I once had the chance to speak with a retired Israeli military officer who had served for over 25 years and held a high rank. He explained to me that while Israel could fight on multiple fronts, it could only sustain a high-intensity conflict for 1 to 3 months. If the war continued beyond that, Israel would need to sue for peace unless America intervened. Their entire strategy hinges on holding out long enough for the U.S. to deploy troops and equipment. However, if left to fend for themselves, they would ultimately have to consider using their nuclear arsenal.
@@Dan-yf2df Israel has not been in a full-scale war since the 2006 Lebanon War, which involved ground battles, airstrikes, and more. Since then, Israel has only engaged in conflicts with smaller, irregular groups-nothing on the scale of a full-blown conflict with a nation like Iran or Syria. It seems you don’t know the difference between one and the other. 🤷🏻♂️ And even the Lebanon war of 2006 only lasted for 34 days. LMAO. Israel hasn’t have a major conflict with nations since 1973 with the Yom Kippur War and they were helped by USA with the famous Operation Nickel Grass
@Porter-1488 What does your comment have to do with the main topic of our conversation? It doesn’t seem to relate at all. We’re discussing whether Israel could withstand a prolonged full-scale war with another nation without the assistance of the USA, but you’ve shifted the focus to Hamas and Palestine, which isn’t relevant to the point we’re making. We haven’t mentioned Hamas or Palestine at all; the discussion is solely about Israel’s reliance on America in the event of a prolonged war, for example, with Iran. Please make sure to read the conversation thoroughly before commenting. Thank you.
Doesn't matter. Allied support is a key aspect of military strategy. Iran & co. have to assume Israel will receive support from those countries, or anything they do will fail.
The north of Israel is a ghost town and every day keeping all soldiers on high alert and having to fire iron dome missiles is costing the Israeli economy massively lebanons been through worse they will survive I’m not sure about Israel on the other hand
Even funding them I don’t think israel has the capabilities I truly believe if all out war happened and it looked like israel were going to loose I think they would use the nuclear bomb then claim to be the victim when the whole world Condemns them
Israel doesn’t want to avoid an all out war because Netanyahu’s political carrier is at stake and he will go to jail if it ends in a stalemate. If they don’t agree on two states solution the war will never end.
@@samtheresearcherNever! All peace resolutions are all about Palestinians 22% and never about Israel's 78% why should Palestinians accept losing more land to greedy Israel? Then you blame Palestinians?
Israel has been trying to draw the US into a war with Iran since the beginning. Two assasinations have not yet succeeded in the US attacking Iran. Israel will try again, and again. Striking Lebanon is a waste of ammo because Iran can re-supply for years. And with help from Russia and N. Korea Iran will be able to defend itself.
The stakes are too high for a military confrontation. US will not stand idle if Iran and its proxies attack Israel. What the world needs at this time is PEACE amongst all Nations.
Must rather ask those who organized the return of the cursed people in the region, after the crucifixion of the Christ and the destruction of the temple...
Gaza - Killed: at least 40,405 people, including nearly 16,500 children. Injured: more than 93,468 people. Missing: more than 10,000. Occupied West Bank - Killed: at least 642 people, including more than 147 children. Injured: more than 5,400. More than half of Gaza’s homes destroyed or damaged - 80 percent of commercial facilities. 85 percent of school buildings. 16 out of 36 hospitals are partially functioning. 65 percent of road networks. 65 percent of cropland damaged.
We are tired of all out regional wall … every day all out regional war .. so annoying hearing this words over and over . You guys should let us rest in peace with this all panic statement all the time
The US keeps claiming progress has been made in talks for a ceasefire in the Gaza Strip. At the same time, it keeps funding and arming Israel’s war machine against the people of Gaza, and it also helps Tel Aviv maintain and strengthen the all-out siege on the Palestinian territory. Now, alongside the everyday bombings, the weaponized starvation and the lack of medicine and necessities, Gazans face the threat of a Polio virus outbreak. With the international community incapable of taking any meaningful action.
Moral of the story = don’t attack Israel and play victim card and use people as human shields if u gonna attack em by jumping cuz is not a 1v1 atleast win how you fight somebody with more than 1 person and still loose
@@taniamariolamenalaboriel7444 You're deluded if you believe Palestinians are the aggressors & obviously are influenced by a prejudicial perspective & propoganda. All of humanity wants ☮️ peace,.,not war. 🔥
Indeed, Indeed there are still foreign non invited "guests " that are getting hurt in Syria and Iraq why haven't they gone home after destroying the country
Short answer is yes, because it has US logistics, reconnaissance, intelligence, supply and military propping it up. We'll have to come out from behind the curtain soon enough.
True it's better to exchange world leadership for a dictatorship with a petty narcissist/clown on the top who is easily manipulated by Putin and Kim...
Sign with who. The Israeli government killed the intermediaries. Meanwhile colonists in the east keep harassing and murdering with the government endorsement.
The US can help intercept drones and cruise missiles from Iran, if they come again, but what can they do against ballistic missiles which only take about 12 minutes to get to Israel. US naval assets may also be at risk, if Hezbollah also has ballistic missiles.
Preventive strikes are not defensive. The most famous is the Japanese preventive strike over Pearl Harbor, in response to the blockade imposed by the US in the China/Japan Sea, as a response to the IJN campaign of conquest in the Continental Asia.
Every war Israel has fought since 1948 has been on multiple fronts. So yes. To quote that seminal rock song. "June 67, Total Respect, Control Jerusalem"
It's not debate to discuss whether they can or not. Rather, it should be in different ways, either isreal terrorist state or not, isreal state sponsored acts of terrorism have been proven by international community
@@lawrencekirchheimer734 news is not a wish concert. Journalist should about debate over facts. You can skip Taylor Swift concert if you don’t like her, not war and politics
My book is a testament of what happens when a people goes against God. I am truly grateful that I dont have to compromise after all with humanity. I can start new with people that are actually decent.
Politically, Israel's incompetend leadership (in my opinion) lost the fight for the next 50 yrs. They just gave birth of generations of israelis haters across their borders and far beyond. Milittary speaking, need to have the financial data. But honestly how much does it cost having fancy dooms trying to stop drones or missiles of the previous century? It is my feeling that israel starts to expirience an economic disaster. For me their leadership is kindergarden and not better than the ukrainian joke. It is really dissapointing that israel did not used its power to stabilise the region and bring prosperity. What they just did was to reproduce hate and violence in the region for the next decades.
^ this guy: ”Not fair! Israel has to wait until the 1000 rockets are actually in the air and other way to Tel Aviv before they can respond, waa, waa,😩 “
Desperate Netanyahu - trying to get western support for his on going colonisation of Palestinian land and to be aloowed to continue his barbaric destruction of Gaza…..
How to avoid all out war ? You should tell the American to have some self respect and not allow israil to play you. Israil is playing dice with peoples lives, issue genocide in the region has consequences so there security and they want to re establish they by taunting and flexing is muscles with Iran in the hope Iran wouldn’t retaliate at there own soft power recreation. Israil also assumes America will bail them out if there calculation is incorrect and Iran does understandably does retaliate out of self defence from israil aggression. End of the day American tax pay pay for israil selfish gains and the people in the region pay with there lives for israil greed.
Hezbollah weapons is from iran iraq militia weapons also from iran Yemen militia weapons also from iran,stop hezbollah iraq militia Yemen militia weapons a point only
I once had the chance to speak with a retired Israeli military officer who had served for over 25 years and held a high rank. He explained to me that while Israel could fight on multiple fronts, it could only sustain a high-intensity conflict for 1 to 3 months. If the war continued beyond that, Israel would need to sue for peace unless America intervened. Their entire strategy hinges on holding out long enough for the U.S. to deploy troops and equipment. However, if left to fend for themselves, they would ultimately have to consider using their nuclear arsenal.
Israel has been fighting on multiple fronts for most of the past year with foreign troops so whatever you were told is nonsense.
@@Dan-yf2df Israel has not been in a full-scale war since the 2006 Lebanon War, which involved ground battles, airstrikes, and more. Since then, Israel has only engaged in conflicts with smaller, irregular groups-nothing on the scale of a full-blown conflict with a nation like Iran or Syria. It seems you don’t know the difference between one and the other. 🤷🏻♂️
And even the Lebanon war of 2006 only lasted for 34 days. LMAO. Israel hasn’t have a major conflict with nations since 1973 with the Yom Kippur War and they were helped by USA with the famous Operation Nickel Grass
Lie much
@Porter-1488 What does your comment have to do with the main topic of our conversation? It doesn’t seem to relate at all. We’re discussing whether Israel could withstand a prolonged full-scale war with another nation without the assistance of the USA, but you’ve shifted the focus to Hamas and Palestine, which isn’t relevant to the point we’re making.
We haven’t mentioned Hamas or Palestine at all; the discussion is solely about Israel’s reliance on America in the event of a prolonged war, for example, with Iran. Please make sure to read the conversation thoroughly before commenting. Thank you.
The media just love these scenarios
Another question. Can Israel fight on multiple fronts without US, EU and UK assistance in the region?
If you want to be really accurate, Israel is actually fighting America's war.
Yes,,, they can,,, but making a short war, like in 67 ... Sounds impossible but is possible,
Doesn't matter. Allied support is a key aspect of military strategy. Iran & co. have to assume Israel will receive support from those countries, or anything they do will fail.
Can not fight Iran alone...
Can hisbulla lead war with out Iran and other funny
Without US - No Israel
Without Israel, no Middle East
That shows that Israel is right in defending themselves. Billions of Arabs vs tiny Israel. What a shame.
Without iran peace in the middle east
with islam - no peace in the world.
I agree Iran's a major problem here... but that's a bit of a strech@@JeanBod1111
Israel can’t never engage in a three front without the help of the United States
Lebanon will be in turmoil economically if Hez gets into war.
Lebanon have no economy the have nothing to lose its israel who will lose
They already are.
46,000 Businesses have closed in Israel since 7th October.
Will?
The north of Israel is a ghost town and every day keeping all soldiers on high alert and having to fire iron dome missiles is costing the Israeli economy massively lebanons been through worse they will survive I’m not sure about Israel on the other hand
"Can Israel fight on multiple fronts?" the thumbnail says.
Not if the US and Europe stop supplying the weapons and start holding them accountable.
Even funding them I don’t think israel has the capabilities I truly believe if all out war happened and it looked like israel were going to loose I think they would use the nuclear bomb then claim to be the victim when the whole world Condemns them
israel must create a buffer/security zone inside Southern Lebanon to keep their citizens safe in Northern Israel.
@@dan61131jews must give back Palestinian land & go to Germany
@@dan61131 Sounds like Russian and Eastern Ukraine all over. In other words, it's simply land-grapping.
They can’t even hold territories in Gaza. Israel is doing all this terrorism just to end up losing in the end.
I think the missiles launched first, then the IAF scrambled into action.
@Porter-1488 It's good that UA-cam is protecting your tender self. Kiku.
@Porter-1488 History repeats itself. It's just a matter of time.
Israel doesn’t want to avoid an all out war because Netanyahu’s political carrier is at stake and he will go to jail if it ends in a stalemate. If they don’t agree on two states solution the war will never end.
How does Israeli politics concern you
Two state solution? How many times have Palestinians rejected the offer?
@@samtheresearcher Israel has always vetoed a 2 state solution. So zero offers, zero rejections.
@@samtheresearcherNever! All peace resolutions are all about Palestinians 22% and never about Israel's 78% why should Palestinians accept losing more land to greedy Israel? Then you blame Palestinians?
Israel has been trying to draw the US into a war with Iran since the beginning. Two assasinations have not yet succeeded in the US attacking Iran. Israel will try again, and again. Striking Lebanon is a waste of ammo because Iran can re-supply for years. And with help from Russia and N. Korea Iran will be able to defend itself.
I don't get it. Are we meant to show empathy?
"A land without a people for a people without a land!"
What went wrong?
What went wrong is that was always a lie
There were people in the land
What went wrong? Exceptionalism, apartheid, among other things.
The Europeans should have compensated for the Holocaust by ensuring their safe return to their homes in Europe.
The arabs in British Palestina e were not a people, they were tribes that came from arab countries
Bad title! The question is why it should fight on multiple fronts or why not perhaps🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
The stakes are too high for a military confrontation. US will not stand idle if Iran and its proxies attack Israel. What the world needs at this time is PEACE amongst all Nations.
We cannot even comment anymore, anything that does not match DW and Israel's narrative is being removed. Why comment section even then?
Must rather ask those who organized the return of the cursed people in the region, after the crucifixion of the Christ and the destruction of the temple...
@@bobgonzales9680 seek psychiatric help
They r scared
Молодцы Хезбола Иран тоже добавил бы несколько сотен современные ракеты еврейским терористам
You cannot even describe in neutral terms the actions of Hamas without being censored.
THE EXPERT TALKING AT 8:03 HAS A WOBBLY HEAD!!! IT'S CRAZY THAT ITS EGG SHAPED TOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I AM DYING LAUGHING
Gaza - Killed: at least 40,405 people, including nearly 16,500 children. Injured: more than 93,468 people. Missing: more than 10,000.
Occupied West Bank - Killed: at least 642 people, including more than 147 children. Injured: more than 5,400.
More than half of Gaza’s homes destroyed or damaged - 80 percent of commercial facilities. 85 percent of school buildings. 16 out of 36 hospitals are partially functioning. 65 percent of road networks. 65 percent of cropland damaged.
And still can’t figure out don’t attack Israel
moral of the story: dont attack israel
@@accomplice7 real
@@JeffEbe-te2xs real
So?
I fully support hezbollah and Iran in their fight against all that is e-il
We are tired of all out regional wall … every day all out regional war .. so annoying hearing this words over and over . You guys should let us rest in peace with this all panic statement all the time
Drone vs fighter jet hot beef😮
So the so called invincible Iron Dome is taking shelter that it has to be the fighter jets that repel the rains of rockets on sky?😂
Yes
Blessed be Israel forever ❤️ 🇮🇱
@@Julionking Hopfully not
Can they..?
Hopefully hellz NO.
The US keeps claiming progress has been made in talks for a ceasefire in the Gaza Strip. At the same time, it keeps funding and arming Israel’s war machine against the people of Gaza, and it also helps Tel Aviv maintain and strengthen the all-out siege on the Palestinian territory.
Now, alongside the everyday bombings, the weaponized starvation and the lack of medicine and necessities, Gazans face the threat of a Polio virus outbreak.
With the international community incapable of taking any meaningful action.
Moral of the story = don’t attack Israel and play victim card and use people as human shields if u gonna attack em by jumping cuz is not a 1v1 atleast win how you fight somebody with more than 1 person and still loose
@@taniamariolamenalaboriel7444
You're deluded if you believe Palestinians are the aggressors & obviously are influenced by a prejudicial perspective & propoganda. All of humanity wants ☮️ peace,.,not war. 🔥
Its almost like extremist of any kind shouldnt be accepted on either side..
Germany must stop giving weapons to this war criminal
It's the German politicians who are vassals to the US neocons.
Germany needs to stop letting in Palestinians
Can they fight multiple fronts? Well, they wanted it, so I guess we'll find out.
Well, in the end, it's the Hamas that makes peace impossible, as their goal is the destruction of Israel.
The British academic forgot to mention the Hezbollah linked groups in Iraq and Syria who have hit US bases in their countries and the Golan Heights.
Yeah there every where Yemen Syria Iran irgc Hezbollah is all together
I don't think anyone in usa or UK cares if Americans die in middle east , as long as Israel is happy with what they are doing
Didn’t forget
Indeed, Indeed there are still foreign non invited "guests " that are getting hurt in Syria and Iraq why haven't they gone home after destroying the country
Yea
Short answer is yes, because it has US logistics, reconnaissance, intelligence, supply and military propping it up. We'll have to come out from behind the curtain soon enough.
Yes I also agree
What a silly question!
No,they cant handle one front
Pavel Durov DW! His long will you ignore it?!
put our usa tax payer foreign aid on the voting ballot and let’s see what happens
True it's better to exchange world leadership for a dictatorship with a petty narcissist/clown on the top who is easily manipulated by Putin and Kim...
But also add countries to turn into parking lots with b-52s.
But you look HAMMAS 😂😂😂
Many who paid much more taxes than you want the USA to help israel 😂...
But then isreal will be fighting with sticks and stones
Off course they can . They got free money from the Uncle like $3.8 billions peryear
Yeah, they are smart right? Unlike hamas who cannot get uncle's money 😂
thats less than UNRWA gets from the UN
"pick up your arms and were heading to the inhabited land"
"crucified"
"they refused so it is then offered to others"
Did you search for this shirt a lot?😅
Go to Italy or Turkey to wear😅😅😅
But.... if you know their history, then you know they've done it before.
Israel has been fighting on multiple fronts since 1948
comments deleted by DW. dw says you must support isreal in the comments
DW people lost their courage long time ago
DW from Germany so what do you expect 😂history repeat itself
Because DW is Israel's media arm in Germany.
Like Aljazeera delete my comments always and blocking me to post comment for one day
Same with al Jazeera, support jehaadis in the comment section.
1:40 Mr Security can't afford a peace deal 'cause then he'll have to answer to Israelis for his massive Oct 7 failure 🤷🏽♂
They did it multiple times already
Even if israel signs the peace deal terrorism wont end 😢
Benjamin Mileikowsky is the Problem.
Mohamed is the problem
Your message should have been, Even if Israel signs peace deal, it won’t end its terrorism.
Sign with who. The Israeli government killed the intermediaries. Meanwhile colonists in the east keep harassing and murdering with the government endorsement.
As long as Israel illegally occupies and steal Palestinian land, there will not be peace.
Of course with the support of US, UK and other European countries they can ....
The US can help intercept drones and cruise missiles from Iran, if they come again, but what can they do against ballistic missiles which only take about 12 minutes to get to Israel. US naval assets may also be at risk, if Hezbollah also has ballistic missiles.
Why does Israel always get into so many fights?
They did since October 28 leading to the eliminations in Iran
Short answer: No
Long answer: No way
sure as long as the us and allies help and pay the bills
GOD of Israel fights in all fronts
When you have two aircraft carriers assisting you and unlimited weapons transfer, yes. The enemies of Israel are land based armies.
Israel will defend himself 😢
2:21 With what bruh? Since when without us n uk support?
Preventive strikes are not defensive. The most famous is the Japanese preventive strike over Pearl Harbor, in response to the blockade imposed by the US in the China/Japan Sea, as a response to the IJN campaign of conquest in the Continental Asia.
@@SabdoBagusIngAtiin the words of Usher Raymond, Let It Burn
IDF are lost nearly 6500 personals in Gaza
Israel is a specialist in preemptive strikes.
With USA, UK and UN, yes, Israel can
Hopefully they stop helping
That country on psychopaths in the news every day
I'm not sure if hezbollah will exist until the second phase
I think Israel can fight two fronts. But collateral damage will increase.
Every war Israel has fought since 1948 has been on multiple fronts. So yes.
To quote that seminal rock song. "June 67, Total Respect, Control Jerusalem"
It's not debate to discuss whether they can or not. Rather, it should be in different ways, either isreal terrorist state or not, isreal state sponsored acts of terrorism have been proven by international community
the Day their scheming will be of no benefit to them whatsoever, nor will they be helped.
Israel, the apartheid state
Where are you from theran Moscow or doha?
@@JeanBod1111
"Forget about Russia, the real Threat to America is Israel and the Israel Lobby "
~Julian Assange, many years ago.
Isreal= Apartheid for Palestinians
The rest if the Middle east = Apartheid for woman.
You must be Sinwar s cousin 😂
@@mariahewitt9787That Schmuck? Hahahaha
Yeah they can that's why no neihbors dare to attack in total war.
Where is big Daddy , cry and call for help
I don't worry about the safety of Israel . Weird thumbnail, i have yet to meet anyone that does
And Korean smoke grenades
Imagine religion in 2024
old proverb, an 'Israeli' will tell you what happened to them, but wont tell you what they did!
Oh God please severa us
DW wont let people tell the truth about isreal
Germany lost sovereignity after WWII.
You do not like this reporting then leave, you won't be missed.
@@lawrencekirchheimer734 news is not a wish concert. Journalist should about debate over facts. You can skip Taylor Swift concert if you don’t like her, not war and politics
@@EthanLemon-w2pif they had skipped Islam, world would be happier place.
You don't need DW to tell anything, the fact that israel still exist mean they are winning
My book is a testament of what happens when a people goes against God. I am truly grateful that I dont have to compromise after all with humanity. I can start new with people that are actually decent.
Ad..lf Netanyahu at it again.
Turns out israelis narrative was right and the left felt for irans narrative.
@@icephoenix5466 major copium
@@icephoenix5466 Israel has lied over and over what are you waffling about
You have no country
The cause and foundation of the problem is italy and France Paris,Rome,Napolitano,Napoli,America,Rome,Taranto,Torino,Sardinia %*?*
No and its wild we have nations funding IDF like classic war criminals.
War criminals are determined by those who are winning and control the world
It's impossible to avoid and all out war. Religion-driven wars will persist forever.
Fight for an imaginary figure! Weehoo
This is not about religion, this is zionism
Politically, Israel's incompetend leadership (in my opinion) lost the fight for the next 50 yrs. They just gave birth of generations of israelis haters across their borders and far beyond. Milittary speaking, need to have the financial data. But honestly how much does it cost having fancy dooms trying to stop drones or missiles of the previous century? It is my feeling that israel starts to expirience an economic disaster. For me their leadership is kindergarden and not better than the ukrainian joke. It is really dissapointing that israel did not used its power to stabilise the region and bring prosperity. What they just did was to reproduce hate and violence in the region for the next decades.
History will judge Israel harshly.
Bot/avatar account
We'll see , but i doubt that
🍉 🍉 🍉 🍉 🍉 .
If Israel started indiscriminate bombing,there will be no human being in labanon,forget about hezbolla
Would that be a bad thing
Isreal can never live in peace until Palestine have there freedom. It's obvious and the only truth.
Hisbollocks
Israel can attack preamptiv...and Iran cannot retaliate.....😮
^ this guy:
”Not fair! Israel has to wait until the 1000 rockets are actually in the air and other way to Tel Aviv before they can respond, waa, waa,😩 “
Israel has done in the past..
The Ayatollahs want the Arabs to fight to the last hijaballa!
😜cope
Nice hair, Tania..
❤🇮🇱💪🏼☘️
Desperate Netanyahu - trying to get western support for his on going colonisation of Palestinian land and to be aloowed to continue his barbaric destruction of Gaza…..
How to avoid all out war ? You should tell the American to have some self respect and not allow israil to play you. Israil is playing dice with peoples lives, issue genocide in the region has consequences so there security and they want to re establish they by taunting and flexing is muscles with Iran in the hope Iran wouldn’t retaliate at there own soft power recreation. Israil also assumes America will bail them out if there calculation is incorrect and Iran does understandably does retaliate out of self defence from israil aggression. End of the day American tax pay pay for israil selfish gains and the people in the region pay with there lives for israil greed.
Israel's game is over
Is US backed Israel has territory?
I don't know, has it?
Military industry share 😅😅invest you fool😅
Hezbollah weapons is from iran iraq militia weapons also from iran Yemen militia weapons also from iran,stop hezbollah iraq militia Yemen militia weapons a point only
Yes.... cos there is NO HOLY.WAR.........
🇮🇱👍
One sided reporting?
Then go your Al Jazeera 😂
Because Germany has faced terror and they realize the danger Israel and Europe faces!
You keep asking dumb questions Isreal is already fighting on multiple front almost all Israel wars are multiple front
"Six days of fire
One day of rest
June 67
Total Respect
Control Jerusalem"
Sabaton- Counter Strike
PLAY IT ON SUPER LOUD
I stand with Isreal
G😢
Ask those who organized the return of the cursed people in the region, after the crucifixion of the Christ and the destruction of the temple...