MCDM Plays Dune - Round 4
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- MCDM plays Avalon Hill's legendary DUNE board game! This week we are joined by Lindz and Zach Madere.
💝 Support us on the MCDM Patreon | / mcdm
📚 Enhance your game with MCDM products from our Shop!
shop.mcdmprodu...
🐦 Follow us on Twitter!
MCDM - / hellomcdm
Matt - / mattcolville
💬 Join the conversation on the MCDM Discord!
mcdm.gg/discord
#mcdm #mcdmplays #dune #boardgames
O ' D: "We should play this once a month" Everyone Else: Agrees. State of the World: "And then they never played Dune again."
So true; so sad
Too true 😢
Watching this in 2024, I wish you guys could get back together and play this regularly. I adored all 4 rounds and not many play this game at all.
As someone who adores the game but lacks the 5 people to play with, I loved watching you guys play!
I just got this game and the book. I’m so excited to get my gaming group to try it out. Aaahh
Rules end at 7:02
You will have a blast. Dune is coming back in a big way now that the harkonnen are in the Whitehouse.
Beware the book spoiler at 43:15. Skip ahead to 45:00 to avoid it.
@@cl0udbear that is very thoughtful of you but at the same, 30 40 years is a long lead time for spoilers lol
@@fuchila2point0 Plenty of people just got into the book because of MCDM streaming this game. Someone in the chat during the stream had this spoiled for them by Matt, as did I.
@@cl0udbear I'm with you. Everything gets spoiled for me as i check things out with reviews and such before putting more time into it. You are right.
YASSS PLEASE PLAY THIS ONCE A MONTH !!!! THANK YOU
I SECOND THIS! THE SPICE SHALL FLOW!
The world said "no", but hopefully it comes back once this whole mess is all over :P
Love Dune. Hope you find time to play again.
Yes yes yes!!!!
Waiting for Dune Round 5!
These Dune videos have made me start reading the book. Just got the the part where he gets his name.
Same. I've been curious about the game for years now, and now that it's out again, I've finally taken the plunge and started the book series.
@@drodjenkins I tried watching the movie - the one with Sting. I got about 30 minutes in and I just did not get it at all. Seems like I will have to try the book
@@bunnythekid The book is really good paired with lore vids about the world. I have ADHD so reading is an endeavor for me, but surrounding myself with Dune stuff got me hyped up for the book and now I'm hooked.
D-rod Jenkins I recently got diagnosed myself, at the tender age of 28! Reading can be difficult for me too, so I might look into getting an audiobook. I’d recommend you try it too. I listened to all of the available game of thrones books recently - something I doubt I could have ever read.
@@bunnythekid There may or may not be a decent professional Dune audiobook right here on UA-cam.
I want to see Colville as the Fremen, and OD as the Bene Gesserit. My reason? OD's predictions are so random that they must be true
Give OD some centuries head start to plant his myths and his prophecy will come true.
First of all, I love watching these!
Please, be aware that when you choose to dismiss the 'pay to count full force' rule, you actually alter the balance of the game quite significantly:
- The Fremen's advantage of not having to pay is there to counteract the fact that they're very poor.
- The Bene Gesserit rely more on the use of their powerful leaders combined with the Voice ability, rather than the sheer number of troops. Not paying spice to make forces count full strength makes BG significantly weaker.
- The Emperor's Sardaukar are much more cost-efficient than regular forces for the same cost.
- It's much harder to guess what your opponent is going to choose on the wheel, if they have to pay for it as well.
The rule is very thematic: a small number of well supplied troops may be able to match a large force of undersupplied ones, you make killing leaders all the more important, you make the Fremen's mastery of the environment apparent, and you add another layer of mind games.
Also:
- Bene Gesserit start with one advisor in any territory, apart from the warrior in the Polar Sink.
- The number of players allowed to have forces in a given territory is only limited to two if the territory is a stronghold.
It's extremely difficult for the Fremen to win with the rule set that they're playing, and extremely easy for the Guild to win. And lo and behold, that's exactly what has been happening.
This is a high quality comment, thank you very much for sharing.
100% agree! We always play with all the advanced rules (including spice-supported combat); the complexity of spice-combat is greatly exaggerated, imo, and worth the table figuring out so that the Fremen player can have a chance.
What's most confusing to me, though, is why they are playing with double spice blows if they're dropping spice combat.
yep. While their games are fun to watch, they are terribly unbalanced. And i disagree with the sentiment "playing with a weak side is good because winning is more rewarding".
I really like assymetrical games, but this is no reason to not have at least close winning percentages. Id say the gf9 ruleset does help to balance the factions.
They're also not doing the Fremen "you can start units in the storm if you let half die".
16:30 "2 hour is a lot"
I've watched all 4 of these in a row... haven't played the game yet, this is research!
Please bring back "MCDM Plays". I'd especially love to see more Dune, but even a simple game like Codenames would be awesome!
I see the length is 1h 18m... where is the other 5 hours?
Bring on round 5! This was super interesting to see a shorter length game. And I'll say it again the music adds the best atmosphere!
I truly am indebt to you guys. I really didn't understand this game when it popped up on my radar and when I watched a review of it, it just seemed like a jumbled mess that was hard to understand. Soon after in early November I saw your first installment of Dune and was like holy crap this game seems amazing. Got my copy, have played two 6 player games since and it is my all time favorite game. Thank you so much for uploading these because they are so entertaining along with everything else. I was able to catch this one on stream but wow what a game this 4th round of it was, I'm also a third of the way through the book now too!
You should check out the Dune Board game discord server (TTS games)
Wow! That's so cool!! I'm so happy folks are discovering this brilliant game. And the book! :D Go forth Evin and spread the word!!
@@mcolville Wait until they play Talisman!
Exactly this. I saw a few reviews and really just wrote this game off. it seemed incredibly fiddly and unnecessary complicated. But after these videos I have preordered myself a copy. Did a really good job of convincing me that it is manageable if everybody is into it and kind of gets their powers.
I watched the SUSD review and thought, meh its ok I guess, but watching this I am totally sold on the game. sadly I do not have enough friends willing to give up 3-4 hrs for a game. We normally play Battle for Rokugan. Not as thematic but a great game nonetheless.
These Dune games are the most entertaining board game videos I've ever seen.
@MCDM please bring these back!
Game needs a deluxe edition. Wood board with a track for the stained glass storm pie wedge. Resin minis for troops and colored crystals for spice.
Second
It would be great and horrible at the same time, just imagine the amount of money you’d need to spend on it, already loving it :v
Shut up and take my money omg.
you gonna pay $500.00 for it?
how would minis as troops fit on the board? :,D
I love when yall play dune. I can play codenames or Whitehall with friends... but getting 5 other people to commit to learning how to play a game this complex hasn't happened for me yet.
I hope you continue playing games yall enjoy because your enthusiasm makes it entertaining, I just hope yall continue to enjoy Dune!
Man, I miss these gaming sessions! It was such a delight discovering Dune and finding these people play Dune!
The Game starts around the 13:45 if you want to skip the rules/intro
Thank you so much!!! Was looking for this!!! :)
real MVP. I get it is a complicated game, but the good content is rendered almost unwatchable with the repetitive rule tirades.
Perfect, thanks Matt and the crew. We were all waiting for the 4th installment of Dune with y'all. Bravo. We had a fantastic game at my home last week and I won as the bene because of guessing Paul would win on round 8. Fantastic twist. He thought he had it. 4 hour game and a blast.
I wish MCDM would show us the card they are bidding. It would be a nice addition.
Not a bad idea, we don't keep track like the players might be doing, maybe if it wasn't too much work it could be shown on screen?
brilliant idea!
@@ShanomoBro would be easy to implement with a poker card-cam.
Their camera set up is insane already. A camera for each player, the board, a zoom. That's a lot to juggle.
Please continue this series! So good!
“We should play once a month!” Weeks later, Coronavirus: “Oh, I don’t think so.”
I would so love an episode of this with Matt fully awake.
The issue with the alternate bidding, it shouldn't be the first player each time, it should be the first bidder that gets priority.
Game as so few turns, it gives massive advantage to whoever is first, they just need to equal best bid, never exceed it.
First bidder moving around the table counters that, each player have a chance to be first for each bidding.
Another alternative idea would be to have a 2nd (or 3rd, 4th, etc.) round of blind bidding, just between the tied players. This would be how much they want to ADD to their initial bid. This would probably not take that much longer and would help avoid the issue of turn-order priority advantage.
Or, you could have everyone put in the maximum they are willing to spend, at the start. Then have the winner only pay the 2nd highest bid +1 (not all that they put in). This might work out to a similar spend as if bidding is done like normal.
Seeing how everyone gets to bid first, this isn’t an issue.
YESSSSSS I watched your guys first 3 games, and immediatly got it for myself. I created 200 small "spice" vials with mica powder and played a few rounds with friends. Keep it up!!!
That sounds pretty cool.
How exactly?
@@MrMarkWilcoxon look up 0.5ml glass vial with cork on amazon, and then fill with whatever kind of pigment you want, bonus for using differently sized vials for 1, 5, and 10. ( I used a copperish resin pigment).
Thank you all, because so much passion you put in the setting and those gameplay, I've returned after a long time to audiobook, and also compulsively bought the 2019 version - we've played one game so far and it was a blast, I knew I'd love this game watching you, but now I have 5 more people loving it as much as I do. Stay cool and provide quality content.
Also, Matt I need your in depth series about Dune!
Also in first game I lost as Bene Gesserit only because I predicted win by Harkonnens on turn 7 and they were 1 men short of winning the game (I even was able to stop the storm after Family Atomics to make sure they'd win)
I so hoped that Matt would reveal that he predicted that. It would have been amazing.
Hopefully they start doing these again. If they do, they should do what TotalBiscuit did and add a 5-30 minute “anti-spoiler” at the end so you don’t know exactly when it will end. Not needed for games that end at turn 7 (or other games that end at specified point)
Please play this game again! I love this game and its so interesting to watch other play groups duke it out for Arrakis!
Looks like Zach(Atreides) looked at each treachery card(6 total) before bidding began on the first treachery card began(1st round).
Unless I am mistaken,
Atreides should only be able to look at the current treachery card up for bid.
Which they explained later in the vid...lol
"Someone has to stop Tom" in a low stage whisper. I see what you did there Matt.
I think I prefer betting on Treachery Cards one by one rather than the simultaneous reveals, it takes longer but gives more opportunity for mind games and driving the price up.
I agree
The emperor gets the money, right? My guess is that simultaneous bidding means less money for the emperor.
And you can Karama a card that is currently in a bidding war.
oh my god finally more dune, i've been quivering with anticipation for far too long!
I applaud your choice of words. Gets the point across vividly.
I would love a new episode that includes the expansion with the Ixian and Tleilaxu factions.
wish there were more Dune gameplay videos! the first four convinced me to pick up the game myself, my gaming group and i have had a blast every time we've played it
Hello. It's funny you should say: "There's no way to say the imperial bassin is safe from the sand storm"...because it's the one thing they did in this edition. If you look, desert zones have a normal, single line border. Mountains and safe zones have a double line border. Arrakeen, Cartagh and the zone protected by the wall have a double line border but the second line is dotted to denote that it's not "permanent". My mind got (spice) blown by this piece of UI :)
Matt is playing a print 'n play version from years ago, gf9 used tha same artwork but modded some aspects including this for clarity.
I'd recommend a Vickrey auction in the future, where the winner pays the second-highest bid. It incentivizes bidding your true value, and is equivalent to an English auction (almost what you were doing before) while this bidding system is not. It really is just a speedy version of the normal bidding system. Essentially, the winner only has to pay just enough to beat the second-highest bid. You can do second-highest bid plus one for exact equivalence.
These videos are how I found your channel and I absolutely love them. I love watching you play and I like that you guys know the game well enough that you can play quickly.
I don’t like the changes you made to bidding this time around as much. But you guys are awesome. Keep kicking ass.
We need more rounds!!!!
A new gameplay with Tleilaxu and Richese will be great, hope a new chapter someday
Bring this series back Matt! These were so fun
that truth trance was so anticlimactic haha
Perfect timing, I had just finished watching Round 3.
More! I've watched all 4 episodes so far, this is my favorite series on the channel.
No advanced combat really puts the Fremen at a disadvantage, and makes the spice economy overflow with money for shipment and revivals.
Agreed! Not sure why they are still playing double spice blow if they aren't doing spice-supported combat.
I know it's hard to get together with all the shit that's happening right now, but this is GOOD UA-cam!!! Colville & Co. Are just great people! And Dune is my favorite game, so it's a win/win.
Please more DUNE! ..and more Anna!
I really hope you guys can play this again, only just discovered this series and game and I love it
Matt! You need to turn up your game as Bene Gesserit. Seeing the win coming, that coexisting needed to end with lasgun :)
I know right? It's like he's not even trying :(
Been roping my friends into playing Dune with me for the last few weeks, and it's every bit as amazing as it is to watch. Just last game we had double traitor, blown up shieldwall and lazgun shield explosion all within first three rounds.
And doubly thank you for introducing me to a world I've been lost in since I watched the first round of this mess.
I just want to thank you all. I am a Dune fan but never knew about the game. Your videos pushed me to buy the GF9 remake: I do not regret it one bit. One of the best experiences ever.
Kudos to all of you!
ps: I love being my group Spiritual Advisor. :D
I can't wait until you play this again. These videos got me into the game and therefore the books
The advanced rule that requires supporting your troops in combat is bothersome, but not using it puts the Fremen at a significant disadvantage within the context of the advanced rules, since they are the exception to that rule, always fighting at full strength. This way you're nerfing the Fremen quite severely, you should homebrew together some bonus for them to offset that.
The same-time reveal for the bidding phase is much better than the normal way !
Played my first game of GF9s Dune yesterday after watching MCDMs videos and now there is a new one. I'm a happy camper.
You are the prophet sent to us by Shai Hulud!
All of you. :) Been a huge Dune fan for years. I never knew this existed until I just binged it a week ago. Thank you!
alternate bidding is a good idea. Here's a proposal on how to incorporate the Atreides "ability" to drive the prize on useless cards: let them reveal how much they're willing to pay first and then let all others choose their prize and reveal those at the same time.
Really wish more vids of you playing Dune!
Mooooore Dune!! I just played my first game of it and you guys are the reason why I went and got it in the first place. Won as the Benes btw, but with brutal force :D
yes yes yes, i got the game after watching your streams, even made my own acrylic spice!
By cutting a bunch of acrylic in different sizes? :D
Awesome game. This is a perfect example of how short this game CAN be. Perfect!
I just got my copy of the new Expansion and I can't wait to play! It adds the Ixians & Tleilaxu as playable factions. Both seem pretty interesting.
Played it a week ago. What's your opinion? From my expirience: Tleilaxu are too rich and as a result too strong, while Ixians are too weak because their total combat strength can be only 20,5 but suboids were not meant for combat usage so total strengh goes down to only 14 which is absolutely nothing. Also they break the game with everyone starting with 2 cards that's why guild or other late game factions get enough treachery to rush from the first turn. And in 6 player game it becomes a real problem to watch not 5 but 7! victory points and prevent only 3 of them beeing controled by somebody. New cards are amazing though, especially poison tooth.
@@HeadHunterFett Super late reply but I finally got to play! I agree with you, but have one caveat. When playing with six players; I keep the Tleilaxu and ditch the Bene Gesserit. IMO the Bene Gesserit & the Ixians are too weak to play. So I leave them out unless someone at the table wants to try them.
@@gjpokey Thx for the answer, it's never too late)
I SAW THIS AND WENT KULL WAHAD
I FINISHED THE BOOK AGAIN TODAY FOR THE FIFTH TIME BLESS THE MAKER FOR THIS.
I'm rather excited. Can't wait to watch it. Hope you guys play even more :D
LOL! When I saw the duration of the video, I was like... "Uh. Somebody won fast!" :D GG TOM!
I really hope you guys are getting through 2020 without taking too much damage and I look forward to once more see all of you play Dune again, since your videos are the best in terms of quality and entertainment!
Since we didn't get a stream of the North Africa campaign, I say we should get a new round of Dune games going.
Another great game. Don't really like the new bidding method that was used at all as bidding is one of my favorite parts of the Dune game, but hey man, each table to their own! Loving watching through these games.
This is f***ing fantastic, is there any more of this coming up? I'm going out tomorrow to find this game to buy! xD
Glad this video got uploaded I watched the first 3 and will be buying a copy and playing my first game tomorrow
These Dune games were fun to watch :)
"Tom, Fuck off, Tom."
Love it.
I love watching these games
I can see how playing with the Teleilaxu would make things more complex. If both sides lose lots of troops they can make out like bandits and then throw their own guys in bum rushes because they can use the money they just got to bring outer people's armies back and bring their own back making a battle of attrition.
I've really enjoyed watching your MCDM Plays Dune series. It's a great game, but it's a challenge for me to get 6 players together, so this is a great substitute for actually playing! I would love to see you play another game using some of the factions from the expansions.
Ohh.. new invention in bidding looks quite controversial. It makes less spice for the Emperor
Also spoils his alliance "power", unless you communicate very quickly with your partner before each bid.
Watching the first three episodes inspired me to buy the first Dune book, which I promptly finished in 4 days. Absolutely amazing book; thanks for the inspiration!
Just played my first game with 3 other friends who hadn't even heard about the Dune universe and it was really fun, looking forward to bring in another two friends and play a proper game.
more Dune please!
Reminder to play more Dune pls (:
I think the alt bidding you're after is.
1. Eligible bidders willing to pay 1 put hand up (or other clear signal)
2. Keep hand up if willing to lay 2
3. Repeat 2 until a winner of bid (only 1 person goes to next price) or everyone left dropped out
4. If it was a tie, roll a die or whatever to chose at random between tied players.
I love these playthroughs, i was really hoping you guys would do another one. I like the once a month idea, I'll be watching each one. Keep up the amazing work!
Gotta say, this was probably my favorite game so far. Great job, Tom!
Its 2021. More dune please
Just finished all of these, they're great, thanks!
I have thoroughly enjoyed watching these games! Love the game concept, mechanics and intricate political power struggle. I was mildly disappointed to see Matt play Bene Gesserit again, only because I would like to see a veteran player show different faction strategies. Lars is a stellar Harkonnen player, but I would like to see his Guild or Bene Gesserit play as well. At the time of writing this, I'm only 21 minutes in, so I'm holding out hope for a Bene Prediction victory!
Dang! 3 rounds off Matt, well played all!
"They look like candy!" Me: mmmm spice-y candy ;)
Is it actually „beaming down“, or is it flying down with transporters?
It's actually just flying down. The world of Dune has no sense of Star Trek style transporters. It just seems easier to understand when describing the rules to newer players.
I love your Dune rounds!
YES! Please play more. Please forever.
Love these, keep going. Prefer the proper bidding, more tension!
@MCDM now that the movie is out could I humbly request a return to this marvelous game?
I like this way of bidding. Going to try it out next time.
Oh My God, THANK YOU SO MUCH. I thought you guys stopped doing this series. Btw, how do u think the strength of Fremen is without the advanced battle rule (Since they don't have to pay for full strength)
I've thought the same. I am considering making the Freeman able to double their troop strength, which is essentially the advantage they have. But probably limit them to three spice.
@@lukehanson_ I'm thinking about this: if in a battle against Fremen with their star force present, fremen's opponent must play like the advanced rule (pay for full strength) this will work in conjunction with only single spice blow to make game clean.
@@muchendai1361 that's an interesting idea. But I think the double spice is important to help basically all other factors keep up with the Guild and Emperor's economy, it also makes more of the game happen outside the strongholds. So I personally would want to keep that.
I also would avoid that adjustment because you will have to explain how half strength battles work, I'm just very opposed to dialing half numbers on battle wheels.
Matt: "I fucking love this game."
Also Matt: "THIS GAME BLOWS!!!"
I think the 'tie in bidding goes to the first player' would work better if the 'first player' rotated after each card being bid on
Hoy should play the gane with 7 players and include the faction that Matt told about. So we can see how does work the Bene Tleilax.!!
When I finally get around to playing, I’m definitely gonna use that quick bidding process.
The fast bidding is neat, but it seems like it reeeeally hurts the Emperor's pocketbook.
Should continue this series please!
Wow, crazy fast game. I'd definitely love to see you guys playing more often.
Looks like Hulud was indeed shy today >.>