Who Destroyed Bengal ?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 лип 2023
- #URGENT | Help Vaishnavi by clicking on her Ketto fundraiser link here: bit.ly/Save-Baby-Vaishnavi Your support can save her life!
-------------------------------------------------
Why Bengal is Falling ? | End of Bengal | The Downfall of Bengal | The Downfall of Bengal Economy | What is wrong with Bengal's Economy | Bengal economic crisis | Bengal Economic Problem | Fall of Bengal | Why Bengal Economy is Failing ? | Bengal Economy
In this compelling video, we delve into the pressing topic of "The Downfall of Bengal Economy," investigating the root causes behind the economic challenges faced by the region and exploring potential solutions to catalyze its resurgence.
With its rich history and diverse cultural heritage, Bengal has been a significant player in India's economic landscape. However, recent times have witnessed a downturn in its economic fortunes, prompting deep concerns among its citizens and policymakers alike. Join us as we shed light on the complexities of this issue.
Key points covered in this thought-provoking video:
In-depth analysis of Bengal's economic history, growth trajectory, and pivotal sectors that have been affected.
Identification and exploration of the major challenges that have contributed to the decline, including industrial stagnation, unemployment, infrastructure gaps, and more.
A comprehensive examination of the role of policy decisions, political factors, and external influences on Bengal's economy.
Insights from experts and economists who share their perspectives on the underlying causes and potential strategies for economic revival.
Thoughtful consideration of possible solutions, innovative initiatives, and measures that could reinvigorate Bengal's economic landscape and uplift its people.
Whether you're a concerned citizen, an economic enthusiast, or simply curious about the intricacies of regional economies, this video is a must-watch.
-------------------------------------------------
MORE POWERFULL VIDEOS:
💼Business Case Studies: • Business Case Studies ...
🏭Dark Sides of Industries: • Dark Sides of Industri...
📈Stock Market Case Studies: • Stock Market Case Stud...
🏟Startup Case Studies: • Startup Case Studies
🎧Aditya Saini Podcasts: • Playlist
-------------------------------------------------
MY SOCIAL MEDIA HANDLES:
📸 Instagram: / aditya.saini4
📝 Linkedin: / adityasainiofficial
🐤 Twitter: theadityasaini?t=...
📹 Facebook: / realadityasaini
📟 Facebook Page: / adityasaini04
💬 DISCORD: / discord
🩳 Shorts Channel: / @opencastclips
-------------------------------------------------
📱FOR COLLABORATION & BUSINESS INQUIRY: collabwithadityasaini@gmail.com
THANK YOU SO MUCH
#adityasaini #bengali #bengalinews #westbengal #westbengalnews #economy #bengal #westbengalnews #westbengalpolitics #mamatabanerjee #mamata_banerjee #mamata #westbengalnews #indianeconomy #india #DownfallofBengal #BengalChallenges #BengalEconomicDecline #PathToProgress #BengalEconomy #EconomicDecline #BengalRevival #EconomicChallenges #IndiaEconomy #PolicySolutions #EconomicAnalysis#BengalHistory #CollectiveVision #BengalRevival
#URGENT | Help Vaishnavi by clicking on her Ketto fundraiser link here: bit.ly/Save-Baby-Vaishnavi Your support can save her life!
JAB AAP BACHA PAAL NAHI SAKTE TOH BKL CHUDAI MACHATE HI KYU HO IF YOU CANT EVEN FEED YOURSELF WHY DAMN GIVE BIRTH TO KIDS
yah sab ka peace Hai Tera Abba Modi. central government Bangal Mein invest karne Nahin deta dusra company ko. Bangal ka yah HAL hone Ke Piche Central Government ka dosh hai. Jab India power Mein aaega FIR Bengal theek ho jaega. Tu Tera UA-cam mein Vyapar state karana ismein Dhyan den. Jab India power Mein aaega tab dekhna 2 sal ke andar bilkul change ho jaega. Jaisa Modi ka Gujarat abhi ho raha hai.
@@integratedfarm2080gawar kahika 😂
Congress jitgaya to Momta chalane wale hein I.N.D.I.A ko 🤣🤣😅... 💀
East command Islamic jihadi headquarters __--_ Waste bengal🚬
West Bengal has been destroyed by
East Bengal immigrants (Bangal). They (Bangal) forms CPI(M) & TMC government and dominant over orginal people of West Bengal (called "Ghoti"). Bangal people is destroying everything and looting everywhere in West Bengal.Bangals are emotionally connected with East Bengal now Bangladesh.Bangals hates lndia, West Bengal, Ghoti and other races of lndia.Communist and TMC government led by Bangal people and Bangal people turn Ghoti into slave in West Bengal.Bengal was leader in industry in British Raj because lt was United.And Bengal was divided into to parts -1.
West Bengal (India) 2. East Bengal (East Pakistan) in the partitions of lndia.Partition of lndia was one of the big reasons of West Bengal's deindustrialization situation and poor economy.Jai Hind.
I am a Bengali and I am just sad that people here have voted for such a evil political party 😢
Its Not You Who Are voting .. its Immigrants
PK has managed the counting officers.
better than double engine ki sarkar like manipur
@@PEAKPERFORMAaby thoda padhai kr jaake
@@ROHITB100 Tere se zyada pada likha hu 5 fail
As a bengali..I'm happy to be a part of this state..but at the same time after seeing today's condition I'm also sad
😂😂😂🤮🤮🤮🤮
আমারও একই অবস্থা...
I m nt Bengali but living in Bengal and I must say that in Benegal people are highly educated and they truly respect women. Women’ condition in wb is better than other developed state like delhi, Haryana, Gujarat and so on…..
Khela hobe
🇮🇳ns are scared greedy and corrupt by birth.
Being a bengali, I'm really sad to see the condition my home state.
Earlier, Bengal missed the IT revolution, then many other industrial opportunities. Now, the state is really dying and the corrupt politicians are busy filling their own pocket 😢😢
Another hatred propoganda from Arya refugees (Brahmin, Kayastha), Huna invaders (Rajput, Gujjars), Ahom chinese refugees to show indigeneous muslims in poor light.
Now which party u will vote?
রাত যতই গভীর হোক না কেন ভোরের আলো ততই এগিয়ে আসে। আমার বিশ্বাস আমার বাংলা আবার ভারতের অন্যতম সেরা রাজ্য হিসেবে পরিচিত হবে।❤
আশা করি তাই হবে
Ekdom thik🕉🇮🇳🕉
No hope until people vote to momta
Yes keep voting the same way and be proud of it. Bengal will be the most developed state in India. Trust me it's always the central government's fault why there is no development in Bengal😅. And keep reinvesting on those old colonial building repairs and hallucinate on how rich bengal was once (No I mean one should be proud of the ones who looted bengal once and should preserve their creations as a remembrance). Truly said bengal will rise again after the Sun of our solar system is aged enough to be black hole someday. Important lesson to learn from these positive thinkers. Hallucinations are the way to development and action means nothing.
laorar bichi hobe. bhanga chora bari ghor thik koro aage
Reason of Bengal's downfall
1-illigal Bangladeshis
2-political issue
3-crime rate
4-graveyard for business
5-mamta banarji
ভাগ শুয়োর পরাধীন পশ্চিম বাংলার ভিখারিরা নিজেরা উন্নতি করতে পারে না আবার বাংলাদেশকে টানে 😂
Yep, that guy didn't mentioned the illegal migration.
The only conclusion.. MAMTA BANERJEE
Right
@@Tausif-tr7dj Bengal is ruled by trinamul. So she is the main problem.
Bengal is a great example to show how politics destroys everything...sad to see the downfall of the state where I grew and lived for 17 years...
Another hatred propoganda from Arya refugees (Brahmin, Kayastha), Huna invaders (Rajput, Gujjars), Ahom chinese refugees to show indigeneous muslims in poor light.
Politics nahi islam bolo
@@kishanaahir3260 kiser Islam Ora oder moton thak tor oto ki tui sala bjp r maal bujhte perechi ebar baler party tar chatis tui Durga Puja te dekhechis maar danga hote ram navami te hoy Keno bol tui amay Durga Puja te Muslim Rao Jay Prasad khay onek Muslim Jay ar chinta nei bjp astei parbe na Jodi ase Hindu Muslim korbe diye Durga Puja teo maar danga hobe
@@kishanaahir3260Right
@@kishanaahir3260Kuch bhi bakwas kar raha hai. 😂 we don't need Gujarati industries in bengal.
Ha tumko q dikkat hai ye bhi ham bata dete hai. Q ki bengalis BJP ko vote nhi diya. 😂😂😂 nhi ji ham apne howrah bridge ambani ko bechna nhi chate naahi Victoria memorial ko kisi k pass girwi rakhna chate hai. Hamare eha government properties public ka hi hai uska privatisation ham nhi chate.
Bengal ko bengal ki tarah khubsurat dekhna chate hai. Bengalis are educated people. So we believe in equality and diversity. Ham har ek culture ko respect karte hai. Bengal 1976 me jaise bhukmari k sikar hua tha or separation k doran jaise violence k sikar hua tha. Waise halat agar UP, Bihar, Ya fir Gujarat ka hota. To aaj tumlog katora lekar ghumrahe hote.
Bengal aaj bhi 10₹ me bharpet khana mil jata hai. Eha bhukmari nhi hai. So ye bakwas band karo. Itna hi padi hai to Central government (modiji) ko bolo tax kam karne k liye.
Some major reasons for this downfall of W.B.
1. Femine caused by British Govt. 1943
2. Partition
3. Freight equalization policy adopted by the centre post independence
4. Anti-establishment activities of leftist Govt and parties
5. Ousting of major industrialists by the then opposition, TMC supported by others
Partition toh Haryana aur Punjab ka bhi hua lekin voh Bengal se kai guna achee hai
Very much appreciated with you,I am from Bengal , people hear starts morning with political talking they even not know this how much we are falling down... your ways of explaining is too good.
I'm a Bengali and I'm saying This is the most detailed analysed video I've ever seen about WB's downfall. Thank you 🙏🏼
share karo sab apne parents ko dikhao
It took a non Bengali to make such info. Shows the bengali are useless scum freeloaders
@@ModifiedRulesBengal kitnabhi niche gir jaye Bihar se hamesha uper rahega.
Tumi akta bokachoda
Kigo, first e sudhu lekha ta porlam account ta kheyal korini 😬
As a Bengali we are in trap of regional politics of TMC, CPM. They capture Panchayat Vote using State Election Commission and get advantage in Bidhansobha, Loksabha. National parties are not aware about Bengal politics. People are helpless.
CPM is over. And under TMC, Bengal has been among faster growing states. Bengal is still in far better shape than the North India states. And that is despite multiple famines, partition, CPIM disaster rule and central governments being partial against Bengal.
I am not saying the growth is because of TMC, but TMC is as good as any politics you are going to get. Politicians are corrupt. If you want to improve Bengal, don't look for jobs. Create jobs.
TMC is doing everything to win vote. TMC government have no future planning for development, employment, industrialisation etc. TMC only calculating how to get vote. TMC distributing patta, identity to Bangladeshi people to create secure vote bank.
@@betadevbbatol baji ta bhalo hyeche aro batol dite hobe tomar pisir 'pulma', geraso rupay ka gas pe bina paisa ka chaal fut raha er moton...
People are not helpless kisne bola tha Mamta ko vapas jitane ke liye
@@betadevbwake up kido
Bengal needs to come back!
We are a border state!
A weak border state means weaker borders!😢
sir maine pura A to z video dekha
Thank you so much for your great informations .
Very imp video 🙏🙏💐💐
As a pure Bengali, it is hard to say Yes, it is true and it is very sad for us. Only 2 Govt ends everything. One didn't do anything in 34 yrs and next one is unimaginable.
One didn't do anything and the other did everything even what we could barely imagine 😂😂 jokes apart 🙏
Mao zedong was still alive during indo china war in 1962
What's impure Bengali?
@@blackwolf5947 those who came from Bangladesh and settled in west Bengal
@@blackwolf5947 Radicalized illegal Bangladeshi mullah
As a Bengali I actually feel ashamed of the condition of bengal now 😢….Gladly my father left bengal and now we are well settled in Maharashtra and actually living peacefully here.I can actually say this is the most detailed video about Bengal
Iam living in JAMMU CITY INDIA
To Bhai kuchh karo aese maar kha kyu rahe kyu jel rahe ho itna sab 😢
@@hvv001 kya kare BJP ko vote de?saala ek dhang ka candidate nahi hain....saab saale gandh failate hain..... religion k basis pe vote de ne se kya hoga???kuch development hoga kya???Bengal k halaat na TMC na BJP na CPIM sudhar sakta hain... Village based politics chalta hain yaha...gaon k unpad gareeb logo ko manipulate aur brainwash karo....apna vote bank bharo aur gayab ho jao
@@hvv001 Bhai hum nahi jhel rahe hai Bengal ke log apne galtiyo ki saza bhugat rahe hai
@@Mvd9911Bengal ke log nhi Bangladeshi immigrants ne Mamta ke party ko vote kara he kyuki usne unhe illegally India laya aur WB me settle kiya. It's not us..
THIS VIDEO IS VERY IMPORTANT, USEFUL AND HELPFUL.
A true and transparent presentation!!!
I am a bangali so first thing i know evry votting prossec is unfair all winning are fake
We all are waiting for complete collapse of West Bengal 😂😂😂🤭🤭
@@sharad7340oh , it will happen to your state
Waysa hota to BJP 77 nahi milta
Tum savi youtuber Bengal ko badnam karne ma busy ho 😡😡 I'm also Bengali 😡 paid promotion youtuber
@@UnishAli-xm8fk jyada overacting mt kr bangladesh vaapas jaa 🤣🤣🤣
Bengal has set an example that how negative politics can ruin a state. People of Bengal had always chosen a government who actually wasn't having a far sight visionary to uplift condition of the state. Present government is a corrupted one from top to bottom.
People are but a reflection of leaders
Very informative video. Nicely explained on detoriation/degradation of Bengal.
आदरणीय महोदय, आपके विचारों से मैं पूर्णतया सहमत हूं ।
I strongly agree with you.
As a bangali i want to say
If Bangladesh imegration not stop than Bengal is the next Kashmir 😢.
They destroy everything for a vote😭
I think we should change the ministry 💪
Same as Tripura State
@@danieltripura3891 am live in tripura amarpur and I also knew it Tripura has no company
No means no ...😢
No out going investment in tripura
For that reason I thinking to move on Tripura and live in Chennai 😢😢😢
@@Ridjoy_Deycome to ahmedabad Gujarat bro
We are developing really fast
@@infinix2005that's not a solution
@@infinix2005 aise nhi hota bhai kalko gujrat mai bhi aise hoga fir kaha jayega Huma lagna hoga inse
You did not highlight when TATA tried to set up a factory in Bengal, however due to TMC leader and Current CM of Bengal Mamta Banerjee so called Didi manipulate the farmers and started a hunger strike. Unfortunately TATA had to Shut down the factory 😞
Bruh Mamata did that during CPI(M) rule to uproot the communist government and make herself project as the Messiah of Bengal, due to which she became the Chief Minister in 2011.
Erm... didn't even supreme court pass a verdict on this in 2016?
Supreme Court verdict? Things have procedures and you can't forcefully acquire lands. Also, there's a rumour that TATA won't ever work in Bengal but there are many factories and hotels run by TATA in the state.
😢😢😢😢yesss
@@shawmavamukherjee9635 all of them are preexisting factories and hotel...which preceded Mamata's rule. No new factories were opened since, there were news of them shifting from jamshedpur to kharagpur last year, but those were bluffs by our cm which never materialised.
Excellent analysis. Every word is true and valuable 😢
As a Bengali I just want to say, Every words is true....👍
Actually Bengal mein Technical investment aur Industrial Growth bohot hi zaroori hai.
😢😢
it's true every word 😢
Kerala also going to same path
Reasons
1.Partition of Bengal
2.Five year Plan
3.Freight equlising policy
4.Jyoti Basu
5.Mamata Banerjee
Only one CM tried to change that's Buddhadev Bhattchaya but People of Bengal dethroned him
People of Bengal are responsible for voting to commies for 34 years and gundas for 13 years running.
Unbelievable selection, congrats on falling behind even BIMARU state of MP in GDP per capita income 🤢
People of Bengal are responsible for voting to commies for 34 years and gundas for 13 years running.
Unbelievable selection, congrats on falling behind even BIMARU state of MP in GDP per capita income 🤢
That communist was no different than his preferences
That communist was no different than his precedents 😅
Freight equal charges policy and subsequently removing manbhum district from bengal was a devastating reason. Although we got back purulia but majority of resources went out of bengal. Industrialists from west india took advantage of this policy by buying raw materials at the same rate at which factories of calcutta bought. Bengal government did not protest against this policy which was a blunder. If companies got raw materials at same rate even if they are far from the source, they will set up factory on the west coast for the ease of exporting to the western countries.
Thanks for your information
I don't know when those days will come back
The fall of Bengal not only impacted WB but it has impacted the whole neighborhood. Strong Bengal will be beneficial for the whole region ( Bihar ,Odisha,Jharkhand and North East ) . I hope Politicians and Bureaucrats think about the development of WB by keeping aside their own egos , differences and their own wealth creation.
Apke baat mein dum to hai
Odisha bihar are recovering now bro
Hindutani MC
@@rishavyadav2000only Odisha
@@Overflowersonlyno now Bihar is also developing
As a bengali * bangladeshi Muslim* sabse bade karan hai . 😢
That's so wrong
Bangladesh is better than India... Almost every sector
@@Honeypots22 yes
@@XxxYyy-pu1ny ikr..
That's so Right
Very informative. The sun will rise again.
But in the case of Bangladesh, it is completely different. When we got independence in 1971, we were a very poor country, but from there we built "Sonar Bangla". Today, Bangladesh is considered a role model of development in the whole world. I am proud to be a Bangladeshi.
Bloody Sonar Bangla 😂
Maybe your income is very high, but the middle class cannot afford daily necessary commodities.
Yes, Bangladesh is sonar Bangla to a certain group of people.
@@Abdullah-do2trতোর এত সমস্যা থাকলে ভিকারিষ্টান যা যা
Kangladeshi day dreaming 😂😂😂
@@user-jw5bl9iu7n😂😂😂 toiletless country India
Bro try to respect other countries.than other countries people will respect your country. This kangladesh is doing better than India in a lot of term. @@user-jw5bl9iu7n
As a Bengali ,I feel so sad for my state..how some politicians corrupted the entire state, 😢 infrastructure falls down ,people r jobless , industries r abondoned , GDP got down ..everything destroyed
Tmc kuch kara raha hai too gotalaa
😢😢
Only TMC destroy bengal
As a Bengali Hindu im happy to stay here, But after seeing this condition i can say we are facing very bad problems, And the most biggest problem is its very hard to get a job in bengal.
Which is your profession?
As a bengali i am very happy but at the same time after watched today's conditions😢
I am From west bengal but I am always happy in my west bengal ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I left Bengal in 1998 and left India in 2002. When I read stories of India’s progress and watch videos, I get optimistic about India, especially for states like UP, MP, Haryana etc. But when it comes to Bengal stories, I get depressed, especially when Mamata blabbers and misleads the innocent and ignorant people of Bengal.
I fear the seeds of intelligence in Bengal have been left in the harshest conditions for decades and may not germinate properly. And if some gritty ones manage to sprout, may not flourish for lack of nourishment. But we must try. And I hope and pray a regime change with divine blessings will be the turning point.
The three guiding stars of the current political dispensation at the Centre are all from Bengal; Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose on the political front, Swami Vivekanada on the spiritual front and Ravindranath Tagore on the cultural front. And I am convinced our PM has very high respect for the core values of Bengal and will do a wonderful thing for Bengal if given opportunity and reasonable amount of time. But first we the progressive people of Bengal must first uproot the invasive weeds whose roots have gone too deep over the decades in the fertile plains of Bengal. Jai Maa Durga, Jai Maa Kali!
Ap abhi kaha par rahti hoo.
Dominance of one party rule ,one party monopoly,dirty politics in bengal,people has to be educated enough to choose the leader , be wise while choosing the leader, once Plato sayd ," if you. Refuse to participate in politics then you will end up ruling by your inferiors*"
Regime change is now inevitable for Bengal to regain it's lost glory.
What is the solution
Very sad, Bengalis are so artistic sweet cultured now it is polluted.
As a Bengali I feel shame, if you visit Kolkata you won't find any new thing, all are made in British time...
And in other place of Bengal, people still live in soil made house (can you imagine)
Bengal is garbage of India and violence capital of India...
I really feel shame as a bengali
🤡🤡
@@FuCKBuntY do you think different?
@@amitpaul6109I don't what world you are living in.
A lot of things have been built post independence. Entire Salt Lake. The state is a surplus producer of electricity. Lot of industrial projects have started over the last few years, and many are in progress.
Kolkata doesn't have nearly the same infrastructural issues as Bangalore. No safety problems like Delhi. It has a higher GDP than Bangalore, Hyderabad. For women, Kolkata is still by far the safest metro.
I can understand comparing Kolkata to Mumbai or Chennai - but both the cities (and Bangalore) benefited from favorable central government policies and targeted investments. But Kolkata has improved a lot since the early 2000s, and it is getting better. And there is now even a small startup scene (with some pretty good companies). Bengal has had among highest MSME growth in last few years in the country.
We have much larger issues than Bengal the state - there are terrible central govt policies since 2009 or so around tax terrorism and not allowing or killing new industries - that's what is holding the country back as a whole.
@@betadevb Kolkata footpath is captured by Bangladeshi people. TMC local party worker collecting monthly fee from them.
@@betadevb you are comparing Kolkata with Bangalore, Hyderabad in terms of development. Where Kolkata should be compared with Delhi, Chennai, Mumbai. These 4 are metropolitan cities. Where Delhi is the capital, Mumbai is financial capital and Chennai has one of the best Medical Sector, What is Kolkata. And you are talking about Kolkata and Salt Lake only. I lived in Salt Lake for 20 years and living in New Town for 2 years, New Town is fairly developed and modern but salt lake is not in a condition, roads are broken, street lights wont work in many streets.
The sun will shine on us again.Just wait and watch.....
Today i am 76 yrs old born and brought up in Kolkata in my childhood i saw dazzling and smood Calcutta most of the products made in Calcutta then came the time to close down production units instead of modernizing kolkata we started chasing IT sectors from coming to WB followed by mass migration of skilled workers in their place refugees from neighbouring countries who had nothing to offer for the development of the state today every inch of WB is getting occupied by them now winning elections is the only policy and where is the time and money for the development
As a bengali from W.B, wb's downfall started in CPM era 30 years ago, Current TMC govt just accelerate this process several times faster. The way Bangladeshi people are coming to wb is alarming but current govt is literally helping them to get all the id by providing fake birth certificate first, then school certificate, then rashan card, pan card and then finally adhar, schools in village areas are full of Bangladeshi children, they just came to school along with their parents to eat the mid day meal. and they do threat school teachers if they don't get food..
Because the economic condition of West Bengal is very bad. There is no major industry, businessman in West Bengal. So they blame Bangladesh for everything😂😂😂 lazy people cannot do anything without blaming.
@@nafsizawed3188 i would have argued with you only if your name was not nafis, because arguing with brain less community is point less. but still i'll ask you to go to taki, basirhat and other stations and just sit there beside the ticket counter just for a day, you'll get your answer how many people came from bangladash
@@nafsizawed3188shutup bitchass sach sunna main itni gand faad gyi
@@nafsizawed3188 You are right. WB and its people are highly anti-business and anti corporate people. All the offices and industries are investing in Bangalore, Pune, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Delhi and Gurgaon but no company is establishing in Kolkata. If you are communist and you hate industrialist and Businessmen then how come you prosperous.
I am from Bengal and it is true that people over here busy playing dirty politics of CPM, Congress and TMC. Bengal has the India's violent election.
UP is developing infrastructure and Bengal is doing "Khlea hobe", what else you want??
Even if Bangladeshi and Rohingya Refugees are coming to Bengal then what Bengal police and BSF is doing in the border?? How come Bangladeshi citizens getting legal id card in Bengal, these shows Bengal is corrupt as F**K.
Bengal is gone case. Here people only talk about politics and communism.
@@nafsizawed3188then why are bangkadeshis afraid of NRC 😂😂😂😂😂😂
As a Bengali and who understands ground level reality of West Bengal...my opinion is that only God can save Bengal from this downfall......
Nort Banglal is beat
God? Isiliye barbad hue ho salo abhi bhi time he god ko maro goli sahi insaan ko power do 🤥
That God is the bjp a progressive party that works for the betterment of the people n country
Seriously, Only God can save our West Bengal. Situation is totally out of our hands.
BJP can save
As i liveing in bangal i realise that Bengali education system is become distroy 😢
34 years CPIM and 14 years TMC are totally destroyed my beautiful Bengal 😢😫😭😭💔💔
I'm a Bengali & i watched your videos since long time, i will say your content is very honest ❤ keep going bro i wish you deserve more audience 💪
@lethalburmesedude5006 agree 👍
As a Bengali I can say, only God can save West Bengal right now. Situation is now out of our hands. Politics ruined everything just everything. Democracy is nothing but a joke here.
then what about hindutva biased party BJP
bjp ruled states are in a much better condition
good infrastructure (expressways roads airports)
bengal govt. is never interested in infra development.@@subhangisen2224
@@subhangisen2224 hindutva is better than bhatasree
@@subhangisen2224It still brings development compared to other parties.
That's why my grandfather left Bengal, and migrated towards Maharashtra,,, now my family happily & safely living life here..,, Marathi people is such a humble & so welcoming.... I'm proud to be a marathi or Maharashtrian & India ❤️✨,,over Bengal
You are absolutely right 👍. We are ashamed of this bad situation. politics 🔴politics🔴 and politics🔴 ...The politics responsible for this situation today is the main reason for this decline 😮💨.
Being a Bengali I should say a high liberate state in India is shrinking by dirty politics of Bengal
Bengal ,where Ishwarchandra Vidyasagar ,Khudiram Bose,Rabindranath,Raja Rammohon Roy,Netaji,Swami Vivekananda, and such like many Great people was born ,This land is the touching land of that people .As a Bengali ,I am feeling very proud to be a part of this great LAND ❤❤❤❤❤
Salute a true Bengali.
You could also feel proud about ballot box race competition 😉 partho manik Kunal kesto shantanu these are the actual gems of Bengal
@@suryadebpyne1343 unfortunately you were being dominated by chota Pakistan peaceful army
@@simranarora7145 Salute to you as well who thinks more Superior than the Lord. You have more power of dividing cast creed and religion which was not divided by the Supreme Lord Himself. You should be the super god.
Hare Krishna
Please save these illeterates who thinks that they are having more power than you.
@@simranarora7145 moreover the content of the video has mentioned clearly the exact downfall in West Bengal after British Raj till 2011. And the ruling party was ... everybody knows. Please reply according to the main content of the video. Dnt comment out of context.
Good presentation, but blog heads always late realisation creates miserable uncalculated damages.
Love for all Bengalis, from Dhaka ❤🇧🇩
As a bengali , I am very sad and feel insecure in this terrible situation. Also , this is very shameful that maximum people have no political ideology. They just vote to fascists for so called bribe .
Saha r bacha if you feel insecure in Bengal then you are not fit in any states of India. Goto Delhi, Bangalore. It's just for showoff you people go out of states. Even I was out of Kolkata for 10 yrs. I love all languages all over India. The actual fact is many Bengalis go out of state and while they return home they just showoff so many things which they are not doing actually over there where they are staying. Think of Btech students , it students suffering in call centers, some left job and doing businesses in other states only. But when they return home these so called showoffs come back they tel that I am working in big MNC XYZ, but what they are doing no one is going to see.
@@suryadebpyne1343 I told about political ideology. Spread toxicity anywhere. What do you meant by " Saha r baccha". Damn idiot.
EVILS are not people who have supported the ruling regime.....whether it's CPI or BJP or TMC or any Political parties, the EVILS are the BBK - Bhrahmin, Baidhya, Kayastha including Kulins........This Demonic & Stananic 25% are EVILS.........
The fall started from the divide and destroy policy of British. They cut India in three parts where it had the most effective city duo. Kolkata and Dhaka on the other side Amritsar and Lahore. You know played real well when two of the most important states of India has already fallen. And yes this two states were also leading the independence movement.
but why are these 2 states so anti-india, anti-central govt, anti-hindi?? other states are not india/hindu haters. and not super secular like these woke bengalis and keralites
@@AA13494because Congress screwed us sitting as central government
@@AA13494 I just hate foreigners from North India. North Indian politics and people has no place in Bengal. Get out foreigner.
@@AA13494because the most extremist mindset people live in these two states, extremist minded, aggressive & illiterate population. Also these guys love to live in history. Good that they got showed their place in Modern world.
Don't blame British.Its the people always.
Bhai yeh video bahat hi achha bananaya hai pura research kiya hua hai ❤
I Salute 🫡 you for this truth presentation of West Bengal & its Dacoit Government (2023 )
I'm totally agree with your video .I am born and brought up in WB , and still living here but I've been studying in Punjab and UP as well but those states are much more developed , especially the rural areas show the most differennce .Im sad to see this situation in bengal .The violence should stop 😢
Up are developed than Bengal 🤭🤭they first need toilets in their home
@@karanchoudhury450 Lol bro 🤣
The UK is set to announce a package of partnerships on electric mobility and green construction with the West Bengal government as part of British trade minister Nigel Huddleston’s visit to India
@@karanchoudhury450😂😂
@@karanchoudhury450avg bengali still in fool paradise..actually western up a lot more developed than bengal..if u take per capita income of western up it is nearly equal to punjab and haryana🤡💩
Very good job bhaijan. We are all human beings.
As a Bengali from Assam, I must say that modern bhodroloks from Bengal has made Bengalis across the nation hung our head in shame because of their Narcissistic, pseudo liberalist thinking, they have lost cultural values, which I think is also responsible for the downfall of Bengal.
They are no bhadrolok, they are the epitome of ashobbholok, who use a facade of liberalism and spoil the image of bengal in all of India.
I agree. Bengal Shud be nuked.
Joi aai axom
ममता की सरकार बंगाल में हारती क्यू नही इसका कारण ।
1) पश्चिम बंगाल की जनसंख्या में 65% हिंदू है और 30-32 % मुस्लिम है ।
ममता Geographycal चेंजेस ला रही है रोहिंग्या को बसाकर बंगाल में मुस्लिम जनसंख्या बढ़ा रही है ...उसको पता है कि बंगाल के मुस्लिम का 99.9% वोट ममता को ही जायेगा ।*pro Muslim Goverment Jo Hai
और ममता को पता है आधे से ज्यादा हिंदू तो धर्मनिरपेक्ष होते है , 65% में 35-38% हिंदू धर्म निरपेक्ष है ....
उनका सीधा टारगेट 30% कट्टर हिंदू है ।
अगर bjp रोकना है बंगाल में आने से तो मुस्लिम जनसंख्या ज्यादा चाहिए ....कट्टर हिन्दू से ज्यादा ।
30% हिंदू > 32% मुस्लिम
So 32 % Greater....
इस तरह ,बंगाल दीदी का होबे ...😊
Probasi Bengalees can not indulge in the ruinous way of life as in WB, because they have got to struggle much harder to eke out a rewarding life for themselves and promote the society at large. That's the propelling force for non-WB Bengalees, while the position is just rickety in WB.
Its changing rapidly now. Bengal is the most rapidly developing state in india now and have attracted huge investments. Things are changing rapidly and bengal will outperform many states in the next 5 years.
Thank you very much
Dude really hat's off for such a well explained video with analysis. The real reasons of bengals downfall is well explained.
Awesome case study! It covers the whole gamut of all the issues faced by WB
Your words absolutely true
I am a Bengali and we know that we have ruined the situation of our golden Bengal, so everyone should think at least once before voting:)
Wow, hats off to you, my friend! Your video is incredibly well-explained, and the analysis provided is truly commendable. You've shed light on the genuine reasons behind Bengal's downfall in a comprehensive manner.
Bengal already died when East Bengal was cut-off from Bengal in 1947.
I'm from Bengal. TMC destroyed this state badly.
হ্যাঁ ভাই
Yes
Why they win elections again and again?
how to get rid of those illegal bangladeshi in bengal ?? if bengal can get rid of them , then there will be peace , because bangladeshi will vote for tmc and bengal will be more destroyed
ট্রেন এ উঠে এদের জানালাটা ছেড়ে দিতে হয় "হওয়াটা গায়ে লাগবে বলে"
मैं एक बंगाली हूं और मुझे पता है कि बंगाल में सबसे ज्यादा घूस लेने वाला वहां का टीएमसी क्लब है।
Firstly concrete High wall can be made in the all borders with seal tightly.
I want to share about my experience of starting a service office in Kolkata. I applied for GST online and it took 10 days for them to reply. Now the problem began. The local GST office replied with email wanting unnecessary documents which are only required during purchase of property or mutation. Then they wanted proof of electricity meter installation even after submitting electricity bill. Lastly they wanted a map of my office which is on 2nd floor of an apartment. I submitted Google Map and Mouza map(stamped) which didn't work because they could not see the 2nd floor on google map and Govt. maps don't have images of buildings.
Ultimately rejected. I always got harassed at every Govt. office for paperwork. I left for Noida and got my job done there.
The day is not far WB will look like Somalia. Already you can see 3/4 of all beggars in West Bengal.😢
The land revenue department doesn't let you easily change the 200 years old land classification. That means if your land was an agricultural land 200 years back but now it is urban with all the buildings and apartments. Till the time you get clearance to setup mini non polluting factory, you'll be dead. Banks won't approve loans on such cases. Doesn't matter if you're Adani or Tata. Nobody's spared !
Bengali and Bengal is dead now . Mamta Bano made Bengal islamic state . Only corruption scams violence jungaleraj
Bhai Riswat mang raha tha local GST wala
Abe konsa office khonle aya tha 😂, the beggars are biharis only that also everyone knows
Abe chutiye office khonle ke liya GST office kon jata hai 😂, jhatu aur hai bol kiss chiz ka office konle aya tha
I'm from Bengal, whatever you said in this video is true😢
did u face racism there
@@kazi_the_wood_firefor what? 😂
@@ripandas2318 for being a Bengali
@@kazi_the_wood_fire you sound like a bangladeshi.
রাজ্যের সরকার আমাদের হাত পাততে বাধ্য করে অশিক্ষার আড়ালে সারমেয় করে রেখেছে বলে ভারত চাঁদে পৌঁছে গেলেও বাঙালি আজ সারমেওর মত এদের পিছনে ঘুরছে ।আমি বিংশ শতকের বাংলায় জন্মগ্রহণ করলে নিজের জীবন কে ধন্য মনে করতাম কিন্ত একজন একবিংশ শতকের বাঙালি হিসেবে লজ্জা বোধ হয়!
হে বাংলা তুমি আজ ভারতের লজ্জা!
যদি নিজের মাথা না বিক্রি করে থাকেন তাহলে
বাঙালি বলে গর্ব নয় লজ্জা বোধ করুন!
Hi, I'm from East Bengal (Bangladesh)
Earlier in u.p. also no business man is interested to setup business but after Yogi govt strong leadership things are going to change 😊
Your analysis is completely true. I am from Howrah, west Bengal. In that time howrah is renowned for engineering industry, got a tag "Manchester of Benga" . I have many relatives and known person whos had engineering industry, made many parts : for India railway and other heavy engineering industry. But from last 15-20 year faces heavy loss in business, got no contract and finally shut down their industry. In our childhood i brought up in a such area where 24× 7 hear machine sound, labour from bihar jharkhand came and settled here for work. But now , majority of workshop place has given to real estate company, ware house company.
Actually once upon a time from Bengal india got visionary leader like Subhas chandra bose, rabindranath tagore but after independence to now we get corrupted and vission less leader.
In past British exploit Bengal after independence Central govt destroy Eastern india as well as Bengal to develop Western India, through a exploiting policy like Freight equilisation pokicy, Naxalite movement and communist's anti industrial policy and corruption completely broken the leg of Bengal. Now TMC doing corruption in peak level, more freebies culture rather than fast infrastructure development.
Actually Bengal always Exploited in the past, is now and will be in the future.
Howrah r kothai?
@@shallowsharma9349kyano Bhai oor ghore chhele dhokabi nki 😅
Sad next bihar is wb
@@sandipmaji1835😂😂😂😂
I am a Bengali we are so much proud for our culture our tradition our ancestors but Right now a particular evil political party is governing the state and they are destroying our beloved bengal, but still people are voting them every year.... Such a shame 😓
muslim when are in minority then they show Bengali Bengali bhai bhai like in west bengal but when muslim became majority then they show there true colour like in Bangladesh by reading quran Bengali muslim committed genocide against Bengali hindu great calcutta killing
Noakhali riots
1950 East Pakistan riots
1962 Rajshahi massacres
1964 East Pakistan riots( bengali muslim starting killing hindu because some relic was missing in Kashmir mosque) this is your Bengali brotherhood
Bangladesh genocide(90% victim were hindu) 1971
Resignation letter of Jogendra Nath Mandaldalit traitor (in his letter to pak pm he mentioned hindu genocide by there bengali brethens)
can u tell me any riot started by Bengali hindu directed toward Bengali muslim yes hindu population in Bangladesh have reduced from 30% to 7%
this genocide caused emigration of Bengali hindu into west Bengal, these penniless Bengali hindu like garga chatterjee instead of kicking out muslim from west Bengal thet supported communism , secularism and destroyed west Bengal
Evil govt. Is importing bangladeshi for vote 😢
Because of lack of education ❤
Even in bangal majorly bangali are non letrate many of them give to vote to mamata didi 😂
Andhra, Telengana, Bihar, Tamil, Kerala, Himachal, Chattisgarh, Oriya, Punjab don’t vote for Modi shah
As a Bengali, not indian (Bangladeshi), i think the division of Bangla is the main reason of downfall in both two side. Where Bangalis hold worlds 12% GDP, now we are living under poverty both two side.
Where was Sultanate Bangalah, Bengal Nawabid? And Bangladesh is still the largest producer and exporter of jute. Again Bangladesh is still doing better than India, though it was exploited by Pakistan. So why West Bengal is struggling, the reason is simple modern Indian Colonialism of Bengal.
Bengal CM:-Violence Violence I don't like it 😂 but Violence likes me.😅......I can't avoid. 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
As a Bengali you are absolutely right CPI and TMC plus small proportion of population are responsible for this
Small population is islamic intruders
call out small section of population PSEUDO- LEFTISTS sir...they are responsible for destruction of West Bengal
Bangladeshi muslim 😅
Vote ka chakar mai sab Bangladeshi muslim ka voter card bana rahi mamta didi😂
ममता की सरकार बंगाल में हारती क्यू नही इसका कारण ।
1) पश्चिम बंगाल की जनसंख्या में 65% हिंदू है और 30-32 % मुस्लिम है ।
ममता Geographycal चेंजेस ला रही है रोहिंग्या को बसाकर बंगाल में मुस्लिम जनसंख्या बढ़ा रही है ...उसको पता है कि बंगाल के मुस्लिम का 99.9% वोट ममता को ही जायेगा ।*pro Muslim Goverment Jo Hai
और ममता को पता है आधे से ज्यादा हिंदू तो धर्मनिरपेक्ष होते है , 65% में 35-38% हिंदू धर्म निरपेक्ष है ....
उनका सीधा टारगेट 30% कट्टर हिंदू है ।
अगर bjp रोकना है बंगाल में आने से तो मुस्लिम जनसंख्या ज्यादा चाहिए ....कट्टर हिन्दू से ज्यादा ।
30% हिंदू > 32% मुस्लिम
So 32 % Greater....
इस तरह ,बंगाल दीदी का होबे ...😊
I gave a Thumbs-Up to your video as it was very informative and well-researched. However, you missed the key details about the TATA-Singur controversy which was created by the current chief minister of West Bengal. In addition, the arrival of migrants from Bangladesh, Myanmar, etc are putting immense burden on the limited resources of the state thanks to the corrupt practices of the ruling party. It's very unsettling!
Bhai u doing very good... Were you very fast on vlog..!! Thoda slow
As a bengali I say.... People can't relate what is happening here... This video is a short story about it but the big drama is more dangerous..... common bengalis are servent of some politicians 😣😣
This video is just to put Bengal and Bengali down. UA-cam is just an open book for all. So many people are misusing this privilege given by UA-cam.
yaaa 😢😢😢... Independence ke pehle British ne loote the aur ab TMC loot rahe hain.. I am a bengali too
@@suryadebpyne1343 yes you're right
@@dipankarbanerjee1130
CPM to kuch nei Kiye the
Aur sabse Bara Joker Party pura desh ko daan kar re he. Gas Petrol etc etc
I have never seen such a detailed video on Bengal. Outstanding ❤.
Yes dada you are right 😢
Very apt title every Bengali Hindu who loves his her beloved state will agree ! "End of Bengal"
its no more Sanatani Bengal which everyone was proud of
As a bengali I realized that bengali forgot differences between donation and development.. Government give us donation but development they can't... Also I think,, bengal is most corrupted state in India...
But you should stop migrating to other States
Bengal mein Industrial Development upto the mark nahi ho raha hai. Aur Technical investment mein bohot kami hai but most corrupted nahi hai.
@@AnkitSingh-vp6nh na ho kisi ko ghantaa fark nhi padta 🤣🤣🤭🤭
Ok so you are saying there is no corruption in other states only Bengal. Delhi is pure , up is pure, Bihar is pure etc . That's why people are migrating from up, Bihar jharkhand and from many places. That's why you can see more non Bengali are filled in Bengal than Bengali. If they are migrating from their own states , why aren't they not eligible in their own states to get job or do business. Why only Bengal. Blind people are saying only Bangladesi people. Then they should speak pure Bangal bhasa not bhojpuris or matlis. Just observe your surroundings before blindly saying anything.
@@sharad7340 Aur dusre States k log jo Migrate hokar Bengal ate hai unke baare mein kya kahenge app??
Well both Panjab and west bengal got excellent neighbours contributing to this extraordinary performance
It's so true😢, my mother went to chandigarh for her msc and she said that women working below her post were paid higher salary than her, but here govt. Is busy paying money to women whoose husband have govt. jobs but not increase salary, i hope and plan to move out of bengal after i complete my college for job, hopefully someday a chance to another country too
I am a bengali. I left Bengal in 1996 after I failed to get a job in Bengal for a long time after my graduation. I moved to Delhi and settled there. I appreciate Aditya Saini for the detailed and informative video on the decline of Bengal. I have seen how the factories employing hundreds of people got closed in our state during the communist rule in the 80s and 90s. People were encouraged to attack rich people and snatch there properties. Acres of land were captured by the left front goons. The left government actually encouraged this in the name serving the poor. When TMC got to power, I hoped for change for the better. But they only worsened the situation. These days hardly any educated and capable Bengali stays there. Mostly move out to other states or out of the country. TMC has adoped a shameless approach of providing full state backing to Bangladeshis who enter the state illegally and get all necessary government IDs and faclilties in a very short time. Mamata Bannerjee knows this tactic is necessary to keep herself in power for long. State jay bhar me. Her only aim is to hold on to power.
It's sad that even well educated people keep voting for her for their own interests. If they do not wake up and throw out TMC government, West Bengal will soon be worse than the Bihar of Lalu ragime. Cong, Left and TMC all have ruled and pushed it back to darkeness. I think the people of Bengal now should give and chance to BJP and see what they do in five years.
congress was better than other two.
@@BengaliManfromWBnow congress has no money Bengal will exploit again if they got choosen and in return you will get less values freebies 😂
Try congress if you want to exploit again
Strongly agree
@@BengaliManfromWBnope congress was same, especially so bcq central govt. Tend to ignore bengal and north east, u can see that in the video too, i only hope if bjp gets power next election they wouldn't be the same
People of your mindset are the reason for the current hopeless condition of West Bengal.
THOUGH I LIVE IN WEST BENGAL, I COMPLETELY AGREE ON YOUR VIEWPOINT.
Kolkata and Bengal were murdered by TT Krishnamachari in 1955 when he equalised the prices of all industrial raw materials. In 1966-69 Mororarji Desai openly asked all industries and banks to go away from West Bengal to Maharastra. He refused to give any contract to them. When CPIM came to power in 1977 West Bengal was already dead.
Thus, Tamils, Gujaratis, and Nehru destroyed Bengal and Kolkata. In 1970, West Bengal was destroyed already.
As a bengal resident I acknowledge that this is tru
Good analysis, IT revolution during 1990s was also not welcomed by bengal during Jyoti Basu govt in fear of job loss. This was also one factor...
Literally a great thanks to Open Media Productions . They along with Aditya's voice make the videos very addictive as sugar.
Right and nice comments bro
Missed out some vital points. First, the division of the state and the targetted killing of Bengali Hindus in East Pakistan made millions to migrate in West Bengal right upto this day.
Secondly, the Jute fields were in East Bengal, but the Jute mills were in the West, this is why Jinnah tried to forcibly occupy Kolkata in Direct Action Day in 1946. But he failed and the situation became a detroriating stalemate.
Thirdly, with millions of unemployed Bengali refugees, government of India enacted Freight Equalization Policy, which did the capital shift.
Other than these 3 the video was largely correct, hope we rectify our mistakes and other issues ailing us now.
As a Bengali
I want to leave West Bengal 😔
@@rajarshimanna5825 bangladeshi west bengal se fut
No man replace the ministry 😒
@@iarikm😂 sahi sahi sahi
Aese chhod ne se kuch nahi hoga tum logo ko kuchh karna padega dada
@@hvv001 kuch nahi ho sakta iss jaga ka
Corruption now high level😢😢😢
Bad politics and politicians are killing West Bengal.
This is called delivering information. You did a good job. What Vivek Bindra did was spreading hate. Love from Bengal.