@@hedda4902 I know you mean well, but that's very disrespectful to both Taehyun and Jonghyun... Taehyun isn't filling in for Jonghyun, he's his own person with his own set of talents and personal grievances. And there's no replacing Jonghyun- as much as it hurts, there's no filling the void he's left behind.
@@2222titia i dont want anyone to feel that way. if someone sees it that way, please don't! jonghyun just didn't feel like he belonged there, it doesn't mean there's no hope for other people!! there's always hope!
@@no1catstan i completely agree his members and family members felt the worst pain and still feeling. I just want them to be happy they all worked hard and deserve good things in life. Love u jjong u did well 💙
@@siah9659 I never heard anything about his parents though. His sister was the one who was always around. Mind filling me in on like if the parents were in contact with him or outside of the country or smth. Cuz as I said, I have heard nothing about them. Only the sister and the members.
seeing this VCR of Jonghyun made me realize how much of an impact he has on the kpop industry. Jonghyun was one of a kind, and it’s sad to know that he took the route that he did. But, we must remember him for all the good he has done. Jonghyun was not always sad. whenever Jonghyun was around the ones he loved he was the brightest soul with the brightest smile. Whenever you watch cams of him at SHINEES concerts you can tell how much he deeply cherishes Shawols. It’s been a year since his death, I just want to take the time to say thank you Jonghyun for becoming one of the most talented singers/producers/songwriters I have ever seen. You left a legacy that we will never forget. Thank you for making us smile with your amazing personality. We know you are watching over Shawols and SHINEE and your loved ones. Thank you for everything Kim Jonghyun. Rest in peace.
Some people don’t understand how a depression feel like. It’s not always sad but numb. When u are rlly depressive u can’t feel happiness. From a certain time his happiness was just a mask.
No matter how much popularity a person gets they would always feel mixed emotions. They would always see light and darkness at some point. I just wish this precious boys would always feel the love, and all the other idols out there who are doing their best to be known they all have done soooo much well. Skills, fame and as a person I hope people see that for them because everyone deserves to be loved and understood.
GDA did the hard thing but did the right thing tributing him this openly. His tribute raised awareness for everyone. His pain and struggles are shared by every korean celeb and idol under the limelight. I'm sure everyone felt a part of themselves lost with his passing.
Its exactly what im doing right now 😔 I thought i could control my tears but when i heard the song and saw his face the tears tried to come down so i decided to watch this when im alone 😢
나는 종현님이 누군지도 몰랐었는데 잘알지도 못했던 사람인데 종현님 영상이 나오면 눈물이 흐른다...라디오 마지막 날 영상을 보면 일부로 단정하게 입고 나와서 펑펑 우는데 그걸 보면 가슴이 진짜 미워진다 너무 안타깝고 내가 이 사람을 몰랐던게 후회되고 잘알지도 좋아하지도 않았지만 그립다
Sometimes I feel very unlucky bcoz I didn't know about this legend.... when i heard the News about his death,then only I searched for him....n believe me I cried a lot...I saw his various fanmeeting, concerts videos...I really missed his magical voice...I always pray 2 god for u..Whenever r u, be happy .
same and I cant handle it. i didn't search for it because i would have cried but my jorney in kpop was just starting so i was bts biased. alot changed now and i would have known him by now. that kind of hurts and i respect him and yall alot
thinking about how proud jonghyun would be to see them where they are now. he's always been such an angel and truly never deserved this. rest in peace jjong
At 0:37 I couldn’t help but cry. His face broke my heart. It’s even worse knowing that that was the last time he performed, his last concert. He was looking at his fans one last time, like he didn’t want to forget them. I still can’t believe he his now gone, our precious Jjong we miss you❤️
So as someone who's also suffering from severe depression and unfortunately knowing how it is when you're feeling cornered by your own mind in that horrible moment. These type of statements are sometimes annoying. I know yall don't mean it like that but it sounds close to romantising the whole thing. He most likely didn't plan anything here. Most suicides actually aren't planned, he could've made the decision the same day. I just hate that people read into every single thing now a dead person did and it kinda takes away from the aspect of how mental illness works. It's rare that people plan far ahead to commit suicide.
he had so much more to live. he didn’t even got the chance to be a father or even to marry someone he really loved. to this day, I still cry when I think of him and I imagine how much he must have suffered to the point of ending his own life. He will forever be our Jonghyun and I hope now he is in a better place. May his soul Rest In Peace❤️
You’re not alone. I too still cry when I think of him very deeply. Never had the death of an artist affected me this bad but I think it’s the fact that to us kpop stans, it’s a natural given to care for our favs as people more than as artists and it’s okay to still cry no one can tell you that because you didn’t know him personally, you can’t mourn his loss however you are comfortable doing so. I Believe in being able to talk to the deceased by speaking to a photo of them with the heart and I’ve promised him that I would never let his memory die and I just hope that everyone else that ever loved him does the same....
저렇게 영상을 보거나 음성을 들으면.. 나도 너무너무너무 보고싶어지고 눈물이 나는데... 샤월분들은 얼마나... 보고싶으실까..ㅠㅠ 종현아.. 여전히 너의 목소린 너무좋고 니 웃는 모습이 너무 이쁘게 빛나서 너무 시리다...♥ 너무 수고했고... 여전히 고마워.. 좋은 노래 선물해준 너가 너무 고마워..♥
방탄소년단이 슬퍼하느냐 아니냐를 떠나서 이런 추모 영상의 리액션 영상을 찍어 올리는건 잘못된 겁니다. 오바가 아니라요. 누군가의 소중한 가수가 세상을 떠났고, 그 가수의 추모 영상이 틀어졌습니다. 그런데 추모 영상을 보는 가수들을 찍어 올리다니요. 방탄소년단에게도, 샤이니 멤버분들과 팬분들에게도 예의가 아닙니다. 제발 입장을 바꿔서 생각해주세요. 원래 리액션 영상을 찍어 올리시던 분인 건 맞는데, 이번 건 선을 넘지 않았나요? 팬을 떠나서 샤월이 아닌 입장에서도 황당하고 어이가 없네요. Regardless of whether BTS is sad or not, it is wrong to take a reaction video of a memorial video like this. It's not over. Someone's precious singer passed away, and the singer's memorial video was played. However, they are taking pictures of singers watching the memorial video. Neither BTS nor SHINee members and fans are polite. Please change your position and think. It's true that you were the one who uploaded the original reaction video, but this time hasn't crossed the line? Apart from the fans, it's absurd and ridiculous even from a position other than Shawol.
맞아요 ,, 무대 리액션 영상이면 아무 문제가 되지 않겠지만... 고인의 추모 영상인데 리액션에 중점을 두고 찍어올리는 것은 예의가 아닐 뿐더러 본래 추모 의도와도 맞지 않는 것 같네요 추모한다는 건 고인을 생각하는 시간을 가지는 것이지 다른 사람의 리액션을 보고자 하는 게 아니니까요,,
I wonder why this popped out in my recommendation and I just had to push it and now I'm regretting it bcs it's still sad even it's been few years. Jonghyun's passing will leave holes in lots people, never mind the shinee fans or general fans even since he's a major contributor of kpop in 2nd gen, but of course it'd be nothing compared to Jonghyun's friends.Lets remember his legacy thats the least we can do
andre imanuel Same. I wasn’t aware of K-Pop, BTS, or Jonghyun at the time of his passing, but it still breaks my heart. It hurts every day, and I don’t even understand how or why. But like you said, for his close friends, members, and family, it must be unbearable.
@@anduril2132 Thats why I really take my hats off for lots of his close friends who decided to become stronger in the name of Jonghyun's legacy. I'm not putting words in anyone's mouth bcs I dont know anything but seeing shinee's members continue to do their best and other close friends like IU or Taeyeon paying tribute for Jonghyun, or Kyuhyun who decided to sing his song and talk about him despite his obvious pain still warm my heart, at least Jonghyun's memory and legacy will forever live as memory for a lot of people
I wasn’t a shinee fan back then and even now, but this hits me every time. Seeing how he showed to his fans that he was happy, and no one knowing the pain he was going through it’s frustrating. It’s been almost 3 years now since his death and I think everyone still cries it like if it was just yesterday
@@__alevlogs true, for some people Jonghyun's passing might be their first time seeing the importance of mental health and realizing how people arent always what they seem. The regret felt by people close to Jonghyun wont be gone even after a long time, I still remember Kyuhyun from SJ sang a tribute to him in KOMS and he still cried after talking about it for like few seconds, its heartbreaking tbh but it was a beautiful thing to remember Jonghyun's legacy and I'm all for that
Music speaks for their artists so do not let it die. As long his music is alive, he's alive, right here in our hearts, shining brightly. I'd consider his real death the moment his music will die so let's atleast listen to his works. It means a lot to the artist who does it. As an Linkin Park fan who went to similar situations like shawols, this is a message to all: Do not let their music die. He left his music with us so that we all can remember him. After hearing to his works I no longer feel that he isn't with us. Maybe not physically but his songs represent him so I no longer feel like he's dead. He's right here, shining brightly in our memories & most importantly, through his music. Let's support his work.
One year later IU collaborate with Suga and wrote the song Eight as a tribute to Jonghyun and Sulli. After their collaboration people start to ship IU and Suga without knowing the real reason why they collaborate.
yoongi's reaction sent me crying off guard, i feel you yoongi. people might say yh cause jonghyun is their friend, but when you went throw the same depression journey.. IT HITS YOU HARDER!
All the boys look like they're about to cry here. Namjoon and Jimin drop their heads as soon as they recognize Jonghyun. Jin and Tae fidget and stare at the bigscreen sadly the whole time. Yoongi is fidgeting as well and looks like he may have cried a little towards the end. Hoseok and Jungkookie 100% cried. It must be hard. Jonghyun was one of those people they looked up to, and he as well as the rest of Shinee have always been kind to our boys. I can imagine they probably think about how they might feel if something like this were to happen to one of them as well. It's only human nature to put yourself in someone else's shoes. It's a shame that Jonghyun suffered so much that he felt there was no other way out. I hope that companies get better at keeping their idols mentally healthy as well as physically healthy. My heart aches for Jonghyun, his family, his members, Shawols, and everyone who was close to him. It's such a shame such a talented, lovely human being left the world so soon. I hope he's at peace.
Jjong, Shawols miss you Your brothers SHINee miss you Everyone does Jonghyun was so loveable let's not forget he had a good friendship with BTS as well, he was so loving and caring towards everyone ❤️🌙✨
NEVER SAY THAT THIS AWARD WAS ONLY BECAUSE THEY FELT SORRY FOR HIM. JONGHYUN TRULY DESERVES EVERYTHING FOR HIS HARD WORK AND IM HAPPY THAT HE IS ATILL BEING REWARDED FOR HIS HARD WORK. YOU’VE DONW WELL OPPA AND YOU WILL XONTINUE TO DO WELL. I MISS YOU😭💜 May you always be happy wherever you are❤️
@@k.m.m.m.827 on the original video. the award was posted on a channel and a lot of people said it was only bc he wasn't here anymore that he was getting awards.
Don't...just don't... Every time I see that man's face tears effortlessly gravitate down like an angry water fall... he was soo much to my heart and now he's gone... but even then everytime I come across his smiling face, I fail to tame my tears...Shawols miss you alot bling bling... you're forever engraved in our heart 💜💜💜
i miss jonghyun so much . 2 days before i heard the news about him, i was literally binge watching some videos of him :( he was so kind-hearted and talented 🥺.
I was thinking about Yoongi. He recently opened about his depression issues and suicidal thoughts. I can't even imagine how he felt during this whole tribute, what he was thinking about. Wishing him the best, always, against haters trying to let him down.
The fact that we got to see BTS and SHINee so close during 1 of 1 promotions...it must be hard to lose their hyung...they'd even smack each other's butts LOOOOOL
They are watching it without moving. They respect him so much. 😭 Wish we could turn back time and tell him he's doing really well and bring him back. Please😭
Let's not put blame where we don't know where to put it. Jonghyun was going through something and he voiced it, wrote about it, but one thing we will never ever know is the main reason for his decision. I miss him as well, been a fan of the entire group for 8 years. It's sad, but the best way to deal is continuing listening to his music, and never, ever, ever.......forget him and his massive contribution to the kpop industry.........Jonghyun, Prince of Kpop"❤❤❤
Tw: dec 18 As a blinger, some of yall need to stop acting as if yall knew jjong. Stop using him for clout, and stop saying SO much misinformation about him. He is not your "omg a member can turn out like him😢". He is not your poster boy for mental health, especially suicide; his depression and death doesn't define him as a person. He was open about his depression, he didn't "hide it" and he was around people who loved him for YEARS. He was the most brightest, charming, and most loving person. While of course I agree with my entire being his death shouldn't have happened, some of yalls comments are SO insensitive. EDIT: It seems that a lot of people are misunderstanding my comment so let me firstly apologize if I make it seem that I am trying to tell people how to feel. I know people begin to only know him after his death, and of course that is okay. I whole heartedly welcome new shawols. At the time when I made this comment there were A LOT of non-fans who began using him for clout and spreading misinformation. I do believe people should continue to talk about him and tell others how much of amazing person he was. He is not some forbidden topic. Whether or not you are an old or new shawol, we lost someone very dear to all of us. *My original comment was directed to those who **_only_** used him for clout and spread misinformation* .
thank you for saying this i found out about jjong after december, but it doesn't make it hurt less. we still miss him as much as those who knew him from the start. but people who want to benefit over people's sadness? acting like they know how it feels. like they care. it's messed up really i still don't feel like it's ok for me to feel sad, i didn't even know anything when i saw the news on tv but i want to be there for you guys and help you through this c: we should cherish the moments that jjong was with us, even though it hurts, we can bear the pain together
@@drainyang I have somewhat mixed feelings about new fans. Like yes, anyone can be sad over him but I personally believe it is somewhat worse for us blingers and shawols who had known him for a long period of time since some of us grew attached to him. However at the same time, I welcome new fans as long as they genuinely care and will support and love the boys. I've seen so many people stan them out of "pity" and it's heartbreaking. It's taken quite a long time for myself to realize certain things but I agree that we should just continue to cherish him instead of those who treat talking about him as a taboo. Myself along with other blingers I know will never stop talking about jjong and how much we love him. On a side note, I enjoyed you're comment so thank you :)
벌써 몇 년이 지났네요. 정말 종현님 수고하셨고 하늘에선 부디 행복한 일만 가득하시길 기도하겠습니다. 정말 감사했습니다.영상을 보다 문득 이런 생각이 들었어요.만약 내가 좋아하는 방탄소년단의 멤버분이 돌아가셨다면 내가 지금처럼 정신을 차리고 눈을 뜨고 숨을 쉬고 있을까? 지금처럼 모든 게 편안하고 안정적이게 살아갈 수 있을까? 정말 무서운 것 같아요. 요즘 연예계가 진짜 떠들썩한데 다들 참 고생 많이 하시는 것 같네요.모든 연예인들 다 건강하고 행복하시기만 하셨으면 좋겠어요. 다들 부디 건강하고 행복하고 아름다운 연예계 활동 하시기를 기도하겠습니다!
I'm not brave enough to watch this. I feel like I'll burst in tears, even if it's already 2020. So I'll leave this till next time I'm brave enough to watch it. :(
It‘s still so hard for me to believe that he is actually gone.. but at least he‘s happy now wherever he is. we love you and you‘ll always be remembered jonghyun💛
I'm reminded of that one moment BTS had with SHINee during a VLive where they were reacting to their own performances in a music broadcast. I was genuinely surprised they were acquainted. It was such a nice interaction that I hoped to see another SHINeeBTS moment... This moment hurts... yet, I am grateful that you have shared it...
What makes me cry so hard everytime I see anything related to jonghyun is not only the fact that we lost such an angel but also knowing that he died because he was hurting so much to the point that death became his way to survive is what kills me inside... such a heart-warming person shouldn't have gone through all this... RIP I won't ever forget u.. none of us will..
Opening it with his laugh tho, I miss it so much. I wish more people remembered him for things like that, for the happiness he did have and the happiness he gave to so many
BTS, you are one of the groups that bring huge success to K-Pop world. I am sure Jonghyun is proud because K-Pop is a part of his life. I get the feeling that he said thank you for your hardwork♡
I swear the fans and industry gotta treat these idols better because we never know what’s going on with them. There are too many cases of idols committing suicide.
Taehyungie couldn't watch it. Jinnie tried his best to let his eyes on the screen (Jin is truly like me), RMie and Jiminnie did great, I love how they clapped at the end with Jungkook, we can see the respect, Hoseokie's serious face worried me a bit, I wonder if he was thinking about his own depression and the way he could've dealt with it, or maybe that he could've been just like Jonghyun if it wasn't for BTS, and Yoongi...I think he didn't even notice, he seems so tired, I hope he's okay, our baby boy, BTS are truly humble Kings. I wanted to see the reaction of Taehyung and Jimin cause they are both really close friends with Minho and Taemin, I hope everyone is okay and taking care of each other, I wonder if SHINee live now in one and only place so that they can support each other ? Be happy everyone, live happily, I hope you'll find what you want in this life, good luck.
Actaully yoongi probably feels very much connected to this. Because he suffers from depression he definitely was uncomfortable. Also bts were close to Shinee memebers there’s even a backstage of blood sweat and tears I think where Shinee where watching the comeback and Jongyun just layer on the two... another time also kicking bts out of the room teasingly while Minho Huged tae
@@fakhriyahannisa4260 EXO is celebrating their 7th anniversary this year and has long ago began living apart. But BTS still chose to live together so I don't think they're moving anytime soon
Was I the only one who saw tae almost crying? ... I think I saw those two lines appearing on his face that appeared at an award receiving before wher they cried......... Or not..
It is just still really hard to believe that jonghyun is gone. But i know he's already happy wherever he is now. We just really missed you jjong. 😢
I'm thinking the same😢
He's up in.the clouds watching over us
paupau yeah! We have a younger Jonghyun! We have TxT Taehyun! They look alike
@@hedda4902 I know you mean well, but that's very disrespectful to both Taehyun and Jonghyun... Taehyun isn't filling in for Jonghyun, he's his own person with his own set of talents and personal grievances. And there's no replacing Jonghyun- as much as it hurts, there's no filling the void he's left behind.
;(
Ah. The wound of him being gone is still fresh.
방탄소년단타이 I can't patch mine 😔
@@dominikaskorupa884 i have tried but it just doesn't work-
It truly is :")
Why did they show Jonghyun VCR?
Was he honoured with any award?
@@aribaanam5156 he was awarded a daesang. Taemin and Minho did a speech in his honour.
This remind me when Jonghyun reaction bts cover perfect man from shinhwa . I burst in to tears TT 😭 Now he would sing in heaven.
Omg. More wanna cry after see this comment
Man he is going to hell
@@empire3590 someone finally said it 🤷♀️
エンパイアُEmpire you absolute piece of shit
aya what the fuck
The only regret I have was not being able to appreciate him when he was here with us.
Same tho
me too i’m crying
Same
Exactly
Literally same. I’m crying as I type this. This breaks my heart.
저기 계시는 아티스트 분들,팬분들 다 함성안지르시고 박수만 쳐주시는게 멋있당
영상 딱 틀자마자 바로 울었다 종현의 엄청난 팬도 아니였고 그냥 노래 몇 곡 좋아하는 정도였는데 그냥 막 눈물이 난다 벌써 시간도 꽤 지나서 괜찮을 거라 생각했는데 아직은 많이 그립나 보다 수고 많이 했어요 꼭 행복하시길..
그러게요 이상하게 시간이 지날수록 더 생각나네요..
보고싶어요 많이
Nani?
너무 좋은 사람이라 놓아주질 못하겠네요..
I avoided crying earlier but now?... Damn I couldn't hold my tears anymore
Veagle BANGTAN same
Same
Same
Me too. When I heard that beautiful laugh my heart skipped a beat and then it felt like it was being squeezed...after that, there's no holding back.
Same..
i nearly teared up when they show the VCR of the Late Jonghyun
wow.. yoongi seemed really down.. it hit him too.
we know how you feel yoongi, don't worry. he's now in a better place. ❣
Jonghyun was a friend of theirs 🥺
did he really cry ow
He’s human . Got to remember that .
Please don t say that he is in a better place or that he is happier now, it could encourage suicidal people to do it...
@@2222titia i dont want anyone to feel that way. if someone sees it that way, please don't! jonghyun just didn't feel like he belonged there, it doesn't mean there's no hope for other people!! there's always hope!
i can’t imagine the amount of pain these boys felt when they heard about his passing.
imagine the amount of pain his members felt, his family felt. He was such a great man I hope he's in a better place now
^
@@no1catstan i completely agree his members and family members felt the worst pain and still feeling. I just want them to be happy they all worked hard and deserve good things in life. Love u jjong u did well 💙
@@siah9659 I never heard anything about his parents though. His sister was the one who was always around. Mind filling me in on like if the parents were in contact with him or outside of the country or smth. Cuz as I said, I have heard nothing about them. Only the sister and the members.
Also cuz jimin is friends with taemin and V is friends with minho. Both groups were also backstage together the sadness must have been indescribable.
seeing this VCR of Jonghyun made me realize how much of an impact he has on the kpop industry. Jonghyun was one of a kind, and it’s sad to know that he took the route that he did. But, we must remember him for all the good he has done. Jonghyun was not always sad. whenever Jonghyun was around the ones he loved he was the brightest soul with the brightest smile. Whenever you watch cams of him at SHINEES concerts you can tell how much he deeply cherishes Shawols. It’s been a year since his death, I just want to take the time to say thank you Jonghyun for becoming one of the most talented singers/producers/songwriters I have ever seen. You left a legacy that we will never forget. Thank you for making us smile with your amazing personality. We know you are watching over Shawols and SHINEE and your loved ones. Thank you for everything Kim Jonghyun. Rest in peace.
who is brian ???!!! We also lost some of the fans as well that day if I remember correctly I think we lost 14 people or more
@@violetstarlight5561 omg! really?💔😢
Natasha I. Yea
Some people don’t understand how a depression feel like. It’s not always sad but numb. When u are rlly depressive u can’t feel happiness. From a certain time his happiness was just a mask.
Actually it's true it was big shock for kpop
No matter how much popularity a person gets they would always feel mixed emotions. They would always see light and darkness at some point. I just wish this precious boys would always feel the love, and all the other idols out there who are doing their best to be known they all have done soooo much well. Skills, fame and as a person I hope people see that for them because everyone deserves to be loved and understood.
So true. You spoke my words.💜
Best comment in the whole comment section.
GDA did the hard thing but did the right thing tributing him this openly. His tribute raised awareness for everyone. His pain and struggles are shared by every korean celeb and idol under the limelight. I'm sure everyone felt a part of themselves lost with his passing.
0:20 you can see Jimin say, “Oh, Jonghyun” and his face expression dropping into a pained one...
they are close to shinee members.
he was singing
I am crying so much I miss him
:(((
@@aielth8098 i dont think he was, he looked like he said something to rm and focused back towards the vr
jimin looked like he's gonna burst into tears any minute... i feel ya jimin
wish jjong was able to take the award himself today :'(
Me too but now he is in another life
Why did they show Jonghyun VCR?
Saaame
@@aribaanam5156 a tribute
I’m crying again...
I will forever cry
*i saved this to my watch later lost bc im with my family and im gonna cry and they will ask why im crying*
Ikr im gonna watch it now bc I’m alone now
im sobbing 😭
Its exactly what im doing right now 😔
I thought i could control my tears but when i heard the song and saw his face the tears tried to come down so i decided to watch this when im alone 😢
Yeah me too
•http.kookv• I’m tearing up at work because this is too much for me as a armyshawol
Damn. Their expressions instantly dropped. Even for me it's still hard to deal with. Can't image how hard it is for them.
I HATE U YT FOR RECOMMENDING ME THIS NOW A FEW DAYS AFTER THE 3 YEARS MARK 😭
Same💔😭
The wound is back😭😭💔💔
Same
Same
😭
I can't hold my tears.. 😭...still remember when I stan Jonghyun because his voice.... Don't worry untill now I still stan him 💜
내 귀에는 종현님의 노래가 맴돌고
내 눈에는 종현님의 무대에서 빛나던 모습이 보여
내 머리에는 항상 밝게 웃던 종현님이 떠올라
내 가슴에는 공연을 보고 감동을 받은게 느껴져
항상 보고싶다. 종현 ♥️
샤월로서 속상한듯 표정 지으시는 방탄분들이 걱정되지만서도 그냥 별거아닌데도 감사하네요. 방탄분들은 아픔없이 행복만가득하길 빌게요.
@뱌하 이 시대의 맥락맹
뱌하 사람이 죽은게 별거 아니라는게 아니라 방탄소년단이 저런 속삭해 하는 듯한 표정 짓는 것이 별거 아닌데도 감사하다는 거예요
많이 존경하던 분이 하루아침에 세상을 떠나셨으니까요....
저도 샤월은 아니였고 민호님,키님만 좋아했는데 마음 아프네요....
힘내세요
@뱌하 이래서 잼민이는 유튜브 못 하게 해야된다
전 샤월이 아니지만 첨에 소식 듣고 맘이 좀 복잡했어요...
원재현 님도 더이상은 아픔이없길 다랍니다.
나는 종현님이 누군지도 몰랐었는데 잘알지도 못했던 사람인데 종현님 영상이 나오면 눈물이 흐른다...라디오 마지막 날 영상을 보면 일부로 단정하게 입고 나와서 펑펑 우는데 그걸 보면 가슴이 진짜 미워진다 너무 안타깝고 내가 이 사람을 몰랐던게 후회되고 잘알지도 좋아하지도 않았지만 그립다
0:35 이때 vcr에 표정 가슴아픈건 니뿐인가... 되게 떠날것만같은 사람처럼 쳐다봐.. 정말 가슴아프다..
그곳에서도 잘 지내길...😯
종현이 마지막 콘서트 엔딩이였어요
방탄팬이지만 샤이니 너무너무 좋아합니다. 종현이가 정말 그립고 보고싶어요..
Sometimes I feel very unlucky bcoz I didn't know about this legend.... when i heard the News about his death,then only I searched for him....n believe me I cried a lot...I saw his various fanmeeting, concerts videos...I really missed his magical voice...I always pray 2 god for u..Whenever r u, be happy
.
Me too.
Me too😢😍
He was truly amazing, I wish you would have known him before this because he was the brightest light
same and I cant handle it. i didn't search for it because i would have cried but my jorney in kpop was just starting so i was bts biased. alot changed now and i would have known him by now. that kind of hurts and i respect him and yall alot
Same
You've worked hard jonghyun, I miss you :( I started sobbing seeing the vcr again
thinking about how proud jonghyun would be to see them where they are now. he's always been such an angel and truly never deserved this. rest in peace jjong
본 영상보다 방탄 리액션 영상이 조회수도 훨씬 많고 검색해도 먼저 뜨고.. 방탄소년단 분들이 추모한다는 것을 알리고 싶으신 마음은 이해하지만 제 입장에서는 이것마저 리액션 영상을 올려야 할지..
인정해요 이런영상 리액션 올린의도가 너무 투명해서.. 샤월은 아닌데 이건 좀..ㅔ
리액션 한 건 별 문제가 안 되는 데 이걸 올린 게 문제가 되는 거임
진짜 그립다.. 많은 사람들이 진심으로 그리워하고 있다는걸 알았으면 좋겠어요....하늘에서라도 행복하기를.
+그리고 저 영상을 보는 연예인들은 또 어떤 마음일지..
종현아 본상 축하해ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ보고싶어
너무 슬프다..ㅠ 방탄도 다들 숙연해졌어..ㅠ
At 0:37 I couldn’t help but cry. His face broke my heart. It’s even worse knowing that that was the last time he performed, his last concert. He was looking at his fans one last time, like he didn’t want to forget them. I still can’t believe he his now gone, our precious Jjong we miss you❤️
So as someone who's also suffering from severe depression and unfortunately knowing how it is when you're feeling cornered by your own mind in that horrible moment. These type of statements are sometimes annoying. I know yall don't mean it like that but it sounds close to romantising the whole thing. He most likely didn't plan anything here. Most suicides actually aren't planned, he could've made the decision the same day. I just hate that people read into every single thing now a dead person did and it kinda takes away from the aspect of how mental illness works. It's rare that people plan far ahead to commit suicide.
he had so much more to live. he didn’t even got the chance to be a father or even to marry someone he really loved. to this day, I still cry when I think of him and I imagine how much he must have suffered to the point of ending his own life. He will forever be our Jonghyun and I hope now he is in a better place. May his soul Rest In Peace❤️
You’re not alone. I too still cry when I think of him very deeply. Never had the death of an artist affected me this bad but I think it’s the fact that to us kpop stans, it’s a natural given to care for our favs as people more than as artists and it’s okay to still cry no one can tell you that because you didn’t know him personally, you can’t mourn his loss however you are comfortable doing so. I Believe in being able to talk to the deceased by speaking to a photo of them with the heart and I’ve promised him that I would never let his memory die and I just hope that everyone else that ever loved him does the same....
J hope and Jungkook cried
yeaahh😭
@@iwachan2475 1:22 ?
suga also.
I see it too😢
@@monicazela5160 yeah, I can tell he's having a hard time
저렇게 영상을 보거나 음성을 들으면.. 나도 너무너무너무 보고싶어지고 눈물이 나는데... 샤월분들은 얼마나... 보고싶으실까..ㅠㅠ 종현아.. 여전히 너의 목소린 너무좋고 니 웃는 모습이 너무 이쁘게 빛나서 너무 시리다...♥ 너무 수고했고... 여전히 고마워.. 좋은 노래 선물해준 너가 너무 고마워..♥
방탄소년단이 슬퍼하느냐 아니냐를 떠나서 이런 추모 영상의 리액션 영상을 찍어 올리는건 잘못된 겁니다. 오바가 아니라요. 누군가의 소중한 가수가 세상을 떠났고, 그 가수의 추모 영상이 틀어졌습니다. 그런데 추모 영상을 보는 가수들을 찍어 올리다니요. 방탄소년단에게도, 샤이니 멤버분들과 팬분들에게도 예의가 아닙니다. 제발 입장을 바꿔서 생각해주세요. 원래 리액션 영상을 찍어 올리시던 분인 건 맞는데, 이번 건 선을 넘지 않았나요? 팬을 떠나서 샤월이 아닌 입장에서도 황당하고 어이가 없네요.
Regardless of whether BTS is sad or not, it is wrong to take a reaction video of a memorial video like this. It's not over. Someone's precious singer passed away, and the singer's memorial video was played. However, they are taking pictures of singers watching the memorial video. Neither BTS nor SHINee members and fans are polite. Please change your position and think. It's true that you were the one who uploaded the original reaction video, but this time hasn't crossed the line? Apart from the fans, it's absurd and ridiculous even from a position other than Shawol.
맞아요 ,, 무대 리액션 영상이면 아무 문제가 되지 않겠지만... 고인의 추모 영상인데 리액션에 중점을 두고 찍어올리는 것은 예의가 아닐 뿐더러 본래 추모 의도와도 맞지 않는 것 같네요 추모한다는 건 고인을 생각하는 시간을 가지는 것이지 다른 사람의 리액션을 보고자 하는 게 아니니까요,,
Tbh It’s still really heartbreaking that he is not alive but he’ll be proud of all of us💜 I miss him sooo much🥺🥺🥺
the fact that Jungkook grew up listening to Jonghyun, he was 11 when SHINee debuted.
RIP my beautiful moon🪦🕊 💙
I wonder why this popped out in my recommendation and I just had to push it and now I'm regretting it bcs it's still sad even it's been few years. Jonghyun's passing will leave holes in lots people, never mind the shinee fans or general fans even since he's a major contributor of kpop in 2nd gen, but of course it'd be nothing compared to Jonghyun's friends.Lets remember his legacy thats the least we can do
andre imanuel Same. I wasn’t aware of K-Pop, BTS, or Jonghyun at the time of his passing, but it still breaks my heart. It hurts every day, and I don’t even understand how or why. But like you said, for his close friends, members, and family, it must be unbearable.
@@anduril2132 Thats why I really take my hats off for lots of his close friends who decided to become stronger in the name of Jonghyun's legacy. I'm not putting words in anyone's mouth bcs I dont know anything but seeing shinee's members continue to do their best and other close friends like IU or Taeyeon paying tribute for Jonghyun, or Kyuhyun who decided to sing his song and talk about him despite his obvious pain still warm my heart, at least Jonghyun's memory and legacy will forever live as memory for a lot of people
I wasn’t a shinee fan back then and even now, but this hits me every time. Seeing how he showed to his fans that he was happy, and no one knowing the pain he was going through it’s frustrating. It’s been almost 3 years now since his death and I think everyone still cries it like if it was just yesterday
@@__alevlogs true, for some people Jonghyun's passing might be their first time seeing the importance of mental health and realizing how people arent always what they seem. The regret felt by people close to Jonghyun wont be gone even after a long time, I still remember Kyuhyun from SJ sang a tribute to him in KOMS and he still cried after talking about it for like few seconds, its heartbreaking tbh but it was a beautiful thing to remember Jonghyun's legacy and I'm all for that
Music speaks for their artists so do not let it die. As long his music is alive, he's alive, right here in our hearts, shining brightly. I'd consider his real death the moment his music will die so let's atleast listen to his works. It means a lot to the artist who does it. As an Linkin Park fan who went to similar situations like shawols, this is a message to all: Do not let their music die. He left his music with us so that we all can remember him. After hearing to his works I no longer feel that he isn't with us. Maybe not physically but his songs represent him so I no longer feel like he's dead. He's right here, shining brightly in our memories & most importantly, through his music. Let's support his work.
He will always remain as good memory for us... And our Boys were also close to him, they must had felt really sad that time.. 😞💜
종현님 잘 알지도 못했었는데.. 수고했어 고생했어 듣자마자.. 와.. 무너져버림..
솔직히 샤이니를 정말 많이 좋아하는 팬은 아니였지만 좋은 노래가 너무 많아서 호감이 갔던 아이돌이였음 근데도 종현 얼굴만 보면 눈물 나네
One year later IU collaborate with Suga and wrote the song Eight as a tribute to Jonghyun and Sulli. After their collaboration people start to ship IU and Suga without knowing the real reason why they collaborate.
WE LOVE YOU JJONG ! FOREVER!
I can’t get over 0:36. It’s such a heartbreaking shot of him. We miss you so much, I hope you’re happy up there ❤️
Me too
yoongi's reaction sent me crying off guard, i feel you yoongi.
people might say yh cause jonghyun is their friend, but when you went throw the same depression journey.. IT HITS YOU HARDER!
All the boys look like they're about to cry here. Namjoon and Jimin drop their heads as soon as they recognize Jonghyun. Jin and Tae fidget and stare at the bigscreen sadly the whole time. Yoongi is fidgeting as well and looks like he may have cried a little towards the end. Hoseok and Jungkookie 100% cried. It must be hard. Jonghyun was one of those people they looked up to, and he as well as the rest of Shinee have always been kind to our boys. I can imagine they probably think about how they might feel if something like this were to happen to one of them as well. It's only human nature to put yourself in someone else's shoes. It's a shame that Jonghyun suffered so much that he felt there was no other way out. I hope that companies get better at keeping their idols mentally healthy as well as physically healthy. My heart aches for Jonghyun, his family, his members, Shawols, and everyone who was close to him. It's such a shame such a talented, lovely human being left the world so soon. I hope he's at peace.
Ya, SM better take care of their artist. They already lost two talented idol, jonghyun, and Sulli... No more.
I still can’t believe that he’s gone... but we know that he isn’t suffering anymore. That the angel jonghyun is looking over them
수고했어요. 정말 고생했어요. 그댄 나의 자랑이죠.
When I heard Jong's laughter... 😢😢
jimin.serendipity Soon as I heard it, I broke down😣
늘 밝았던 모습으로 티비에나오고 라디오를하고 노래로 사람들을 위로해줬던 종현님..이젠 당신이 위로받을차렙니다 늘 평안하시길..🙏🙏
Jjong, Shawols miss you
Your brothers SHINee miss you
Everyone does
Jonghyun was so loveable let's not forget he had a good friendship with BTS as well, he was so loving and caring towards everyone ❤️🌙✨
무대에서 빛났었던 종현이형! 항상 외롭고 힘들었을텐데 우리가 알아채지 못해서 미안해 하늘에서도 무대위 처럼 반짝였으면 좋겠어!😢
정말수고했어 정말고생했어
NEVER SAY THAT THIS AWARD WAS ONLY BECAUSE THEY FELT SORRY FOR HIM. JONGHYUN TRULY DESERVES EVERYTHING FOR HIS HARD WORK AND IM HAPPY THAT HE IS ATILL BEING REWARDED FOR HIS HARD WORK. YOU’VE DONW WELL OPPA AND YOU WILL XONTINUE TO DO WELL. I MISS YOU😭💜 May you always be happy wherever you are❤️
Who said that? :0
@@k.m.m.m.827 on the original video. the award was posted on a channel and a lot of people said it was only bc he wasn't here anymore that he was getting awards.
Don't...just don't...
Every time I see that man's face tears effortlessly gravitate down like an angry water fall... he was soo much to my heart and now he's gone... but even then everytime I come across his smiling face, I fail to tame my tears...Shawols miss you alot bling bling... you're forever engraved in our heart 💜💜💜
추모영상이랑 방탄이랑 무슨 관련이 있는지도 모르겠고 무례하단 생각이 드네요... 남의 추모를 보고 슬퍼하나 슬퍼하지 않나 태도가 어떤가 등이 구경거리가 된다는게 어이가 없네요
걍 영상 보는 모습 올린게 뭐라고 어이가 없기까지ㅋ ㅋ ㅋ
어이없을수도있죠
저도 같은 생각
유서진 추모하는 모습까지 굳이 찍어 올려야하나..?
Yunseo Chung 그거랑 무슨 상관이죠
i miss jonghyun so much . 2 days before i heard the news about him, i was literally binge watching some videos of him :( he was so kind-hearted and talented 🥺.
아닌척 하지만 속으론 많이 울었을 멤버들. 다들 아닌척 하지만 속으론 정말 많이 아프고 속상할거예요..몇년이 지나 괜찮은 줄 알았지만 아직 많이 속상하고 종현님의 목소리가 들리자 눈물이 흐르네요. 종현님 정말 고생하셨어요 그곳에선 행복하시길 바랍니다.
I desperately wish I had found jonghyun before he passed but I’m so blessed to see videos and pics of him. I miss him.
I was thinking about Yoongi.
He recently opened about his depression issues and suicidal thoughts.
I can't even imagine how he felt during this whole tribute, what he was thinking about.
Wishing him the best, always, against haters trying to let him down.
종현님...비록 타팬이지만 하늘에서 편히 쉬세요...행복하세요..
The fact that we got to see BTS and SHINee so close during 1 of 1 promotions...it must be hard to lose their hyung...they'd even smack each other's butts LOOOOOL
Did anybody notice jungkook trying hard not to cry at the end then bow his head down and wipe his tears he has a pure heart ❤️
I watched this to see their reactions but I cried and missed him instead 😢
They are watching it without moving. They respect him so much. 😭
Wish we could turn back time and tell him he's doing really well and bring him back. Please😭
가수로 치면은 백퍼센트 민우도 작년에 떠났는데 이게 무명가수의 슬픔인가ㅏㅜㅜㅜ
아 네ㅔㅜㅜ 아마 인터넷에 치면 나올꺼예요 ㅜㅜ2018년 5월쯤 돌아 가신거로 알고 있어요 ㅜㅜ그래서 백퍼센트 그룹 맴버들도 샤이니랑 똑같이 팬들을 위해서 콘서트 하겠다고 나섰었죠 ㅜㅜ 너무 슬퍼요 ㅜㅜ
@@user-gt6zm9xm6y 그 반올림 나왔던 배우출신 맞죠?
뇌진탕 앗네!맞아용!!
@@user-gt6zm9xm6y 반올림때 좋은배우로 기억했었는데 아쉽네요 아이돌로 데뷔했었군요
좋은곳으로 가셨을거에요...제가 감히 위로를 해드릴수가없네요
종현오빠 보고싶어요... 매일매일 오빠생각을 하면 눈에서 눈물부터 흘러요.. 오빠 너무 보고싶어요..
그냥 종현님의 팬도 아닌데 울컥하네요.
28세.. 진짜.. 하늘에서 가장 행복하게 사시길 기도할께요. 다음생에선 100세. 아니,200세두 넘게. 행복하게 . 가슴 아프다
Let's not put blame where we don't know where to put it. Jonghyun was going through something and he voiced it, wrote about it, but one thing we will never ever know is the main reason for his decision. I miss him as well, been a fan of the entire group for 8 years. It's sad, but the best way to deal is continuing listening to his music, and never, ever, ever.......forget him and his massive contribution to the kpop industry.........Jonghyun, Prince of Kpop"❤❤❤
aww BTS really do love other kpop groups too and they show love and empathy towards jjong aww
Tw: dec 18
As a blinger, some of yall need to stop acting as if yall knew jjong. Stop using him for clout, and stop saying SO much misinformation about him. He is not your "omg a member can turn out like him😢". He is not your poster boy for mental health, especially suicide; his depression and death doesn't define him as a person. He was open about his depression, he didn't "hide it" and he was around people who loved him for YEARS. He was the most brightest, charming, and most loving person. While of course I agree with my entire being his death shouldn't have happened, some of yalls comments are SO insensitive.
EDIT: It seems that a lot of people are misunderstanding my comment so let me firstly apologize if I make it seem that I am trying to tell people how to feel. I know people begin to only know him after his death, and of course that is okay. I whole heartedly welcome new shawols. At the time when I made this comment there were A LOT of non-fans who began using him for clout and spreading misinformation. I do believe people should continue to talk about him and tell others how much of amazing person he was. He is not some forbidden topic. Whether or not you are an old or new shawol, we lost someone very dear to all of us. *My original comment was directed to those who **_only_** used him for clout and spread misinformation* .
My heart is tired. I just want non-Shawols to see him MORE than that. I’m sick of people pretending to care and be a “fan.”
thank you for saying this
i found out about jjong after december, but it doesn't make it hurt less. we still miss him as much as those who knew him from the start.
but people who want to benefit over people's sadness? acting like they know how it feels. like they care. it's messed up really
i still don't feel like it's ok for me to feel sad, i didn't even know anything when i saw the news on tv
but i want to be there for you guys and help you through this c:
we should cherish the moments that jjong was with us, even though it hurts, we can bear the pain together
@@clementine6276 Yes! I'm sick of these people calling him "jjong" when they never even knew him or cared about him.
@@drainyang I have somewhat mixed feelings about new fans. Like yes, anyone can be sad over him but I personally believe it is somewhat worse for us blingers and shawols who had known him for a long period of time since some of us grew attached to him. However at the same time, I welcome new fans as long as they genuinely care and will support and love the boys. I've seen so many people stan them out of "pity" and it's heartbreaking. It's taken quite a long time for myself to realize certain things but I agree that we should just continue to cherish him instead of those who treat talking about him as a taboo. Myself along with other blingers I know will never stop talking about jjong and how much we love him. On a side note, I enjoyed you're comment so thank you :)
Angela Flores I can’t see the problem..
정말 종현아 수고했어... 거기에선 아픔은 다 잊고... 편하게 잘 지내고있어야해...
아프지말고..사랑했어 종현아...
As someone who struggles with depression too, I know exactly how he felt....same feelings...
This is so sad😔
Rip Jonghyun💔
Here I am.....again.
When jjong's laugh echoed through the whole venue it still hit hard.
I don’t ever want BTS- let alone anyone to feel like they have to end their lives to fix something. Bless everyone 🙏
0:37 Jonghyun's face broke my heart 😢😢😢
벌써 몇 년이 지났네요. 정말 종현님 수고하셨고 하늘에선 부디 행복한 일만 가득하시길 기도하겠습니다. 정말 감사했습니다.영상을 보다 문득 이런 생각이 들었어요.만약 내가 좋아하는 방탄소년단의 멤버분이 돌아가셨다면 내가 지금처럼 정신을 차리고 눈을 뜨고 숨을 쉬고 있을까?
지금처럼 모든 게 편안하고 안정적이게 살아갈 수 있을까? 정말 무서운 것 같아요.
요즘 연예계가 진짜 떠들썩한데 다들 참 고생 많이 하시는 것 같네요.모든 연예인들 다 건강하고 행복하시기만 하셨으면 좋겠어요.
다들 부디 건강하고 행복하고 아름다운 연예계 활동 하시기를 기도하겠습니다!
I'm not brave enough to watch this. I feel like I'll burst in tears, even if it's already 2020. So I'll leave this till next time I'm brave enough to watch it. :(
It‘s still so hard for me to believe that he is actually gone.. but at least he‘s happy now wherever he is. we love you and you‘ll always be remembered jonghyun💛
They all look like they’re holding back tears, Jin, Jimin, Hobi and yoongi especially.
I'm burst into tears again when see this video 😭😭 Rest well, Jonghyun. We always love you ♥♥♥
From : Army
To : Shawol
Stay strong!! ♥♥♥
I don't focus on BTS I always focus on Jonghyun's VCR..and I cry..
Jonghyung's voice it's just amazing...i'm sad he is gone...but I hope he is happy now! I love him!rip angel
I'm not even Fan of him but it makes me cry when ever I see him .
I'm reminded of that one moment BTS had with SHINee during a VLive where they were reacting to their own performances in a music broadcast. I was genuinely surprised they were acquainted. It was such a nice interaction that I hoped to see another SHINeeBTS moment... This moment hurts... yet, I am grateful that you have shared it...
What makes me cry so hard everytime I see anything related to jonghyun is not only the fact that we lost such an angel but also knowing that he died because he was hurting so much to the point that death became his way to survive is what kills me inside... such a heart-warming person shouldn't have gone through all this...
RIP I won't ever forget u.. none of us will..
수고했어요 정말수고했어요 에서 진짜나도 모르게 눈물 맺힘
Opening it with his laugh tho, I miss it so much. I wish more people remembered him for things like that, for the happiness he did have and the happiness he gave to so many
BTS, you are one of the groups that bring huge success to K-Pop world. I am sure Jonghyun is proud because K-Pop is a part of his life. I get the feeling that he said thank you for your hardwork♡
the vcr didn't even play yet and I was already in tears hearing the music
tae looks like he’s trying so hard not to cry it actually breaks my heart
Yes
They looks so sad
I was never a shinee fan but id always been aware of Jonghyun's presence and found him entertaining. I find it crazy to think he's .. dead.
I swear the fans and industry gotta treat these idols better because we never know what’s going on with them. There are too many cases of idols committing suicide.
Taehyungie couldn't watch it. Jinnie tried his best to let his eyes on the screen (Jin is truly like me), RMie and Jiminnie did great, I love how they clapped at the end with Jungkook, we can see the respect, Hoseokie's serious face worried me a bit, I wonder if he was thinking about his own depression and the way he could've dealt with it, or maybe that he could've been just like Jonghyun if it wasn't for BTS, and Yoongi...I think he didn't even notice, he seems so tired, I hope he's okay, our baby boy, BTS are truly humble Kings.
I wanted to see the reaction of Taehyung and Jimin cause they are both really close friends with Minho and Taemin, I hope everyone is okay and taking care of each other, I wonder if SHINee live now in one and only place so that they can support each other ?
Be happy everyone, live happily, I hope you'll find what you want in this life, good luck.
They have lived seprately for quite some time now. it's just Jinki and Minho who lives together in dorm.
Actaully yoongi probably feels very much connected to this. Because he suffers from depression he definitely was uncomfortable. Also bts were close to Shinee memebers there’s even a backstage of blood sweat and tears I think where Shinee where watching the comeback and Jongyun just layer on the two... another time also kicking bts out of the room teasingly while Minho Huged tae
all group in korean they will live in dorm when 1-7 year debut. when 8 years-10years they will live in apertement personal
@@fakhriyahannisa4260 EXO is celebrating their 7th anniversary this year and has long ago began living apart. But BTS still chose to live together so I don't think they're moving anytime soon
Yoongi and Taehyung did watch, but from another smaller screen.
Was I the only one who saw tae almost crying?
...
I think I saw those two lines appearing on his face that appeared at an award receiving before wher they cried.........
Or not..
I actually saw that too!
His face started to look like it did before he started to cry at the award speech :/
36초에 종현님이 팬들 바라보는 표정이 왜이렇게 슬프게 느껴질까 ㅠㅠ
제목 보자마자 눈 찡그리면서 들어왔네
I am crying right now, I can’t believe he is gone. He is our angel, we love you Jonghyun 💖😭❤️