TELL these WOMEN THIS IS A DEMOCRACY NOT THEIR LITTLE COMPANY to Keep Secrets.. SHAMEFULL. THEY ARE HOPELESS. Are We SUPPOSED to FEEL SAFE??? With THEM IN CHARGE?? NO
A question is asked, 3 people whisper together for a few seconds and then dodge the question or refuse to answer.... "One of the penalties of refusing to participate in politics is that you end up being governed by your inferiors" How true Plato.
as true as that is, these people are also held accountable for people out of their direct control. i agree with you, but there are inefficiencies below them which they aren't and can't be in control of.
I admire your patience and your persistance, especially with that quite hostile female in blue who had the gall, or ignorance to respond to one of your questions, as to why she did not have this or that information with: "because I dont". She must be related to the equally hostile female chair who actually "reprimanded" you, for asking questions. While they seem to all come from the departments of "Passing the Buck", they also seem to lack manners and intelligence. Here, among the voters we are happy that we now have some intelligent and genuinely interested in the people's concern senators, even if you have to beat your heads against some stone walls. Thank you for your work.
Totally agree. Taxpayers paying obnoxious salaries to ignorant people who have no idea what they are doing. Doesn't want to get into anything because she hasn't a clue about what she is suppose to do.
So in 2001 world governments introduced "temporary" draconian anti terror laws.... Fast forward you are now the terrorist, buckle up if you question the narratives
In many professional services the dates of "action completed" are added to a master sheet, or ticked and dated as they occur. It's then easy to see where things stand, but also where bottlenecks occur.
That would assume that they want to be held accountable for good administration practices, by not doing so it’s somebody else’s problem, classic passing the buck if something goes wrong.
They aren't willing to investigate or clearly relay information on anything. "I Can't talk about it, we are working on it, we will speak to you in a closed setting and we will get back to you on that" is no more than a disingenuous way of saying WE AREN'T GOING TO TELL YOU. COPY CATTING THE U.S.A. three letter agency replies to investigative committees.
@@jamesdeegan7365 ah but there is a remnant of that empire floundering around the top eschelon ..where they still believe their in charge and they still run the show ..mearly because a lot of Australian's are still asleep ..their minds have been psopsed so they are unaware..how else could a militant remnant survive against 8. Billion people and be so cocksure of themselves ..with a wee help from all those traitors at Mainstreammedia. .churning out lies and fears ..wait for their next moves when they will even throw human- projectiles in an attempt to deflect 5heir lies .!!!
Well Mz bureaucrat is typical, not answering questions, hiding behind bureaucratic rubbish. Sack the lot and limit employment to 10 years so they dont get entrenched and hide in politics , just acturally do some work, make decisions and stop wasting our money. (We work effectively 🤣 with in the time frame , total rubbish) sack them
Thank you Senator Patterson. I feel your frustration in having to go down to such basic functionality to reveal a departments chronic dysfunctionality. Indeed this department needs a major overhaul. It appears unable to answer the most basic of questions. I’m sorry you have to waste such an inordinate amount of time to reveal such chronic ineptness.
He knows how to uncover inefficiency by bureaucrats. How do they continue to retain their jobs? Protected species, taking money under false pretences. This Senator does his job like one would expect.
Clueless. Totally incompetent. $20 mill on WHAT?? What’s the point of these ignorant staffers, and how did they get into this bloody inquiry? DISGRACEFUL 😳😳😳😳😳
They were clearly lying about not being able to access the data from there. We just spent years working from home and the government departments absolutely relished that opportunity so they were all capable of accessing their work data from anywhere. And who travels anywhere important without their work laptop?
Oooh isn't Chigey a bristly and defensive little character?! Sr. Patterson has been amazing in this interview. That female chair used her 'soft' voice to give a hardline order and her own personally biased assessment of Sr. Patterson's very calm approach, as him needing to 'calm down'. Classic gaslighting tactic. I know coz I am a woman and she is using her fake 'soft' voice as a pretence of fairness, but fair... it is not!
Out of their depth. Useless, like an ashtray on a motor bike. No results, what the fark are we paying them for. No wonder this country is in such a mess. There are smarter people on the tools than in our parliament. They are told what to think and do.
OK, so there are 25 million Australians. How many Public Servants do each of us have? I want some of them to join Rugby League teams. Their 'flick passes' are awe inspiring.
No wonder this country is going backwards, pure And simple incompetence in the public service, private sector would not accept this level of incompetence
This really is fun to watch.Men have been managing these types of management discussion since we were in tribal enclaves and ultimately know mistakes cost lives.Women on the other hand are new at this arrangement and are learning the ropes because a couple couple of decades at these levels don't give generational experience. I'm not suggesting this can't happen it will but natural instincts to develop this might take centuries. Don't know if humans have that time for them to learn.
China's looking at this and rubbing their hands together. Easy pickings. low hanging fruit, fiddling while Rome is burning, a walk over etc. We need a much more substantial and serious and coordinated approach to these matters. We cannot be seen to be sitting on our hands. Bogged down by beaucracy.
We have more women in parliament to even the numbers, but not because they are smarter. Most have never had their hands dirtied by hard manual work. Just looking for cushy job with perks.
Great job Senator. Why are we paying huge money to these important agencies? THESE PEOPLE IN FRONT ROW SHOULD ALL BE SACKED. TOTAL INCOMPETENCE. Where do they get off not answering questions about their activities or LACK there of.
Question? now! why am I not getting her kind of salary? because i can definitely assure you senator I can also fail EQUALY as she and I am only on stuff all salary.
F*** how hard would that be, what a bloody joke 17.8m how us get this outrages cost and time talking should be so easy Max two weeks Max cost $ 200K What a discusting cost, can we have a forensic Audit on this cost.
It must be very frustrating for you to ask proper and significant questions to senior staff in this department and not receive any forth coming answers. Does the way in which our departmental systems operate cause the public service to be scared of answering these questions to the best of their ability/ knowledge and as a consequence “put up the shutters” so their relevant Minister doesn’t ridicule them in public? If this is the case it is no wonder we waste time and therefore money going through this wasted activity. Surely we must have Australians who can ‘operate’ in this environment effectively.
TELL these WOMEN THIS IS A DEMOCRACY NOT THEIR LITTLE COMPANY to Keep Secrets.. SHAMEFULL. THEY ARE HOPELESS. Are We SUPPOSED to FEEL SAFE??? With THEM IN CHARGE?? NO
It's relevant.....The taxpayer pays the wages of these slack beurocrats.
Thank you Senator for the grill.
If these oxygen thief's were in a private business they would have filed for bankruptcy a long time ago.
And in a very real way we are bankrupt on a lot of government fronts
Well done Senator 👏 surely highlights the the incompetence protecting our security against terrorism at any level .
These bureaucrats sound like the type that would advise a first world nation to leave weapons behind to arm a terrorist organisation to attack Iran
A question is asked, 3 people whisper together for a few seconds and then dodge the question or refuse to answer....
"One of the penalties of refusing to participate in politics is that you end up being governed by your inferiors" How true Plato.
Great work Senator James Paterson
Make these lame public servant clowns accountable
Brilliant. Well done Senator. These overpaid bureaucrats are completely useless. They go to water as soon as they pressed.
These public servants are a waste of taxpayer money.
Sack the lot of them.
Honestly this was like watching a skit on the comedy company....absolutely gold...this needs to go viral...
Yes, just like Yes, Minster, who is getting.
I'm liking this guy. He ties these public service stooges in knots. They should be hosting Tupperware parties.
Why tarnish a product like Tupperware with likes of these parasites.
Nah they’d fail that
Terrorist, we are too busy trying to jail Aussie Cossack
The attempts to dodge questioning displays an attitude of wilful disregard to the responsibilities of their positions.
You mean wilful disrespect for the elected reps and all of us.
as true as that is, these people are also held accountable for people out of their direct control. i agree with you, but there are inefficiencies below them which they aren't and can't be in control of.
All these women doing these useless jobs and probably getting paid more than me, someone who works hard labor. What a scam on hard working men...
I admire your patience and your persistance, especially with that quite hostile female in blue who had the gall, or ignorance to respond to one of your questions, as to why she did not have this or that information with: "because I dont". She must be related to the equally hostile female chair who actually "reprimanded" you, for asking questions. While they seem to all come from the departments of "Passing the Buck", they also seem to lack manners and intelligence.
Here, among the voters we are happy that we now have some intelligent and genuinely interested in the people's concern senators, even if you have to beat your heads against some stone walls. Thank you for your work.
Totally agree. Taxpayers paying obnoxious salaries to ignorant people who have no idea what they are doing. Doesn't want to get into anything because she hasn't a clue about what she is suppose to do.
Shocking. Dangerous. Those staff should be removed and prosecuted, especially the main speaker on the panel .
So in 2001 world governments introduced "temporary" draconian anti terror laws....
Fast forward you are now the terrorist, buckle up if you question the narratives
I am glad, Senator, that you are bringing these ppl into account. Thanks for your job.
Thank you senator for your service. Please keep pushing for the people
What a waste of space and taxpayers money are these worthless evaders of truth .
And we pay a fortune for these Public Servants to supposedly do their jobs. Surely their jobs is not to protect useless governments for scrutiny.
The Senator is the epitome of calm , Just Amazing! Cool as a cucumber 🥒
In many professional services the dates of "action completed" are added to a master sheet, or ticked and dated as they occur. It's then easy to see where things stand, but also where bottlenecks occur.
That would assume that they want to be held accountable for good administration practices, by not doing so it’s somebody else’s problem, classic passing the buck if something goes wrong.
It all seems to be a catch 22 just going around in circles & nothing is getting done.
Its all about the art of ducking and weaving the questions and avoiding accountability...
Never in my life have I seen a system so corrupt and negligence at the top echelon of governance
I have, they called it "Rome" they obviously didn't stay a super power, who would of thought
Thats why dummies get appointed to these positions.
They aren't willing to investigate or clearly relay information on anything.
"I Can't talk about it, we are working on it, we will speak to you in a closed setting and we will get back to you on that" is no more than a disingenuous way of saying WE AREN'T GOING TO TELL YOU.
COPY CATTING THE U.S.A. three letter agency replies to investigative committees.
@@jamesdeegan7365 ah but there is a remnant of that empire floundering around the top eschelon ..where they still believe their in charge and they still run the show ..mearly because a lot of Australian's are still asleep ..their minds have been psopsed so they are unaware..how else could a militant remnant survive against 8. Billion people and be so cocksure of themselves ..with a wee help from all those traitors at Mainstreammedia. .churning out lies and fears ..wait for their next moves when they will even throw human- projectiles in an attempt to deflect 5heir lies .!!!
Well Mz bureaucrat is typical, not answering questions, hiding behind bureaucratic rubbish. Sack the lot and limit employment to 10 years so they dont get entrenched and hide in politics , just acturally do some work, make decisions and stop wasting our money. (We work effectively 🤣 with in the time frame , total rubbish) sack them
See corruption again. And our money wasted.
Thank you Senator Patterson. I feel your frustration in having to go down to such basic functionality to reveal a departments chronic dysfunctionality. Indeed this department needs a major overhaul. It appears unable to answer the most basic of questions. I’m sorry you have to waste such an inordinate amount of time to reveal such chronic ineptness.
He knows how to uncover inefficiency by bureaucrats. How do they continue to retain their jobs? Protected species, taking money under false pretences. This Senator does his job like one would expect.
Clueless. Totally incompetent. $20 mill on WHAT?? What’s the point of these ignorant staffers, and how did they get into this bloody inquiry? DISGRACEFUL 😳😳😳😳😳
They were clearly lying about not being able to access the data from there. We just spent years working from home and the government departments absolutely relished that opportunity so they were all capable of accessing their work data from anywhere. And who travels anywhere important without their work laptop?
Oooh isn't Chigey a bristly and defensive little character?! Sr. Patterson has been amazing in this interview. That female chair used her 'soft' voice to give a hardline order and her own personally biased assessment of Sr. Patterson's very calm approach, as him needing to 'calm down'. Classic gaslighting tactic. I know coz I am a woman and she is using her fake 'soft' voice as a pretence of fairness, but fair... it is not!
Tax oayer funded bureaucracy have zero competence in any field and are all on massive wages
After watching these public servants I am now quite alarmed.
Send the whole lot of them to jail to reconsider their answer, as they are in front of a governmental inquiry.
It is appropriate, these people need to be dismissed.
Please keep up the good work to show how inept some these public servants are.
Out of their depth. Useless, like an ashtray on a motor bike. No results, what the fark are we paying them for. No wonder this country is in such a mess. There are smarter people on the tools than in our parliament. They are told what to think and do.
Wow, do these bureaucrats get paid for this🤨
Stakeholders?🤔
Stakeholder groups? 🤔
UN/WEF.
OK, so there are 25 million Australians. How many Public Servants do each of us have? I want some of them to join Rugby League teams. Their 'flick passes' are awe inspiring.
WHAT A JOKE😂😂😂CLOSE ALL THESE AGENCIES
DOWN😮😮😮
Are these people real. Do they all go to a special school where they learn how not to answer a question and just look incompetent.
No wonder this country is going backwards, pure
And simple incompetence in the public service, private sector would not accept this level of incompetence
What are we paying these bloody corrupt criminals for they know nothing and how much a year are they on
They are taking money under false pretences. Not doing their jobs.
Albo has done more damage than any terroist
Sack the lot of them and hire adults
Do they realize i can hear the whispering? Cheers senator job well done
Obviously these people work for probably appointed by Labor
So is treason included in this
This really is fun to watch.Men have been managing these types of management discussion since we were in tribal enclaves and ultimately know mistakes cost lives.Women on the other hand are new at this arrangement and are learning the ropes because a couple couple of decades at these levels don't give generational experience. I'm not suggesting this can't happen it will but natural instincts to develop this might take centuries. Don't know if humans have that time for them to learn.
They give the impression they don't know what they are doing and when alsimas???
18:54 Boss is clearly silencing subordinate. When challenged over this silencing, the Senator is then reprimanded for being observant.
China's looking at this and rubbing their hands together. Easy pickings. low hanging fruit, fiddling while Rome is burning, a walk over etc. We need a much more substantial and serious and coordinated approach to these matters. We cannot be seen to be sitting on our hands. Bogged down by beaucracy.
It seems like no one can answer any questions, but can definitely take your millions for something thay can't talk about or even do anything for .
The answer is no, labour has a lack of interest. Actions speak louder than words.
Australia today, US tomorrow. This is liberal swamp at its finest!
Was that $19000000000 for what?
Thankyou senator
No tell no money.
The govt doesnt like competition. Terrorism is their job.
one look at these people says it all
Oh no... the man spoke without permission 😂😂😂
Why is not the best person in charge...
Men in Government zero debit in 1975
Women in Government near 1 trillion debit.2023.???
We have more women in parliament to even the numbers, but not because they are smarter. Most have never had their hands dirtied by hard manual work. Just looking for cushy job with perks.
All who cannot protect the people, get out. Get a different job, out of the government..
Why are there so many women in these positions
They are quite clearly out of their depth.
Look out Senator, you will be on some kind of list for making them do their job.
I think we need some "gender affirming care".
Well.... I guess on the bright side...... if any of us have a career change to terrorist...... not too much to worry about 😂😂😂😂
Let’s start with everyone on this panel be on the list
Women in politics 😂😂😂😂we are so screwed
Great job Senator. Why are we paying huge money to these important agencies? THESE PEOPLE IN FRONT ROW SHOULD ALL BE SACKED. TOTAL INCOMPETENCE. Where do they get off not answering questions about their activities or LACK there of.
Actions speak louder than words.
This is where you end up ,when on one is criticised and questioning for not doing their job. accountable
This is all a joke.
Question? now! why am I not getting her kind of salary? because i can definitely assure you senator I can also fail EQUALY as she and I am only on stuff all salary.
Its great that we have equal outcomes not oppurtunity eh...
If a wages gap actually existed you now know why it should.
19 Million and they don't know anything about Terrorists ? LOL Can I get a Job Please?
Trouble is when you but do gooders in charge of this department.
The should all have someone to answer to when spending $ you can hear in their answers they are not use to this
Affirmitive action 🤦♂️
This looks like a scene from Utopia. I’m shocked that this is how government departments actually ‘work’. Bahahaha
Let Luke Speak 😂
F*** how hard would that be, what a bloody joke 17.8m how us get this outrages cost and time talking should be so easy Max two weeks Max cost
$ 200K What a discusting cost, can we have a forensic Audit on this cost.
Beware of Fascists bearing gifts 🇺🇸
Affirmitive action 😂😂😂
How the hell did theses people get these jobs.
Senate estimates should be called.
Senate, interjecting control freaks.
It must be very frustrating for you to ask proper and significant questions to senior staff in this department and not receive any forth coming answers. Does the way in which our departmental systems operate cause the public service to be scared of answering these questions to the best of their ability/ knowledge and as a consequence “put up the shutters” so their relevant Minister doesn’t ridicule them in public? If this is the case it is no wonder we waste time and therefore money going through this wasted activity. Surely we must have Australians who can ‘operate’ in this environment effectively.
If this happened in any other industry, you'd be looking for another job. The answers are pathetic, and a dereliction of duty to the taxpayer.
Thanks Luke 😂
the chair at the end, wow.. just condescending.
Either that or labour
Must employe criminals 6:48 6:51
A bunch of high paid do little. ..
Are the Canberra enclave…..
I am sorry I really am but continuing watching this I'm continually looking for a red nose and long red shoes wow
Wow what a lier she is
government couldn't run a raffle
People employed by any government body are people private enterprise will not employ...Because of there incompetence!!!
they play dune to cover truthfulness
9 year's to must enough is enough must stop.to hurt's me.thank you amen
U want an Answer, Luke will give u the Answer, 💯🥳👏