The Garmin R50 is REALLY GOOD...but There's a CATCH! (Full Review & Accuracy Test)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @asapherd1879
    @asapherd1879 26 днів тому +6

    This is the best channel on youtube when it comes to sim reviews.

  • @Evan_Rodgers
    @Evan_Rodgers 26 днів тому +21

    The subscription price ($100/yr) for Garmin Golf absolutely isn’t hefty in comparison to the rest of the industry. Bushnell charges $500/yr just to unlock basic software functionality. Uneekor charges $400, Skytrak+ and Rapsodo charge more than Garmin. The Garmin Golf sub also unlocks green contour mapping if you have a compatible Garmin golf watch.

    • @Evan_Rodgers
      @Evan_Rodgers 26 днів тому +7

      There’s no cost to use third party connectors, so this is actually one of the cheapest continued-use LMs for GSPro.

    • @MOTOBLADE
      @MOTOBLADE 9 днів тому

      @@Evan_Rodgersthat’s what I thought! I don’t like subscriptions but compared to the market it’s positively cheap! And if you have the garmin watch (which no one else is talking about but I happen to have one) you get the benefit on the course too. Great deal from garmin in my opinion. I think they should’ve thrown in a free year maybe for the price you’re paying for the unit, but still I wouldn’t be complaining!

  • @allahalibaba9063
    @allahalibaba9063 17 днів тому +1

    One thing that come to my mind is that no mention of if one can set the lofts for each club...This is a very important item for a accurate data.. So can it be set per club or is it fixed per club? Thanks....

  • @Chase-ing_Golf
    @Chase-ing_Golf 25 днів тому +8

    If you’re in the position in life where you can afford a $5000 launch monitor, you are most likely not worried about a $10 a month subscription. God do I wish I can get one of these for Chase and myself for when it gets to 100° plus Fahrenheit with 95% humidity. Here in Thailand.

    • @JoeyTheNote
      @JoeyTheNote 5 днів тому +1

      Im from Thailand and I got a skytrack. You defniitely need a golf sim!

    • @Chase-ing_Golf
      @Chase-ing_Golf 5 днів тому

      @ 100% going to need something by April. Or Chase and I are going to roast. Just gets too hot outside by then.

  • @OMG-2
    @OMG-2 23 дні тому +3

    I think you nailed it with the simplicity EXCEPT you didn't mention the constant bending to interface with the unit while playing a round. During practice that issue sort of goes away unless you want to map the data to a particular club and change often. As much as you hammered home the price it seems to be right priced for a unit with all its features. For folks without enough suitable space for radar units there currently is no great option without any subscription. The Uneekor Eye Mini and Eye Mini Lite have a $200 annual subscription minimum and the golf courses that you get with it are pitiful. The Eye Mini, with a screen that does much less than the R50 (yet is still better than Bushnell/GC3) is typically sold at the same price as the R50 and requires an iPad at minimum to get a driving range and shot shape and to play a sim round you need a PC to play the terrible Refine golf courses that are included. The Eye Mini LITE version costs much less but has no screen and MUST have a PC or iPad to get ANY data similar to the SkyTrak+. The only upside is, like the Garmin, they do not charge extra to connect to 3rd party options. So I guess, like everything else, you get what you pay for and the R50 earns its hefty price with all the features and simplicity it provide.
    One more thing... I can't think of another unit would be better to go out in the back and hit balls into a net for a golf simulation experience.

  • @brewster102
    @brewster102 21 день тому +1

    So is the R50 more accurate than the Mevo ? If it is, I don't understand comparing the two. If there was a way to compare the R50 with the GC3, that would be the way to go.l

  • @dougswist7547
    @dougswist7547 18 днів тому

    How thick is your mat and what are your settings for the height offset on the Mevo plus?

  • @justinstephenson9360
    @justinstephenson9360 26 днів тому +3

    Like a lot of LMs it will be better after one maybe two software updates after initial product launch.
    The R50 is definitely the LM which spent rather too much time at the "all you can eat" buffet!
    Things I love:
    - no subscription fees for the basic club and ball data
    - options for temperature and humidity, I love the idea of finding out what a cold day does to my carry distances.
    - no need for a PC unless you want to play GSPro or E6 Apex or similar. HTH2 is still a bit cartoonish but very playable.
    - Garmin subscription is very reasonably priced
    - Software is very customisable
    - speed of response
    Things I think need improved
    - ideally I would like to see a 4K version. 1080p is good but it could be better.
    - does not provide descent angle data
    - not convinced that the club data is as accurate as it should be - but that is very common issue for new LM
    - HTH2 should include course total yardages with each course description
    - price
    None of the negatives are major other than the price. This is a great device, there could be some interesting integration with other Garmin devices such as their GPS watches, rangefinders etc

  • @dallenlee4773
    @dallenlee4773 25 днів тому +1

    Didn't notice the R50- that swing of yours is a treat to watch

  • @nationhotrods
    @nationhotrods 23 дні тому

    What size screen are you using? If I preorder this, I would like to get a 14ft screen but not sure how it would look with the 16:10 and unfortunately I don’t know anything about these lol. Thanks

  • @karl0s77
    @karl0s77 26 днів тому +7

    Garmin is nailling it. Is an apple like business model that just gets you at some point. Ive been using garmin approach watches for the last 7 seven years, Ive tried to use apple watch ultra and Tag Heurer but somehow I always come back to Garmin, its just better in every single feature. I also got the Garmin R10 and I just love it. So, when you are into the garmin ecosystem, paying a $100 USD suscription that you’re gonna use in all your devices is nothing.

    • @Evan_Rodgers
      @Evan_Rodgers 26 днів тому

      Yep I pay for green contours and now I get upgraded HTH for free!

  • @AdamAirline
    @AdamAirline 18 днів тому

    Is it good for indoor hitting nets. No projector for me. I need mobility for my garage.

  • @jayprince9857
    @jayprince9857 26 днів тому

    Would you go with this or a GC3- struggling to decide which one to go for?

  • @leeb8950
    @leeb8950 2 дні тому

    Can you link this to a tablet display so you don't have to keep bending down to use the touch screen?

  • @AdamAirline
    @AdamAirline 8 днів тому

    Is it worth it if you’re not a virtual golf nerd and don’t have a setup? Looking to improve my game in my garage bay. Don’t want to dork out with a PC

  • @dddmmm21
    @dddmmm21 23 дні тому

    This is the real question for me, I dont mind having to still use an iPad or PC to run 3rd party software, that is reasonable... BUT... can you get ADDITIONAL info on the R50 screen while using 3rd party software? For example, if I use Awesome Golf on my iPad, can I at same time get slow-mo replays of my face impact location at the R50? That would be a killer combo. Or does the R50 just goes dead when using 3rd party software? Thanks

  • @OMG-2
    @OMG-2 23 дні тому

    Curious - did you do a software or firmware update before doing the video.

  • @bam14bam
    @bam14bam 26 днів тому

    Awesome video. What is the mat and enclosure you are using in the video?

  • @My-2-Cents
    @My-2-Cents 16 днів тому

    Would it work outdoors into a net?

  • @davidbrennan5253
    @davidbrennan5253 23 дні тому

    Looking for an answer ... I have a mat and a net and would like to simply attach the R50 to a television with an HDMI cable instead of looking at a 10" screen. Is this possible?

    • @Golficity
      @Golficity  21 день тому

      Yes you can use the HDMI to connect to a TV or a projector.

  • @Tubezilla
    @Tubezilla 26 днів тому

    Did the low resolution not look bad from the projector

  • @mlfpv7025
    @mlfpv7025 26 днів тому +3

    11:29 dude GSPRO and others are their own companies. Idk what you’re expecting that Garmin would get you an eternal license for awesome golf, gspro, and E6.
    You’re talking like a lot of this stuff isn’t the same as every other monitor on the market.

  • @marcelwieczorek6604
    @marcelwieczorek6604 25 днів тому

    My R50 is on Track, I will Test for myself at the Weekend.

  • @oreoten8283
    @oreoten8283 23 години тому

    I want one of these. My gears are turning and thinking of how to build a bay in my basement. I have 9’ ceilings. I think I can make it happen with this. I see this in my near future.

  • @alainjacob3841
    @alainjacob3841 24 дні тому

    How do we know that our club is on the Home T Hero list?

    • @ianridge
      @ianridge 21 день тому

      If you do a google search for “Home Tee Hero course list” you will be directed to the Garmin site and the course search tool. I found my course in it. Looks a good piece of kit.

  • @islandsnow
    @islandsnow 26 днів тому +4

    To me, get rid of that hunking built in monitor and make it the size of a buschnell or gc 3 and make an iPad mount in place of their monitor or you can put an iPad on a tripod at eye level. Keep the UI the same but in iPad app format and processsing still on the r50. Then you can keep the price down to $3,500

  • @johndomutz1052
    @johndomutz1052 25 днів тому

    I really like watching these reviews to follow the technology. I can't afford it, but still like to know what is going on out there.😊

  • @donaven283
    @donaven283 22 дні тому

    Nice job. Thanks for the review

  • @joeyjoejoeshabadoo
    @joeyjoejoeshabadoo 3 години тому

    Why would you test against the mevo?!

  • @salahlah23
    @salahlah23 21 день тому

    Flightscope do recommend that there should be no gap between the mevo+ and the hitting zone, you unfortunately did your comparison so we can’t know if the differences are real or biased due to setting

    • @salahlah23
      @salahlah23 21 день тому

      Gap = same ground level from lm to tee

  • @mlfpv7025
    @mlfpv7025 26 днів тому

    I’m really confused all monitors have a subscription which is more than this? You keep saying hefty like it costs more than GC3, MLM2PRO, etc. 9:53 some other monitors don’t work at all without a subscription. You don’t need to pay the subscription if all you want is all the ball and club data.

  • @zacharymilos392
    @zacharymilos392 25 днів тому

    This will be a good buy - assuming it's accurate - in a year or so for $3-3.5k. Not being able to run GsPro out of the box is very disappointing.

    • @phild3892
      @phild3892 22 дні тому

      You can’t run GS pro out of the box with ANY launch monitor on the market. Atleast with this you can play 42k courses out of the box. Along with driving range

  • @rodmarshallpga4571
    @rodmarshallpga4571 26 днів тому

    Can you see the screen in the bright sunlight outside?

    • @doublea9698
      @doublea9698 26 днів тому +1

      Been using mine outside for a couple days and no issues seeing the screen.

  • @Trey43w753
    @Trey43w753 26 днів тому

    I'd like to see this up against the Truegolf launch box.

  • @Cardroid
    @Cardroid 25 днів тому

    there's no issue.. most golfers who are already using GS Pro already have a pc or if they are running awesome golf.. they will already have an iPad.

  • @Shaboodle0114
    @Shaboodle0114 25 днів тому +2

    “I’ve got no skin in the game here” but also “follow the link below and use our code” 😂😉

    • @bearish7081
      @bearish7081 24 дні тому

      He meant from Garmin to give them a good review. Seemed pretty obvious to me.

    • @Shaboodle0114
      @Shaboodle0114 24 дні тому

      @@bearish7081making money off of this video is exactly what “skin in the game” would refer to. He’s clearly trying to mislead a some there, just check the tone during that little segment of the video. Let me just slow down and explain why I’m unbiased (even though I get paid if you buy one… wink wink).

  • @heavylift47
    @heavylift47 5 днів тому +1

    This thing is incredible, but I can't justify owning it. So if anyone is looking to buy an R50, hit me up in the comments.

    • @ianc7751
      @ianc7751 5 днів тому

      Have serious interest in this unit for its simplicity. Never owned a LM before but teetering back and forth on this one or GC3. Sadly, GC3 will require decent PC to run software. I want to see R50 vs GC3 video so badly.

    • @heavylift47
      @heavylift47 5 днів тому

      @ianc7751 fair point! I haven't seen a comparison between the R50 and the GC3 yet either. Thankfully, the R50 is comparable, but almost 50% the cost of the GC3. Looking forward to that comparison video.

  • @clow242
    @clow242 26 днів тому +1

    You don’t need another launch monitor, just send me the R50 😂

  • @onyonder7244
    @onyonder7244 21 день тому

    What if your lefty? And your playing a round of golf with your friends who are righty? Not one review video has mentioned this ????😳

    • @Golficity
      @Golficity  21 день тому

      Unfortunately this is a limitation of all launch monitors that sit next to the golf ball (instead of behind or overhead). With the R50 you will have to move and realign the unit each time when switching between righty and lefty golfers.

    • @onyonder7244
      @onyonder7244 21 день тому

      Yeah that sucks man!!! Appreciate the quick reply tho ✊🏼

  • @nbargolf
    @nbargolf 25 днів тому

    Nothing is different with GSPRO. It only runs on higher level PC period doesn't matter which LM. Another downer the hdmi resolution is the same as the screen 800 x 1280 pixels not very good.

  • @Ghostygoon
    @Ghostygoon 26 днів тому +2

    To be fair I would think the r50 is more accurate then the mevo

    • @rubelukeable
      @rubelukeable 26 днів тому +1

      By far. I’ve had it for 2 weeks and is comparable to Full Swing and Launch Pro

    • @Evan_Rodgers
      @Evan_Rodgers 26 днів тому

      @@rubelukeable important to note that radar LMs typically measure slightly higher (~0.5-1.5 mph) clubhead speed and carry distance. I never hit the ball further than when I use a trackman sim 😂

    • @rubelukeable
      @rubelukeable 26 днів тому

      @@Evan_Rodgers That's actually not true. As per Trackman 4 and Full Swing representatives. Please read as follows:
      ***TRACKMAN (Radar based)
      Club speed: Measured just before impact.
      Face angle: Represents the clubface orientation at impact.
      Launch angle: Measured as the ball leaves the clubface.
      Spin rate: The amount of spin on the ball, measured immediately after impact
      ***(GC Quad/BLP - camera based)
      Club data at impact:
      This includes club head speed, face angle, lie angle, club path, and impact location on the club face.
      Ball data after impact:
      This includes ball speed, launch angle (vertical and horizontal), spin rate, and side spin.
      My 7 iron club head speed on GC Quad is 85-86 and 82-83 on Trackman and Full Swing Kit. Cheers!! Hopes this clarifies any misconceptions.

  • @GSKGolfSimulatorSystems
    @GSKGolfSimulatorSystems 23 дні тому +1

    testing it against a Mevo+ Indoor - seriously?
    How inaccurate are these numbers then? Even a Trackman 4 has its difficulties indoors with RCT Balls, not mentioning the not so good Radar inside the mevo+.
    2 degrees club path or face angle difference are not 1 or 2 % difference
    Without testing it against a swing robot you never know the real numbers.

  • @adamjb8165
    @adamjb8165 14 днів тому

    “This is just to prove what we already know that this [the R50] is accurate […] Garmin is known even with the R10 and some other units to be very accurate. ”
    Um, no we don’t know that this is accurate. I would think that’s one of the main points of a review like this!
    Saying that is completely disingenuous.
    In fact, the R10 specifically is known to be pretty inaccurate, especially indoors, and especially with both higher ball-speeds, even with RCT balls, and shorter chip shots.
    And the R10 and Garmin’s other LM’s are all Doppler radar-based systems. This is their first photometric unit, so they don’t have any experience with a unit like this.
    From what I’ve seen on Reddit, the GSPro discord, and some UA-cam comments on R50 reviews, this thing can spit out some weird numbers.
    More testing required!
    And what is the size of its hitting area? Looks tiny?
    I couldn’t recommend this at this point over a BLP/GC3 or Eye Mini/Lite.

  • @justinSD-8662
    @justinSD-8662 24 дні тому

    I don’t think enough people are talking about this 😂

  • @mikeing36
    @mikeing36 22 дні тому

    Carrying the R50 to the range is a non issue. Dont see that as a downside.

  • @glennwatson3313
    @glennwatson3313 26 днів тому +1

    The things I like:
    1. The built in computer
    2. The large display
    3. The cheap subscription
    4. No weird balls
    But the price is a bit much.

    • @prakkerschlang7823
      @prakkerschlang7823 25 днів тому +1

      So you mentioned built in computer and cheap subscription then you say it's too expensive? When you compare realistically you have a 1000-1500$ laptop built in, that drops it 3500$ then let's say we had to pay 500 per year to use it. In 10 years you've spent an entire other 5 thousand on subscriptions. Garmin comes with 43k courses. Is it cheap? No. It's not expensive.

    • @glennwatson3313
      @glennwatson3313 24 дні тому

      @@prakkerschlang7823 Cost and expense are relative. To some its expensive and to others its not. For me its a bit too expensive, at least for now.
      I would like to see it at $3000.00, but then I am not the one in charge of pricing.

  • @DeeMannMusic
    @DeeMannMusic 25 днів тому

    “Alright”

  • @PrtPrtPrtGood
    @PrtPrtPrtGood 26 днів тому

    Hey is Mike not a petty of this channel anymore?

    • @Golficity
      @Golficity  26 днів тому

      Hey Mike here! Frank went full time not long ago so he’s been dialing up some GREAT product reviews from time to time. Wait til you see Mondays video 😉

  • @chrisbright2088
    @chrisbright2088 26 днів тому

    The lent on his shoulder is annoying me

  • @Tubezilla
    @Tubezilla 26 днів тому +3

    I wouldnt buy it unless it can be compared directly to trackman or GC4.

  • @alainjacob3841
    @alainjacob3841 22 дні тому +1

    I'm sorry you didn't bother to answer my very simple question, which shows a blatant lack of professionalism.

    • @bayarea13
      @bayarea13 6 днів тому

      Don't be an entitled asshat @alainjocob3841. Broham is making you a free video. He's not your personal coach. You should just thank him.

  • @JaySimmons-n9t
    @JaySimmons-n9t 3 дні тому

    It's not good, it's overpriced and average.