What do you mean by 'the rise of Islamists'? Bangladesh is a muslim majority country while India is a Hindu majority country. Stop misleading people by you misinterpretation of the reality of Bangladesh and its culture. Bangladesh is a moderate muslim country where people of all religions or faith systems are protected. Stop instigating communal divisions to achieve your narrow selfish interests.
complete BS , bangladesh have highest anti indian sentiments in the world. more then Pakistan. thier leaders anti india rhetoric is another level. now they realising india is very important for thier food security, energy, medicine ,raw material .
How does that bother you and your country? We don't come to your country for anything....... instead you guys flock to our country illegally.......,.we don't want anything from y'all just don't come to our country
Bangladesh will always remain a Muslim majority country. Indians need to understand that Bangladesh is a sovereign country and will never accept unwarranted Indian interference as we had been witnessing in last 15 years. Stop talking about your usual categorization of Islam.
Undisrupted support to Hasina was one of the greatest mistake of India. None was believable for india except Hasina. But they had to mind that those arise anti India and anti Awami League sentiment and fundamentalism should arise. It happened really. India shuold take it in mind if Hasina pull out from power there no liberal power would come. These funalamentals must come and that would be more headache than before. That will not go for a long term or forever. So India should had alternative liberal options.
Indians may do justice to themselves if they stop thinking obnoxious ideas of Bangladesh becoming Islamic state with 94 percentage Muslim majority, when Democracy entails majority rule , but Irony is the Indians with majority Hindus claim it a Secular one While in reality its a state propagating Hinduism by the BJP and its allies.
@@rezaulkabir6759 Come to India or at least read about India you will find each and every religion..race which the world have coexisting here for centuries..This is beauty of India ( Hindu) ...Islam ( In all its sects) ..Jain.. Buddhist...Sikh... Christian...Jews .. Zorasthians...you name ..? you will find it in India .... Don't play victims cards ...
Me, among like many other as Bangladeshi do not hate the Indians but we hate how the some Indian politicians are trying to bully us. In one side China and Pakistan showing sympathy towards the students died in the movement and offering help on the other hand most of the Indian media and politicians are dancing in the awami league tune whom everyone hates. What’s the point of supporting and talking in the same tone of awami league whose popularity is extremely pathetic now. And please do not believe what you see in Indian media, they are acting as if Bangladesh is becoming a islamist country and so on… the ground level reality is quite different.
"...on the other hand most of the Indian media and politicians are dancing in the awami league tune "? NOT TRUE. After the coup d'etat, the new Bangladeshi "Advisor" was openly hostile towards India and embraced Pakistan! Now Bangladesh will not allow Hindus to celebrate Durga Puja. They will not allow "bishorjan" of idols. They have become one with Pakistan again... but India should stand idly by while the minority suffers and not express genuine concern for the minority populations? Can we agree that it is outrageous that the "modern" Islamic Republic of Bangladesh will not recognize the rights of Hindus, Buddhists, and tribal populations their "unalienable rights and freedom" to practice his faith as they have done in their "jonmo-bhumi" for over 5000 years. Does Biden not recognize the same rights in America? Why is he papering over the rights of the Bangladeshi Minority ? Should they not enjoy the same unalienable rights guaranteed in their " Bill of Rights"? If not what is the point in being Democracy, with only selective and arbitrarily issued set of rights? We must respect all faiths, even in the most challenging of times. If not, nothing good will come out of it. But know that Bharat upholds the rights of ALL citizens. Our Constitution guarantees it. If I am proud, it is not at the expense of Bangladesh or Pakistan. It is because I feel genuinely happy to live in such a vast country with the same challenges as every other neighbor of ours, and with greater diversity. We have muddled through and found solutions. Do not allow Bangladesh to be controlled by other countries who will put their agenda ahead of the best interests of Bangladesh. Scrutinize Pakistan's model of governance since 1947. Is that what you wish for Bangladesh going forward? How many Coup D'etats have there been from the assassination of Liaqat Ali Khan in 1951 to Imran Khan? There has never been a time of peace long enough to grow strong Democratic and equitable institutions. Only turbulence and violence. Indonesia is peaceful, because they did NOT abandon their pluralistic heritage and culture. And Malaysia too, despite some recent fanaticism in their leaders, have been guided by centuries old tradition. They have NOT put the screws to their minority Hindu, Buddhist and Christian minority populations.
Say something about direct threat to India's sovereignty given by Mr Yunus and one of their young leader particularly about Siliguri corridor..NE...New Bangadesh thinks Indian economy is dependent on Bangladesh....No relationship with Bangladesh is the best relationship.....Thanks
@@sushilupadhyay3340 I guarantee you, we know how big the Indian economy is and how smaller ours is. The reality in the country and how I see in the Indian media is entirely different, trust me. If you ask any general Bangladeshi who do not have any strong political affiliation will say the same. If possible visit Bangladesh, you’ll know. Most of the Indian media is showing things in a very exaggerated way. And which threat Mr Yunus gave to India, can you please quote which statement you are talking about?
@@Quazishaab Ya ...good before coming to Bangladesh..Mr Yunus gave a statement to the press at Paris airport that NE India will burn any time....and one your young leader now he is in Govt threatens about the Siliguri ... Corridor.... actually 80%Indians did not know who Hashina is ..The priority of Indian youth is not Bangladesh...their priorities are quantum Computing...Semi conductor...Rare earths elements..Space Technology..Why world most big companies has Indian CEO.. education...But my opinion is the hate India campaign in Bangladesh is now reached at the point of no return particularly through social media...
@@sushilupadhyay3340 i have seen the news in the Paris airport, I urge you to rewatch the interview. And the things you mentioned India is focused on, the next technologies and the Ceo, I really respect that. Its good for the whole region to focus on productivity instead of spreading fake news and hate news. Majority of us understand that we cannot change a neighbour but how the Indian foreign policy towards us are unfair and mostly bully’s us. I can provide you 100s of instances with sources about how shitty some of the India’s foreign towards Bangladesh is. At the end of the day, China and Pakistan is showing they want to be friend and Indian media and Indian policy is showing the opposite, just think for a moment, will that be a good thing in the longrun?
I am impressed that a rank anti-BJP platform like The Federal at least got an interview on B'desh which was honest. Mostly, like Mamata & TMC, or The Wire, etc pseudos, "secularists" can be trusted to gloss over genocide of Hindus. V good insights shared by Purokayastha who is nuanced & knowledgable. FYI, 1941 census 28% H8ndus, today its 7.9%.
After 41, one partition happened on 47 and another migration to WB happened on 52 and at 71 almost 1 cr people migrated to India. Many Hindus didn’t come back. So your data is not accurate. People migrated that's the reason for the falling population.
The interviewer is mixing Islam with Urdu and has little understanding of Bengali culture. Please refrain from choosing such interviews, Sir. Your area of expertise is obviously different
What do you mean by Bengali culture? The Bangladeshi culture is no longer Bengali culture. See the dresses of general public. The country is looks like Afghanistan.
It It is a fact of life and a universally accepted principle that when someone continuously talks about a person or issue that doesn’t concern them, it reflects jealousy, frustration, or both. In this case, the constant ranting by the Indian media about Bangladesh clearly shows India’s jealousy and frustration with Bangladesh’s progress. Why is the Indian mindset so restless and in crisis? The truth is they are upset because the people of Bangladesh, led by courageous students, have ousted India’s puppet, Sheikh Hasina, who has been an unelected, illegitimate prime minister for the past 17 years. Only India supported and recognized the sham elections held under her rule. With Sheikh Hasina as India’s puppet, they enjoyed free reign in Bangladesh. But why is India now obsessively attacking Dr. Muhammad Yunus, using the familiar “Save Hindu” narrative, as if it were some Bollywood drama? The reality is that whenever things don’t align with India’s interests, they play the Hindu card for their own dirty politics. India, along with its puppet Sheikh Hasina, has always exploited this tactic. India's RSS-led regime, through RAW, is notorious for extrajudicial killings of Sikhs, Muslims, and others. India’s jealousy and frustration stem from the international recognition Dr. Yunus continues to receive, and they can't stand that Bangladesh is now speaking and acting like a truly independent nation, standing up to India. India is disliked by every country in the region. Just recently, Sri Lanka expelled India’s Adani Group, which is really a political arm of the Indian regime. Similarly, about a week ago, Kenya also expelled the Adani Group! The world is not interested in India's fake news and this is why only Indians listen to it to pass time as some kind of Bollywood entertainment!! We in Bangladesh are not interested in any friendship with the Indian regime, which is an autocracy itself and supports autocracat Indian puppets in the region. India is only a democracy in theory, not in practice. In practice it is a multi-faced hypocrisy. This explains the real problem behind India's mental crisis!
Now when Bangladesh is becoming Kangladesh..fir jake akal thikane aayi ...n now taking a u turn.. for example first Hilsa export was banned and now they started exporting 😂
India should accept the new reality in Bangladesh ,yes Bangladesh may turn into a liberal Islamic democracy ,India made mistakes by steadfastly standing with the autocracy of Hasina .
Liberalism and islamisam are opposite to each other. Just like north pole and south pole. While One promotes equal rights for all citizen other one promotes brutal jihad towards other faiths
There is a break line Between Indians and BJP Congress government for Bangladeshi citizens. I mean i would like to express my opinion that there is a good relations among Bangladeshi citizens and Indians. Issues Against Indian regimes ugly political stands with Bangladesh. Muslims are NOT a extremist but RSS.
Sir, look at yourself, tell about your fundamental characteristics of Hinduism, oppressions of the minorities in all aspects of life. First make sure your own minorities human, religion and other citizens wrights. Bangladesh is on the wright path and doing well after the fall of fascist, undemocratic and murderer government. We all Bangladeshi nationals are brothers and sisters. We are serious to protect each other from any harmful activities from internal or external sources. Pity for Mr. K S Dakshina Murthy, how poor he is and how bios is his thoughts about Bangladesh. On the other hand, thanks to Mr Samir K Purkayastha who know the pulse of Bengali peoples. Because he himself is a Bengali and almost perfectly described the nature and norm of Bengali mentalities. After all thank both the guys for discussing about the present situation of Bangladesh.
"What Bengali Islam" 😂 .. what a joke.. Islam came through revelation in Arabic, and there's no racism in Islam... the guy discussing has no idea of islamic aqeedah 😂
What do you mean by 'the rise of Islamists'? Bangladesh is a muslim majority country while India is a Hindu majority country. Stop misleading people by you misinterpretation of the reality of Bangladesh and its culture. Bangladesh is a moderate muslim country where people of all religions or faith systems are protected. Stop instigating communal divisions to achieve your narrow selfish interests.
But don’t you think Yunus is failing to protect Hindus. Mandirs are still being vandalised. There is no law in the country. The police are sleeping
It's coming from the Islamophobia inside their hearts which they will never directly admit but it can be seen clearly from their actions.
lol
What made you think that Bangladesh would be like Afghanistan or any other strict Islamic country?
We never were nor will be
complete BS , bangladesh have highest anti indian sentiments in the world. more then Pakistan. thier leaders anti india rhetoric is another level. now they realising india is very important for thier food security, energy, medicine ,raw material .
What about the hindutva vadi policy of Indian govt?
How does that bother you and your country? We don't come to your country for anything....... instead you guys flock to our country illegally.......,.we don't want anything from y'all just don't come to our country
Bangladesh will always remain a Muslim majority country. Indians need to understand that Bangladesh is a sovereign country and will never accept unwarranted Indian interference as we had been witnessing in last 15 years. Stop talking about your usual categorization of Islam.
Bangladesh people are very hospitality minded anyone specialy and practicaly a good friend with Indian people
Undisrupted support to Hasina was one of the greatest mistake of India. None was believable for india except Hasina. But they had to mind that those arise anti India and anti Awami League sentiment and fundamentalism should arise. It happened really. India shuold take it in mind if Hasina pull out from power there no liberal power would come. These funalamentals must come and that would be more headache than before. That will not go for a long term or forever. So India should had alternative liberal options.
Indians may do justice to themselves if they stop thinking obnoxious ideas of Bangladesh becoming Islamic state with 94 percentage Muslim majority, when Democracy entails majority rule , but Irony is the Indians with majority Hindus claim it a Secular one While in reality its a state propagating Hinduism by the BJP and its allies.
@@rezaulkabir6759 Come to India or at least read about India you will find each and every religion..race which the world have coexisting here for centuries..This is beauty of India ( Hindu) ...Islam ( In all its sects) ..Jain.. Buddhist...Sikh... Christian...Jews .. Zorasthians...you name ..? you will find it in India .... Don't play victims cards ...
Thank you Samir
Me, among like many other as Bangladeshi do not hate the Indians but we hate how the some Indian politicians are trying to bully us. In one side China and Pakistan showing sympathy towards the students died in the movement and offering help on the other hand most of the Indian media and politicians are dancing in the awami league tune whom everyone hates. What’s the point of supporting and talking in the same tone of awami league whose popularity is extremely pathetic now.
And please do not believe what you see in Indian media, they are acting as if Bangladesh is becoming a islamist country and so on… the ground level reality is quite different.
"...on the other hand most of the Indian media and politicians are dancing in the awami league tune "?
NOT TRUE.
After the coup d'etat, the new Bangladeshi "Advisor" was openly hostile towards India and embraced Pakistan!
Now Bangladesh will not allow Hindus to celebrate Durga Puja. They will not allow "bishorjan" of idols.
They have become one with Pakistan again... but India should stand idly by while the minority suffers and not express genuine concern for the minority populations?
Can we agree that it is outrageous that the "modern" Islamic Republic of Bangladesh will not recognize the rights of Hindus, Buddhists, and tribal populations their "unalienable rights and freedom" to practice his faith as they have done in their "jonmo-bhumi" for over 5000 years.
Does Biden not recognize the same rights in America? Why is he papering over the rights of the Bangladeshi Minority ? Should they not enjoy the same unalienable rights guaranteed in their " Bill of Rights"?
If not what is the point in being Democracy, with only selective and arbitrarily issued set of rights?
We must respect all faiths, even in the most challenging of times. If not, nothing good will come out of it.
But know that Bharat upholds the rights of ALL citizens. Our Constitution guarantees it.
If I am proud, it is not at the expense of Bangladesh or Pakistan. It is because I feel genuinely happy to live in such a vast country with the same challenges as every other neighbor of ours, and with greater diversity. We have muddled through and found solutions.
Do not allow Bangladesh to be controlled by other countries who will put their agenda ahead of the best interests of Bangladesh.
Scrutinize Pakistan's model of governance since 1947. Is that what you wish for Bangladesh going forward?
How many Coup D'etats have there been from the assassination of Liaqat Ali Khan in 1951 to Imran Khan?
There has never been a time of peace long enough to grow strong Democratic and equitable institutions.
Only turbulence and violence.
Indonesia is peaceful, because they did NOT abandon their pluralistic heritage and culture.
And Malaysia too, despite some recent fanaticism in their leaders, have been guided by centuries old tradition.
They have NOT put the screws to their minority Hindu, Buddhist and Christian minority populations.
Say something about direct threat to India's sovereignty given by Mr Yunus and one of their young leader particularly about Siliguri corridor..NE...New Bangadesh thinks Indian economy is dependent on Bangladesh....No relationship with Bangladesh is the best relationship.....Thanks
@@sushilupadhyay3340 I guarantee you, we know how big the Indian economy is and how smaller ours is. The reality in the country and how I see in the Indian media is entirely different, trust me. If you ask any general Bangladeshi who do not have any strong political affiliation will say the same. If possible visit Bangladesh, you’ll know. Most of the Indian media is showing things in a very exaggerated way. And which threat Mr Yunus gave to India, can you please quote which statement you are talking about?
@@Quazishaab Ya ...good before coming to Bangladesh..Mr Yunus gave a statement to the press at Paris airport that NE India will burn any time....and one your young leader now he is in Govt threatens about the Siliguri ... Corridor.... actually 80%Indians did not know who Hashina is ..The priority of Indian youth is not Bangladesh...their priorities are quantum Computing...Semi conductor...Rare earths elements..Space Technology..Why world most big companies has Indian CEO.. education...But my opinion is the hate India campaign in Bangladesh is now reached at the point of no return particularly through social media...
@@sushilupadhyay3340 i have seen the news in the Paris airport, I urge you to rewatch the interview. And the things you mentioned India is focused on, the next technologies and the Ceo, I really respect that. Its good for the whole region to focus on productivity instead of spreading fake news and hate news. Majority of us understand that we cannot change a neighbour but how the Indian foreign policy towards us are unfair and mostly bully’s us. I can provide you 100s of instances with sources about how shitty some of the India’s foreign towards Bangladesh is.
At the end of the day, China and Pakistan is showing they want to be friend and Indian media and Indian policy is showing the opposite, just think for a moment, will that be a good thing in the longrun?
Dada Bangladesh nia apnader ato jalapora ata matha betha bum betha piles er betha
Apnader desh er internal matter nia to amra matha ghamai na
Next Pakistan
We are hearing the loudest crying noise from India and we are enjoying it😂😂
Atomic superpower?
😂😂
And we would be proud if the federal Pak system of pre-71 is launched again.
I am impressed that a rank anti-BJP platform like The Federal at least got an interview on B'desh which was honest. Mostly, like Mamata & TMC, or The Wire, etc pseudos, "secularists" can be trusted to gloss over genocide of Hindus.
V good insights shared by Purokayastha who is nuanced & knowledgable.
FYI, 1941 census 28% H8ndus, today its 7.9%.
Cause they moved to wb
@@adityamohan8514 Absolutely!
After 41, one partition happened on 47 and another migration to WB happened on 52 and at 71 almost 1 cr people migrated to India. Many Hindus didn’t come back. So your data is not accurate. People migrated that's the reason for the falling population.
How many Muslims from India are moving to Bangladesh? Why one sided movement?
@@sujoy1968 Because india is their home???
The interviewer is mixing Islam with Urdu and has little understanding of Bengali culture. Please refrain from choosing such interviews, Sir. Your area of expertise is obviously different
What do you mean by Bengali culture? The Bangladeshi culture is no longer Bengali culture. See the dresses of general public. The country is looks like Afghanistan.
It It is a fact of life and a universally accepted principle that when someone continuously talks about a person or issue that doesn’t concern them, it reflects jealousy, frustration, or both. In this case, the constant ranting by the Indian media about Bangladesh clearly shows India’s jealousy and frustration with Bangladesh’s progress.
Why is the Indian mindset so restless and in crisis? The truth is they are upset because the people of Bangladesh, led by courageous students, have ousted India’s puppet, Sheikh Hasina, who has been an unelected, illegitimate prime minister for the past 17 years. Only India supported and recognized the sham elections held under her rule. With Sheikh Hasina as India’s puppet, they enjoyed free reign in Bangladesh.
But why is India now obsessively attacking Dr. Muhammad Yunus, using the familiar “Save Hindu” narrative, as if it were some Bollywood drama? The reality is that whenever things don’t align with India’s interests, they play the Hindu card for their own dirty politics. India, along with its puppet Sheikh Hasina, has always exploited this tactic.
India's RSS-led regime, through RAW, is notorious for extrajudicial killings of Sikhs, Muslims, and others. India’s jealousy and frustration stem from the international recognition Dr. Yunus continues to receive, and they can't stand that Bangladesh is now speaking and acting like a truly independent nation, standing up to India.
India is disliked by every country in the region. Just recently, Sri Lanka expelled India’s Adani Group, which is really a political arm of the Indian regime. Similarly, about a week ago, Kenya also expelled the Adani Group!
The world is not interested in India's fake news and this is why only Indians listen to it to pass time as some kind of Bollywood entertainment!!
We in Bangladesh are not interested in any friendship with the Indian regime, which is an autocracy itself and supports autocracat Indian puppets in the region. India is only a democracy in theory, not in practice. In practice it is a multi-faced hypocrisy.
This explains the real problem behind India's mental crisis!
Ok, now I genuinely want to know Why were Hindus protesting in dhaka or was that fake news too?
@@moistboi4980Lol This is the Islamist mindset.
Now when Bangladesh is becoming Kangladesh..fir jake akal thikane aayi ...n now taking a u turn.. for example first Hilsa export was banned and now they started exporting 😂
India out story is live....😊😅😅😊😊 ita eye opener for hindu here
India should accept the new reality in Bangladesh ,yes Bangladesh may turn into a liberal Islamic democracy ,India made mistakes by steadfastly standing with the autocracy of Hasina .
Liberalism and islamisam are opposite to each other. Just like north pole and south pole. While One promotes equal rights for all citizen other one promotes brutal jihad towards other faiths
Liberal Islamic is oxymoron. There is nothing called Liberal Islamic democracy.
10:30 horseshit. This guy don't even know what he is talking about. 128 of 156 student protest leader just came out as SHIBIR
I wanted to hard its some stupid sentence back but i don't like to wast my time.
Good explained
There is a break line Between Indians and BJP Congress government for Bangladeshi citizens. I mean i would like to express my opinion that there is a good relations among Bangladeshi citizens and Indians. Issues Against Indian regimes ugly political stands with Bangladesh. Muslims are NOT a extremist but RSS.
Sir, look at yourself, tell about your fundamental characteristics of Hinduism, oppressions of the minorities in all aspects of life. First make sure your own minorities human, religion and other citizens wrights. Bangladesh is on the wright path and doing well after the fall of fascist, undemocratic and murderer government. We all Bangladeshi nationals are brothers and sisters. We are serious to protect each other from any harmful activities from internal or external sources. Pity for Mr. K S Dakshina Murthy, how poor he is and how bios is his thoughts about Bangladesh. On the other hand, thanks to Mr Samir K Purkayastha who know the pulse of Bengali peoples. Because he himself is a Bengali and almost perfectly described the nature and norm of Bengali mentalities. After all thank both the guys for discussing about the present situation of Bangladesh.
"What Bengali Islam" 😂 .. what a joke.. Islam came through revelation in Arabic, and there's no racism in Islam... the guy discussing has no idea of islamic aqeedah 😂
Most of us who have rejected Islam know its ideology far better than the delusional people who still follow it.
7th Century Arabic cultural colonialism is growing in Bangladesh. Even the current Arab country are trying to move away from this culture.