Algae in the planted aquarium - Systems design and control
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 лип 2024
- How to handle algae issues in a planted aquarium
Scapes by Cory Hopkins:
/ stringdeity
Scapes by Hiep Hong:
/ @ichthyofile
Scapes by Arturo:
/ @aquascapegoattv
Visit my new website:
www.advancedplantedtank.com/
0:09
Relations between trophic state indicators and plant biomass in Florida lakes by Roger W. Bachmann, Christine A. Horsburgh, Mark Hoyer, Laura K. Mataraza, Daniel E. Canfield.
Effects of submersed Macrophytes on Ecosystem processes: Stephen R. Carpenter, David M. Lodge
Music: Virtutes Vocis Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b... - Домашні улюбленці та дикі тварини
Thanks Dennis. You're the only consistently high quality source of information for keeping aquariums that I have come across. I really appreciate the effort you put into the videos, and just how much better the information you give is compared to other channels.
ha, Thanks man... A lot of the information comes from the barr report.com / so indirectly we have barr to thank for the background research
im so Sad ;-;
I dont undestand spoken english ;-;
4 years later, this video still rocks! on the detail information and missing gaps which makes your brain tickle. Dennis - awesome job mate!
Clear and accessible discussion of a complex topic. Best algae video I've seen. Thanks so much.
Dennis, thank God we have you helping this community! The amount of effort you spent on each topic is greatly appreciated!
As everyone else has said, thank you for all the work you do to keep all of us well educated. Your channel has helped me a lot and has helped my knowledge increase as I learn more about this hobby!
This video is legendary, no one else explains these stuff on youtube better than Kevin.
Why doesn’t this video have a million views? It should. Thank you Dennis Wong.
Probably the most informative video i have ever seen regarding algae. This should be required viewing FOR ALL planted tank aquarists.
Most informative video on aquarium algae. Thanks for taking your time to make this brother.
This is the best presentation for Algae as it pertains to Aquascaping.
Thank you so much for your tests and research. You've earned my SUB for life.
Dennis, you did a spectacular job in this video! I appreciate the time you put into making this video and the willingness to share your extensive knowledge with all who are fortunate in coming across your channel!
I've watched other planted tank videos, and I'd have to say that your videos are the most informative and entertaining to watch. Not to mention, your tanks are absolutely BEAUTIFUL!
Thank you for putting in the time to make these videos!!! You answer so many of my questions in all of them. Keep it up!
nice job of using the scientific approach to analyse the Algae Problem!
I recommend this video to all who desperately search for help with algae!!! All mentioned there complies with my experience or at least with my belief. And there are not many other sources of information on the web as good as this one about algae. That is why I am writing this comment as my first comment on UA-cam! I also recommend Mr. Wong's website! Very good one! Thank you!
Great video Dennis. Your straightforward and informative manner is appreciated.
Love your videos, exactly what this hobby needs more of!
Dennis, I’m just getting back into the hobby & planted aquascape is my focus. I’m having a lot of success but do have some algae, mainly on my slower growing plants. Thank you so much, I think I have learnt & understood more from this one video than the many others I have watched (from other UA-camrs). I know I’m commenting after this video has been out for a few years, but thank you so much, Brilliant!
Dennis! That was an awesomely informative and really well put together presentation. I learned more in the last 14 minutes then in years. Thank you.
ha thanks...
Dennis love your videos. Super informative and technical, keep it up!
First time I've heard about type 1 and type 2 tanks, great stuff!
Really good content , more time devoted to experiment than I could dream of. Thanks and very much appreciated!
Cheers Dennis.... Have got the bug and find myself gravitating to your tuition... Many thanks... Joe
Fantastic video. Seen it several times, the details are excellent and the examples are practical. Have read most of your articles. Your website is a class apart. Keep up the good work!!! Thanks!!
Dennis, I love your videos and your tanks are truly beautiful
Love your videos. Thanks for the detailed and informative advice.
thank you very much for this informative video i learned quite a bit from this pls continue to display more in the future.We all battle with algae issues and more knowledge we have the easier it will be to control it
Very organized presentation. Thank you.
Awsome just Awsome. Thank you for your knowledge and willingness to show us. I have been watching and learning from you for years from rotalas to cuspidatums... God bless and tank on
What a great video bro. I just got back into the aquarium hobby and I'm enjoying the successes and the challenges of a planted aquarium. Your video was presented in a well thought out manner. It made sense to me. I'm currently working thru a algae bloom of green hair and I eventually came to the final three points at the end of your video in managing my GA bloom. I just wanted to say you did a great job in your presentation. I've liked, subscribed and will be viewing more of your videos. Have a good one bud.
Thanks man ~
Brilliant! Finally .... advice that actually works with my kind of tank!
what a awesome well inform video the best I've ever seen on UA-cam thank you so much for your time
Good one, really helpfull. Thanks for all those precious info
Your videos have the best content off it's kind on youtube hat's off to you sir
By far best algae vid on youtube from what I'v seen! Really solid.
Thanks man
You made my research simple! Thank you so much!
Best information around youtube!! Thank you sooo much!!!!!!
thank you for your videos. I have watched them all and have learned so much from you. I hope you continue providing your advice through these videos.
Thank you~
Thank you Dennis for such a good video!
Another Must watch video from Dennis.
by far the best video on algae !!!
It's been awhile since your last video. Good to see a new one. Thanks for the info.
Thanks for coming by ~ good luck with your tanks too
Once again Dennis you generously share your seasoned knowledge, clearly and easy to follow, with us. This video is spot on as most of us struggle with algae at some point.
Thanks ! Glad you found it useful
Another great vid Xiaozhuang!
very good learning experience! keep it coming, Dennis!
Very good video, full of relevant informations. Thanks for share it.
Wow super good info nicely planed out and presented
Thanks man ~
Excellent. Thank you for this
high quality work! simple.
This is gold! Thank you!
thanks for this video, i will follow it thoroughly.
Excellent video with a lot of great info. Thank you so much! Please keep them coming!
thanks ~ you're welcome
So far I have enjoyed every video of yours that I have watched. I am waiting for the second part of the video on dirting a tank. Thanks!
Great information. Thanks
very good,thank you dennis
Fantastic content and organization. Subscribed and looking forward to more!
Thanks man~
Dennis, you rock! Agree with all, you know your stuff, this is the best algae advice for planted tanks on UA-cam. Look forward to see more of your videos. In my case the green dust algae you mentioned is more back in colour when on rocks, I assume it is the same - so I need to adjust lighting a bit. Thank you.
You're welcome; can try nerites snails & bristlenose plecos as well
thank you! Very well explained.
Thanks for the Informative video.
Another amazing and informative video. Thanks!
You're welcome ~
This video is so incredibly full of valuable information, it is unbelievable. It totally helped me controlling algae in my tank. Thank you Dennis!
In the middle of the video you say you are planning to make a separate vid about growing red plants. Would love to hear your insights on this! Thanks again!
Thanks man `
excellently explained
yep Dennis you rock dude... knowledgeable but never too complicated, lifesaver... recent subscriber
ha thanks man
for me circulation and proper pruning technique helped the most
sir, this video is pure gold.
How so? What exactly did you learn from this video? It’s not very informative
awesome video
Great video! Thanks Dennis! :)
Great video man! I love this kind of stuff.
Thanks Dave; love your recent small low tech scape with the overhanging large rock ~
Best planted tank videos on the internet
haa thanks man
One of the best videos I have seen about algae!
I have to add something though. There are other factors that can cause problems with algae. Take your water for instance:
- Where is it taken from?
-Is it processed by reverse osmosis and then re-mineralized or is it used together with tap water?
I found that tap water used either as a whole or in part can bring problems. Water suppliers add certain additives to the water to protect plumbing, such as Polyphosphate. Even in very small doses, they can react with nutrients such as trace elements and render them completely useless. The result is stagnating plant growth and a lot of algae.
Polyphospate cannot easily be traced, since it bypasses water drop tests because it is a polymerization of phosphoric acid derivatives. The water containing the Polyphosphates have to be cooked above 70°C for a few minutes and then the broken down phosphate can be detected if present.
Since I have found it in my tap water (1mg/liter), I use pure re-mineralized reverse-osmosis water and my plants are doing much better and the algae are disappearing!
yup, RO water removes guess work. Some folks with difficult tap water and no RO find no end to their problems.
Really helpful!
wow great video
Very usefull, thx : -) You should write a book on the biology of aquascaping tank !
Your videos are really helpful :) Short and informative!
Would you mind writing/ submitting a few articles for a magazine website?
U r a master. Thank you
Very interesting!! I learned alot from this video, I have a started my new planted Aquarium ... Having a few algae problems but it's weird it only grows on my anubias? Little green spots and it won't come off I tried rubbing it with my finger, very strange¿?¿
Thank you
Great information ;)
this is really helpful :)
Very basic rules to success growing pretty much any aquatic plant:
1) Have the proper equipment (wrgb light, co2, strong filtration, good substrate, fertilizers)
2) use fast growing, dense plant mass from the start and trim frequently to promote faster growth
3) Lights on for 8 hours, use a timer
4) 60-80% water change weekly
5) stock a few algae eaters (snails, fish etc)
Thank you plant bro!
My tank was a 30x30x30 tank which I woefully neglected after my initial attempts to grow utricularia graminifolia always failed. Any attempt I tried to adjust dosing/CO2/lighting up or down would inevitably lead to algae and yet utricularia graminifolia just refused to flourish in any of my tanks. So this tank was my last attempt and I eventually gave up on properly keeping a planted tank. I relegated it as a low tech shrimp tank with only a small hang on filter and about LED light dimmed to around 10W. The timer and/or plugs and/or me would occasionally cock up in some way, leading to days of no lighting or 24hr lighting. Or else, the filter would clog to a trickle for weeks, or the plug would loosen somehow so it wasn't running for many days before I found out after my tenant told me he saw mosquito larvae in my tank.
I only fed my shrimp occasionally when I remembered, never changed water, only topped up the water, and never dosed anything other than occasional guilt triggered sparse dosing of seachem excel and fluorish. My substrate was bare gravel about 2 inches thick. The plants were petite nanas, hornworts, some fissidens, very unhealthy mini pellia, and all sorts of algae including diatoms, cladophora, and BBA. I think I also had BGA.... It was so bad that I could hardly see anything in the tank. But despite this, my only fauna, cherry shrimp, were thriving. Their redness had faded to brown and very pale shades after generations of inbreeding. I didn't have any snails as they were eradicated from my last failed attempt with overboard excel dosing to get rid of algae when this tank was first set up.
Then came the interesting thing. I recently had more spare time, so I decided to do some intensive spot treatment of my algae with excel, however, I went overboard and added 5ml or more in total. Then I forgot about my tank again for some time (I can't remember how long, it could be weeks) When I eventually remmebered to look at my tank again. I found that almost all the algae had disappeared. There was only some diatoms around. However, all the plants except nana had died, and all the shrimp and snails had disappeared as well. No corpses O_o, so I must have forgotten about the tank for pretty long....
Feeling quite ecstatic at my new found tank visibility nevertheless, I decided to give utricularia graminifolia another go. I did a 80% water change and sucked out a lot of the organic detritus, got a teams of 10 otos (but 3 died), 20 bloody mary shrimp (I love C328), and some fast growing stem plants, hornworts, and utricularia graminifolia. I kept lighting at 10W 7hrs daily , but maintained regular daily dosing of 0.5ml seachem excel and flourish. Nothing very different from what I had been doing long ago when I was still quite vigilant with my upkeep actually, but this time it felt like my tank had become blessed by the ghosts of all the shrimp who died. The remaining algae are getting lesser and lesser all by itself, there is little if any organic detritus from decaying plants which I always experienced in the past, my utricularia graminifolia is starting to spread quite nicely, and water clarity is excellent.
After seeing your website and youtube videos this week, I feel I have the confidence to slowly scale up my current tank to a high tech tank with CO2 gas dosing, and ferts via dosing pump from taobao. Many thanks for the valuable info
Dennis - I love your vids. Very informative and great from a scientific point of view! A question for you: Do you find that the bluer spectrum of light encourages brown algae/diatom growth? And - I just installed a Finnex Planted Plus 24/7. I have to imagine leaving it on 24/7 mode will be too much light, as cool as that feature looks. I can control the Red, White, Blue, Green colors. Is there a spectrum setting you would recommend?
I don't see a correlation at all.... I prefer a stronger red spectrum selection myself, and some blues, and less green
Hi Dennis, can you do a video on glossostigma if possible? Thank you
thank you for this. you mentioned spores, so would it be advisable to use UV filters, like they do in marine tanks , to eliminate algal spores?
yes, but UV also strips the water of chelated iron, so from the fert dosing angle that's something to consider. It's effect isn't as strong as people think - badly run tanks would still get algae
good vid for newcome
once again another very informative and detailed video. i have more surface agitation than your tank, more movement per se but it does not break the water. is that too much movement you think?
Should not be unless you realize that you have to inject a tremendous amount of CO2 just to hit your target CO2 levels ?
Very good and easy to follow video thanks mate .from !oz! Land
thanks ! you're welcome~
Love ur vids bro
Thanks man~
Hey Dennis I was wondering if you had any tips on controlling hair algae
What about other factors; O2 vs CO2 ppm; also PH; temperature must play a role; also lighting spectrum? How do these factor? Very interesting.
Outstanding video! It is thorough and well thought out. Thanks a lot for putting this together.
Quick question, did you use dechlorinator on the tap water bottles in your experiment? I'm assuming you did.
I was wondering about this info too. I hope he answers you.
ha, what do you think...
I think you were thorough enough to not get tripped up by something like that...but it would be wrong of me to assume something that was not mentioned in the methods. So..yes you used dechlorinator.
I stickied this video on Aquascaping World's Algae subforum.
Hmm yeah, I skipped over many details to keep the vids short. But yeah I did use dechlorinated water ~ Thanks man
All true. Many fish in a tank? Means plants will not do well. You can't fight that. Few fish and proper light= thriving plants.
TOO MUCH light and fish?= Hair algae. The only way to fight that then is to grow algae resistant plants like Vals,Crypts,Java ferns,Rotala. Other plants are plagued..like Bacopa in high light. Ludwigia seems to be another. Mosses are first to die to hair algae.
I like what you said about the health of the plants define what you grow and what you keep in fish. You have to choose.
i would love to see your findings on small planted tanks and algae.
I don't think it applies any differently, except that smaller tanks are generally easier to manage (trimming, water changes etc) and they benefit from better gaseous exchange generally
i agree , But the Algae is out of controll.... in my case
There is more information on the website , you can check there for more information~
good video,very nice soundtrack to what was playing?
Thanks ~ It should be in the vid description
🙏🙏🙏
my aquarium with Iwagumi setup broke last week as a result of deteriorating silicone edges... I now move on with a new tank, still using the same rocks, but this time, I really practised Dennis's method now.
1. 60cm (60L,30W, 35H), Chihiros WRGB paired with Commander, Hailea 1/10HP Chiller, Timer-based solenoid CO2 injection (6 seconds 1 bubble)
2. Full black soil-based (Fluval Stratum)
3. Increased the plant mass of the tank to 70% (the back of the tank is fully covered, leaving the front with carpet Mini HC)
4. Dosing APT Complete 4 times per week (5ml each time)
Now the algae slowly kicking in as the tank's overall system is still yet to settle down, now all I can do is just keep WC to help my plants to fight for their survival against the algae. Hopefully, the plants would settle down and starts to absorb the excess nutrient in the water.
Your co2 injection rate may be low
@@2hrAquarist oh, then may I try adjusting it to 3 seconds 1 bubble?
@@derekw9358 watch your livestock and tune it up. My 60L tank uses about 1 bubble per second. However, different bubble counter have different bubble sizes, so its a very rough gauge
@@2hrAquarist oh.. Yaya I recalled some of your videos did mentioned that. Okay, I'll put that in my note and test it out.
Hi Dennis, what do think about using a sump on a planted aquarium? are sumps ok or should I just use a canister filter? great videos thank you!
Tom barr uses sumps
Hey, loved the video! I had a question about diatoms, since there are many conflicting observations about it. I setup my 7gal planted tank around 5 weeks ago, by the 4th week everything was growing great but i was using lights that were at a color temp of 10k and 15k so I added a 20w 6500k 2000 lumen Led to my setup, immediately i noticed a lot of pearling from all my plants and better growth, little did i know it was overkill, I noticed brown algae within 2 days on my plant leaves,substrate and rocks(it also seemed to be pearling on the substrate). I have switched over to a 7w led rather than that 20w led bulb and everything seems to be stable. The older leaves still have the brown stuff on them, will it go away itself or should i manually remove it, I am having a hard time finding otos so i dont think that is an option.
Various fish eat that; you can manually siphon the existing ones away, more water changes. It shouldn't be a persistent issue
Great video Dennis! Would you mind if I share this video?
sure, thanks for coming by ~
Hey Dennis, great video and information as always, I have a question I know you like to use dirt, when you use dirt why do you dose if the the dirt provides the nutrients your plants need? ive red the that dirt for example can provide enough iron up to 6 years, do you dose to increase plant rate growth to help fight algea? In my nano tank that I had dirted for 2 years I was able to grow all the plants with co2, with out ei method, but in my ada tank I had to dose to 6et the same result, so I was wondering why do you dose your planted tanks, I my opion if you start your new tank with good substrate ie dirt, and allow your scape to acclimatize to the conditions you provide and keep good husbentry you dont have to dose at all, thanks for time a d have a great weekend. Sincerely Jeremie
It depends on how wholesome the soil is ? Many soils can grow plants fine for a period of time; how long depends on the exact soil used, speed of growth, density of plant mass etc. In the short run, on a higher growth speed tank (i.e. CO2 injected), I find regular dosing gives better quality growth; deeper reds, better colors etc. There are other subtle nuances, such as plants preferring shoot up-take of potassium, while preferring root up-take of iron. There are many plants not rooted to the substrate to consider; Buceps, mosses, etc. Water column dosing covers all bases