📚 *MORE HISTORY* 📚 Read after watching the video for no spoiler! *_BTS Dorm_* 2012. All the members sleep in one room with bunk beds. Bed: SG-RM, V-JM, Jin-JH (upper-lower bunk), King JK in a single bed. Mar 2015. Roommate: Jin-SG, V-JM-JH, JK-RM. Sep 2016. Roommate: Jin-SG, V-RM, JM-JH + JK in the closet. Dec 2017. Hannam The Hill. Everyone has their own rooms except for JM & JH. *_BTS Contract_* On Bang Bang Con, Jin stated that the contract ended in June 2020, but they renewed it. They didn't specify for how many years; it's possible that it’s not seven years like the previous one although people _automatically assume_ that it's the case. I think they had to choose in 2018 because BTS planned everything in advance; they couldn't just stop all of a sudden. Edit. According to the official document, BTS contract will expire in 2024 if they don't renew it again. Source: www.quora.com/When-does-BTS-s-contract-end-I-read-on-AllKpop-their-contract-is-ending-with-BigHit-in-2024-I-thought-it-was-in-2026/answer/SooA-Ramond?ch=10&share=fbe3e7f0&srid=nMRfS *_Seokjin Gay Twitwar_* Because of the 20:12 poll, 'Seokjin gay' was trending on Twitter. It's not even about his s3xuality, but about how gays and lesbians love him. However, some straight ARMYs urged to "clear the search," which wasn't taken lightly by the LGBT ARMYs. The thought that being associated with the word gay is considered as an insult is insulting for them. It's not a swear word or a bad word; they're just celebrating. Isn't it an honour to be loved by gays, straights, and everyone? So, they created #seokjingay to counter that, and it's trended for the whole month. Twitter is tiring, LOL. PS. There's a widely circulated "fact" that Jin received 16 roses on Valentine even though he's in an all-boys school. Sounds plausible, but no source stated this. It's probably a joke that's unintentionally spread (as always). Though most are harmless, I wish big accounts were more responsible in spreading information. *_Edit. Pre-debut Bangtan_* K-Hiphop phase: RM, Iron, Supreme Boi + i11ven, Suga, J-Hope (most left once the concept changed). Hiphop idol phase: RM (the only OG lineup left), Suga, J-Hope, Kidoh + they added the vocal line. Final: Kidoh left, IDK if anyone who's supposed to be in the vocal line left too. So many people come and go, no wonder JK cried when JH almost left. Bless RM for being super patient! 🙇 *_Kidoh (Hyosang) Left Pre-debut Bangtan_* Yes, Bangtan. He and Iron weren't just a trainee at Big Hit. Kidoh never stated the official reason, and it'll remain a mystery; similar to what happened to 2jin-how hard is the breakup 💔😭 The only clue is this song of him as a Bangtan trainee ua-cam.com/video/dRrpXPyyQXo/v-deo.html It's odd because others who left chose to be a solo rapper/producer, but Kidoh still debuted as an idol. Nevertheless, he got a bigger role in Topp Dogg since he's also a producer. He's like Suga; the agency promised him things, but Big Hit delivered, while Stardom/Hunus is a mess (unfair profit distribution, CEO stole money). Kidoh even rumoured to file a lawsuit before he left. The number of K-entertainment companies that ruin aspiring singers’ life is devastating. Arario & Annie are timeless bops, though. PS. Kidoh, Jin, and JK joined BH around the same time in 2011. I believe Kidoh has a huge part in Jin's life. He's concerned about Jin's screen time way before we do and supported Jin _a lot_ back then. He might as well be the leader of Jin stan, but life happens, I guess? Despite everything, I appreciate him, and he deserves a mention. *_대남협 DaeNamHyup ➜ Rock Bottom_* A collective of several underground rappers. RM, Iron, Supreme Boi, i11ven, and Kidoh are some of the members. Usually, they perform and go on tour together. RM genuinely loved being with DNH as he can have more freedom and relax since he's not the leader. He officially left in 2015. For more information, watch '4 Things' Ep.3 (Rap Monster special), the theme is about being an idol-rapper. This is the source of the legendary clip when Bang PD pranked him to choose between a solo career or BTS. Clip: ua-cam.com/video/FrPHYARptuQ/v-deo.html DNH Rap Monster made 'Expensive Girl' and 'Trouble,' BTS RM made masterpieces. He matured a lot as a rapper, apparently, by leaving the underground world and staying with BTS. PS. No, Jin isn't on 'Trouble.' Namjin shippers started it, and they admitted it as the misinformation won't stop spreading to new ARMY twitter.com/namjincollab/status/1290144215373144065?s=19 PSS. Here's the OG We Are Bulletproof Pt.1 with Iron (Hunchul) & Supreme Boi (Donghyuk) ua-cam.com/video/iRjzw1pADFo/v-deo.html. It's that good. Learning old stuff like this will make you appreciate rap line more for keeping up with the sound change. *_Iron & Kidoh controversy (TW ⚠️)_* Iron started the song 'Roll' with a line about r*pe fantasy. While people who have that tendency do exist, it's insensitive to make it into a song for the GP considering the amount of harassment that women get daily. Kidoh apologised (Iron didn't) and clarified on his Twitter that it's about "a twisted BD$M love," but most people don't buy it. Kidoh is fluent in English as he used to live in Australia, so he reaches out to international fans more. Also, the line about giving trauma is nonsense. Things like that should help to cope with trauma. It's never about the abuse but the trust & control. I hate Iron for bringing everyone in the group down. PS. Supreme Boi produced & co-wrote 'Roll' and many more explicit/s3xist songs. He's even more involved than Kidoh, TBH, but he never apologised for anything. Now you know why some ARMY hate him and make memes of him. Unfortunately, he produced too many BTS songs; it's almost impossible to cancel him. *_Bonus: JK's GCF_* On comment since people often ask about this. Thank you for reading the history lesson. I hope you learn something new today~ Intertextuality is important for nuance, and I feel that it's often missing. I hope my channel can provide you with precisely that so we can appreciate them not just as a pair but also as human beings ❤️ Edit 1. Edit 2. This video excludes one singing performance at 30:51 due to copyrighted Love Maze Japan performance, but the content will be the same. Gdrive link for UNCUT VERSION of Ep.05: drive.google.com/file/d/1OUB4fMGah_wmjM5GabIFtvjrl0kdUgQ5/view?usp=sharing More information: ua-cam.com/users/postUgxsHr-YUn7rv395jyF4AaABCQ
*GCF Tokyo* I think people make a bigger deal over it. Let's appreciate JK's first directing project instead of over-analysing it. 🥺 The Jikook analysis of that is scary and borderline stalking. Jimin _deserves_ it considering how JK treated him in the past (ex. the visual ranking, his bias towards Jin though Jimin often helped him too). It’s good that JK started to pay more attention to everyone else besides Jin & RM. More things to consider: 1. They're in the middle of the Wings Tour in Asia. Based on the holiday before BV4, we know that Jin isn't a fan of travelling; he prefers to rest. They only get several days for the break, and Jimin is always up for travelling. It's also his birthday month, so it could be a gift. 2. JK wanted to go on a trip to Japan; Jimin wanted it too. They stated it multiple times, and they went together. Actually, Tae also wanted to travel, but 2017 was hard for him. This is the time when people started to worry about him. In Oct, he lost a friend (Lee Ui So) to su1c1de after losing his grandfather. So, that could be the reason he didn't join them. 3. Don't 100% believe anything that Jimin says because he often exaggerates things for fun (this isn't related to him professionally). Ex. In BV3, Jimin reminded Tae that in BV2 he wrote about how he can't live without Jimin, but Tae didn't. People turn it into a theory; he couldn't care less. If anything indeed made Jin upset, IMHO, it's not JK, but the fans and all the far-fetched analysis that makes things awkward between them; making something innocent & sincere turns into a "sexy & romantic getaway in a love hotel." Because not long after that, they did the Army.Zip interview when JK said that Jin is his everything and vice versa. They're also close in 2018 shows (Run BTS 50-67, BV3). So, there's no problem except for the personal issues related to the contract extension. They're just lowkey~ 😎✨ --- *EDIT 1.* Hello everyone. Iron (Jung Hunchul) just passed away today 21/01/25. Condolences to all his family and friends. Please take everything that I mentioned as simply facts so that we don't speak ill of the deceased. *EDIT 2.* This video excludes one singing performance at 30:51 due to copyrighted Love Maze Japan performance, but the content will be the same. Gdrive link for UNCUT VERSION of Ep.05: drive.google.com/file/d/1OUB4fMGah_wmjM5GabIFtvjrl0kdUgQ5/view?usp=sharing More information: ua-cam.com/users/postUgxsHr-YUn7rv395jyF4AaABCQ
i cant believe someone like u with this much of a talent in research and data gathering and video making is out here doing god's work but Kudos AF. the amount of time and effort put into this and all ur other videos as well is evident and the results are Remarkable. i cant wait for your next videos!
Funfact: Jungkook composed “Stay” originally for his mixtape. He’s a genius. Anyway we all know Jungkook is close to Jin. Even Jungkook’s brother likes Jin bc Jin took care of Jungkook so well. Like this if u agree
Jin’s friendship with Kidoh at that time seems understandable since RM couldn’t get Jin’s attitude to work, Suga was being extra rebellious, Hobi was struggling to fit in the rap line and the rest were teens. No wonder they got on well due to the same age. What’s happened next was for the best as time showed. KenJin... Was someone seriously considering them more than good buddies, lol? They’re 92 liners holding the same position in their bands as the oldest vocalists, also sharing the interest for acting. Ken gives me impression of being a sweet and genuine person who remains close to Jin to this day. All in all Seokjin is a perfect example of what nowadays called an emotionally intelligent person. He’s an empath with highly developed social skills, an adept at understanding how other people might feel and able to solve problems in ways that work for everyone. Real social butterfly. I gotta say I’ve never really been into shipping. Jin is my bias. I was observing him mostly and Jinkook relationship was thought-provoking. To me both the type for whom being a true self in relationship is highly important and therefore choice of a friend as a partner is a good option since as close friends, you know each others’ weaknesses, insecurities and dark sides all too well. Plus JK initially might be into older people. But with my utmost respect I don’t want to put any label on them, if they are happy, safe and sound, that’s enough I admire your love to Jinkook and your dedication to provide such a high quality content! Thank you from the bottom of my heart!
I couldn’t agree more to your comment. If Jin is your bias you are equally as high emotionally intelligent one like him! Like you, i am not into shipping. I just wish them to be true to themselves and be happy. 😊
Most of the 'ship' videos I see are fixated on some imagination of how some nonsense made them jealous or this touch/look ment something... But you showed the basis of why Kook & Jin became closer, how their friendship grew, how their love for each other grew... And that's why I liked this video coz it didnt fantasize on something that wasn't there rather showed something that is there (platonic or not that's not upto us) Wish I had a friendship like Jinkook 😭 Please keep making videos like this💜
Thank you! I didn't buy the jealousy narrative either. I mean, the reason people in the entertainment industry end up dating someone in the same field is exactly because of that; to have someone who understands that a job is just a job. You can't be overly jealous if you're with someone in this industry, be it idols or actors. Even if it's there, it's probably just a fleeting emotion that disappears quickly, and that's normal.
Agree! So many exaggerated "jealousy" jinkook videos here in YT. If all of those are true, it's amazing that JK or J even has the time to breathe or even do anything else 🥴
I love and appreciate that your analysis doesn't try to prove Jin and JK are in a romantic relationship. You are wise enough to realize that only Jinkook know what is between them. Your intent is to document the growth of their genuine bond. You do that brilliantly. Don't stop. If you are shipping members only because you believe they are in a romantic relationship, you will be disappointed. BH would never allow a gay couple to be exposed. It would cause incredible backlash for BTS and the couple in their home country. We are fans. We only see maybe 10% of the members' private lives. BH controls the content and the narrative. BH makes business decisions to maximize profits. BH does not produce Kdramas. Because of your analysis, I'm even more convinced that Jinkook share a deep, complicated and loving bond that will probably last a lifetime. Their connection and chemistry is unique for a hyung and maknae. It doesn't matter to me if their bond is platonic or romantic. The nature of Jin and JK's relationship is none of my business. I support Jinkook as human beings, not just as a ship. Regardless of who they are to each other, it is a true love story.
You expressed it so well. The different ships videos out there can be pretty convincing. But like you said, only ones who knows for sure is them and the other members. Never thought it a good rule to be involved with someone you work with, but things happen. I just hope they’re all happy and fulfilled.
"Eyes are window of soul" and the way their eyes glows when they see each other tells thousand reasons why Jinkook is a strong bond. I've never been amazed by any ship than Jinkook when it comes to their relationship. I don't want to label it. But whatever it is-it's pure and strong.
Thank you so much for giving us another well written analysis. I used to ship other Bangtan Shipper, but then I noticed that JK also showed the same expression of feelings towards Jin, it could be seen from the look in his eyes, his touches, the so many little attention JK gave to Jin. I paid more attention to Jinkook after seeing the video footage on BV2 Hawaii where Jinkook walking together (with the third wheeling Jimin) pretended to be a bride & groom and especially when BTS was at a restaurant, where suddenly RM and Jin stood up while the host at the restaurant was holding an event for a married couple. On the show RM asked Jin why Jin stood with him because Jin was not his partner, RM asked “What about Jungkook?”. That's what then made me start to find out about Jinkook. My curiosity grew more with Taehyung Vlive when there was an indication that Jin was in JK's room (hiding in the bathroom) when Taehyung came to JK's hotel room while they were in Japan. I increasingly believe that there is a special relationship between Jinkook when BTS members tease JK about the extension of JK is from Kim Jungkook and Jungkook looks very flustered. When Suga teased and reprimanded JK and will make Jin sad because Jin was not included in the list of the most important people in JK's life, once again JK looks so flustered and there are many other hints which I found and show that there is indeed a special relationship between Jinkook. Your interesting analysis really helped me more in my curiosity about them. I am happy because lately BH content has been showing the interactions between Jinkook more often without trying to cut their scenes, although of course there are still more scenes that they have to hide. Jinkook's interaction in In The Soop shows how domestic and intimate the two of them are even though we still don't get Jinkook sharing the same room. I knew about Hyosang and Jin are close friend, but never knew that there are an indication that both of them are more than close friend. You really need to work harder to prepare this new video, it’s a blessing for us Jinkooker to have you. We will always be waiting for another content from you. 😘💜
Quite honestly, one of the best JinKook channels on UA-cam. I can feel the love respect you have for both Jin and Kook as you don’t make up anything or shove ridiculous theories about their relationship. I like that you concentrate on the most important aspects of their relationships, which are essentially shown organically. Please keep up the great work on these videos. 👍🏼👏🏼
After I watched the “ship” part i guess that’s more reason why Jinkook always stay lowkey & closed off... I wish they stay underrated cos somehow feel like that’s a way to protect them. I hope they just stay in their own private bubble without needing to disclose it to public... Since now BTS are well known worldwide..a little slip up can cause problems to everyone... Everyone have their past but what matter is the future.. and i really want Jinkook have their happy ending.. Be it together or with someone else. It hurts to think if they ended up with other people but for now i just want to enjoy their moments together.. BH & the member really did a great job protecting each other... Everyone knows Jin is a mysterious person. The Jin we see in public is very different from Kim Seok Jin... It’s probably not easy to hide his dark side cos he didn’t want to worry army... But i hope he didn’t lose himself.. **Thank you for the video. It’s beautifully made... Keep up the good work! 💜
Isn't it crazy that JK's smile is so different when he laugh with Jin. His eyes crinkle and smiles so genuinely. I think that's why it calls his "Jin hyung smile"
Wow, this was such an amazing video, the progression of their relationship was eye opening. I had no clue about the other ships with Jin, wow you really did your research to present this. I am greedy for more. I heard a lot about Jikook and Taekook ships, but this is no ship. What Jin and Jungkook have is pure authentic true love, not figments of our imagination, this is why their bond is so strong even to this day.
True, their relationship is very supportive and healthy. We can learn so much from them! I feel like I grow as a person too while observing them. That's why I want to share it on this channel.
How amazing and eye-opening 43 minutes and 18 seconds! I've never seen anyone compiling Jinkook history chronologically in such a clear fashion. It also proves to me that I am still too new to this fandom. There are so many things I don't know, while all this time I thought that I surfed all things related to Jinkook, haha. Putting the history aside, as I am just a baby Army since Nov 2019, it is still easy to note by observing Jin and JK today that there is a unique bond. A bond so special makes them impossible just "brothers." I don't favor imagination outruns the facts, so I much appreciate your masterpiece supporting Jinkookers with the truth. Please keep it up. I am now your faithful viewer.
I have some deleted scenes and I don't know what to do with the information that I have 😢 It's in the past but it still breaks my heart, knowing that it _might_ affect him a lot too 💔
I am really picky when it comes to shipper analysis videos coz from my POV, they sometimes overanalyzed things and made things weird. Sometimes, I tried to point out things but at the end, I was considered as a hater which made me sad. But, yours is not like that. You don’t label or tag anything on their relationship and let us make decision by watching all those beautiful moments. Coz my bias is Jin, I am extra attentive to him from day one till now. Although he has been showing his happy and cheerful sides from day one, I can sense the feeling of insecurity when I look into his solo songs and bts songs that he participated in producing and composing. In term of insecurity, what I want to say is that he is afraid of losing something or someone. He might have lost many ppl who he held dear during this long journey. And your video provides me the clue which I need to make my puzzle complete - like Kidoh. And another thing I like about your videos is that it didn’t include those slomo, hickeys, sexual tensions or lots of jealousy mm which I found a little bit irritating. Hehehe I am not a fan of it. Like you said, a relationship is more than just skinship and jealousy. And another thing I respect about loyal jinkookers is that they don’t try to question about not getting moments.Yep, there are some who change ships coz of that. But, for me, not getting moments doesn’t mean that their relationship was torn apart or they are not that close anymore. We need to keep in mind that we are supporting and appreciating the relationship of two ppl in real life not the ones in fanfics or romcom. I also had a boyfriend but I don’t stick with him all the time coz I need to give times and loves to my friends, my bff and family and even need to have “me” time. For BTS, they’ve been living together over 8 years and for some, it is nearly 10 years, so, how strong their bonds will be. So, every ship will have their wonderful, sweet moments even if it is the least popular ones. We don’t need to doubt or question every time and also we don’t have the right to doubt.After all, we are just the third persons. But I found most of the jinkookers are mature and insightful. In the comment section, I am really happy to find such jinkookers like (Seokjin’d Smeraldo, Julia, Ginia Marlafe Mabanta, Gerilyn Mitchell, etc). Sorry for mentioning names, I have the habit of reading long comment under analysis videos coz they let me know other ppl’s perspectives and I love your insights. My comment got quite long, too. Thanks a lot for this awesome videos and also Noumena fanfic. Looking forward to ep 6
@@lrhlrh7393 hehe thanks Tbh, I somehow love the fact that our jinkook is not much popular camparing with other ships. Instead of having a large community of toxic and biased ppl, I prefer being in a small one even though there are just 10 or 100. Coz the ppl matter not the number. Besides, most of my ships are the least popular ones 😅
Thank you so much for made this video for us to watch. Your edit and the way you explained it were so beautiful. I didn't know about Kidoh "Jin's other half" omg maybe that's why he frequently saying that he want BTS are always together :( because he lost his best friend. I'm so relieved Jin found JK and BTS :( I love their friendship so much. Even if you don't know about anything, you still can see the way they treat each other is very different from other members. Please don't stop loving Jinkook ♡
And the thought that he's almost in BTS and they could still be together right now and be okay and he could protect him from falling deeper into the abyss could be something for him too (just a guess). After all, they're still very close no matter what kind of relationship they had. Again, what I love from Jinkook is everything fits like a puzzle. It can explain how Jin views things as you mentioned above.
This is a masterpiece of jinkook’s history iswtg when i first learned about bts i noticed a special connection between them. I’ve felt like their relationship is just so pure and sincere that i’ve never seen it from other duos.
I have watched jinkook videos and this is one of the most reliable that I can say I was able to verify how Jin and JK develop that kind of relationship that they have as time goes by. It maybe underrated but that's OK as long as both of them takes care of what is with them and I can say that now it's clear when JK said that it's better to appreciate things even in a small way possible. That's how love I guess, you can appreciate things even in a small way as long as it has something to do with the other. I just hope whatever happens, both will be brave and have the courage to be in each others back. Those that they have encountered during those times is Really something that will not be Possible without the help of each other.. Thanks again and hope to see more...
thank you for the elaboration of their timeline. I start to suspect since V's Vlive at Osaka where JK seems so awkward and he kept shifting his attention to the bathroom. And Jimin's Vlive after that incident where he tease Jin about it. And not to mention JK and Jin holding hands when they are sleeping together during BON VOYAGE season 1, when they are sleeping at the upper bunk of the camper van. JK was sleeping in the middle or Jin and J-hope and JK naturally move close to Jin while sleeping and waking up at Jin's side. I always love how JK look at Jin and smile and his gaze for Jin. During the BTS festa 2018, V noticed that Jin was wearing JK's shirt and mentioned it, but no one reply to that question. Instead Jin said he just wear what he see in his wardrobe. 2020 BTS festa, Jin and JK are always together. I am happy that BH finally release more footage and screen time of them both being together and they are so happy. BH start showing other ships and less of JINKOOK since after BV1 and the Osaka Vlive incident. I am also happy with their MV Life goes on with JK being the director, it is like, see Jin through JK's eyes. I hope they will be happy together forever.
Yes ur right there bond is so special but still people ignore it and always say namjin or taekook is best but for me it jinkook it's the best bond it may be frndship ,brotherly love i still love it
@@moonbathingrite you have a vision of a great storyteller that is armed with well researched facts and references. may i know what software are u using?
@@moonbathingrite your analysing is great you are the best so far. I subscribed to your channel bcz I really loved the video. The reason I started in believing jinkook is bcz of some anonymous sasaengs who wants to sell info through quora. They stated that jk is bisexual and dating a member. So eventually after some analysis I came to the conclusion that jinkook. Must be the couple
Oh wow! This was so good! You unearthed so much of their old content (some of them I've never seen before) and created a definitive history of their relationship. You made this ship soar! Great work!
I really enjoy your series. You've gathered bits and pieces of them I've never even thought to look for, like Jin's tweets and outings with Kidoh, their excerpts from magazines etc. If people find your videos and watch them, it'll be a great way of introducing the two to them and help them see Jinkook in a new light. On a side note I want to vent a bit sorry... I've been an Army for 7 years now and thanks to external circumstances (cross-referencing another celebrity couple I was following) it finally hit me that Jinkook didn't just have a very serious brother complex towards each other. I think new fans can see the true nature of their relationship more easily than older fans... some of us are still stuck with the mindset that they're very close brothers. The impression of baby Jungkook was just imprinted into my mind. It took a couple of days for it to sink in but everything is so clear now that I'm looking at them from a new perspective. It's really fascinating. Your channel definitely helped me through lol Please keep updating!
As JK’s fan i always admire how bangtan hyungs treated JK as their maknae and somehow Jin is noteably playing a huge part as to how JK is part of bangtan today. Its shocking that this video even exists. The facts explosion and progressive timeline clearly explains the flow. I love how this documentary is not based on assumptions like most of JinKook’s analysis videos and the unexpected “ship” in early bangtan days is the most interesting part i have learnt today. Thank you for your effort to produce this documentary video and hope we could have more of this in the future.
I may have read his name long mg time ago(kidoh) but I know nothing about him & jin. Don't know why but it breaks my heart to think that jin does 'lost' his bestfriend. About jinkook, I don't even know what to address them but I really love jinkook. They basically grow up together since becoming trainees. Jin once said they are close without boundaries. I just want them to be happy, no matter what happens in the future
Omg, you're just like telling us from head to toe abt their debut. I like very much the way your speech expression, it make clear to those new jinkookers or any other still confuse about their relationship. Thank you so much, hope to see this kind of vid again.
I hope so. Honestly, when I heard that people are confused about Jinkook, my first thought is, "Why??" But then I remember that people get into BTS in a different phase of their relationship and might not have the time to watch old videos and read old interviews or watch them grow through the different seasons, so I finally understand that point of view.
@@moonbathingrite honestly I've watched this vid more than twice, it really worth seeing. And at 6.19min, when jk was interviewed all the members, only jin has special to drink his drink and that was jk feed jin drink it. Seeing Jin's expression a little blank at first. Hahaha
My Wednesday pray: These two beautiful people to be together and make each other happy FOREVER 💜💜. And for their family, friends and fans (ARMY or not ARMY) to accept them the way they are and their beautiful relationship! I'm sure that there are millions of other out there wishing and praying the same. 🥰
it's almost scary to realize I have basically all the pictures that showed up (alongside some videos and gifs) broooo am I whipped for those two?!! Indeed, I am! who am I even trying to fool? lol
I will say one thing: YOU BLEW MY MIND AWAY!! You did such goof research and everything you said is really true! I've been watching this over the past few days, and I really enjoyed it! You had all your facts and everything! The ending when Jungkook was asked what is happiness and he replied with "being able to smile" and all those pictures of him smiling came after, I had tears in my eyes. It was such a beautiful presentation, really well done!
OMG im so speechless. This video really really awesome!! The details you made are so crazy its prove that how much you love jinkook, now i know the jin's affraid its bcs he dont wanna lost his soulmate again, so he take care a lot jkey as his half of his soul. Im so melting when i know that reason. Jin have really hard time to survive aftr his broken heart. I cant imagine his feelin that time. Now i wish he always happy with his lover. Once again i wanna say thankyou fr making this amazing analyze video. Borahae 💜
I wanna write down loads of things but I am also kind of speechless.. I wanna sincerely thank you for creating such a beautiful and detailed video about Jinkook.. I learned a lot from you.. and your cinematography is *chef's kiss* fabulous!
Wow! They all have a special relationship with each other. Thank you for sharing apart of the culture. They all deserve the best and all the happiness they can get. They are all loved and cherished .
I love how you always quoted something based on what they did or said. You bring fact, collect them all, make a very good video and edit to make us understand more. I really hope the 'hard' stan of whoever ship in bts will do the same and being intelligent enough like you❤️ and can stop them making imaginary theory based on nonexistent things lmao. Thank you so much for point out their bond, love you so much for this❤️ hope your channel will get bigger time by time
It's even more accurate information here...I was able to start from their beginning of their journey with BTS. Being the latest army I should say and able to watch vids and clips with different side of the story I can honestly tell that JK and Jin's relationship is quite different and natural compared to the other members regardless how other people push to ship their bets.
This is so beautiful. It was so perfectly arranged and well-put together. I nearly cried at the middle of the video, I literally feel the heartache and then finally made the connection on how Jinkook slowly got together. I knew of Hyosang (but is like I only know about his name and he left bighit, that all) but with your video, I felt like I have discovered another secret again! Thinking like how closed Jin and Hyosang have been made my heart hurt Thank you so much for the video!
OMG I wish there was a way to put a super like on this masterpiece! I loved everything about this and learned new things as well. You got my sub and appreciation for your hard work. Thank you. Let's keep fighting in their corner together 💜💜💜💜
I can't just watch it once, it's so beautiful. really made me cry. Thank you for your hard work, I hope you are always happy and make more videos like this again.
woaaah im really amazed, imagine all the time, research and effort made into this series, it’s really nice to think that someone actually makes these videos, tbh these kind of jinkook stuff are the ones keeping me alive. so im really thankful. have a great day 💕
I just noticed that!! I always think RM knows something about jinkook, in run ep123 did u notice that when Jhope got a little angry and rose his voice at Jin, RM looked at JK straight away!!!
👏👏👏👏👏👏 Really enjoyed this video. Jin and Jungkook caught my eyes early on and this really helped me better understand Jin. I will watch again and look forward to future videos.
Omg it was adorable!! The best fanmade video that I've ever watched so far. I've watched so many videos but it was something else. Thank you so much and please keep doing this you are really talented. I'll be looking forward to your next video!
everytime saw channel about Jinkook i did subscribed at once this channel really amazed me.. thank you for ur videos i've learned more about them.. keep it up! 💜💜💜
Wow...this is beautiful.. Seeing their close bond is so adorable.. The way both Jin and Jk transformed beautifully over the years is simply amazing. Appreciate your efforts on this video...it's so well done.👍🏼
I thought I couldn't watch the video until the end because it was too long. But I watched it without moving and my tears flowed out of my eyes. Thanks for this nice edit. :)
Jin had said in a interview that he has lost many friends . I really hope he finds a true friend who understands him well and makes him happy . If he really thinks someone as a friend he never leaves that person and always stays by his side but mostly in his case people don't do the same way for him . Ahh I really want to see him with a friend that stays by his side . This video is so good I am Jin bias still I didn't know about his old friendships . Thank you so much for this amazing research .
I'm devastated, yet another time, by your work. I think I'll suffer for days. It was a heartbreaking pleasure watching your video. Sending my love and support to you from your very first work to the ones to come. Also to Jin, Jk, BTS, and Kidoh.
That's very kind of you to include Kidoh too! I was worried that he'll get hate by posting this, but I'm so relieved that everyone wishes him well! He truly deserves a second chance in the music industry after everything that happened to him.
Another piece of Art I am crying...thank you so much. I am blown away by the amount of effort and details in the video. I wish Jin and JK would stay together and be happy.
when i felt jin does'nt like to lose people i was so emotinal and also seeing kidoh and jin's friendship break hurted me . And the smile when jungkook is with jin and viceversa made me fall for them. I just hope them to keep smiling as always . And as subscriber i would like to say you're analysis are so good and i did'nt find it exagerrating and keep doing more videos. cheers!!
i was like crying while watching these video🤧 and today I even realize that im so very lucky & happy that i found Jinkook in my life bcs i really love them sm😭❤️ omg thankyou so muchh, u did a great job♡ much luv from a filipina girl❤️🇵🇭
Jin is the most consistent and fun, loving person in the group. He is the same almost all the time. Jungkook is the most loving person in the group and being the youngest has been shower with love from all six hyungs but he is extremely close with Jin, Jimin, and Tae. They all have their moment. But Jin is the one that taken care of Jungkook the most from the beginning and playing with him too. They just fun to see how they are interacting. Who would not love Jungkook though, he is so easy to please and so sensitive, and appreciative.
hi.. this is my first time commenting on 1 of your videos. this video was way too amazing to not leave a comment. 1. I'd like to compliment you on how you put the video together. it was fantastic. it didn't feel too long despite being almost 45 mins.. the info was tight and there was no skipping. 2. Your research work is amazing. after seeing your video, i looked up 2jin and the number of people who had shipped them was an eye opener. it also felt a bit heavy.. seeing the similarities between 2jin and jinkook.. I wonder if that's the reason why jin is a little over protective of him. 3. I really want to thank you for the way you do your videos. I'll be open. I detest shipper videos that focus on physical intimacy and try to paint every non-ship interaction as a moment of jealousy for one of the members of the ship. it's such a toxic way of thinking about relationships. surely everyone has close relationships outside of a ship and any partner who immediately gets jealous is a dangerous person? or maybe I am too old (mid-30s) to understand the teenage ways of thinking about love. 4. I also won't deny that I'm aware of the element of delusion that goes into "shipping" as the young ones call it today. So while I admit that there is an itch in my brain wrt jinkook because their behaviour shows a definite partiality and attention, I also know that there are gaps which my brain has filled with my own romantic notions. And it's easy for jinkook because you can tell how well a relationship between them would work. So I am swept away by your way of narrating their story. 5. I'm curious to know where your next stop will be. now that you've shown their history, I'm sure you have an idea on where to take this next. you don't have to tell me. i just want you to know that i look forward to it.
Thank you!! This has been a way to channel my frustration too because I'm afraid that "shipping" has been a way to promote a toxic relationship. It's dangerous, especially for teenagers who see the video. Anyway, I still can't get over 2jin too; how Hyosang slipped into a different circle of friends and his downfall began from that... It pains me but at the same time, it sheds a new light if how Jin protects JK and the other members. Thankfully, even with the tattoos and the way JK dressed it's just how he expresses himself, and deep inside he's such a sweetheart ❤️
@@moonbathingrite I wonder if Jin sees this as a way to rectify his own past "mistakes" such as maybe not being open with hyosang regarding some of choices and decisions.. because jin's influence on jk is not small..
Spent 2 hours watching and savoring this, and it was the best 2 hours of my life! WELL SPENT INDEED! hahaha Can I just blabber a lot of things here just to unload the thoughts I've had since knowing them? My bias is Jin and I did a lot of digging about him when I first got into BTS, read his past, and heard about Hyongsang before. But he was that unheard legend that was like a mystery even to old army's because not much was known about him. Yet I've always wondered where Hyongsang disappeared because Jin and he were so close even when he left bighit. I speculated before that when Hyongsang surrounded himself with the same crowd as Namjoon did (I really thought those folks had axes to grind when Joon stayed and focus all his time on BTS as an idol group). I remember Joon and Jin bonded in the early days of BTS after they accepted their differences, especially Joonie, and he has more than implied that he and Jin used to have serious conversations, go to cafes or somewhere when their dance training is done. It's not farfetched to say that maybe Jin got a sense of Joon's worries with regards to his former teammates and friends in the rap industry. I always thought there was something toxic in their mentality, especially when I saw that video of Joon meeting them at a cafe. Even then you can sense that intense tension behind their somewhat regulated/ trying to be polite words, while Joon tried to be at ease with his old crew but they were somehow, crass? to Joon. Maybe that's how Jin and Hyongsang grew apart when their values changed as well, as we know whom you surround yourself with pretty much influences your views and choices in life. It was a big mystery to me because Jin will not voluntarily cut off ties, not even at the behest of Bighit, not unless Hyongsang did something so grave that Jin decided to let their friendship go and forget they even knew each other. It's just pure speculation on my part, but after knowing and watching Jin all these years, I've always thought that he is the most secretive member of BTS. He only lets us see what he thinks we need to see and never really reveals who he is. He has always done things in a very calculated manner, and although he always speaks about only going with the general flow with no thoughts on it, knowing him, even a little already means something, and once he makes his final decision, Jin always pushes through with it and never looks back. Jin did mention losing lots of friends along the way, and maybe that's part of the reason why he took such good care of his members. Technically, Jin only needs to be there to train, work, and not take responsibility for 6 other people. It was the first time he had to lived away from his family, and his mom, who did everything for him before because he was the youngest. Jin look and sounded like a very pampered, rich kid when they just started, ahahaha. It's such a wonder how he'd grown, living together with a bunch of strangers and suddenly got the 'hyung' role when least expected. He was just supposed to go to college and learn how to act, but fate somehow had other plans for him. haha He took Jungkook, a kid he barely knew, under his wing and gave him love, money (which is sometimes harder to give than anything, honest to God), good food, emotional support, and playmate (hahaha). I think if he was asked again, Jin will say that he will not have it any other way. He would've still love to meet Jungkook the way he did, raise him for years to become his best friend/ lover? (I HOPE) forever.
Yes, that cafe clip is from 4 Things! And to witness that RM was so devastated to be left out from the group, saying, "I am DNH too," in that show hurts a bit. Like boy, you better listen to Jin and stay with BTS, escape from that group ASAP. Here ua-cam.com/video/-sCs3iKcTVo/v-deo.html, Supreme Boi said, "Right now Rap Monster was off dancing somewhere." IDK if it's an internal joke, but that seems inappropriate. I can't imagine the sht they say to the "unheard legend" too since he's also an idol, yet he chose to stay with them. Wait, maybe that's also the reason Jin looks for someone who listens to him well? I'm glad and grateful that JK clings to Jin during his crucial teenage years and always listens to him. In the process, he grows up to be such an amazing individual and find his self 💜
@@moonbathingrite Yeah, you see it too right? They did not mention it, but it was quite possible that happen a long time ago. I mean, Joon can be cryptic sometimes, but we all know everything he says is mostly about his life and experiences, and remember in his logs when he said that Jin influenced him a lot, his thinking, and the decisions he made later on in his life? Jin might be sympathetic and kind but he had always been on the logical or sensible side, and he might be sentimental yet he always had a clear vision when it comes to right or wrong. He's treated life similarly to how he does his cooking, he always likes to keep his working area clean and wash the dishes right after using them. He never lets dirty dishes sit for too long, and has always been swift with his decision when a delicate situation arises. Bang PD said it in a few words, how Jin never really change much from who he is, and how he kept the boys in line even from before. Joon had tried hard to hang on to his crew at the start, even he was already busy with BTS, supreme boi stayed with them initially when those ties should have been cut a long time ago. Joon valued his friendship and presence too much that he let him stay on, even when it was so obvious how he looks at the group (in disdain) and it wasn't really conducive for the whole team. God knows what Yoongi had to say during those days. They must have argued about it too, knowing Yoongi he will not be able to tolerate a passive-aggressive guy like him. At that point Hyongsang might have chosen his career over his friendship with Jin, and he has every right to do so, it wasn't his fault he wanted a career too, but Jin clearly cut him out when he saw that he's turned. Hyongsang liked the underground scene more than being an idol so it was his choice to make. I'm just glad that he didn't air anything bad about Jin and just deleted his post, and Jin also didn't talk anything bad or mention why they stop talking just that they did, but didn't it look like it was a bad breakup? hahaha, we really won't ever know. maybe in the future, we will? but it's been so long ago, does it even matter anymore? Jin might have talked to Joon about learning to let go and prioritizing himself and the group, and not taking on more than he can handle. That guy was like a ticking bomb and Jin, sensible that he is, might have open Joon's eyes about it. He always had a way with words, and he can tackle a very sensitive topic in a way that is not offensive and won't make you think on the defensive side (take for example that speech in that award show about creating music in an honest way) Yes, I'm thankful that Jk listens to Jin, despite him being independent since young. Jk wasn't sure most of the time, but then he always did what he set out to do regardless of consequences. Even at a young age he had the gal to come to Seoul without his parents (they must have dissuaded him no? since he was so young) but he always did things his way no matter what everybody says, even at that age, and when an idea takes on in his head, he mostly follows through with it regardless if he stops in the middle (as he often does with ALL his short lived hobbies lol). I think he follows Jin mostly because he just loves him. More than knowing that Jin is his Hyung who will always consider his wellbeing, I think Jungkook follows him because he wants to. For the few things in life that he is still crazy passionate about, like music, eating, exercise and filming, Jin has always been on the top of things he's willing to cross oceans for. Idk why, but Jungkook has always looked at Jin like he just met him yesterday and I've always wondered how he can still be so, so into him as if they didn't already know each other for 10 years. He's always been romantic, and if that devotion means nothing at all then I really have no clue what is love anymore hahaha. I honestly cannot be 100% certain, but everyday Jungkook always surprises me when he does something that makes me think long and hard if it's really just platonic or not.
@@minsu1110 I enjoy reading ur comment here 💜 Sorry to butt in, but I do love talking about jinkook. I love, appreciate, and respect Jin. The reason? Just like what u mentioned. All of the above. He’s a great person. He knows so many things yet humble n always let others shine and doing all that while looking like god. Lol. Also I respect the way he try to balance everything. He knows his limit so he never go overboard during performance. We can c how other members sometimes almost passed out (esp JK & Jm) after performance or voice cracked (Jm & V) coz they’ve been pushing too hard, but Jin always get a great control of himself. If he knows it’s too much then he won’t do it. I can talk about how I admire him for a month nonstop. Lol. That’s y after watching this video, it breaks my heart how he n his best friend (perhaps ex lover - as he called him his other half) grew apart n cut ties. Hopefully he can (if not already) get over it n meet more great people. And about JK... JK-ahhh.... I’m in the same boat with u, I also wonder how did he manage to be sooo consistent with his love to J??? Look at those eyes. Seems like his ‘crush stage to Jin’ never left him. Even until now they way he look at Jin is like having a love struck for a first time. And this is after knowing him for 10 f*cking years!!! The only change I noticed from JK is his possessiveness. He used to be so aggressive (pushing n pulling n glaring members if they get too close to J) now he seems to toned it down. Maybe he’s now confident enough that J also only look at him 💜💜💜 Ohhh my hearteuuuu 💜🤧
What a great Jinkook video you made us Jinkooker understand more the relationship of Jin and JK. Thank you for your hard work to make this a very detailed presentation. Stay safe, healthy and happy.
I cannot explain how I love your videos, especially this one, I am grateful that there is this type of "analysis" especially focusing on how they feel, without a doubt they are no longer the same people they were before and that is the best part of growing up, these days jin and JK are more about being aware of each other, but they don't take away the part of treating each other like "Tom and Jerry" idk, they really love each other a lot, I can't imagine when jin goes to MS, how much they will miss him (especially JK) I repeat, I am a fan of what you do, thank you for always showing us the true face of JinKook (sorry for my bad english)
This is sooooooo good. Hands down... the best. Well documented and put together. I especially appreciate the early moments that shows us there shy nature and how the bond was formed. I purple you 💜💜💜
Hello everyone. Iron (Jung Hunchul) just passed away today 21/01/25. Condolences to all his family and friends. Please take everything that I mentioned as simply facts so that we don't speak ill of the deceased. Let's pray that it doesn't affect the boys, and I'm honestly concerned about Hyosang & RM. Anyway, thank you. Rest in peace. www.soompi.com/article/1450596wpp/rapper-iron-passes-away
Outstanding, Marvelous, Fantastic. I am highly impressed by your hard work and research. Excellent. Keep up the good work. You are awesome. Keep loving Jinkook everyone. They will need our love and support. 💜
Thanks Admin. Actually this is my first time to heard about the story of Jin and the other "Jin". At first i was so shocked to know about the other Jin and how closed they were before. The days they're spent together and how honest he was in sharing their pics/convo in social media which public might see it. As a fan of Jinkook😊 i believe that jin and jk were really destined to meet each other. 😊 Jinkook is my happy pill. I love them both and I'll support them all the way 💜 more videos of Jinkook moment please..😊 #jinkookforever💜
Yes, the thanks to in the album is very sweet to me. However, Jin didn't share much; it's Hyosang. All the photos in the video are tweeted by him but then he deleted them all. So, Jin is a very private person ever since the beginning.
So niceu..i loved it from the start until the end.. Your so talented and smart. Im so glad your a jinkook shipper👏Pls continue to feed us Jinkook contents👉👈💜
I know theres lot of people who already said this, but your video is so beautiful ❤️❤️ all the editing, the analysis and all is so perfect. Thank you so much for your hard work ❤️❤️
I can watch your videos for 4 or 5 times and no matter how long it is. It's clear, correct, informative, pure?, sweet, touchable! Your videos are feels like a ... Home? Yes it feel like home! I love you! Please stay healthy!
This indeed an eye opening vid. almost all of the clips here as usual has never before seen in any videos. Kudos to your keen eye for details and sources for all these. Still, I can't believe that Jin has somewhat been in a "special" kind of relationship because I couldn't imagine him without jungkook. They both have the greatest chemistry and I can't imagine Jin ending with that guy whose completely different from JK. I think Jinkook is destined to be together.
Him during 2013-2014 = 2016-2018 Jin that we finally see after Fire era haha. Act like a kid, blunt, sudden outburst yet funny at the same time. Two Sagittarians. But Jin being with JK balance & complement each other better. Being too similar often doesn't work well.
@@moonbathingrite I completely agree..that's the right word..they COMPLEMENT each other. Your Jinkook videos and analysis were so precise and clever at the same time. You even have timelines of their activities and milestones over the past years. We thank you for all your effort in making all these. We can't wait for more! Borahae!
Once again you amazed me with your thoroughness and detailed information about JinKook events. Thank You. Since debut of Dynamite i became confused of Jinkook relationship because after watching old videos of them (since im a new army I've seen oldvideos only) I thought in 2020 they are less close to each other. they dont even bicker that much anymore. It didn't help that JK and Jimin are always together and everyone hyping it up. It didn't help that during dynamite promotion period, Jin was always sad and had poker face all the time, barely smiling. Then one of the Army open my eyes, saying "do we really see JK going from one relationship to another within the group in such a short amount of time?" and I thought NO. JK seems like the type of person who performs on stage fiercely, like no one can touch him. It showshis passion to something and sticks to it. Just like he shows and tell us how much he cares for Jin even when he was younger till now. Then we found out that Jin was going thru something. It came clear to me during Life goes on promotion that nothing was change with JinKook. They both just became more mature and probably more secure in their relationship. although there are times JK is still possessive of Jin. (have you seen the scene where V tried to lift Jin shirt during MOTS concert, JK was clearly upset with V) They just decided to keep things in private and keep it safe. especially with Dispatch mentioning they will reveal couples from BTS. Not only it might ruin them it might ruin the group and company. so its clear they are protecting a lot aside from themselves. If only they can freely announced their relationship without prejudice from their own country. Im sure the rest of the world or ARMY from other country will support but as a Korean im sure they know the extent of acceptance they will receive. My only wish for Jinkook is to finally be free of expressing each others feelings whatever it is without recieving prejudice or some kind of backlash from their own society. Borahae everyone. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I agree with the more mature and secure part. As I mentioned in the video, I think they begin to find their pace and rhythm, and I'm glad that you see it that way too. Regarding the moments, we should wait until Memories of 2020 and newer Bangtan Bomb videos are released because it also happens in 2019. They keep everything behind the scenes and outside social media. At this point, BB still stucks on Feb-Mar 2020 during MOTS:7 promotion.
@@moonbathingrite BB always post throwbacks yes, but if we want to see their relationship in 2020 we can c from the vlive and the recent performances. For me, I like to c their live coz that’s when BH can’t edit n cut their interaction. MOST OBVIOUS ones are in the beginning 2020 when Suga throw hints about Holly & also Jin apologising to JK (I believe smth happened b4 the vlive), 2nd will b dynamite release; how JK can’t even focus with the live n keep on glancing at Jin at the back n how he ‘warns’ V being too close to J, 3rd is grammy celebration vlive where 2 of them obviously has their own world. For me what even makes it more obvious is the members’ reaction. Esp Jhope 😂 @shirley gan of course BH will try to put Jikook more together. Their PR & marketing team KNOWS what they r doing. They can’t bcome this big without genius marketing strategy behind the scene. They know now maknae line is their cash cow. The most video thumbnails r maknae. From BB, vlive, Run BTS, n even MV. It attracts more clicks. And actually I personally think Jimin & Suga r Jinkook’s best supporter. Sometimes it makes me sad to c how they r forced to act that way for the sake of the company (look at dynamite Xmas version how they r forced to stand side by side with their ‘popular shipping partner’ Namjin Jikook Vhope’ n how JK can’t help but keep glancing to Jin’s direction n even snatched him away from RM 😁. BUT I also believe BH did that to protect jinkook. As u mentioned, SK doesn’t seem to b ready with idol’s openness with LGBT esp for BTS. They can’t even being mature with idols getting married let alone to accept the fact about their perfect idols r in relationship EO. Side note: I think now JK grows a lot, more confident about himself n his view of life. He didn’t even hesitate to tell Jin don’t b scared n nth to worry about. And as JK is now the most popular member, I think he uses the opportunity & use his ‘power’ with BH (ex: he can put Jin as the center n the most important element in LGO MV)
@Mrs S you are so right! everything you said is 100% correct. i do love those vlives. those are the ones they cant edit. i really think our Jinkook are extra careful nowadays. but yeah you can still see that they still care for each other. and i agree with you i am thankful to Jimin, jhope and suga. those three seemz to always protect and chamge the subject whenever some topic get to close for comfot for jinkook. i noticed on Jin bday vlive i think BH change the caption when Jin called jimin on the phone. according to the caption, he's with JK in the car and why was Jin callin him live on vlive without giving him a headsup. but when i translate the conversation jimin didnt say anything about giving a heads up. He said "we are coming now" and not "you called me without a heads up" ive seen other videos where editors change captions so i was suspicious and checked that conversation myself. it is clear during xmas season especially and award shows Jinkook are still madly inlove. i dont think anyone notice the behind the scene of black swan where jin kneeled down and did his acting with that shiny flying thingy, Jk and namjoon was watching on the side. thats probably why Jin answered JK "im always by your side" when they were opening the BE album with jhope, JK dedicated a line from the sonh stay to Jin " wherever you are" i also think BH is aware of Jinkook and just really protecting the both of them. sometimes its just frustrating not just for us but im sure for jinkook too. especially now they are stockholders of BH. they all have a lot to loose. and too many employees depending on them. Absolutely, i think 2020, BTS break from travelling arund the world was kinda good for jinkook relationship. I believe they are given a chance to get to know each other more in an adult level without fights about fanservices especially from concerts. i was just telling my friend that recent run bts although its filmed early 2020 you can see how JK pays attention to Jin and vice versa. now that BB are releasing more behind the scenes video we can see that they are still happy. im wishing for more lol. i do love that JK is putting jin in center and i do hope it happens again. i screamed when i watch that xmas video when JK snatched Jin away from RM. i was laughing so hard. and i thought, wow Bh didnt cut or change that. yeah i am praying , lets all pray that someday they actually get that chance to have freedom of expressing their feelings without consequences. sorry for this long comment and thank you for your patience with me borahae y'all! ✨💞✨💎✨
WOW!! U really made it like a drama.. The content is 100% different than other channel.. So far, ur channel is one of the best.. I'm so glad I found u.. Keep up the good work master-nim.. The detail about J** and H****** surprised me a lot.. It gave me bad feeling..
W.O.W.... 👍👍👍 thumbs up... This video from part 1-5 are amazing 😆😆 the details... Story line.... 100% entertaining... Thank You... Looking forward for your next Story 😘💜
I knew about 2jin but i didn't know he deleted all things related to jin😳 i wonder why... Again, such a lovely video, thank you. I can only imagine the time you spent in making this video. They went through a lot of phases, a lot of things that they don't let us see. But still, if it's true, it's true and what's genuine will always slip and show through.
I double-checked again before making the video and he deleted them ALL 💔 No photos, no hashtag. Here, there's nothing on this hashtag anymore from his Twitter: twitter.com/search?q=%23%EA%B9%80%EC%84%9D%EC%A7%84%ED%9A%A8%EC%83%81%20from%3A%40khyo_twt&src=typed_query But there's still one from BTS: twitter.com/search?q=%23%EA%B9%80%EC%84%9D%EC%A7%84%ED%9A%A8%EC%83%81%20from%3A%40bts_twt&src=typed_query I guess he's kind of impulsive? Posting and deleting everything as he wishes. It also happens when he clarified the controversy. By the way, look at the latest tweet that Hyosang liked, it's from BTS 😭 I'm so emo for them.
@@moonbathingrite it's me again :-) - i followed the link to the liked tweet, and then I also saw some new posts of Hyosang who has moved on. What happened was in the past (5 years ago?) and Jin looks much-loved (despite Abyss) and I credit JK really (remember that JK declared in one interview that he will fight for his love; whereas Jin would sacrifice)? As for observed less interaction in 2021, BH does limit their interaction, after shows where they show affection etc. Previous analyses had shown this to be true (@9792_archive's). Let's wait for the 2020 bombs; (aren't we all analysts now hehe; the Jinkook effect for me). Thank you so much for this video. I hope more get to see your work.
Ok, I have another comment and I really hope that those who read this would go and read the fanfic of our content creator, Moonbathingrite because when you do, all his/her videos, especially Episode 5 will hit you differently. Promise!!!! I just finished reading "Noumena" and I hated having to be interrupted by meals, by chores, by my children (although I love them still) because all I wanted to do was just read the story in its entirety and watch the videos referenced in the Notes Section. Moonbathingrite, you rock, gurl! You are my queen and you made me cry along with JK and SJ!!!!!!! Your story is so good. I wish that it was real although I think it is close -- or I am hoping that it is close IRL. Please keep on writing and please keep on making your videos. I don't know how you'll up your ante after "Noumena" because what else is there to write after that? You ended it beautifully!!!! But maybe their future after Bangtan perhaps? JK as a successful solo performer (he mentioned in his Weverse interview that he wonders how it would feel like to perform by himself for 4 hours onstage) and SJ as a successful sought-after actor? And how will they continue with their blissful togetherness? What would their hurdles be as a couple? Just some thoughts to keep your creative juice flowing. But, hey Jinkookers, you really have to read what our great author and Jinkook UA-camr wrote. S/he is our Jinkook Muse!!!!!! Here is the link to "Noumena." archiveofourown.org/works/24750598?view_full_work=true PS I wrote a long comment on the Comment Section of Noumena. I hope you get to read it.
Whoa, tysm! I guess it's time to log in back to my ao3. I'm planning to switch alternatively between writing and video making or else I'll lose interest because I get bored easily haha. For Noumena, I want to continue with the "what if" future scenario as you mentioned, a short pre-debut flashback because I find it veryy intriguing in shaping them today, and whatever feels right at that moment. I end it like that because I feel that the story will continue in reality. Also, the sequel for the Zombie.Zip one! I hope I'm motivated enough to do all~
@@moonbathingrite I hope we, your fans and avid followers, will motivate you enough, as well as our Jin and JK of course. Thank you again for such wonderful content. 😍😍😍😍😍😍 Borahae 💜💜💜💜
![[Leemujin Service] EP.141 BTS Jin | Life Goes On, I'll Be There, Running Wild, Falling](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n-f_Cv-_WPM/mqdefault.jpg)
📚 *MORE HISTORY* 📚
Read after watching the video for no spoiler!
*_BTS Dorm_*
2012. All the members sleep in one room with bunk beds. Bed: SG-RM, V-JM, Jin-JH (upper-lower bunk), King JK in a single bed.
Mar 2015. Roommate: Jin-SG, V-JM-JH, JK-RM.
Sep 2016. Roommate: Jin-SG, V-RM, JM-JH + JK in the closet.
Dec 2017. Hannam The Hill. Everyone has their own rooms except for JM & JH.
*_BTS Contract_*
On Bang Bang Con, Jin stated that the contract ended in June 2020, but they renewed it. They didn't specify for how many years; it's possible that it’s not seven years like the previous one although people _automatically assume_ that it's the case. I think they had to choose in 2018 because BTS planned everything in advance; they couldn't just stop all of a sudden.
Edit. According to the official document, BTS contract will expire in 2024 if they don't renew it again. Source: www.quora.com/When-does-BTS-s-contract-end-I-read-on-AllKpop-their-contract-is-ending-with-BigHit-in-2024-I-thought-it-was-in-2026/answer/SooA-Ramond?ch=10&share=fbe3e7f0&srid=nMRfS
*_Seokjin Gay Twitwar_*
Because of the 20:12 poll, 'Seokjin gay' was trending on Twitter. It's not even about his s3xuality, but about how gays and lesbians love him. However, some straight ARMYs urged to "clear the search," which wasn't taken lightly by the LGBT ARMYs. The thought that being associated with the word gay is considered as an insult is insulting for them. It's not a swear word or a bad word; they're just celebrating. Isn't it an honour to be loved by gays, straights, and everyone? So, they created #seokjingay to counter that, and it's trended for the whole month. Twitter is tiring, LOL.
PS. There's a widely circulated "fact" that Jin received 16 roses on Valentine even though he's in an all-boys school. Sounds plausible, but no source stated this. It's probably a joke that's unintentionally spread (as always). Though most are harmless, I wish big accounts were more responsible in spreading information.
*_Edit. Pre-debut Bangtan_*
K-Hiphop phase: RM, Iron, Supreme Boi + i11ven, Suga, J-Hope (most left once the concept changed).
Hiphop idol phase: RM (the only OG lineup left), Suga, J-Hope, Kidoh + they added the vocal line.
Final: Kidoh left, IDK if anyone who's supposed to be in the vocal line left too. So many people come and go, no wonder JK cried when JH almost left. Bless RM for being super patient! 🙇
*_Kidoh (Hyosang) Left Pre-debut Bangtan_*
Yes, Bangtan. He and Iron weren't just a trainee at Big Hit. Kidoh never stated the official reason, and it'll remain a mystery; similar to what happened to 2jin-how hard is the breakup 💔😭 The only clue is this song of him as a Bangtan trainee ua-cam.com/video/dRrpXPyyQXo/v-deo.html
It's odd because others who left chose to be a solo rapper/producer, but Kidoh still debuted as an idol. Nevertheless, he got a bigger role in Topp Dogg since he's also a producer. He's like Suga; the agency promised him things, but Big Hit delivered, while Stardom/Hunus is a mess (unfair profit distribution, CEO stole money). Kidoh even rumoured to file a lawsuit before he left. The number of K-entertainment companies that ruin aspiring singers’ life is devastating. Arario & Annie are timeless bops, though.
PS. Kidoh, Jin, and JK joined BH around the same time in 2011. I believe Kidoh has a huge part in Jin's life. He's concerned about Jin's screen time way before we do and supported Jin _a lot_ back then. He might as well be the leader of Jin stan, but life happens, I guess? Despite everything, I appreciate him, and he deserves a mention.
*_대남협 DaeNamHyup ➜ Rock Bottom_*
A collective of several underground rappers. RM, Iron, Supreme Boi, i11ven, and Kidoh are some of the members. Usually, they perform and go on tour together. RM genuinely loved being with DNH as he can have more freedom and relax since he's not the leader. He officially left in 2015. For more information, watch '4 Things' Ep.3 (Rap Monster special), the theme is about being an idol-rapper. This is the source of the legendary clip when Bang PD pranked him to choose between a solo career or BTS. Clip: ua-cam.com/video/FrPHYARptuQ/v-deo.html
DNH Rap Monster made 'Expensive Girl' and 'Trouble,' BTS RM made masterpieces. He matured a lot as a rapper, apparently, by leaving the underground world and staying with BTS.
PS. No, Jin isn't on 'Trouble.' Namjin shippers started it, and they admitted it as the misinformation won't stop spreading to new ARMY twitter.com/namjincollab/status/1290144215373144065?s=19
PSS. Here's the OG We Are Bulletproof Pt.1 with Iron (Hunchul) & Supreme Boi (Donghyuk) ua-cam.com/video/iRjzw1pADFo/v-deo.html. It's that good. Learning old stuff like this will make you appreciate rap line more for keeping up with the sound change.
*_Iron & Kidoh controversy (TW ⚠️)_*
Iron started the song 'Roll' with a line about r*pe fantasy. While people who have that tendency do exist, it's insensitive to make it into a song for the GP considering the amount of harassment that women get daily. Kidoh apologised (Iron didn't) and clarified on his Twitter that it's about "a twisted BD$M love," but most people don't buy it. Kidoh is fluent in English as he used to live in Australia, so he reaches out to international fans more.
Also, the line about giving trauma is nonsense. Things like that should help to cope with trauma. It's never about the abuse but the trust & control. I hate Iron for bringing everyone in the group down.
PS. Supreme Boi produced & co-wrote 'Roll' and many more explicit/s3xist songs. He's even more involved than Kidoh, TBH, but he never apologised for anything. Now you know why some ARMY hate him and make memes of him. Unfortunately, he produced too many BTS songs; it's almost impossible to cancel him.
*_Bonus: JK's GCF_*
On comment since people often ask about this.
Thank you for reading the history lesson. I hope you learn something new today~
Intertextuality is important for nuance, and I feel that it's often missing. I hope my channel can provide you with precisely that so we can appreciate them not just as a pair but also as human beings ❤️
Edit 1.
Edit 2. This video excludes one singing performance at 30:51 due to copyrighted Love Maze Japan performance, but the content will be the same. Gdrive link for UNCUT VERSION of Ep.05: drive.google.com/file/d/1OUB4fMGah_wmjM5GabIFtvjrl0kdUgQ5/view?usp=sharing
More information: ua-cam.com/users/postUgxsHr-YUn7rv395jyF4AaABCQ
*GCF Tokyo*
I think people make a bigger deal over it. Let's appreciate JK's first directing project instead of over-analysing it. 🥺 The Jikook analysis of that is scary and borderline stalking. Jimin _deserves_ it considering how JK treated him in the past (ex. the visual ranking, his bias towards Jin though Jimin often helped him too). It’s good that JK started to pay more attention to everyone else besides Jin & RM.
More things to consider:
1. They're in the middle of the Wings Tour in Asia. Based on the holiday before BV4, we know that Jin isn't a fan of travelling; he prefers to rest. They only get several days for the break, and Jimin is always up for travelling. It's also his birthday month, so it could be a gift.
2. JK wanted to go on a trip to Japan; Jimin wanted it too. They stated it multiple times, and they went together. Actually, Tae also wanted to travel, but 2017 was hard for him. This is the time when people started to worry about him. In Oct, he lost a friend (Lee Ui So) to su1c1de after losing his grandfather. So, that could be the reason he didn't join them.
3. Don't 100% believe anything that Jimin says because he often exaggerates things for fun (this isn't related to him professionally). Ex. In BV3, Jimin reminded Tae that in BV2 he wrote about how he can't live without Jimin, but Tae didn't. People turn it into a theory; he couldn't care less.
If anything indeed made Jin upset, IMHO, it's not JK, but the fans and all the far-fetched analysis that makes things awkward between them; making something innocent & sincere turns into a "sexy & romantic getaway in a love hotel." Because not long after that, they did the Army.Zip interview when JK said that Jin is his everything and vice versa.
They're also close in 2018 shows (Run BTS 50-67, BV3). So, there's no problem except for the personal issues related to the contract extension. They're just lowkey~
😎✨
---
*EDIT 1.* Hello everyone. Iron (Jung Hunchul) just passed away today 21/01/25. Condolences to all his family and friends. Please take everything that I mentioned as simply facts so that we don't speak ill of the deceased.
*EDIT 2.* This video excludes one singing performance at 30:51 due to copyrighted Love Maze Japan performance, but the content will be the same. Gdrive link for UNCUT VERSION of Ep.05: drive.google.com/file/d/1OUB4fMGah_wmjM5GabIFtvjrl0kdUgQ5/view?usp=sharing
More information: ua-cam.com/users/postUgxsHr-YUn7rv395jyF4AaABCQ
@@moonbathingrite your analysis is so on point. Thanks. Where can I find the army zip?
@@jasmine_88 Here's the link mslittlerinran.tumblr.com/post/165690244387/bts-4th-army-zip-magazine-unit-interview-jin
@@moonbathingrite thanks.. and the history is great too.. very insightful
i cant believe someone like u with this much of a talent in research and data gathering and video making is out here doing god's work but Kudos AF. the amount of time and effort put into this and all ur other videos as well is evident and the results are Remarkable. i cant wait for your next videos!
Funfact: Jungkook composed “Stay” originally for his mixtape. He’s a genius.
Anyway we all know Jungkook is close to Jin. Even Jungkook’s brother likes Jin bc Jin took care of Jungkook so well. Like this if u agree
His brother is also good in drawing.. he draws funny Jin poses from run bts episodes coz Jin's his bias 💜
@@ma.ceciliadamasco5098 His bias is Jin too.. Wow! I didn't know
That’s good to hear 😍
Jin’s friendship with Kidoh at that time seems understandable since RM couldn’t get Jin’s attitude to work, Suga was being extra rebellious, Hobi was struggling to fit in the rap line and the rest were teens. No wonder they got on well due to the same age. What’s happened next was for the best as time showed. KenJin... Was someone seriously considering them more than good buddies, lol? They’re 92 liners holding the same position in their bands as the oldest vocalists, also sharing the interest for acting. Ken gives me impression of being a sweet and genuine person who remains close to Jin to this day.
All in all Seokjin is a perfect example of what nowadays called an emotionally intelligent person. He’s an empath with highly developed social skills, an adept at understanding how other people might feel and able to solve problems in ways that work for everyone. Real social butterfly.
I gotta say I’ve never really been into shipping. Jin is my bias. I was observing him mostly and Jinkook relationship was thought-provoking. To me both the type for whom being a true self in relationship is highly important and therefore choice of a friend as a partner is a good option since as close friends, you know each others’ weaknesses, insecurities and dark sides all too well. Plus JK initially might be into older people. But with my utmost respect I don’t want to put any label on them, if they are happy, safe and sound, that’s enough
I admire your love to Jinkook and your dedication to provide such a high quality content! Thank you from the bottom of my heart!
Im 100% agree with u...
>333
I couldn’t agree more to your comment. If Jin is your bias you are equally as high emotionally intelligent one like him! Like you, i am not into shipping. I just wish them to be true to themselves and be happy. 😊
Wow you are eloquent in writing! Im not surprise JIN is your bias! You look up to the person with the same intelligence as you are.
Wow you wrote my mind. I'm against shipping any of them. Just found Jin's attitude towards Jk really interesting
Most of the 'ship' videos I see are fixated on some imagination of how some nonsense made them jealous or this touch/look ment something... But you showed the basis of why Kook & Jin became closer, how their friendship grew, how their love for each other grew... And that's why I liked this video coz it didnt fantasize on something that wasn't there rather showed something that is there (platonic or not that's not upto us)
Wish I had a friendship like Jinkook 😭
Please keep making videos like this💜
Thank you! I didn't buy the jealousy narrative either. I mean, the reason people in the entertainment industry end up dating someone in the same field is exactly because of that; to have someone who understands that a job is just a job. You can't be overly jealous if you're with someone in this industry, be it idols or actors. Even if it's there, it's probably just a fleeting emotion that disappears quickly, and that's normal.
Yaaaaaa i agreeee withhh you
Agree! So many exaggerated "jealousy" jinkook videos here in YT. If all of those are true, it's amazing that JK or J even has the time to breathe or even do anything else 🥴
I love and appreciate that your analysis doesn't try to prove Jin and JK are in a romantic relationship. You are wise enough to realize that only Jinkook know what is between them. Your intent is to document the growth of their genuine bond.
You do that brilliantly. Don't stop.
If you are shipping members only because you believe they are in a romantic relationship, you will be disappointed. BH would never allow a gay couple to be exposed. It would cause incredible backlash for BTS and the couple in their home country.
We are fans. We only see maybe 10% of the members' private lives. BH controls the content and the narrative. BH makes business decisions to maximize profits. BH does not produce Kdramas.
Because of your analysis, I'm even more convinced that Jinkook share a deep, complicated and loving bond that will probably last a lifetime. Their connection and chemistry is unique for a hyung and maknae.
It doesn't matter to me if their bond is platonic or romantic. The nature of Jin and JK's relationship is none of my business. I support Jinkook as human beings, not just as a ship. Regardless of who they are to each other, it is a true love story.
Thank you!! You captured my intention perfectly! 💜 That's why I named the series Various Loves because love itself transcends any label!
@@moonbathingrite Well said.
Love transcends all labels. Love is love. 💜❤💞💖💕
You expressed it so well. The different ships videos out there can be pretty convincing. But like you said, only ones who knows for sure is them and the other members. Never thought it a good rule to be involved with someone you work with, but things happen. I just hope they’re all happy and fulfilled.
This comment is so beautiful, omg :(
And yes, you just spoke facts💯💯
This video is epic. Its almost at par with responsible journalism/documentary. Im a fan. I hope jinkook will be together forever...
"Eyes are window of soul" and the way their eyes glows when they see each other tells thousand reasons why Jinkook is a strong bond. I've never been amazed by any ship than Jinkook when it comes to their relationship. I don't want to label it. But whatever it is-it's pure and strong.
Thank you so much for giving us another well written analysis.
I used to ship other Bangtan Shipper, but then I noticed that JK also showed the same expression of feelings towards Jin, it could be seen from the look in his eyes, his touches, the so many little attention JK gave to Jin. I paid more attention to Jinkook after seeing the video footage on BV2 Hawaii where Jinkook walking together (with the third wheeling Jimin) pretended to be a bride & groom and especially when BTS was at a restaurant, where suddenly RM and Jin stood up while the host at the restaurant was holding an event for a married couple. On the show RM asked Jin why Jin stood with him because Jin was not his partner, RM asked “What about Jungkook?”. That's what then made me start to find out about Jinkook. My curiosity grew more with Taehyung Vlive when there was an indication that Jin was in JK's room (hiding in the bathroom) when Taehyung came to JK's hotel room while they were in Japan.
I increasingly believe that there is a special relationship between Jinkook when BTS members tease JK about the extension of JK is from Kim Jungkook and Jungkook looks very flustered.
When Suga teased and reprimanded JK and will make Jin sad because Jin was not included in the list of the most important people in JK's life, once again JK looks so flustered and there are many other hints which I found and show that there is indeed a special relationship between Jinkook.
Your interesting analysis really helped me more in my curiosity about them. I am happy because lately BH content has been showing the interactions between Jinkook more often without trying to cut their scenes, although of course there are still more scenes that they have to hide. Jinkook's interaction in In The Soop shows how domestic and intimate the two of them are even though we still don't get Jinkook sharing the same room. I knew about Hyosang and Jin are close friend, but never knew that there are an indication that both of them are more than close friend.
You really need to work harder to prepare this new video, it’s a blessing for us Jinkooker to have you. We will always be waiting for another content from you.
😘💜
Quite honestly, one of the best JinKook channels on UA-cam. I can feel the love respect you have for both Jin and Kook as you don’t make up anything or shove ridiculous theories about their relationship. I like that you concentrate on the most important aspects of their relationships, which are essentially shown organically. Please keep up the great work on these videos. 👍🏼👏🏼
After I watched the “ship” part i guess that’s more reason why Jinkook always stay lowkey & closed off... I wish they stay underrated cos somehow feel like that’s a way to protect them. I hope they just stay in their own private bubble without needing to disclose it to public...
Since now BTS are well known worldwide..a little slip up can cause problems to everyone...
Everyone have their past but what matter is the future.. and i really want Jinkook have their happy ending.. Be it together or with someone else. It hurts to think if they ended up with other people but for now i just want to enjoy their moments together..
BH & the member really did a great job protecting each other...
Everyone knows Jin is a mysterious person. The Jin we see in public is very different from Kim Seok Jin... It’s probably not easy to hide his dark side cos he didn’t want to worry army... But i hope he didn’t lose himself..
**Thank you for the video. It’s beautifully made... Keep up the good work! 💜
Agreed
Their bond is the purest and not many people take it really seriously But they both are really close and one of the bestest bonds among BTS.
Isn't it crazy that JK's smile is so different when he laugh with Jin. His eyes crinkle and smiles so genuinely. I think that's why it calls his "Jin hyung smile"
Wow, this was such an amazing video, the progression of their relationship was eye opening. I had no clue about the other ships with Jin, wow you really did your research to present this. I am greedy for more. I heard a lot about Jikook and Taekook ships, but this is no ship. What Jin and Jungkook have is pure authentic true love, not figments of our imagination, this is why their bond is so strong even to this day.
True, their relationship is very supportive and healthy. We can learn so much from them! I feel like I grow as a person too while observing them. That's why I want to share it on this channel.
Great bond. Jungkook own brother thanked jin for taking care of jungkook has his own brother.
How amazing and eye-opening 43 minutes and 18 seconds! I've never seen anyone compiling Jinkook history chronologically in such a clear fashion. It also proves to me that I am still too new to this fandom. There are so many things I don't know, while all this time I thought that I surfed all things related to Jinkook, haha.
Putting the history aside, as I am just a baby Army since Nov 2019, it is still easy to note by observing Jin and JK today that there is a unique bond. A bond so special makes them impossible just "brothers." I don't favor imagination outruns the facts, so I much appreciate your masterpiece supporting Jinkookers with the truth. Please keep it up. I am now your faithful viewer.
Jin lost his other half before, so lets pray that he wont lose his everything and vice versa.
me:crying nonstop
I have some deleted scenes and I don't know what to do with the information that I have 😢 It's in the past but it still breaks my heart, knowing that it _might_ affect him a lot too 💔
@@moonbathingrite please share with us.... 😭😭😭
@@moonbathingrite pls share....
Other half?
@@beegees810 fan asked jin what is hyosang to him and he answered his other half
I am really picky when it comes to shipper analysis videos coz from my POV, they sometimes overanalyzed things and made things weird. Sometimes, I tried to point out things but at the end, I was considered as a hater which made me sad. But, yours is not like that. You don’t label or tag anything on their relationship and let us make decision by watching all those beautiful moments. Coz my bias is Jin, I am extra attentive to him from day one till now. Although he has been showing his happy and cheerful sides from day one, I can sense the feeling of insecurity when I look into his solo songs and bts songs that he participated in producing and composing. In term of insecurity, what I want to say is that he is afraid of losing something or someone. He might have lost many ppl who he held dear during this long journey. And your video provides me the clue which I need to make my puzzle complete - like Kidoh. And another thing I like about your videos is that it didn’t include those slomo, hickeys, sexual tensions or lots of jealousy mm which I found a little bit irritating. Hehehe I am not a fan of it. Like you said, a relationship is more than just skinship and jealousy. And another thing I respect about loyal jinkookers is that they don’t try to question about not getting moments.Yep, there are some who change ships coz of that. But, for me, not getting moments doesn’t mean that their relationship was torn apart or they are not that close anymore. We need to keep in mind that we are supporting and appreciating the relationship of two ppl in real life not the ones in fanfics or romcom. I also had a boyfriend but I don’t stick with him all the time coz I need to give times and loves to my friends, my bff and family and even need to have “me” time. For BTS, they’ve been living together over 8 years and for some, it is nearly 10 years, so, how strong their bonds will be. So, every ship will have their wonderful, sweet moments even if it is the least popular ones. We don’t need to doubt or question every time and also we don’t have the right to doubt.After all, we are just the third persons. But I found most of the jinkookers are mature and insightful. In the comment section, I am really happy to find such jinkookers like (Seokjin’d Smeraldo, Julia, Ginia Marlafe Mabanta, Gerilyn Mitchell, etc). Sorry for mentioning names, I have the habit of reading long comment under analysis videos coz they let me know other ppl’s perspectives and I love your insights. My comment got quite long, too. Thanks a lot for this awesome videos and also Noumena fanfic. Looking forward to ep 6
You should include yourself on that list of Jinkookers with insightful and mature comments.
🙂💜
@@lrhlrh7393 hehe thanks
Tbh, I somehow love the fact that our jinkook is not much popular camparing with other ships. Instead of having a large community of toxic and biased ppl, I prefer being in a small one even though there are just 10 or 100. Coz the ppl matter not the number. Besides, most of my ships are the least popular ones 😅
Popularity in relationship is not important.I HOPE JINKOOK HAPPY FOREVER
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽💜
Wow! Same!
Thank you so much for made this video for us to watch. Your edit and the way you explained it were so beautiful. I didn't know about Kidoh "Jin's other half" omg maybe that's why he frequently saying that he want BTS are always together :( because he lost his best friend. I'm so relieved Jin found JK and BTS :( I love their friendship so much. Even if you don't know about anything, you still can see the way they treat each other is very different from other members. Please don't stop loving Jinkook ♡
And the thought that he's almost in BTS and they could still be together right now and be okay and he could protect him from falling deeper into the abyss could be something for him too (just a guess). After all, they're still very close no matter what kind of relationship they had. Again, what I love from Jinkook is everything fits like a puzzle. It can explain how Jin views things as you mentioned above.
This is a masterpiece of jinkook’s history iswtg when i first learned about bts i noticed a special connection between them. I’ve felt like their relationship is just so pure and sincere that i’ve never seen it from other duos.
I have watched jinkook videos and this is one of the most reliable that I can say I was able to verify how Jin and JK develop that kind of relationship that they have as time goes by. It maybe underrated but that's OK as long as both of them takes care of what is with them and I can say that now it's clear when JK said that it's better to appreciate things even in a small way possible. That's how love I guess, you can appreciate things even in a small way as long as it has something to do with the other. I just hope whatever happens, both will be brave and have the courage to be in each others back. Those that they have encountered during those times is Really something that will not be Possible without the help of each other.. Thanks again and hope to see more...
thank you for the elaboration of their timeline. I start to suspect since V's Vlive at Osaka where JK seems so awkward and he kept shifting his attention to the bathroom. And Jimin's Vlive after that incident where he tease Jin about it. And not to mention JK and Jin holding hands when they are sleeping together during BON VOYAGE season 1, when they are sleeping at the upper bunk of the camper van. JK was sleeping in the middle or Jin and J-hope and JK naturally move close to Jin while sleeping and waking up at Jin's side. I always love how JK look at Jin and smile and his gaze for Jin.
During the BTS festa 2018, V noticed that Jin was wearing JK's shirt and mentioned it, but no one reply to that question. Instead Jin said he just wear what he see in his wardrobe. 2020 BTS festa, Jin and JK are always together. I am happy that BH finally release more footage and screen time of them both being together and they are so happy. BH start showing other ships and less of JINKOOK since after BV1 and the Osaka Vlive incident. I am also happy with their MV Life goes on with JK being the director, it is like, see Jin through JK's eyes.
I hope they will be happy together forever.
I just love the way u bring the JINKOOK chemistry out logically. Hope our Jinkook is ever lasting.
Jungkook learnt a lot of things from Jin!
Like what ?
Anyway my bias Jin Love
Yes ur right there bond is so special but still people ignore it and always say namjin or taekook is best but for me it jinkook it's the best bond it may be frndship ,brotherly love i still love it
One of the BEST Jinkook content I’ve ever seen. I might watch it everyday for the next 4 weeks to feed my Jinkook heart 🤧🥺
I think I’ve watched about 90% of Jinkook videos here on UA-cam, yours are one of the best. Did u study to make film??
No, but I'm interested in that. I only started learning the software this quarantine :)
@@moonbathingrite you have a vision of a great storyteller that is armed with well researched facts and references. may i know what software are u using?
Yes, it was not corny like many I have watched. Well organized. Hope you keep up the great work
@@moonbathingrite Woww you certainly have a talent here, I hope you can be a film maker someday!!!
@@moonbathingrite your analysing is great you are the best so far. I subscribed to your channel bcz I really loved the video. The reason I started in believing jinkook is bcz of some anonymous sasaengs who wants to sell info through quora. They stated that jk is bisexual and dating a member. So eventually after some analysis I came to the conclusion that jinkook. Must be the couple
Oh wow! This was so good! You unearthed so much of their old content (some of them I've never seen before) and created a definitive history of their relationship. You made this ship soar! Great work!
I really enjoy your series. You've gathered bits and pieces of them I've never even thought to look for, like Jin's tweets and outings with Kidoh, their excerpts from magazines etc. If people find your videos and watch them, it'll be a great way of introducing the two to them and help them see Jinkook in a new light.
On a side note I want to vent a bit sorry... I've been an Army for 7 years now and thanks to external circumstances (cross-referencing another celebrity couple I was following) it finally hit me that Jinkook didn't just have a very serious brother complex towards each other. I think new fans can see the true nature of their relationship more easily than older fans... some of us are still stuck with the mindset that they're very close brothers. The impression of baby Jungkook was just imprinted into my mind. It took a couple of days for it to sink in but everything is so clear now that I'm looking at them from a new perspective. It's really fascinating. Your channel definitely helped me through lol
Please keep updating!
As JK’s fan i always admire how bangtan hyungs treated JK as their maknae and somehow Jin is noteably playing a huge part as to how JK is part of bangtan today.
Its shocking that this video even exists. The facts explosion and progressive timeline clearly explains the flow. I love how this documentary is not based on assumptions like most of JinKook’s analysis videos and the unexpected “ship” in early bangtan days is the most interesting part i have learnt today.
Thank you for your effort to produce this documentary video and hope we could have more of this in the future.
If I met someone as caring as Jin when I was 13 (intl age) I'd love him forever too 😭
@@moonbathingrite same....jin is so precious
@@moonbathingrite true
I fell in love with Jinkook all over again. Thank you for the love, time, and effort in putting together these videos. 🥺💜💓
I may have read his name long mg time ago(kidoh) but I know nothing about him & jin. Don't know why but it breaks my heart to think that jin does 'lost' his bestfriend. About jinkook, I don't even know what to address them but I really love jinkook. They basically grow up together since becoming trainees. Jin once said they are close without boundaries. I just want them to be happy, no matter what happens in the future
Omg, you're just like telling us from head to toe abt their debut. I like very much the way your speech expression, it make clear to those new jinkookers or any other still confuse about their relationship. Thank you so much, hope to see this kind of vid again.
I hope so. Honestly, when I heard that people are confused about Jinkook, my first thought is, "Why??" But then I remember that people get into BTS in a different phase of their relationship and might not have the time to watch old videos and read old interviews or watch them grow through the different seasons, so I finally understand that point of view.
@@moonbathingrite keep going my dear, I really love your vid.
@@moonbathingrite honestly I've watched this vid more than twice, it really worth seeing. And at 6.19min, when jk was interviewed all the members, only jin has special to drink his drink and that was jk feed jin drink it. Seeing Jin's expression a little blank at first. Hahaha
My Wednesday pray: These two beautiful people to be together and make each other happy FOREVER 💜💜. And for their family, friends and fans (ARMY or not ARMY) to accept them the way they are and their beautiful relationship! I'm sure that there are millions of other out there wishing and praying the same. 🥰
it's almost scary to realize I have basically all the pictures that showed up (alongside some videos and gifs)
broooo am I whipped for those two?!! Indeed, I am! who am I even trying to fool? lol
Love the 7 boys but Jinkook will always be special. The analysis is daebak. 😍
I will say one thing: YOU BLEW MY MIND AWAY!!
You did such goof research and everything you said is really true! I've been watching this over the past few days, and I really enjoyed it! You had all your facts and everything! The ending when Jungkook was asked what is happiness and he replied with "being able to smile" and all those pictures of him smiling came after, I had tears in my eyes. It was such a beautiful presentation, really well done!
And the first clip that I use is JK saying that he can't force a smile 😊
Wow, hats off! 🤩 This is a MUST MUST MUST SEE for a compelling story of my two stunning baes 🥂
PS I really think that their relationship is EXCLUSIVE
Yes I doubt jk shares when he wont allow jhope to hold jin hand.
I also notice this, Jin is kinda seemed uncomfy when doin skinship with other members, (with JK too sometimes), but I think he tolerates JK the most.
Jin can always brings the best out of every members...
Yes!
OMG im so speechless. This video really really awesome!! The details you made are so crazy its prove that how much you love jinkook, now i know the jin's affraid its bcs he dont wanna lost his soulmate again, so he take care a lot jkey as his half of his soul. Im so melting when i know that reason. Jin have really hard time to survive aftr his broken heart. I cant imagine his feelin that time. Now i wish he always happy with his lover. Once again i wanna say thankyou fr making this amazing analyze video. Borahae 💜
I'm always amazed with your work💜💕you are the best...thank you so much💜💕hope jinkook will stay together 4ever💜💕
the shocking ships! the editing skills! the keen eyes! love your works so much! 💜
I wanna write down loads of things but I am also kind of speechless..
I wanna sincerely thank you for creating such a beautiful and detailed video about Jinkook.. I learned a lot from you..
and your cinematography is *chef's kiss* fabulous!
Wow! They all have a special relationship with each other. Thank you for sharing apart of the culture. They all deserve the best and all the happiness they can get. They are all loved and cherished .
This is just beautiful, im crying even though i dont finish watching this video 😭😭
Me too in the middle of making this
I love how you always quoted something based on what they did or said. You bring fact, collect them all, make a very good video and edit to make us understand more. I really hope the 'hard' stan of whoever ship in bts will do the same and being intelligent enough like you❤️ and can stop them making imaginary theory based on nonexistent things lmao.
Thank you so much for point out their bond, love you so much for this❤️ hope your channel will get bigger time by time
Thank you! Why making up stories when they can tell the stories themselves ^^
It's even more accurate information here...I was able to start from their beginning of their journey with BTS. Being the latest army I should say and able to watch vids and clips with different side of the story I can honestly tell that JK and Jin's relationship is quite different and natural compared to the other members regardless how other people push to ship their bets.
This is so beautiful. It was so perfectly arranged and well-put together. I nearly cried at the middle of the video, I literally feel the heartache and then finally made the connection on how Jinkook slowly got together. I knew of Hyosang (but is like I only know about his name and he left bighit, that all) but with your video, I felt like I have discovered another secret again! Thinking like how closed Jin and Hyosang have been made my heart hurt
Thank you so much for the video!
This is better than movies for sure!!!! Always in luv with ur videos.. Fighting!!!!💪💪
OMG I wish there was a way to put a super like on this masterpiece! I loved everything about this and learned new things as well. You got my sub and appreciation for your hard work. Thank you. Let's keep fighting in their corner together 💜💜💜💜
I can't just watch it once, it's so beautiful. really made me cry. Thank you for your hard work, I hope you are always happy and make more videos like this again.
woaaah im really amazed, imagine all the time, research and effort made into this series, it’s really nice to think that someone actually makes these videos, tbh these kind of jinkook stuff are the ones keeping me alive. so im really thankful. have a great day 💕
36:56 omg when jk said my hand,my hand.. Jin doesn't want anyone touch him except jk💜💛
Look at RM' s reaction
I just noticed that!! I always think RM knows something about jinkook, in run ep123 did u notice that when Jhope got a little angry and rose his voice at Jin, RM looked at JK straight away!!!
@@Sehugoo I think they all know 😁 there r too many hints left n right
@@Sehugoo Yes. I think RM knew it already from the very start and he's just supporting them.
@@mrss670 hahahaha yes especially JM and Suga😅
👏👏👏👏👏👏 Really enjoyed this video. Jin and Jungkook caught my eyes early on and this really helped me better understand Jin. I will watch again and look forward to future videos.
This is the best video I have seen about them. I really enjoyed it.
Loved seeing them grow up together and have such closeness.
Omg it was adorable!! The best fanmade video that I've ever watched so far. I've watched so many videos but it was something else. Thank you so much and please keep doing this you are really talented. I'll be looking forward to your next video!
The most beautiful vedio of jinkook!and super meaningful!🤗
Thankyouuu for your vedio!😊👏
Thank you for this well thought and beautifully done video. Jin is my fave and all I want for him is to be happy.
everytime saw channel about Jinkook i did subscribed at once this channel really amazed me.. thank you for ur videos i've learned more about them..
keep it up! 💜💜💜
Wow...this is beautiful.. Seeing their close bond is so adorable.. The way both Jin and Jk transformed beautifully over the years is simply amazing.
Appreciate your efforts on this video...it's so well done.👍🏼
I thought I couldn't watch the video until the end because it was too long. But I watched it without moving and my tears flowed out of my eyes. Thanks for this nice edit. :)
Wow, i'm in love with your editing...you use it very cleverly to bring out your story! Great video.
The amount of work and hours you put it. Its an amzing video. So pleasing to the soul and so tastefully presented. Tq💜
Jin had said in a interview that he has lost many friends . I really hope he finds a true friend who understands him well and makes him happy . If he really thinks someone as a friend he never leaves that person and always stays by his side but mostly in his case people don't do the same way for him . Ahh I really want to see him with a friend that stays by his side .
This video is so good I am Jin bias still I didn't know about his old friendships . Thank you so much for this amazing research .
I'm devastated, yet another time, by your work. I think I'll suffer for days. It was a heartbreaking pleasure watching your video. Sending my love and support to you from your very first work to the ones to come. Also to Jin, Jk, BTS, and Kidoh.
That's very kind of you to include Kidoh too! I was worried that he'll get hate by posting this, but I'm so relieved that everyone wishes him well! He truly deserves a second chance in the music industry after everything that happened to him.
Another piece of Art I am crying...thank you so much. I am blown away by the amount of effort and details in the video. I wish Jin and JK would stay together and be happy.
when i felt jin does'nt like to lose people i was so emotinal and also seeing kidoh and jin's friendship break hurted me . And the smile when jungkook is with jin and viceversa made me fall for them. I just hope them to keep smiling as always . And as subscriber i would like to say you're analysis are so good and i did'nt find it exagerrating and keep doing more videos. cheers!!
i was like crying while watching these video🤧 and today I even realize that im so very lucky & happy that i found Jinkook in my life bcs i really love them sm😭❤️ omg thankyou so muchh, u did a great job♡
much luv from a filipina girl❤️🇵🇭
Jin is the most consistent and fun, loving person in the group. He is the same almost all the time. Jungkook is the most loving person in the group and being the youngest has been shower with love from all six hyungs but he is extremely close with Jin, Jimin, and Tae. They all have their moment. But Jin is the one that taken care of Jungkook the most from the beginning and playing with him too. They just fun to see how they are interacting. Who would not love Jungkook though, he is so easy to please and so sensitive, and appreciative.
The last part was so beautiful .(epilogue)
hi.. this is my first time commenting on 1 of your videos. this video was way too amazing to not leave a comment.
1. I'd like to compliment you on how you put the video together. it was fantastic. it didn't feel too long despite being almost 45 mins.. the info was tight and there was no skipping.
2. Your research work is amazing. after seeing your video, i looked up 2jin and the number of people who had shipped them was an eye opener. it also felt a bit heavy.. seeing the similarities between 2jin and jinkook.. I wonder if that's the reason why jin is a little over protective of him.
3. I really want to thank you for the way you do your videos. I'll be open. I detest shipper videos that focus on physical intimacy and try to paint every non-ship interaction as a moment of jealousy for one of the members of the ship. it's such a toxic way of thinking about relationships. surely everyone has close relationships outside of a ship and any partner who immediately gets jealous is a dangerous person? or maybe I am too old (mid-30s) to understand the teenage ways of thinking about love.
4. I also won't deny that I'm aware of the element of delusion that goes into "shipping" as the young ones call it today. So while I admit that there is an itch in my brain wrt jinkook because their behaviour shows a definite partiality and attention, I also know that there are gaps which my brain has filled with my own romantic notions. And it's easy for jinkook because you can tell how well a relationship between them would work. So I am swept away by your way of narrating their story.
5. I'm curious to know where your next stop will be. now that you've shown their history, I'm sure you have an idea on where to take this next. you don't have to tell me. i just want you to know that i look forward to it.
Thank you!! This has been a way to channel my frustration too because I'm afraid that "shipping" has been a way to promote a toxic relationship. It's dangerous, especially for teenagers who see the video.
Anyway, I still can't get over 2jin too; how Hyosang slipped into a different circle of friends and his downfall began from that... It pains me but at the same time, it sheds a new light if how Jin protects JK and the other members. Thankfully, even with the tattoos and the way JK dressed it's just how he expresses himself, and deep inside he's such a sweetheart ❤️
@@moonbathingrite I wonder if Jin sees this as a way to rectify his own past "mistakes" such as maybe not being open with hyosang regarding some of choices and decisions.. because jin's influence on jk is not small..
@Fierte haiy dear, absolutely agree with you, this JinKook video documentary really good, amazing.. the best JinKook video I've ever seen...
Agree.
Spent 2 hours watching and savoring this, and it was the best 2 hours of my life!
WELL SPENT INDEED! hahaha
Can I just blabber a lot of things here just to unload the thoughts I've had since knowing them? My bias is Jin and I did a lot of digging about him when I first got into BTS, read his past, and heard about Hyongsang before. But he was that unheard legend that was like a mystery even to old army's because not much was known about him.
Yet I've always wondered where Hyongsang disappeared because Jin and he were so close even when he left bighit.
I speculated before that when Hyongsang surrounded himself with the same crowd as Namjoon did (I really thought those folks had axes to grind when Joon stayed and focus all his time on BTS as an idol group).
I remember Joon and Jin bonded in the early days of BTS after they accepted their differences, especially Joonie, and he has more than implied that he and Jin used to have serious conversations, go to cafes or somewhere when their dance training is done.
It's not farfetched to say that maybe Jin got a sense of Joon's worries with regards to his former teammates and friends in the rap industry. I always thought there was something toxic in their mentality, especially when I saw that video of Joon meeting them at a cafe. Even then you can sense that intense tension behind their somewhat regulated/ trying to be polite words, while Joon tried to be at ease with his old crew but they were somehow, crass? to Joon. Maybe that's how Jin and Hyongsang grew apart when their values changed as well, as we know whom you surround yourself with pretty much influences your views and choices in life.
It was a big mystery to me because Jin will not voluntarily cut off ties, not even at the behest of Bighit, not unless Hyongsang did something so grave that Jin decided to let their friendship go and forget they even knew each other.
It's just pure speculation on my part, but after knowing and watching Jin all these years, I've always thought that he is the most secretive member of BTS. He only lets us see what he thinks we need to see and never really reveals who he is.
He has always done things in a very calculated manner, and although he always speaks about only going with the general flow with no thoughts on it, knowing him, even a little already means something, and once he makes his final decision, Jin always pushes through with it and never looks back.
Jin did mention losing lots of friends along the way, and maybe that's part of the reason why he took such good care of his members. Technically, Jin only needs to be there to train, work, and not take responsibility for 6 other people.
It was the first time he had to lived away from his family, and his mom, who did everything for him before because he was the youngest. Jin look and sounded like a very pampered, rich kid when they just started, ahahaha.
It's such a wonder how he'd grown, living together with a bunch of strangers and suddenly got the 'hyung' role when least expected. He was just supposed to go to college and learn how to act, but fate somehow had other plans for him. haha
He took Jungkook, a kid he barely knew, under his wing and gave him love, money (which is sometimes harder to give than anything, honest to God), good food, emotional support, and playmate (hahaha).
I think if he was asked again, Jin will say that he will not have it any other way. He would've still love to meet Jungkook the way he did, raise him for years to become his best friend/ lover? (I HOPE) forever.
Yes, that cafe clip is from 4 Things! And to witness that RM was so devastated to be left out from the group, saying, "I am DNH too," in that show hurts a bit. Like boy, you better listen to Jin and stay with BTS, escape from that group ASAP.
Here ua-cam.com/video/-sCs3iKcTVo/v-deo.html, Supreme Boi said, "Right now Rap Monster was off dancing somewhere." IDK if it's an internal joke, but that seems inappropriate. I can't imagine the sht they say to the "unheard legend" too since he's also an idol, yet he chose to stay with them. Wait, maybe that's also the reason Jin looks for someone who listens to him well?
I'm glad and grateful that JK clings to Jin during his crucial teenage years and always listens to him. In the process, he grows up to be such an amazing individual and find his self 💜
@@moonbathingrite Yeah, you see it too right? They did not mention it, but it was quite possible that happen a long time ago. I mean, Joon can be cryptic sometimes, but we all know everything he says is mostly about his life and experiences, and remember in his logs when he said that Jin influenced him a lot, his thinking, and the decisions he made later on in his life?
Jin might be sympathetic and kind but he had always been on the logical or sensible side, and he might be sentimental yet he always had a clear vision when it comes to right or wrong.
He's treated life similarly to how he does his cooking, he always likes to keep his working area clean and wash the dishes right after using them. He never lets dirty dishes sit for too long, and has always been swift with his decision when a delicate situation arises.
Bang PD said it in a few words, how Jin never really change much from who he is, and how he kept the boys in line even from before. Joon had tried hard to hang on to his crew at the start, even he was already busy with BTS, supreme boi stayed with them initially when those ties should have been cut a long time ago.
Joon valued his friendship and presence too much that he let him stay on, even when it was so obvious how he looks at the group (in disdain) and it wasn't really conducive for the whole team. God knows what Yoongi had to say during those days. They must have argued about it too, knowing Yoongi he will not be able to tolerate a passive-aggressive guy like him.
At that point Hyongsang might have chosen his career over his friendship with Jin, and he has every right to do so, it wasn't his fault he wanted a career too, but Jin clearly cut him out when he saw that he's turned. Hyongsang liked the underground scene more than being an idol so it was his choice to make. I'm just glad that he didn't air anything bad about Jin and just deleted his post, and Jin also didn't talk anything bad or mention why they stop talking just that they did, but didn't it look like it was a bad breakup? hahaha, we really won't ever know. maybe in the future, we will? but it's been so long ago, does it even matter anymore?
Jin might have talked to Joon about learning to let go and prioritizing himself and the group, and not taking on more than he can handle. That guy was like a ticking bomb and Jin, sensible that he is, might have open Joon's eyes about it. He always had a way with words, and he can tackle a very sensitive topic in a way that is not offensive and won't make you think on the defensive side (take for example that speech in that award show about creating music in an honest way)
Yes, I'm thankful that Jk listens to Jin, despite him being independent since young. Jk wasn't sure most of the time, but then he always did what he set out to do regardless of consequences. Even at a young age he had the gal to come to Seoul without his parents (they must have dissuaded him no? since he was so young) but he always did things his way no matter what everybody says, even at that age, and when an idea takes on in his head, he mostly follows through with it regardless if he stops in the middle (as he often does with ALL his short lived hobbies lol).
I think he follows Jin mostly because he just loves him. More than knowing that Jin is his Hyung who will always consider his wellbeing, I think Jungkook follows him because he wants to. For the few things in life that he is still crazy passionate about, like music, eating, exercise and filming, Jin has always been on the top of things he's willing to cross oceans for.
Idk why, but Jungkook has always looked at Jin like he just met him yesterday and I've always wondered how he can still be so, so into him as if they didn't already know each other for 10 years.
He's always been romantic, and if that devotion means nothing at all then I really have no clue what is love anymore hahaha.
I honestly cannot be 100% certain, but everyday Jungkook always surprises me when he does something that makes me think long and hard if it's really just platonic or not.
@@minsu1110 I enjoy reading ur comment here 💜
Sorry to butt in, but I do love talking about jinkook.
I love, appreciate, and respect Jin. The reason? Just like what u mentioned. All of the above. He’s a great person. He knows so many things yet humble n always let others shine and doing all that while looking like god. Lol.
Also I respect the way he try to balance everything. He knows his limit so he never go overboard during performance. We can c how other members sometimes almost passed out (esp JK & Jm) after performance or voice cracked (Jm & V) coz they’ve been pushing too hard, but Jin always get a great control of himself. If he knows it’s too much then he won’t do it. I can talk about how I admire him for a month nonstop. Lol.
That’s y after watching this video, it breaks my heart how he n his best friend (perhaps ex lover - as he called him his other half) grew apart n cut ties. Hopefully he can (if not already) get over it n meet more great people.
And about JK... JK-ahhh.... I’m in the same boat with u, I also wonder how did he manage to be sooo consistent with his love to J??? Look at those eyes. Seems like his ‘crush stage to Jin’ never left him. Even until now they way he look at Jin is like having a love struck for a first time. And this is after knowing him for 10 f*cking years!!!
The only change I noticed from JK is his possessiveness. He used to be so aggressive (pushing n pulling n glaring members if they get too close to J) now he seems to toned it down. Maybe he’s now confident enough that J also only look at him 💜💜💜
Ohhh my hearteuuuu 💜🤧
The best edited video and the best explained video that I ever have seen !!!
What a great Jinkook video you made us Jinkooker understand more the relationship of Jin and JK. Thank you for your hard work to make this a very detailed presentation. Stay safe, healthy and happy.
I cannot explain how I love your videos, especially this one, I am grateful that there is this type of "analysis" especially focusing on how they feel, without a doubt they are no longer the same people they were before and that is the best part of growing up, these days jin and JK are more about being aware of each other, but they don't take away the part of treating each other like "Tom and Jerry" idk, they really love each other a lot, I can't imagine when jin goes to MS, how much they will miss him (especially JK)
I repeat, I am a fan of what you do, thank you for always showing us the true face of JinKook
(sorry for my bad english)
This is sooooooo good. Hands down... the best. Well documented and put together. I especially appreciate the early moments that shows us there shy nature and how the bond was formed. I purple you 💜💜💜
One of the best videos of Jinkook💜
Im watching about JINKOOK and i feel happy about their story i feel contentment. Bts always supporting you stay safe god blessed you all
Hello everyone. Iron (Jung Hunchul) just passed away today 21/01/25. Condolences to all his family and friends. Please take everything that I mentioned as simply facts so that we don't speak ill of the deceased. Let's pray that it doesn't affect the boys, and I'm honestly concerned about Hyosang & RM. Anyway, thank you. Rest in peace. www.soompi.com/article/1450596wpp/rapper-iron-passes-away
Im still thinks about kiddoh....i hope he still fine
@@ardianah9879 I'm _devastated_ too, I can't imagine how it might be for both of them.
@@moonbathingrite are u have deleted scene or story about kiddoh?why u have deleted?
@@ardianah9879 1. The focus of the video is on Jinkook.
2. The duration will be too long.
Thanks you very much, your research is very enlightening for me. Kidoh been a part of Jin’s life is bittersweet i hope kidoh’s healthy.
Outstanding, Marvelous, Fantastic. I am highly impressed by your hard work and research. Excellent. Keep up the good work. You are awesome. Keep loving Jinkook everyone. They will need our love and support. 💜
I was so excited when I saw you had posted a new video. I had just finished watching all yours again. Great job. Please keep them coming.
Woah for a long time jinkooker, I am thankful I found your channel. Love your explanations and analysis and presentations.
Thanks Admin. Actually this is my first time to heard about the story of Jin and the other "Jin". At first i was so shocked to know about the other Jin and how closed they were before. The days they're spent together and how honest he was in sharing their pics/convo in social media which public might see it.
As a fan of Jinkook😊 i believe that jin and jk were really destined to meet each other. 😊
Jinkook is my happy pill. I love them both and I'll support them all the way 💜 more videos of Jinkook moment please..😊
#jinkookforever💜
Yes, the thanks to in the album is very sweet to me. However, Jin didn't share much; it's Hyosang. All the photos in the video are tweeted by him but then he deleted them all. So, Jin is a very private person ever since the beginning.
So niceu..i loved it from the start until the end.. Your so talented and smart. Im so glad your a jinkook shipper👏Pls continue to feed us Jinkook contents👉👈💜
I know theres lot of people who already said this, but your video is so beautiful ❤️❤️ all the editing, the analysis and all is so perfect. Thank you so much for your hard work ❤️❤️
I can watch your videos for 4 or 5 times and no matter how long it is. It's clear, correct, informative, pure?, sweet, touchable! Your videos are feels like a ... Home? Yes it feel like home! I love you! Please stay healthy!
same me too
The most informative video ever
Thankyou so much for letting us know this much of informations
Keep posting !!
Wow. That's really thorough. I haven't even seen some of the videos before. Thank you so much for this.
Wow this is one of the best jinkook videos I’ve ever watched it was perfect 🤩 I truly hope to see lots more by you 💜💜💜💜💜 support always
This indeed an eye opening vid. almost all of the clips here as usual has never before seen in any videos. Kudos to your keen eye for details and sources for all these. Still, I can't believe that Jin has somewhat been in a "special" kind of relationship because I couldn't imagine him without jungkook. They both have the greatest chemistry and I can't imagine Jin ending with that guy whose completely different from JK. I think Jinkook is destined to be together.
Him during 2013-2014 = 2016-2018 Jin that we finally see after Fire era haha. Act like a kid, blunt, sudden outburst yet funny at the same time. Two Sagittarians. But Jin being with JK balance & complement each other better. Being too similar often doesn't work well.
@@moonbathingrite I completely agree..that's the right word..they COMPLEMENT each other. Your Jinkook videos and analysis were so precise and clever at the same time. You even have timelines of their activities and milestones over the past years. We thank you for all your effort in making all these. We can't wait for more! Borahae!
Once again you amazed me with your thoroughness and detailed information about JinKook events. Thank You. Since debut of Dynamite i became confused of Jinkook relationship because after watching old videos of them (since im a new army I've seen oldvideos only) I thought in 2020 they are less close to each other. they dont even bicker that much anymore. It didn't help that JK and Jimin are always together and everyone hyping it up. It didn't help that during dynamite promotion period, Jin was always sad and had poker face all the time, barely smiling. Then one of the Army open my eyes, saying "do we really see JK going from one relationship to another within the group in such a short amount of time?" and I thought NO. JK seems like the type of person who performs on stage fiercely, like no one can touch him. It showshis passion to something and sticks to it. Just like he shows and tell us how much he cares for Jin even when he was younger till now. Then we found out that Jin was going thru something. It came clear to me during Life goes on promotion that nothing was change with JinKook. They both just became more mature and probably more secure in their relationship. although there are times JK is still possessive of Jin. (have you seen the scene where V tried to lift Jin shirt during MOTS concert, JK was clearly upset with V) They just decided to keep things in private and keep it safe. especially with Dispatch mentioning they will reveal couples from BTS. Not only it might ruin them it might ruin the group and company. so its clear they are protecting a lot aside from themselves. If only they can freely announced their relationship without prejudice from their own country. Im sure the rest of the world or ARMY from other country will support but as a Korean im sure they know the extent of acceptance they will receive. My only wish for Jinkook is to finally be free of expressing each others feelings whatever it is without recieving prejudice or some kind of backlash from their own society. Borahae everyone. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I agree with the more mature and secure part. As I mentioned in the video, I think they begin to find their pace and rhythm, and I'm glad that you see it that way too. Regarding the moments, we should wait until Memories of 2020 and newer Bangtan Bomb videos are released because it also happens in 2019. They keep everything behind the scenes and outside social media. At this point, BB still stucks on Feb-Mar 2020 during MOTS:7 promotion.
@@moonbathingrite do you believe that BH is slowly letting us in in Jinkook world?
@@moonbathingrite BB always post throwbacks yes, but if we want to see their relationship in 2020 we can c from the vlive and the recent performances.
For me, I like to c their live coz that’s when BH can’t edit n cut their interaction. MOST OBVIOUS ones are in the beginning 2020 when Suga throw hints about Holly & also Jin apologising to JK (I believe smth happened b4 the vlive), 2nd will b dynamite release; how JK can’t even focus with the live n keep on glancing at Jin at the back n how he ‘warns’ V being too close to J, 3rd is grammy celebration vlive where 2 of them obviously has their own world.
For me what even makes it more obvious is the members’ reaction. Esp Jhope 😂
@shirley gan of course BH will try to put Jikook more together. Their PR & marketing team KNOWS what they r doing. They can’t bcome this big without genius marketing strategy behind the scene. They know now maknae line is their cash cow. The most video thumbnails r maknae. From BB, vlive, Run BTS, n even MV. It attracts more clicks. And actually I personally think Jimin & Suga r Jinkook’s best supporter.
Sometimes it makes me sad to c how they r forced to act that way for the sake of the company (look at dynamite Xmas version how they r forced to stand side by side with their ‘popular shipping partner’ Namjin Jikook Vhope’ n how JK can’t help but keep glancing to Jin’s direction n even snatched him away from RM 😁.
BUT I also believe BH did that to protect jinkook. As u mentioned, SK doesn’t seem to b ready with idol’s openness with LGBT esp for BTS. They can’t even being mature with idols getting married let alone to accept the fact about their perfect idols r in relationship EO.
Side note: I think now JK grows a lot, more confident about himself n his view of life. He didn’t even hesitate to tell Jin don’t b scared n nth to worry about. And as JK is now the most popular member, I think he uses the opportunity & use his ‘power’ with BH (ex: he can put Jin as the center n the most important element in LGO MV)
i love it this is exactLy i want to say aBout jinkook thank you so mUch
@Mrs S you are so right! everything you said is 100% correct. i do love those vlives. those are the ones they cant edit. i really think our Jinkook are extra careful nowadays. but yeah you can still see that they still care for each other. and i agree with you i am thankful to Jimin, jhope and suga. those three seemz to always protect and chamge the subject whenever some topic get to close for comfot for jinkook. i noticed on Jin bday vlive i think BH change the caption when Jin called jimin on the phone. according to the caption, he's with JK in the car and why was Jin callin him live on vlive without giving him a headsup. but when i translate the conversation jimin didnt say anything about giving a heads up. He said "we are coming now" and not "you called me without a heads up" ive seen other videos where editors change captions so i was suspicious and checked that conversation myself. it is clear during xmas season especially and award shows Jinkook are still madly inlove. i dont think anyone notice the behind the scene of black swan where jin kneeled down and did his acting with that shiny flying thingy, Jk and namjoon was watching on the side. thats probably why Jin answered JK "im always by your side" when they were opening the BE album with jhope, JK dedicated a line from the sonh stay to Jin " wherever you are" i also think BH is aware of Jinkook and just really protecting the both of them. sometimes its just frustrating not just for us but im sure for jinkook too. especially now they are stockholders of BH. they all have a lot to loose. and too many employees depending on them.
Absolutely, i think 2020, BTS break from travelling arund the world was kinda good for jinkook relationship. I believe they are given a chance to get to know each other more in an adult level without fights about fanservices especially from concerts. i was just telling my friend that recent run bts although its filmed early 2020 you can see how JK pays attention to Jin and vice versa. now that BB are releasing more behind the scenes video we can see that they are still happy. im wishing for more lol. i do love that JK is putting jin in center and i do hope it happens again. i screamed when i watch that xmas video when JK snatched Jin away from RM. i was laughing so hard. and i thought, wow Bh didnt cut or change that.
yeah i am praying , lets all pray that someday they actually get that chance to have freedom of expressing their feelings without consequences. sorry for this long comment and thank you for your patience with me borahae y'all! ✨💞✨💎✨
WOW!! U really made it like a drama.. The content is 100% different than other channel.. So far, ur channel is one of the best.. I'm so glad I found u.. Keep up the good work master-nim..
The detail about J** and H****** surprised me a lot.. It gave me bad feeling..
This is beautiful, meaningful and full of love.
i swear,i love jinkook to bits.....thnak you so much for the 5th ep.....looking forward for more heartwarming episodes...
W.O.W.... 👍👍👍 thumbs up... This video from part 1-5 are amazing 😆😆 the details... Story line.... 100% entertaining... Thank You... Looking forward for your next Story 😘💜
I knew about 2jin but i didn't know he deleted all things related to jin😳 i wonder why...
Again, such a lovely video, thank you. I can only imagine the time you spent in making this video. They went through a lot of phases, a lot of things that they don't let us see. But still, if it's true, it's true and what's genuine will always slip and show through.
I double-checked again before making the video and he deleted them ALL 💔 No photos, no hashtag. Here, there's nothing on this hashtag anymore from his Twitter: twitter.com/search?q=%23%EA%B9%80%EC%84%9D%EC%A7%84%ED%9A%A8%EC%83%81%20from%3A%40khyo_twt&src=typed_query
But there's still one from BTS: twitter.com/search?q=%23%EA%B9%80%EC%84%9D%EC%A7%84%ED%9A%A8%EC%83%81%20from%3A%40bts_twt&src=typed_query
I guess he's kind of impulsive? Posting and deleting everything as he wishes. It also happens when he clarified the controversy. By the way, look at the latest tweet that Hyosang liked, it's from BTS 😭 I'm so emo for them.
@@moonbathingrite it's me again :-) - i followed the link to the liked tweet, and then I also saw some new posts of Hyosang who has moved on. What happened was in the past (5 years ago?) and Jin looks much-loved (despite Abyss) and I credit JK really (remember that JK declared in one interview that he will fight for his love; whereas Jin would sacrifice)?
As for observed less interaction in 2021, BH does limit their interaction, after shows where they show affection etc. Previous analyses had shown this to be true (@9792_archive's). Let's wait for the 2020 bombs;
(aren't we all analysts now hehe; the Jinkook effect for me).
Thank you so much for this video. I hope more get to see your work.
@@moonbathingrite omg you're right!! So i guess they don't have bad blood with each other right? That makes me happy!🥲
The absolute best analysis ever thank you 😊
Ok, I have another comment and I really hope that those who read this would go and read the fanfic of our content creator, Moonbathingrite because when you do, all his/her videos, especially Episode 5 will hit you differently. Promise!!!! I just finished reading "Noumena" and I hated having to be interrupted by meals, by chores, by my children (although I love them still) because all I wanted to do was just read the story in its entirety and watch the videos referenced in the Notes Section. Moonbathingrite, you rock, gurl! You are my queen and you made me cry along with JK and SJ!!!!!!! Your story is so good. I wish that it was real although I think it is close -- or I am hoping that it is close IRL. Please keep on writing and please keep on making your videos. I don't know how you'll up your ante after "Noumena" because what else is there to write after that? You ended it beautifully!!!! But maybe their future after Bangtan perhaps? JK as a successful solo performer (he mentioned in his Weverse interview that he wonders how it would feel like to perform by himself for 4 hours onstage) and SJ as a successful sought-after actor? And how will they continue with their blissful togetherness? What would their hurdles be as a couple? Just some thoughts to keep your creative juice flowing. But, hey Jinkookers, you really have to read what our great author and Jinkook UA-camr wrote. S/he is our Jinkook Muse!!!!!! Here is the link to "Noumena." archiveofourown.org/works/24750598?view_full_work=true PS I wrote a long comment on the Comment Section of Noumena. I hope you get to read it.
Whoa, tysm! I guess it's time to log in back to my ao3. I'm planning to switch alternatively between writing and video making or else I'll lose interest because I get bored easily haha. For Noumena, I want to continue with the "what if" future scenario as you mentioned, a short pre-debut flashback because I find it veryy intriguing in shaping them today, and whatever feels right at that moment. I end it like that because I feel that the story will continue in reality. Also, the sequel for the Zombie.Zip one! I hope I'm motivated enough to do all~
@@moonbathingrite I hope we, your fans and avid followers, will motivate you enough, as well as our Jin and JK of course. Thank you again for such wonderful content. 😍😍😍😍😍😍 Borahae 💜💜💜💜
Thank you!! i will sure check this out!!!
@@alianajwa9231 yes!!!!! Please read it. It made me cry. You are going to love it...
Wow...
It s beautiful, i feel like watching a sweet movies here..
Thank you 😆💜
seeing back these two were the most quite,shy one and now the most funniest,loud ,bold,confident