@@dylsdrumz7081 There is a difference between a change in tempo for dynamics and literally rushing during a fill, changing the tempo multiple times up and down. Joey didn't track those songs to a click, which gave him freedom to change the tempo according to the dynamics of the songs. But Jay is not doing that here. It's very clear.
@@dylsdrumz7081 não se trata de efeitos, se trata de time metrônomo conhece? Jay acelerava e isso é um fato, fora as emboladas que ele dava no pedal duplo
Eloy’s video is recorded with a very simple room mic while jay was micd up. Even that double foot cam, Eloy’s is more powerful and precise. Can’t wait for pro shot footage
@@lawrence9012 such a boneheaded comment. Both those guys are great but neither one of them could hang show after show, night after night with the demands that Slipknot’s music puts on Eloy.
Jay is a great drummer, but Eloy is just a fucking technical powerhouse. Timing, grooves, fills, all of it thrown together into the perfect package for this band 🤘🏻🤘🏻
Tbh... he isnt even pro level bro at least not for metal. There are fans who literally play these songs way better than him. And im not hating... you can see it for yourself on UA-cam.
I believe Jay is a Machine as well! I don't believe Slipknot was the right band for him though after months of observing and holding opinions. I believe he really did pay tribute to Joey and gave everything he had to secure not just a Grammy but Slipknot's eventual departure from their label Roadrunner, making them an 'Independant Empire'. I'm not undermining Eloy's abilities whatsoever but Jay is also part of the reason why Slipknot is as big as it is today.. There is no doubt that the Grammys will be all over Slipknot's ass when they release the new shit but I've seen that Jay is a super move for any Band to hire. He's a skilled drummer who has lightning fast chops and ferocious speed, Suicidal Tendencies and Infectious Grooves are amazing picks for him but he deserves a lot more. Eloy however combines the best of both worlds.. I have been a Fan of Eloy Casagrande since he first joined one of my Favourite Bands 'Sepultura', even then he made Iggor Cavalera really bitter because he was all 'Too Technical, No Feel'. Eloy has both but also something not many drummers have.. Power and Complete Control. It was a smart business choice to choose Eloy. He's proven himself over the years that he would be an ideal candidate but we got to remember that Jay has been a part of the Slipknot Family since he was a kid, He was the planned candidate to replace Joey with or without his Condition unfortunately so that proves how cut-throat the industry and slipknot are. I applaud Eloy and cannot wait to see what he does but all of you in this comment section need to praise Jay more...
The main differences between them is power, swing, consistency, pocket and sense of timing that suits this type of band. Eloy has it on all fronts. Flash and ability ceiling aside, Jay played well and was great for his tenure. Eloy is just the next level of elite. He makes the band sound better and their stage presence is up a few notches. Eloy’s style has resurrected the band from some kinda funk.
You can hear that Jay doesn't break through the bass drum.He weakly knocks on the drum trigger sound. When Eloy hits the drum, you can hear a booming bass. It is clearly visible that one has thin legs. The other has more powerful ones.
Nunca vou dizer q Jay é ruim, pq ele estava num lugar onde só os alto nível chegam, mas simplesmente o nosso menino Eloy passa por cima de qualquer um.
É muito bom ver o Eloy tocando no Slipknot, é uma baita representatividade para muita gente, diferentemente dos bateristas anteriores, especialmente para o povo careca.
In addition to Eloy's technique and strength, it's incredible the sound he managed to get from the drums with the tuning of the pieces, the authentic acoustic drum sound and no triggers.
Jay loves his drums and takes care of them with longevity in mind. Eloy doesn't care and probably goes through and tears cracks on his crash cymbals 3 times a week.
Eloy is definitely a powerful and precise player. He's already doing hella well in the live shows and im sure future songs will be great too. Make no mistake tho, nu metal is definitely the genre for Jay. Hes killing it right now with suicidal tendencies
Eloy sounds more like a human drum machine. Tempo and timing is almost perfect. With Jay it's a little bit a different story. Both drummers are good though...
Yea I say Jay was awesome he did slipknot proud over the years the Grey chapter was on but huge respect to Jay and was an honor and now we have Eloy who is not old to the game but is definitely keeping the slipknot sound going and can't wait to hear what new beats he comes up with no doubt they will be insane so keep it coming slippy the world is still spinning, r.i.p Joey and Paul cannot forget the og,s
Notem q os pedais do Jay não são consistentes, perdem um pouco o compasso, já o eloy ele consegue manter muito bem, sem contar o fato da energia q o eloy transmite.
Let's be honest: Jay is a good drummer and was a 'worthy' replacement for Joey. I was pretty damn pissed when he got fired, like many fans. But with Eloy they got things back on track. I would still love to know why Jay was fired.
Comparing two amazing drummers side by side. Both playing Joey Jordison's music. I'm not saying he'll top Joey, but I hope Eloy will make his time in Slipknot HIS time.
When pedaling those bass, in this footage Jay has timing issues, but that's not mean he's not great, maybe he's already tired when taking this vid. But damn man Eloy is f888g machine gun , when Jay hit the bass in single, Eloy doubles it with power and precision like a machine gun rrrrtattttatttattt.
Eloy hits about 4x harder, and way more closely resembles joey behind the kit in terms of his showmanship. Jay played the parts fine but didnt bring much to their live shows imo. It was kind of like when Korn and lamb of god replaced their drummers, new guys play the parts but dont add any creativity to the new songs
Jay is really good but has timing issues. Eloy is a damn machine
not necessarily if you listen in to the drums closely there are slight delays to give an edgy dramatic feel
Jay is less acurate with bass drum for exemple. Eloy is pure precision.
@@dylsdrumz7081 There is a difference between a change in tempo for dynamics and literally rushing during a fill, changing the tempo multiple times up and down.
Joey didn't track those songs to a click, which gave him freedom to change the tempo according to the dynamics of the songs. But Jay is not doing that here. It's very clear.
Bro c'mon... he isnt pro level 😂 there are fans that play these songs way better than him. Im not hating but c'mon.
@@dylsdrumz7081 não se trata de efeitos, se trata de time metrônomo conhece? Jay acelerava e isso é um fato, fora as emboladas que ele dava no pedal duplo
Eloy’s video is recorded with a very simple room mic while jay was micd up. Even that double foot cam, Eloy’s is more powerful and precise. Can’t wait for pro shot footage
Eloy, precisão, potência e técnica. Muito superior
Eloy is a machine! The best drummer of this fucking world.
He’s great! But the best in the world?!? Matt Garstka and Chris Turner blow him out of the water in the same style of drumming.
There is no „best drummer“ in the world…
@@lawrence9012 Not to mention Gene Hoglan, Dave Lombardo, and Inferno.
@@lawrence9012Chris turner might have more double kick skills than Eloy but Eloy could out solo Chris turner all day long
@@lawrence9012 such a boneheaded comment. Both those guys are great but neither one of them could hang show after show, night after night with the demands that Slipknot’s music puts on Eloy.
Jay is a great drummer, but Eloy is just a fucking technical powerhouse. Timing, grooves, fills, all of it thrown together into the perfect package for this band 🤘🏻🤘🏻
Jay is heavy duty level, eloy super heavy duty. Both great
Yeah jay did good but can’t wait to see them with Eloy
Jay parece iniciante vendo a comparação com Eloy.
I don’t think it’s even a debate, Eloy is way above man. Power, precision, sound, presence…
Cant take anything away from jay. He’s an awesome drummer.
Pelo visto vc não saca nada de bateria kkk
@@pinguimbateraoficiale tu nada de humildade, para que daqui a pouco o saco do Eloy cai de tanto você lamber
Ngm falou que ele é ruim. Ele é de fato um otimo baterista, porém Eloy e melhor!
👁👁 🥴🥴🥴🥴
Tbh... he isnt even pro level bro at least not for metal. There are fans who literally play these songs way better than him. And im not hating... you can see it for yourself on UA-cam.
Quando me perguntarem a diferença de bateria eletrônica VS bateria acústica, mostrarei este vídeo.
А у Джея электронные? Или типа триггеры?
No because Eloy is a machine@@arturiomarkevitv2546
Eloy is so groovy yet heavy n hard hitting at the same time! And he will include ghost notes on the snare whenever he can
okay, Jay had a big part for SLIPKNOT since Joey's departure. kudos to him! But Eloy, Oh my God, those fills though! pretty much no dead space.
Eloy...Sem mais, No más, Period.
Jay parece que tá tocando no Real Drum, Eloy absurdo como sempre
Jay é incrível...
Mas ...
O Eloy é, fora do normal, com tanta técnica e muita precisão...
RIP JAY WEINBERG
broooo
don't predict the future like that, man!
Disrespectful and unfitting comment.
Jay is doing just fine. Get your head out of your a..
@@chrisb.4715 Yo! Linkin Park fan spotted. what's up?
Jay is the type to play what's on the recording, Eloy adds his flair on the beat. I prefer Eloy, make the beat your own without stepping on toes.
Huh? Jay playing terrible fills to mask his double bass... how's that on the recording? 😂
Jay is a phenomenal drummer and does a great job. Eloy is reinventing the instrument as we know it on the other hand.
Jay canela de frango não tem muita resistência no pedal duplo ele usa muito o pruprupru .
Son estilos distintos 😂
Pruprupru hauahauaauahauuahahauahusususususuwuudushwududihwhwibwihwh7eh8hehw8h8wh8dh8dh88
PRUPRUPRU AKKAKAKAKAKAAKAKAKAKAKAKAK
Canela de frango kkkkkkk
@@herickdavidmolinaforero9856a mesma música? Só pode ser uma viuva do Jay kkkk
Mesmo não entendendo nada de bateria e vendo a diferença clara na captura de som, é muito fácil perceber a diferença.
I believe Jay is a Machine as well! I don't believe Slipknot was the right band for him though after months of observing and holding opinions. I believe he really did pay tribute to Joey and gave everything he had to secure not just a Grammy but Slipknot's eventual departure from their label Roadrunner, making them an 'Independant Empire'. I'm not undermining Eloy's abilities whatsoever but Jay is also part of the reason why Slipknot is as big as it is today.. There is no doubt that the Grammys will be all over Slipknot's ass when they release the new shit but I've seen that Jay is a super move for any Band to hire. He's a skilled drummer who has lightning fast chops and ferocious speed, Suicidal Tendencies and Infectious Grooves are amazing picks for him but he deserves a lot more. Eloy however combines the best of both worlds.. I have been a Fan of Eloy Casagrande since he first joined one of my Favourite Bands 'Sepultura', even then he made Iggor Cavalera really bitter because he was all 'Too Technical, No Feel'. Eloy has both but also something not many drummers have.. Power and Complete Control. It was a smart business choice to choose Eloy. He's proven himself over the years that he would be an ideal candidate but we got to remember that Jay has been a part of the Slipknot Family since he was a kid, He was the planned candidate to replace Joey with or without his Condition unfortunately so that proves how cut-throat the industry and slipknot are. I applaud Eloy and cannot wait to see what he does but all of you in this comment section need to praise Jay more...
Eloy has groove ! Jay is more punk style-sound
The main differences between them is power, swing, consistency, pocket and sense of timing that suits this type of band. Eloy has it on all fronts. Flash and ability ceiling aside, Jay played well and was great for his tenure. Eloy is just the next level of elite. He makes the band sound better and their stage presence is up a few notches. Eloy’s style has resurrected the band from some kinda funk.
You can hear that Jay doesn't break through the bass drum.He weakly knocks on the drum trigger sound. When Eloy hits the drum, you can hear a booming bass.
It is clearly visible that one has thin legs. The other has more powerful ones.
I like Jay's drumming style, both are great though
Como é o estilo do Jay? Sujo? Embolado! Oscilante no tempo???
@@pinguimbateraoficial deixa de ser infantil e ficar comentando várias vezes mal do jay. Mentalidade de uma criança de 10 anos.
@@gabriellcntr tá achando ruim?
Nunca vou dizer q Jay é ruim, pq ele estava num lugar onde só os alto nível chegam, mas simplesmente o nosso menino Eloy passa por cima de qualquer um.
É muito bom ver o Eloy tocando no Slipknot, é uma baita representatividade para muita gente, diferentemente dos bateristas anteriores, especialmente para o povo careca.
Dois bateristas gigantes !!!
Eloy has the Power in any note You can feel the strong of the hits
JAY AND JOEY R GREAT BUT ELROY IS ON ANOTHER LEVEL
Dos grandes cada cual con su estilo.
In addition to Eloy's technique and strength, it's incredible the sound he managed to get from the drums with the tuning of the pieces, the authentic acoustic drum sound and no triggers.
Didnt need a choke he hits so hard 😂
The legend both of them are
Those Eloy snare ghost notes are just 😩
Jay turu turu trutuu turutuuu tuturu
Eloy tu tu tu tu tu tu tu tu tu tu tu....😂😂😂😂
Jay loves his drums and takes care of them with longevity in mind.
Eloy doesn't care and probably goes through and tears cracks on his crash cymbals 3 times a week.
Joey beats them 🗿
Eloy is definitely a powerful and precise player. He's already doing hella well in the live shows and im sure future songs will be great too. Make no mistake tho, nu metal is definitely the genre for Jay. Hes killing it right now with suicidal tendencies
Eloy sounds more like a human drum machine. Tempo and timing is almost perfect. With Jay it's a little bit a different story. Both drummers are good though...
very creative, eloy adding more ghost note in snare
Yea I say Jay was awesome he did slipknot proud over the years the Grey chapter was on but huge respect to Jay and was an honor and now we have Eloy who is not old to the game but is definitely keeping the slipknot sound going and can't wait to hear what new beats he comes up with no doubt they will be insane so keep it coming slippy the world is still spinning, r.i.p Joey and Paul cannot forget the og,s
Power and precision, Eloy hands down.
without wanting to belittle Jay, but eloy is on another level
Those Eloy kicks be kickin’🔥
Pedal dublo do jay e bem irregular
Inconstante eu diria.
Jay's snare drum sounds soooo fucking awesome!!! Eargasm
Notem q os pedais do Jay não são consistentes, perdem um pouco o compasso, já o eloy ele consegue manter muito bem, sem contar o fato da energia q o eloy transmite.
Let's be honest: Jay is a good drummer and was a 'worthy' replacement for Joey. I was pretty damn pissed when he got fired, like many fans.
But with Eloy they got things back on track.
I would still love to know why Jay was fired.
Jay is a magnificent drummer. No question. However, Eloy is just heavier and his double bass kicking is like a machine gun… no mistakes.
its incomparable ... Eloy is next level
Comparing two amazing drummers side by side. Both playing Joey Jordison's music. I'm not saying he'll top Joey, but I hope Eloy will make his time in Slipknot HIS time.
I’ve seen him on videos, but he looks better on stage at 🥁💯
When pedaling those bass, in this footage Jay has timing issues, but that's not mean he's not great, maybe he's already tired when taking this vid. But damn man Eloy is f888g machine gun , when Jay hit the bass in single, Eloy doubles it with power and precision like a machine gun rrrrtattttatttattt.
Não deveriam nem existir comparações, Eloy 100%
Eloy nomber 1 in the world drummer metal🤘🤘🤘
Continue praticando Jay. Mais uma vida e meia você chega no nível do Eloy. Tá susse 😊
Pienso que los dos son grandes bateristas con tecnicas distintas y que aportaron cosas diferentes a Slipknot... Maquinas los dos.
Jay não servia para Slipknot, simples
Eloy is like… “ yeah i want you fuckers to hear this” 😭😂🔥🔥
Both
Look people Jay Weinberg is a great drummer. Very very talented but Eloy is a world class Drummer. He can get a gig touring with any style music.
melhor do melhor do mundo meu amigo! (best of the best in the world my friend!)
Jay Por Mucho me Recuerda Como Tocaba Jay En Cierto Punto Eloy Es Mas Que Exagera Los Movimientos Por Su Forma De Tocar
Jay plays like he had one too many Jägers 😂
Eloy is definitely a nuclear bomb, much more strength, precision in his touches, and when he has to improvise he does it wonderfully
Eloy check all boxes he's got it all
Eloy é melhor em tudo, precisão, força, consistente, dentro do tempo.
Eloy é muita pressão e controle
the Kid who replaced Eloy is faster then both Jay and Eloy
Cara nem precisa de enquete basta ter ouvidos que saberá que o Eloy foi a melhor versão
Eloy domina o tempo, Jay atropela o tempo..
Eloy inseriu notas fantasmas na música e o resultado ficou muito bom
Saat ELOY injak pedal Double Bas Drum... Dunia seakan Gempa..
Então essa é a banda que o Eloy tá ajudando a crescer na cena musical?
the frequency cutouts on jays clip really doesn't do him any justice. I know there arent perfect comparison clips yet but just doesn't feel the same.
Eloy é o melhor ❤🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Incomparable ! Jay soft gay-eloy is terminator metal butcher ! ⛓️⚒️
Jay parece que tá tocando air drumm!
jay style very good but eloy like monster 😂😂😂
Wow Jay's issues with timing really become apparent when you see it like this
The difference between a (very) good metal drummer and a GOD metal drummer.
Eloy hits about 4x harder, and way more closely resembles joey behind the kit in terms of his showmanship. Jay played the parts fine but didnt bring much to their live shows imo. It was kind of like when Korn and lamb of god replaced their drummers, new guys play the parts but dont add any creativity to the new songs
Eloy!
Cara, nem parece q eles estão tocando a mesma musica no inicio wtf
have all of you forgotten Joey was the original drummer?
it's not fair for Jay to compare them
A diferença de pegada e técnica é absurda. Coitado do ex😅😅😅😅😅
Bughuul vs Jason Voorhees
Jay o famoso soca fofo, ops, bate fofo 😂
even though there's nothing technically wrong, I feel like you can distinctively hear that Brazilian swing to Eloy's playing.
Eloy has his drum rudiments in check and Jay doesn't. Can't build a house without a solid foundation.
Nothing against Jay,he's a good drummer,Eloy just fits in better with slipknot. Jay will be just fine in Suicidal Tendencies
Eloy have the power like Joey
Eloy sem dúvida 😂
May eloy be bald egg but holly sh** he is that guy
Yeah yeah. But who was the inventor of this fills/song? Hahah
The fills are Eloy’s. The drumming you hear from Eloy in this clip is more complex than the original studio version.
This is like comparing an smg to a rocket launcher. Love and respect jay too but it is what it is 😅
O equipamento do Eloy é melhor do que o da época do Joey ou é a potência do Eloy q está acima mesmo? Não entendo nada de música pessoal 😂😂😂
É surra que fala?
Joey ❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥
Machine Drum
Com certeza o Eloy BigHouse