Ironically, the Father might have lived. His ultimate death came when he was trying to make sure his Wife was safe and wasn't being carted to the execution pits.
Robert Dukarm Awesome dad. BUT TERRIBLE HUSBAND!!! I woulda been yelling to her, not to get on the train, to go the fuck back home. Not only one less worry. But would never want anyone I loved that much, to be in that dire situation.
@@voodoochef100 more to your point of "one less worry", do you ever think/wonder that if Dora had not gotten on the train that Guido might have survived? Because if he had not been going to find her and warn her at the end of the movie he would not have gotten caught by the Camp guard and shot. Instead he and Giosue might have gotten away or hidden for those last few hours and survived, and then later reunited with Dora who was safe at home??
I second this. That actor deserves credit, he conveyed a wide swath of subtle emotion with few words and a few changing glances. The acting in this scene from everyone is outstanding.
This is why I read true accounts of the Holocaust: the bravery, the sacrifice, the kindness, even anony prisoners in the camps. Also those who risked their lives to rescue or hide those who would have died. I love The Hiding Place (the nonfiction book by Corrie Ten Boom) and "Hidden in Silence," another true story.
It's an incredibly courageous thing to do, what she did. There were real women who did that, real women who knowingly went to their deaths with their Jewish husbands.
I am a volunteer at the Hocking Valley Scenic Railway as engine crew and I always think of this movie scene whenever I see passengers boarding a train.
what a phenomenal scene. Many actresses would have been tempted to yell in this scene but I think the way this was done was infinitely more powerful. And I just gotta say that Nazi commander was soo handsome-Dang!
snowhey01 “Before you speak ask yourself if what you are going to say is true, is kind, is necessary, is helpful. If the answer is no, maybe what you are about to say should be left unsaid.” -Bernard Meltzer
This is the saddest movie I have ever watched. To think that people had this much cruelty in them. And Guildo kept going and stayed happy when in the concentration camp.
I couldn’t imagine being a German Soldier and seeing and hearing things that you wish didn’t happen but are. Like how can you not feel compassion for a father and his son?
Life is beautiful !!a strong msg of true luv of a woman for her son and husband lucky are those who share this strong bond of luv their journey of life ❤️❤️This movie touched my soul ❤️😢😢
You loved her family so much she got on that cursed train knowing full well what was going to happen. A mother and wife who willing plunged into hell to share the fate of her husband and son.
I always wonder, what must that officer be thinking in that moment? Does he figure she’ll be a recurring annoyance to them if they make her stay? Does he respect her courage and decide to let her follow it? Does he think her stupid? Does he think at all, or is he acting solely off some undefinable feeling? What causes you to stop the train and let a woman on when both of you know where it’s going?
After watching this movie I couldn’t stop crying for a week this is one of the best movies of all time father really told his son it was a game so he wouldn’t know what was really going on🥺🥺🥲🥲
A brave woman and a true mother. Jumped to the hell trying to be with her husband and son. But he died in the end trying to save her. Had she stayed at home, he would be alive. Such an irony.
This is a great scene. But the thing that bugs me is that if she doesn't get on the train, Guido would still be alive at the end. That's what ultimately got Guido killed when he was spotted sneaking over to the women's side of the camp during the final night.
How you know you found the right woman: ask yourself if your wife and mother of your child would get on that train. I know damn well my wife would have drawn blood to board that train
She could have easily condemned her family to death and just let her husband and son go to the camp. She would be judged as "right" by society, because while sad, it would have been a "sensible thing" to not put her self in danger. She actively chose danger and death because of unconditional love for her husband and son. This scene solidifies her love as unconditional, because no rational being would actively and genuinely choose to go to a death camp. It didn't matter that her husband and son were "Jewish". It mattered that they were alive, human, and her family. A powerful scene later on is the doctor who liked Guido, but was more concerned with the riddle than this man's life and his son's life. The "Universe of Obligation" means that we care about those closest to us, and not much else. Seeing our neighbors as "others" and "Strangers" is what allowed this to happen.
For those who don't explicitly know that the train is taking them to death camps... where do people think they're going? what pretenses are the German guards giving people to have them board? Does Dora KNOW?
They took Guido and Joshua while they were at their home and she was out picking up her mother. When she saw that they had been kidnapped she decided to take matters into her own hands, unknowing that she'd be taken to a concentration camp.
+Arlie Daniel No, that's not quite true. She wasn't arrested because she's not Jewish; she's Italian (Catholic). She knew the trains were going to concentration camps, but she wanted to be with her family regardless of the danger that lied ahead.
@@granadina48 Exactly. That's why their initial reaction to her is so incredulous--she's not Jewish, there is nothing but suffering and almost certain death at those camps, but she's just that devoted.
MAGNIFICENT SCENE!! She making the german military accompish her rules! !!AWESOMEEEEEEE! And he did it because he recognized she had personality, conviction and STRENGH!!! And nazis appreciated that!!! THATS WHY HE DID IT FOR!!
They didn’t do anything for her LOL they basically sent her to her death that train was going to a concentration camp it wasn’t like they were doing her a favor it made no difference to them if she got on the train or not. The Italians were allies him but that doesn’t mean they would go out of their way for one person. Que loco lol
Anyone ever wonder that if Dora had not gotten on the train that Guido might have survived? Because if he had not been going to find her and warn her at the end of the movie he would not have gotten caught by the Camp guard and shot. Instead he and Giosue might have gotten away or hidden for those last few hours and survived, and then later reunited with Dora who was safe at home??
I can’t really say I understand the choice. Maybe life is not worth living without them, maybe she thinks she can save them. I understand the first one, but she probably has a better chance of saving them from the outside. I also wonder if there’s a belief in everyone’s mind about self-sacrifice as a good thing. If she were my spouse, I would be devastated.
1:32 Is the soldier saying «È tutto pronto!» (All ready!) an Italian (traitor)? He doesn't look 'Aryan' at all. Then he says something like «Vai! Vai! Parti...»?
I blame Dora mother for getting the husband, grandson, uncle arrested and sent away. She couldn't except that her daughter married to someone below her social standing.
I don't think her mom had anything to do with it, they were arrested because they were jews. Just the day before they were taken she came to the bookshop to try and make amends.
One person on the news said that veterans thought world war 2 was pointless, look at who they saved. There was a point. God wanted them to save those children in the camps and out. Poland had Jews living there, if they had gotten Poland, what would have happened to them?
I hate this scene because I do not like how they lock the people up in a box cars and made them slaves and send them to the concentration camps which is not nice and I don't like that. A lot of people and I like McDonald's PlayPlaces and school buses with an electric stop arm better than that train. The subway train in Toronto Ontario, the subway in New York city, Amtrak, and New Jersey Transit are all way better trains than that train.
This is what actually happened. They were loaded onto boxcars like animals and sometimes traveled for days even standing up with little air and only a bucket to do their business in.
The love of a mother and wife...
Stunning.
@Raz Bloom 10/10 I see what you did there.
Imagine if she didn’t get on that train, she wouldn’t be able to live with herself for the rest of her life. She is a brave woman.
Ironically, the Father might have lived. His ultimate death came when he was trying to make sure his Wife was safe and wasn't being carted to the execution pits.
@@kalkuttadrop6371 yeaa
Yeah, and I’m sure that gave Guido the extra strength he needed to pull off his charade!
i like that mean, cold look on the officer. How he shows her the way out with that cold look as if he was saying "you wanna die? be my guest"
memoranda1 and u like it??? stupid!!!!
yes we like good acting
you mongaloid
Keti Halili It's a performance, you simpleton.
@@ketihalili91 you totally missed the point of the comment.
@@ketihalili91 r/whooosh
Lessons on what being an awesome dad is all about throughout the whole movie, I guess that what makes me love it so much even though it's sad.
Robert Dukarm Awesome dad. BUT TERRIBLE HUSBAND!!! I woulda been yelling to her, not to get on the train, to go the fuck back home. Not only one less worry. But would never want anyone I loved that much, to be in that dire situation.
voodoochef100 Lol; I hear you on that one.
He knew that yelling at her to go home wouldn't have stopped her; doing so would only get them all in more trouble and freak out his son.
100%! He is just marvelous! One of the best movies ever made!
@@voodoochef100 more to your point of "one less worry", do you ever think/wonder that if Dora had not gotten on the train that Guido might have survived?
Because if he had not been going to find her and warn her at the end of the movie he would not have gotten caught by the Camp guard and shot. Instead he and Giosue might have gotten away or hidden for those last few hours and survived, and then later reunited with Dora who was safe at home??
That look from the officer..
From friendly and humble look when he ask her, to confused ridicule look when he let her aboard the train.
I second this. That actor deserves credit, he conveyed a wide swath of subtle emotion with few words and a few changing glances. The acting in this scene from everyone is outstanding.
THAT is love! Dora is brave. I don't know what I would do if I were her.
Dood u just helped me answer a question on my homework. THANKS
Eliana Herrero Glad I could help!
@@joyhaswell751 then maybe you deserve a Special Someone.
This is why I read true accounts of the Holocaust: the bravery, the sacrifice, the kindness, even anony prisoners in the camps. Also those who risked their lives to rescue or hide those who would have died. I love The Hiding Place (the nonfiction book by Corrie Ten Boom) and "Hidden in Silence," another true story.
You'd of gone home...
It's an incredibly courageous thing to do, what she did. There were real women who did that, real women who knowingly went to their deaths with their Jewish husbands.
very powerful scene indeed, can't help my eyes from welling up
I am a volunteer at the Hocking Valley Scenic Railway as engine crew and I always think of this movie scene whenever I see passengers boarding a train.
A mom would travel to the pits of hell to save her son.
That's a true mom
what a phenomenal scene. Many actresses would have been tempted to yell in this scene but I think the way this was done was infinitely more powerful. And I just gotta say that Nazi commander was soo handsome-Dang!
That's Richard Sammel. Recognized him from watching "Un Village Francaise", where he played Heinrich Müller over seven seasons.
Jose Maria Torres He is also from the series, "The Strain".
Jose Maria Torres Oh right!
Patricia Johnson Chad nazi
i choked reading the end lmao but ur not wrong
Life is Beautiful...this film is beautiful...thanks for uploading these clips :D
I never saw this movie it’s amazing how he plays like it’s a game for his son So sad and beautiful
such a powerful scene...
"This man wants to die for his country! Obliiiige him!!"
Blackdoll n pink I see what you did there!
@@RaelEmpire316 lol!
I KNEW I RECOGNIZED HIM FROM SOMEWHERE
VERY well done. The acting from everyone just giving a 1000%. THIS is the hollywood I know and love.
Let’s just hope you’re not this dumb lol
snowhey01 “Before you speak ask yourself if what you are going to say is true, is kind, is necessary, is helpful. If the answer is no, maybe what you are about to say should be left unsaid.”
-Bernard Meltzer
If it was hollywood it would be an action movie :P
Not hollywood mate!
Hollywood making movies in Italian?
This is the saddest movie I have ever watched. To think that people had this much cruelty in them. And Guildo kept going and stayed happy when in the concentration camp.
He wasn't happy he was acting for his child
I couldn’t imagine being a German Soldier and seeing and hearing things that you wish didn’t happen but are. Like how can you not feel compassion for a father and his son?
Because they were brain washed
And then the Bastards heard about him.
Or he became a Strigoi...
A RIVER DERCHY
I read the comments hoping to find this.
She's very brave.
Life is beautiful !!a strong msg of true luv of a woman for her son and husband lucky are those who share this strong bond of luv their journey of life ❤️❤️This movie touched my soul ❤️😢😢
これは本当に一度は見たほうがいい映画だと思います!!
That's real bravery
@PRO’s Gaming Umm what?
@PRO’s Gaming Owh ok lol
You loved her family so much she got on that cursed train knowing full well what was going to happen. A mother and wife who willing plunged into hell to share the fate of her husband and son.
I always wonder, what must that officer be thinking in that moment? Does he figure she’ll be a recurring annoyance to them if they make her stay? Does he respect her courage and decide to let her follow it? Does he think her stupid? Does he think at all, or is he acting solely off some undefinable feeling? What causes you to stop the train and let a woman on when both of you know where it’s going?
Our teacher made us watch this movie because he liked it..........
heels in the houlcaust
Ther were people who had nice attire and it was all taken away from them. They were deceived ..
Haunting music. One of the saddest movies ever.
After watching this movie I couldn’t stop crying for a week this is one of the best movies of all time father really told his son it was a game so he wouldn’t know what was really going on🥺🥺🥲🥲
A brave woman and a true mother. Jumped to the hell trying to be with her husband and son. But he died in the end trying to save her. Had she stayed at home, he would be alive. Such an irony.
She’d rather be close to her family suffering than at home in comfort. I respect her decision.
My condolences to all the victims . Hope they r at peace .
beautiful life comes from his beautiful mind
This is a great scene. But the thing that bugs me is that if she doesn't get on the train, Guido would still be alive at the end. That's what ultimately got Guido killed when he was spotted sneaking over to the women's side of the camp during the final night.
She wasn’t about to leave her husband and child behind tho
1:40 Soldier: Go back home ma'am
Dora : Okay
Movie ends.
How you know you found the right woman: ask yourself if your wife and mother of your child would get on that train.
I know damn well my wife would have drawn blood to board that train
A devastating time to be in. Totally and utterly destroying not just families, but the essence of human dignity and decency.
Well that’s a jump from clip 4...
Love this movie. ;)
My Mother was born in Avellino. This was the last movie we watched together before she flew to Heaven.
@@angelozollo9506 So sorry for your loss Angelo
For better or worse til death do us part.
Why would anyone downvote this??
nazis did
The OG ride or die
When you tell the waitress you're ready for the blazing wings.
Could have been worse, Guido and Gioshue could have ended up in a camp that was under Amon Goeth’s supervision.
Who?
I can't believe this is happening again.
Haha.. I like the way of the male actor 's acting styles.. The German soldier... The actress is so normal at her roles.
Always my favourite movie ,,,,love from Pakistan 😘😘😘
I understand that her choice is not for everyone... But it's the only choice I could live with.
She could have easily condemned her family to death and just let her husband and son go to the camp. She would be judged as "right" by society, because while sad, it would have been a "sensible thing" to not put her self in danger. She actively chose danger and death because of unconditional love for her husband and son. This scene solidifies her love as unconditional, because no rational being would actively and genuinely choose to go to a death camp. It didn't matter that her husband and son were "Jewish". It mattered that they were alive, human, and her family. A powerful scene later on is the doctor who liked Guido, but was more concerned with the riddle than this man's life and his son's life. The "Universe of Obligation" means that we care about those closest to us, and not much else. Seeing our neighbors as "others" and "Strangers" is what allowed this to happen.
Everybody in the German Army has heard of HuuuGgooo Shtttigggglizzzzzz
Она итальянка он еврей . фильм отличный. Давно смотрела широкоформате .Жизнь прекрасна.
Thats real love
May God give releaf to all those who sufferd in his kingdom.
this is so beutiful
For those who don't explicitly know that the train is taking them to death camps... where do people think they're going?
what pretenses are the German guards giving people to have them board?
Does Dora KNOW?
Why wasn't she selected to go on the train in the first place? Was she not Jewish?
They took Guido and Joshua while they were at their home and she was out picking up her mother. When she saw that they had been kidnapped she decided to take matters into her own hands, unknowing that she'd be taken to a concentration camp.
+Maximus Crusade shes italian
+Arlie Daniel No, that's not quite true. She wasn't arrested because she's not Jewish; she's Italian (Catholic). She knew the trains were going to concentration camps, but she wanted to be with her family regardless of the danger that lied ahead.
Italiano
@@granadina48 Exactly. That's why their initial reaction to her is so incredulous--she's not Jewish, there is nothing but suffering and almost certain death at those camps, but she's just that devoted.
MAGNIFICENT SCENE!! She making the german military accompish her rules! !!AWESOMEEEEEEE! And he did it because he recognized she had personality, conviction and STRENGH!!! And nazis appreciated that!!! THATS WHY HE DID IT FOR!!
They didn’t do anything for her LOL they basically sent her to her death that train was going to a concentration camp it wasn’t like they were doing her a favor it made no difference to them if she got on the train or not. The Italians were allies him but that doesn’t mean they would go out of their way for one person. Que loco lol
Nah it’s just more people to kill for them
nothing is more scary than an SS officer who speaks OTHER LANGUAGES
That SS officer is so cold looking
I saw that officer in Bastards 2009 lol
I mean they’re not supposed to be friendly lol
Dear ヴァイオリニストAyasa
天国で、幸せにになろうね👼
From K.W
銀河鉄道999を思い出したわ。
Great film.
That's a very scary looking SS officer. Deep eye gorges, long nose bridge and clean shaven face
now that is a strong female character
Anyone ever wonder that if Dora had not gotten on the train that Guido might have survived?
Because if he had not been going to find her and warn her at the end of the movie he would not have gotten caught by the Camp guard and shot. Instead he and Giosue might have gotten away or hidden for those last few hours and survived, and then later reunited with Dora who was safe at home??
Yes, but you don't have much control over that. She wanted to be where they went out of love.
Good luck stopping her tho
I can’t really say I understand the choice. Maybe life is not worth living without them, maybe she thinks she can save them. I understand the first one, but she probably has a better chance of saving them from the outside. I also wonder if there’s a belief in everyone’s mind about self-sacrifice as a good thing. If she were my spouse, I would be devastated.
1:32 Is the soldier saying «È tutto pronto!» (All ready!) an Italian (traitor)? He doesn't look 'Aryan' at all.
Then he says something like «Vai! Vai! Parti...»?
All germans should watch this movie,and must understand how people sufferd bacauae of their crimes,and should not repeat once again.
Thomas eichorst
Many people chose not to get on train with their Jewish family members.
This guard is the most evil man in the whole movie.
He was trying to let her go free so actually not really...
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I blame Dora mother for getting the husband, grandson, uncle arrested and sent away. She couldn't except that her daughter married to someone below her social standing.
I don't think her mom had anything to do with it, they were arrested because they were jews. Just the day before they were taken she came to the bookshop to try and make amends.
@@stefanmakara373 not amends but a false sense of security
@@stefanmakara373 Jews in Italy
Women then were brave, honorable, beautiful.
Now .. they would probably take a video selfie as the train departs and post it on TikTok. 😅
One person on the news said that veterans thought world war 2 was pointless, look at who they saved. There was a point. God wanted them to save those children in the camps and out. Poland had Jews living there, if they had gotten Poland, what would have happened to them?
Wait so the mother is a german?
No she’s Italian just like her family but she wasn’t forced to go because she’s not Jewish she’s catholic
Сильный Момент
The reason why they didn’t let her in it was because they thought that she was a German not a Jewish
@@jarolrivera640 *Axis powers
Allied powers are the US, britain, france, USSR and a whole lot of other minor nations
I dont get it why are both of them in the train i thought was only jews? Hes Italian
All these happened lass than 100 years ago, but now germans act as if they do not nothing.
The Bear Jew like this.
Based Germans
So she was German!?
No she simply wasn't Jewish
No, she was Italian
Crazy woman
I hate this scene because I do not like how they lock the people up in a box cars and made them slaves and send them to the concentration camps which is not nice and I don't like that. A lot of people and I like McDonald's PlayPlaces and school buses with an electric stop arm better than that train. The subway train in Toronto Ontario, the subway in New York city, Amtrak, and New Jersey Transit are all way better trains than that train.
I know this scene is bad. And no I am not kidding.
This is what actually happened. They were loaded onto boxcars like animals and sometimes traveled for days even standing up with little air and only a bucket to do their business in.
On revision this is a troll comment and I got caught in the net.
+Panzer Faust: Maybe not a troll .... Maybe an ignorant, indifferent child who was simply interested in trains!
+Panzer Faust: Maybe not a troll .... Maybe an ignorant, indifferent child who was simply interested in trains!
I HATE this place. HATE HATE HATE. it.
If i were her i wouldn't get on that Train
beautiful life comes from his beautiful mind
beautiful life comes from his beautiful mind