Fue una de sus despedidas en los teatros que canto..... El publico aplaude y ovaciona a la Edita de ayer y de siempre que tanto nos dio a traves del tiempo... Y sino vean la despedida de La Callas en Saporo, Japon... El publico a La Callas de ayer y siempre que tambien tanto nos dio... Gracias Edita y gracias Maria por hacer arder nuestros corazones con su arte y su don de grandes cantantes y artistas. Que ambas descansen en la paz de divino corazon de Dios.😊
Love this casta diva is one of the best i ever heard, anna netrebko should learn from this performance, my favourite soprano is birgit nilsson, rest in peace Edita the world will miss you. Love from Sweden ❤️
@@arboretum1153 I love Gruberova and don't care much for Netrebko. Yet I'm still hoping that one day people will be able to compliment one singer without trashing another.
I saw her in Munich last year, singing Casta Diva only 10 meters apart from me, I sat in the front row. I can only say: Bravaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa !!!
If you close your eyes and just listen, she sounds just like an angel! I love that she is not letting her age discourage her or slow her down. Keep singing! Keep singing!!! ♥♫♪♥
In early 90s she said in an interview that she was not going to sing Norma ever and here she is after almost 2 decades. Callas with her best Norma is known to have had the best voice for Norma - that thick and deep voice which was referred to as often being ugly and big, and yes Caballe's version is beautiful and magical. All 3 are great and so very different.
Let me add that she is near 60 at the time of this performance. Edita not only has been able to preserve her voice this long, but she has even grown stronger. Brava, Edita!!!
Casta Diva!!Thank you Edita for everything you give us and the whole world. It was my fortune to have the same teacher in Vienna..and having you as a good friend ..God bless Chamber Singer Ruthilde Boesch. The Best! We love you..
Although I absolutely adore the Casta Diva of Maria Callas and Renate Tebaldi, Edita's version made me absolutely swoon with her beautiful coloratura and the high note you never hear the others sing. Brava Edita Gruberova!
John Snead Sai per quale ragione è morta da anni la vera arte lirica?! Perché c’è pubblico ignorante come te. 65 anni fa era assurdo di pensare 💭 che Norma ha 60 anni come è in questo caso e che qualcuno in quest’epoca avrà l’idea ‘geniale’ di lasciare la bisnonna della Norma con la sua voce vecchia, orrenda di interpretare un ruolo scritto per la voce della sua nipotina… O tempora i mores il vecchio
@@bodiloto Bene, grazie per la risposta. Ma l'unico "pubblico ignorante: ecco te! Potresti essere italiano e credere che SOLO gli italiani eseguano correttamente l'opera. La mia opinione, tuttavia, è che scelgo di commentare indipendentemente dalle macchinazioni di età, altezza, peso, colore della pelle, ecc., Su ciò che percepisco i meriti del cantante sono in qualsiasi pezzo!!! A proposito, perché la tua mente sempliciste ha avuto nove anni per rispondere al mio particolare commento? Ogni singolo cantante d'opera non è mai in grado di cantare tutta l'opera con tono, tono o precisione perfetti per tutto il tempo. Sembri solo che solo le tue opinioni e commenti sull'opera siano validi. Forse hai bisogno di uscire e fare una lunga passeggiata sotto il sole italiano per illuminare la tua indole eccessivamente negativa! Avere una giornata fantastica!!! 😀
@@johnsnead2413 Grazie di cuore del tuo bellissimo monologo pieno del buon senso e una immaginazione 💭 direi infinita. Molto simpatico il tuo commento ma dimmi cosa c’entra il tuo pensier profondo con la vera arte lirica?! Direi proprio niente. La Callas e La Tebaldi erano due dee, non sapevi prima questo fatto?!… Come puoi mettere una vecchia gatta 🐈⬛ la Gruberova accanto alle due leonesse 🐅 La Callas e La Tebaldi ?!… Caro giovane amico, nella Natura questo errore non succede mai… Saluti cordiali il vecchio PS Da anni mi chiedevo : - Ma per quale ragione durante gli ultimi anni mori la vera arte lirica?! Grazie ai ragazzini come te finalmente credo che ho trovato la risposta giusta. Grazie 🙏 di cuore 💖! il vecchio
gran voz, delicada y pulcrisima interpretacion, me gusta mucho su afinacion y voz llena de sobretonos, robusta, clara y delicada. bellisima interpretacion.
1. I am not a singer but only one of the public who has seen live Edita Gruberova many, many times and every time it was a big success. She has thousands of fans here in Germany and also in Vienna, Barcelona, in Zurich and many other cities who hope that she will retire as late as possible. There are so many young singers whom I don't like at all: they should retire not the Gruberova!
8. I am looking forward to it and like me thousands of her fans in Germany, Vienna, Zürich, Barcelona and other cities. At 66 she has still a beautiful voice that many singers, much younger than her, don't have at all. I think that the vast majority of the public who are not singers share my points of view.
Сегодня, 18 октября 2021 года наткнулся на это видео. Очень, очень впечатлила Норма Груберовой! Никто сейчас так не поёт, сколько Норм не слушал.( Хотелось бы всю оперу с её участием послушать.) СВЕТЛАЯ ЕЙ ПАМЯТЬ!((
Η ΠΙΟ ΥΠΕΡΟΧΗ, Η ΠΙΟ ΘΕΙΚΗ ΕΡΜΗΝΕΙΑ ΤΗΣ CASTA DIVA, ΠΟΥ ΑΚΟΥΣΤΗΚΕ ΠΟΤΕ ΣΤΟΝ ΚΟΣΜΟ ΑΥΤΟ......ΑΥΤΗ !!!!!! ΤΗΣ EDITA GRUBEROVA ΕΥΓΕ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What a voice! Love the dramatic she puts into it! Cecilia Bartoli which I also like gives an other impression of that song... Edita is one among millions... And Maria Callas interpretation in lower tones is also lovely... I am not that much into operah but when I do, I know my chicks...
Casta Diva che inargenti Queste sacre antiche piante, A noi volgi il bel sembiante Senza nube e senza vel. Tempra tu de' cori ardenti, Tempra ancor lo zelo audace, Spargi in terra quella pace Che regnar tu fai nel ciel.
Pleins d'émotions dans cette interprétation de Madame Gruberova,j'en ai pleuré à la fin...lorsqu’elle reprend son souffle et qu'une note en sort comme ça sans qu'elle l'ai voulue.
Herzlichen Dank für das Video. Ich war gestern (17.1.2009) in München und konnte von bestem Platz die unglaubliche Darbietung verfolgen. Die Schönheit des Gesangs rührten mich zu Tränen.- Thank you for posting this video; I've been to munich yesterday to see this opera and was so impressed, that tears ran from my eyes.
I saw her live in Norma several times and I liked her very much. She had endless ovations from all the public. I consider it a fortune that she sings Casta diva because before I never listened to this aria because I did not like so much the voices and the interpretations of the other singers.
@Lederius18 i agree with you. i am not a musical expert and therefore as a profane i listen to all casta diva videos (callas, sutherland, caballe, sills, fleming, ecc.) and can say that the interpretation of casta diva that most pleases my soul and my ears is that of gruberova followed by that of sarah poncell. with the gruberova i thought there is finally a casta diva sung with subtle delicate voice with a very beautiful timbre and not with dark and too heavy voices that i dislike completely.
2) and find Gruberova's interpretation of this aria wonderful, the best one for us. I read that Giuditta Pasta was not able to sing Casta Diva in the original key written by Bellini and that he had to lower it an entire tone. Gruberova sings it in the original key and in my opinion it is not true that her interpretation is not dramatic: I find it dramatic but also beautiful as I already wrote. The other interpretations are for me only dramatic but unplesant for my ears. Greetings
Very nice ,if the Callas or the Caballes did not exist or were invented ,after those 2 is very difficult to give a proper judgement to anybody talent.Gruberova does NOT disgrace herself in this aria ,but it is not for her to sing this role,her light voice does not bring out the necessary dramatic effects required in this masterpiece .The Opera cannot be shelved due to lack of singers for the role,so we take the second or third best ,but as usual for my personal pleasure i shall have to go back in time . Saluti Gino
Thankfully nor Callas nor Caballé sang this aria in their 60s. Callas had to quit a performance of Norma in her 40s and Caballé was flat most of the times in her 40s as well. Very often the past seems greener, but is it really?
utahdan231 well not really.........she had one of the most beautiful voice in operatic history but its just that voice.shes cold, emotionless and had very bad diction
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia you have no clue what good singing sounds like. I am sad for you. If you don't understand the quality of tone here, then you haven't heard many operas in-persoj in halls. Gruberova is a master of technique, her tone is more exciting and travels far better than most of her contemporaries today. Let's see modern sopranos hold a career that long :/ not likely
Congratulations! If the ensemble can do it in the same way like Saturday, they'll put a spell on you - from the moment, Casta Diva will start till the end. - My husband, not a real fan, asked in the end: "Is it really finished? I could hear some more!" Best wishes!
Callas with thick and deep voice and gruberova with her light and lovely voice
Both are my fav... they give me goosebumps..
Fue una de sus despedidas en los teatros que canto..... El publico aplaude y ovaciona a la Edita de ayer y de siempre que tanto nos dio a traves del tiempo... Y sino vean la despedida de La Callas en Saporo, Japon... El publico a La Callas de ayer y siempre que tambien tanto nos dio... Gracias Edita y gracias Maria por hacer arder nuestros corazones con su arte y su don de grandes cantantes y artistas. Que ambas descansen en la paz de divino corazon de Dios.😊
Love this casta diva is one of the best i ever heard, anna netrebko should learn from this performance, my favourite soprano is birgit nilsson, rest in peace Edita the world will miss you. Love from Sweden ❤️
Anna netrebko should have stopped singing many years ago.
@@arboretum1153 I love Gruberova and don't care much for Netrebko. Yet I'm still hoping that one day people will be able to compliment one singer without trashing another.
Fantastic!!!!! Amazing and magic, grandiose Edita Gruberova!!!! Bravo 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Oh I can't believe this was at her 60s. She's indeed the pride of Slovakia. Crystal clear voice as always..
Welch ein Stimme!
R.I.P liebe Edita Gruberova, Sie bleiben unvergessen.
I saw her in Munich last year, singing Casta Diva only 10 meters apart from me, I sat in the front row. I can only say:
Bravaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa !!!
Невероятный голос!! Покойся с миром,выдающаяся Эдита Груберова,и пусть твой небесный голос звучит на Небесах!! Светлая память...
If you close your eyes and just listen, she sounds just like an angel! I love that she is not letting her age discourage her or slow her down. Keep singing! Keep singing!!! ♥♫♪♥
Yes, I do believe in Yeti as well...
@@artdanks you sound horrible
Rachel Williams Keppner
Se gli angeli hanno tali voci e tale fisico, mi immagino il resto del Paradiso…
Allora preferisco l’Inferno .
il vecchio
@@bodiloto Ma che commento è?....
La perfección absoluta
it´s divine, i love her voice and technique so much
She's my favourite soprano, thank you for posting! Her voice is the most beautiful I've herad.
La Grandiosa! Gran Diosa !
A me pare solo diosa?
@@alexeyizmirliev64
Io direi odiosa …
Saluti cordiali
il vecchio
PS
Poka .
starik
In early 90s she said in an interview that she was not going to sing Norma ever and here she is after almost 2 decades. Callas with her best Norma is known to have had the best voice for Norma - that thick and deep voice which was referred to as often being ugly and big, and yes Caballe's version is beautiful and magical. All 3 are great and so very different.
Ich war in der Premiere in München. Auch in der Wiener Staatsoper, konzertant. Unvergessen, nicht nur als Norma. Ruhe in Frieden!
Has llenado de belleza este mundo. Descansa en paz
6:14 is my favorite part! The note that she expressed so clearly and so beautifully is heavenly!!!! She is an awesome opera singer!!!!
,,,very proud of her....that Diva of world opera s stage...this great daughter of Slovak nation...!
Regardless of which great soprano signs this, it's one of the great arias of all time. Spectacular work of composition.
It was heart melting. Beautiful!!!
She is absolutely stunning!!!
Maravillosa Ópera !!!!!
Wonderful! I am proud of her She was born here in Slovakia....
,Светлая память прекрасной певице!
Bravissima Gruberova mi ricordo al Comunale di Bologna quanti applausi. Sei una grande !!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ 7:50
Let me add that she is near 60 at the time of this performance. Edita not only has been able to preserve her voice this long, but she has even grown stronger. Brava, Edita!!!
She clearly does not have the breathing range for this cavatina, the age is definitely one of the reasons she doesn't master this piece.
Una splendida interpretazione
Just SUPERB! THANK YOU MADAM!
The best Costa Diva
Jo també vaig plorar... Bellini! Quin geni! La Gruberova, quin àngel! GRÀCIES!!!
Casta Diva!!Thank you Edita for everything you give us and the whole world. It was my fortune to have the same teacher in Vienna..and having you as a good friend ..God bless Chamber Singer Ruthilde Boesch. The Best! We love you..
Although I absolutely adore the Casta Diva of Maria Callas and Renate Tebaldi, Edita's version made me absolutely swoon with her beautiful coloratura and the high note you never hear the others sing. Brava Edita Gruberova!
John Snead
Sai per quale ragione è morta da anni la vera arte lirica?!
Perché c’è pubblico ignorante come te.
65 anni fa era assurdo di pensare 💭 che Norma ha 60 anni come è in questo caso e che qualcuno in quest’epoca avrà l’idea ‘geniale’ di lasciare la bisnonna della Norma con la sua voce vecchia, orrenda di interpretare un ruolo scritto per la voce della sua nipotina…
O tempora i mores
il vecchio
@@bodiloto Bene, grazie per la risposta. Ma l'unico "pubblico ignorante: ecco te! Potresti essere italiano e credere che SOLO gli italiani eseguano correttamente l'opera. La mia opinione, tuttavia, è che scelgo di commentare indipendentemente dalle macchinazioni di età, altezza, peso, colore della pelle, ecc., Su ciò che percepisco i meriti del cantante sono in qualsiasi pezzo!!! A proposito, perché la tua mente sempliciste ha avuto nove anni per rispondere al mio particolare commento? Ogni singolo cantante d'opera non è mai in grado di cantare tutta l'opera con tono, tono o precisione perfetti per tutto il tempo. Sembri solo che solo le tue opinioni e commenti sull'opera siano validi. Forse hai bisogno di uscire e fare una lunga passeggiata sotto il sole italiano per illuminare la tua indole eccessivamente negativa! Avere una giornata fantastica!!!
😀
@@johnsnead2413
Grazie di cuore del tuo bellissimo monologo pieno del buon senso e una immaginazione 💭 direi infinita.
Molto simpatico il tuo commento ma dimmi cosa c’entra il tuo pensier profondo con la vera arte lirica?!
Direi proprio niente.
La Callas e La Tebaldi erano due dee, non sapevi prima questo fatto?!…
Come puoi mettere una vecchia gatta 🐈⬛ la Gruberova accanto alle due leonesse 🐅 La Callas e La Tebaldi ?!…
Caro giovane amico, nella Natura questo errore non succede mai…
Saluti cordiali
il vecchio
PS
Da anni mi chiedevo :
- Ma per quale ragione durante gli ultimi anni mori la vera arte lirica?!
Grazie ai ragazzini come te finalmente credo che ho trovato la risposta giusta.
Grazie 🙏 di cuore 💖!
il vecchio
@@bodiloto Adoro le tue risposte!♥️
@@bodiloto Ma che cacchius di arroganza è questa?....
Eine unglaubliche Leistung ... Ich sah die Oper mit ihr in der Hauptrolle in München. Ihre Interpretation rührte mich zu Tränen.
You are fantastic Madame👏👏👏❤
Люблю.
gran voz, delicada y pulcrisima interpretacion,
me gusta mucho su afinacion y voz llena de sobretonos, robusta, clara y delicada.
bellisima interpretacion.
M A R A V I L L O S A!!!!! INTERPRETACION Y VOZ!!!! GRACIAS EDITA, DESDE MEXICO!
io voi giovani vi capisco poco.
mi fate spesso paura con i vostri commenti veramente assurdi e poco professionali .
amen
il vecchio
Superb. She gets better and better as the aria proceeds.
fantastique!
simplemente Brillante!
ahahahahahahahahah !
questa era bellissima !
ahahahahahahahahah !
la voce più ''Brillante'' fra le bisnonne !
ahahahahahahahahah !
Meravigliosa Edita
Царствия Небесного!
1.
I am not a singer but only one of the public who has seen live Edita Gruberova many, many times and every time it was a big success. She has thousands of fans here in Germany and also in Vienna, Barcelona, in Zurich and many other cities who hope that she will retire as late as possible. There are so many young singers whom I don't like at all:
they should retire not the Gruberova!
8.
I am looking forward to it and like me thousands of her fans in Germany, Vienna, Zürich, Barcelona and other cities. At 66 she has still a beautiful voice that many singers, much younger than her, don't have at all. I think that the vast majority of the public who are not singers share my points of view.
I think this is a masterpiece, she's really good!
Fantastiske Edita !!!!!
Любимая Норма.Браво !!!
Сегодня, 18 октября 2021 года наткнулся на это видео.
Очень, очень впечатлила Норма Груберовой! Никто сейчас так не поёт, сколько Норм не слушал.( Хотелось бы всю оперу с её участием послушать.)
СВЕТЛАЯ ЕЙ ПАМЯТЬ!((
This is perfect.
Amazing! ❤️
Η ΠΙΟ ΥΠΕΡΟΧΗ, Η ΠΙΟ ΘΕΙΚΗ ΕΡΜΗΝΕΙΑ ΤΗΣ CASTA DIVA, ΠΟΥ ΑΚΟΥΣΤΗΚΕ ΠΟΤΕ ΣΤΟΝ ΚΟΣΜΟ ΑΥΤΟ......ΑΥΤΗ !!!!!! ΤΗΣ EDITA GRUBEROVA ΕΥΓΕ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Silky beautiful voice.
excellent!! what a clear voice!!!
I'll never forget her voice and performances.
What a voice! Love the dramatic she puts into it! Cecilia Bartoli which I also like gives an other impression of that song... Edita is one among millions... And Maria Callas interpretation in lower tones is also lovely... I am not that much into operah but when I do, I know my chicks...
Woooow
Sublime
I saw her live in Munich!!!
She is awesome!!!!!!
Какая потрясающая работа🥲
Totalmente de acuerdo. La mejor de todos los tiempos!!!
love Gruberova... she is a force to never be reckoned with.
perfect
Superbe
Yesterday I saw in TV the complete opera and Gruberova was amazing....thanls for posting...
Bravo Maestro Bellini .Bravo Edita Gruberova
Как проникновенно! Просто божественно поет!
Interpretacion muy personal. Las facultades de Edita son extraordinarias. Magnifica
wow wow wow ...... amazing
UNA DELICIA ESCUCHAR SU VERSION
Чудо!!!
волшебство
''volshebstvo ''?
ahahahahahahah !
Rip 😓😓😓😓
Saw this overwhelming performance last week in Munich. An impressing experience.
Bravo Bravíssimo
It takes my breath away !
Casta Diva che inargenti
Queste sacre antiche piante,
A noi volgi il bel sembiante
Senza nube e senza vel.
Tempra tu de' cori ardenti,
Tempra ancor lo zelo audace,
Spargi in terra quella pace
Che regnar tu fai nel ciel.
Lovely light tones. A different take than Sutherland or Callas. Bless her for her gifts to us.
So sad she has left this world now at 74.
Una sirena continua..."Casta Fissa ".
saw her in Munich ... epic !
It’s wonderful. I love her voice!
Pleins d'émotions dans cette interprétation de Madame Gruberova,j'en ai pleuré à la fin...lorsqu’elle reprend son souffle et qu'une note en sort comme ça sans qu'elle l'ai voulue.
Herzlichen Dank für das Video. Ich war gestern (17.1.2009) in München und konnte von bestem Platz die unglaubliche Darbietung verfolgen. Die Schönheit des Gesangs rührten mich zu Tränen.-
Thank you for posting this video; I've been to munich yesterday to see this opera and was so impressed, that tears ran from my eyes.
Después de María Callas, esta interpretación es la más hermosa que he escuchado
Está sorda o es imbécil.
I saw her live in Norma several times and I liked her very much. She had endless ovations from all the public.
I consider it a fortune that she sings Casta diva because before I never listened to this aria because I did not like so much the voices and the interpretations of the other singers.
Très beau
I absolutely love the setting
@Lederius18
i agree with you. i am not a musical expert and therefore as a profane i listen to all casta diva videos (callas, sutherland, caballe, sills, fleming, ecc.) and can say that the interpretation of casta diva that most pleases my soul and my ears is that of gruberova followed by that of sarah poncell. with the gruberova i thought there is finally a casta diva sung with subtle delicate voice with a very beautiful timbre and not with dark and too heavy voices that i dislike completely.
2) and find Gruberova's interpretation of this aria wonderful, the best one for us. I read that Giuditta Pasta was not able to sing Casta Diva in the original key written by Bellini and that he had to lower it an entire tone.
Gruberova sings it in the original key and in my opinion it is not true that her interpretation is not dramatic: I find it dramatic but also beautiful as I already wrote. The other interpretations are for me only dramatic but unplesant for my ears.
Greetings
nn capisci niente dell'arte lirica,è un fatto.
are you sure this is the best???
ua-cam.com/video/RRiNdIaOKPY/v-deo.html
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia And totally wrong opera to touch.
Mamma mia EDITA un mostro di bravura
Very nice ,if the Callas or the Caballes did not exist or were invented ,after those 2 is very difficult to give a proper judgement to anybody talent.Gruberova does NOT disgrace herself in this aria ,but it is not for her to sing this role,her light voice does not bring out the necessary dramatic effects required in this masterpiece .The Opera cannot be shelved due to lack of singers for the role,so we take the second or third best ,but as usual for my personal pleasure i shall have to go back in time . Saluti Gino
Maddalena Arena You forgot about Joan Sutherland? Nobody was better than her.
Thankfully nor Callas nor Caballé sang this aria in their 60s. Callas had to quit a performance of Norma in her 40s and Caballé was flat most of the times in her 40s as well. Very often the past seems greener, but is it really?
Never mind you forgot Sutherland. I wish I could too.
utahdan231 well not really.........she had one of the most beautiful voice in operatic history but its just that voice.shes cold, emotionless and had very bad diction
utahdan231 just saying my thoughts....im not asking for a fight.peace
Great job!
this gives me chills all over... my god. *tear*
Its so beautiful
thank you for posting....
simplemente única perfecta inigualable
She is great!
Brava bella scena
Love this woman!! BRAVA!!
Divina gruverova.
incredible singing.
@Barone Vitellio Scarpia you have no clue what good singing sounds like. I am sad for you.
If you don't understand the quality of tone here, then you haven't heard many operas in-persoj in halls. Gruberova is a master of technique, her tone is more exciting and travels far better than most of her contemporaries today. Let's see modern sopranos hold a career that long :/ not likely
Superbe !
Congratulations! If the ensemble can do it in the same way like Saturday, they'll put a spell on you - from the moment, Casta Diva will start till the end. - My husband, not a real fan, asked in the end: "Is it really finished? I could hear some more!" Best wishes!