Is The Flow Hive Dead? The Competition Has Arrived!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 120

  • @BlackMountainHoney
    @BlackMountainHoney  6 місяців тому +2

    Available HERE: www.modernbeekeeping.co.uk/paradise-honey-beebox-smart-system

  • @johnsutton6906
    @johnsutton6906 6 місяців тому +24

    Be great to see a vid of how you inspect it once the supers are filling up…

  • @austerror
    @austerror Місяць тому +12

    That's not an argument being lazy saying the flow hive you can only extract one at a time, it's false.

  • @jamesmgreen15
    @jamesmgreen15 3 місяці тому +12

    Any follow ups will also be appreciated.

  • @628DirtRooster
    @628DirtRooster 6 місяців тому +13

    I'm really interested to see how well they function after a couple of seasons.

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  6 місяців тому +1

      Me too Randy. I'll keep you posted 🍯

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn 25 днів тому +4

      Hey Randy! :) I spoke with Blue Sky Bee Supply as they are the only U.S. sellers. After the conversation on November 8th, Blue Sky removed the smart system from their online catalog completely. I'm having trouble getting my own questions answered. Looking forward to seeing you in January. I hope Paradise will have a vendor table and I look forward to talking with them.

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  25 днів тому +1

      it's such a shame that these aren't readily available. Clearly some legal wrangling going on behind the scene :(

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn 25 днів тому +3

      @@BlackMountainHoney Thank you for the response. How was your harvest with the system? Will you be doing a follow-up video that I can send my viewers to? Thanks so much :)

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  25 днів тому +1

      @FrederickDunn Oh yes. I'll definitely do a follow up early next year for the system and I'm sure there will be a honey crop this time around :)

  • @FrederickDunn
    @FrederickDunn 25 днів тому +7

    Thanks for posting this! I've been receiving several questions about this system recently. So, how did it work out, and do you stand by it? Thank you so much. I find that the company is non-responsive about this system, so anything you can share would be great :)

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  25 днів тому +2

      Hi Fred. In terms of the overall hive it's just as good the standard paradise hive. A good usable floor and much improved feeder/roof vs the flow hive
      Unfortunately my bees swarmed in it this year and so I didn't get to test the honey supers but will definitely get them working in it early next year. Bit of a disappointment but first year with plastic supers can sometimes result in early swarming in this type of hive. Hope you are well BTW :)

    • @FrederickDunn
      @FrederickDunn 24 дні тому +2

      @@BlackMountainHoney Thanks for that information.

  • @TerryWheelyabarrabackApiary
    @TerryWheelyabarrabackApiary 6 місяців тому +17

    Don't know why you say it's better? Nothing in this video showed me that.
    They have also stolen a concept from flow hive who spent years of research. The idea behind single spigot's is that you get to taste different pollen honey. They're not all the same as pouring everything in one barrel. They are also not meant for commercial use. They are a hobby Bee kit. Most people that have a flow hive like them. So I don't get your point? Also I personally wouldn't even use a flow hive as I hate all this plastic landfill happening everywhere. And Polystyrene's are the worst.
    Wood and Bee's perfect match.

  • @philaandrew100
    @philaandrew100 6 місяців тому +13

    Frames look a bit flimsy, will be interested to see how they stack up against the Flow frames. I am still running my Founding Member Flow frames from 2015....

    • @albigensian4655
      @albigensian4655 5 місяців тому +1

      The frames are quite sturdy and less likely to come apart than the flow frames, however if you want to pull one out to inspect it more closely the flow frames are easier to pull out and put back, they're in pretty tight i've found, and that's without being propolised by the bees.

    • @philaandrew100
      @philaandrew100 5 місяців тому

      @@albigensian4655 True, the FF's are a bit sensitive to rough handling. Had one that dissasembled itself when I unpacked the box but the good folk at Flowhive sent me a replacement free of charge and told me how to reassemble the offending frame. Can't fault their customer service.

  • @DreamofaHive
    @DreamofaHive 6 місяців тому +21

    If it is heavy BEFORE it is being filled will honey how are you expected to inspect your bees?

    • @sinisterhipp0
      @sinisterhipp0 6 місяців тому +2

      Interesting question.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 6 місяців тому

      Weetabix? Flowhive has the same issue so you could say it's not an issue? On my Flowhives I sometimes remove some Flowframes before lifting the super. Similar can be done with the Paradise but what we don't yet know how robust these new frames are but that's for Laurence to find out and share to us.

    • @michaeldargan3163
      @michaeldargan3163 3 місяці тому +1

      Not interesting, it is ESSENTIAL to check your brood hive at least every few weeks for disease, -eats and bee vitality

  • @mattlockhart-i3j
    @mattlockhart-i3j Місяць тому +15

    I don't understand why your so impressed by a rival company doing a rip off the original flow hive. They didn't come up with the idea just changed the process slightly to void copy right. Plus the main advantage you say of 1 harvest point is actually a disadvantage in that you can't separate the different honey flavours and colours that come with the flow hive of harvesting different frames.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 19 днів тому

      You do realise that the frames can be harvested individually just like with a Flowhive?

  • @honeymcdonald9120
    @honeymcdonald9120 5 місяців тому +13

    Looks like a total ripoff to me - a copy. I'm not sure I see the gaps needed to keep the bees safe either but camera work didn't show that. I would also NEVER extract more than one frame into one jar - you might as well go back to homogenised extraction, making all honey taste the same -like a supermarket. No competition at all. Team flowhive. I see you are selling them -- someone is biased.

  • @LileCremeans
    @LileCremeans 6 місяців тому +37

    Absolutely nothing in this video showed me how this is better than the Flow Hive or traditional Langstroth. If anything it looks cheaper than the flow hive knock offs.

    • @albigensian4655
      @albigensian4655 5 місяців тому +1

      if you want to keep the honey unblended from frame to frame, i'd recommend the flow hive which it's simple to set up an extraction method to do all the frames at once whilst keeping the honey unblended, with the bee box you'd have to wait for each individual frame to drain before moving to the next, second the observation windows on the sides only have a bit of tape holding them in, i removed those tabs on one of mine thinking the bees will soon rip that off, and now i'm hoping the bees will propalise them because atm, every time i remove the observation cover on that hive it's a bit tricky, since they will drop out, the windows on the flow however are screwed in.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 3 місяці тому

      @@albigensian4655 But you can harvest just a single frame with the Paradise version !!!

    • @mikieemiike3979
      @mikieemiike3979 2 місяці тому

      ​@@albigensian4655How do you deal with this system during the winter (The honey gumming, queen not having open comb spaces etc.)?

  • @raterus
    @raterus 6 місяців тому +11

    Curious, did you buy in this yourself, or did they send you the stuff for free to try and give an honest opinion?

    • @JyeDaRos
      @JyeDaRos 6 місяців тому +2

      Its all supplied, this is clearly an ad

  • @alancooney6382
    @alancooney6382 6 місяців тому +10

    Hello,
    Alan from Australia here.
    So you are saying all honey from all the frames get combined and into a bucket, then you close up the frames and start filling Jars from the bucket?
    If so then all the different flavours from each frame will be lost as they are all now mixed. I’m not saying it’s an improvement to the flow system it’s just a simplified way to extract honey.
    But I am interested in your next video on this product and I am also open to different ways to extract.

    • @tidymeup
      @tidymeup 6 місяців тому

      This is geared more towards a commercial market where you might have many remote apiaries, it will avoid the need to make multiple trips with empty and full supers back and forth. Having said that it will work for smaller scale and hobby beekeepers also.

    • @NaturalRawHoneyBees
      @NaturalRawHoneyBees 6 місяців тому +1

      You can still extract the honey from individual frames, one at the time to benefit from the different honey in each individual frame

  • @crashclan9772
    @crashclan9772 6 місяців тому +17

    How do you check if all the frames are capped so you don’t get too wet honey

    • @sinisterhipp0
      @sinisterhipp0 6 місяців тому +2

      Interesting question.

    • @albigensian4655
      @albigensian4655 6 місяців тому

      the outside frames are capped last and there are viewing windows on the sides of the super, similar to the flow hive but no viewing point at the back to see the ends unlike the flow hive. the smart frames are in quite tight though unlike the flow frames so could be fun getting them out when the bees have glued them down.

    • @raterus
      @raterus 6 місяців тому +1

      The flow frames (the actual flow frames) will only capture capped honey due to the design. Uncapped honey spills over and the bees put it somewhere else. Honestly the best way to know is to just pop the top and inspect the best frames.

  • @dcrosco1458
    @dcrosco1458 6 місяців тому +19

    YOU really can tell you are getting paid to sell this equipment. NO I dont care about either system. but you are doing a good job brown nosing for the competition of the flow hive.

    • @dcrosco1458
      @dcrosco1458 6 місяців тому

      NO I AM NOT A TROLL just a truth teller

  • @Cypher7765
    @Cypher7765 6 місяців тому +2

    If it’s that heavy, how do you inspect and treat?

  • @livingadamman7994
    @livingadamman7994 6 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for this, I'm still perplexed how the fine walled plastic cell walls can change position when capped honey is filled that would be some pressure. I guess I'll have to wait till you show the extraction with honey in practice. Cheers

  • @eastsussexbeesandwildlife5801
    @eastsussexbeesandwildlife5801 6 місяців тому +3

    Look forward to the updates!😊

  • @albigensian4655
    @albigensian4655 6 місяців тому +5

    i already have 2 up and running, couldn't wait any longer to see you review them lol, personally i like extracting individual frames on the flow hive keeping the honey frames unblended, a selling point i like to have, trouble with the smart hive is i'd have to wait 3hrs to do each frame rather than 3hrs for all at once with the flow hive, but that's horses for courses, not sure about the viewing windows on the sides though as unlike the flow hive the plastic viewing windows are not screwed in or anything just a bit of tape holding them in when i got mine they drop out easily when i uncover to look, hopefully the bees will glue them in place, definately you'll need a top feeder ashforth ect since although the gabled rooves on the flow hives are horrible, they at least give a bit of room for feeding syrup ect. as for the super frames, omg are they in tight. hard to get out and hard to get back in, and that was just painting a bit of wax on the frames to encourage the bees. on the plus side, yeah should be well insulated, and half the price of a flow, will have to see how they work out before i'd get more, i love the fact there's no wires and the frames are more solid than the flow ones.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 6 місяців тому

      I can't get my head around this (I have two Flowhives so know a bit) how does it take that long to drain one frame in the Paradise system? Less flow?

    • @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm
      @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm 6 місяців тому

      Enjoy your brood filled supers Mmmmmmm

    • @albigensian4655
      @albigensian4655 6 місяців тому

      @@JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm only if you don't put in a q excluder lol

    • @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm
      @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm 6 місяців тому

      Lol? Typical wannabeekeeper
      Queen excluders dont exclude laying workers. These fad hives are garbage. Just like your beekeeping skills.

    • @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm
      @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm 6 місяців тому

      *Like yer mom

  • @swohiobees
    @swohiobees 6 місяців тому

    I look forward to your updates on this hive. Always interested in how others are beekeeping.

  • @Devonhoneyandcandles
    @Devonhoneyandcandles 6 місяців тому

    awesome vid, good job Lawrence. That hive looks very cool.... did you forget your mic ☺. look at that nuc with four brood boxes on it... pro!

  • @khaziirsoze5952
    @khaziirsoze5952 Місяць тому

    Can you mount this flush in a shed so extracting honey can be done inside and bees stay outside? Plus hive should stay warmer in winter maybe?

  • @honeybee3317
    @honeybee3317 25 днів тому

    What do the bees live on in the summer dearth if the beekeepers take all their Spring honey?
    At least with Langstroth many supers are on the hive and bees can have plenty of stores.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 19 днів тому

      They ARE Langstroth hives ;) and like any hive you decide to take or leave honey.

  • @carolannmathieson1594
    @carolannmathieson1594 6 місяців тому

    My son at I visited Paradise honey in Finland. Their motto "more honey, less money" ,constantly lmproving equipment and processes. These smart hives improve productivity and reduce much of the time needed to collect honey from many sites.

  • @won2winit
    @won2winit 6 місяців тому +1

    Certainly looks like a potential future purchase but will wait to see what if any issues there maybe with inspections when its filling up with honey etc
    One question is how will you know which ones are capped and ready to be extracted so you don't take of any honey above the standard moisture levels leading to it fermenting?

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  6 місяців тому +1

      You can kind of peak down in between the frames to see how capped they are. I had a look in the other day

    • @won2winit
      @won2winit 6 місяців тому

      Next question their website states the brood box is an 8 frame but you have managed to add 9 frames, is this due to you using Hoffman self spacing instead of other frames that use the plastic spacers that many only allow 8 ?

  • @ogradus
    @ogradus 19 днів тому

    Is that ABS or PLA plastic?
    PLA will warp in the sun.
    Do bees like plastic the same as wood?

  • @AndrewAHayes
    @AndrewAHayes 4 місяці тому

    Everytime I have seen someone do an extraction from the flow hive they have a leak from the bottom of the frame, I think they were trying to empty too many cells at once!

  • @evonyshaky65
    @evonyshaky65 11 днів тому

    You appeared to be saying open/closed cells the wrong way around.
    The cells looked open when you were saying closed.

  • @neilfrozenoak5438
    @neilfrozenoak5438 6 місяців тому +1

    No one else going there? I feel I'm letting Ronnie Barker down 😅

  • @97footballplayer
    @97footballplayer 3 дні тому

    Using plastics to house your honey, especially when exposed to direct sunlight and heat, is not wise IMO. Who knows how many different chemicals will leach into the honey by the time it is consumed? Who knows the dose exposure of the various chemicals and plasticizers from the plastic you will be exposing you, and others to, in a hive like that?
    It’s best to minimize exposure to these types of products as best as possible.

  • @dannysalvador1769
    @dannysalvador1769 6 місяців тому

    How would one go about getting one? I went to the website and i cant seem to find the order page.

  • @chrishumphreys9363
    @chrishumphreys9363 6 місяців тому +1

    Hopeful this is not a daft question...Are the bees still in the super when you extract the honey???? If yes won't they all get covered in honey as it runs down the frames? Or does the honey run out from the middle of the two segments. ?

    • @AndreLeandro139
      @AndreLeandro139 6 місяців тому

      I am a newbie, and never done it, i believe after tou havest, you extract the honwy, and put the frames back, soo bees can eat all honey left, it will not drip to the bottom frames

  • @paulward7104
    @paulward7104 2 місяці тому

    Hi Laurence. Did you do a follow up to this video? It have just bought 4 of these and wondered how you found them. Thanks for all you do. Paul

  • @crashclan9772
    @crashclan9772 6 місяців тому +1

    So Cool might get one

  • @MountainTopBeekeeping
    @MountainTopBeekeeping 6 місяців тому

    Flow hive should have
    Done this upgrade before
    Others do.
    😅

  • @BaileysHstead
    @BaileysHstead 20 днів тому

    What’s that update on this hive? It’s cheaper than the flow hive but is it better or they are just a sponsor? There is no other videos about this product, and I’m looking to buy it in the spring. Update please.

  • @Dogtagnan
    @Dogtagnan 5 місяців тому

    You say the super is heavy even before you start. Obviously it's going to get heavier. So one consideration for less able / older beekeepers is how we cope with inspections, swarm management and pest control. I'd be interested in your take on that. Also storing the thing over winter when you treat the hive with oxalic acid, also sanitising it. Many thanks.

  • @yonicarmel789
    @yonicarmel789 6 місяців тому

    Any chance of them making something compatible with british national hives?

  • @patrickmcauley151
    @patrickmcauley151 5 місяців тому

    Do you have to wax the honey frames

  • @mustrumridcully3853
    @mustrumridcully3853 6 місяців тому

    Is a 9 frame single brood enough?

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 19 днів тому

      Absolutely if you use 'manage' them accordingly.

  • @NaturalRawHoneyBees
    @NaturalRawHoneyBees 6 місяців тому +3

    It is a shame how Flow are threatening to take sellers of Paradise Hive retailers forcing them to stop selling. Paradise should support their retailers who are being threatened with legal action as they are Paradise’s Agents! If Paradise stand by their design being materially different for believe Flow’s design protections are not accurate or so high level are unreasonable - then open to challenge, then they should work with retailers in different countries to stand up against Flow’s anti-competitive actions.
    I have 2 Flows, however no longer recommend them due to what I believe is unethical business practices to stifle competition by threatening the small retailers and not taking action against the manufacturer- Paradise, who themselves should stand by and support their retailers. Not doing so can also be seen as unethical!
    Both have there place and should be considered by beekeepers looking for a method to extract direct from the hive.
    This may well spark a reaction….

    • @researcherAmateur
      @researcherAmateur 6 місяців тому +1

      I think you should be threatened to change your name in plastic honey

    • @mrspot234
      @mrspot234 5 місяців тому +2

      If a patent has been infringed, then flow have a right to defend that patent in any way that is legal.. I expect flow only have another 10 years of protection anyway. If Paradise Smart Beehive haven't infringed the flow patents, then I expect that they will be protecting their IP as well, just as flow does. I am sure they won't be embracing Chinese knockoffs any more than flow does.

    • @mrspot234
      @mrspot234 4 місяці тому

      @notme1345 At first glance it does appear very similar, but the operation is very different (flow hives don't drain through the bottom of the cell) - and I guess that is why the patent was granted to Flow Hive. Still fascinating to see the drawings from 80 years ago. I have often thought that there are not too many really new ideas - and this is another example.

    • @researcherAmateur
      @researcherAmateur 4 місяці тому

      There's an old comedy sketch when the guy says: it isn't shit ! Just a dog taking a poop.

  • @hevchip741
    @hevchip741 6 місяців тому +1

    This sounds good for honey farmers/businesses.

  • @exvcator
    @exvcator 5 місяців тому

    It certainly seems like there are some interesting innovations, which is great to see. As for whether Flow hive is dead, they raised almost $17m in crowdfunding, and with that war chest have already made a number of enhancements to their original design. The advocates of Video 2000 and Betamax thought they had better technology, but in the end it was the corporate might of JVC and Sony that won out. Time will tell whether Flow hive is dead, but I’m not betting on it.

  • @AshleyMalyon
    @AshleyMalyon 5 місяців тому

    Ive got one and ive just put the super on seems good to me

  • @Funnypooly
    @Funnypooly 6 місяців тому +1

    plastic honeycombs for a barbie world :D microplastic honey bon appetit, enjoy!

  • @carmemalencar5583
    @carmemalencar5583 5 місяців тому

    Amei ver pena q não sei inglês...

  • @bluelab5019
    @bluelab5019 6 місяців тому

    Maybe i missed itbon the video, but i don't think you put a price on it?

    • @DreamofaHive
      @DreamofaHive 6 місяців тому +1

      It is £375

    • @bluelab5019
      @bluelab5019 6 місяців тому

      @@DreamofaHive not bad at all. Thanks

  • @marktechsci
    @marktechsci 6 місяців тому

    Wait. Can you repeat the closed and open part 200 more times cause it is hard to understand.

  • @sinisterhipp0
    @sinisterhipp0 6 місяців тому

    Interesting so as you push the rod it opens each column of cells one by one. So it should require less force than flow hive where you twist but open a chunk of cells.

    • @tidymeup
      @tidymeup 6 місяців тому

      Also if it becomes quite stiff to move you can attach the rod to a drill, turn it slowly while pushing inwards to make life easier.

    • @ulaB
      @ulaB 6 місяців тому +2

      While I do find the rod thing interesting, you can use the flow key in smaller intervals too.

    • @sinisterhipp0
      @sinisterhipp0 6 місяців тому +1

      Yes, that’s why I said opens a chunk. But twisting 1inch a time is works but maybe not as slick as poking this rod through.

  • @Krullfath
    @Krullfath 5 місяців тому

    Your audio could use some fine tuning

  • @kamonreynolds
    @kamonreynolds 6 місяців тому

    Looking forward to seeing where this goes!

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  6 місяців тому

      Cheers Kamon. I'll keep you posted! 🐝

    • @paulward7104
      @paulward7104 3 місяці тому

      Just bought 4. Paradise is nice kit. Fits together beautifully. Interested to see how this goes. Personally, I find honey extraction a ballache after the excitement of the first 10 minutes 😁. Would love an update on your experience thought.

  • @NaturalRawHoneyBees
    @NaturalRawHoneyBees 6 місяців тому +1

    It is a shame how Flow are threatening to take sellers of Paradise Hive retailers to court, forcing them to stop selling. Paradise should support their retailers who are being threatened with legal action as they are Paradise’s Agents! If Paradise stand by their design being materially different for believe Flow’s design protections /patents are not accurate or so high level are unreasonable - then open to challenge, then they should work with retailers in different countries to stand up against Flow’s anti-competitive actions.
    I have 2 Flows, however no longer recommend them due to what I believe is unethical business practices to stifle competition by threatening the small retailers and not taking action against the manufacturer- Paradise, who themselves should stand by and support their retailers. Not doing so can also be seen as unethical!
    Both have there place and should be considered by beekeepers looking for a method to extract direct from the hive.
    This may well spark a reaction….

    • @dsherman9438
      @dsherman9438 5 місяців тому +1

      I'll hold my judgement until I see if Flow Hives have a true case of patent violation. If they do then Flow has every right to enforce their patent. That's the law.

  • @splashandbuzz6836
    @splashandbuzz6836 6 місяців тому

    FlowHive's lawyers will be sharpening their pencils

    • @sinisterhipp0
      @sinisterhipp0 6 місяців тому

      Numerous differences in approach for the same goal. I think they’ve done a good job to avoiding a letter.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 6 місяців тому

      I'd suggest they already have and failed! Paradise Honey are a big operation and no mugs. This system has been in development for years they will have checked and double checked any possibility of copyright/patent infringements.

    • @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm
      @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm 6 місяців тому

      GRbage

    • @NaturalRawHoneyBees
      @NaturalRawHoneyBees 6 місяців тому

      Flow have been known to threaten retailers with legal action in a number of countries, but do not challenge the manufacturer - Paradise themselves as that is likely to mean if they lose once then precedent will be set in a number of other countries. I believe there are too many improvements and new features that Paradise should aim to do a test case against Flow to support their retailers/distributors in a number of countries - they would then benefit by being able to openly market and gain greater share in those markets, as well as encourage innovation.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 6 місяців тому

      @@NaturalRawHoneyBees Flowhive haven't got a leg to stand on against the Paradise system! They're not mugs and have spent years working on this. Their 'claims' for patent doesn't hold up.

  • @aidanquick3151
    @aidanquick3151 6 місяців тому

    Plastic

  • @BigRedNZ1
    @BigRedNZ1 6 місяців тому +1

    Great… more rubbish. And imagine the smoke when you get AFB. I don’t understand this need to avoid honey extraction and replace wax & wood frames with plastic

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 6 місяців тому

      And therein lies the problem - with all due respect 'you don't understand' ;)

    • @ulaB
      @ulaB 6 місяців тому

      What does AFB have to do with it?

    • @aidanquick3151
      @aidanquick3151 6 місяців тому

      ​@@ulaBwhen you burn your gear

    • @ulaB
      @ulaB 6 місяців тому

      @@aidanquick3151 There are different treatments available depending on your location like Bleach or Gamma Irradiation.

  • @brentncindy9023
    @brentncindy9023 Місяць тому

    It's seems as though nobody has any videos of themselves harvesting honey. That seems odd to me.

  • @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm
    @JawandoOokomondo-cb7fm 6 місяців тому

    Flow hive needs to be sued into babnrupsy

  • @paulward7104
    @paulward7104 2 місяці тому

    Hi Laurence. Did you do a follow up to this video? It have just bought 4 of these and wondered how you found them. Thanks for all you do. Paul