Problem Lowering the Tower / Mast!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 106

  • @chrisbartlett6022
    @chrisbartlett6022 22 дні тому +2

    Larkshead knot, the one you call a kite knot. Of course of no importance, just nice to learn things. You have taught me loads over the years.
    BTW, pleased to see you letting the line out hand over hand. Lots of folks let it slide and can easily get rope burns.

  • @Professzore
    @Professzore 24 дні тому +2

    Hi Cal,
    Though you did an amazing job here, let me introduce some safety instructions (based on some rock climbing and competition sailing experience).
    First and foremost: never EVER stand in the line of the tension vector. NEVER. If anything fails, it will hit you with an enormous power. Stay at least 20 degrees off. Over 40 degrees is even better.
    To manage the twisting of tensioned cords, use proper tools to avoid unwanted tangling of pulley ropes. A swivel with ball bearings (which can rotate under heavy load) will be very handy at the right spot. Some not-so-cheap solutions will be available mostly for sailing. I'll write more details in an email if you need them (even with product suggestions).
    To fast secure a rope (even under tension), use clove hitch. Never will get lose under tension, and very easy to knot and release.
    Never use a threaded part as an anchor point. The tread can easily cut the rope. Use a horn cleat or a ringbolt instead.
    Adjusting the falling derrick to the proper length is a great idea to maintain better functionality (and higher safety), though, I suggest making proper plans to transfer tension from one line to another. Always use a security line during these procedures (a partial failure will be handled by a secondary option, if there is no substitute, the whole system will collapse in seconds).
    Both rising and lowering the tower, use a transfer point with a single pulley between the rising pulley system and you. It will also help you a lot to stay out of the danger zone. Before lowering, always lay out the rope in a very long S-curve, one line after another without crossing each other. This will prevent you from facing an unwanted knot on the lowering line. And if it may happen (it will, whatever you do), an extra horn cleat or clam cleat next to the above-mentioned transfer point will help you a lot to free both of your hands without releasing the holding tension.
    All other parts are within the "safe zone" of a prototype.
    And finally. Make a plan. A check-list. And follow it. After the action, make a debrief and note all your experiences and hints for the future-Cal. 😀
    All the best, 73 de
    Tom, HA5CST

  • @arthurgumbus3969
    @arthurgumbus3969 24 дні тому +3

    I do appreciate your angst over the lowering of the new mast system. History is a good teacher... You may want to make a sort of "checklist" to follow... when the adrenaline gets high the brain gets "low". This is an amazing series of videos and I do applaud you for the effort it takes to do this AND film it. Cheers Art W1SWL

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  24 дні тому +2

      Checklists are for committees. I always sit down BEFORE these things are get all this in my head. I have a bizarre ADHD mental agility. A checklist would go wrong for me.

  • @DD5LP
    @DD5LP 24 дні тому +2

    There's nothing wrong with being scared when doing these actions! I've found it makes you more cautious - which is a good thing. Ed.

  • @ianwhiting8822
    @ianwhiting8822 25 днів тому +3

    Well done Cal, your field looks like a model village version of the old Rugby Radio Station lol.

  • @mrmrlee
    @mrmrlee 25 днів тому +16

    If you cut that huge slot in the mast it will be weakened and might buckle. Don't do it! Run the cables alongside the mast with zip ties.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому +2

      It won't buckle. You have no idea sorry :)

    • @nlo114
      @nlo114 25 днів тому +7

      @@DXCommanderHQ
      As above, don't cut the pole. As soon as you cut a slot in it, it goes from being a tube, to being a channel-section and will lose torsional rigidity. (A scaffolder would scrap any pole with such a slot) When you factor in hole-edge finish, corrosion, and micro-cracking initiation due to aeolian vibration, the 'frightening' will increase quite a bit. Use black ty-raps.

    • @mrmrlee
      @mrmrlee 25 днів тому +7

      @@DXCommanderHQ Not meaning to seem rude, but you're talking about cutting a 1 inch wide channel in a pole that looks to be 2 inches diameter? That's like cutting a tree half through and not worrying about it falling in a storm. I've watched your channel for years, I'd just hate to see you getting any grief from your setup.

    • @BenCos2018
      @BenCos2018 24 дні тому +4

      @@DXCommanderHQ I wouldn't cut a hole in it personally tbh

    • @ronleblanc9832
      @ronleblanc9832 24 дні тому +1

      Lot of work but a beautiful set up

  • @kenmartin1211
    @kenmartin1211 25 днів тому +1

    You have a Great Mast System taking shape here and it's very enjoyable watching.. I just installed a 2 meter / 70 cm Antenna on my house... 38' to the peak and I was up there with a 1'' diameter x 12' Long mast with the Diamond 30 Antenna on top by myself... It was enough excitement for my day... But it's up and I'm on the air... Thank You for sharing the progress of this.. KC3ZDW 73

  • @jackK5FIT
    @jackK5FIT 25 днів тому +3

    This looks very much like a two man job to me. Being afraid and doing it anyway because it has to be done is courage. Good luck and be safe.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому +1

      May I ask what the second man would actually do? He would have to think the same as me, act when I thought it etc..!

    • @jackK5FIT
      @jackK5FIT 24 дні тому +2

      @@DXCommanderHQ I agree. It just looks dangerous.

    • @AubsUK
      @AubsUK 21 день тому +2

      @@DXCommanderHQ The second person could call for help ! 🤣🤭

    • @bill-2018
      @bill-2018 19 днів тому +1

      @@AubsUK That's what I thought. Accidents are not planned!
      G4GHB.

  • @TheDoctorhuw
    @TheDoctorhuw 25 днів тому +2

    Well done Cal, its good to be a liile bit affraid, keeps you sharp and ahead of future problems.

  • @lyfandeth
    @lyfandeth 25 днів тому +2

    You can buy stainless steel "slot frames" from marine suppliers. They are used on sailboat masts, to provide a smooth sliding surface when halyards are being fed into masts that way.

  • @radiotowers1159
    @radiotowers1159 25 днів тому +1

    Every time I luff my mast I feel the same, well done I know its complicated as you have so many guys etc to watch.

  • @alanslade2319
    @alanslade2319 25 днів тому +2

    Wow I've not heard of the falling Derek since my granddad god bless him, and I still don't believe him, till one day at work someone else said it, well done that man , looking forward to seeing the rest, take care of yourself and yours Alan 🇬🇧💯👍

  • @grandpaandlucas7054
    @grandpaandlucas7054 24 дні тому +2

    i run rg 213 up to the rotator then spice mini 8 to the antenna. i run the mini 8 through garden hose it protects the mini 8 from rubbing and stops snagging around the rotator. i then cable tie the hose up to the antenna the hose gently grips the coax and stops damage. if you chop out the pole it will weaken it.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  24 дні тому

      Yes it will weaken the pole. And so what? There is only downward force at the base.

  • @TheREALJosephTurner
    @TheREALJosephTurner 25 днів тому +2

    I know you must have been a bit nervous, because I was on the edge of my seat and I'm on the other side of the globe!

  • @julianrobertson3303
    @julianrobertson3303 25 днів тому +1

    Excellent as always , thank goodness for the mild weather .

  • @vicmiller7191
    @vicmiller7191 25 днів тому

    Given the fact you have seen a accident with this arraingment, you have the right to be a ratteled. And you are doing this by your self. But I do like the way it appears to work. When set up, I am sure it will make maintenace and changes easy to do. Job very well done Mister Calum. Take care and 73... Vic de KE8JWE

  • @m0bob
    @m0bob 25 днів тому

    I am really impressed with your mast Callum. I am sure it will be in production soon 😅 You deserve a hot chocolate or something stronger!

  • @andylinton2798
    @andylinton2798 25 днів тому +1

    Stellar work - on your own!

  • @Will_N4WIL
    @Will_N4WIL 25 днів тому

    That is quite the contraption! Enjoying the series 👍

  • @ianxfs
    @ianxfs 25 днів тому +1

    Yes, cup of tea and a rest after that. I hope you did too ☕️ 👍🏻

  • @DiscusRussell
    @DiscusRussell 25 днів тому +1

    Cal cutting a slot into the tube is not your best idea fella, but its your mast to do with as you please. I hope it all works out ok for you in the end without dramas

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  24 дні тому

      SO many folks about this slot. Think about it. What's going to go wrong? There is only downward force here. Speed up :)

    • @kurtpfister8359
      @kurtpfister8359 24 дні тому +1

      @@DXCommanderHQ It's only downward force, true. When the mast is vertical. Wind load and Raising/Lowering forces are not downward forces. That said, it IS your mast, your antenna farm, your call.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  16 днів тому

      Even lowering or raising, you would only have the downward force plus the physical weigh ot the pole, so 20-30kg more. ZIlch. Yes it's mine and out of all the things that COULD go wrong, this is way down the list.

  • @j.p.thearmoredchef
    @j.p.thearmoredchef 25 днів тому

    Good luck Cal!

  • @timgoad5750
    @timgoad5750 24 дні тому

    Good job Sir Callum

  • @mikesmithg0rfd356
    @mikesmithg0rfd356 24 дні тому

    thank you

  • @2321brendan
    @2321brendan 25 днів тому

    watching with interest ,as I need to do similar with my new to me, trailer able sail boat mast. 10.5m length.scary fun.

  • @paulwynneroberts1731
    @paulwynneroberts1731 24 дні тому

    Love it. Star man

  • @wilfredswinkels
    @wilfredswinkels 24 дні тому

    all your knots look up to par, you old boy scout 😀

  • @youtubeaccount931
    @youtubeaccount931 25 днів тому

    I do a cup of tea before as well as after.

  • @sparkyboots
    @sparkyboots 23 дні тому

    Does it ever get windy there? I suppose you purposely, film/work when there isn't much wind. Keep it up! Cheers!

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  19 днів тому

      It's the other way around.. I just don't film in the rain so I do something else. And Davinci Studio has an AI module that will totally remove wind noise etc.

  • @votremaitre3907
    @votremaitre3907 25 днів тому

    If you want to run the cables inside the mast, cut the notch at the very bottom iside where its clamped in the rotor. That's a much better option.

  • @davedave6404
    @davedave6404 25 днів тому +2

    Gloves to avoid rope burn.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому

      Prefer to let go.. Google "industrial accidents with gloves" (or any other clothing).

  • @James_Bowie
    @James_Bowie 25 днів тому +1

    Blue sky? Have you left England? 😃

  • @dodegkr
    @dodegkr 24 дні тому

    Maybe consider a pair of gloves when you do the up and down stuff with those ropes..

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  24 дні тому

      There are more industrial accidents BECAUSE of clothing than not. I can let go - but gloves can get caught.

  • @2140BlackCreek
    @2140BlackCreek 24 дні тому

    Humm. You lost me somewhere above the Lubbers hole. Suggest you contact your Navy and the staff of the HMS Victory and have a chat with her sailing master. Or, pick up a copy of :The Complete Rigger's Apprentice by Brion Toss.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  24 дні тому

      HAHA

    • @2140BlackCreek
      @2140BlackCreek 23 дні тому

      @@DXCommanderHQ Callum, of course not serious about the HMS Victory, yet the book I mentioned may help. B. Toss was a master at rigging and his clear explanations may help you and others when dealing with the erection and support of towers and poles. AA7MO

  • @stargazer7644
    @stargazer7644 25 днів тому +1

    "people have started calling a falling derrick a gin pole" Only the utterly clueless ones. They can be ignored.

  • @Chris-hy6jy
    @Chris-hy6jy 25 днів тому +1

    Wouldn't a tilt-over tower be easier to deal with?

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому +1

      How much do you think I have spent to far..? Two thrust bearings and a reel of cheap rope. Join the dots.

    • @Chris-hy6jy
      @Chris-hy6jy 25 днів тому

      @DXCommanderHQ you can't afford it, ok noted.

  • @bill-2018
    @bill-2018 19 днів тому

    I too don't like the idea of cutting a slot. Read on to my second paragraph.
    Showing how destructive wind can be I know an amateur who had a 60' commercially made three legged tower and it was up one very windy gusty night and he decided to drop it in height and lay it horizontally. The wind caught it and twisted it 90°. Three cross braced steel tube legs twisted!
    The point is, are you sure your mast will not twist in windy weather? Will it be held totally rigid? Twisting at the top but stressing the slot?
    I wouldn't cut it. As someone said below a scaffolder would reject it.
    But like you say, it is your mast.
    G4GHB.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  19 днів тому

      Will it twist? I have calculated that the couplers should slip or the rotator should give way before the steel in the event it's blowing a hurricane.

    • @bill-2018
      @bill-2018 19 днів тому

      @@DXCommanderHQ O.K.

  • @andylinton2798
    @andylinton2798 25 днів тому +1

    /pedant ON Point of discussion: Is it ɑ tower or ɑ mast? I've always called something guyed ɑ mast, and ɑ self-supporter ɑ tower. /pedant OFF

  • @oobihdahboobeeboppah
    @oobihdahboobeeboppah 25 днів тому

    Callum, couldn't you just run the cables through a PVC/EMT pipe going up?

    • @FjHenderson
      @FjHenderson 25 днів тому

      The rotor is at the ground, you have to loop the coax around the thrust bearing. Usually just a big loop gives enough to allow it to move 360 degrees without fouling up.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому

      No.. The whole tower rotates. That would be a nightmare.

  • @muddy11111
    @muddy11111 25 днів тому

    It would be less stressful with a wire rope hoist instead of the rope block. You can let go and walk away at any point.
    ebay 800kg Wire Rope Winch Hoist Manual Clamping Puller with Handle & Rope 10-50mtr

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому

      A lot of things would be less stressful but I'm not going to spend more than a few pennies..

  • @GM5DDX
    @GM5DDX 25 днів тому +1

    There’s got to be an easier way.

  • @mrmrlee
    @mrmrlee 25 днів тому

    Not a fan of towers with moving parts. Just make 2 or more inverted vees cut to whatever frequencies you prefer, set them to radiate at your preferred directions east/west, north/south etc. Suspend them from a tower and simply switch between elements to change direction. I was just talking to Europe on 10 meters with such a setup from the USA. Easy peasy!

    • @bill-2018
      @bill-2018 19 днів тому

      I've not been on much but a simple 10m attic dipole so about 28' high and 1Watt c.w. got me both Bulgaria and Sicily and later that week I did it again with two other stations with ½ Watt. So both about 1200 miles.
      Trying for U.S.A., maybe with my QRO of 5 Watts?
      G4GHB.

  • @potrzebiehuck
    @potrzebiehuck 25 днів тому

    Don't cut a slot in the pipe! You'll weaken it dramatically! Just run the cable one the outside.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому

      It won't.. I don't think you get it. There should be zero lateral load at that point.

  • @devinholland2189
    @devinholland2189 25 днів тому

    That block and tackle will not fair well exposed to the elements. If you can a sewer pipe or downspout with ends would keep it protected and reliable for the next time. Or take it in the shop when your not using it.

  • @andye2005
    @andye2005 24 дні тому

    Not too bad as a concept. I do have a couple of dislikes.
    I agree with the other comments regarding cutting a slot, that will seriously weaken the pole at the point of highest stress, As suggested go in at the bottom where the rotator clamp is.
    I don 't like that allen key pole fixing. widget. Dump it and use a standard scaffold right angle clamp, much more secure.
    Finally the pulley system, dump that as well, get a hand cranked winch they have plenty of gearing so you probably will not need any extra gearing, if you do a single snatch pulley block will double the gearing.
    You can make a fixture that will bolt onto that eye bolt to secure the winch. Using a winch will allow you to engage the ratchet if you want to stop and not have to try to tie off a rope.
    It's unlikely that you will need the bungie cord to get the pole moving down once you get the main antennas on the top. Just a slight push will get the thing moving.
    Using a winch you can just leave a slight bit of slack in the wire, and then give the derek a lift and things will start to move. Of course with another pair of hands this will not be such a problem anyway.
    Andy

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  24 дні тому

      Yes the pole will be weakend. But it doesn't matter. You guys are not thinking this through. There are no other forces on that base other than downward force..

  • @michaelltnv6741
    @michaelltnv6741 25 днів тому

    Please don't make a cut that big. It might just ruin what you accomplished. Great job. I wish I had your yard size.

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  25 днів тому +2

      Too late. And BTW it's fine.

    • @michaelltnv6741
      @michaelltnv6741 25 днів тому

      @DXCommanderHQ I'm glad to hear it. I really appreciate the effort you have made for us. Thanks

  • @FjHenderson
    @FjHenderson 25 днів тому

    I don't know why you didn't just make a hexbeam

  • @db3mi
    @db3mi 24 дні тому

    it's white ones. bemi, sheepman. 73

  • @brianlawrence9681
    @brianlawrence9681 9 днів тому

    Hi Callum what's you do it works but you make it so complicated that is not easy to follow I wish you all the best in your project love you mate I am my operator also they call me copy London UK on the East SideHi Callum what's you do it works but you make it so complicated that is not easy to follow I wish you all the best in your project love you mate I am my operator also they call me copy London UK on the East Side

    • @DXCommanderHQ
      @DXCommanderHQ  8 днів тому

      It's not supposed to be complicated.. But thanks for saying hello!

  • @FjHenderson
    @FjHenderson 25 днів тому

    I don't know why you didn't just make a hexbeam