I’m glad that you covered this. Just because Fred and George are twins doesn’t mean they don’t have their own personalities/traits. They fed off of each other but were also quite different in their own ways.
True but fred didn't plan it all they did together because they are brothers and they have an amazing bond they made the joke shop stuff together I repeat fred didn't plan it all other wise it might aswell just be weasley wizard wheezes not weasleys wizard wheezes
I would bet that to their family and closest friends they were easy to distinguish. I have twin friends who are now young men in college, but I have known them since they were born, taught them in Sunday school at every age, and got them hooked on the Dresden Files books. They are very different to me, and easy to tell apart. It’s nice that JKR treated them like real people with differences. My son is reading book 5 now, and just got to the triumphant exit from Hogwarts. He probably can tell something bad is coming because I have trouble hiding my feelings from him as we talk about my favorite characters who are now his, Fred and George.
My late father, he died of pancreatic cancer in 2015, was the "lead singer " of a set of identical twins. My uncle has described as it as losing a part of one's self, quite literally. Identical twins share everything, literally everything, and to have one die....it seems to be against nature itself. My uncle, like George Weasley, has had to go on. It truly is getting used to a new normal, albeit an incomplete one.
They will meet again. Life on earth is like a fleeting wind. Our true home resides in the realm beyond with our Creator. I hope that at least can bring comfort. It certainly does for me.
George in the books is the more subtle, docile twin but more active in Quidditch. I love their small differences. I also love how their mum can't tell them apart sometimes but Ron always can.
Fred and George were born on April Fools, that makes sense because they always pull pranks and jokes. It's not like every person born on April 1 has to do that but sometimes it kinda makes sense
I think Fred should have appeared as a ghost in the books, jump scaring everybody even better and doing mischief. They could have run the store together. It would have been a lot of fun. 😊
Sadly, becoming a ghost in the Wizarding World is a fate "worse than death", because they can't feel any physical pleasure, only have limited interactions with the physical world, and if you have "unfinished business", you cannot "move on" even after you finished conducting said business. That's why a lot of wizards prefer to move on after death.
Going into the final book, I'd have thought that if you had to have a Weasley die, it would be Percy. Even with this explanation, I'd still be confused about the brothers. It's good to know that George and Angelina could at least find comfort in each other's company, even though they'd both grieve for a long time.
This is a beautiful analysis of the two and spot on. Yes, Fred seems to have been the “Mischievous in Chief” here, but of course, George was always a willing accomplice.
It’s great how the differences between the twins are actually kinda built into their names. Fred is Firstborn, but also their names are in alphabetical order to reflect their birth order. Fred had a shorter name and a shorter life. George had a longer name, and talked at greater length. Even when it comes to quidditch, George’s longer name can be used to remember that he involved himself more in the game.
One of my best friends who adopted me as her little brother took in two cats and apply named them Fred and George. She loved Harry Potter, I was resistant at the time but eventually came around. I miss you big sis, you were right - HP is good.
I've always thought their personality differences were super apparent in the books, but that could be because I've had several twins as friends growing up. And I've always thought Hermoine should have ended up with George. She was always so impressed with their magic skills and George was super thoughtful and could easily see others' needs
I think Fred is listed more bc even when say their names it’s ALWAYS “Fred and George” in that order (I have identical twin cousins Alec and Erik and I feel like Alec is always said more bc their names are always in that order) 🤷🏻♀️
I once was friends with identical twins, a lot of people would ask me how I can tell the difference between them and to be honest... I never did know the difference I just had a feeling I knew who was who and I was right all the time 😅
I have an identical twin sister, and if she died I dont know how I would go on.....I always feel sad in this part of the movie when the twin dies its so sad and hard for me to watch. But I am glad to hear the remaining twin is doing good :)
In terms of getting with his brothers Ex I kinda like thinking its because of the Traits unique to Fred that made their relationship fail , making them decide to break up , where George's Unique traits and their mutual close bond with and loss of Fred made them the more compatible Match and ultimately allowed the relationship to take root and bare fruit. Aswell as keeping Fred's memory alive ^^
I can only imagine that the actors who played the twins had a real hard time shooting some of the scenes in the final movie, especially the one where Fred dies. If there wasn't crying on set that day I would be surprised.
Yeah i always love that when fred says remember george always opening sentence was from fred.i wish rowling should not had killed fred in the end coz it was tregedy beyond bearance if i had a twin who died like fred i definately would had killed myself too what kind of life u can have when your soulmate is gone
No they said they didn’t because they didn’t mess around at the expense of production and didn’t want to be responsible for the filming process being messed up and delayed because it’s stressful as it is. But they did play a couple of small pranks
Video idea for you to do: What additional effects do spells have that are not seen in the movies? For instance, what else can the patronus charm do besides ward off dementors?
Also, (I think) Fred usually appears screen left, and George screen right when the two are involved together in scenes. Am I right? I still can't keep the brothers Phelps straight, however. Odd...
These two are some of my favorite characters one because they’re awesome and two because there were two red headed twins that always fooled around in my band class they are the real life version of Fred and George
My wife's mother was an identical twin. She told me that her mother wasn't the same at all after she lost her aunt in a very tragic way, to the extent that she (the wife) had to take on the role of parent at 13, while her mother essentially took on the life of a wild, rebellious teenager. She also had to be prescribed Paxil for depression and suicidal tendencies. Her mother would also go on drinking binges sometimes - she recalls the time her mother and her pet chicken got drunk on New Years'. After around 30 years after the death of her twin, she started acting more like an adult and taking up responsible endeavors. She died a few years ago and never stopped missing her twin.
I’m seriously considering having Fred survive in my fanfic where Dudley Dursley is a wizard, he ends up being a much better person, probably ends up idolizing Mad Eye.
3:11 Kind of like Phineas and Ferb? 6:05 Also, I believe George was the one that didn't beat the * out of Draco (though not for a lack of trying). Also, thanks for proving that Fred spoke first.
Thanks for the video but I do have a request to hear your thoughts on the new footage for hogwarts legacy game after the new state of play trailer just dropped
I know in MANY fanfictions George Weasley has a mole and Fred does not whether or not. It is just creative license or not is up to the reader it how in certain works of fanfiction one can tell the twins apart
I knew the physical differences and the personality differences (the pranks part) but I think I got Fred and George exactly mismatched. Fred was the one with the longer rounder face and George was the one with the shorter and slightly more squarish face.
Yo just wondering I love harry potter but I never understood why the ministry didn't use thruth potions to ask harry if Voldemort was back in order of the Phoenix or to question any possible death eater?
My list (only 7😂) 1. One is named Fred and one George 2. George lost an ear Fred did not 3. Fred died George did not 4. He's not Fred I am 6. George married Angelina Fred did not 7. Gred is better than forge
I have an unrelated question! One of the elemental rules is you can’t magic food. But, we’ve seen inanimate objects being transfigured into animals… so. Seems like a hungry wizard could transfigure a rock into a chicken. Food!
Fred did drive the car but he didn't plan everything fred wasn't behind it all they both were you know why? Because they are brothers and they have the biggest bond in the whole movies and books this video is a scam george is awesome and so is fred but you don't have to lie to everybody
Thanks for watching everyone! If you enjoy the content please LIKE the video and SUBSCRIBE to help support the channel.
how did you do those emojis?
Didn't you already do a video like this ? I feel like I have already seen it
I’m glad that you covered this. Just because Fred and George are twins doesn’t mean they don’t have their own personalities/traits. They fed off of each other but were also quite different in their own ways.
Agreed!
True but fred didn't plan it all they did together because they are brothers and they have an amazing bond they made the joke shop stuff together I repeat fred didn't plan it all other wise it might aswell just be weasley wizard wheezes not weasleys wizard wheezes
I would bet that to their family and closest friends they were easy to distinguish. I have twin friends who are now young men in college, but I have known them since they were born, taught them in Sunday school at every age, and got them hooked on the Dresden Files books. They are very different to me, and easy to tell apart. It’s nice that JKR treated them like real people with differences.
My son is reading book 5 now, and just got to the triumphant exit from Hogwarts. He probably can tell something bad is coming because I have trouble hiding my feelings from him as we talk about my favorite characters who are now his, Fred and George.
My late father, he died of pancreatic cancer in 2015, was the "lead singer " of a set of identical twins. My uncle has described as it as losing a part of one's self, quite literally. Identical twins share everything, literally everything, and to have one die....it seems to be against nature itself. My uncle, like George Weasley, has had to go on. It truly is getting used to a new normal, albeit an incomplete one.
🥺
They will meet again. Life on earth is like a fleeting wind. Our true home resides in the realm beyond with our Creator.
I hope that at least can bring comfort. It certainly does for me.
I've a cousin who married one of a pair of identical twins. He died from cancer only a few years ago. It was very devastating for his brother.
George in the books is the more subtle, docile twin but more active in Quidditch. I love their small differences. I also love how their mum can't tell them apart sometimes but Ron always can.
Fred and George were born on April Fools, that makes sense because they always pull pranks and jokes. It's not like every person born on April 1 has to do that but sometimes it kinda makes sense
i was born on April fools too lmao
SAMEEEE
I was born April 2nd
I think Fred should have appeared as a ghost in the books, jump scaring everybody even better and doing mischief. They could have run the store together. It would have been a lot of fun. 😊
this would be brilliant 🤩
Sadly, becoming a ghost in the Wizarding World is a fate "worse than death", because they can't feel any physical pleasure, only have limited interactions with the physical world, and if you have "unfinished business", you cannot "move on" even after you finished conducting said business. That's why a lot of wizards prefer to move on after death.
Thanks -- I often wonder how great the two might have become had Fred survived
Going into the final book, I'd have thought that if you had to have a Weasley die, it would be Percy. Even with this explanation, I'd still be confused about the brothers. It's good to know that George and Angelina could at least find comfort in each other's company, even though they'd both grieve for a long time.
I'd like to know more about George and Angelina,if possible. Thanks
@@sandisteinberg731 Me too.
I noticed this isn't just the differences of the Weasley twins but also the Phelps Twins! And Keep up at your amazingly informative channel!
This is a beautiful analysis of the two and spot on. Yes, Fred seems to have been the “Mischievous in Chief” here, but of course, George was always a willing accomplice.
It’s great how the differences between the twins are actually kinda built into their names. Fred is Firstborn, but also their names are in alphabetical order to reflect their birth order. Fred had a shorter name and a shorter life. George had a longer name, and talked at greater length. Even when it comes to quidditch, George’s longer name can be used to remember that he involved himself more in the game.
One of my best friends who adopted me as her little brother took in two cats and apply named them Fred and George. She loved Harry Potter, I was resistant at the time but eventually came around. I miss you big sis, you were right - HP is good.
I've always thought their personality differences were super apparent in the books, but that could be because I've had several twins as friends growing up.
And I've always thought Hermoine should have ended up with George. She was always so impressed with their magic skills and George was super thoughtful and could easily see others' needs
I read somewhere that after Fred's death George was not able to conjure a patronus at all no matter how hard he tried.
Because all his happy memories he shared with Fred and thinking of him made him sad ..
:(
This is genuinely something that I had been quite thoroughly thinking about while rereading the books. Thank you for all the interesting information.
Fantastic video mate! I recently lost a very close friend who was a twin. You made me laugh and cry simultaneously. That’s good art.
hey thanks for constantly uploading content.
are u excited about the new dumbledore movie?
You bet!
The best channel for Harry Potter updates! Love and support from India 🇮🇳
P.S. Thank you for the ❤️ 😀😀
I think Fred is listed more bc even when say their names it’s ALWAYS “Fred and George” in that order (I have identical twin cousins Alec and Erik and I feel like Alec is always said more bc their names are always in that order) 🤷🏻♀️
_What has 8 legs as an infant, 4 legs at 20 and 2 legs for the rest of it's life?_
*George Weasley* 😢😭
I once was friends with identical twins, a lot of people would ask me how I can tell the difference between them and to be honest... I never did know the difference I just had a feeling I knew who was who and I was right all the time 😅
I have an identical twin sister, and if she died I dont know how I would go on.....I always feel sad in this part of the movie when the twin dies its so sad and hard for me to watch. But I am glad to hear the remaining twin is doing good :)
In terms of getting with his brothers Ex I kinda like thinking its because of the Traits unique to Fred that made their relationship fail , making them decide to break up , where George's Unique traits and their mutual close bond with and loss of Fred made them the more compatible Match and ultimately allowed the relationship to take root and bare fruit.
Aswell as keeping Fred's memory alive ^^
I have a way of telling them apart, its just what u said actually, i like to say that george is the more "warm" twin-
I can only imagine that the actors who played the twins had a real hard time shooting some of the scenes in the final movie, especially the one where Fred dies. If there wasn't crying on set that day I would be surprised.
Yeah i always love that when fred says remember george always opening sentence was from fred.i wish rowling should not had killed fred in the end coz it was tregedy beyond bearance if i had a twin who died like fred i definately would had killed myself too what kind of life u can have when your soulmate is gone
Love your channel :)!
Thank-you!
@@HarryPotterTheory np😀
In Theory’s mellow, calming voice: “Number One. One isn’t fucking dead.”
tell the weaknesses of all the villain in harry potter
Did Oliver and James switch between Fred and George? They could try to trick us when trying to recognise them. I would if had a twin :D
No they said they didn’t because they didn’t mess around at the expense of production and didn’t want to be responsible for the filming process being messed up and delayed because it’s stressful as it is. But they did play a couple of small pranks
Video idea for you to do:
What additional effects do spells have that are not seen in the movies? For instance, what else can the patronus charm do besides ward off dementors?
Wow, you have been doing this for quite a long time.
It's was almost impossible to differentiate between the on looks alone in the movies.
Not to mention it’s always Fred then George on screen from left to right except for the last time we saw them speak before the battle of Hogwarts :)
Good to know!
Also, (I think) Fred usually appears screen left, and George screen right when the two are involved together in scenes. Am I right? I still can't keep the brothers Phelps straight, however. Odd...
Thanks I already knew a bit of this but then I watched this video and it really expanded more on things that I didn’t understand
These two are some of my favorite characters one because they’re awesome and two because there were two red headed twins that always fooled around in my band class they are the real life version of Fred and George
For Ron helping I thought that was only for a brief time before he became an auror
George, the quiet Beatle, I mean the quiet Weasley twin...
My wife's mother was an identical twin. She told me that her mother wasn't the same at all after she lost her aunt in a very tragic way, to the extent that she (the wife) had to take on the role of parent at 13, while her mother essentially took on the life of a wild, rebellious teenager. She also had to be prescribed Paxil for depression and suicidal tendencies. Her mother would also go on drinking binges sometimes - she recalls the time her mother and her pet chicken got drunk on New Years'. After around 30 years after the death of her twin, she started acting more like an adult and taking up responsible endeavors. She died a few years ago and never stopped missing her twin.
I’m seriously considering having Fred survive in my fanfic where Dudley Dursley is a wizard, he ends up being a much better person, probably ends up idolizing Mad Eye.
I never wondered what the difference was
Also I was the first view and first comment
@@ducky2846 me
They don’t have the same fingerprints. This is a result that occurs during pregnancy and varies even with identical twins.
3:11 Kind of like Phineas and Ferb?
6:05 Also, I believe George was the one that didn't beat the * out of Draco (though not for a lack of trying).
Also, thanks for proving that Fred spoke first.
Good day to you
You too
knew most of the physical differences of the movie characters from prior videos on this channel.
What about the differences between the Phelps twins? Can you interview them and do a video on this topic with them?
Wait a minute, wait a minute. You mean the two greatest pranksters in all of fiction history were born on April Fools'? Damn, no wonder.
Thanks for the video but I do have a request to hear your thoughts on the new footage for hogwarts legacy game after the new state of play trailer just dropped
somebody on tiktok said that fred looks like he wants to commit arson and george looks like he's just happy to be involved and i love it
I only reached 2:38 without crying. I pause it for comment and tears, now play. :(
Tell me few things which are mentioned in books but not in movie.
F&G Forever
I would have loved to see Hermione with one of the twins. Opposites attract. Hi from Australia
Thank goodness twins have differences, otherwise, good luck differentiating them.
I know in MANY fanfictions George Weasley has a mole and Fred does not whether or not. It is just creative license or not is up to the reader it how in certain works of fanfiction one can tell the twins apart
I knew the physical differences and the personality differences (the pranks part) but I think I got Fred and George exactly mismatched. Fred was the one with the longer rounder face and George was the one with the shorter and slightly more squarish face.
Can you upload top 5 best fathers and top 5 best mothers?
I read somewhere that when you see them on screen the one on the left is allways the same and the one on the right is too.
I've said for years that James is the more handsome, in my opinion
Feel like I've seen this..
I was born on April fools day :)
They should make the actor that plays fred charlie if it is needed charlie can have makeup he is supposed to look similar.
When is the fourth episode of "what happened to these 10 characters after Deathly Hallows" coming out?
It’s obvious to recognize isn’t it? If you see one of them, it must be George since Fred’s gone 🥲🥲🥲
...
Yo just wondering I love harry potter but I never understood why the ministry didn't use thruth potions to ask harry if Voldemort was back in order of the Phoenix or to question any possible death eater?
I think they knew Voldemort was back but didn’t want to admit it.
Because it was more that they didn’t want to admit it, they were in denial because of fear they were deliberately being stupid
My list (only 7😂)
1. One is named Fred and one George
2. George lost an ear Fred did not
3. Fred died George did not
4. He's not Fred I am
6. George married Angelina Fred did not
7. Gred is better than forge
It's not a "mole" it's a freckle. Didn't know about the scar on eyebrow? Now I need to investigate 🕵️
I have an unrelated question! One of the elemental rules is you can’t magic food. But, we’ve seen inanimate objects being transfigured into animals… so. Seems like a hungry wizard could transfigure a rock into a chicken. Food!
I thought, don't trust me for 100%, that the movies always put Fred on the left and George on the right to set them apart
Just watch the Phelps’ UA-cam channel, the Normal Not Normal podcast. You’ll soon see the differences.
Great job fred👏 👍
One is a alive and one is dead?
This was made for Molly Weasley.
🙏✌️fred
Before watching this. If one of the differences isn't "ones dead" I will be disappointed
I think it's Fred and George because it sounds better than the opposite.
Hello
Fred did drive the car but he didn't plan everything fred wasn't behind it all they both were you know why? Because they are brothers and they have the biggest bond in the whole movies and books this video is a scam george is awesome and so is fred but you don't have to lie to everybody
In movies, one of them has the deepest voice. Is it Fred?
Yeah, Fred has the deeper voice
Was that really ten? I want counting…
JK is Slytherin and not in a good way because their are good ones im marrying one xxx
swag
Hi
One had red hair
Wait a minute
Love 💕 from Pakistan
Magical number 7 comment!
Under 301 view club