I agree 100% Some of them were Okay but then some were Like “🤨🤨🤨” and did you SEE they’re award show Dresses?? My lord SM is setting them Up and they still manage not to flop. THAT’S talent
Based on what i have seen from dancers and vocalist pretty sure the ranking is Vocal 1.Ningning (kinda obvious she is the main Vocalist) 2.Winter (Lead vocalist) 3.Karina (she shows more support than giselle) 4.Giselle Dance 1.Karina (main dancer) 2.Winter (lead dancer) 3.Giselle (kinda interchangable with ningning but slightly better aside from facials) 4.Ningning Rap 1.Giselle (main rapper) 2.Karina (lead rapper) 3.Ningning (unlike winter Ningning has actually said that she practices rapping) 4.Winter
Giselle was the prettiest for me since day 1! She might not fit the korean beauty standard like the others but her beauty is the most praised globally GISELLE MY TALENTED VISUAL
I am agree, She looks like an AE seriously.. Winter looks beautiful with long hair but she lose her aura beautiful when she cut her hair .. Karina's Aura never change
@@purpleflowy1785 well she respect your opinion so please respect her opinion too. Just check karina's predebut videos. Karina's strong and sweet voice is really stand out the most
NingNing 3rd in dancing just proves how high are the qualifications needed for Lead and Main Dancer positions in SM Group how much more the Leads And Mains wow
@@aestheticdancemoms958 ok first of all this was 8 months ago. now that i've seen more of them a few things are diff but no matter how many times its clearly my opinion, ppl always say like "no actually this person is better than this person." it's very irritating so i'm going to fix it now so be quiet.
@@helloworldholly4552 YOUR LITERALLY BEING BIASED. Rankings are based off on facts not opinions. That doesn't seem to suit you tbh, you can think of excuses but that just shows how you really are. so it's better if you be quiet.
All are talented and ace. That's why they are ace-spa. But a interesting fact that happen to me is that my bias is karina. Her beauty is insane and unrealistic. But I am slowly attracted to winter. Not only her visual but also her vocal enchanting me. I was enchanted when she cover 'secret garden' by IU in knowing bros. I always every day listen her cover that song.
I agree with the vocal but I have my own ranking in terms of the rest Dance 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Ningning Rap 1. Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ningning 4. Winter Visual 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Ningning Also my bias hehe 1. Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ningning 4. Winter
@@jupitteria spanish, but what i meant overall was that i wouldnt switch the first two positions thats why i said “behind” them, didn’t mean it to sound wrong
I would rank Karina in no.3 in Vocals, it might sound like she has a really deep voice, but actually her vocals are stable and powerful.... And she can do high notes too :) But everything else I agree ☺️
As i see it karina is underhype among ifans yeah? Whereas i see it knetz put her the highest among in 4th gen visual ranking in all articles and even among aespa. Maybe im the only one who saw the shines in her. She has unique voice compared to any sm idols but ppl chose to not appreciate her (maybe tiffany but its diff as well). Yeah but i respect ppl have diff standard and this is her opinion. Its not like thousand of ppl vote for this. fighting karina!!! I hope u will be more successful in korea.
It's visual there's a standard in that.but Giselle is 3rd in visual.the top tier visual of aespa is karina and winter it's really obvious.not because you ranked last in visual it doesn't mean that you're least pretty.example yeji of itzy she's really pretty but in visual she ranked no 4 in their group because of the KBS.what I mean to say is visual in not the prettiest member for you it's the member who fit KBS the most.
I don't have bias and this is just based after listening to Black Mamba and Forever. Vocal: 1. NingNing (One of the best Main Vocal of 4th Gen) 2. Winter (If she debuted in diff group she can be Main Vocal) 3. Giselle 4. Karina Dance: 1. Karina (She's so good) 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. NingNing Rap: 1. Giselle (I can't wait to listen to her future raps) 2. Karina 3. NingNing /Winter Visual: 1. Winter 2. Karina 3. NingNing 4. Giselle
My ranking Vocal: 1:ning ning 2:winter 3:giselle(go and hear her vocals at forever) 4:karina Dance: 1:Karina 2:winter 3:Ning Ning and giselle(both are good) Rap: 1:giselle 2:Karina 3: winter and Ning Ning(lets wait for them to rap) Visual: 1:aespa😎
All of them literally an all rounder but their has a specific main things. Karina-Main Dance NingNing-Main Vocal Giselle-Main Rap Winter-Main Visual But all of them is ACE(All rounder)
my opinion: Vocal 1-Winter 2-Ningning 3-Giselle 4-Karina Dance 1-Karina 2-Winter 3-Giselle 4-Ningning Rap 1-Giselle 2-Karina 3-Winter 4-Ningning Visual 1-Winter 2-Karina 3-Giselle 4-Ningning This is just my opinion,not your Opinion
all of them is good but giselle is trained well before also giselle's vocal tone is unique. karina is last bur doesn't mean she is not good it is just the others is much better 😅 all of them is good even karina can be main or lead vocal in other group
@@stantalentedidols8824 Karina is well trained too, the video of her singing high note was during her predebut (not in SM yet). She was a trainee since 2016 so i am pretty sure that she improved a lot. I am sure a lot of people will suprise by her vocal ability in the next comeback. Her lines in this debut song didnt do her justice
@@asdkjgf that's why all of them is good but doesn't mean karina is 4th she is bad. giselle have more control and nice vocal tone but karina is also very impressive 😊
my rankings: vocal: 1. Ningning 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Karina rap: 1. Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ningning 4. Winter dance: 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Ningning visual: (this is my own opinion,,, pls don't come for me) 1. Karina 2. Giselle 3. Winter 4. Ningning (this was so hard bc all of them are so pretty---)
There's so many interchangeable in aespa members like: Vocal: Karina and Giselle Dance: Ningning and Giselle Rap: Ningning and Winter Visual: Karina and Winter So for me stop arguing because maybe their potential will be grow up just wait for atleast 2 years🤣🤣🤣🤣
How i rate myself : Vocals 4. Karina 3. Ningning 2. Giselle 1. Winter Dance 4. Giselle 3. Ningning 2. Winter 1. Karina Rap 4. Ningning 3. Karina 2. Winter 1. Giselle Visual 4. Karina 3. Ningning 2. Winter 1. Giselle These are only according to me and i don't hate any members
Who's your bias ?
My bias is NingNing
Ningning 🦋👑
Karina💜💜
MY nias Winter
WINTER
Having Karina as the no.4 in vocals only shows how good these girls' vocals are
Yes
@random roaster she is really 4 in vocal range , sm say giselle is better than her
@@jeannedemba6120 when
@@jeannedemba6120 when :))
Karina is better vocalist than Giselle.
Giselle is a type which at first sight you don't like her visuals much but the more you look at her the prettier she gets
true, actually i think she was ok at debut but when time passes she now became one of my top faves in visuals lol
@@eternal6257 omg same for me! i think it was because her blonde hair... 'm glad she switched
I tried to do tht trust me but i still find the others beautiful.
@@artsistic_2273 then u are fake MY
Same
æspa's stylist gave them really good outfits in music shows but then ruined everything with the outfits in award shows..
nah, you just dont like
@@알라니스야 finish your sentence
I agree 100% Some of them were Okay but then some were Like “🤨🤨🤨” and did you SEE they’re award show Dresses?? My lord SM is setting them Up and they still manage not to flop. THAT’S talent
*vocal*
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
*rap*
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
*dance*
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
_visual_
they’re all so pretty
Winter is taeyeon's look a like😍😍😍
My Ranking:
Vocal:
1. NingNing
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
Dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. NingNing
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. NingNing
4. Winter
Visual:
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. NingNing
4. Giselle
Extra One:
Stage Presence:
1. NingNing
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Winter
I thini ningning is better in rap thn winter... she said in an interview she will rap once for jay park. Seems like ningning is really in to rap
@@filmi6873 really ??? wow I didn't know that hihi
Super concordop
Karina last in stage presence? I think it is winter either Giselle
@@karimotosanstering3791 Giselle last in stage presence and Ningning
Based on what i have seen from dancers and vocalist pretty sure the ranking is
Vocal
1.Ningning (kinda obvious she is the main Vocalist)
2.Winter (Lead vocalist)
3.Karina (she shows more support than giselle)
4.Giselle
Dance
1.Karina (main dancer)
2.Winter (lead dancer)
3.Giselle (kinda interchangable with ningning but slightly better aside from facials)
4.Ningning
Rap
1.Giselle (main rapper)
2.Karina (lead rapper)
3.Ningning (unlike winter Ningning has actually said that she practices rapping)
4.Winter
I agree, but in vocal for me giselle is a no.3 because is a choir singer and I like her voice more.
I feel like giselle is better then karina at sing
Winter is better at rap than Ningning
Giselle was the prettiest for me since day 1! She might not fit the korean beauty standard like the others but her beauty is the most praised globally GISELLE MY TALENTED VISUAL
i would give ningning 3rd for rap cause the girls and her said she raps in MY time
Yep and she loves rappers. She said she will rap one day for jay park
@@filmi6873 She raps in Next Level
@Ice Queen Is it weird that mine is the opposite. NingNing has this aura of arrogance and being a an aristocrat on stage and it showed
For me:
VOCALS:
1-NINGNING
2-WINTER
3-KARINA & GISELLE
RAP:
1-GISELE
2-KARINA
3-WINTER & NINGNING
DANCE:
1-KARINA
2-WINTER
3-NINGNING
4-GISELE
VISUAL:
1-WINTER
2-KARINA
3-NINGNING
4-GISELE
This is the kind of my ranking opinion, I just really hate the toxic MY's who's comparing karina and giselle's vocals
Ningning is the prettiest imo, cuz she is so beautiful and cute!! I love Ningning so much!!
Chinese beauty
Purrr
my bias ningning
I agree with most of this but Karina is first in visuals for me.
Winter isn't the Visual for nothing but Both of them are pretty
I am agree, She looks like an AE seriously.. Winter looks beautiful with long hair but she lose her aura beautiful when she cut her hair .. Karina's Aura never change
i can totally agree especially without makeup she looks so stunning :(
Karina: Dance
Giselle: Rap
Winter: All
NingNing : Vocal
Agreed
Winter:VISUAL
Winter ace❤️
Winter doesn't know how to rap. I think everyone is Karina or Ningning .
@@LinhLinh-zn7vp you don't know if she can rap or not it hasn't even been a year since they debut
Karina and ningning😍😘😘
I'm a vocalist so...
1- NingNing
2- Winter
3- Karina
4- Giselle
Ofc no! Giselle is singer before, and Karina just trained vocal less
@Arachan i agree.
@@purpleflowy1785 well she respect your opinion so please respect her opinion too. Just check karina's predebut videos. Karina's strong and sweet voice is really stand out the most
@@elishasweetgirl What? I Never Seen Shes Respect Me Dude
@@elishasweetgirl Say Less If You Stan They Opinion, And You DOn't Want Your Opinion Cracked.
WINTER IS MORE THAN A VISUAL.
SAY IT WITH ME.
*WINTER IS MORE THAN A VISUAL.*
She is a beauty queen. And all the the other members are extraordinary.
No one said that she‘s an amazing vocalist and dancer too
In vocal
1 ) ningning
2)winter
3)karina
4)giselle
This is the most well balanced group if I ever saw one.
NingNing 3rd in dancing just proves how high are the qualifications needed for Lead and Main Dancer positions in SM Group how much more the Leads And Mains wow
Its so impossible... NING NING said she will rap like Jay Park... most vocalists can rap and I believe he can than winter.
for me its
vocals:
1. Ningning
Ur bias is Ningning ohhhh that's y u put winter always last coz u don't want your bias last
@@imokcauseimjk4416 yes but last doesn't mean bad since they are all talented and i love all of them
@@helloworldholly4552 how is winter last in dancing? She is literally lead dancer and winter can rap bruh
@@aestheticdancemoms958 ok first of all this was 8 months ago. now that i've seen more of them a few things are diff but no matter how many times its clearly my opinion, ppl always say like "no actually this person is better than this person." it's very irritating so i'm going to fix it now so be quiet.
@@helloworldholly4552 YOUR LITERALLY BEING BIASED. Rankings are based off on facts not opinions. That doesn't seem to suit you tbh, you can think of excuses but that just shows how you really are. so it's better if you be quiet.
My opinion(My bias ranking)
1.Giselle
2.Winter
3.Karina
4.Ningning
Giselle: body shape
Karina: height
Ningning:cuteness
Winter:eyes
Are my favorite
All are talented and ace. That's why they are ace-spa. But a interesting fact that happen to me is that my bias is karina. Her beauty is insane and unrealistic. But I am slowly attracted to winter. Not only her visual but also her vocal enchanting me. I was enchanted when she cover 'secret garden' by IU in knowing bros. I always every day listen her cover that song.
I agree with the vocal but I have my own ranking in terms of the rest
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning
4. Winter
Visual
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Also my bias hehe
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning
4. Winter
Winter
-lead vocal
-lead dancer
-main visual
Here's My Opinion
VOCAL
4.Giselle
3.Karina
2.Winter
1.Ning Ning
Dance
4.Giselle
3.Ning Ning
2.Winter
1.Karina
Rap
4.Ning Ning
3.Winter
2.Karina
1.Giselle
Visual
4.Giselle
3.Ning Ning
2.Karina
1.Winter
Stage Precense
4.Giselle
3.Winter
2.Ning Ning
1.Karina
My Bias
4.Karina
3.Ning Ning
2.Giselle
1.Winter
Ningning is a representation of chungha✨👁️👄👁️✨
My bias ningning😘😘😘😘
My bias
1 winter
2 karina
3 giselle
4 ningning
They r all awasome
same
I agree with most but on vocal i would put Karina in 3rd place💗
“Behind”...
@@Fer-fy8dx oh sorry if my wording was wrong lmao, im not a native eng speaker i didnt know saying behind as a locator was bad :(
@@pinkrose1600 what language you speak
@@jupitteria spanish, but what i meant overall was that i wouldnt switch the first two positions thats why i said “behind” them, didn’t mean it to sound wrong
@@pinkrose1600 no problem xD i speak portuguese
My opinion
Vocal:
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Karina/Giselle
Dance:
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Giselle/Ningning
Rap:
1 Giselle
2 Karina
3 Ningning
4 Winter
Visual(all of them could be 1st):
1 Winter
2 Karina
3 Ningning
4 Giselle
My bias:
1 Winter/Ningning
2 Karina/Giselle
my opinion:
vocal
1. ningning
2. winter
3. karina
4. giselle
dance
1. karina
2. winter
3. giselle
4. ningning
rap
1. giselle
2. karina
3. winter
4. ningning
visual
1. winter
2. karina
3. ningning
4. giselle
I would rank Karina in no.3 in Vocals, it might sound like she has a really deep voice, but actually her vocals are stable and powerful.... And she can do high notes too :)
But everything else I agree ☺️
Vocal:
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Visual:
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Outfit:
1. Karina
2. Ningning
3. Winter
4. Giselle
Karina is kinda like those idols who's voice is so good but their last (like lisa from bp)
yeah if karina or lisa are in another group they can be lead vocalist
and karina is way better vocally than lisa
@@jes1888 well its ur opinion
@@hajar__doksa i know
@@jes1888 ok
i like karina😣❤
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter and Ningning
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Visual
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Ningning should be the only 3rd place in rapping since she said she practices while winter has not said anything about rapping
Me
Vocal
1 Ningning
2 Winter
3 Karina
4 Giselle
Rap
1 Giselle
2 Karina
3 Winter
4 Ningning
Dance
1 Karina
2 Winter
3 Ningning
4 Giselle
Visual (no hate)
1 Winter
2 Karina
3 Ningning
4 Giselle
Vocal:
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Visual (my opinion):
1. Ningning
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Winter
Stage presence:
1. Ningning
2. Giselle
3. Karina / Winter
My bias:
1. Ningning
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Winter
As i see it karina is underhype among ifans yeah? Whereas i see it knetz put her the highest among in 4th gen visual ranking in all articles and even among aespa. Maybe im the only one who saw the shines in her. She has unique voice compared to any sm idols but ppl chose to not appreciate her (maybe tiffany but its diff as well). Yeah but i respect ppl have diff standard and this is her opinion. Its not like thousand of ppl vote for this. fighting karina!!! I hope u will be more successful in korea.
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Giselle
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning
4. Winter
Visual
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
My opinion
Vocal
4th Giselle
3rd Karina
2nd Winter
1st Ningning
after savage, dreams come true and step back, i'd say, winter is third for rap and karina third in vocal
Vocal
1- Ningning
2- Winter
3- Giselle
4- Karina
Dance
1- Karina
2- Winter
3- Ningning
4- Giselle
Rap
1- Giselle
2- Karina
3- Winter
4- Ningning
Visual
1- Karina
2- Winter
3- Giselle
4- Ninging
Bias
1- Karina
2- Ningning
3- Giselle
4- Winter
agreed but i dont think giselle is the least pretty
I agree. She and Winter are the prettiest.
It's visual there's a standard in that.but Giselle is 3rd in visual.the top tier visual of aespa is karina and winter it's really obvious.not because you ranked last in visual it doesn't mean that you're least pretty.example yeji of itzy she's really pretty but in visual she ranked no 4 in their group because of the KBS.what I mean to say is visual in not the prettiest member for you it's the member who fit KBS the most.
@@kwangbaeimean1660 just for some.beauty is subjective but y'all must know that the visual has a standard.
Who is least pretty then?
Btw its not a hate comment😏
@@me2764 i was thinking about it for long and still haven't decided..
MY PERSONAL RANKING WOULD BE:
Vocal
1.Ningning
2.Winter
3.Giselle
4.Karina
Dance
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
Rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Ningning
4.Winter
Visuals
1.Karina
2.Ningning
3.Winter/Giselle
Stage presence and Charisma
1.Ningning/Karina
2.Winter
3.Giselle
Vocal
1:ningning
2:winter
3:karina
4:giselle
Visual
1:winter
2:karina
3:ningning
4:giselle
Dance
1:karina
2:winter
3:giselle
4:ningning
Rap
1:giselle
2:karina
3:winter
4:ningning
Visual
1:winter
2:karina
3:giselle
4:ningning
Bias
1:karina
2:winter
3:giselle
4:ningning
My opinion ok 😉
I don't have bias and this is just based after listening to Black Mamba and Forever.
Vocal:
1. NingNing (One of the best Main Vocal of 4th Gen)
2. Winter (If she debuted in diff group she can be Main Vocal)
3. Giselle
4. Karina
Dance:
1. Karina (She's so good)
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. NingNing
Rap:
1. Giselle (I can't wait to listen to her future raps)
2. Karina
3. NingNing
/Winter
Visual:
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. NingNing
4. Giselle
My ranking
Vocal:
1:ning ning
2:winter
3:giselle(go and hear her vocals at forever)
4:karina
Dance:
1:Karina
2:winter
3:Ning Ning and giselle(both are good)
Rap:
1:giselle
2:Karina
3: winter and Ning Ning(lets wait for them to rap)
Visual:
1:aespa😎
My Ranking (my opinion)
Vocal:
4. Karina
3. Giselle
2. Winter
1. NingNing
Dance:
4. Giselle
3. NingNing
2. Winter
1. Karina
Rap:
4. NingNing
3. Winter
2. Karina
1. Giselle
Visual:
4. Giselle
3. NingNing
2. Karina
1. Winter
Winter is literally an all rounder
All of them literally an all rounder but their has a specific main things.
Karina-Main Dance
NingNing-Main Vocal
Giselle-Main Rap
Winter-Main Visual
But all of them is ACE(All rounder)
For me:
•Vocals
1. ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina & Giselle
•Rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Winter & Giselle
•Visual (Kbs)
1. Karina & winter (both fit 80%)
2.Giselle (60%)
3.Ningning (40%)
•Dance
1. Karina
2. winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
•Stage presence
1. Ningning & Karina
2. Giselle
3. Winter
💜✨
Thing that I see with mys ranking
Vocal: Ningning
Dance:winter
Rap:Giselle
Visual:Karina
my opinion:
Vocal
1-Winter
2-Ningning
3-Giselle
4-Karina
Dance
1-Karina
2-Winter
3-Giselle
4-Ningning
Rap
1-Giselle
2-Karina
3-Winter
4-Ningning
Visual
1-Winter
2-Karina
3-Giselle
4-Ningning
This is just my opinion,not your Opinion
Karina queen dance visul vocal rap
I think so Karina best all 👸💛
For me-
Vocals
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ninging
4. Giselle
Rap-
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning and winter
Visual
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Ningning and Giselle
In my opinion,visual is 1.Winter
2.Karina
3.Giselle
4.Ningning
And my bia is Karina😊
🥰❤️
karina vocal 3, look her high notes
all of them is good but giselle is trained well before also giselle's vocal tone is unique. karina is last bur doesn't mean she is not good it is just the others is much better 😅 all of them is good even karina can be main or lead vocal in other group
@@stantalentedidols8824 Karina is well trained too, the video of her singing high note was during her predebut (not in SM yet). She was a trainee since 2016 so i am pretty sure that she improved a lot. I am sure a lot of people will suprise by her vocal ability in the next comeback. Her lines in this debut song didnt do her justice
@@asdkjgf that's why all of them is good but doesn't mean karina is 4th she is bad. giselle have more control and nice vocal tone but karina is also very impressive 😊
@@stantalentedidols8824 Not really, Giselle doesn't have more control than Karina, only reason you are saying this is because she was in choir.
High notes does not make you a better vocalist...
Mine:
Vocal
1.Ningning
2.Winter
3.Giselle
4.Karina
Dance
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.giselle
4.ningning
Rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Ningning/winter
Visual
1.Winter
2.Karina
3.Ningning
4.giselle
Cute
1.Ningning
2.Karina/Winter/Giselle
Bias
1.Karina
2.Giselle
3.winter
4.ningning
my rankings:
vocal:
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
rap:
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning
4. Winter
dance:
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
visual: (this is my own opinion,,, pls don't come for me)
1. Karina
2. Giselle
3. Winter
4. Ningning
(this was so hard bc all of them are so pretty---)
for some people are not agreeing with this
This is her opinion thank you😂
Ningning is the best visual 😍😍😍😍😍
Spill
Karina
The real visual, leader, main dancer, lead rapper, vocalist, center, face of the group
The visual is Winter
@@josepablonunez7151 it's not official though
@@kimlee6140 it actually is
@@josepablonunez7151 no it's not
@@kimlee6140 if you see kprofiles you can see she’s the visual
1. Winter 8
2. Karina 9
3. Ningning 11
4. Giselle 12
Your intro 🥺
they are a group that is fully well balanced.they can sing, they can dance , they can rap, and man those visuals.
Karina is the 3rd best vocalist...
My opinion
Vocal:
4. Karina
3. Giselle
2. Winter
1. Ningning
Dance:
4. Giselle
3. Ningning
2. Winter
1. Karina
Rap:
4. Winter
3. Ningning
2. Karina
1. Giselle
Visual:
4. Karina
3. Giselle
2. Ningning
1. Winter
Karina visual in 4 her visual is crazy..but thats your opinion i respect it
I am aespa New fan 😊
Karina of vocal 3.
First🥺
It's nicer that I thought
imo
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle/Ningning (tbh their power n move looks same)
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning/Winter
Visual (once again imo)
1. Winter
2. Ningning
3. Karina
4. Giselle
❤My Opinion❤
*VOCAL*
1° NingNing
2° Winter
3° Karina/Giselle
*Dance*
1° Karina
2° Winter
3° NingNing
4° Giselle
*Rap*
1° Giselle
2° Karina
3° Winter
4° NingNing
*Visual*
1° Winter/Karina
2° Giselle
3° NingNing
*Funny*
1° NingNing
2° Winter
3° Giselle
4° Karina
*Age*
1° Karina = Granny
2° Giselle = Mom
3° Winter = the oldest Kid
4° NingNing = The Baby
*Craziness*
1° NingNing
2° Giselle/Winter
3° Karina
*Bias*
1° Winter/NingNing/Giselle
2°Karina
*Smartness*
1° Giselle
2° Karina
3° Winter/NingNing
*Cute*
1°NingNing
2° Winter
3° Giselle
4° Karina.
(They are crazy and
❤I LOVE THEY❤)
There's so many interchangeable in aespa members like:
Vocal:
Karina and Giselle
Dance:
Ningning and Giselle
Rap:
Ningning and Winter
Visual:
Karina and Winter
So for me stop arguing because maybe their potential will be grow up just wait for atleast 2 years🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ranking For Me :
Vocal :
1. Ning Ning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Gissele
Dance :
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Gissele
4. Ning Ning
Rap :
1. Gissele
2. Karina
3. Winter
4.Ning Ning
Visual :
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Gissele
4. Ning Ning
Winter is Visual. and just see Giselle on Forever M/V u such a dummie well it is ur opinion but u'll gonna public it with people opinion
@@purpleflowy1785 Karina Is Visual!!!
@@jershyvidya8050 No dummie, she kprofiles and on Forever M/V
@@jershyvidya8050 um hun winter is visual as well your opinion doesn’t matter cuz you’re wrong
@@lssosheirujh3620 Karina is visual 😭😭😭🙂🙂🙂🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Visuals for me is
1-Winter and Karina
2-Giselle
3-Ningning
ACE WINTER👑
Mine opinion:
VOCAL
1.Ningning
2.Winter
3.Karina
4.Giselle
DANCE
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
RAP
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.Ningning
VISUAL
1.Karina (she is stunning)
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
FACE OF THE GROUP
1.Karina
2.Giselle
3.Winter
4.Ningning
Agree in everithing 100%.
Winter is the most talented and the most well-rounded. She could probably rap?
Karina forever! ❤️🔥😝
6:00 she looks like a 80% Jennie
My opinion:
Vocal
1 - Ningning
2 - Winter
3 - Karina
4 - Giselle
Dance
1 - Karina
2 - Winter
3 - Ningning
4 - Giselle
Rap
1 - Giselle
2 - Karina
3 - Winter/Ningning(cant tell who's better)
Visual
1 - Karina (she's unreal and gives more visual vibes for me)
2 - Winter (really pretty and cute)
3 - Ningning/Giselle (They're stunning and I feel like I can't put any of them at 4)
How i rate myself :
Vocals
4. Karina
3. Ningning
2. Giselle
1. Winter
Dance
4. Giselle
3. Ningning
2. Winter
1. Karina
Rap
4. Ningning
3. Karina
2. Winter
1. Giselle
Visual
4. Karina
3. Ningning
2. Winter
1. Giselle
These are only according to me and i don't hate any members
Aespa is one of the most balanced and best dancing groups
Karina
Winter
NignNing
Giselle
My ranking
:
Vocal : 1. Ning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
Rap :
My bias is Karina
If we average all, the winner is winter....
My opinion
Vocal
1:Ningning
2: Winter
3:Karina
4: Giselle
Ningning's vocal is no joke
For me.
Vocal
1. NingNing 9.0/10
2. Winter 8.8/10
3. Karina 7.3/10
4. Giselle 7.0/10
Dance
1. Karina 9.2/10
2. Winter 8.7/10
3. NingNing 5.4/10
4. Giselle 5.3/10
Rap
1. Giselle 8.0/10
2. Karina 6.5/10
3. Winter 3.0/10
4. NingNing 3.0/10
Visual
1. Winter 7.5/10
2. Karina 7.0/10
3. NingNing 6.9/10
4. Giselle 4.8/10
for me:
vocal
1. ningning
2. winter
3. gislle
4. karina
rap:
1. gislle
2.karina
3. ningning
3. winter
dance:
1. karina
2.winter
3.gislle
4.ningning
visaul:
1.winter
2.karina
3.ningning
4.gislle
Ning ning
For me
Vocal:
Ningning
Winter
Giselle
Karina
Dance:
Karina
Winter
Giselle/Ningning
Rap:
Giselle
Karina
Winter/Ningning
Visual:
Karina
Winter
Ningning
Giselle
Is there a group where there is a member that is main dancer and lead vocalist
My bais ningning