Marburg-Biedenkopf | 1945 und ich | Archivmaterial

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 кві 2020
  • Die Filmaufnahmen zeigen 00:00 deutsche Rot-Kreuz-Schwestern Ende März 1945, den Vormarsch der US-Truppen durch eine brennende Stadt 04:12, Militärkolonnen und ein Internierungslager 07:17.
    Alle Retro Beiträge hier: 1.ard.de/hr_Retro_Schaetze_au...
    Alle Retro Beiträge der Hessenschau hier: 1.ard.de/hr_Retro
    Alle Retro Beiträge aus der DDR hier: 1.ard.de/Retro_Spezial_DDR?hr
    Mehr Infos:
    Am späten Vormittag des 28. März 1945 erreichten die US-Truppen die Marburg und nehmen die Stadt kampflos ein. Der Bürgermeister übergibt seine Stadt und verhindert mit Gleichgesinnten die Sprengung der Brücken und Versorgungseinrichtungen. In anderen Orten wie Kirchhain wurde Widerstand geleistet. Mit fatalen Folgen: Kirchhain lag bei Kriegsende in Schutt und Asche, 100 Menschen ließen bei den schweren Kämpfen ihr Leben.
    Anlässlich des 75.Jahrestages des Kriegsendes haben wir Archivmaterial für alle Regionen Hessens recherchiert - in unserem hr-Archiv und in den National Archives in Washington. Dort haben wir auch viele bisher unveröffentlichte Aufnahmen gefunden, die die US-Armee während Ihres Einmarsches und kurz danach in Hessen gemacht hat. Dieses Filmmaterial haben wir anhand der Angaben des Archivs nach hessischen Regionen und Kreisen sortiert. Da es oft keine Infos gab, wo genau die Aufnahmen entstanden sind: Habt ihr mehr Informationen, was in diesem Clip oder wer genau zu sehen ist? Dann meldet euch bei 75Jahre@hr.de.
    Alle anderen Clips zum Thema “1945 und ich” findet ihr hier in der Playlist: bit.ly/1945undich_Alle_Videos
    Hier ist auch der Film zu sehen "1945 und Ich - 75 Jahre Frieden in Hessen", in dem die jüngere Generation auf Zeitzeug*innen trifft.
    Falls ihr euch jetzt fragt was hat das mit mir zu tun? Hier gibt es eine Reportage zum Thema Was hat ein Stipendium mit Zwangsarbeit in der Nazi-Zeit zu tun? • Wie Zwangsarbeiter dei...
    Außerdem gibt es multimedial noch viel mehr zum Thema: www.daserste.de/kinder-des-kr...
    www.daserste.de/geschichte
    www.hr-inforadio.de/programm/...
    #1945undich #Hessen #Geschichte

КОМЕНТАРІ • 224

  • @OswaldOstfalen
    @OswaldOstfalen Рік тому +78

    Min. 0.45
    In the same uniform, my grandmother came to my hometown on April 7th, 1945 at the age of 20 by chance and the chaos of war. She was a "Flakwaffenhelferin" and didn't know where to go. She couldn't go back to Breslau. 5 days later the American came. In September my grandfather came back from being a prisoner of war, they got to know each other and fell in love. 39 years later I emerged from it. My granny will be 98 in March 😘 She is the best granny in the world for me!

    • @fantomas3066
      @fantomas3066 Рік тому

      Hébin, sacré parcours.
      Et avec un peu de retard bonne anniversaire à mamie.

    • @Packard1947
      @Packard1947 Рік тому +4

      God bless her and your family

    • @OswaldOstfalen
      @OswaldOstfalen Рік тому +1

      @@Packard1947
      🤝🙂

    • @fredericmasson6841
      @fredericmasson6841 3 місяці тому

      Bon, écoutez nos "amis" allemand, ça commence à devenir pénible , vous estimez qu'au bout de 80 ans vous pouvez vous faire passer pour des victimes. Seulement, il y a des peuples européens qui ne sont pas de votre avis, ils n'ont pas oublié que l'allemagne à tué 40 MILLIONS d'européens entre 1939 et 1945.
      Et voilà !

    • @carmenpozzi7357
      @carmenpozzi7357 12 днів тому

      ❤❤❤

  • @Justin-xy9cm
    @Justin-xy9cm 4 місяці тому +14

    I live in Marburg Biedenkopf my grandfather told me about the day the Americans came through his town he told me he watched the tanks and military vehicles drive by his house he said he felt relieved and scared at the same time

    • @gunerkaya2905
      @gunerkaya2905 4 місяці тому

      Kennt man sich?😂 bin auch aus biedenkopf. Krasse Geschichte von deinem Großvater..

    • @billmillar1841
      @billmillar1841 3 місяці тому

      I attended the Uni in Marburg, and my father was one of those men who went through. My German friend's father was also there in 1940 mustering for the invasion of France. Quite a coincidence.

  • @gunerkaya2905
    @gunerkaya2905 5 місяців тому +3

    Lebe in Biedenkopf schon mein ganzes Leben. Erkenne keinen einzigen Ort wieder.. krass was passiert ist😢

  • @shafur3
    @shafur3 2 роки тому +23

    Could you imagine tanks, men with guns, destroyed buildings, no home to go to no food or medicine in your town. No family left or you don't know where they are. Prayers for them.

    • @j-ch8787
      @j-ch8787 2 роки тому +2

      Germany was a field of full ruins in 45. But their armies did same too often in rest of europe. This was the price they had to pay for the madness of their industrial and financial elites... And not all but too many low class people starving in the streets during 20ties and 30ties who believed in Adolf 's promises of renovation of german independance. It works during a few years even a lot resisted to his false dreams. They inaugured their jails were tortured.. Killed... Or sent to first camps right after 33. My Oma (gran ma)' s family were opponents to nazis and all adults dispeared very soon. His eldest brother was arrested in 33... And got out of Dachau camp in 45. 12 years he spent there. He was tortured and became mad. Dead in 46. 2 other brothers were in stqlingrad and tve youngest disapeared in Karelie finland on russland front in 41. All the adults were killed women and men. In 45 they were only a whole bunch of orphans nobody cared about in this destroyed country. The oldest was only 11 y. o.
      Sad period... For sure.
      Memories are the best vaccin against such madness.

    • @ps4games164
      @ps4games164 2 роки тому +6

      Yes it was awful.

    • @wymple09
      @wymple09 Рік тому +1

      Now add being Jewish to that.

    • @shafur3
      @shafur3 Рік тому +7

      @@wymple09 it breaks my heart to think what the Jews lived thru.

    • @duncanchizizi6543
      @duncanchizizi6543 Рік тому

      @@shafur3 it was worse for jews sure .very sad.

  • @ragnor56
    @ragnor56 2 роки тому +18

    Great historic films of a defeated nation as the old saying goes "War is Futile"!

  • @thatperformer3879
    @thatperformer3879 Рік тому +11

    Those dames are sure lucky they were captured by Americans and not the Soviets. 😢

    • @Andreas-wm6ut
      @Andreas-wm6ut 2 місяці тому +1

      Es gibt Bücher, die über das Leid berichten.Einige hatten Glück. Die Amerikaner sind keine Unschuldslämmer.

  • @user-dz7np9ol6v
    @user-dz7np9ol6v 2 роки тому +12

    Все ушло.сколь живём столь и воеем.за расу за деньги за идеологию.а конец один.крышка всем...

  • @curtite
    @curtite Рік тому +7

    Amazing how pretty her hair is in all this mayhem

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому +5

    Это наши, деды, прадеды.

  • @evitasarmiento3455
    @evitasarmiento3455 Рік тому +3

    Muy triste!!!😭

  • @c3aloha
    @c3aloha Рік тому +7

    Must’ve been a shock to see the fully mechanized US Army compared to the German army which still used horse drawn logistics.

    • @user-xu6qq9gk1b
      @user-xu6qq9gk1b Рік тому +3

      Вы не правы. Вермахт был неплохо механизирован, только оставил свою технику на полях России.

    • @crowdog56
      @crowdog56 Рік тому +4

      my father in law fought in US Army from D-Day through to German surrender. He said they were all amazed at how much German army relied on horse-drawn logistics, just as you said.

    • @peterh3955
      @peterh3955 3 місяці тому +1

      Horses were an effective form of transport and for hauling heavy equipment; they are all terrain capable, fuel to run them is all around, they are low maintenance & rarely break down, and if needed can be eaten.

  • @sandymiller870
    @sandymiller870 4 місяці тому +3

    Anyone know what group this is 1:29? S U on their caps?

    • @motorcollection6635
      @motorcollection6635 3 місяці тому

      Sowjetunion

    • @twinsonic
      @twinsonic 2 місяці тому

      Sudetendeutsche

    • @user-js4zx1lr2u
      @user-js4zx1lr2u 21 день тому

      POWs from the Soviet Union. Heading home, most ended up dead or in gulags for having failed to fight to the death, and allowing themselves to be captured. Stalin was afraid that the rot of capitalism/democracy might have infected them.

  • @boscodog4358
    @boscodog4358 Рік тому +2

    Does anyone know why the two names for the towns??

    • @gunerkaya2905
      @gunerkaya2905 4 місяці тому +2

      Yes, Marburg is a bigger city then Biedenkopf and many other smaller towns are „attached“ to it.
      And even attached to Biedenkopf there are villages called Like Biedenkopf-Eckelshausen.
      Hard to explain with broken english I am sorry.

    • @boscodog4358
      @boscodog4358 4 місяці тому +2

      @@gunerkaya2905 you sound perfect Guner.

    • @gunerkaya2905
      @gunerkaya2905 4 місяці тому

      @@boscodog4358thank you✌🏽

  • @shiinaanon8008
    @shiinaanon8008 Рік тому +2

    Keine 20 km von meinem Dorf entfernt.

  • @Capochin950
    @Capochin950 Рік тому +11

    When the horrors of the camps were discovered the attitude of the liberating armies to the german population changed .They realised they were in an alien dehumanised world. Very scary.

    • @josepherhardt164
      @josepherhardt164 9 місяців тому

      There is one story where, after the mayor and his wife were forced to walk through a camp at the edge of their town, to see just what had been going on, they returned home and committed suicide. Reportedly, several times the adults of a town near a concentration camp were forced to walk through the camp by the liberating armies. Probably a seriously decent object lesson.

    • @juliaforsyth8332
      @juliaforsyth8332 4 місяці тому +1

      What exactly could civilians actually do about camps anyway? nothing. Or Jews being hauled away?@@josepherhardt164

  • @user-xu6qq9gk1b
    @user-xu6qq9gk1b Рік тому +14

    В Советском Союзе на освобождённой от гитлеровцев территории и молиться было зачастую некому, один пепел и смерть кругом.

    • @carmenpozzi7357
      @carmenpozzi7357 Рік тому

      E voi cosa avete fatto a Berlino a donne e bambini? Violentati e uccisi? Maledetti comunisti. 🇮🇹🖤

    • @johncater7861
      @johncater7861 3 місяці тому

      Liberated. That's an interesting word.

  • @sigitwibowo3257
    @sigitwibowo3257 Рік тому +1

    Wow

  • @jurgendupre-gq7uh
    @jurgendupre-gq7uh 3 місяці тому +2

    Die Rheinwiesenlager grüssen

  • @MOHAMMEDCOBRA101
    @MOHAMMEDCOBRA101 Рік тому +1

    🌹RIP🌹

  • @Auronfan02
    @Auronfan02 4 місяці тому +1

    Impressive quality on that footage. Can anyone mame me the music theme used in those videos?

  • @peterguthorl9599
    @peterguthorl9599 6 місяців тому +1

    I rather would say that at 1:56 this is the station of Niederscheld close to Dillenburg, isn't it?

    • @gunerkaya2905
      @gunerkaya2905 5 місяців тому

      Looks Like it. I made a musicvideo there recently.

  • @reginaldmcnab3265
    @reginaldmcnab3265 2 роки тому +16

    Germany had no clue that the victors had broken their enigma code and therefore were able to read their most secret messages. When Dönitz was told in 1980 that their code was broken, he said, I always ad my doubts but after an investigation I was told that it was impossible but I decided to add an additional 3 more wheels to the Kriegsmarine enigma machine.
    But finally he said: “IT WAS A BITTER PILL TO SALLOW”

    • @mikecain3134
      @mikecain3134 3 місяці тому +2

      The Germans had broken England's naval codes in 1939 and read their messages for the whole war. It didn't help.

    • @reginaldmcnab3265
      @reginaldmcnab3265 3 місяці тому

      @@mikecain3134 so how then did the Germans did the Germans not when or where the invasion at Normandy would take place even weeks after the landing they still didn’t know that it was the main landing.

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому +2

    Жостко, но, как-то так.

  • @rggl3438
    @rggl3438 Рік тому +4

    those men sent to the internment camp more than likely were sentenced to death for war crimes!!!

    • @user-xu6qq9gk1b
      @user-xu6qq9gk1b Рік тому

      Далеко не все. В немецких концлагерях действительно был конвейер смерти. До сих пор у нас внуков советских солдат по спине пробегает не хороший холод при упоминании концлагерей смерти Освенцима, Треблинки, Бухенвальда, а сколько ещё было менее известных но не менее бесчеловечных концлагерей.

    • @RudolfAuer
      @RudolfAuer 3 місяці тому

      Nein keineswegs, sie wurden zeitweise interniert, manche bekamen einen Prozess, es gab sogar sowas wie Schutzhaft, das heißt Haft für Nsdap Funktionäre zum Schutz vor Racheakten, diese wurden dann eingeteilt in minder oder weniger minder eventuell schwerer belastet ecet. Demnach wurden sie später abgehandelt.
      Dann kam der kalte Krieg, unddas meiste wurde über den Haufen geworfen, da man gerade viele der sogenannten Belasteten brauchte um diese eventuell irgendwie gegen den neuen Gegner, den früheren verbündeten einsetzen zu können.
      Ausserdem wurden alle, besondersdie gut ausgebildeten zum Aufbau des neuen Staates dringen und unverzichtbar gebraucht .
      Daran denkt heute in dem allgemeinem Geschimpfe keiner mehr.

  • @jule5234
    @jule5234 Рік тому +3

    Das ist schrecklich zu sehen. Wohne in der Nähe von biedenkopf.. bedrückende Bilder. Warum diese Stadt zerstört wurde? Ich dachte mehr die grossen Städte

    • @KoenigFranz
      @KoenigFranz Рік тому +1

      das ist schnell gesagt. Der Mensch ist eine Bestie. Eugen Drewermann predigt leeren Hirnen....Mir wird das immer klarer.

    • @jule5234
      @jule5234 Рік тому

      @@KoenigFranz ja nur so kann man das erklären

    • @KoenigFranz
      @KoenigFranz Рік тому +1

      @@jule5234 ich hatte über 60 Jahre an das Gute im Menschen geglaubt und es für selbstverständlich gehalten. Die Menschheit auf dem Weg...Das war eine Illusion.

    • @hansfischer7261
      @hansfischer7261 Рік тому

      Ganz schlimm, so was

    • @carmenpozzi7357
      @carmenpozzi7357 Рік тому

      Mbe pensa a Dresda, tutto bruciato come un:
      atomica.... Bombe amerikane, come a Milano🇮🇹😢

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому +2

    Надо,,!Опять,прошлое,.

  • @user-fm4pf6em5v
    @user-fm4pf6em5v 2 роки тому +1

    Да,война-ерунда,а вот последствия:до сих пор разхлёбываем.

  • @marcobranco8848
    @marcobranco8848 Рік тому

    🚑🚑🚑🚑💝

  • @tommi3771
    @tommi3771 Рік тому +2

    dramat ludzkosci przez skutki grzechow

  • @robertobaiK
    @robertobaiK 2 місяці тому

    GUERRAS TODOS PIERDEN .

  • @maxwellfan55
    @maxwellfan55 Рік тому +1

    Faces of the Defeated.

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому +1

    Вот,так.

  • @helltonwerrmann9358
    @helltonwerrmann9358 Рік тому +2

    " All lies " won and today the world is worst than before.

    • @davenichols5156
      @davenichols5156 Рік тому

      It seems Hitler was right about alot i was told by a woman who was there who was in stalins camps and hitlers camps this is what she said hitler was a good man he just went to far meaning the crimes against humanity if you were jewish services were cheap if you werent jewish it cost alot more this is what she said i also spoke with polish men i worked with who said the same . So hitler started iy for the right reasons but obvisouly lost it and went crazy . She said stalin was a animal and was on the death march . Kind of makes you wonder are we being told the truth i highly doubt it

    • @duncanchizizi6543
      @duncanchizizi6543 Рік тому

      You are very false. The world is far much better and peaceful than it was with Nazism. Don't be ridiculous. Nazism was a dangerous cult.

  • @MrBurtur
    @MrBurtur 2 роки тому +2

    1.40 SU-Soviet Union

  • @jbe_7550
    @jbe_7550 Рік тому +3

    what american division attacked these towns???

    • @jbe_7550
      @jbe_7550 Рік тому +1

      I have noticed marks of the 3rd armored division on the vehicles.

    • @jbe_7550
      @jbe_7550 Рік тому +1

      The Spearhead

    • @wymple09
      @wymple09 Рік тому

      All of them

    • @jbe_7550
      @jbe_7550 Рік тому

      @@wymple09 That 's impossible because the entire western German border was simultaneously attacked by three different American armies, Ninth, First and Third US armies.

    • @wymple09
      @wymple09 Рік тому

      @@jbe_7550 It was tongue in cheek

  • @user-jd4pe8iw2x
    @user-jd4pe8iw2x Рік тому +3

    Война это отвратительно. Но Германия сама виновата, что развязала в 20 веке 2 мировые войны, в которых погибли десятки миллионов людей разных стран.

    • @duncanchizizi6543
      @duncanchizizi6543 Рік тому

      Very true. They never learn I guess. Hope they don't cause another third world war otherwise it will be the end if Thier country this time around.

    • @christiandemmler1596
      @christiandemmler1596 4 місяці тому

      Priwjet . Der 1. Weltkrieg, da waren schon viele 'schuld '. Österreich- Ungarn , der Zar auch... Und Stalin ist 2 Wochen nach Hitler auch in Polen einmarschiert. Hoffen wir trotzdem auf Frieden. MIR.

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому

    Но есть исключение.

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому +1

    Надо .!

  • @user-ej6fl6cp4h
    @user-ej6fl6cp4h 2 роки тому +4

    Это не Россия, у которой в это время в деревнях крыши соломой покрыты.

    • @user-er5rt9pv7g
      @user-er5rt9pv7g 2 роки тому

      И грязь непролазная.

    • @user-wx2gv1tk4u
      @user-wx2gv1tk4u 2 роки тому

      И что ты этим хочешь заказать дятел!?

    • @georgemiller151
      @georgemiller151 2 роки тому +1

      It’s Germany, film shot my American military.

    • @user-xu6qq9gk1b
      @user-xu6qq9gk1b Рік тому +4

      У нас в это время и домов то не было, одни печные трубы торчали на пепелищах.

  • @gefredame
    @gefredame Рік тому +1

    Do que essas mulheres alemãs estão rindo?

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому +2

    Это Война.

  • @maxwunsche8549
    @maxwunsche8549 Рік тому +4

    Ruhm 🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪

  • @Syliz932
    @Syliz932 3 місяці тому

    Ils ne savaient pas ??? Personne ne savaient ?????

  • @johncater7861
    @johncater7861 3 місяці тому

    Many comments are quite trite and unnecessary.
    WAr is brutal. War is terrible.

  • @gefredame
    @gefredame Рік тому +1

    E lembrar que os brasileiros também estiveram lá na Itália tomando o monte castelo. Muitos morreram. Dois parentes meus foram e voltaram. Os dois chegaram a alto posto do generalato. Já morrerá. .

    • @carmenpozzi7357
      @carmenpozzi7357 Рік тому

      Sono crepati? Ora sono all'inferno. 🇮🇹🖤

  • @user-se7fx1tr7h
    @user-se7fx1tr7h Рік тому

    Женщины недолжны,воевать,!

  • @samsyng638
    @samsyng638 3 місяці тому

    Джек-пот 777 карты сброшены Paris сдает5тесь или продолжение следует

  • @monikajurgens8754
    @monikajurgens8754 2 роки тому +15

    7:40 Haben sich dort die Amerikaner für ihre Kriegsverbrechen, die Zivilbevölkerung zu bombardieren, selbst verurteilt?

    • @andantecomodo1767
      @andantecomodo1767 2 роки тому +3

      Nein, denn die Täter sind jedes mal die, die den Krieg verloren haben. Auf der Richterbank sitzen und unsere Geschichtsbücher diktieren tun die anderen.

    • @badgerostripey-one6734
      @badgerostripey-one6734 2 роки тому +1

      @@andantecomodo1767 "No, because the perpetrators are always the ones who lost the war. Sitting on the bench and dictating our history books is what the others do."

    • @ericasenen2664
      @ericasenen2664 2 роки тому +6

      Die Frage sollte an dieser Stelle eigentlich lauten: Wer bitte hat mit dem Krieg begonnen? Wer hat ab 5:45 Uhr ganz offiziell damit begonnen Polen, in Schutt und Asche zu bombardieren? Der überwiegende Teil der Toten und Opfer war unter den Zivilisten zu finden. So war es schon immer und LEIDER gehört das zu jedem Krieg dazu. Wollte das dt. Volk nicht den totalen Krieg? Nun, zum Schluss haben sie davon ganz viel bekommen.. Krieg ist nie gerecht.

    • @andantecomodo1767
      @andantecomodo1767 2 роки тому +4

      @@ericasenen2664 Hat hier irgend jemand die Kriegsgreuel der Nazis relativiert?? Es geht darum, dass die Krieggreuel der anderen nicht nur ungesühnt geblieben sind (weil die Täter den Krieg gewonnen haben), sondern auch noch tabuisiert werden, während die Untaten der Nazis noch unseren Urenkeln Tag und Nacht um die Ohren gehauen werden. Und zwar, um diesen, unseren Urenkeln einen potentiellen, unterschwelligen oder tatsächlichen Nachteil zu verschaffen! Einfach, weil sie als Deutsche geboren wurden!

    • @NomenFugazi
      @NomenFugazi 2 роки тому +1

      @@andantecomodo1767 Well,according to you ,who else should have been sitting on the judge’s bench and dictating your history books?Freisler andGoebbels were dead,so there goes your jurist and historian.

  • @hossafat
    @hossafat 2 роки тому +5

    Is there one freaking city that we didn't bomb to hell? Jesus H. Christ

    • @badgerostripey-one6734
      @badgerostripey-one6734 2 роки тому +4

      I sincerely hope there wasn't. I'd be very upset if they missed one.

    • @chucknapier5108
      @chucknapier5108 2 роки тому +3

      For the targeted murdering of six million people of one faith and nationality and then murdering prisoners of war by the hundreds of thousands, hope not. A entire society was to blame for such a belief that women, children, elderly, unarmed men, all could be summarily put to death by ideology alone. Every city had to feel the wrath of the world.

    • @j-ch8787
      @j-ch8787 2 роки тому +3

      @@chucknapier5108
      Could yu express such gently appreciation about what happened in... The list is very ling indeed... Let s say "viet-nam" does it ring a bell in yur brain and memories ? I lose 2 cousins there... Alan and Robert... 3 and 4 years older than me. Very proud of their country usa. Land of my ancestors too.
      Easy to give lessons 80 years after.
      By the way who helped Adolf to get the power hum? And don t tell me the myth of tbe "97% of germans who voted for him" pls... There was never such an approbation by german people. Ok?!
      By the way did yu ever heard of the aborted attempt of a fuckin genetal a butcher named Butler who organised a plot to kill Th Roosevelt? He was inspired and supported by US big bosses. Rockefeller was a nice partisan of nazi system... Disney too... And so many others in usa or GB or France...
      German people weren t the sole responsible of what happened during 2d WW.

    • @chucknapier5108
      @chucknapier5108 2 роки тому

      @J-ch. I am sorry you lost two cousins in that war. I have a uncle who returned and still isn't who he was before he was sent, my mom and others told me of his extreme differences in certain situations. He was a linesman, nothing like presenting yourself as a target. People can have a horrible outlook of the world around them. Adolf Hitler a prime example, his ambition to conquer the world, allowing his subordinate officer corps to decide how to try and eliminate a entire religious group from the planet. Or was this his own plan? No one may never know. Vietnam, was our mistake I think. There was obviously not enough foresight or intelligence to see that a truly battle hardened people who weren't giving up without a fight. We sent advisors to build something within a country already overrun and no one could see it. The French lost to those people, so, they took their lessons learned and used them against what little we had over there. Then, we sent a army, too late. We should have stayed out with such a failed Intel failure. We lost too many good people and returned home hearts and minds seriously harmed, such as my uncle. Korea, pretty sad. Great, a peace was won through several decades of a ceasefire between the North and South. In my time there, peaceful times of course. But, our political leaders decided at one point a tree was in the way of observing a building in the North across the DMZ. A series of pictures hang inside a large glass frame. It depicts a truck load of U.S. soldiers sent across the DMZ, across a bridge, having nothing more than axes and shovels. So, the pictures depict the soldiers dismounting the truck to be met by North Korean soldiers carrying nothing more, than axes and shovels. American soldiers desperately ran for their lives picture by picture as each was butchered. All for a stupid tree which still remains, grown much larger by now of course. The ideology supporting those North Korean soldiers remains fully intact today. Now, China is showing off its new found muscle, the North Korean soldiers are a taste of what is out there. Let's hope the world never has to see such a mess. But, I'm pretty confident our soldiers will be able to be prepared to meet such a ordeal.

    • @j-ch8787
      @j-ch8787 2 роки тому

      @@chucknapier5108
      I agree with yur post. Tks for yur witness.
      My dad was CEO of all US army basis in east of france till 1962. He was engaged in 2d WW and met His uncle in Bastogne. Was born in germany and refugee in france in 39 with my gd parents. Then he participated to end of war in berlin 45. Then as he knew perfect german... American and french he spent 2 years in innsbruck tirol.
      His family (originately settled in virginia near richmond since 1637) as many irish families gave lot of US soldiers. Some were high graduated (general Mc Cluskey and Mc Auliffe). My youngest bro just retired from Us Army... (Ex Seal living both in Texas and Virginia). He made lot of missions in central america then some in south Am. Africa... Mid east and finish in last Iraki war.
      I heard about wars my life long even if I hate that. Never spent any journey in america. My bros often invited me but I have no real link with this country. Just my ancestors ' country. I worked in a diplomatic mission here (with a guy a vice consul named David Ostroff who was the chief of US delegation during the signature of end of first conflict with Saddam Hussein) and I worked... recently, for US and Brits or German funds of pension (was a gech and financial real estate expert in Paris).
      I would like we ll stand in peaceful world next future but am doubtful.
      I gonna renove my property in normandy not far from where they landed on omaha and utah beaches the 82d and tbe 101 AB my dad was member too (but after the war) ... But i will remove myself in a lonely place with prairies river grass and flowers... Lot of buildings I ll have to renove and "embeauty" them. Lot of job to finish gently my life with this enterprise. Far from this agitated and mad world. Then i will give the keys to my son in order he will be be able to protect his family in case of a big "economico-climatic" clash next future.
      I will begin again my handy skills as a cabinet maker and restorator of nice old french furnitures (very expensive) and some other manual activities or crafts I practiced before.( Plus building bio climatic architectures) ...
      "Last call" in a way before i ll quit this world. Enjoying simple life... Beauty... Looking at sun every morning and listening rain flowing on the house. Reading and listening music facing wood burning in my stove or chemney.
      What else?
      We should all purchase this dream.
      I hope yu can do same.
      [By the way I saw yur name is so "frenchy" probably comin from south usa...and as far as i know a protestant one from south west france region. Funny how people move all over the planet to get better conditions of life.
      Have a nice day Chuck. Bye !]

  • @user-sd3wm1ys9z
    @user-sd3wm1ys9z Рік тому +2

    Дурацкая музыка.

  • @badgerostripey-one6734
    @badgerostripey-one6734 2 роки тому +8

    I wasted over an hour constructing a rather lengthy dissertation explaining the genetic causes of Nazi barbarism from 1871 to the end of the Holocaust. UA-cam decided you were not adult enough to face up to the truth of what happened in France in 1871, German West Africa 1906-1908, France and Belgium in the fall of 1914, Armenians in 1915, Nuremberg in 1936 and the Holocaust which actually started not in February 1942 but on the first day of the invasion of Poland, Sept 1, 1939.
    Shame on UA-cam and shame on Google.

    • @chucknapier5108
      @chucknapier5108 2 роки тому

      Perhaps a published book would do?

    • @pawelpap9
      @pawelpap9 2 роки тому +3

      @@chucknapier5108 Which would be read by the author’s family and friends. It indeed telling that UA-cam )and other similar platform) do not think that not even 100 years old history is unsuitable for contemporary youth. Young people who otherwise educate themselves by playing computer games loosely based on historical conflicts. Maybe UA-cam forgot that all totalitarian systems thrived on manipulation and suppression of history. Or simply within 100 years humanity turned whole circle and thus century will be a replay of previous century?

    • @chucknapier5108
      @chucknapier5108 2 роки тому +2

      @pawelpap9 - Yes u-tube does throw a lot at anyone who observed, history is in the context, how it is perceived is on the viewer and many different views can be taken unfortunately. Sadly, even now, events unfold with sometimes similar likeness' as did within Nazi Germany but at least in much smaller scales. Our younger generations appear to hang around the video games and I do feel these take a enormous fact from fiction from history. It would be nice if people could all see these historical notes ad they really were, sometimes a book provides a stimulus that no video could provide, but hopefully video games never overdue the book.

    • @deutschpanzergrenadier7990
      @deutschpanzergrenadier7990 2 роки тому +4

      What barbarisim in 1871? Your confused with King Leopold of Belgium who killed 10 million central Africans. Poor little Belgium. Not Democratic like France and England during their Cololnialisim. Huh! To bad Stalin, Beria and NKVD were not hanged for Great Terror, Gulag Archipelago and Stalinist Famine of the Ukraine or signing Molotov-Ribbentrop pact.

    • @pawelpap9
      @pawelpap9 2 роки тому +1

      @@deutschpanzergrenadier7990 He probably refers to Paris Commune. They didn’t teach history in your school?

  • @samsyng638
    @samsyng638 3 місяці тому

    Moscow капитуляция

  • @user-ez6bw4xf1g
    @user-ez6bw4xf1g 2 місяці тому

    Deutschland

  • @user-co4rs7ob1t
    @user-co4rs7ob1t 2 роки тому +7

    Как это американцы мешки у санитарок не отобрали на сувениры...

    • @tracymesser296
      @tracymesser296 2 роки тому +2

      RESPECT is what I’m thinking! IMO!

    • @NomenFugazi
      @NomenFugazi 2 роки тому +3

      Because they were Americans,if you know what I mean..

    • @MrBelmont79
      @MrBelmont79 2 роки тому +2

      And they were not raped either by the “Western Allies”

    • @chucknapier5108
      @chucknapier5108 2 роки тому +1

      Perhaps because they were nurses.

    • @user-er5rt9pv7g
      @user-er5rt9pv7g 2 роки тому

      За них это сделал мясник жуков, отправив домой два эшелона награбленных трофеев.
      Ну зачем крохобору понадобился вагон только одних ковров, не знаю.

  • @christiangriesser5573
    @christiangriesser5573 2 роки тому +2

    Waren das, zwei getarnte ss Scherginnen, von einem ehemaligen Konzentrationslager ??? Oder wirkliche Rotkreuzschwestern ??? Falls es Schwestern waren, so bitte ich um Vergebung 🙏. Denn diese , erleben in all den Kriegen , auch in der Vergangenheit , viel Leid und Schrecken 👹💀💀💀👎!!!

    • @heinzkarlheinz5774
      @heinzkarlheinz5774 2 роки тому +5

      Wo im Kreis Mrbg.-Biedk. oder in der Nähe gab es ein KZ ?

    • @steffenrosmus9177
      @steffenrosmus9177 2 роки тому +2

      Wer vor dem Posten seinen Brägen einschaltet muss nachher nicht um Vergebung bitten.

    • @andreasseibert3486
      @andreasseibert3486 2 роки тому

      @@heinzkarlheinz5774 , Nordhessen. 100 km nördlich von Frankfurt/Main. Marburg war u. a. wegen den Behring Werken ein militärisches Ziel

    • @heinzkarlheinz5774
      @heinzkarlheinz5774 2 роки тому +2

      Für die amerik. Jabo-Piloten war jeder Landwirt auf dem Feld ein militärisches Ziel

    • @susannesperre9573
      @susannesperre9573 Рік тому

      @@steffenrosmus9177 Aber so etwas von . Ich kenne kein Volk, welches xxxx.

  • @user-zf3nm4ro3w
    @user-zf3nm4ro3w Рік тому +1

    Какую красоту разрушали и не жалко было ?

    • @user-mx9cy5zp2k
      @user-mx9cy5zp2k Рік тому

      А людей не жалко миллионы погибшие.

    • @duncanchizizi6543
      @duncanchizizi6543 Рік тому

      @@user-mx9cy5zp2k imagine Germans are asking about the building forgetting the people they gassed for no reason in their stupid camps.

  • @philipbutler6608
    @philipbutler6608 2 роки тому +16

    The Germans were treated better than they deserved. A lot of them have smirks on their faces in the other films. There were very few Japanese prisoners of war compared to Europe.

    • @KG-li7kg
      @KG-li7kg 2 роки тому +7

      Die Deutschen wurden besser Behandelt, wie sie es verdient hatten? Wo kommst Du denn her? Hast mal etwas von "der goldenen Meile" bei Remagen gehört? Da starben über 1 Millionen Deutsche gefangene Soldaten, in US-Gefangenen Lager. Kein US Soldat wurde von den deutschen so miess Behandelt.

    • @brunoreis2315
      @brunoreis2315 2 роки тому +2

      @@KG-li7kg com certeza e uma guerra infelizmente, mas com os judeus , ciganos, Tchecoslováquia e poloneses matando 9 milhões não tem problema. Acho que o ditador foi muito infeliz e tomar certas atitudes!

    • @steffenrosmus9177
      @steffenrosmus9177 2 роки тому +3

      @@KG-li7kg 1 Million? Woher sind die Zahlen? Quellen bitte!

    • @monikajurgens8754
      @monikajurgens8754 2 роки тому +4

      @@steffenrosmus9177 Dazu gibt es genug Material, so daß der dümmliche Standard-Text aller Trolle "Quellen bitte" hier gänzlich überflüssig ist.

    • @KG-li7kg
      @KG-li7kg 2 роки тому +1

      @@steffenrosmus9177 Nun bekommst Du eben mal Geschichtlichen Nachhilfe-Unterricht: Die Amis haben mit voller Überlegung die gefangenen Deutschen Soldaten, Buchstäblich verrecken lassen. Angeblich hatten die Amis einen "Engpass" in der Versorgung der gefangenenlager. Hier wollte das Rote Kreuz, die die Ernährung und die medizinische Versorgung übernehmen. Auch deutsche Städte und Gemeinden wollten helfen, diese gefangenen zu ernähren, was der Ami aber abgelehnt hat. Als dem General Eisenhower gemeldet wurde, das es in den Gefangenenlagern schon über 1 Millionen Tote gegeben habe, fragte dieser lakonisch: "Na, und warum nicht mehr?"
      Man Beklagt immer, das es bei den Russen viel schlimmer war, das ist aber nur die halbe Wahrheit. ganz im gegensatz zu den Amis, hatten die Russen selbst nicht mehr an Verpflegung und mussten diese faktisch mit den Gefangenen teilen

  • @johndragon3900
    @johndragon3900 Рік тому +1

    The Americans were to easy on them

  • @user-ej6fl6cp4h
    @user-ej6fl6cp4h 2 роки тому +6

    Немцы перед американцами по стойке смирно, хорошо стоят.

  • @philipbutler6608
    @philipbutler6608 2 роки тому +1

    They all took their NAZI emblems off. I doubt they were American. They were well fed too.

  • @user-ej6fl6cp4h
    @user-ej6fl6cp4h Рік тому

    Немки довольны, что проиграла их страна.

    • @user-hq1qc4nh6j
      @user-hq1qc4nh6j Рік тому +1

      Они довольны, что война кончилась.

  • @user-nh6lt8ot9z
    @user-nh6lt8ot9z Рік тому +5

    А почему нигде нет хроники боёв реальных боёв американцев?

    • @blitzkopf7267
      @blitzkopf7267 Рік тому +2

      посмотри бомбардировки германских городов и объекты не военной инфраструктуры.
      это и есть их реальные бои.