'Gag order is a big part of this case': Friend of Judge Merchan weighs in on hush money trial
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 кві 2024
- Retired New York State Supreme Court Justice Jill Konviser, who has known Judge Merchan for 15 years, joined Chris Jansing to discuss former President Trump's hush money trial.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#GagOrder #Trump #donaldtrump
As soon as Merchan finds Trump in contempt Chutkan should state Trump is in violation of his terms of pretrial release. Lock him up! That will quicken the pace.
It’s the only thing that will work
There's also the one in GA who said the same thing. When it gets done with one, it can visit the other😅.
It's my hope that the trial will not move quickly if he is jailed. The more time he spends incarcerated the better.
Yes!!!!
Bumps?
A lot of people were jailed over far less "bumps".
Lock him up & he can enjoy the trial from jail where he belongs.
do you really expect to see him behind bars ?????
Fascist hypocrites are funny.
😅😅. Fascist blue is hilarious
@@Americasinertia You aren’t fluent on Fascist definition lol. Define it in one sentence
@@Americasinertia fascism is red, has always been red, you do know that right, oh wait you're a wilfully ignorant trump supporter and just don't know any better!!! Oh again do you even know what fascism is and how it works, please do explain that to everyone here, after all wasn't it you who said fascism is great???
Trump talks about other people lying????? oh FFS
that is called projection and every republican specially those that support trump do that and have always done that, they project what they are doing while they do that dirty dead!!!
He’s good at projecting
@@ecurewitzKeeping in mind projection is a psychological defense mechanism which allows for the displacement of the unwanted and nasty pieces of ourselves.
It's Trump default mechanism.
He thinks he should be the only one to be "the" LIAR !
Biden always lying and sleeping. Ask Hunter Biden about his millions. Corrupt Biden. So be a smart dumb sheep for Biden and remain ignorant and dumb and poor
this is such a massive joke.
When will America wake up and fix this system?
Best to escept, America messed up on this one so we can NOT un-ring the bell.
We're waiting for you.
@@413smr why??
Your question is a little ambiguous. Do you mean trump should be put in jail already for his contempt?
Never in the history of famous people has anyone whined as much as this man.
You mean 77 yo child.
START TREATING TRUMP LIKE ANY OTHER CRIMINAL DEFENDANT. Throw trump in jail for contempt
Yes! If any of the rest of us were to violate a judge's gag order, we would be thrown in jail! "King Trump" is no different!!!
Well if he's treated like any criminal defendant. The case would be dismissed , judges practice releasing those caught . It's catch and release . Do not complain when he's released then .
@@user-xl7kx7bi3l Catch and release is a Immigration policy, not a generic term.
@@user-xl7kx7bi3l none of the cases would be dismissed. trump's actions led to an attempted coup. People died. there are more than 2 million citizens in prison in the US, most on lesser crimes
Judge Merchan is absolutely brilliant!
@@americanpatriot6484we hope so! 💙 Biden 2024💙
Why doesn’t he have the courage to throw t in jail?
@@susangraim5490 because he can't throw Trump in jail.
@@user-ei8do4uq4j Why not?
@@americanpatriot6484How this pathetic lying creature can still get your support is beyond belief. To escape from a cult you first have to recognise that you are in one.
Rubbish! If he was any other defendant, he would be in jail right now.... in fact, he would have been jailed ages ago! So don't say the judge is trying to get it right by treating him like anybody else.
you are 100% I'm sick of hearing about how careful they have to be he isn't like any other citizen. In fact, he is! and they are the ones making this up!!The deputies will take him away, and the authorities can figure it out!!! And NO MORE secret service for convicted criminals!!!
@@GeneTurner-gg4yo
I completely agree! I'm sure the prison services and the secret services can work something out between them until the law is changed. It's not rocket science.
How about Trumps lies! Hes so stupid! He should not be able to speak outside the courtroom. Hes on a never ending loop of lies!
Every time he opens his mouth, he gets in more trouble
They don't want to lock him up because they're concerned with his base.. January six.. Not to worry most of them are in jail..
@@ecurewitz Exactly. My 8 year old grandson behaves better than Trump!
That’s not an intellectual argument
30,000+ when in office. It hasn’t slowed down
Maybe he goes in jail over night, every night after court until the next day a few days, or over the weekend, see if that stops the behaviour?
Would the court do that for any of us? He should go to jail and stay there until the trial ends. Deny him a public voice and make him crazy (Oh, wait, too late!).
Well, he incited a riot - when will he be held accountable for that?
Wasn't this gag order hearing supposed to happen THIS week?? Why has it been delayed YET AGAIN? FFS..............
It did happen this week, The judge is still twiddling his thumbs and contemplating what he should do about Donald Trump violating his orders and rubbing his face in it.
Because the judge wants to get it right.
that seems to be the game[delaying ??????]
Fear of Trump. He’s still running the country😢
These things take time. What's the rush anyway?
A gag order is pointless if it isn't enforced and so far, no one has done that, so...
so enforce it.
@@petermartell568 we're nobodies. we cant enforce it. this is on the judge.
PLEASE lock him up!!
first offense - for two weeks with NO cell phone or communications
second offense - until and through the trial with NO cell phone or communications.
PERIOD!!!!!!!!!!
That's far more severe than anything we are likely to actually see. None of our judges have the courage to actually enforce their own orders in any meaningful way.
Fascism is great
I bet just taking his cell phone and jacket away for one day will drive him crazy. More crazy.
@@Americasinertia ah now the truth comes out, is that why you support trump because you think fascism is great, perhaps you might want to move to Chine, or North Korea, or Russia if you love it so much, oh wait maybe you're over there already and you're just projecting that!!!
@@Americasinertia
Judge needs to take back control of this case. Book him and send a message. Trump running ruff shot over this judge.
45 can be put in jail and it would not delay the trial!!
All talk no cojones Trump knows that Democrats are weak😂😂😂
What happened to
NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW ?????!!!!!!!
Cult45 proves every day he's above the law. The courts just verify he's above the law by doing nothing.
Trump insists on special treatment
except trump
Biden is only one
How is putting him in the pokey going to delay anything? Really! He’ll be even closer to the courtroom …
Because he would appeal
These people have this irrational, rabid desire to put Trump in prison. It is weird and not normal
@@canderson1955 He cannot appeal a judge finding him in contempt and enforcing his orders. Trump can appeal after he is convicted - but, not before.
@@keithm9337 What is weird and not normal is the biggest crybaby on the entire planet to have millions of people willing to throw their support behind him.
@@keithm9337 We are all tired of all the whining. Jail the Dumpster and let the rest of us move forward.
Lock him up , OVER THE WEEKEND, so he might reconsider doing it again(since he will not be out campaigning.
I think a quiet move at about 2 a.m Saturday morning to the local jailer would be quiet and contemplative -- and Trump can whinge eternally.
Jail until the trial is over, solitary confinement, no electronics, prison food, prison Monday in prison garb, the weekend might work but I doubt it , for the trial would be better!!!
What happened to the Miranda rights? "You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say will come against you in the court of law."
Trump can’t remain silent
@@ecurewitz he can't keep his mouth shut unless the judge throws him in jail.
@@dianaramirez2561 and even that might jot work
He's forgotten it or he doesn't go by it, Trump
Will Donnie get any prison time if found guilty on all counts? Or just fines he won't pay?
I suspect this entire trial will only demonstrate that he's still getting away with it.
That is a concern of mine also.
I'm new to Earth. Can someone explain the reason for a gag order that has no consequences? Please and thank you.
Money
He is only human... Why would you say something negative about a person who's Holds your future on the gavel...⚖️
Exactly...he holds power over you and won't stop til you die...justice system wins!😅
Sorry Judge, your'e doing a poor job, if you need more time to make sure you come to the right decision for a defendant that constantly breaks the rules with the crazy followers that he has
The end of your freedom is close, Donald!👍
Merchan is exceptional from my point of view.
I was perplexed at first by Merchan's reluctance to rule on the gag order but I think he might be giving Trump this leeway so that he doesn't appear in any way to be a victim that people, and especially the jury can feel sorry for.
It may, in fact, create a sense of purpose for the jury to be the ones who finally hold Trump accountable for his crimes.
Weekend time outs wont interfere with the case.
🌊🌊🌊 Blue Wave 🌊🌊🌊
❤️🤍💙 Biden/Harrs 2024 ❤️🤍💙
Why doesn't the Judge start with banning Trump from doing media bits outside the Courthouse! and fine him for the first few, with the rest held for future judgement. Not giving him a ruling on all the gag order breaches seems to have had a tiny bit of an effect, so keep jail time as a warning for any future breaches and tell Trump it will be on you and it will be jail time!
Judge Konviser, is an example of what I think some of the SC judges lack. The SC is a political platform.
Lock him up.
NAW, **** THAT! Everybody keeps trying to say "Nobody is above law." when they're on the judicial side of this, like this woman here. "He'll take his time and get it right...." No, all you people are doing is making us citizens MORE AWARE of what WE already knew. You do WHATEVER you want with rich folks and then he rest of us have OUR OWN punishments and rules. The fact that people like this woman keep coming on here to rub our noses in it, is INSULTING!
if i violated as many gag orders as trump, id spend more time in prison than he did working during his term.
95% of jurors is 17.1 jurors. So please ask 45 who the .1 is!!!
And there's bail conditions....
Trump should spend a Wednesday in the cell in the courthouse. Whole day! Maybe that would shut him up!
With everything we know he has done criminally denying any participation and just blaming others is beyond contempt… how I hate this man…..
Interesting to hear another judge speak about this.
Excellent. Thank you.
GAGING IS A BIG PART OF THIS CASE? YOU MEAN WHEN STORMY WAS ON HER KNEES? 😂
ANOTHER hearing?
yes,a convicted liar FOR YOU!!
There, there, relax and take deep breaths. I am going to talk you down.
Let me guess, someone used the wrong pronoun on you, right?
They didn't know you where a They/Them because they saw only one of you.
Then they told you there was only 2 sexes, male & female and that's when you lost it, correct?
Okay, first you need to find a safe space - then you need to phone 911 and report a "hate crime"
and make sure they use your plural Pronoun They/Them. If they ask for 2 ID's, tell them no, there
only one of you - Good luck!
Even if it were just 24 hours in jail. It would at least something
The most shocking part is Todd Blanche standing next to Trump and not saying or doing anything while he's blatantly violating the gag order. He better forget about NYC after this, his reputation is toast-burnt, even.
Give him a "timeout"! Let him sit out a morning or afternoon of the trial in the holding cell just down the hall in the courthouse. Timeouts are often used by parents with children who don't behave. If he continues, then more "timeouts" - A "happy compromise - somewhat milder than sending him to jail for the weekend.
Merchan will do NOTHING.
Accordion hand is yet another nick name for him.
The judge should tell trump. Next time he violates the gag order, Wednesday will be court days too. 😊😊
A conviction of criminal contempt violates his condition of release in Georgia. Should get interesting.
A hearing next Thursday????????? Didn't they do that yesterday????????????????????
Thanks for sharing
As you would expect from a retired judge, a very articulate lady with carefully balanced insight. I hope we hear more from her as the trial progresses.
And? And? And? Were are the consequences of the gag order!
Quicker action from judge. A regular criminal who cannot control his dog, does not get to delay the penalty. Judge can collect $1000 immediately, or if he does not pay IMMEDIATELY, trump spends a night in jail, with regular guards, not secret service.
Someone tell the defendant that just because he says something doesn't make it true.
Why does this judge keep putting off punishment for this monster??? He's getting away with this crap every week and judge Merchan does nothing to him!!!🤬🤬🤬 This is total BS!
This gag order is in violation of our 1st ammendment rights: FREE SPEECH!
But it’s a waste of time - judge won’t take effective action no courage
It's so cute watching him gesture with his little hands
Hah! They really are tiny. There's a pic with his foot next to someone's. His foot was incredibly small. Small feet; small socks.
Infringement on a person's constitutional rights.
If she is doing interviews and knows the judge this case is over
What are some of the infrastructures that FDJT CAN BE GUILTY OF.
Gag order is No used unless judge executes jail penalty !
You can legally yell fire in a crowded theater: you want to warn people after all. What you can't do is falsely yell fire in a crowded theater and thereby unnecessarily cause panic. Get it right.
Thanks for the great reporting and discussions on this historical first week of the trial of the disgraced wannabe dictator ex-president 😡⚖️🇺🇲👏
5:03 You get more 'flies' with honey, than with vinegar; but you get less respect with syrup. 🤔🧐
He is NOT treated like other defendants, any other defedant would have been jailed by now for similar behaviour,
Yep, you got indicted for that Trump.
her eyes are beautiful.
What's the reason for the gag order?
Different rules 4 different folks. Rest my case 😌
Most mechanics know that when troubleshooting a horn to stick a rag in it so as not to annoy others.
What if you have to honk to avoid an accident?
*WHY I$ The Fir$t Amendment "fundamental" but the 14th I$ NOT???!!!*
Judge should check weekly on Wednesday with the gag order …, if trump really wants to campaign maybe he should adhere to the gag order.
I don't listen to LIARS. Please STOP giving him free air time. You are a responsible for his notoriety as he himself is.
Of course it’s a big part; how else can you manipulate, but to silence your opponent?? Thats your, Democracy… Thanks Jim S
Mam! people violate pretrial conditions all of the time so why in this case would it slow the case down??? That makes no sense! In fact moving away from his antics might help move the trail along!
So a supreme court judge can speak about a fellow judges active case and the case isnt in closed why when this breaks the ethics rules of law
NOPE. I don't pollute myself by listening to a LIAR.
I like the bit where she said “if we find them to be impartial then we get them out.” Little slip of the tongue there. Telling the truth on msnbc? That’s weird.
Ok imma call this out ..judge Merchan seems to respect his position of power and I'm pretty sure he is not telling folks about this case over a bbq
I can't help but admire the judges strategy in not calling Trump on his challenging the Gag order. If one thinks back to some of the other cases, as soon as he is called on it, he appeals. A higher court puts a stay on the case and there is a delay. As currently proceeding the trial is moving along and the ball is in Trump's court to see if he will escalate it to the point that an Appeals court can do nothing but support the judges decision due to severity or where the case has progressed to.
If regular Americans violate a judge's gag order, the court would swiftly act and punish them. "King Trump" should be no different!!!
This would be an interesting jury to be on, regardless of the outcome. Being impartial when everyone on both sides wants you to be impartial, would be something they should be proud of if they manage to do that. You can never be sure what a jury will do, and that is why trials need to be held. At some point, there will be a verdict. Until then, all this speculation and analysis means little.
I heard from a lawyer that this judge can sentence Trump to jail after the trial is over! I didn’t know he could do that 😁
Why are we still talking about it. There is no acceptable reason for not ruling on this sooner. Someone explain it.
They are not “alleged” gag violations! Why aren’t you calling them out?
What about community service - a month for each violation? This would happen to us normal people. Or all three as he needs jail, solitary and incommunicado.
NEXT Thur????!!!!! Why so long????
One violation of gag order is equal to 1 year of jail. At the end of the trials, the number of violations to be added to the sentence. It is going to be much longer period for trump's jail.
They stick together always have......
Didn't they already have a hearing on the gag order violations?
The 1st time, these violations are for the 2nd thru 10th time
@@Julian198-hv2zx I thought the first was for the 1-10 violations and that his verdict would be out by now.
@@tra757200 Yes the first hearing was for the first ten violations, the judge was quite clear that the argument from Trump lawyer were BS and that he was "loosing all credibility" but said that he still needed to deliberate before making his call about the exact sanction. Now it seems that he intends to group the decision about the first 10 with the new hearing for the 11th to 14th, delaying it by another week ...
& im not a bot
lol lady just contradicted herself at 5:08 to 5:45
"yes and no... it's effective because it makes no difference" (actually it's always yes, never no, to the question asked)
MERCHAN IS AS POPULAR AS HAMAS.
Hey,you should of thought of that before committing Crimes in a Liberal Cities...WE CAN'T LET CRIMES GO COLD CASE,BRING IT BACK,bring it back...
'Bumps" this is ridiculous - anyone else would have been carted from the courtroom to jail and back the next day..... so NO he is not acting like he would with any other person!! Are you kidding me - yet again another person letting this man bully them.
I'm tired of hearing judges and media people saying that the judge lacks options on how to deal with Trump's violation of the gag order because of this or that and nobody is talking about the safety of the witnesses and the jurors along with court personnel safety. When are we the people going to be considered first because this man is a threat to others!?
Wait what? I thought that Michael Cohen wasn't it's lawyer🤔.