Bears QB Caleb Williams: 2024 NFL Draft Scouting Report
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 січ 2024
- In this video, I give my scouting report for USC QB Caleb Williams, who is my #2 QB in the 2024 NFL Draft. Williams would've been the highest graded player in the any of the last 3 drafts, but I do have the former Heisman winner barely behind Drake Maye (as of now).
Bears QB Caleb Williams: 2024 NFL Draft Scouting Report
For more film breakdowns follow us here:
atozsports.com/all-nfl-film-r...
NFL Draft Board: atozsports.com/nfl-draft/2024...
Instagram: / atozsportsfilmroom
TikTok: / atozfilmroom
Twitter: / noflagsfilm
Facebook: / nflfansatoz
#NFLDraft #NFLFootball #ChicagoBears
All film used is courtesy of NFL+ and the All-22 broadcasts associated with that service and subscription. No copyright is intended. - Спорт
2024 NFL Draft Big Board: atozsports.com/nfl-draft/2024-nfl-draft-big-board-top-prospects/
Caleb vs ASU:
322 yds
3:0 TD/INT
2 rush TDs
Caleb vs COL:
403 yds
6:1 TD/INT
Idk if that classifies as a couple of bad games
P.S. i will also be curious to see how much hero ball CW plays considering he wont have to put up like 45 pts/gm just to MAYBE win
Caleb was playing too much hero ball last season. Caleb knew the offense had to score big because of the defense.
Appreciate the visuals and info. Top notch!!!
Waiting on the DSR on B. Bowers.
PLEASE PLEASE TELL ME WHERE YOU GET THESE START
STAT TOOLS
I don’t think his build is that slight. His clavicles aren’t that narrow and his calves are almost disproportionately big which tends to hint at good hypertrophic genetics. He can definitely put more muscle on his frame as compared to someone like Bryce young. And he definitely plays strong, hard to bring down and is durable enough to sprint downfield, throw lead blocks and jog to the huddle unphased the next play.
I think he’ll be a surprisingly good dual threat at the next level
Insightful review, especially your observation that some of the hero plays he makes at the collegiate level will be difficult to accomplish in the NFL.
I feel like he had to play hero ball because of the garbage defense. If he doesn’t put up points, the game is over.
@@theman8034if anything he should be trying to double the other teams time of possession so they don’t have as much time to score on the D
Excellent video, your film study and explanation is definitely on point. Kyler Murray comp is accurate. As a Broncos fan potentially looking for a QB in the draft, a Jayden Daniels video would be great. He’s my top QB, but granted, I have not seen much of Drake Maye.
I will agree with you on Caleb Williams not being the top QB in this year’s class. In my opinion, he sits way too long in the pocket and the majority of his highlights are improvising. I have concerns with Caleb’s lack of consistency from within the pocket. However, I will say a team like the Commanders could be a nice fit for Caleb. They have many talented playmakers and he could excel outside the pocket with Washington’s poor o-line and be coached by Eric Bienemy. What do you think?
Jayden Daniels will be coming soon, stay tuned. Williams to WSH would be an interesting fit for sure, but I could see it working. WSH's situation with Howell is a weird one, I thought he was their guy halfway through this year, but now obviously things have changed.
Is Caleb Williams personality and mental toughness going to affect him at the next level though ? We know he can ball on the field but the mentality to play qb in Chicago is what I worry about. And his processing. Is his level of processing a worry to you? That fields biggest weakness imo. Jus wondering ur opinion if u have one on that
Alright, tough question and one begging for you to make a video on...Caleb Williams vs Justin Fields. Which QB should the Bears go with in your opinion? I would think this would be a exceptionally well viewed video.
I would say that the Bears would have to go Williams if it was one or the other. Give Fields a fresh start somewhere else and cut your losses with him (he wasn't the only issue obviously). Gotta get some help either way though around him
One comparison I absolutely hate is the CW = JF1
Yes, they both hold onto the ball for a long time. But Caleb's scramble-run% is around 3%. Whereas JF1 has around 9%. Also CW reads the Field far better and has a much quicker release and better arm tallent.
JF1 doesnt suck but I hate the direct comparison
@@AtoZSportsFilmRoom The advantages to keeping Fields and trading the top pick would be...yet another draft haul. People forget just HOW bad the Bears roster was a year ago. The roster has improved, but there are still plenty of holes on it that could be filled with a trade down.
With Caleb Williams he HAS to be a great player or you took the wrong option. With a trade down, you have a larger margin for error imo. The best teams generally make the most draft picks. Some of those picks will pan out, some won't. But the volume of picks they make will make up for it. This was Dallas in the 90s and Patriots in the early 2000s.
I tend to think any QB will struggle unless the supporting cast around him is also good. Fields reads the defense slower than he should and never loved his throwing mechanics, but he also had about as bad a supporting cast as you can get his first two years.
caleb time
I like that you have him second behind Daniels...I think the most accurate take based on recent data
Scary thing is even as I watched him as a bears fan working at usc is although his splash plays and ability is amazing he has some inconsistency and reminds me a lot of Zach Wilson.. He is better than Zach don’t get me wrong but his inconsistency of the structured plays and routes scares me . Zach had the same wow and struggle tho not at Caleb level the similarities give me pause..
As a sad Titans fan like yourself, I'd appreciate as much OL scouting reports as possible lol.
Already have breakdowns out on Olu Fashanu, Joe Alt, and JC Latham, go check em out! (99.99% chance one of them will be a Titan)
@@AtoZSportsFilmRoomTitans fan here too! Either one will work
Micheal Penix Jr or Odunze next plz !!! *can you tell imma Huskie fan?* GO DAWGS
Both will come soon, stay tuned.
Definitely doesn’t have a slight build , the kid is strong. And his comparison should be pat mahomes, he gets a bad rap because he is quirky, this kid will be great.
Lmbo Smh Kyler and Bryce comp is priceless humor.Dude’s pocket presence and passing release is from another world.Watching whole games is important because he’s a budding superstar.As soon as he puts that Chicago Bears helmet on let enshrinement begin.
Listen to what I said again. Off the charts talent doesn't automatically make it work in the NFL.
@@AtoZSportsFilmRoomI listened then I commented and now I’m replying again your comment.His comps I don’t agree with and no other football person agrees with it.😂.It’s cool though we’ve all have had far fetched opinions before.Nice vid my boy
@@Yatazachqa-E-SI have seen a lot of Kyler comps
@@Ericrr79 I've seen alot more Mahomes.Shalom
Woah, QB2 not QB1? Interesting. I’d like to hear more about why you think he isn’t the top QB over Maye?
Titans should take him if he's available @6-10.
IDC what Levis has shown. This guy is a no doubt foundational piece with elite potential and can be a top 3 guy for the next 10 years.
Package Levis for picks. Can Vrabel and Kelly. Start the rebuild the correct way.
@@Fakewhack-st8flI don't see him making it past the giants, at the latest. Plus, he'd still be behind a horrendous line, and have little to no weapons.
Big hell to the no!
Dude had the worst o line in college football lmao of course he played hero ball. To a fault.. but let’s be real. Worst defense and offense, he gotta do what he gotta do. Not to mention… he doesn’t turn the ball over at all
Def doesn't have a slight build......powerful lower half
Don’t agree with this accuracy, I’ve watched over half of usc games this year, and he misses dozens of recievers and doesn’t throw on target
Small hands, weak grip, 35 sacks in 12 games…lots of fun stuff but lots of bad stuff too, against powerhouses like San Jose State and UCLA, you know the “Alabama and Georgia’s if the PAC 12!
Shane Steichen coaching tree/scheme fits far better than the McDaniel west coast. McDaniels offense is unique to him and caleb is not going to Miami. Lazy
He seems over rated. His replacement put up 6 TDs replacing him in the Holiday bowl and 372 yards. They didn’t miss a beat. The season record was 7-5. He seems to have an attitude wanting piece of team and denying teams draft him. Do locker rooms follow guys like that?
Eli did that and won 2 super bowls
Nah the kid is really good. Seems like a dickhead but definitely not overrated as far as play on the field his backup is a good qb as well let’s not forget we talking about usc
Louisville didn’t have film on Moss thats part of the reason he had a 6 TD day
2:50 if anyone watch Justin Fields highlights the second half of 2023 season, you can see that he does EXACTLY the same things. In 2022 he did not look down the field to find someone open but now he does all the time. I think that is his greatest jump to the NFL level. How many times have you seen QBs roll out and then find someone open. Rodgers, Mahomes, Jackson. All the time!! They keep their eyes down field as they are running from defenders with the thought of passing first, run second. Fields found open guys a lot in the game against the Falcons. A defense ranked top 10
This is an evaluation on Patrick Mahomes.
@@glenncarter2494 What? lol I obviously hit a nerve.
Settle down.
Bro is gonna be the worst bust since Zach Wilson
Arginine four reasons that disproves y'all theories about this young man being a generational quarterback won his character is shity he's not an on-field leader or a locker leader 3 he don't perform well against good competition for his backup quarterback came in through for six touchdown and broke all type of passing records in one game that speaks volumes to what type of player he really is
You know what’s crazy❓you just described Aaron Rodgers at the pro level and I think his career panned out well
1. Rubs teammates the wrong way.. bad leader
2.horrible numbers vs elite defenses (Niners and Seahawks especially..NFC West in general basically anyone minus Bears)
Packers back up Matt Flynn had a 6 TD game as well
So yeah❓he’s Aaron Rodgers I guess
I’m sorry I don’t see it. Mark my words either JJ MCARTHY OR MICHAEL PENIX IF HE STATS HEALTHY WILL HAVE A BETTER CAREER. Caleb has a good arm but the NFL is not college. So do an nfl QB GIVE ME PENIX OR JJ
After 2022, I thought Caleb was going to be a generational pick. However, his inconsistent, mediocre, and even poor play at times this year has made me less confident in his capability to be great in the NFL. We will see soon enough.
Would've benefited him more if he came out last year
Commanders take jayden daniels
3:30 At best I think Caleb Williams is Justin Fields 2.0. At best. I totally agree with this assessment! He wont have that kind of time in the NFL. He will struggle the way Fields struggled his first 2 years. Not sure if he can improve the way Fields has. We shall see
I cannot trust a QB in the NFL that cries to his mom & has a PINK PHONE ,Pink nails etc. DANIELS will be picked # 1.
never draft a usc qb. They don’t do well in the NFL *Carson Palmer is the exception
What schools consistently produce productive qbs in the nfl?
@@williamwoods9669 Oklahoma Sooner lately
Murray, Hurts, Mayfield
@@CCF_Christopherand they worked with Kliff just like Williams also they said the same thing about Ohio state and look at stroud
@@bakedgriffin0972 Stroud would be the exception, like Carson.
Plus he went to the right team.
Can’t see him doing the same thing if he were on the Carolina Panthers team or Washington Commanders.
Same thing was said about Ohio state when stroud was drafted.
Michael penix Jr please. He's the true QB1
Lol
I definitely believe he’s overrated stop comparing him to Patrick mahomes he’s comp is Kyler Murray just little taller and bigger 💯
Nah he's not the runner Murray is but he has the imrov of Mahomes. Being compared doesn't mean he'll be as good. I mean no one knew Mahomes would be this good. But when u think abt how he can throw the ball at different angles, on the move, across his body and be accurate all over the field, he's a lot like mahomes
I hope my Chicago Bears do not draft this Diva of a quarterback
@@glenncarter2494and if caleb suceeds and the football team stays irrelevant like they have for the past decade what will you say then 😂
This dude has not made one big play in the NFL. You don’t know sh**