british, caste system is still exist in india, india is so diverse, I can't explain it in words as I am indian too, I think first we have to make changes in our ethics the work force, the way we work, the way our school system is designed,they teach us to get a better job, not to open our own business,I think we have to redesign our education system, it should more engaging,"India is poor but not poor" Try to understand this statement india is the most corrupted country in the world , poor is getting poorer and richer is getting more richer and that is the fact, first we have to kickout those corruped officals, BJP is the most corrupted party in the world, we should have expert who should handle the government, not the criminals, corrupted officers. That's my point of view
Buddy, he made this video on the request of China Mobile. It’s biased in china’s favor. China has a horrible future as it ages critically. Don’t worry, India is growing naturally. Democracies naturally progress and communism and oppression naturally does off. So don’t worry. China doesn’t have a future.
The three major obstacles to India’s economic growth are Corruption, Religious divide and Caste system. It is easy to get rid of corruptions. The other two, insurmountable!!
It is important to note Chinese gdp was 2.3 trillion 15 years back In 2021 for india it's 3 trillion so yah there are things comparable (even if we take account of surplus population 1.2-1.3 china 2005 & India's 1.4 billion 2021) Morever India being an open market it might catch up sooner And looking at ground increments i.e.- Foreign direct investment rose 10% from 2019 & in 2020 even under covid stood at 81 billion $ Reason Earlier every govs used to focuse only on agri but from past 2 terms drastic developments are made in Infrastructure , Policies , foreign co-operation thanks to pro-industrialist centre Not even that But it's need for Korea, Japan & west to diversify investment than segregating in China As it's backfiring in form of aggression In this chaos India is becoming a prominent option Which they are heavily considering too Looking at the •Japan's huge investment in indian infrastructure •Initiation of development for India-Australia-Japan supply chain •Return Talks for EU-India free trade agreement (which hopefully & most likely be successful) For upcoming •Greater push in Infrastructure from B3W
Very sensible post and numbers put things in perspective. We might take longer or might get there sooner, but the point is we can get there in a couple of decades with concerted efforts or not get there at all if some unruly elements sabotage our growth with insurgencies etc.
Lol India is not an open market. Even now India refuse to join RCEP and other free trade agreements, still very protectionist. It cannot match china if it doesn't open up and welcome foreign investment. Also, unelss India imorove relations with china, and continues to ban Chinese investment, then it will never be able to replicate china's rise since china will be the number 1 economy by 2027-8. That would be the same as if china banned usa from investment in the 90/00s. Also, by 2040-2050 china's economy will be double usas basically, so it will be even worse for India if they don't embrace Chinese investment or Chinese market.
India has caste system where 15% uppercaste people don't want to share resources with 85% population of lower caste people and Minorities. That's the main problem.
Dude India was a large economy before British came. Then also we have caste amd religion problems. Then why was our economy so large. Ofcourse we need to improve social equality but that isn't the reason for slow economic growth. Main reasons are: 1) policy paralysis & slow bureaucracy 2) poor infrastructure and slow logistics 3) education without real skills.
The first thing india has to do is stop reacting to everything that happens in the USA. That's so so stupid of us to get fever if US sneezes.
Kehna kiya cahte ho
@Tech Gyan ab tum kiya keh rhe ho
@@sparkly3989 Samajhdar to isara kaafi
Indian stock market is heavily influence by American investor.
I want to say that democracy is the problem of Indian. China's success is mainly due to its unique efficient system. But then I thought every people has their own tradition and way of organize their society. It is that the Chinese think for their own and come up their own way of development but India can't.
India need to change it's labor and land reforms and also bureaucratic system
Labor reforms.✔
I think the biggest problem which needs to be changed is the political system in India. India has big potential but the political system stops it.
@@hotchi1566 Its not just about political system ..In a democracy its not easy to make changes , unlike in a totalitarian regime .
@@Galavya41 The objective of democracy is to make changes to meet the people's demands. Otherwise, democracy makes no sense.
@@hotchi1566 In a democracy you cant just force anything ...changes takes time as naturally there are different groups . Let me give you an example . In my city last year the Govt. had decided to clear a small area of forested land for the construction of a shed for the Metro trains ....Now as soon as news of this was heard by some ' Nature Loving ' people a big protest was arranged and they took the matter to court ( In India once any issue is taken up by the judiciary and is pending for hearing the Govt. cannot do anything as far as that particular subject matter is concerned ) ...Later the courts did allow the Govt. to construct the shed there as the small forested area was just too small to be categorized under forests hence the Law which orders the Govt. to protect the forests was not applicable there and more importantly the land was legally owned by the railways anyway ...So the railways was able to construct a shed there BUT do you know how long it took ..Almost two years ...Something which would had been completed in six months took two years to finish and for that the entire Metro rail construction had to suffer as well . This is what happens .
India is hopelessly divided, also western world will not allow an other country with size of China to rise again, they have no more job to give. I have been to India many many times, love the country and people, every intellectual I met with in India can list all the issues India facing, no one has solutions.
Democracy is not good for a developing country like india
@@harshitkapoor1909 It should be "democracy is not good for EVERY developing country due to low efficiency"
@@harshitkapoor1909 we don't want to be communist
@@user-xu6zu5ym8u India doesnt need communism but needs a good ,efficienf and clean dictator. And i know many people dont want to hear it
@@user-xu6zu5ym8u
There is no true communist country. It's more of a socialist country and with "Chinese characteristics" as the Chinese often project themselves. This idea for a revamp of their system stemmed from Deng Xiaopeng's visit to Singapore in 1979.
After years of trials and errors and much tweaking, the Chinese govt managed to alleviate hardcore poverty for 700-800 million of its population. The Chinese are not saying that this system is the greatest and that it works for every country and definitely has no plans to shove it down the throat of other countries.
Someone in this comment section mentioned that China is no angel...and i agree. Each country works primarily to serve its own interests and China's interests are simple; to have food on the tables of each household and a roof over their heads. Once these 2 basic needs are satisfied would only then you have a stable society. And we have seen what progress can be achieved with a stable society.
China send their best to universities abroad and come back home.
While India goes overseas and never return this is why China has the startup companies like the U.S.
who want to get home when there a lot of shitz💩💩 in India
@@JoanFortnite-jh1oz there is shit filled in your mind and u hold a lot of prejudice against India, india is world's software and it hub.
@@ninadkadam8570 it is all theoritical things bro... See our education system... Dont compare USA with india... They are 1000 miles ahead ... Its actually USA who should be proud that they are helping the brilliant indians for success..... And those brilliant indians are doing and contributing for the whole world....... Everybody has their own dreams
true☹
@@JoanFortnite-jh1oz ☹ we are behind china cause of leadership
I made this 1.5x faster. Try it. 😉😊
It works for me!
2x
It works.
Thanks bro 😊
it works
IMO China is not only a decade ahead of India, they are also progressing faster through aggressive modernization of every aspects of their lives, governance and technology.
5 decades
2-3 decades
Actually its was going to war with America, india and othe big country. And when war broke out china was badly destroy by these country
@@vivek__sharma u mean india was destroy by western powers and rules like slaves
China is many decades ahead of India.
"Lagging about a decade behind China in basics like ..."
Not a decade behind. At least five.
INDIA IS NOT A COUNTRY.IT IS GROUP OF COUNTRIES PUT TO GETHER BY BRITAIN. EVERY STATE IN INDIA IS A COUNTRY IN IT SELF.
This is the only honest and true description of India I have read from an Indian. I fully agree with it.
@Nikhil Gihar I think that is the beauty of my nation also in vid he left some points like india has support of US European powers quad while world is turning against china examples of antiasian incidents are increasing
US and these countries will try to deaccelerate China's growth because US will not allow any other country to take its status of super power
Also for india the thing u mentioned Britain gave a super tool to us the power of language
Also india is a democracy western countries will try to stop the rise of a communist nation which was all the cause for which cold war happened
But according to me most probably two blocks will be formed in future with China Russia and other side western powers and then the stance of india will be important of course this will happen after a decade in late 2030s i guess if india remained non aligned it will be great but i think at that time if india chose china asia will be united for first time if india chose US which I think will happen world will see another cold war
@@worldwatcher9671
I fully agree with you
@@worldwatcher9671 back again supporting a break India perspective. Not surprising. Lol.
No it's not. Old Vedic scriptures describes the geography of India from the stretch of Himalayas to the forests of South. Your statement is naive and ignorant.
The following is what I borrowed from a Malaysian UA-camr’s comment:
I’m from Malaysia. China has traded with Malaysia for 2000 years. In those years, they had been the world’s biggest powers many times. Never once they sent troops to take our land. Admiral Zhenghe came to Malacca five times, in gigantic fleets, and a flagship eight times the size of Christopher Columbus’ flagship, Santa Maria. He could have seized Malacca easily, but he did not. In 1511, the Portuguese came. In 1642, the Dutch came. In the 18th century the British came. We were colonised by each, one after another.
When China wanted spices from India, they traded with the Indians. When they wanted gems, they traded with the Persian. They didn’t take lands. The only time China expanded beyond their current borders was in Yuan Dynasty, when Genghis and his descendants Ogedei Khan, Guyuk Khan & Kublai Khan concurred China, Mid Asia and Eastern Europe. But Yuan Dynasty, although being based in China, was a part of the Mongolian Empire.
Then came the Century of Humiliation. Britain smuggled opium into China to dope the population, a strategy to turn the trade deficit around, after the British could not find enough silver to pay the Qing Dynasty in their tea and porcelain trades. After the opium warehouses were burned down and ports were closed by the Chinese in ordered to curb opium, the British started the Opium War I, which China lost. Hong Kong was forced to be surrendered to the British in a peace talk (Nanjing Treaty). The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron. The remaining 10% was owned by American merchants from Boston. Many of Boston’s institutions were built with profit from opium.
After 12 years of Nanjing Treaty, the West started getting really really greedy. The British wanted the Qing government:
1. To open the borders of China to allow goods coming in and out freely, and tax free.
2. Make opium legal in China.
Insane requests, Qing government said no. The British and French (with supports from the US), started Opium War II with China, which again, China lost. The Anglo-French military raided the Summer Palace, and threatened to burn down the Imperial Palace, the Qing government was forced to pay with ports, free business zones, 300,000 kilograms of silver and Kowloon was taken. Since then, China’s resources flew out freely through these business zones and ports. In the subsequent amendment to the treaties, Chinese people were sold overseas to serve as labor.
In 1900, China suffered attacks by the 8-National Alliance (Empire of Japan, Russian Empire, British Empire (including India), France, USA, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary). Innocent Chinese civilians in Peking (Beijing now) were murdered, buildings were destroyed & women were raped. The Imperial Palace was raided, and treasures ended up in museums like the British Museum in London and the Louvre in Paris.
In late 1930s China was occupied by the Japanese in WWII. Millions of Chinese died during the occupancy. 300,000 Chinese died in Nanjing Massacre alone.
Mao brought China together again from the shambles. There were peace and unity for some time. But Mao’s later reign saw sufferings and deaths from famine and power struggles.
Then came Deng Xiao Ping and his infamous “black-cat and white-cat” story. His preference in pragmatism than ideologies has transformed China. This thinking allowed China to evolve all the time to adapt to the actual needs in the country, instead of rigidly bounded to ideologies. It also signified the death of Communism in actually practice in China. The current Socialism+Meritocracy+Market Economy model fits the Chinese like gloves, and it propels the uprise of China. Singapore has a similar model, and has been arguably more successful than Hong Kong, because Hong Kong being gateway to China, was riding on the economic boom in China, while Singapore had no one to gain from.
In just 30 years, the CPC have moved 800 millions of people out from poverty. The rate of growth is unprecedented in human history. They have built the biggest mobile network, by far the biggest high speed rail network in the world, and they have become a behemoth in infrastructure. They made a fishing village called Shenzhen into the world’s second largest technological centre after the Silicon Valley. They are growing into a technological power house. It has the most elaborate e-commerce and cashless payment system in the world. They have launched exploration to Mars. The Chinese are living a good life and China has become one of the safest countries in the world. The level of patriotism in the country has reached an unprecedented height.
For all of the achievements, the West has nothing good to say about it. China suffers from intense anti-China propagandas from the West. Western Media used the keyword “Communist” to instil fear and hatred towards China.
Everything China does is negatively reported.
They claimed China used slave labor in making iPhones. The truth was, Apple was the most profitable company in the world, it took most of the profit, leave some to Foxconn (a Taiwanese company) and little to the labor.
They claimed China was inhuman with one-child policy. At the same time, they accused China of polluting the earth with its huge population. The fact is the Chinese consume just 30% of energy per capita compared to the US.
Minorities in China
Show me any currency in the world which also prints the language of its ethinc minorities. Chinese bank notes show 5 languages of 5 minorities living in China, including Tibetan and Uyghur.
They claimed China underwent ethnic cleansing in Xinjiang. The fact is China has a policy which priorities ethnic minorities. For a long time, the ethnic minorities were allowed to have two children and the majority Han only allowed one. The minorities are allowed a lower score for university intakes. Muslims students get Halal food at the university cafeteria. There are 39,000 mosque in China, and 2100 in the US. China has about 3 times more mosque per muslim than the US.
When terrorist attacks happened in Xinjiang, China had two choices:
1. Re-educate the Uighur extremists before they turned terrorists.
2. Let them be, after they launch attacks and killed innocent people, bomb their homes.
China chose 1 to solve problem from the root and not to do killing. How the US solve terrorism? Fire missiles from battleships, drop bombs from the sky.
During the pandemic,
When China took extreme measures to lockdown the people, they were accused of being inhuman.
When China recovered swiftly because of the extreme measures, they were accused of lying about the actual numbers.
When China’s cases became so low that they could provide medical support to other countries, they were accused of politically motivated.
Western Media always have reasons to bash China.
Just like any country, there are irresponsible individuals from China which do bad and dirty things, but the China government overall has done very well. But I hear this comment over and over by people from the West: I like Chinese people, but the CPC is evil. What they really want is the Chinese to change the government, because the current one is too good.
Fortunately China is not a multi-party democratic country, otherwise the opposition party in China will be supported by notorious NGOs (Non-Government Organization) of the USA, like the NED (National Endowment for Democracy), to topple the ruling party. The US and the British couldn’t crack Mainland China, so they work on Hong Kong. Of all the ex-British colonial countries, only the Hong Kongers were offered BNOs by the British. Because the UK would like the Hong Kongers to think they are British citizens, not Chinese. A divide-and-conquer strategy, which they often used in Color Revolutions around the world.
They resort to low dirty tricks like detaining Huawei’s CFO & banning Huawei. They raised a silly trade war which benefits no one. Trade deficit always exist between a developing and a developed country. USA is like a luxury car seller who ask a farmer: why am I always buying your vegetables and you haven’t bought any of my cars?
When the Chinese were making socks for the world 30 years ago, the world let it be. But when Chinese started to make high technology products, like Huawei and DJI, it caused red-alert. Because when Western and Japanese products are equal to Chinese in technologies, they could never match the Chinese in prices. First world countries want China to continue in making socks. Instead of stepping up themselves, they want to pull China down.
The recent movement by the US against China has a very important background. When Libya, Iran, and China decided to ditch the US dollar in oil trades, Gaddafi’s was killed by the US, Iran was being sanctioned by the US, and now it’s China’s turn. The US has been printing money out of nothing. The only reason why the US Dollar is still widely accepted, is because it’s the only currency which oil is allowed to be traded with. The US has an agreement with Saudi that oil must be traded in US dollar ONLY. Without the petrol-dollar status, the US dollars will sink, and America will fall. Therefore anyone trying to disobey this order will be eliminated. China will soon use a gold-backed crypto-currency, the alarms in the White House go off like mad.
China’s achievements and success have been by hard work. Not by looting and plundering the world.
I have deep respect and love for China for all the suffering and the hardship they endured, but now I feel happy for them. China is not rising, they are going back to where they belong. Good luck China.
--Nihilist
Well said!!!!
I just have one question to u
For all ur lecture
Why china has border dispute with so many countries? Including India..why did it occupy Tibet illegally.. why do they claim India's land as it's own and refuse to follow Internationally established boundaries?
@@ms.dentist Similar to the US involvement in Ukraine, the Russia would never have conflicts with Ukraine. The CIA involved in Tibet. China had to stop the US occupation in that region. And Dalai Lama was on the CIA payroll. The chaos was created by the CIA. In regards to India & China the conflict always involve both sides. You need to check out from the India’ side of the story too. Back to Tibet they have more freedom than even in the West. They even have the bullet train that some Western countries do not have😉
@@jng4880 Dalai Lama was on CIA payroll.. really? First of all.. Tibet was an independent nation..for all the development..did china had any right to occupy it in the first place?
And the border dispute is not only with India..but japan, Phillipines, Vietnam, and soo many more
I mean with every nation china has border dispute.
India on the other hand..has border dispute only with china
And not other neighbours
@@jng4880 i really want to understand China's perspective
But when i see my map and Aksai chin that china illegally occupied when our prime minister trusted china..makes me loose all empathy with them..they are still trying to add more land.. continue their expansionist policy
Why??? Why not let neighbours live peacefully and develop together?
Why to blame America when it was China that took a part of India in 1962 war
Chinese here now living in Canada. I don't like that Chinese talk ill about Indians and vice versa! both countries have great culture and long traditions. Respect each other and build a symbiotic relationship is the way to go~ no war , no American kind BS~
I also bro
I'm an Indian and I don't like people saying bad about China
Love from India
couldn't agree more as an Indian in fact India and china have a lot in common in terms of culture and civilization and can work really well together, they can seriously challenge neocolonial ecosystem, if not much they should at least work together in historical social sciences and cultural front in terms of decolonizing the discourse in these streams within academia media public etc.
Exactly. The people of china and India are not to blame but the government of china is very provocative. Occupying lands of their neighbours for absolutely no reason and for being expansive to almost everyone is dangerous. I hope democracy can return to China and future can be bright for the people of both nations.
@@sarthakpathania and plz keep your so-called democracy , ur so-called democracy is just a placebo that makes u little bit better.
@ yes India's democracy is flawed. It's not perfect but all i did was criticise CCP which is very bad for China and Chinese people. But I guess if you know better then good day ahead.
India need to do it the old fashion way like everyone else... develop the physical manufacturing before going into services. Back to fundamentals.
You are very very right that can solve it s jobs problem and we need it for Indian market for exports MNCs can help with automation so that when employment problem solves full scale automation could be switched over
True .
Very difficult with high degree of automation in industry. But wholly necessarily none the less.
It doesn't works that way ppl will run where money is and it's in software. Plus manufacturing in India has issues.
to compare India with China is like comparing Haiti with US. the best discussion on India vs. China is from Jayant Bhandari who gives the most insightful analysis on this topic.
@Jazz24
You are absolutely correct..!!!
India politicians should learn from ASEAN countries, do not always considered itself is always right, other is wrong
Question: What was China's GDP in 2006?
Chinese living overseas bashed china back then and thought it would never succeed. It is fashionable to bash your country of origin. Self criticism is important but self deprecation is unhealthy.
@@uvg319 exactly!!! Our economic fate depends on the work we do in the coming 10 yrs
@@uvg319 Chinese overseas you knew were Taiwaneses i think. There are millions of Chinese overseas around the world including Asean, Europe and America
Jayant Bhandari speaks just bullshit. I know India is way behind China and isn't going to grow as fast as China. But the reasons Jayant Bhandari gives are bullshit. He is just trying to make Indians sign RCEP nothing else.
I am Indian and we love China and the Chinese people.
May God shower blessing on them!
As a Chinese,I hope India and China can work together to make asia great!
@@likevin3087 honestly I don't think our countries can become ally but atleast we have to make sure our conflicts doesn't grow much that west can take advantage of it to maintain their hegemony.
Chinese have a view of what they want to be.... India struggling in this domain.
CCP is more a nationalist party than a communist one. That said, the communism is a key element of the CCP. Check out how CCP has done to lift poorest Chinese out of poverty: ua-cam.com/video/k24-ZhKGjnI/v-deo.html.
@@cheval63sg Yeah they are nationalists.
Summing up his talk: India and China should team up. Cooperate instead of compete. India needs to remove bureaucratic bottlenecks and improve infrastructure
Healthy competition is good for both countries. And India also needs to focussing on shifting people out of agricultural jobs.
Get the rich indians to drop their ego first, To China India is not a competitor at all and also dont wish to wake indians up knowing india have great potential 😁. So hilarious to this date ppl still wanna compares India to China. The day will come when India start to show great advancements to beat USA, history will repeat itself like what happen to Japan France and now S.Korea & Taiwan both need to basically surrender all their knowhow n tech (Samsung&TSMC) to USA. USA tried on Huawei but fail simply because China dare to stand up and say fxxk off will India dare or have the power to say no when the time comes? So sometime is better to go slow till the bully is out of the picture.
@@alvino2211 you can see the future...India and china should have more and more cooperation,not the vicious competition . May we can find the problem if the GDP of india reach to 40% of usa.
@@alvino2211 , are you saying India cannot "sit" until US say so? 😁 Sounds like US will never allow India to beat US to be the 2nd largest economy globally.
@@alvino2211 india will NEVER really develop. they've been saying saying the same things for 40 years.
How does India hold a significant lead in software over China when it doesn't even have its own big websites? Among other applications like gadgets, vehicles, and robots.
India has its software... But those softwares are small and made by the guidelines.... In india innovation is almost 0 .... And in harware and electronics.... Forget china and usa... We are not even a cup of tea to taiwan, Vietnam hong kong also
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 The main problem is lack of interest and funding for research and our education system. Our education system was framed in British era by Sir Macaulay who stated that India should have a utilitarian system of education which simply means a system in which there's no questioning and one should just focus on what's the input and output of a thing so yup it's a mistake at our behalf to not to change the system even after this long.
@@harinramesh3468 those indian companies you've mentioned worked for clients. they don't create innovation or R&D. the are the back office for US and European companies. FB & Google contributed a lot to tech world. creating new frameworks, standards and tools for other IT companies
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 the problem is we have nowhere close to the number of users for those websites other nations do. Compare the number of e commerce consumers in other countries to those on India on a percentage basis.
We actually develop and sell alot of software to all the countries you mentioned.
I think ban the Facebook UA-cam Google in Indian to improve software skills. India have more population that can become a super internet market.
In US, more Indian work for US internet company, but they didn't get the better salary. In future ，I hope to see India Google Apple Tesla
Having been to India, I think they had massive potential but couldn't control their population growth unlike China. I forsee a massive problem in the future in India because of their population with no real apparent solution. The worst feature of India is that the rich try and insulate themselves from the concerns of the poor (the vast majority) so they see no reason to change the current situation for the average person, if that continues India is in for massive trouble.
Get ready to see a lot of indians in your country as refugees in future
@@aalhadbapat3489 Sadly the doors will be shut pretty quickly. We can only hope that Indian leaders start looking after their people, not just themselves and provide a decent life for the majority. The world needs India to get it together ASAP.
@@aalhadbapat3489 The West is collapsing. Too much immigration, cultural collapse, crime, collapse of families, ghetto behaviour. West is becoming third world.
@@mudra5114 oh really... Maybe its not all of the countries..... They will never collapse... Cauz people are hardworking ... People are self confident... I mean look at those little little sized countries eh.... Germany, France,UK .... And in northern side sweden and scandinavian countries are on the rise...... See their healthcare... See their education system mate
@@sparksmacoy your sweet fantasy of immigrants completely stopping going to Europe will not materalise the world leaders has realised that this crisis has to be solved and especially the European leaders are really good there already thousands of Indians going to Canada Russia USA Japan uae to escape poverty.
India just needs time , give it that and it will rise .
40 years is not enough ? Maybe another 4000 years ?
Yes, in a 1000 years it will rise.
@Ninja Star Teah I was optimistic. 2000 years.
@@geoprzm4488 be patience
@@geoprzm4488 we were so rich that Britishers needed 200 year... To loot India... And u r saying to regain that in 40years... 😂😂😂
Well, this year India has added more startups than China yet it's 16 whereas in overall before 2021 India had 28 even tho China has thousand times startups than India. This shows we are moving in a great direction also the infra has majorly improved especially in Urban areas.
The government needs to pull up a major campaign for modernizing the agriculture system here. Where China needs 2 employees in the farming sector India needs 20.
Another thing that can be done is skill development Indian engineers are called that they aren't skilled enough to be competing with any engineer from developed nations. The great thing is that just 6-8 months of training is enough to make them skilled as they already have theoretical knowledge. Those people from the farming sector can easily be pushed into manufacturing if govt supports them.
In India women employees are decreasing day by day previously total of 10-12% women used to work outside but it has come down to 6% in 2021 95% of women in India aren't self-dependent that's literally half of India's population sitting at home where has over 90% of women in China works. India needs to stop seeing the modern world as a sin or curse. Most of the women want to work but culture forces them to take care of their child at home if we push and accept babysitting as something good then not just mothers but other women who will work as a baby sitter can get jobs. Sorry to say but Indian culture has a huge toxic part due to which we aren't able to grow as fast and that's also the reason why so many of Indians leave the country and never come back.
Most logical comment I have seen yet
Those are very good points to add
Lmaooo
The startups only help top 1% at ground level India is as poor as ever, infrastructure hasn't 'majorly' improved, agriculture stops India from relying too much on global supplies hence India is actually helping the world through the food shortage we're going through right now, training engineers is optimistic at best and daydream at worst and finally the biggest reason why the West is going through this moral crisis with both fall of Christianity, rise of SJW and fall of functional literacy down to 60% all which is more than enough to destroy civilization is mothers not being there for their children. It's the biggest experiment in human history where an entire generation was raised without the affection required for a healthy life and we're seeing results as SJW demands individuals-with-penises-identifying-as-female to give access to the private space of individuals-with-vaginas.
Overall, I'm glad you're not running India.
Please study Jayant Bhandari he is greater than Chanakya
The future of india depended on the calibre of future leaders who must be dedicated and focused on the country's development..they must be corruption free and law abiding..
Imagine watch this video 10 years later. He probably gonna say the same thing again in his new video 10 years later.
😂😂😂😂😂 you're probably right. We would have made some leaps forwards and some backwards by then.
India has a lead in software development ? Only if all the Chinese E-commerce platforms & apps were done by India, otherwise China is way ahead of India in software.
Both India and China are great countries and can co-exist and work together in a win-win situation. India will catch up quickly due to demographic dividend.
USA will never allow that scenario
@@badbad-cat It is already doing so with the Quad, turning India and China as rivals instead of partners.
The US just wouldn't like to see Russia, India & China as partners and allies.
@Vajra 21 I don't know the details of what really happened in this part of Indya, so I cannot reply to your question.
@Vajra 21 Did I say that? The Quad was created by the US to counter & prevent the rise of Chyna. Indya is part of the Quad. Do you think the intention of the Quad is to promote the cooperation & friendship between these countries?
@Vajra 21 Yep, Indy-a and Chy-na have unresolved issues.
Ofcourse india cannot be compared to China economically.....3trillion vs 14 trillion ...huge difference.
The Indian government counts cow dung into GDP
@@祖宗-e5o please keep revising your dead soldiers until it's real numbers...
@@RohitSingh-my7kw please keep revising your dead soldiers until it's real numbers...
@stop looking here I don't have a name 哈哈哈 India No.1
@stop looking here I don't have a name hahaha ,India No.1 dead people corona country ,well done
Experts feel that it takes about 150 years for India to reach the economic standards of China... with the present rate of growth of the two countries
No David... Not possible in 150yrs also, it is not possible. It is like a joke where the girl is 1 year older than the guy and the guy says I will wait 1 year to get married with you.. In 150 yrs china will also move on 150 yrs ahead.
India's present rate of growth is below China's. So basically, never.
Kevin, you have mentioned a decade here and a decade there on many areas of infra, edu, etc... to be realistic, a democratic parliament can only pass a big project once every few years. Only if the next government after elections do not cancel or modify the previous projects.. all the decades mentioned is about 100 years in total..🤣 🤣
Maybe not a 100 but at the rate we're going certainly more than 10. Surprisingly many big projects have been passed(and many concluded) by our current govt. The problem at current levels of taxation is we can't keep the growth story going indefinitely without incurring alot more debt.
Zyada ud mat hawa main
@@uvg319 nothing will happen chill😂
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 we will see, as long as we have Nithin Gadkari....We need to pull our middle class to a much larger size that should be very important I think.
@@uvg319 take a chill pill he is not a Chinese cause no Chinese can speak English. There's no English school in China😃😃😃😃😃
I predict food security will become a great issue in this century and I still hope India pays much attention to agriculture
We need to worry about water reforms and power reforms before worrying about agricultural reforms in the way popular imagination conjures them.
@@uvg319 Yes
We just need to stop export of some commodities simple as that.
India is a food surplus country
We export billion dollars of food
There's no possible comparison between both countries...
India is not China, will never be China. India doesn't want to be China.
India is unique, it's diversity is unique, innovation is a deep seated cultural value.
India's path to greatness will lie in outthinking the world and getting to the top. India's burgeoning IT Industry is a good example of that.
All that India needs to do is to put an end to the conflict within.
Let the Govt create the infrastructure and not divide people.
India's entrepreneurial mindset will ensure the rest.
It will take India at least 100 yrs to be in position China right now
Yes, by which time India would have probably broken up into several ethnically or religiously defined countries and China would be a superpower, having take over from the USA.
@@worldwatcher9671 no division of Territory in India is not possible because as we grow modern cultural and language difference becomes less. Right now India is in the situation of China 30 years ago that is divided and religious.but it will take some more time to become that is at least 50 years to cope up with china
@@jaiakash3819 Sorry my friend but be honest. Cultural , linguistic and religious tensions in India are getting WORSE not LESS. Never has hate been so prevalent in the Indian society than now. Unless you (Indian people) kill this hate by kicking out Modi and his extremist Hindu policies of BJP/RSS, India is eventually doomed.
@Yash Chaudhary OK Yash, you believe what you want. After all its your funeral !
@Yash Chaudhary Now Indians have started aping America so much that their English has been corrupted to "Dude" and "bro" slangs ! LOL
As per the title I was expecting something on the future of India & China...... But in that video everything described except the future......
All u talked about is fact...
Because he didn't see any changes in the future
@@MrPathorock What does that even mean?
@lost world But India is continuously leaping though? I don't understand what you meant....
@@madrexertheboredtm7728 So cruel. but LMAO.
@@madrexertheboredtm7728 Says a Dhruv Rathee fan lol
India is still living with the colonial mind set
India has missed the best time for industrialization. India is now beginning to industrialize. When the industrialization is successful, the United States and China will have become informatized and intelligent.
China is undergoing industrial upgrading, realizing intelligent automation of industrial and agricultural industries, further reducing labor costs and improving production efficiency. In the high-tech field, China will stand shoulder to shoulder with the United States in the next 10 years. India looks at the key demographic dividend, which may become a population burden.
Without a major change in India, it will be difficult for India to continue to develop, let alone catch up with China. In the next 10 years, China's per capita GDP may reach 20,000 U.S. dollars, and India may only have 5,000 U.S. dollars, and the gap may become wider and wider. The current gap in per capita GDP is 9,000 U.S. dollars, and the gap in the future is 15,000 U.S. dollars.
Every country has its own best time and wait what Chinese are doing on UA-cam?😂😂
India is democratic and China is one party rule.... Biggest difference
But this may not be an advantage for India though.
And India is so diverse which causes so many protests in a year...
One day protest = 3500 crore ₹ lost
Most people in our country hardly understand the concept of democracy and though it is the best system of government, Indians have more of factional loyalty. We are a country with several nations in it. It was never bound to work well.
Democracy is biggest threat
Jai Hind Jai Hind Jai Hind
To put it simply, India has a lot of obstacles, and challenges it needs to face and overcome and also needs to make changes to things like it’s infrastructure but with its current growth and development, India does have a bright future. But a lot of work still needs to be done.
This will always be the way of the world. Eventually, your nationality will not
Matter
INDIA IS - [ 4 decades behind China ] - I had an apportunity to go to China in 1972 to assist in the implementation of a computer system
For domestic problems
China: Yes, how to solve these problems? Immediately convene experts and the masses to hold a discussion meeting. Develop a solution.
India: We don’t have any problems. Those who say we have problems are all rumors. How can our great India have problems? We are the world’s largest democracy, we will be the world’s most populous country, we will surpass China, we will surpass the United States, and we will lead the world.
It really is so.
Good analysis. Thanks!. While burocracy graf is almost flat, the curruption graf is rising exponentially. That really drags India behind China.
I see no Indian software or apps on the market, only Chinese. Pray tell, how India lead in software?
@Varadharajan R Software services come under labor. Without a product, it's not software. It's like mechanic servicing car as opposed to producing a car.
I don't understand why people always want to compare India with China, there is no comparison, one is an apple and another an orange, the culture is different, the type of government is different, the history is different, the demographic, the economy structures are totally different, the only thing that is similar is the size of their populations, Taiwan and Australia has the similar population but you don't see anyone wanting to compare the two.
Before heading to a developed country, India must be able to overcome the middle income trap in the future and politically, must be able to face challenges from western countries which will surely try to prevent India from becoming a developed country at the level of China in the years to come as China is facing now.
👍 👍👍
I have been discussing this with many Indian friends and I believe that the only way for India to have a bright future is to join hands with China. Without India's support, Sooner or later China will also become a developed world, only need a bit more time. But without China's support, the entire Western world could not allow India to industrialize. This is the nature of the human world which has been revealled by entire history of mankind.
Indian government is too short sighted to live in the illusion of self-styled democracy for petty profits from West Wold.
If China has become developed in 20 years, how long will India take? 2 times? Whichbis 40 years? India will be developed with or without China. Look at the world GDP since 1AD till 1700AD - India had larger GDP that China. So history is in our favour , maybe you read CCP curriculum? And btw, when you introduce yourself as "Chinese" to the world, please remember everytime that the name "China" was introduced to the world by your big brother India.
@@sampadmohanty8573 What are you talking about? China used to be father country of most of the 'Indian' tribes before British glued them into one 'country' of British Raj(OK, they cut off Pakistan) for hundreds years of continous fxxk, you still don't have a native Indian language but some tribal language and can't communicate without your master's leftover English. You can include USA 1700AD GDP too they are 'Indian', LOL
chinese stand in between the democrats and autocrats....reasonably perfect mix between two
There are three things you argument that I don't know Agree. The first one is China is better at software than India the advantage is not dressed in hardware it’s a common sense that India is only known for outsourcing and those surface job from those American companies whereas trainer has a lot of its own companies which have invented their own technologies. For example Ali Baba and Tencent.There isn’t any world famous Hi tech companies from India.As a matter of fact China is probably the only country that’s competing with US in terms of high technology. The second thing is diversity diversity isn’t bad and the problem is not all kind of cities will be excepted worldwide and specifically India’s diversity isn’t really admired and a lot of times it’s being looked down upon so I don’t see that that is a advantage of India. The third point is English there at the millions of Chinese who have studied abroad and even more people who have lived abroad there isn’t a shortage of Chinese people who are proficient in English
English is not important. You see Japan and korea, are their English good?
China >>> Japan and korea. There are Chinese everywhere, chinatowns in every major city in the world, Chinese have been in usa, Australia, Canada etc since their founding in gold rush days.
I don't see any Korean or japanese in Australia, my country, but there are 1 million+ Chinese.
Chinese can assimilate and succeed anywhere they migrate or move to. You don't see japanese anywhere in the worl(apart from few in Brazil), or Koreans (apart from few in Japan). But Chinese are everywhere, and always successful and always assimilate and can fit into the new countries cultures.
The biggest difference is India has a culture of being a talker bragging, bullshitting and pleasing the boss, and only talk without getting hands dirty and being proud of that. whereas chinese instead are cultural ly more pround of hard working silently and humbly. If u take a look at Indians and Chinese in silicon valley u will understand it. This simple difference can explain every single fact between the two countries
Many of the big tech CEOs are Indians. Is that talking, bragging, bullshiting or pleasing one's boss. Indians are outspoken but they are hard working and smart. They come from a world of free thinking and not from where they are treated like machines. Clean up your head before talking about anyone.
Yes Chinese are hard working like machine
@@viprp Yes Many of the big tech CEOs are Indians. so what? China has 129 of the world's top 500 enterprises
. India has only 7 top 500 companies in the world
@@lchristin4430 It will grow and we will bury you.
@@viprp lol yep true, but based on your logic, since in American if you are humble you are OUT, Indian feature of that bragging fit there so well !
simply do a simple math, to show you how it is impossible, China's GDP is $14.72 Trillion, India is $2.632 Trillion
14.72/2.632=5.59
to get to the level of China, assume India with growth rage 1% more than China, that will need 173 year, if 2% more than China, that will take 86.5 years, 4% more than China, it will take 43.3 year, 8% more than China, that will take 21 year, etc,
Assume China growth rate is 5%, India growth keeps at 6%, India will get the same amount of GDP of China in 173 years.
the reality is , India growth in 2021 predicted will be 8.4%, but growth at 2020 was -7.3%, so for 2 years, it is (-7.3 + 8.4 )/ 2 = 0.5%.
China in 2020 growth was 2.2 and 2021 (predicted) 6 %, so for 2 years, (2.2+6)/2= 4.1%, China growth is 4.1-0.5=3.6% more than India,
It's actually true .. our India will become a developed country within this decade 😌..I believe
@V k yes..media must help in this not. Shitty topics😑
Realistically speaking it would take many reforms in India before it can start its journey on becoming a developed country
Jai Hind India number 1
I was shocked by the Indian style of self-confidence. They ignored the objective facts
@@dudu7038 India will become a superpower in 2025. You will only believe the brainwashing news of Europe and America You are a fool
China took 500 million people out of poverty. If you want to see poverty, see it in India. There is no comparison between the two.
China also has the highest C02 emissions and has the largest surveillance state.
Chîna also Killed Millions of Poor for rapidly get rid of Poverty, they Directly get rid of poor's lives!!!
@Nikhil Gihar 4% of 1.4 billion is a huge number.
This came across as a solid attempt at being impartial, well-informed and attempting to provide at least some positives from both parties. All-in-all, great commentary. Thank you.
70 percent of people in Indias 1.3 billion population have to use outdoor toilets. They are at least 4 decades behind
@@serk1933 Not any more
@@serk1933 same old lame stuff, grow up.
Straightforward talk Why India lagging behind China bec.of overconfidence, colonial mentality ,poor leadership arrogant, and lack of vision !
We are actually doing things together, indian engineers are working with Chinese automotive counterparts. One of the areas I know in which they are Co-operating. However with global geopolitical change i see it changing slowly.
Bjp is focussed on hard infrastructure
True. Hopefully import substitution works also!
Comparing CHINA with india is same as Comparing A Dragon with cow dung
Chinese new skyscrapers and infrastructures did not get build overnight. You can accomplish those as long you strive and plan towards the goal no matter how long it takes.
If ever learned about macroecon, poorer countries have higher growth rates. TBH India is 1/5 to China's gdp, so it has a long long way to go. What I believe decides the country's future is always technology and education. India has great IT people and engineers, current layback isn't forever.
Those people are forced to work in IT sector because india has no other sector
and they all work in us
I disagree with you in the start but your were right in other points, China invested heavily in manufacturing but they didn't ignore their agriculture sector but if you think should leapfrog it's way from agriculture centric to high technology without going through low level manufacturing with its base weak, India is huge country with strong population so here are the point which needs to be thought of -
1. This hugh population needs employment whereas high tech sector is more demanded on skilled labour and automation for efficiency. If you are aware about India's education it has highest number of engineering graduates who are not skilled enough with this advancing market.
2. With today's geopolitical affair it is very important to be self sufficient, otherwise you are only looking to get strong armed by rich countries and their sanctions.
as a Chinese, I do not want India compares with China, I actually don't want my country compares with any other countries but our self, the yestoday China.
I think India should compares with America.
India will never develop ina hundred years
Forget comparing
But that's close to impossible
Chinese are also good at building healthcare and education resources for its citizens... apart from industrialization. Has world view... Human values... Helping poor countries in Africa.... And other Asian countries.... Law and order bigger issue in India.
@Nikhil Gihar How come you and op had the same first name?
@Nikhil Gihar relax..i am just curious
They are not main issues for economic growth. Once your economy grow rapidly, you can invest in anything.
India is ahead of software than CHINA? You are kidding right? Your maybe basing it on BPOs or outsourcing industry which not really entirely equates to software. Based on data alone, CHINA's software industry alone is about at least 400B USD that is about 4x whole india's IT industry. Not to mention, CHINA has gaming & internet industries & services which mostly their exports IT services. Largest gaming company in the world is Tencent, Ant Financial is the world's most valuble startup, Alibaba and its subsidiary is dominating not only in CHINA but also in Southeast Asia, Africa and even india thru paytm. Tech scene in CHINA is now rivaling the west, no wonder why trump is so keen to ban and maligning CHINA's tech companies and related businesses like TikTok, WeChat and even Zoom. 🙄
Mostly three decades behind
2
Very interesting comparison between China and India. At the same time, the relation between hardware and software. He is more cautious about projecting the relationship between the two countries in future.
Why always pit China against India or vice versa? How about promoting peace between India, China, and Pakistan.
"Indians had several century tradition of using English as a native language"?? Since when was that? I've never (really never) came across a native Indian with native mastery of the English language, not even close. I suspect Indians may also have a misconception of what being a native speaker of a language means. An anecdote was when I came across an Indian university graduate who indicated in her resume that she is a "native" speaker of English but alas, she in no way spoke or use words a native English speaker would, not even taking into account the very strong Indian accent that she had.
Throughout 5000 years of history China had numerous inventions and scientific discoveries beside the well known four great inventions. What about comparable inventions has India? Culture and tradition and
best novel of china "journey to the west" is written by the guy who came and learn in india
what was india u dont know nor u will know
first surgery done by indian sushrta
zero introduced by india
alot of other things by ancient indians so before you talk just research then comment
If India can work with China, the west dominance will end faster. But it is just wishful thinking. The west has the best understanding of how to divide and rule.
India dislike China and see China as a threat, it seems Chinese people very ignorant.
Only..if only china left it's expansionist policy..in current situation..border tensions are holding back Indians to reach out to China
India's territory claim is based British colonial expansion, those areas never part of historical India. When Brits left, Burma & Pak reasonably realigned the border with China. But India insisted on grabbing every single inch which led to war. China won, but retreated, preferred diplomatic solution. Who's the greedy land robber?
You can never have reasonable debate with Indians, they have no honor, no respect for facts and logic.
India missed the boat long-time ago. Poverty and castle system can not be sorted if ever. What a shame.
Software industry can't lift millions out of poverty like hardware manufacturing can do because working in software and computing industry requires highly educated and skilled workers which are few in India hence it will deepen the income divide in India I want India to develop pharmaceutical industry which is something India can easily excel in and dominate
Thanks alot man, you just gave me a new point of thinking. 🔥
I see no Indian software on the market, whereas I see more Chinese software and apps. Don't think we lead in software.
@@benishan3 it's not that our companies are leading in software. But most of the MNCs have offices in India and employ Indians.
Personally I think if India can manage all these shortcomings, they would still need 15 to 20 years to catch up, not 10.
Lot to learn from Chinese people🇨🇳...🙏
Only the educated population can talk about the demographic dividend. Look at the illiteracy rate in India。
But that doesn't mean demographic crisis isn't a small problem.
I have been to India. I don’t understand people’s obsession of China/India comparison. The two countries are diversely different, for India, they need to figure out their own way of development, instead of copycat everything China did because they might not repeat the same success of China, e.g. the world factory.
If I were an Indian I would feel ashamed to compare India with China. The gap in every sector of the two countries where China is very far ahead is just too wide to mention and more so to even want to compare. Please do not ever bring up this subject of comparison again. If you do, it shows you have been living in the jungle for the past 30 years. ndia cannot even build enough toilet as a human basic right for his people as the link provide here {what a shame} #opendefecation Latest report from IMF on China contribution to the world economy.According to the IMF’s World Economic Outlook (WEO) report in October, global economic output is forecast to expand by 3% this year, to which China is expected to contribute 0.9 percentage point, Barnett said.
He made the remarks at a launch of the publication in Beijing last Friday. The event was organised by the IMF Resident Representative Office in China and the International Monetary Institute at the Renmin University of China.
By comparison, the United States is forecast to contribute 0.3 percentage point while India’s contribution might be 0.5 percentage point, Barnett told China Daily on the sidelines of the event.
On 2024, China is forecast to contribute 0.8 percentage point of the 2.9% global growth, just under one-third and still higher than 0.2 percentage point of the United States and 0.5 percentage point of India, he said.
The WEO, published lastTuesday, has lowered the 2023 economic growth forecast for China to 5% from 5.2%, citing the pressures brought by the weakness in the real estate sector
Imho, the main, insurmountable obstacle of India to compete with China is its deep religiosity ...
Religions are irrational: None is based in logic, common sense, rational arguments
China's keys to current success:
1. Its non-religiosity
2. Ethical confucian upbringing, both for family and society
3. Millennia of socio-political learning process, with many ups and downs
4. Social cohesion provided by basically same language and writing for millennia.
Agree.
No we just use them for scapegoats. Main reasons are:
1) policy paralysis & slow bureaucracy
2) poor infrastructure and slow logistics
3) education without real skills
I'm working with many talents in India. India has good & skilled talents. But the problem is mindset, risk taking. Untill and unless this changes, India can't improve.
All you said is 100% true. But to become like China or any other developed Western countries, there are many aspects which have to be taken into consideration, because of which India still lags behind and will be lagging behind in the future. The main reason behind India lagging behind is lack of innovative minds, bookish knowledge never gonna help them to become like China unless you have a creative mindset. Another important reason is, India may overcome corruption at some point but there is hardly any possibility of overcoming inequalities and intolerance.
Our Chinese people are fascinated with new ideas and technologies nowadays. I hope we can keep up with this.
No need to compare.
India doesnt have what it takes to compare with the world's beater - in its rising economic and military superpower - the X factor.
It's its people and ethos , wrought by centuries of both wars and wisdom that sharpen em like you put a blunt tool to the grinder.
What didnt kill em have em evolved with so much resilience and enterprising , the spirit of the fittest and cohesiveness of society that manifested itself against the best - given the right government ie the leadership glue that directs and propels em upwards.
I think india can beat in service sector and not in manufacturing sector .
There are some areas that India can surpass China, population and unemployment rate.
@Fahim Rahman you can move out from India its quite easy,.go to either Bangladesh, srilanka, Nepal, Myanmar, Vietnam or Philippines they don't have much restrictions. All the best man.
The highest export of Chinese goods to India is less than US $90 billion a year, accounting for 1.2% of China's export. In 2019, India's exports to China accounted for 5.3% of India's total exports. If Hong Kong is added, the ratio will reach 9%. Who do you think is hurt by mutual resistance?
India in 1950 bulls, villages,poor people,un educated etc india in 2021 compared to China , USA,UK etc.😂
2050 wait and watch.
China was at the same level, even worse
@@sharduldiwan2009 china has a communist party which makes it easy for them to make democracy on the other hand India is the largest domeocracy and you know india is blessed with such good Neighbour "pakistan" Which helps India so much 😂😂
@@abinashparida.8125 India is a mobocracy not democracy.
@@chiluxr250 usa has only 2 political party and india has many but still we call it a democratic country but in reality they have 2 party rule.
@@abinashparida.8125 USA no1!
2:40 Your comparison and argument here is so naive and irrational. Why are you comparing Indian App ecosystem with China's deep tech?
As long as we are doing comparisons here, there are various Indian Deep Tech services and Unicorn companies who provide and manufacture "Drones" and even "Robots" and that too on a large scale. I can even show the stats and source if ya want.
Please look into topics before stating an opinion.
I have learnt a lot from you sir!
Thank you!🙏😊👏
Indians should drink more ganges water to be confident
@@无敌帅的江哥 what do you mean you foolish
Very good commentary. Thank you.
I think you are right , the biggest problem india faces right now is poor infrastructure that's true 100 percent I agree, but there is also a huge problem regarding religion, I won't blame it all on british, caste system is still exist in india, india is so diverse, I can't explain it in words as I am indian too, I think first we have to make changes in our ethics the work force, the way we work, the way our school system is designed,they teach us to get a better job, not to open our own business,I think we have to redesign our education system, it should more engaging,"India is poor but not poor" Try to understand this statement india is the most corrupted country in the world , poor is getting poorer and richer is getting more richer and that is the fact, first we have to kickout those corruped officals, BJP is the most corrupted party in the world, we should have expert who should handle the government, not the criminals, corrupted officers.
That's my point of view
Buddy, he made this video on the request of China Mobile. It’s biased in china’s favor. China has a horrible future as it ages critically. Don’t worry, India is growing naturally. Democracies naturally progress and communism and oppression naturally does off. So don’t worry. China doesn’t have a future.
@@vivekcse1 Democracy is not good for india politicians care about vote not india
The three major obstacles to India’s economic growth are Corruption, Religious divide and Caste system. It is easy to get rid of corruptions. The other two, insurmountable!!
Once visit India you will know Where we are
It is important to note Chinese gdp was 2.3 trillion 15 years back
In 2021 for india it's 3 trillion so yah there are things comparable (even if we take account of surplus population 1.2-1.3 china 2005 & India's 1.4 billion 2021)
Morever
India being an open market it might catch up sooner
And looking at ground increments
i.e.- Foreign direct investment rose 10% from 2019 & in
2020 even under covid stood at 81 billion $
Reason
Earlier every govs used to focuse only on agri but from past 2 terms drastic developments are made in Infrastructure , Policies , foreign co-operation thanks to pro-industrialist centre
Not even that
But it's need for Korea, Japan & west to diversify investment than segregating in China
As it's backfiring in form of aggression
In this chaos
India is becoming a prominent option
Which they are heavily considering too
Looking at the
•Japan's huge investment in indian infrastructure
•Initiation of development for India-Australia-Japan supply chain
•Return Talks for EU-India free trade agreement (which hopefully & most likely be successful)
For upcoming
•Greater push in Infrastructure from B3W
Very sensible post and numbers put things in perspective.
We might take longer or might get there sooner, but the point is we can get there in a couple of decades with concerted efforts or not get there at all if some unruly elements sabotage our growth with insurgencies etc.
Lol India is not an open market.
Even now India refuse to join RCEP and other free trade agreements, still very protectionist. It cannot match china if it doesn't open up and welcome foreign investment.
Also, unelss India imorove relations with china, and continues to ban Chinese investment, then it will never be able to replicate china's rise since china will be the number 1 economy by 2027-8.
That would be the same as if china banned usa from investment in the 90/00s.
Also, by 2040-2050 china's economy will be double usas basically, so it will be even worse for India if they don't embrace Chinese investment or Chinese market.
Watch 1.75x speed.. We Indian very fast. Just wait and watch 😎😎😎
A country with 70 percent people not having food.... A country with so much unemployed will become developed country 😂🤣nice joke
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 70%??? Where did you get this number?
Make it happen first. Talk is cheap.
@@maitrishchakraborty3470 India is a rising superpower!
Please make analysis about ASEAN, in particular its major countries within that region.
India has caste system where 15% uppercaste people don't want to share resources with 85% population of lower caste people and Minorities. That's the main problem.
@Varadharajan R Are you Brahmin?
See how many unicorns we had in India this year alone :)
But most are service based, we need more in manufacturing sector.
never trust a man who doesn't has a mustache
I love India and China both as a Sri Lankan, but China became great power because, they could control religions.
Thank you Master Obi-Wan
finally a impartial economic video about india
The future of India is totally dependent upon whether or not the *Caste* system is eliminated or maintained.
@@madrexertheboredtm7728 it's our culture dude, we as indian people suck to do anything good.
Dude India was a large economy before British came. Then also we have caste amd religion problems. Then why was our economy so large. Ofcourse we need to improve social equality but that isn't the reason for slow economic growth. Main reasons are:
1) policy paralysis & slow bureaucracy
2) poor infrastructure and slow logistics
3) education without real skills.
What if China and India work together to leverage strengths, instead of letting US drive the wedge between them. Economic colonization
Very well explained sir. I also think same that it will take decades to reach in position that China is currently
Decades not decade