The Best Planned City in the World: Olmsted, Vaux, and the Buffalo Park System

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @jimsheibley4125
    @jimsheibley4125 7 днів тому +7

    I am thankful for the wisdom of creating the Conservancy to preserve this design and legacy.

    • @artshake9524
      @artshake9524 6 днів тому +1

      Agreed, I have great admiration for those with the foresight to invest in the future of Buffalo. A society grows great when 'citizens with vision' plant trees in whose shade they shall never sit

  • @Ascertivon
    @Ascertivon Рік тому +8

    Quality video on some quality landmarks. Excellent content.

  • @craignunnallypurcell
    @craignunnallypurcell 6 років тому +16

    Olmsted’s work has stood the test of time.

  • @debean5670
    @debean5670 9 років тому +32

    My grandfather was born on Sidney St., off of Fillmore Ave., near E. Ferry, in 1910. He used to speak fondly of Humboldt Parkway and its beautiful trees. As a boy, it was his job to carry a ladder up and down the parkway and climb the old gas street lamps to put them out, before school (by the mid-late 1920s, there were still approximately 10,000 working gas street lamps in the city of Buffalo). He was devastated when they blasted the canyon through that neighborhood to put in the expressway.

    • @craigellsworth3952
      @craigellsworth3952 Рік тому

      @debean5670 My GGGG Grandfather was on the other side of the border. In exchange for his service he was given 200 acres of land at the brink of the Canadian falls. It extended from the waterfall to what is now Lundy's Lane. His first name was Francis.

    • @RobertaFierro-mc1ub
      @RobertaFierro-mc1ub Місяць тому

      All his memories were rooted there.

  • @racker9999
    @racker9999 5 років тому +9

    Thank you for this splendid presentation which hopefully will inspire a renaissance in the Olmsted/Vaux model of humanistic thought and action.

  • @HansBjorgman
    @HansBjorgman 6 років тому +6

    5:30 That tree to the left is like a bunch of trees formed together.

    • @releventhurt
      @releventhurt 10 місяців тому

      Its possibly regrowth of the original single trunk that they didnt thin out

  • @bobweber4140
    @bobweber4140 3 дні тому +1

    Thankyou lived in buffalo my whole life very in formative

  • @kenhunt5153
    @kenhunt5153 14 днів тому +3

    A National treasure.

  • @ezafcrash3986
    @ezafcrash3986 6 днів тому +4

    I had no idea that my city was regarded so highly. I am a student at University of Toronto going into urban planning, and a large part of that reason is to try and help Buffalo. When I think of my hometown, I think of the bone-headedness that went into its design in the 50s and 60s. Despite the fact I live in an area of the suburbs that wasn’t even conceived when olmstead drew up his designs, I am only a short distance from his park system. It’s really sad to hear that the east side once had a great parkway, matching like the one on the west side. It’s so frustrating to hear not only that it was destroyed, but that it ended up cutting off the east side in an act of systematic racism. For those who don’t know, the new Humboldt parkway is LITERALLY cut into the ground in a massive trench. It has very few bridges and it isolated majority black neighborhoods. In the time since, the East Side became the most unstable part of the city. Buffalo needs to become a leader again in development city-wide, as well as equity and fairness for the east side especially. It all starts with the planting of trees, access to green space, and good ways to access these amenities. Here’s to hoping they rebuild Humboldt parkway and make this city into the place Buffalonians deserve. Go Bills!!

    • @elwoodstanislav9068
      @elwoodstanislav9068 5 днів тому

      Good for you, this is a really inspiring video that shows all the bones of the city are already there, they just need to be brought back to the surface. I encourage you to dedicate yourself to this vision, I think it is worth it.

  • @andrewbnash
    @andrewbnash 11 років тому +79

    Let's bring back some of the progressive thinking that inspired the parks and parkways illustrated in this film. Let's tear down the expressways built through Buffalo's parks and build a sustainable transport system linked to community based economic development. That's the future, Buffalo could lead the way.

    • @seanjankowski9016
      @seanjankowski9016 9 років тому +12

      Andrew Nash I agree. It is also funny, that expressway. I saw another documentary with the politicians in Buffalo that decided that expressway would be a good idea -- they all regret it now and agree it is having a negative effect.

    • @taylorgall9516
      @taylorgall9516 4 роки тому +7

      Buffalo needs to revive its industry along the water, that's the only thing that will carry the city into the future. Cheers, from across the river

    • @anthonysiracuse
      @anthonysiracuse 3 роки тому +3

      @@taylorgall9516 you couldnt be more wrong my friend

    • @anthonysiracuse
      @anthonysiracuse 3 роки тому +1

      7 years later and look how close we are now!!!!! And now Kathy Hochul is Governess and its looking more and more plausible!!!

    • @craigellsworth3952
      @craigellsworth3952 Рік тому +6

      @anthonysiracuse The thought that you'd believe your state tax dollars would come back to Buffalo is fiction.

  • @joymcguire
    @joymcguire 6 днів тому

    thanks! It's still beautiful!

  • @Boots27J
    @Boots27J 10 місяців тому +1

    Cazanovia Park in South Buffalo is beautiful. The surrounding neighborhoods were a great place to grow up. Getting more and more trashed now.

  • @joeconrad9147
    @joeconrad9147 4 роки тому +5

    Sure would love to see some photos of these magnificent buildings under construction

  • @hermanmarie333
    @hermanmarie333 10 років тому +6

    Excellent Documentary.

  • @r.peterreinhardt1091
    @r.peterreinhardt1091 Рік тому +6

    Replant the city with tree types that will grow tall like the old Elms. There are Elm trees highly resistive to the Dutch elm disease, among other species. Tall trees, cool the city in the summertime. Neighborhood kids used to love to play in the streets when I was a kid back in the 50s.

    • @MercuryCold
      @MercuryCold 6 годин тому

      Like elm Street and Delaware park

  • @RrawzZ
    @RrawzZ 5 років тому +6

    And what about McKinley Pkwy. & South Park? There is no mention of them..

  • @caiomonteiro4995
    @caiomonteiro4995 10 років тому +3

    thanks for the subtitle. I can't understand everything when it has only voices. :)

  • @ryanmonahan1336
    @ryanmonahan1336 9 днів тому

    Same person that did central park NYC also did , Duke's Estate,, Hillsborough NJ

    • @JC-nl3nh
      @JC-nl3nh 5 днів тому +1

      did not know that, but can totally see it now that you mention it

  • @sherylchapman4168
    @sherylchapman4168 3 роки тому +15

    Niagara is still the same way. Cheap, shoddy and circus like. Even JohnMuir hated it. The city of Buffalo turned the Humboldt Parkway into the 33 fwy. Why do people take beautiful things and turn them into crap??

    • @CD-ev2vy
      @CD-ev2vy 10 місяців тому

      I grew up on Humboldt pkwy near Kensington ave ìn the 60's. This is a nice historical presentation

    • @MercuryCold
      @MercuryCold 6 годин тому

      When I was a kid they would read the Niagara falls police blotter on the morning radio show..... hilarious like a northern version of Florida.

  • @armusc757
    @armusc757 10 місяців тому +13

    Great documentary, however the city of Buffalo resides in WESTERN NY, not "upstate".

    • @stella-gx8ne
      @stella-gx8ne 4 місяці тому

      it’s WESTERN NY😡

    • @Mike-pb4cd
      @Mike-pb4cd День тому +1

      Buffalo native, but I live in NYC now and I always correct them when someone says "oh you're from upstate" lol.

    • @MatthewOnAFireMissionFromGod
      @MatthewOnAFireMissionFromGod День тому

      According to Long Islanders and NYC anything north of Westchester is "Upstate" New York

    • @MercuryCold
      @MercuryCold 6 годин тому +1

      Everything North of Westchester is upstate NY including Western NY.

    • @Mike-pb4cd
      @Mike-pb4cd 4 години тому

      @@MercuryCold That's like saying everything above the south pole is the north pole.

  • @krakhedd
    @krakhedd 3 дні тому +2

    3:15 Buffalo is in Western New York; there is nothing "upstate" about us, except to snobby elitist denizens of NYC who waive their hands at anything outside of NYC and Long Island as "upstate". Kind of a rookie mistake and quite the insult.

    • @BillyPLilly
      @BillyPLilly День тому

      Why thank Mr um krak hedd? Am I reading that correct?; any how it a very good example of we keep it over , if your up state , you ain't around here , keep it like that

  • @BillyPLilly
    @BillyPLilly День тому

    The area is very confusing to look at on a map until one turns the map so West is up...

  • @ISeeItThisWay
    @ISeeItThisWay 4 роки тому +5

    There's more than Niagara Falls! Another Buffalo s story is the projection that it may be a popular destination for climate refugees relocating from our increasingly heated South!

    • @philup6274
      @philup6274 4 роки тому +3

      No1 from the south moved up there.

    • @sierrachoco5271
      @sierrachoco5271 3 роки тому +2

      @@philup6274 I think what John Bos is referring to is that many areas are now suffering from lack of fresh water (especially the SW). I saw on PBS people are re-thinking where they live and looking to areas where there is an abundance of water - the Buffalo- Niagara area was one of the places!

    • @philup6274
      @philup6274 3 роки тому

      @@sierrachoco5271 stop watching PBS.
      It's brainwashed you ....

    • @sierrachoco5271
      @sierrachoco5271 3 роки тому

      @@philup6274 versus what? Fox that brainwashed you!

    • @philup6274
      @philup6274 3 роки тому +1

      @@sierrachoco5271 I don't watch what you consider TV.

  • @TaylorMcChaney
    @TaylorMcChaney 5 днів тому +2

    Restore Humboldt Parkway

  • @JC-nl3nh
    @JC-nl3nh 5 днів тому +1

    the removal of the erie canal was a devastation for so much of the USA, it should have been preserved.

    • @depsny
      @depsny 2 дні тому

      What are you talking about? It's still used today.

    • @bigben3648
      @bigben3648 2 дні тому

      It most certainly was/is preserved. Certain parts like the Black River Canal (out of Rome NY) were removed but the main corridors is still used by thousands of people a year. There is now a bike trail along side most of it was well.

  • @michaelsnodgrass1808
    @michaelsnodgrass1808 День тому

    And then…..the first lake effect snow storm hit!

  • @alphonsobutlakiv789
    @alphonsobutlakiv789 3 дні тому

    They compare a parkway to Paris, but no, they are an invers, Paris put monuments at the ends of theres, but he puts the the center without a street and at the intersection, nothing much to see

  • @ecamp6360
    @ecamp6360 2 дні тому

    Yeah, but they only did planning in Summer.

  • @smilergrogan1725
    @smilergrogan1725 Рік тому

    The male narrator sounds like the guy who narrates "The Food That Built America".

    • @hisnamewasSam
      @hisnamewasSam День тому

      I’m pretty sure I hear Campbell Scott’s voice in their as well.

  • @stella-gx8ne
    @stella-gx8ne 4 місяці тому +1

    When they put the expy through the park they destroyed that area.

  • @cracploufglou
    @cracploufglou 11 років тому +9

    When all quality spaces are replaced with car's infrastructures, "It was called progress", well I guess they could have said - It was liberalism beginning-

    • @DavidJGillCA
      @DavidJGillCA 8 років тому +3

      What do you know, a simplistic willful misunderstanding of the use of words is a fun way for knot-head Republicans to peddle their bullshit.

  • @atrank
    @atrank Рік тому +6

    Too bad it’s now crippled by decades of decline, high “administration costs”, big government, corruption, poor business environment (New York State), taxes…. The people are great, but in the modern day, are moving out of New York faster than any other state losing population.

    • @SteveJC
      @SteveJC 23 дні тому +3

      We left. Never looked back. I'll save about 250k in taxes by not giving it to Hochel or whoever the Democrats select.

    • @winterwatson6437
      @winterwatson6437 День тому +1

      @SteveJC poor little guy! won’t anyone look out for the 1% 😢

  • @jay-quinthunder7967
    @jay-quinthunder7967 4 роки тому

    And the sad thing is if I can go back in time to1876, And look at these Parks in their original state I couldn't go probably to certain areas, and or I would be harassed or even hurt or killed! Because I'm African-American sad good old America!

    • @sierrachoco5271
      @sierrachoco5271 3 роки тому +4

      Hello Jay Quinn - I know you would be welcome in North Buffalo. We have a great diversity of ethnicity and nationalities here. Everyone is respectful of one another and there are very few problems here. So come on over and live with us - I know for a fact you would be welcome! Best wishes!

  • @belindafalgout1675
    @belindafalgout1675 4 роки тому +1

    🤣🤣🤣🤣 #tartarianempire #buildings #worldwide #timereset #mudflood #orphantrains #fakery #frequency

  • @johnnicholas1488
    @johnnicholas1488 16 днів тому

    No place to park
    Now a dump.
    Few Hills
    Weather chills
    Go Bills.

  • @ipomoeaalba936
    @ipomoeaalba936 Рік тому +1

    🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
    Nope.

  • @russell2910
    @russell2910 10 місяців тому +1

    Fun fact, thousands of people disappear in buffalo's parks every single day

    • @zekzo
      @zekzo 9 місяців тому

      there arent thousands in a park in a single day 💀💀

    • @russell2910
      @russell2910 9 місяців тому +1

      @@zekzo I know. They all disappear 🫥

    • @stella-gx8ne
      @stella-gx8ne 4 місяці тому

      I’m sorry but “whaaaaaat.”

    • @jamesjoslin7586
      @jamesjoslin7586 22 дні тому +1

      Huh ?

  • @ireekofbeans9397
    @ireekofbeans9397 3 роки тому +2

    sussy amogus :( susussssss susssss

  • @MR-tu9dj
    @MR-tu9dj Рік тому +2

    Might of been planned well but it’s a dump of a city today.

    • @albieh2563
      @albieh2563 Рік тому +6

      Buffalo is not a "dump of a city".

    • @SteveJC
      @SteveJC 23 дні тому +3

      Thank a Democrat.

  • @josephpullen1153
    @josephpullen1153 2 дні тому +1

    Too bad they messed it up with expressways