sahi kaha bhai maki aankh aaj ye budget ki wajah se pehli baar mera 5k tax kata jitna hike mil sab sarkar legaya 😢 Sala ab vote kisko de ek ko hindutva se matlab ek ko reservation. bhains ki aankh hum common middle class kidhar jaaye
only brahmins and upper castes speak about caste politics. you dont know that the larger population is in shambles. they face more than you ever will. they are The Common Man. they are the backwards.
@@0Leakvoice the way they want to do it and are doing it aint ideal bro. They are dividing India on the basis of caste and trust me, the reservation they are getting is enough case if its increasing, the general caste will be against the entirety of the congress or any party that implements, people already can’t get jobs cause of reservation you want more of it.
Are bhai jabtak tribals or st sc oppressed rhenge wo liability rhenge .. unka development necessary h .. religion politics is bllshit, although we should contain extremism
From my perspective, I understood the halwa metaphorically; the budget presented by the finance minister did not cover the needs of Adivasis, Dalits and OBCs.
To All those who might agree or disagree just simply remove caste reservations . Let people get filtered or selected based on education and qualification and talent .....
The ruling party is working for the rich and opposition is concerned with caste politics. We need a new political party which will stand for the common middle class man.
Did you go thoroughly through all schemes mentioned by FM? Ofcourse you wouldn't have. As a citizen of India you didn't even have time to go through the schemes told by FM , do you really think FM has time to speak each and every word in the Parliament within 1 hr? She clearly mentioned "will benefit every state / Citizen " in speech. Grow up kid, stop being childish
@@Addicted-A1 Jisaka saath bas usika Vikas. (Those who are supporting the government only those states will benefit) As a common man i am doing my all day today work. Paying almost 45 to 50 % whatever i earn and get in return Country with lack of governance in almost every field. Why 30% bracket remain same in last 10 years. Doesn't it makes sense that it should also change as per inflation. Thanks to god that there are educated beurocrates are present who are running this Country. (Politicians are only to make money and stay in power)
Does BJP really play on religion, why government policy benefits to Muslims, award Muslim artists? Know what the past was like the only people murdered in 2022 when Nupur Sharma scene happened were Hindus.
I am forever grateful to Mr. David , he has completely changed my life and I will continue to preach in his name until everyone hears that you saved me from a huge financial debt with a small investment, thank you Mr. David
Same here, I believe the Bitcoin ETFs approval will be life changing opportunity for us, with my current portfolio of $108,000 from my investments with my personal financial advisor *David Wilson Clark* 1 totally agree with you
Crypto is bringing a different revolution in the world economy, people who are optimistic investors earn consistently, others will just sit and watch!.
l agree with you and believe that the secret to financial stability is having the right investment ideas to enable you earn more money, I don't know who agrees with me but either way I recommend real estate or crypto and stocks.
Making touch with financial advisors like *David Wilson Clark* who can assist you restructure your portfolio, would be a very creative option. Personal financial management will be crucial to navigating the next difficult times.
BJP achi nahi hai par bhai is samay bhi finance minster ke sath hu. Rahul Gandhi kya baseless argument rakh Raha hai. Dhruv rathee jo BJP ka virodhi hai usne bhi budget ko todha justification di hai. Itna bura nahi hai socho toh.
Rahul Gandhi is born in the wrong era. He is still believing caste politics will work. We really need some one more sensible. Caste divide is not what India wants now
May be u don't understand politics. In India if caste is nothing why maximum crime means almost 85 % crime happen only on sc and st.he clearly said in process of budget making out of 20 officer y 18 belong to upper caste. This is politics
@@aryangupta9800 Do you really want to pin this on the people who are actually suffering this budget? People have always been vigilant and political. The budgets were never this discriminatory during the Congress rule.
You see the title of this video and the previous one! Previous one extraordinary Title. and now Extraordinary Stories. I feel good to see this video after 2 hours after the previous video. Brut! youth of the Nation sees the truth!
For the people saying caste caste you people don't understand how important it is caste is rooted in our country people to this date make fun of people about their caste on reddit and now on instagram publicly so you know how people think about lower caste such things are very much shown in the development They are not privileged like most they don't get better jobs you tell if they're one rich man is and SC st or adivasi Or a business man
@@Anonymiss0 brother don't say illogical things, what sc and st cast are doesn't get better job, then who prevent it's general people. I am from North east here u can see most of higher post occupied by ST as well as ST are economical strong comparing with general. Don't offended i am express view regarding this matter.
@@ajoyrai6549 arre that is the thing na caste senses is important for every state so that people who really needs it will get it It's not the same here in delhi and in uttarpradesh and a lot of states but as you say it's not in your state agar caste senses hoga toh maybe tumhare state m general logo ko reservation milegi ya sc st ki kam ki jayegi
She says the Congress Party is going to divide Indians in terms of caste ..She seems to be saying what she knows isn't the truth..She isn't convincing .
Both BJP and INDIA alliance are trash we need new face, new government, new leaders. This may never happen because we frown upon politicians and do not want to become one. No common man wants to become a politician that's why corrupt and communal people become politicians. This is the reason why India is a "POOR COUNTRY" and will forever be a "POOR COUNTRY" , despite its rich history( history doesn't matter, present and future does.) the future is dark
Who said India is a poor country just wake up bro we are at least at lower upper class level but if you said that you will not get bpl or or NCL cirtificate so everyone in india is poor are you think a poor man had a time to think about tax the main issue of the last budget 😂.
@@heroshe7786 India ranks 111 out of 125 in global hunger index. How your calling yourself even half of rich when 70% population is still sleeping hungry!?
@@manasuniyal2897 no I believe and saw people still living on streets and majority population earning close to 1 dollar per day only. So it's not hard to guess. Also GHI works on average population density statistics and not on emotions or government fund.
Why do "These Idiots" always talk of something ten or fifteen years ago to justify the wrong they are continuing to do today? To talk of Rajiv Gandhi and justify something now is shameful.
5 місяців тому
Convert we learn from history so same mistakes won't be repeated
Even OCs are not getting good college seats & government jobs nowadays & OCs are becoming poorer & poorer due to lack of opportunities,heavy competition, no scholarship from the government, huge college fees , no reservations, etc. Reservation quota is also getting misused by fake certifications & a few Rich educated backward class families for generations. The social upliftment is not working at all. India is gonna be doomed if reservation is not removed in EDUCATION (JEE MAINS For example) and JOBS. Only way India is gonna develop is by making EDUCATION and JOBS merit based.
According to Nirmala tai ideology, Congress literally done nothing under their leader-ship whereas BJP did many things for the nation after 2014 (additionally freedom of the nation).
People of India is just tired of the age old dramatic politics of caste n religion…. It will be great if people get to see drama on inflated prices and the rising cost of living for the common people for a change
Wtf is wrong with other members Why are they shouting like they are in home If they don't be in discipline So how we aspect they grow our country 🙂 5:08
Title: "Rahul Gandhi vs. Nirmala Sitharaman: 2024 Budget showdown" Rahul Gandhi criticizes the budget presentation, highlighting the lack of representation of OBC, Dalit, and Adivasi officers. He points out that the budget preparation and distribution ('halwa ceremony') do not include significant participation from marginalized communities. Gandhi questions the inclusivity of the process, stating only two out of twenty involved officers belong to minority or OBC communities. He mentions that the tradition of the 'halwa ceremony' began in 2013-14 and wasn't questioned back then regarding representation. Gandhi accuses the current government of conspiracies and asks why certain communities are excluded from business, corporate, and government roles. He references the Kaka Kalelkar Commission and Mandal Commission reports, criticizing Congress for not implementing recommendations for backward classes. Gandhi calls for a caste census, claiming 95% of the population wants it to understand their representation. He questions the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation's inclusivity and insists on setting an example before criticizing others. Gandhi emphasizes the need for accountability and representation of SC, ST, and OBC communities in governance and budget processes.
@surajsomkuwar5502 of course Rahul raised a question which seems sensible but unfortunately he does not understands this problem came because of the previous congress governments congress did not bring this caste issues for decades in fact they even sit upon mandal committee recommendations for long time if they acted then the problem would have been non existent and also there is no immediate solution right now to include people from all communities just for sake of representation scrutinise our nation’s budget with lack of experience secretary level officers. FM is right in her defence saying the same and Rahul wants to divide India based upon caste.
I wanted to know what are the facilities for Sc,St,Obs, minorities and depressed people in new Budget of India..? We should learn from our past and make our future..
Jab akash baneerji ne demonitization pe bola toh speaker bol rha tha pehle ka baat q kr rhe ho aur jab finance minister 2k13 2k14 ka baat kr rhi thi speaker was silent 😂 shame on birla
Share the plight of flood landslides bridge collapse power cut In IMD RED ALERT Assam north east Kerala Mumbai MP Guj Entire world surprised today seeing NTA conducting national exam NEET across India It's opposition responsibility to ensure no national NTA exam in rainy seasons
bhai maki aankh aaj ye budget ki wajah se pehli baar mera 5k tax kata jitna hike mila wo sab sarkar legaya Sala ab vote kisko de ek ko hindutva se matlab ek ko reservation. bhains ki aankh hum common middle class kidhar jaaye
I don't see any of the party having capability to deal with the actual problem India is facing. They both have been fighting against eachother only by taking shelt6of Religion and caste. As an Indian I want to see my country develop. I don't want to deal with the tuti sadak anymore, I don't want to deal with the flood like situation when it rains, I don't want to see the news of people dying because of train accident. I want to see a clean India a devloped India An India which knows the need of its citizens. I want a party that deals with Problems na ki bs jhuthe vaade krti hai nothing else.
Its not a conspiracy , its the fact there is some deal going in between the budget minister and these guys un the photo ............ Rahul has spoken the truth .................
Rahul Gandhi says BJP doesn't do justice for OBC SC ST Dalits and BJP says what is your government do for them they are saying We both are same so don't question my government to do justice for them they are all (dalits sc st obc) saves to us. wow what a leaders
Rahul gandhi felt insulted when asked about his caste but wants to know cast of entire India. Please don’t dare come to my house to ask caste , first have guts to say yours Rahul Gandhi. It is simple Unite 20% Divide 80% into caste Congress party learned well “divide and rule” from British. Let me tell you - president of india - ST(dropadi murmu),,,,,, prime minister of India- Modi(obc) Congress denies Modi caste as obc which is denying AN OBC FROM BEING THE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA!!!!!
Bro it's not his mistake it's their PR teams they thought that they can take Nirmal with it but she had prepared this😂 more than that's of her SSLC exam
Fm ne budget aisa bnaya ki sbki lg gai...boht baatein hai discussion ke liye bt guess wt hmari dono so called pyaari party ""hlwe"" pe bhs krri hai or rahul ji sath mai caste politics vi add krre...hmara desh pkaa aise develop hoga🥰
I don't understand one thing... Why there would be reservations after 77 years of indepence???...Are we really moving forward or backward in terms of development?
Dr ambedkar made for 25 years but what can we do that time had not enough for the people who called themselves beem to be educated so they use his name not his teachings 😅
It is not division it is representation. In india 5 % people belong to upper caste but in high court out of 650 judges 399 belong to 5% . in process of budget making 18 out of 20 belong to that 5% .
Because upper castes focus on proper education Bi*ches which lower caste don't go to a village in UO and Bihar their children can't get the environment of study and as a result most of them become chapri
Castes, Religions, Languages, Cultures And Traditions were always present in Lakhs and Crores in India!, But Still we Have Unity in Diversity! These 2 political parties Have it Seems Suddenly woken up From A Long HangOver!,
Even OCs are not getting good college seats & government jobs nowadays & OCs are becoming poorer & poorer due to lack of opportunities,heavy competition, no scholarship from the government, huge college fees , no reservations, etc. Reservation quota is also getting misused by fake certifications & a few Rich educated backward class families for generations. The social upliftment is not working at all. Two big parties are hopeless. One party is concerned about religion & geopolitics . The other party is concerned about caste & other silly things neglecting core problems like overpopulation, bad education system, skill development, pollution, corruption, scams, etc.
India is gonna be doomed if reservation is not removed in EDUCATION (JEE MAINS For example) and JOBS. Only way India is gonna develop is by making EDUCATION and JOBS merit based.
Best comeback madam.. ise kehte hai jise jo bhasha samajh aye use usi ki basha me jawab dena😂 This was much needed.. enough of this pappu nautanki...look at his body language.... Script k according acting karna hai and parliament me hungama machana hai..that's all..
Great decision for truly needy SC ST OBC EWS Must be implemented in all Creamy & non creamy division more important than giving all to creamy SC ST OBC EWS only All SC ST OBC EWS must get benefits of reservation Uplift weak first
Nirmala sitaram is not fit for the finance minister.Nimala must step down from her position and give finance ministry to young talent candidates in india like The Great ManMohan Singh and chidambaram. If she continues as finance minister soon india will face bankruptcy.#ResignNirmala #ResignFinanceMinister
I don’t blame congress for their work in the past. I blame our citizens for not raising their concerns back then. And BJP’s arguments about they did this and that in past is simply irrelevant in current times. Bjp just please be in present, solve and work on current ongoing and future issues and problems if you want to make India great in real. Matter of fact is all these politicians are there for themselves be it modi or Gandhi. We the people of India have to stand up for ourselves.
On the name of answer these people only has the past of congress. "Tab ye nahi kiya" "tab wo nahi hua tha" They need to answer in present. whenever someone asked them questions about their present situation, they straight go to the past of congress! 😅
18 out of 20 people who make budget belong to upper caste. This is serious. Are u saying upper caste people are only talented. Only 5 % people are talented and meritorious
If after Reservation, these people( SC, ST, OBC) are not able to hold any position that's not Our ( General Category) problem, Don't Scratch Our Rights. Because Equality don't mean grabbing someone's right and giving it to SC, ST people. Although they get scholarship even though they are able to afford AC and Still Poor Students / Candidate of general category suffers fo even better study
Not a single party is good these days all are work for making their own money 💰 and we middle class family suffered from these things. They are talking about obc, st ,sc and bjp was talking about rich person what about generals and middle class family. Today 95% job is for st, sc ,obc .they forget about generals categories 😢😢😢😢😢
I dont like politics but this much i know that if BJP is in power, there is a hope of development. And we also need a strong oppositions not like this who always defends every decision.
BJP playing Religion politics.
Congress playing Caste Politics.
While the common man working hard to leave India and settle somewhere else.
sahi kaha bhai maki aankh aaj ye budget ki wajah se pehli baar mera 5k tax kata jitna hike mil sab sarkar legaya 😢 Sala ab vote kisko de ek ko hindutva se matlab ek ko reservation. bhains ki aankh hum common middle class kidhar jaaye
To sare caste ko equal value ki baat kr rh h to galat kya h
only brahmins and upper castes speak about caste politics. you dont know that the larger population is in shambles. they face more than you ever will. they are The Common Man. they are the backwards.
@@0Leakvoice the way they want to do it and are doing it aint ideal bro. They are dividing India on the basis of caste and trust me, the reservation they are getting is enough case if its increasing, the general caste will be against the entirety of the congress or any party that implements, people already can’t get jobs cause of reservation you want more of it.
Are bhai jabtak tribals or st sc oppressed rhenge wo liability rhenge .. unka development necessary h .. religion politics is bllshit, although we should contain extremism
From my perspective, I understood the halwa metaphorically; the budget presented by the finance minister did not cover the needs of Adivasis, Dalits and OBCs.
True ‼️🙌
FM itself knows that what RG perspective 😂😂😂. But they divert the subject to another level 😂 .
ha, they copied the budget from congress manifesto,
To All those who might agree or disagree just simply remove caste reservations .
Let people get filtered or selected based on education and qualification and talent .....
Crt
The ruling party is working for the rich and opposition is concerned with caste politics. We need a new political party which will stand for the common middle class man.
but the ruling party is working for nation
I support you and your party 😂😂😂😂
@@raidaiwik2006 😂 budget ke baad bhi samjh ni aya tumko
@@raidaiwik2006 or kitni andhbhakti dikhaoge 😂
No any government make anyone rich , it's about porson responsible it self
Budget is not for common people. Their interest are not at all considered in budget.
Worst FM of Country.
Did you go thoroughly through all schemes mentioned by FM? Ofcourse you wouldn't have. As a citizen of India you didn't even have time to go through the schemes told by FM , do you really think FM has time to speak each and every word in the Parliament within 1 hr? She clearly mentioned "will benefit every state / Citizen " in speech. Grow up kid, stop being childish
@@Addicted-A1 Jisaka saath bas usika Vikas.
(Those who are supporting the government only those states will benefit)
As a common man i am doing my all day today work. Paying almost 45 to 50 % whatever i earn and get in return Country with lack of governance in almost every field.
Why 30% bracket remain same in last 10 years. Doesn't it makes sense that it should also change as per inflation.
Thanks to god that there are educated beurocrates are present who are running this Country. (Politicians are only to make money and stay in power)
Tum ban jao Bhai.
As a long term investor, she is the worst FM@@Addicted-A1
How much tax did u pay last year, do u pay tax? Are u employed ?
congress plays on caste, bjp plays on religion..
Hindu-muslim game being played since bin kasim invaded india(700AD something) But this cast game being played only after congress invented
He is talking about caste because he wants the representative of each caste and religion to be the member of committee.
mandal kamandal politics
Does BJP really play on religion, why government policy benefits to Muslims, award Muslim artists? Know what the past was like the only people murdered in 2022 when Nupur Sharma scene happened were Hindus.
Politics itself is a shit
We need a New Political party. These 2 main parties are useless.
No, your way of looking the parties is useless ..It doesn't matter which party comes to power... if the issues arise your view will remain the same ..
bjp divides on religion and congress divides on caste. but i think that bjp is slightly better than congress in developing the country
We already have enough amount of political parties, the problem is only corrupt parties who use lies to gain votes are winning
I am forever grateful to Mr. David , he has completely changed my life and I will continue to preach in his name until everyone hears that you saved me from a huge financial debt with a small investment, thank you Mr. David
Same here, I believe the Bitcoin ETFs approval will be life changing opportunity for us, with my current portfolio of $108,000 from my investments with my personal financial advisor *David Wilson Clark* 1 totally agree with you
Crypto is bringing a different revolution in the world economy, people who are optimistic investors earn consistently, others will just sit and watch!.
l agree with you and believe that the secret to financial stability is having the right investment ideas to enable you earn more money, I don't know who agrees with me but either way I recommend real estate or crypto and stocks.
Making touch with financial advisors like *David Wilson Clark* who can assist you restructure your portfolio, would be a very creative option. Personal financial management will be crucial to navigating the next difficult times.
Investing a in crypto/forex is a good idea, a good trading system would put you through many days of success.
Worst finance minister ever 😡
Worst to the core
What ? Sacchai sun ke gand jal gai kya ? She is well enough
BJP achi nahi hai par bhai is samay bhi finance minster ke sath hu.
Rahul Gandhi kya baseless argument rakh Raha hai.
Dhruv rathee jo BJP ka virodhi hai usne bhi budget ko todha justification di hai.
Itna bura nahi hai socho toh.
@@lolpol-hn8dv east, west or north bjp is best is best (south consider themselves as a seperate nation so cannot add )
Even the opposition doesn't thinks bout the middle class, lol hypocrates
Rahul Gandhi is born in the wrong era. He is still believing caste politics will work. We really need some one more sensible. Caste divide is not what India wants now
May be u don't understand politics. In India if caste is nothing why maximum crime means almost 85 % crime happen only on sc and st.he clearly said in process of budget making out of 20 officer y 18 belong to upper caste. This is politics
This FM is a joke! She didnt answer Rahul's full question , she halved his question and changed it entirely 😂
She didn't said anything about caste census it's the most important thing@Anamikaz
She halwad the question
correct word always pain 🤣
budget banane wale
Bjp don't want to talk about caste they just want to talk about HINDU MUSLIM....
Sahi baat he reservation pura cancel kar dena chahiye bjp ne
To kya chahte ho 200% reservation krde🥰
Ik hindu muslim politics is bad ,caste based is worse as well bruhh
Caste census choro, normal census hi band karwa diya. Independence se baad se aise kabhi nahi hua
@@Satyam-fe7hr nahi nahi woh chahata he ki open wale apni jaan de de
@@jaisubu26 kisne boll diya🤦🏻♂️ 2021 mai hona tha covid krke nhi hua ab election ke baad hona tha so election khtm ab census hoga🤦🏻♂️
When we see rahul gandhi as a youth leader and he is talking about caste rather than trying to eliminate it, it's really disappointing 😞
Nirmala 👎
No statistics was counted back then because there was no issue in the budget. People were covered and there was some degree of satisfaction.
No then people were ignorant and now they are somewhat less ignorant
@@aryangupta9800 Do you really want to pin this on the people who are actually suffering this budget? People have always been vigilant and political. The budgets were never this discriminatory during the Congress rule.
she said everything but she still said nothing
You see the title of this video and the previous one!
Previous one extraordinary Title. and now Extraordinary Stories.
I feel good to see this video after 2 hours after the previous video. Brut! youth of the Nation sees the truth!
For the people saying caste caste you people don't understand how important it is caste is rooted in our country people to this date make fun of people about their caste on reddit and now on instagram publicly so you know how people think about lower caste such things are very much shown in the development
They are not privileged like most they don't get better jobs you tell if they're one rich man is and SC st or adivasi
Or a business man
@@Anonymiss0 brother don't say illogical things, what sc and st cast are doesn't get better job, then who prevent it's general people. I am from North east here u can see most of higher post occupied by ST as well as ST are economical strong comparing with general. Don't offended i am express view regarding this matter.
@@ajoyrai6549 arre that is the thing na caste senses is important for every state so that people who really needs it will get it
It's not the same here in delhi and in uttarpradesh and a lot of states but as you say it's not in your state agar caste senses hoga toh maybe tumhare state m general logo ko reservation milegi ya sc st ki kam ki jayegi
@@ajoyrai6549Northeast states have the least caste discrimination among all the states of India take that in acccount
She said in an interview "the so called middle class" like EXCUSE Me?????
Really i appreciate your channels, as you played both sides of the argument.
RG spoke for the people but Nirmala spoke for herself and for her party. That’s it
😂😂really?
He spoke for the votes of reserved castes 💀
She says the Congress Party is going to divide Indians in terms of caste ..She seems to be saying what she knows isn't the truth..She isn't convincing .
Wow now they are fighting over halwa nice
Halwa is metaphor of budget
Both BJP and INDIA alliance are trash we need new face, new government, new leaders. This may never happen because we frown upon politicians and do not want to become one. No common man wants to become a politician that's why corrupt and communal people become politicians. This is the reason why India is a "POOR COUNTRY" and will forever be a "POOR COUNTRY" , despite its rich history( history doesn't matter, present and future does.) the future is dark
Who said India is a poor country just wake up bro we are at least at lower upper class level but if you said that you will not get bpl or or NCL cirtificate so everyone in india is poor are you think a poor man had a time to think about tax the main issue of the last budget 😂.
@@heroshe7786 India ranks 111 out of 125 in global hunger index. How your calling yourself even half of rich when 70% population is still sleeping hungry!?
@@Myblog956 And you believe HUNGER INDEX , where INDIA ranks below PAKISTAN and SRILANKA . India exports food to Sri Lanka .
@@heroshe7786Lol bro thinks India is rich🤣
@@manasuniyal2897 no I believe and saw people still living on streets and majority population earning close to 1 dollar per day only. So it's not hard to guess. Also GHI works on average population density statistics and not on emotions or government fund.
The truth is no party will understand a problem of middleclass people.
Why do "These Idiots" always talk of something ten or fifteen years ago to justify the wrong they are continuing to do today? To talk of Rajiv Gandhi and justify something now is shameful.
Convert we learn from history so same mistakes won't be repeated
Basically, Reservations were only proposed for 10 years by DR BR Ambedkar, and yet congress continued them for votes and are doing so even now 😵💫
Even OCs are not getting good college seats & government jobs nowadays & OCs are becoming poorer & poorer due to lack of opportunities,heavy competition, no scholarship from the government, huge college fees , no reservations, etc. Reservation quota is also getting misused by fake certifications & a few Rich educated backward class families for generations.
The social upliftment is not working at all. India is gonna be doomed if reservation is not removed in EDUCATION (JEE MAINS For example) and JOBS. Only way India is gonna develop is by making EDUCATION and JOBS merit based.
Ek akela Kitno par bhari😅😅😅😅😅😂❤🎉
According to Nirmala tai ideology, Congress literally done nothing under their leader-ship whereas BJP did many things for the nation after 2014 (additionally freedom of the nation).
People of India is just tired of the age old dramatic politics of caste n religion…. It will be great if people get to see drama on inflated prices and the rising cost of living for the common people for a change
Raga saying 73%is obc sc and adivasi etc...still they are claiming minorities what a class dialogue
Wtf is wrong with other members
Why are they shouting like they are in home
If they don't be in discipline
So how we aspect they grow our country 🙂 5:08
Title: "Rahul Gandhi vs. Nirmala Sitharaman: 2024 Budget showdown"
Rahul Gandhi criticizes the budget presentation, highlighting the lack of representation of OBC, Dalit, and Adivasi officers.
He points out that the budget preparation and distribution ('halwa ceremony') do not include significant participation from marginalized communities.
Gandhi questions the inclusivity of the process, stating only two out of twenty involved officers belong to minority or OBC communities.
He mentions that the tradition of the 'halwa ceremony' began in 2013-14 and wasn't questioned back then regarding representation.
Gandhi accuses the current government of conspiracies and asks why certain communities are excluded from business, corporate, and government roles.
He references the Kaka Kalelkar Commission and Mandal Commission reports, criticizing Congress for not implementing recommendations for backward classes.
Gandhi calls for a caste census, claiming 95% of the population wants it to understand their representation.
He questions the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation's inclusivity and insists on setting an example before criticizing others.
Gandhi emphasizes the need for accountability and representation of SC, ST, and OBC communities in governance and budget processes.
@surajsomkuwar5502 of course Rahul raised a question which seems sensible but unfortunately he does not understands this problem came because of the previous congress governments congress did not bring this caste issues for decades in fact they even sit upon mandal committee recommendations for long time if they acted then the problem would have been non existent and also there is no immediate solution right now to include people from all communities just for sake of representation scrutinise our nation’s budget with lack of experience secretary level officers. FM is right in her defence saying the same and Rahul wants to divide India based upon caste.
I wanted to know what are the facilities for Sc,St,Obs, minorities and depressed people in new Budget of India..? We should learn from our past and make our future..
Jab akash baneerji ne demonitization pe bola toh speaker bol rha tha pehle ka baat q kr rhe ho aur jab finance minister 2k13 2k14 ka baat kr rhi thi speaker was silent 😂 shame on birla
Caste politics never end from congress led opposition
Same as the hindu muslim politics of bjp
@@sss8428bjp does not do hindu muslim, only Congress does
Bjp is the epitome of hindu vs muslim..
Congress plays caste base politics no wonder why people want to leave india..
@@sss8428 I said caste, but I didn't want to include any religion with this
Share the plight of flood landslides bridge collapse power cut
In IMD RED ALERT
Assam north east
Kerala
Mumbai
MP
Guj
Entire world surprised today seeing NTA conducting national exam NEET across India
It's opposition responsibility to ensure no national NTA exam in rainy seasons
Nirmla Muskra toh Ese rahi hai jaise Modhi ne Purpose ❤kar diya ho 😊
What about majority that is us,... congress will make majority cry....all the reservation will increase majority will cry for services or governance
She's smiling cutely, how FM denied that??
bhai maki aankh aaj ye budget ki wajah se pehli baar mera 5k tax kata jitna hike mila wo sab sarkar legaya Sala ab vote kisko de ek ko hindutva se matlab ek ko reservation. bhains ki aankh hum common middle class kidhar jaaye
BJP is playing Religion politics.
Congress is playing Caste Politics.
And yet, Congress supporters claim that BJP is biased.
Cancel the halwa, and seize it 😅
Nirmala sitaraman can be wife of modi😂😂😂
Shame on you
U too@@pmurali-n3z
Justice Rahulji❤
I don't see any of the party having capability to deal with the actual problem India is facing. They both have been fighting against eachother only by taking shelt6of Religion and caste.
As an Indian I want to see my country develop. I don't want to deal with the tuti sadak anymore, I don't want to deal with the flood like situation when it rains, I don't want to see the news of people dying because of train accident. I want to see a clean India a devloped India An India which knows the need of its citizens.
I want a party that deals with Problems na ki bs jhuthe vaade krti hai nothing else.
Indian politics in short... No ones is ready to resolve the matters....This is the only thing which Indian is lacking in
Its not a conspiracy , its the fact there is some deal going in between the budget minister and these guys un the photo ............
Rahul has spoken the truth .................
Rahul Gandhi says BJP doesn't do justice for OBC SC ST Dalits and BJP says what is your government do for them they are saying We both are same so don't question my government to do justice for them they are all (dalits sc st obc) saves to us. wow what a leaders
#Resignfinanceministerindia
Rahul gandhi felt insulted when asked about his caste but wants to know cast of entire India.
Please don’t dare come to my house to ask caste , first have guts to say yours Rahul Gandhi.
It is simple
Unite 20%
Divide 80% into caste
Congress party learned well “divide and rule” from British.
Let me tell you - president of india - ST(dropadi murmu),,,,,, prime minister of India- Modi(obc)
Congress denies Modi caste as obc which is denying AN OBC FROM BEING THE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA!!!!!
BJP now what do you think about our north eastern......Nirmala😂😂👎👎👎down
I want to see a strong rahul gandhi but not going back to his useless pappu levels again
Bro it's not his mistake it's their PR teams they thought that they can take Nirmal with it but she had prepared this😂 more than that's of her SSLC exam
@@heroshe7786 yaa bro.
Once a pappu always a pappu
For real
How you can say that
nirmala ji bought all the paperwork dating back to 1955 but not one legit defense for her own budget
Fm ne budget aisa bnaya ki sbki lg gai...boht baatein hai discussion ke liye bt guess wt hmari dono so called pyaari party ""hlwe"" pe bhs krri hai or rahul ji sath mai caste politics vi add krre...hmara desh pkaa aise develop hoga🥰
I don't understand one thing... Why there would be reservations after 77 years of indepence???...Are we really moving forward or backward in terms of development?
Dr ambedkar made for 25 years but what can we do that time had not enough for the people who called themselves beem to be educated so they use his name not his teachings 😅
I mean look at the Olympics, we are indeed going backward somehow
They dont give a Damn about BUDGET!!!! British gye and left these to ENSALVE US AGAIN ON TAX & CASTE
Rahul ❤❤❤❤❤
Look at the way the old lady is speaking ….even her husband ( God knows if they stay together also) agrees with Rahul
Already the country is so much divided based on religion now they want to divide it on caste
It is not division it is representation. In india 5 % people belong to upper caste but in high court out of 650 judges 399 belong to 5% . in process of budget making 18 out of 20 belong to that 5% .
Because upper castes focus on proper education Bi*ches which lower caste don't go to a village in UO and Bihar their children can't get the environment of study and as a result most of them become chapri
They are not interested in country's progress
They are satisfying there ego
Officer obc nhi dikh rha lekin pm obc hai aur president adivasi hai
But Rahul is Rahul waise Rahul kya hai obc ya adivasi
This is shameful. These politicians are the main reason behind this pitiful casteim which is ruining the lives of many.
Castes, Religions, Languages, Cultures And Traditions were always present in Lakhs and Crores in India!,
But Still we Have Unity in Diversity!
These 2 political parties Have it Seems Suddenly woken up From A Long HangOver!,
@@santoshsivaramkrish There is no unity...visit the villages, you'll see the unity 😂. The need of the hour is education (Right education).
Even OCs are not getting good college seats & government jobs nowadays & OCs are becoming poorer & poorer due to lack of opportunities,heavy competition, no scholarship from the government, huge college fees , no reservations, etc. Reservation quota is also getting misused by fake certifications & a few Rich educated backward class families for generations. The social upliftment is not working at all.
Two big parties are hopeless.
One party is concerned about religion & geopolitics . The other party is concerned about caste & other silly things neglecting core problems like overpopulation, bad education system, skill development, pollution, corruption, scams, etc.
India is gonna be doomed if reservation is not removed in EDUCATION (JEE MAINS For example) and JOBS. Only way India is gonna develop is by making EDUCATION and JOBS merit based.
Best comeback madam.. ise kehte hai jise jo bhasha samajh aye use usi ki basha me jawab dena😂
This was much needed.. enough of this pappu nautanki...look at his body language.... Script k according acting karna hai and parliament me hungama machana hai..that's all..
why they always talk about 2014-2015😒
Because, that's when the latter were in power for the last time.
Great decision for truly needy SC ST OBC EWS
Must be implemented in all
Creamy & non creamy division more important than giving all to creamy SC ST OBC EWS only
All SC ST OBC EWS must get benefits of reservation
Uplift weak first
The common public will get only Halwa whoever it is in power.
Rahul Gandhi Sir as next Pm❤
Jaya bachchan of parliament
Nirmala sitaram is not fit for the finance minister.Nimala must step down from her position and give finance ministry to young talent candidates in india like The Great ManMohan Singh and chidambaram.
If she continues as finance minister soon india will face bankruptcy.#ResignNirmala #ResignFinanceMinister
What about generals
Yeh bar bar ghum phir ka picha ka time stamp ma q chala jatai .. fo us on present and avi ka socho and future ka socho ... Worst finance minister
I don’t blame congress for their work in the past. I blame our citizens for not raising their concerns back then. And BJP’s arguments about they did this and that in past is simply irrelevant in current times. Bjp just please be in present, solve and work on current ongoing and future issues and problems if you want to make India great in real. Matter of fact is all these politicians are there for themselves be it modi or Gandhi. We the people of India have to stand up for ourselves.
On the name of answer these people only has the past of congress. "Tab ye nahi kiya" "tab wo nahi hua tha"
They need to answer in present. whenever someone asked them questions about their present situation, they straight go to the past of congress! 😅
Rahul has nothing better things to do.
18 out of 20 people who make budget belong to upper caste. This is serious. Are u saying upper caste people are only talented. Only 5 % people are talented and meritorious
Iske hisab se to jo abhi general class hai wo ab minority hai. To sara aarakshan phir minorities (general class) ko milna chahiye
If after Reservation, these people( SC, ST, OBC) are not able to hold any position that's not Our ( General Category) problem, Don't Scratch Our Rights. Because Equality don't mean grabbing someone's right and giving it to SC, ST people. Although they get scholarship even though they are able to afford AC and Still Poor Students / Candidate of general category suffers fo even better study
Nirmala utter flop 💯
Not a single party is good these days all are work for making their own money 💰 and we middle class family suffered from these things. They are talking about obc, st ,sc and bjp was talking about rich person what about generals and middle class family. Today 95% job is for st, sc ,obc .they forget about generals categories 😢😢😢😢😢
congress always brings caste on table.They can not come in power if they dont perform caste politics.
Shameless FM n BJP..and those hate against Rahul are BJP media team.. don't worry they are not concern Indian citizen but BJP money team
#StopBroadcastingBill
And here we go again, the BJP talking about the previous government. They never answer questions they are just gonna blame previous government😂😂
Please save Bangladeshi students from the dictator Hasina
Rahul Sir ❤❤❤
so ja na fir pappu ke saath
I was starting to respect Raga but now he is bringing caste division which is just as bad as Hindu Muslim division.
This Country should not be governed by Brahmins only.
She should resign
When they will come up with the budget plan for people
Rahul Gandhi alone is the reason why bjp wins the election
Is admi ko budget ki chinta hai ya photo ki 😢
Log budget se ro rahe hai aur ise photo me kaun hai kaun nahi karna hai...yeh banega PM 😂
Salute to great congress leader
At this stage rahul asking right question but due to supermesi of bjp gone wrong
I dont like politics but this much i know that if BJP is in power, there is a hope of development. And we also need a strong oppositions not like this who always defends every decision.
Madam uss samay nahi poocha nahi toh kabhi baa poochhe kya???
फोटो मे अर्थशास्त्री भी नही है
first rahul gandhi was stupid now he is a wicked classic gandhi / nehru
BJP Rss finance minister hatao Desh bachao
Superb reply mam