The original Japanese translation regarding Y'shtola's aether vision actually states something more along the lines of "you will constantly be burning aether in order to do that, it will possibly tire you out" or something to that effect. the EN translation is a consequence of aether being somewhat equated with life force in ffxiv and the terminology not translating 1 to 1 very well. this is why it seems like a super big problem to us, but was never meant as anything more than an off hand remark that Y'shtola is gonna have a tougher life now.
To add to this; By the time HW came out, Y'shtola was already a fan favorite scion in JP. They weren't going to kill off a main character passively, let alone a fan favorite main character. Furthermore, within that conversation Y'shtola has with Matoya, Matoya is directly commenting on how Y'shtola is ACTIVELY circumventing her loss of vision in a potentially dangerous way. So while it's not a mistranslation per say, it does come off FAR more dire and dramatic than it actually is.
The main problem is that the EN version is a localisation instead of a translation so they change a lot of things. I'll always remember the moenbryda doll description...
The Dungeon to V&C Dungeon comparison is less as a direct comparison, and more of the age old argument "They're giving us less content and less dungeons is proof." Yes, less dungeons, but that dev time is going elsewhere. Somewhere else, like V&C and its new kind of dungeon which almost assuredly takes way more dev time for JUST Variant, compared to a single extra dungeon. It's not just gone, that dev time completely forgotten. Criterion is part of the V&C dev time I expect, even if it's more akin to Savage or such. Even ARR to HW had a lower dungeon count. But even if it failed, it's because they put that effort into Diadem and such. Dragoon, it needs a rework. Because for what EW did to improve it and I enjoy, it changed very little from ShB. 2 minute meta I would even say benefited DRG. "DRG is too busy" is the excuse for the rework, but that's part of why I like DRG. And I feel 2 minute meta actually made Dragoon busier, so I'm actually for this 2 minute meta. It personally benefits me. It makes Dragoon a perfect job in my eyes, perfect in just about every way. But you can't really iterate on perfection when they're trying to keep a strict button count. We need to wipe the board and start over if we want to progress DRG in future expansions. We can't realistically just play the same job year after year without it getting stale, and is the true core of the job creation issue. I'm scared to lose a job I have enjoyed every iteration of. But I'm not going to doom post that it's going to be ruined before we see the media tour. If they ruin it, I will for sure be saying how upset I am. But I'm putting my faith in the DRG devs despite the "too busy" comment. I can go into detail of what exactly fires me up for DRG and how that statement is antithetical to my enjoyment, but I have faith in them. You should be trying to do the same, and not just say "identity" over and over. What is the identity, why is that the identity, and how is that identity fun? Especially as a disappointed person, the devs can't understand you if you don't even understand you.
Well said. I think Xeems has gone into pretty good detail on how to make jobs (mostly dark knight) more interesting. I also want DRK to change as well, and I think there's plenty possibilities they can go with. I have my own ideas about designs that could fit the two minute meta and designs that that wouldn't, but I'd say the main gripe is that the kit doesn't interact with itself much. With RPR and RDM, you use one resource to build another or you build the resources together in tandem, but for DRK there's no such thing. In Stormblood, you managed your MP to power your Blood Gauge abilities and you also had to manage mp drain from abilities like Abyssal and Unleash in aoe, but from Shadowbringers on, they feel like two separate entities with only one button to manage each (GCD and oGCD Shinten/Bhava) and Darkside management is non existent. So yeah, I want a DRK rework that promotes interconnectivity of the kit, whether it be another combo to manage Darkside, bringing back Dark Arts to juggle with Edge of Shadow, something.
I disagree with DRG being "perfect", and it's because I feel the job is extremely inflexible. Its gap closers are the least effective of the melees (not the damage but utility due to long cd's and slow animation), and it suffers the most out of cd misalignment that happens between fights, if the content you play has short downtime between fights. The DRG I see today suffers from "I'm built only for raids" syndrome, though imo nothing suffers from this worse than BRD. That doesn't mean DRG is unplayable in dungeons, deep dungeons, etc., but it's not as fun as other melee jobs like NIN. Another personal opinion, I don't think Life Surge should have heal. Or rather, DRG should have something that can be saved specifically for self-healing/mit/etc. at will, rather than as coincidence mid-rotation. NIN has Shadeshift and MNK has Riddle of Earth. SAM's Third Eye is finnicky, but at least you use it with the intention of its effect never going to waste (plus you get +10 gauge). I want to say more than half of my Life Surges go completely to waste, and even when it is useful, it won't save me from death like Bloodbath or Second Wind would whenever healers won't/can't heal.
@@iPlayOnSpica The only gapcloser with a slow animation is Stardiver, and that's a secondary effect more than a main effect. And basically any gapcloser situation beyond can probably pull out Elusive Jump, which is stupidly fast now. I've been making extremely good use of Elusive since forever. Higher skill level needed to make use of it, but not by that much. As far as the CD alignment in casual content, that sounds like you're getting bad groups. Most dungeons I have some really good CD alignments now with the 2min meta. Anytime I feel like I'm in a weird spot, its when the tank's been doing weird stuff or the group isn't pullin high numbers due to gear or skill of any number of people.
@@shiburu I can see why people are afraid of what the rework might do to DRG. And I do agree it's fine to have a strict rotation, but it needs to be a little flexible for different situations. For example, if Spineshatter Dive is one ogcd window ahead of Dragonfire Dive on cd and a situation forces me to delay Spineshatter, I can't double weave the dives, so not only is Dragonfire Dive delayed but also whatever other ogcds I have after Dragonfire. This domino effect could lead to something not accepting my personal buffs (Lance Charge, Dragon Sight, Battle Litany) that otherwise would have. If I would change something, I would at least convert Spineshatter into a fast animation, fast cd, low damage gap closer, and adjust potency elsewhere as needed. I'd also add an effect for Elusive Jump where if you have a target selected, you always jump directly away from that target (like SAM Yaten and RDM Displacement), but its current interation of backstep is still available in the absence of a selected target.
The Summoner community had confidence in the rework of the Summoner, but look at what they've done. It's good to remain objective, but we have to admit that not everything the developers do aligns with the ideal vision we imagine. In Final Fantasy 14, not everything is of consistent quality; it's sometimes random, and at times, it's very good, but it can also be quite bad, and that's a fact.
The funniest mechanic for me in the nier raid is when she throws the square office at you. Someone took a screenshot and saw, the building she throws at you is square enix's main office. She went beyond throwing everything and the kitchen sink at you.
I miss the bug in Hinterlands when you first arrive and a cutscene plays out. But a monster was bugged and would constantly spawn over and over in one spot. When you finish the cutscene you are attacked by 50 monsters at once and die. Only did Extreme Trials and Raids via LS.
@@arknightsboi2050 Players on average are just more knowledgeable now from all the resources to learn from nowadays so you'll see almost zero wipes in new alliance raids, but I remember on Dynamis when the new alliance raids came out it was wipe city.
@@arknightsboi2050 honestly, my least favorite is pharos tower (2nd SB alliance raid) it just feels so pointless, the math boss was amusing for the 1st few times, especially people failing simple math questions. but fuck me are the bosses in the return to ivalice raid series such a drag and a sponge. i love wailing on Yiazmat for 10-12 minutes because he has reduced damage taken till his core finally opens up and we destroy it. the HW alliance raids don't really appeal to me either, just feel boring with very little interaction. (i played them in stormblood, so likely already too late to have truly experienced them at their worst) the Nier raids are amazing to me, the 1st can be a bit boring as i'm getting that the most, but definitely if you're leveling, you want the other alliance raids now instead of the CT series since you get increased rewards.
The Nier raids are also the longest duration by far. I had Tower at Paradigm's Breach take around an hour before. It also has a lot of insta-death mechanics and a good amount of mechanics that require looking at the boss, the latter of which I am fine with since EX and Savage do that all the time, but both make casuals take hits.
What I liked about Expert Dungeons was seeing what happened to dungeons after we had cleared them out. It was pretty interesting seeing what happened in Hakkue manor. With that in mind the most interesting thing was new mechanics over same old mechanics that were common in most dungeons. I would like Expert dungeons to be new and interesting mechs that could be a twist on existing ones or something along that line.
I mean new dungeons are mostly just old mechanics with a twist to them anyways. Dungeons are a nice way to do vidual story telling, sure, but not necessary to get the same information across
what they have to do is have a story version mode for the lastest dungeons and then expert roulette would actually have the same dungeons but somewhat reworked in a way so they add more mechs to fights and actually make it a tad harder... maybe delete some trash pulls and make it faster to get to bosses with added mechs... not much just 2 or 3 more with a little more hp
@@IrisfantasiesThis is a terrible idea. Roulettes only exist to provide a player pool for new players going through the story. If you delete the party for the msq then roulettes are pointless from a systems perspective. Besides, expert roulette takes like, fifteen minutes anyway; how much shorter do you want them to be?
For me, I hate expert roulette or rather dungeons in general. First time through is fine, but thats because it's a new map, new story being tied into it, but after that first run, I hate them. I hate them because they are boring and put me to sleep... literally. Every single dungeon I've done even in endwalker is pull two groups of mobs. Melt them then do boss. Pull two groups do boss. I say 2 groups because that's all the dungeon allows you to pull. Even a tank with dungeon gear won't come close to dying so long as either the tank is pushing buttons, or the healer is. The dps can literally just be spamming on button. And if your tank is a warrior, the healer can literally just push their 1 button aoe over and over and over again. Enemy ages don't do anything but some damage, so a blm can stand I'm everything if they want. Boss mechanics are way to forgiving. So yeah... I'm falling asleep regardless of what class I play. If they had a harder version of these dungeons with expert(savage) roulette option. I'd be okay with that, but this being thr only option pushes me away from doing expert. I'd rather spam cc matches instead.
Solm Al (Hard) is one of the best expert dungeons there is. On top of having a banger of a dungeon theme, it even has a mechanic that a lot of casuals don't know about, avoidable tank busters. The first boss, the crocodile, has that wind up and most tanks just stand there and take it when they could avoid it. Knowing about that really helped whenever I see that skeleton in latter content, like the boss at the end of The Drowned City of Skalla. I didn't realize until I saw someone just walk away from it that it's just a cleave.
I don't forget Lord of Verminion, because I afk the challenge mode 5 times a week for an easy 27000 mgp Also, I wouldn't call what Raubahn did "cold blooded" he was pretty damn inflamed with rage
Endwalker to Shadowbringers is what Nier:Automata is to Nier:Replicant. Replicant has an AMAZING story that is self-contained in the world of game. It makes you feel for story of characters in it, their tragedies and their hopes. It makes you awe at compleicity of the story, woven from elements so intricate you can't help but be flabbergasted. Automata has a story that only superficially is about the events in game, stretching its hands towards the player and player's real life doubts, fears and struggles. It says "I know it is hard. I know it's difficult to keep going. But the fact that you can is beautiful and i need you to know that i acknowledge it". Endwalker's story feels so much more intimate, oddly mature, making you face your own struggles - while Shadowbringers gave you a world where you feel better by changing fate of someone else.
Spot on about Endwalker, it's why it's my favorite FF story now as well as my favorite story overall when it comes to all forms of media that I've consumed up to this point (Video games, movies, novels, etc.); It spoke to me in a very personal way and hit me in the feels harder than anything that came before. I have yet to play any Nier game, but now that you've compared those games in this way, I can tell I'm probably going to enjoy Automata a lot more than Replicant lol. Where Shadowbringers is concerned, people overhyped it to me when I was a sprout (I started in late 2020) so I found it boring until Lv. 76 or 77 MSQ. And of course Patch 5.3 had me like "DAYUMN! O_O" But I was still happier to finally be back home in 5.4 from what had almost felt like a filler episode (to me anyway) that had interrupted the flow of the main story (Stormblood's patch story (4.3 - 4.5 specifically)) which I thought was starting to get really good right before SHB hit. It was a good filler episode, yes, but still just a filler for me. So I really enjoyed focusing back on what I felt was the main story with 5.4, and 5.5. I was a little sad that we never did get the expansion that was supposed to revolve around that place that Post-Stormblood and a few SHB cutscenes were leading to/hinting at since it meant that we probably would've had the chance to see it in all of its glory and explore the whole place BEFORE it was completely destroyed, BUT I was still satisfied with the way that early Endwalker MSQ (Lv. 81-82 with a tiny bit of 83) handled it and wrapped it all up at least. :3 Could it have been better? Hell yes. But I understand that they had to rush to wrap it all up quick after they decided to cancel the entire expansion that that particular MSQ segment was originally intended for.
I find it hard to emotionally associate with XIV stories because they always end extremely well for all the characters who matter, and that's not the case irl. Tragedy in XIV is very superficial. Hearing the main characters talking about "despair" when they never experienced it themselves (at least it wasn't shown to us) just doesn't work for me at all. EW was definitely emotional, but not mature in how it deals with it's themes.
@@xviii5780 Oh, to me it was a little more symbollic. And fighting despair was not about fighting ugly deadly monsters - it was convincing yourself that even if it feels futile, you still can do it. Acknowledging the unbearable, overwhelming weight of it, preventing you from making a move, running into excuses that you lack "ability" to change the situation, rather than "willpower". The final zone in endwalker made me bawl every living second i was in it, because i felt it portray what it feels. A warm but hopeless darkness, full ruins of things that have been and could have been, never fully allowed to rot. A place that embodies this heavy, weighty feeling preventing you from seeing light. Embodiment of resignation, lethargy and marasm that accompanied me for years - and the game, reflecting it all back to me, like: "I know." Do you know Limbus Company? A sweet little game made by one of my favourite game studios; while designed as visual novel with insignificant gacha elements, the story portrays human struggles so relevant, so relatable and so intimate that i genuinely broke down by chapter 4. Because i saw the game do what endwalker did: acknowledge the pain, rather than offer to escape from it. Challenge you to face it and cheer you for it.
@@LeonStarcrestVODs A lot of people are confused as to what N;A is about. I won't spoil much, but thing of the main theme as not as "what is meaning of life", but "Significance of having a purpose, dear to you and you alone". Regardless of what that purpose is.
Damn, nice analogy. Endwalker's story will always get props from me because it came out during the pandemic. I can't imagine anything as powerful as a message about not giving into despair during a time when most of humanity was actively suffering from despair and hopelessness.
Heavensward story was incredible to me, the dropped storyline bits I totally forgot about because of how strong things are. The patch quests in EW really feel like the questing in ARR where it's just all setup for later on so I don't really mind. We all know how well that worked out last time so I'm ok with it. It's also the thing where EW had to follow up Shadowbringers where all of the patch story content is consistently amazing while, again, having all future setup in the patch content
The whole point of the video is that the fondness of the story does not equate to how the expansion itself was. The story is there and (likely) won't go anywhere, but the game has changed a lot in between, and we're past a lot of the rough and outright bad design decisions of prior expansions.
I've noticed that people tend to only rank the expansions based on the story since that's been mostly intact over the years. It's why Heavensward is more well loved than Stormblood these days. I always kind of hated the map design in this game. That's the biggest thing I think World of Warcraft always had over FFXIV. The first time I thought a zone even came close to the quality presented in even Vanilla WoW was in Shadowbringers. That expansion had some pretty good zone design. Mostly in Kholusia, Il Mheg, and Lakeland. It's especially bad in A Realm Reborn, but that was designed to be loaded up on a PS3, so it's understandable to an extent.
.... I liked pagos because the map design was great for exploration, finding secrets and challenging >-> Me and my friends had so many funny moments on this map its just memorable
I love dun scaith and weeping city. Those raids are some of the funniest raids when people dont know wtf they are doing. Plus no AR boss smacks as hard as diabolos, MT'ing other alliance raids can be so boring after diabolos. Only the first one, void ark, sucks cause its boring. Other 2 bangers.
There is something truly special about seeing someone mistaken about Hollowbolos' Crit Shield and telling people to hold off bursting until you see that you're not doing 0 damage to him, and the sprouts go along and promptly get their tanks killed.
I hated Eureka on release. Only having played through it all in Endwalker did I learn to really appreciate it. Bozja I was always cool with, even if the aesthetics between Bozja and Zadnor are pretty much the same. The only thing I didn't like about Bozja was back when you had to run DR 15 times for the relic loooole
Eureka on release was so much more tedious, and only being able to play through one zone while waiting months for the next one to come out didn't help. I think when people look back on it and say "Well people hated it then, but they like it now - what gives?" they are forgetting how painfully slow everything surrounding those zones was at the time they were put into the game. The release schedule, the progression system... I mean it was pretty intolerable at the time. Since then they've adjusted it, and it's all in the game. When patch cycles get slow, it's a great way for people to gather up and farm around some zones together. Having more of that type of content is great for slow periods in the game, I think.
Eureka was fine after the patches when it was still active. The only real issue with Eureka was the initial release, it's still light years ahead of bozja.
Palace of the Dead was originally only 100 floors. There was no sustain potions as well. The additional 100 floors was only added after the community kept clamouring for more challenge. Sustains were added when people kept trying to do solo runs and complained enough. Do wish they had changed the scaling while adding the 100 floors. Even solo running, the 120+ first floors of PotD are a snoozefest, only mistakes/traps will get you killed.
I 100% rather have variant dungeons and such rather than just more dungeons. When it comes to the new relic quest I feel like as somebody that enjoys eureka and bozja a lot it was hmm... its ok to not have something like that every expansions but yah I do agree that it was a mistake to tie it to hildibrand, I did not enjoy it at all and I'm somebody that doesnt really skip any cutscene, it takes me A LOT to actually skip them but I couldnt take hildi quests anymore just not my cup of tea so I started skipping them.
honestly, the biggest mistake was that it's a tome sink at the end of the day. Xenos is a bit of a hypocrit in this sense, since he complain that there isn't enough to do, but then when a relic weapon can give you a goal to work torwards (for example gather sands or whatever from certain types of content) he doesn't like it, and he loves the idea of just spending 1500 tomes on the next relic step, which is just absolutely bad for the game overal. since people who want to have something to do only need to either do dailies, or do a hunt train and buy their next relic.
I just don't see why it didn't make sense to them to tie the EW relic to the Variant dungeons. I know a lot of people loved the relic steps where they were allowed to achieve more than one thing during a single run of whatever content worked for them. That balance was there for a majority of the SHB relic why not use Variants to continue doing that?
Personally would prefer having "just " story dungeon and a couple of side quest dungeons with good reward and the rest being filled up with V&C dungeons because they are so much fun but their loot tables need to expanded upon in a big way.
I'm really hoping they roll the dice and try out an MSQ variant/criterion dungeon in 7.0. See if it works out, and maybe try incorporating it into the MSQ going forward. So what if it means getting one or two less new dungeons in leveling roulette? Does anyone really care?
@@talancorwell Now that would be a really good idea ngl. And it keeps the story dungeons runs fresh as well or a longer life expactency . I would also go as far that specific paths give specific gear drops . And maybe even a step further "mystery blueprints" collect all the blueprints of all paths and get x weapon frame to build a specific weapon you want and then the more patches come out the more you build this weapon . Sounds maybe like a relic grind but I think this would shake everything up really well
The problem with 2 minute meta are raid buffs. They design bosses around 2 minutes ffs. Most recent examples are P9S where you do your 2 minute burst before limit cut and P12S P1 where you get to limit cut just before your 2 minute burst. Imagine if they removed raid buffs and gave you personal cooldowns with like 15/30/60 timers and buffed your core rotation. It would also open more options on boss design as well since you have several personal “burst” windows now and don’t revolve around 2 minute group buffs.
Dungeon wise, I enjoy ARR ones a bit, like Haukke manor is fun for tanking with what you can do. Ads that can be stunned or silenced, bosses can be stunned and silenced which makes for a fun double boss with the imp and skeleton if you pay attention to that. The imp uses ice spikes on pull and on time with the CD of silence and the skeleton aoes not long after and that comes back with the CD of stun, simple but fun when you just make them do nothing.
I'd rather have more variant dungeons than normal dungeons anyday. In fact, I've been saying there should be different paths since StormBlood because every dungeon as a tank, healer or DPS is literally the SAME thing. There are two pulls between each boss, there are always 3 bosses(there's one or two with 4. OOoOoOoOOoOo!),and the only thing that changes are the mechanics and music depending on the expansion. The rewards become junk that's only good for glam or seals and seals are only good for FC boosts or gil. . . The minions are a nice new touch but I could go for more variants and less dungeons any day.
Dungeons need to have some re playability. Not including Variant's, there is one, count them, one dungeon that has a mount as low-ish drop %, Ala Mhigo. Yeah one in then years. Dungeons will probably never give us a "pre raid BIS" gear but at least give them more than a few minions per expansion. Give them mounts or rare drop glam pieces that have unique looks/glows, but mostly mounts.
I think having a handful of dungeons with rare mount drops like Ala Mhigo would do more good than harm for the game. I wonder why they stopped doing that after 4.0.
game just has a really low mount collection in general, rare mobs like ss should drop mounts , rare nodes having a chance to drop mounts would be neat etc. FF14 dungeons have a lot of minions but they are usually really high drop rate, or really low + on MB. Minions are already infinitely less important to people than mounts, and grinding either 10 hours for one or 10 minutes are both non satisfactory @@Enderlinkpawnu
The biggest flaw I see is 50/60/70/80 dungeons being poor sources of xp. If you're leveling a job, you're always picking the highest level leveling dungeon, in which case you only have one best choice. ONE. You might settle for a 2-4 level lower dungeon to break the monotony, but that's it. So in my job leveling experience, I've played too many x1, x3, x5, x7, x9 dungeons and hardly any x0 dungeons. Really a missed opportunity here.
@@aydenmartin5650 A lot of mounts are saved for the new thing they want you to spend time on even if it's kinda dull and not super fun to do (Ishgard rebuilding/Island Sanctuary) while roulettes will ensure dungeons will always be run regardless.
The part about Titan EX back in ARR was spot on. I struggled for months trying to clear that fight in PF (fairly light schedule, maybe for an hour or two on the weekends). I knew the fight but every group I ever got into would always have one or two people who would suddenly start DCing, lag during landslides, or just not know what they were doing. I didn't get the clear until I gave up on PF clear parties and decided to give Duty Finder a shot.
"Have you really done all of it?" That's the most stupid question on the history of stupid questions. I'm sorry, no one should need to count on old content. The problem people has/have with Endwalker is no inovation, nothing to keep you subbed to the game more than 2-3 weeks/patch. Stop patronizing me dude.
The 2 minute argument xeno makes at 43:20 does not apply to all jobs. Drg for example, did not get buttons removed save for the life of the dragoon button, which is negligible, but because everything is 2 minute and 1 minute instead of 90 seconds, 2 minutes, and 3 minutes, all the planning of dragoon's burst phase/gauge got extremely simplified where we don't have to think about how and when to build up Life of the dragoon. That kind of difference was made purely just because of the new 2 minute meta, not because DRG had anything removed. Now, the difference between a great drg and an ok drg is whether or not you've been pressing you're buttons on cooldown, and even then, the competition at high level devolves down to just crit rng instead of planning and execution.
DRG and BLM got out well, but those are two jobs of quite a few. A lot of jobs got things shifted around to fit the meta. PLD and SMN needed to be reworked and NIN's dot had to go because full uptime dot damage didn't fit. MNK needed Blitz because it needed high potency hits that crit for a lot for 2mins. Ninja's trick attack debuff has been moved to mug on 2 mins, so the one minute burst doesn't matter on jobs that don't have a 1min personal buff or 60sec cooldowns. It feels like a lot changed so 2mins could be viable.
@@Jay-mx5ky sure, but the 2 minute meta sacrificed the planning and execution that high end players could have that could make the difference between a savage raid kill at 8 or 9 minutes, or a speed kill at around 7 minutes which would skip major mechanics like E6S conflag. now, we can't even skip stuff like that because the damage variance in high execution/planning is made negligible. sure the floor may have risen up, but the ceiling got dropped hard. we are all literally just doing the same things between trying to speed kill or just get a clear as opposed to before.
@SetsunaFSeieiGN02 I get that for sure. My main issue is the strict job design where every class needs their strongest abilities available at 2mins or on a 1/2min cd. I personally think there should be less raidbuffs and more of an emphasis on single target buffs so that jobs can be on different burst timings (or do sustain damage) and they can work together with support style classes like dancer and astro to optimize damage while (most) raidbuff potency gets baked into everyone's kit. It gives people something to optimize for speed kills (both the buff classes and the buffed class can coordinate when to receive/burst), while also balancing out the damage output difference between unoptimized comps and restoring different job styles.
@@lucasvallet4487 thats only phase 1, and that skip is only the difference between like 6:40 to 7:30. i'm talking about skips that skip a whole 3 ass minutes of a fight plus some of the mechanic walls. we can't skip HH or letter of the law or caloric 2 or classical 2.
they made me give up my seat for someone else for the 2016 fan fest proto ultima all tank fight. The person who took my soot couldn't even use WAR properly. It was an insult to me to being forced to give them my spot
Only reason I can think of for people to like expert dungeons is that they like to do max level for the expansion dungeons. So complete move sets that are different than what you are used to.
I like expert dungeons coz I can mass pull everything with basically zero effort coz OP af with bis gear, and then I can farm my tome cap super quick just spamming expert and doing the shorter roulettes once (normal raid and trial roulette). I already have my tome cap hours before I savage raid in the evening, so I can jus do my weekly coin on alliance and all other weekly stuff and then after raid I am done for the week all on the one day.
SE did those teleport points like that bcz they just gave us flying and they wanted to keep exploration alive. Now the farthest location from a teleport point is like less than 30 seconds away, besides garlemald
As a free trial knowing only ARR through STB so far, I've noticed that HW is the single most guilty of the three with mistranslations. Besides Y'shtola's vision, another example (spoilers)... ... is where upon finding out about Lucia (lvl58-59 msq), Alphinaud remarks in EN he doesn't doubt her loyalty to Aymeric but expressed concern about her loyalty to her sister. In JP with the latter half of the dialogue, he instead directly asks what she thinks of us because of what we did to her sister. Throughout the whole msq, characters refer to our planet as "star" in EN, but in JP, 惑星 (wakusei, planet) can be colloquially abbreviated to 星 (hoshi, star). The characters are really still talking about the planet. Unless Renaissance era English also didn't make the distinction between star and planet, I consider this more mistake than anything.
my biggest gripe with endwalker is it didnt feel like i really had anything to do for large portions of the expansion. im a PVE players, so i do ultimates, savage, extremes, deep dungeons etc. Now savages/extremes/ultimates, yes, i never fully expect those to last long for me, i get my gear and i dip out, so its not like thats ALL i log in for. but this expansion im finding more often than not i just dont have any content i care to partake in left, and i just raid log for fun with friends, which is more spending time with them than me actually wanting to play the game. Like i see the content is being put out. but none of it feels like its lasting very long. crystaline conflict was fun, for like a month. Criterian dungeons were cool at first, but the more i do them, the more im dissapointed because of what they could have been. Maybe im just jaded, but none of the content has that replayability factor to me.
I will say that Bozja is amazing for grinding. When I finally unlocked Bozja I was so happy to not be forced to do tribal quests and go straight into roulette again. Yes, it's just as mindless, but at least you have a bunch of people around you rallying from FATE to FATE and just kill shit, which in itself is kinda fun in bursts.
I get why people like it, but I personally find it intensely dull. I really dislike having even a small chance to not get into an engagement, and I don't enjoy asking for party invites because people disband all the time for seemingly no reason. Bozja was alright, but I'm happy to never go back.
Unfortunately Bozja was a hard miss for me, the intention was there, the execution was almost there, but it didn't quite hit the mark. I even enjoyed Eureka far more than what I did with Bozja. But having nothing for a relic is just so incredibly stupid and a huge sign of laziness. Literally every single expansion including ARR has had better relic quests than what EW does.
I won't get on Xenos for forgetting Papalymo. He's the least developed Scion and you only really interact with him prior to that if you started in Gridania and during the Ramuh stuff. The only other one who's as forgettable at the end of HVW is Urianger, as you only interact with him in ARR to unlock the various primal trials and the WoD last bit. Urianger is just a guy who speaks weird until ShB, where he becomes interesting.
Imma say this. No other expansion tried more new innovative things than HW. Yes the expansion had big flaws but it paved the way for the rest of the expansions
Gotta be ambitious and flawed to let your successors pick up the pieces and refine, imo. It’s good to criticize HW because it was incredibly flawed but what you said is absolutely true.
hmm, let's see if this holds out, using EW as a comparison since this is what is all about HW Innovations: 1-Deep Dungeons, 2-Crafting and Gathering reworks, 3-DC PF, 4-Diadem, 5-Custom Deliveries, 6-Aether Currents, 7-LoV EW Innovations: 1-CC, 2-PVP Rework, 3-V/C Dungeons, 4-Island Sanctuary, 5-Non Grindy Relics, 6-DC Travel, 7-The 2 min META While HW did pave the way for other Expansions by showing the devs what they shouldn't do 'cause they screwed pretty much anything they touched, in reality the things that ppl like the most i.e. story and raiding were paved outside of HW. The story structure and narrative cadence were paved in the latter patches of ARR, while modern raid design was established in SB. Even the "same old" EW tried as many significant innovations as HW did. Point of this being: HW wasn't as good or as innovative or as important as y'all remember it.
Endwalker has a problem with content replayability and longevity, not quantity. The reason people want forays and long relic grinds is because it gives you long term goals. On top of that players need daily incentives to engage with content. Why isn't there a Variant roulette now? How about a deep dungeon roulette with a randomly 10 selected floors from the middle of each of them? What about like a FATE roulette where you get dropped into a random zone with a 4/8 man group and you have to do 10 FATES to get the bonus at the end?
They want variant to stay as an option for branching story-based exploration content for the normal, and then difficult 4 man content for Criterion. Roulette would not work. Deep dungeon requires the player to have armor and weapon levels to function well, queueing random levels would be ass. You can pretty much do this anyway with matching. Fate Roulette sounds genuinely boring. They're designed around drop in and do it if you want, forcing a 10 clear to finish defeats that purpose. They also quite literally added long term grinds in EW too. Bicolor gemstone grind for the mount/wings. Deep dungeon 4 clear mount. Variant path completions. Island sanctuary mounts. Treasure map mounts. 4 mil mgp mount. This is on top of the already massively long grinds still available to do in the game such as Mahjong Master, Big Fish, World-Class Troller... etc.
The content with the most longevity is the story. That’s basically all that’s left from Heavensward, so it’s really not as big of an issue as people say it is. As far as daily incentives, why? Why do you feel the need to have a reason to play every day?
@@Salt_Mage cause people want a reason to keep paying for their sub? cause people actually like playing the game outside of watching cutscenes? cause people like having some form of goal to work towards?
@sDamon593 And yet when we had those in the past the vast majority of the community complained to high heaven. It's only when it's not there do people put on rose tinted glasses and say I miss this.
See, your first sentence is the main problem. The biggest complainers - and a lot of the parrots - are not saying that. Few people I've talked to are. They are saying there's nothing to do. Long term goals, short term goals, the rewards? Those are what are really are lacking. I think the litmus test would be something like Dragonsong Reprise. Is this not like, one of if not the best thing they've ever made? Would it be less quality if it had no reward? No. But you'd probably still lose some people. The title/weapon/plate flex is enough, and it's pretty understood we all like there being rewards. "No activities to do" just means we'll get even more types of activity with even less rewards per activity. And longevity will likely take a hit too. Devs can't just go assuming you mean one thing when you say another if you're all saying the same incorrect line.
I also enjoy the last Nier raid the best. Puppets bunker is a second, but I am bored out of my mind in the first one. The machine life forms are just boring enemies to me. The puppets bunker can kind of suffer the same but the puppet bunker pvp at least makes it so I will sometimes get to deal with something interesting. The last tier I love getting to fight all the nier 1 bosses, so much so that I don't even mind how long it is because I enjoy the whole thing.
Say what you want about the issues HW had, at least we tanks had stance dancing and enmity was a real mechanic. I feel like my brain only has to work at 10% efficiency nowadays, when I tank. It's sad, and not very engaging.
The thing about the 2 minute meta is alot of the downtime filler phase is really bad. You have jobs like rpr where the 1 minute burst is just gluttony, then you have something like sam that feels like its always got a good flow going on. Inbetween these 1-2mins your doing nothing though. So its really a 20 second burst, a 10 second burst and then a minute and 30 seconds of 1-2-3 spam with a resource being spent. Its incredibly boring
for me i want more DRS i want difficult content for free company's and we have friendly competition with other FC in our servers and then there is a leader board for the whole data center it can be a fun friendly FC rivalry
I don’t think people even want Eureka or Bozja particularly, they just want something similar and preferably something that’s even better. People like large scale content where you run around with bunch of random people. That’s what MMOs used to be about.
Xeems is right about the hildabrand shit. When I found out I had to go back just to get my relic I automatically hated it. To the point where I was skipping most the hildi story just to get my shit and move on. It fuckin drags man
As someone who played through the entire MSQ in 2021-2022, Heavensward zones were amazing. Incredible visuals, music, and lore I could really get into. They're still probably my favorite overall group of zones.
@@ruily276 unlocking extremes were so FUN! Love doing a whle other quest just to unlock the harder version! I only ever did the moogles and holy fuck was that aids to do.
@@ruily276I did all of them and I generally like the zones still. I generally play while I have yt or something on a second monitor, so I don’t mind some travel time.
The only reason I have ever interacted with Lord of Verminion is because it has the Clockwork Twintania minion. Once I got that achievement done I never went back. But yeah, I definitely agree. The FFXIV team has had a bad habit of not being able to write characters out of the story when they have nothing to do, let alone kill anybody. Thancred did very little in the 6.0 story and what he did accomplish could of vary easily been rewritten to not include him, and every expansion more and more of the characters join him in that pile. At this point I feel like he's only there because he's the only other NPC in the game (other being G'raha) that can tank in a duty support/trust.
Thancred had an entire solo duty where he and the people of bozja disable the garlean magitec when we first enter garlemald. He was the only one able to stop meteon because of his ability to hold his breath wad the only reason we did immediately die when getting to Ultima Thule. Like what more could yall want?
The writing team are just being very conserative and they are hesitant to do much with the main Scion team because they are very popular characters and they would probably face a lot of backlash from the community if they did something like try killing someone. I have no problems with the Scions, but they have really had all their character arcs completed at this point. Certain characters (like you said) like Thancred, Graha and Estinien have had their stories 'completed' for several expansions now and they are really just kept around because they are popular. I do agree that these characters need to take a backseat and they need to introduce newer characters for the sake of keeping the story fresh. At this point they have very little story relevance and are mostly just anime caricatures (Thancred is the dad of the party, Graha is the fanboy and Estinien is the sexy himbo)
I really really want you to make a video about the two minute meta. I disagree with you and I think 8 person raidbuffs are the crux of the issue, cause if you're not spending your highest potency abilities in a matter of 20 seconds once every two minutes, you're griefing. If your buff window is late, you're griefing. And most of the buffs in the game are just uninteractive "push one button to make damage increase" buffs. And the two minute meta has pushed dot jobs out of existence while limiting designs for jobs that can let you deal more damage by taking damage, deal more damage by protecting allies, having buffs that compound/decay over time (like old RDM embolden), etc. I don't think having 8 person raidbuffs are bad as long as they fit the job fantasy (bard, dancer), but I think the fact that theyre on all but three dps jobs and half of the healers severely limits how much "harder", or at the very least, different job design can be. And they could use that button to add something new to the job.
The 3rd nier raid is still home to one of my absolute favorite non story moments in the game, i was healing the raid one time and my friend got hit by the building, i rezzed him and he happened to spawn on an unsafe train track and instantly died again
its bad because to make all the buffs, OGCD cooldowns, combos etc line up with eachother most classes had to be simplified so even average players can do the 2 minute meta without knowing their class intricately. And since most damage comes from the 2 minute burst window esp with tincs popped on 6/0 minute that means that optimal play outside of the 2 minute means less. As it is right now as soon as you pick up a level 90 class you can look at the abilities and based off cooldown time alone know your 2 minute burst, 1 minutes, and fillers
@@aydenmartin5650 Yeah but the "average players" have proven to us time and time again that no matter how simplified a job gets they will still mess everything up repeatedly. I don't think the 2min meta exists to help struggling players at all and if it does then it's definitely not working.
@@aydenmartin5650 That is a grossly insane overestimating the skill of the average playerbase to know and pick up all that information by just looking at the abilities/descriptions. Have you SEEN the people who play this game?
Its because a bunch of tryhards hate that people can play the jobs in high level content without thinking super duper hard about optimization. Most people that complain about the 2 minute Meta probably dont even raid.
I'm not the best when it comes to expressing my thoughts and feelings, but... Dark Knight honestly does feel like a lesser clone of Warrior. Warrior self heals better than Dark Knight when Dark Knight used to be the better one because its whole gimmick used to be draining the enemies HP to restore its own back in HW and StB. Something it struggles to do now. For whatever reason, Warrior's Shake it Off seems like something Dark Knight should have as a party wide defensive, minus the heal overtime. That healing overtime effect is too much, lol! Instead, I'd rather see Warrior have a party wide attack buff ability rather than Shake it Off. Never understood why it was given such an ability when it should be the selfish Tank; the main thing I really liked about Warrior back in ARR and HW. Dark Knight spams just like Warrior, except it throws everything and the kitchen sink at the enemy(s) instead of just having one or two extremely powerful attacks. Think about how the WoL in the Shadowbringers cinematic opening basically two shoted that Sin Eater. While obviously, I wouldn't advocate for something that freaking powerful, Dark Knight in game should emulate that destructive power to a degree by having a build up gauge specifically meant for it to do a crap ton of damage with just 1 to 3 attacks, again, rather than spamming its attacks over and over again like a discount Fell Cleave Dark Knight. This way, it helps Dark Knight feel more powerful while also giving it a bit of its own identity compared to Warrior. That's as much I can think of at the moment, as I'm having a bit of brain fart moment, but these were some of the things I felt Dark Knight has a serious problen with compared to Warrior. While I still absolutely love both job class for what they are (especially Warrior because I'm simple oonga boonga man), I just wany my former second favorite Tank job class to feel more like its old HW/StB self while also feeling more in line to what the Shadowbringers trailer tried to make it look like.
I'd rather have variant than regular dungeons, if they made them a bit harder. Expert roulette is already easy, but last time I tried variant I just fell asleep, it's even more boring than the regular lvl 90 dungeons, I cba to do all the different paths for boring content like that, but if they upped it a bit where they are a little bit more engaging than regular lvl 90 dungeons, but not as crazy as criterion, that would be perfect. That and add actual rewards to it.
I personally don't like the way this guy is comparing the two expansions as if they got released around the same time. Heavensward is 6 years older than Endwalker and in the world of game development, 6 years is a lot of time to develop new techniques and more sophisticated ingame systems. Another thing that must be kept in mind is that the dev team had literally just got off the mammoth task of rebuilding FF XIV and I can imagine them being fairly 'fatigued' when they started working on Heavensward. Maybe i'm wrong but i can see valid reasons as to why Heavensward is ''not as good'' as Endwalker.
Ya it's a garbage video without anything of substance to say except EW can't be the worst guys HW was way worse. Like sure I'll give him that but it doesn't change the fact Endwalker is mid as hell and lacking in middle player stuff or any sort of shenanigans happening in DF
Gamers:" Nooo, the open field areas are boring and grindy, we don't like it, please square enix make something better" Square enix:" Ok, people don't like our Open field activities. let's try to make something solo for players like Island sanctuary" Gamers:"Nooo, there is no Open field for endgame, why does Square Enix did this, is the game dying? We have nothing to do, it's boring noooo!" I always said this and as a person who plays game I say this:"Most gamers are F stupid, they don't know what they want"
I didn’t like Sea of Clouds at first when I was getting the Aether Currents, but after hanging out there doing the tribal quests and hunting dhalmels for crafting it became one of my favorite zones. And I thought Azys La or whatever was awesome and didn’t really spend too much time there anyway.
I enjoy Dungeons, its just my preference, but l cant say Ive ever been of the opinion they are "Top quality" content, the be all and the end all. Dungeons are fun to me because its easy and you can just do them, lol Im not an adrenaline junky like most Ultimate raiders, the one I cleared, DSR, was purely a from of closure against Throdan, finally killed the old bastard off! Being a Mentor on Materia is also a part of why l like dungeons, because the community is still growing its fun to help people and see how they are enjoying the story and learning the ins and outs of the game, jobs, rotations, crafting, dodging, PF & DF. Mentor roulette is a big help finding fun experiences in dungeons because there is generally a fun aspect to it. You can get a fist timer and teach them or test them, you can get a bunch of Lvl 90 in a lvl 90 dungeon and go ham for 12 minutes pushing for a fast clear and you can meet assholes and great people like every 15 minutes. Hell when I play at work its great fun to just do a trust dungeon for 40 minutes, thats right a TRUST DUNGEON, its gets you tomes and you can do it at your own pace. Granted most people dont get to play at work so my experience is a little different, but doing Dungeon type 4 man content for the sake of it and thinking its fun? Yah I dont know about that. Doing Dungeons for the sake of doing them as Baseline content is not that interesting outside of the first time, but doing them for the interactions and helping people, that my experience.
HW's story is either pretty good or really mid. It depends on your tolerance for Cutscene Paralysis - an aberration that plagues JRPGs, and Squeenix's output particularly. I have none, and HW destroyed my immersion about 3 times (SB and ShB for comparison had only minor infractions, until Bozja). also IMO, EW's reworks of the old content frankly ruined a lot of its cooler moments - for example once you've cleared it, you may want to lookup what The Aery was like before 6.x.
Come to think of it, I'd love it if all leveling dungeons in an expansion were variant dungeons. It'd encourage interacting with things and give different mechanics if you prefer a different boss for your group's composition. Keep the rewards the same for each route and I'm in!
I think that the extra "hard mode" dungeons are more well regarded than Variant/Criterion solely because they expand the main lore of the game and feel less like optional content. That being said, Sildahn is absolutely exempt from this because Nanamo is in fact a main character and it expands her lore...but it's definitely a valid criticism for the other two. Honestly though, I was so disappointed we didn't get stuff like Akademia or Anamnesis Hard because I loved those dungeons so much. They would have also fit in so well with the raid series in End Walker what with us spending so much time with Lahabread and Elidibussy.
I expect that a lot of people are going to be upset about the next expansion. Even though we all know going into it that its supposed to be a step down from the grand story we just went through in Endwalker, i don't think it will take long before people start comparing the two and become upset that the new expansion isn't "one-upping" the previous one. Maybe i will be proven wrong, but thats how people usually are. They never like taking a step backwards, even if its for the best in the long run. Even though i enjoyed most of the story of Endwalker, i was actually really disappointed in the final ending. The game has spent an entire decade building up Zodiark as an ultimate threat only for him to kind of just be a side-piece boss that gets barely any importance just so they can let some new threat out of nowhere take its place. It felt like they threw all of the story work they had done up to this point out the window just so they could make room for Zenos; a character who has basically no depth of personality at all and only existed just to be "a strong opponent."
Pointing out a wide variety of different things to do doesn't address the "There's nothing to do" issue. Of coarse there's something to do, and everyone is aware of it. Those other things simply hold zero value to people and thus they are effectively non content. I don't like fishing and mojong so you telling me my complaint is invalid because someone else ONLY plays fishing and mojong is just stupid. That's my only problem with Wesk's video, the rest is well reasoned and portrayed, even the parts I disagree with. I'm not even saying he's wrong, just that his argument on that point is terrible.
does yoshi p saying they're only following players feedback, and they thus need to reach a consensus mean that there's a chance they might make classes harder ? if enough work to teach people to be better and realize how easy the game already is ?
Why should they do that? Square is a company there absolut goal is to make Money. With the amount of casuals the Game has now i think they make more Money then ever.
Also 24man Savage content is one my fav, would love just doing like atleast 1 fight 24man savage/trial per expansion, 8min doorboss 8min final boss? 24man to do with friends, or hear me out, 24man savage with an ultimate variant test
Honestly if I had a favorite extreme trial that gave me that feeling it’s cinder drift extreme? I think, Ruby weapon , before that I hadn’t even really did the extreme fights and i had to do it 76 times to get the mount I actually enjoyed doing it all day, than the warrior of light extreme I finally got to experience how it is being on discord with a group of actual people
on the topic of variant vs hard mode dungeon, i never thought too much about it but i think the reason i like hard mode dungeon is because it "simulated the passage of time" in a simple way (i know, pretencious wording). or more specifically, the quest around them to that. if Tam-tara deepcroft (and by extension Edda's story) became a variant dungeon, idk how i would feel about it...
I think the general sentiment behind the video is correct but flawed. It doesn't matter if HW had slightly less/worse content than EW since it was SB that set the standard. HW was an upward trajectory of content, whereas EW is on a downward trend. Psycologically, that is far worse. The bottom line is that EW should be held at a higher scrutiny since we are now 10 years into the game instead of 2, and we have also seen how the devs took the feedback from HW and made the best expansion in terms of content and battle systems (stormblood). Defending EW because HW was worse just gets us more EW. Critisising EW for its very real shortcomings gives us Stormblood 2.
I cleared Titan EX in DF and it was my first EX that I cleared, I actually believed it was easier than Ifrit and about equal to Garuda when I did it, and believe me, this was when I was still in ARR and terrible at the game during HW, it was pretty doable, that's where I learned to hold on damage and that was for the gaol, don't get your buddies knocked off the edge
On point of alliance raids, Nier is by far my favorites. The fact that they give same tomes/rewards when it takes close to double the time in comparison with other raids or triple the time if it's CT, is the problem. Raids themselves are the best.
"They are gonna take dragoons combos away and give them to viper" bro you are foul for that.😂 I can already picture them doing that and even though i dont main drg i will cry for them.
The Nier raid is probably my favorite one in the entire game and that's not just cause I'm biased towards butt robot. Good music, cool fights, top night presentation. Its great
Titan Extreme mate... we Sold that sht back in the day and I was our paladin maintank on a PS3 with 2,5 seconds delay and I still managed to solo tank it... Good old times. 😅
I think they should unlock all Unreals at the last patch of the expansion. You can still have the weekly lockout for Faux Hallows, but it would be nice to have all the Unreals available.
Then everyone would only do the easiest/quickest one and make all the other unreals pointless. I'd rather they be on rotation so people can get a taste of what they used to be like when relevant, even though it is still easier now with the jobs and skills we have.
This game is in some serious need of some engaging Overworld content to get players out into the world instead of just sitting around Limsa. Things I'd personally love to see are Domain Invasions, Conquest(both FFXI Overworld content), and Hamlets. Just to comment on the first point in the video with the Zones/Overworld. The rest dude reminded me exactly why I was super pure casual from 1.0 all the way up through HW. SB was when I finally started to Raid and play other aspects of the game as well as catching up on content I left aside over the years. Also on his point of LoV, the devs swung and completely missed the mark with that, then forgot about it when it flopped....just like with a lot of other stuff...even things received well enough >.>
I think the new map can work. The real issue is that ice constantly respawns. Old map ice did not respawn so it would push the teams into conflict, but with respawning ice you can avoid conflict and still advance your score.
@@gamermasterL The playerbase in general almost seems to not understand how substantial killing each other in the kill-each-other gamemode is to your score. You steal 5 of the dead guy's points for a 10 point swing in your favor, murk an enemy alliance and be rewarded with 120 points while they lose 120 points. Not even factoring in Battle High's frankly absurd benefits. And yet they'd rather zerg 15 people over a single 70 point ice block instead of smushing an enemy team in a valley like a pimple for just as many if not more points while tearing down their standing.
@@gamermasterL Exactly. New map is just braindead ice damage simulator. So much so that if you dare to actually fight another person in this PvP map then you're throwing. Old map had room for actually PvP fighting and team strategy.
@@ambystomamexicanum3803 The problem is how long it actually takes to kill a person, and then if you fail to kill they can heal themselves full health instantly. Unless you vastly outnumber the enemy you're wasting your time and just helping the 3rd team win
@@MaximillionPegasus88 This is true. I'm fine with the fact that PVP is now balanced around CC and Frontlines will be getting more 'afterthought' adjustments since frontlines are kinda bad to begin with, but there is surely a better answer to 72 people having CC's killing power than a blanket by-class damage reduction that reaches the ridiculous heights of 60% for dragoon.
I remember i payed 300k to get into clear party of titan extreme i do have a screenshot. The prog groups sucked so much bards dying to landslide, dragoons faced floor, whm healed in cleric stance and no swft cast raise cause lvlin thaumaturge is boring. Fun days
Azys lla is one of my favorite zones wtf...the music is a banger. Also I really think it's stupid to say a map is bad because of Aetheryte locations, it's about the actual design, quests and music. Also they should improve Aetheryte spots in the old maps when possible.
@@biggestboss That's true. I should have specified visual design, as it's what I mean. But the overall layout/traversal is important. Especially before you can fly.
"Who is Papalymo?" YES! Finally! Finally there is someone like me! When I watched his death scene, and people were like sad and screaming his name, I was like: "Who the hell is that?"
I only played ff14 when Shadowlands was a mess, and honestly my favorite thing to do was farm the Nier raids for glams. I am surprised to see so many didn't like it, what was it about those raids that people hated? I though they were so cool and the mechanics stood out as more interesting than some of the others.
I don't think people *hate* the raids, just that it's really odd that such a large piece of content, usually used to expand on the world, was instead used for a crossover. The other ARs have an actual place in the world, expanding on or introducing elements that can or will be used later. The Nier raids are, afaik, purely fanservice, and are immersion/world breaking for a lot of people.
@@ThatGaymer Yeah it's pretty much this for me, I just didn't get invested at all in the story or the theme since I have no interest for Nier, it was a step down from the ivalice story/theme. But in terms of the actual content, they weren't bad raids at all, far better than the 24 mans from EW.
It's always been odd to me how much people fawn over Shadowbringers but then turn around and bash Endwalker when they perfectly complement and bolster each other.
The original Japanese translation regarding Y'shtola's aether vision actually states something more along the lines of "you will constantly be burning aether in order to do that, it will possibly tire you out" or something to that effect. the EN translation is a consequence of aether being somewhat equated with life force in ffxiv and the terminology not translating 1 to 1 very well. this is why it seems like a super big problem to us, but was never meant as anything more than an off hand remark that Y'shtola is gonna have a tougher life now.
Pin this man, because this man speaks the truth.
Yeah I got this comment a bunch on the main video.
It's a HUGE translation issue that really colored people's perspective on the story for years.
Maybe since burgers are aether she just eats like the flash now.
To add to this; By the time HW came out, Y'shtola was already a fan favorite scion in JP. They weren't going to kill off a main character passively, let alone a fan favorite main character. Furthermore, within that conversation Y'shtola has with Matoya, Matoya is directly commenting on how Y'shtola is ACTIVELY circumventing her loss of vision in a potentially dangerous way. So while it's not a mistranslation per say, it does come off FAR more dire and dramatic than it actually is.
The main problem is that the EN version is a localisation instead of a translation so they change a lot of things.
I'll always remember the moenbryda doll description...
The Dungeon to V&C Dungeon comparison is less as a direct comparison, and more of the age old argument "They're giving us less content and less dungeons is proof." Yes, less dungeons, but that dev time is going elsewhere. Somewhere else, like V&C and its new kind of dungeon which almost assuredly takes way more dev time for JUST Variant, compared to a single extra dungeon. It's not just gone, that dev time completely forgotten. Criterion is part of the V&C dev time I expect, even if it's more akin to Savage or such. Even ARR to HW had a lower dungeon count. But even if it failed, it's because they put that effort into Diadem and such.
Dragoon, it needs a rework. Because for what EW did to improve it and I enjoy, it changed very little from ShB. 2 minute meta I would even say benefited DRG. "DRG is too busy" is the excuse for the rework, but that's part of why I like DRG. And I feel 2 minute meta actually made Dragoon busier, so I'm actually for this 2 minute meta. It personally benefits me. It makes Dragoon a perfect job in my eyes, perfect in just about every way. But you can't really iterate on perfection when they're trying to keep a strict button count. We need to wipe the board and start over if we want to progress DRG in future expansions. We can't realistically just play the same job year after year without it getting stale, and is the true core of the job creation issue.
I'm scared to lose a job I have enjoyed every iteration of. But I'm not going to doom post that it's going to be ruined before we see the media tour. If they ruin it, I will for sure be saying how upset I am. But I'm putting my faith in the DRG devs despite the "too busy" comment. I can go into detail of what exactly fires me up for DRG and how that statement is antithetical to my enjoyment, but I have faith in them. You should be trying to do the same, and not just say "identity" over and over. What is the identity, why is that the identity, and how is that identity fun? Especially as a disappointed person, the devs can't understand you if you don't even understand you.
Well said. I think Xeems has gone into pretty good detail on how to make jobs (mostly dark knight) more interesting. I also want DRK to change as well, and I think there's plenty possibilities they can go with. I have my own ideas about designs that could fit the two minute meta and designs that that wouldn't, but I'd say the main gripe is that the kit doesn't interact with itself much.
With RPR and RDM, you use one resource to build another or you build the resources together in tandem, but for DRK there's no such thing. In Stormblood, you managed your MP to power your Blood Gauge abilities and you also had to manage mp drain from abilities like Abyssal and Unleash in aoe, but from Shadowbringers on, they feel like two separate entities with only one button to manage each (GCD and oGCD Shinten/Bhava) and Darkside management is non existent. So yeah, I want a DRK rework that promotes interconnectivity of the kit, whether it be another combo to manage Darkside, bringing back Dark Arts to juggle with Edge of Shadow, something.
I disagree with DRG being "perfect", and it's because I feel the job is extremely inflexible. Its gap closers are the least effective of the melees (not the damage but utility due to long cd's and slow animation), and it suffers the most out of cd misalignment that happens between fights, if the content you play has short downtime between fights. The DRG I see today suffers from "I'm built only for raids" syndrome, though imo nothing suffers from this worse than BRD. That doesn't mean DRG is unplayable in dungeons, deep dungeons, etc., but it's not as fun as other melee jobs like NIN.
Another personal opinion, I don't think Life Surge should have heal. Or rather, DRG should have something that can be saved specifically for self-healing/mit/etc. at will, rather than as coincidence mid-rotation. NIN has Shadeshift and MNK has Riddle of Earth. SAM's Third Eye is finnicky, but at least you use it with the intention of its effect never going to waste (plus you get +10 gauge). I want to say more than half of my Life Surges go completely to waste, and even when it is useful, it won't save me from death like Bloodbath or Second Wind would whenever healers won't/can't heal.
@@iPlayOnSpica The only gapcloser with a slow animation is Stardiver, and that's a secondary effect more than a main effect. And basically any gapcloser situation beyond can probably pull out Elusive Jump, which is stupidly fast now. I've been making extremely good use of Elusive since forever. Higher skill level needed to make use of it, but not by that much.
As far as the CD alignment in casual content, that sounds like you're getting bad groups. Most dungeons I have some really good CD alignments now with the 2min meta. Anytime I feel like I'm in a weird spot, its when the tank's been doing weird stuff or the group isn't pullin high numbers due to gear or skill of any number of people.
@@shiburu I can see why people are afraid of what the rework might do to DRG. And I do agree it's fine to have a strict rotation, but it needs to be a little flexible for different situations. For example, if Spineshatter Dive is one ogcd window ahead of Dragonfire Dive on cd and a situation forces me to delay Spineshatter, I can't double weave the dives, so not only is Dragonfire Dive delayed but also whatever other ogcds I have after Dragonfire. This domino effect could lead to something not accepting my personal buffs (Lance Charge, Dragon Sight, Battle Litany) that otherwise would have. If I would change something, I would at least convert Spineshatter into a fast animation, fast cd, low damage gap closer, and adjust potency elsewhere as needed. I'd also add an effect for Elusive Jump where if you have a target selected, you always jump directly away from that target (like SAM Yaten and RDM Displacement), but its current interation of backstep is still available in the absence of a selected target.
The Summoner community had confidence in the rework of the Summoner, but look at what they've done.
It's good to remain objective, but we have to admit that not everything the developers do aligns with the ideal vision we imagine.
In Final Fantasy 14, not everything is of consistent quality; it's sometimes random, and at times, it's very good, but it can also be quite bad, and that's a fact.
The funniest mechanic for me in the nier raid is when she throws the square office at you.
Someone took a screenshot and saw, the building she throws at you is square enix's main office.
She went beyond throwing everything and the kitchen sink at you.
I miss the bug in Hinterlands when you first arrive and a cutscene plays out. But a monster was bugged and would constantly spawn over and over in one spot. When you finish the cutscene you are attacked by 50 monsters at once and die.
Only did Extreme Trials and Raids via LS.
I didn't know people hated Nier raids so much. Puppet's Bunker is one of my favorites!
@@arknightsboi2050 Players on average are just more knowledgeable now from all the resources to learn from nowadays so you'll see almost zero wipes in new alliance raids, but I remember on Dynamis when the new alliance raids came out it was wipe city.
It's just that they are very long and you have to pay attention or you die very fast.
@@arknightsboi2050 honestly, my least favorite is pharos tower (2nd SB alliance raid)
it just feels so pointless, the math boss was amusing for the 1st few times, especially people failing simple math questions.
but fuck me are the bosses in the return to ivalice raid series such a drag and a sponge.
i love wailing on Yiazmat for 10-12 minutes because he has reduced damage taken till his core finally opens up and we destroy it.
the HW alliance raids don't really appeal to me either, just feel boring with very little interaction. (i played them in stormblood, so likely already too late to have truly experienced them at their worst)
the Nier raids are amazing to me, the 1st can be a bit boring as i'm getting that the most, but definitely if you're leveling, you want the other alliance raids now instead of the CT series since you get increased rewards.
The Nier raids are also the longest duration by far. I had Tower at Paradigm's Breach take around an hour before. It also has a lot of insta-death mechanics and a good amount of mechanics that require looking at the boss, the latter of which I am fine with since EX and Savage do that all the time, but both make casuals take hits.
The variant is omni because you might have a meleedps tanking the boss, but criterion you always have a tank doing their thing.
What I liked about Expert Dungeons was seeing what happened to dungeons after we had cleared them out. It was pretty interesting seeing what happened in Hakkue manor. With that in mind the most interesting thing was new mechanics over same old mechanics that were common in most dungeons. I would like Expert dungeons to be new and interesting mechs that could be a twist on existing ones or something along that line.
I mean new dungeons are mostly just old mechanics with a twist to them anyways. Dungeons are a nice way to do vidual story telling, sure, but not necessary to get the same information across
what they have to do is have a story version mode for the lastest dungeons and then expert roulette would actually have the same dungeons but somewhat reworked in a way so they add more mechs to fights and actually make it a tad harder... maybe delete some trash pulls and make it faster to get to bosses with added mechs... not much just 2 or 3 more with a little more hp
@@IrisfantasiesThis is a terrible idea. Roulettes only exist to provide a player pool for new players going through the story. If you delete the party for the msq then roulettes are pointless from a systems perspective. Besides, expert roulette takes like, fifteen minutes anyway; how much shorter do you want them to be?
For me, I hate expert roulette or rather dungeons in general.
First time through is fine, but thats because it's a new map, new story being tied into it, but after that first run, I hate them. I hate them because they are boring and put me to sleep... literally.
Every single dungeon I've done even in endwalker is pull two groups of mobs. Melt them then do boss. Pull two groups do boss. I say 2 groups because that's all the dungeon allows you to pull. Even a tank with dungeon gear won't come close to dying so long as either the tank is pushing buttons, or the healer is. The dps can literally just be spamming on button. And if your tank is a warrior, the healer can literally just push their 1 button aoe over and over and over again.
Enemy ages don't do anything but some damage, so a blm can stand I'm everything if they want. Boss mechanics are way to forgiving. So yeah... I'm falling asleep regardless of what class I play.
If they had a harder version of these dungeons with expert(savage) roulette option. I'd be okay with that, but this being thr only option pushes me away from doing expert. I'd rather spam cc matches instead.
Solm Al (Hard) is one of the best expert dungeons there is. On top of having a banger of a dungeon theme, it even has a mechanic that a lot of casuals don't know about, avoidable tank busters. The first boss, the crocodile, has that wind up and most tanks just stand there and take it when they could avoid it. Knowing about that really helped whenever I see that skeleton in latter content, like the boss at the end of The Drowned City of Skalla. I didn't realize until I saw someone just walk away from it that it's just a cleave.
I don't forget Lord of Verminion, because I afk the challenge mode 5 times a week for an easy 27000 mgp
Also, I wouldn't call what Raubahn did "cold blooded" he was pretty damn inflamed with rage
thank you for the food my liege
Endwalker to Shadowbringers is what Nier:Automata is to Nier:Replicant.
Replicant has an AMAZING story that is self-contained in the world of game. It makes you feel for story of characters in it, their tragedies and their hopes. It makes you awe at compleicity of the story, woven from elements so intricate you can't help but be flabbergasted.
Automata has a story that only superficially is about the events in game, stretching its hands towards the player and player's real life doubts, fears and struggles. It says "I know it is hard. I know it's difficult to keep going. But the fact that you can is beautiful and i need you to know that i acknowledge it".
Endwalker's story feels so much more intimate, oddly mature, making you face your own struggles - while Shadowbringers gave you a world where you feel better by changing fate of someone else.
Spot on about Endwalker, it's why it's my favorite FF story now as well as my favorite story overall when it comes to all forms of media that I've consumed up to this point (Video games, movies, novels, etc.); It spoke to me in a very personal way and hit me in the feels harder than anything that came before.
I have yet to play any Nier game, but now that you've compared those games in this way, I can tell I'm probably going to enjoy Automata a lot more than Replicant lol.
Where Shadowbringers is concerned, people overhyped it to me when I was a sprout (I started in late 2020) so I found it boring until Lv. 76 or 77 MSQ. And of course Patch 5.3 had me like "DAYUMN! O_O"
But I was still happier to finally be back home in 5.4 from what had almost felt like a filler episode (to me anyway) that had interrupted the flow of the main story (Stormblood's patch story (4.3 - 4.5 specifically)) which I thought was starting to get really good right before SHB hit.
It was a good filler episode, yes, but still just a filler for me. So I really enjoyed focusing back on what I felt was the main story with 5.4, and 5.5.
I was a little sad that we never did get the expansion that was supposed to revolve around that place that Post-Stormblood and a few SHB cutscenes were leading to/hinting at since it meant that we probably would've had the chance to see it in all of its glory and explore the whole place BEFORE it was completely destroyed, BUT I was still satisfied with the way that early Endwalker MSQ (Lv. 81-82 with a tiny bit of 83) handled it and wrapped it all up at least. :3
Could it have been better? Hell yes. But I understand that they had to rush to wrap it all up quick after they decided to cancel the entire expansion that that particular MSQ segment was originally intended for.
I find it hard to emotionally associate with XIV stories because they always end extremely well for all the characters who matter, and that's not the case irl. Tragedy in XIV is very superficial. Hearing the main characters talking about "despair" when they never experienced it themselves (at least it wasn't shown to us) just doesn't work for me at all. EW was definitely emotional, but not mature in how it deals with it's themes.
@@xviii5780 Oh, to me it was a little more symbollic. And fighting despair was not about fighting ugly deadly monsters - it was convincing yourself that even if it feels futile, you still can do it. Acknowledging the unbearable, overwhelming weight of it, preventing you from making a move, running into excuses that you lack "ability" to change the situation, rather than "willpower".
The final zone in endwalker made me bawl every living second i was in it, because i felt it portray what it feels. A warm but hopeless darkness, full ruins of things that have been and could have been, never fully allowed to rot. A place that embodies this heavy, weighty feeling preventing you from seeing light. Embodiment of resignation, lethargy and marasm that accompanied me for years - and the game, reflecting it all back to me, like: "I know."
Do you know Limbus Company? A sweet little game made by one of my favourite game studios; while designed as visual novel with insignificant gacha elements, the story portrays human struggles so relevant, so relatable and so intimate that i genuinely broke down by chapter 4.
Because i saw the game do what endwalker did: acknowledge the pain, rather than offer to escape from it. Challenge you to face it and cheer you for it.
@@LeonStarcrestVODs A lot of people are confused as to what N;A is about. I won't spoil much, but thing of the main theme as not as "what is meaning of life", but "Significance of having a purpose, dear to you and you alone". Regardless of what that purpose is.
Damn, nice analogy. Endwalker's story will always get props from me because it came out during the pandemic. I can't imagine anything as powerful as a message about not giving into despair during a time when most of humanity was actively suffering from despair and hopelessness.
Heavensward story was incredible to me, the dropped storyline bits I totally forgot about because of how strong things are. The patch quests in EW really feel like the questing in ARR where it's just all setup for later on so I don't really mind. We all know how well that worked out last time so I'm ok with it. It's also the thing where EW had to follow up Shadowbringers where all of the patch story content is consistently amazing while, again, having all future setup in the patch content
The whole point of the video is that the fondness of the story does not equate to how the expansion itself was. The story is there and (likely) won't go anywhere, but the game has changed a lot in between, and we're past a lot of the rough and outright bad design decisions of prior expansions.
Not to mention endwalker had a better story and expansion overall
I've noticed that people tend to only rank the expansions based on the story since that's been mostly intact over the years. It's why Heavensward is more well loved than Stormblood these days.
I always kind of hated the map design in this game. That's the biggest thing I think World of Warcraft always had over FFXIV. The first time I thought a zone even came close to the quality presented in even Vanilla WoW was in Shadowbringers. That expansion had some pretty good zone design. Mostly in Kholusia, Il Mheg, and Lakeland.
It's especially bad in A Realm Reborn, but that was designed to be loaded up on a PS3, so it's understandable to an extent.
Probably because the story is literally the main attraction according to YP (and I agree) and the thing that's mostly likely to stay with people.
Only map I have a major complaint about is eureka pagos, awful design lmao
This. Stormblood's Story was weak compared to HW but man, the battle content in Stormblood was lit.
@@Axemninja nah there’s weirdos that think it was “interesting” and not just aggressively anti-QoL
.... I liked pagos because the map design was great for exploration, finding secrets and challenging >-> Me and my friends had so many funny moments on this map its just memorable
I love dun scaith and weeping city.
Those raids are some of the funniest raids when people dont know wtf they are doing. Plus no AR boss smacks as hard as diabolos, MT'ing other alliance raids can be so boring after diabolos.
Only the first one, void ark, sucks cause its boring. Other 2 bangers.
There is something truly special about seeing someone mistaken about Hollowbolos' Crit Shield and telling people to hold off bursting until you see that you're not doing 0 damage to him, and the sprouts go along and promptly get their tanks killed.
funniest or funnest? or both?
*Angry geometry noises*.
:>
Dun scaith made me buy the game
Weeping City of Mhach on release was WIIIIIILD
I hated Eureka on release. Only having played through it all in Endwalker did I learn to really appreciate it. Bozja I was always cool with, even if the aesthetics between Bozja and Zadnor are pretty much the same. The only thing I didn't like about Bozja was back when you had to run DR 15 times for the relic loooole
That was when I actually ran Potd 101-200 for the first time, it was way more interesting for getting the timeworn artifacts
Eureka on release was so much more tedious, and only being able to play through one zone while waiting months for the next one to come out didn't help. I think when people look back on it and say "Well people hated it then, but they like it now - what gives?" they are forgetting how painfully slow everything surrounding those zones was at the time they were put into the game. The release schedule, the progression system... I mean it was pretty intolerable at the time. Since then they've adjusted it, and it's all in the game. When patch cycles get slow, it's a great way for people to gather up and farm around some zones together. Having more of that type of content is great for slow periods in the game, I think.
@@HalberdierHyperion the plus side, was people were socialising alot more during the down time while spawning NMs
Eureka was fine after the patches when it was still active. The only real issue with Eureka was the initial release, it's still light years ahead of bozja.
The transition when he was going to talk about thordan was really good.
thats my oshi WeskAlber.
Palace of the Dead was originally only 100 floors. There was no sustain potions as well. The additional 100 floors was only added after the community kept clamouring for more challenge.
Sustains were added when people kept trying to do solo runs and complained enough. Do wish they had changed the scaling while adding the 100 floors. Even solo running, the 120+ first floors of PotD are a snoozefest, only mistakes/traps will get you killed.
I 100% rather have variant dungeons and such rather than just more dungeons. When it comes to the new relic quest I feel like as somebody that enjoys eureka and bozja a lot it was hmm... its ok to not have something like that every expansions but yah I do agree that it was a mistake to tie it to hildibrand, I did not enjoy it at all and I'm somebody that doesnt really skip any cutscene, it takes me A LOT to actually skip them but I couldnt take hildi quests anymore just not my cup of tea so I started skipping them.
honestly, the biggest mistake was that it's a tome sink at the end of the day.
Xenos is a bit of a hypocrit in this sense, since he complain that there isn't enough to do, but then when a relic weapon can give you a goal to work torwards (for example gather sands or whatever from certain types of content) he doesn't like it, and he loves the idea of just spending 1500 tomes on the next relic step, which is just absolutely bad for the game overal.
since people who want to have something to do only need to either do dailies, or do a hunt train and buy their next relic.
I just don't see why it didn't make sense to them to tie the EW relic to the Variant dungeons. I know a lot of people loved the relic steps where they were allowed to achieve more than one thing during a single run of whatever content worked for them. That balance was there for a majority of the SHB relic why not use Variants to continue doing that?
Personally would prefer having "just " story dungeon and a couple of side quest dungeons with good reward and the rest being filled up with V&C dungeons because they are so much fun but their loot tables need to expanded upon in a big way.
I'm really hoping they roll the dice and try out an MSQ variant/criterion dungeon in 7.0. See if it works out, and maybe try incorporating it into the MSQ going forward. So what if it means getting one or two less new dungeons in leveling roulette? Does anyone really care?
@@talancorwell hell why cant variant dungeons *be* in leveling roulette? They've already got DF matchmaking and they're not that crazy.
@@talancorwell Now that would be a really good idea ngl. And it keeps the story dungeons runs fresh as well or a longer life expactency . I would also go as far that specific paths give specific gear drops . And maybe even a step further "mystery blueprints" collect all the blueprints of all paths and get x weapon frame to build a specific weapon you want and then the more patches come out the more you build this weapon . Sounds maybe like a relic grind but I think this would shake everything up really well
The problem with 2 minute meta are raid buffs. They design bosses around 2 minutes ffs. Most recent examples are P9S where you do your 2 minute burst before limit cut and P12S P1 where you get to limit cut just before your 2 minute burst. Imagine if they removed raid buffs and gave you personal cooldowns with like 15/30/60 timers and buffed your core rotation. It would also open more options on boss design as well since you have several personal “burst” windows now and don’t revolve around 2 minute group buffs.
Dungeon wise, I enjoy ARR ones a bit, like Haukke manor is fun for tanking with what you can do. Ads that can be stunned or silenced, bosses can be stunned and silenced which makes for a fun double boss with the imp and skeleton if you pay attention to that. The imp uses ice spikes on pull and on time with the CD of silence and the skeleton aoes not long after and that comes back with the CD of stun, simple but fun when you just make them do nothing.
I'd rather have more variant dungeons than normal dungeons anyday. In fact, I've been saying there should be different paths since StormBlood because every dungeon as a tank, healer or DPS is literally the SAME thing. There are two pulls between each boss, there are always 3 bosses(there's one or two with 4. OOoOoOoOOoOo!),and the only thing that changes are the mechanics and music depending on the expansion. The rewards become junk that's only good for glam or seals and seals are only good for FC boosts or gil. . . The minions are a nice new touch but I could go for more variants and less dungeons any day.
Dungeons need to have some re playability. Not including Variant's, there is one, count them, one dungeon that has a mount as low-ish drop %, Ala Mhigo. Yeah one in then years. Dungeons will probably never give us a "pre raid BIS" gear but at least give them more than a few minions per expansion. Give them mounts or rare drop glam pieces that have unique looks/glows, but mostly mounts.
I think having a handful of dungeons with rare mount drops like Ala Mhigo would do more good than harm for the game. I wonder why they stopped doing that after 4.0.
game just has a really low mount collection in general, rare mobs like ss should drop mounts , rare nodes having a chance to drop mounts would be neat etc. FF14 dungeons have a lot of minions but they are usually really high drop rate, or really low + on MB. Minions are already infinitely less important to people than mounts, and grinding either 10 hours for one or 10 minutes are both non satisfactory @@Enderlinkpawnu
The biggest flaw I see is 50/60/70/80 dungeons being poor sources of xp. If you're leveling a job, you're always picking the highest level leveling dungeon, in which case you only have one best choice. ONE. You might settle for a 2-4 level lower dungeon to break the monotony, but that's it. So in my job leveling experience, I've played too many x1, x3, x5, x7, x9 dungeons and hardly any x0 dungeons. Really a missed opportunity here.
@@Enderlinkpawnuthey need them for the Shop
@@aydenmartin5650 A lot of mounts are saved for the new thing they want you to spend time on even if it's kinda dull and not super fun to do (Ishgard rebuilding/Island Sanctuary) while roulettes will ensure dungeons will always be run regardless.
The part about Titan EX back in ARR was spot on. I struggled for months trying to clear that fight in PF (fairly light schedule, maybe for an hour or two on the weekends). I knew the fight but every group I ever got into would always have one or two people who would suddenly start DCing, lag during landslides, or just not know what they were doing. I didn't get the clear until I gave up on PF clear parties and decided to give Duty Finder a shot.
"Have you really done all of it?" That's the most stupid question on the history of stupid questions. I'm sorry, no one should need to count on old content. The problem people has/have with Endwalker is no inovation, nothing to keep you subbed to the game more than 2-3 weeks/patch. Stop patronizing me dude.
I think what would be cool for unreal is one unreal trial and one unreal raid. Imagine fighting Nael or Alexander at level 100? It would be fun.
The 2 minute argument xeno makes at 43:20 does not apply to all jobs. Drg for example, did not get buttons removed save for the life of the dragoon button, which is negligible, but because everything is 2 minute and 1 minute instead of 90 seconds, 2 minutes, and 3 minutes, all the planning of dragoon's burst phase/gauge got extremely simplified where we don't have to think about how and when to build up Life of the dragoon. That kind of difference was made purely just because of the new 2 minute meta, not because DRG had anything removed. Now, the difference between a great drg and an ok drg is whether or not you've been pressing you're buttons on cooldown, and even then, the competition at high level devolves down to just crit rng instead of planning and execution.
DRG and BLM got out well, but those are two jobs of quite a few. A lot of jobs got things shifted around to fit the meta. PLD and SMN needed to be reworked and NIN's dot had to go because full uptime dot damage didn't fit. MNK needed Blitz because it needed high potency hits that crit for a lot for 2mins. Ninja's trick attack debuff has been moved to mug on 2 mins, so the one minute burst doesn't matter on jobs that don't have a 1min personal buff or 60sec cooldowns. It feels like a lot changed so 2mins could be viable.
@@Jay-mx5ky sure, but the 2 minute meta sacrificed the planning and execution that high end players could have that could make the difference between a savage raid kill at 8 or 9 minutes, or a speed kill at around 7 minutes which would skip major mechanics like E6S conflag. now, we can't even skip stuff like that because the damage variance in high execution/planning is made negligible. sure the floor may have risen up, but the ceiling got dropped hard. we are all literally just doing the same things between trying to speed kill or just get a clear as opposed to before.
@SetsunaFSeieiGN02 I get that for sure. My main issue is the strict job design where every class needs their strongest abilities available at 2mins or on a 1/2min cd. I personally think there should be less raidbuffs and more of an emphasis on single target buffs so that jobs can be on different burst timings (or do sustain damage) and they can work together with support style classes like dancer and astro to optimize damage while (most) raidbuff potency gets baked into everyone's kit. It gives people something to optimize for speed kills (both the buff classes and the buffed class can coordinate when to receive/burst), while also balancing out the damage output difference between unoptimized comps and restoring different job styles.
@@SetsunaFSeieiGN02>now we cant even skip stuff like that
??
You can skip chain IIA in P12S iirc what. Skipping mech is still possible
@@lucasvallet4487 thats only phase 1, and that skip is only the difference between like 6:40 to 7:30. i'm talking about skips that skip a whole 3 ass minutes of a fight plus some of the mechanic walls. we can't skip HH or letter of the law or caloric 2 or classical 2.
they made me give up my seat for someone else for the 2016 fan fest proto ultima all tank fight. The person who took my soot couldn't even use WAR properly. It was an insult to me to being forced to give them my spot
Only reason I can think of for people to like expert dungeons is that they like to do max level for the expansion dungeons. So complete move sets that are different than what you are used to.
I like expert dungeons coz I can mass pull everything with basically zero effort coz OP af with bis gear, and then I can farm my tome cap super quick just spamming expert and doing the shorter roulettes once (normal raid and trial roulette). I already have my tome cap hours before I savage raid in the evening, so I can jus do my weekly coin on alliance and all other weekly stuff and then after raid I am done for the week all on the one day.
NiER are my favorite raids, but i'm just a 2B simp. I like the music and the aesthetic.
SE did those teleport points like that bcz they just gave us flying and they wanted to keep exploration alive. Now the farthest location from a teleport point is like less than 30 seconds away, besides garlemald
Turn Lord Harchefaunt into the most stone cold Ice of Asciensz…
5:43 That plot point was dropped about the eyes, because it was a mis-translation. I don't remember what the OG JPN lines are, but it's not that.
As a free trial knowing only ARR through STB so far, I've noticed that HW is the single most guilty of the three with mistranslations. Besides Y'shtola's vision, another example (spoilers)...
... is where upon finding out about Lucia (lvl58-59 msq), Alphinaud remarks in EN he doesn't doubt her loyalty to Aymeric but expressed concern about her loyalty to her sister. In JP with the latter half of the dialogue, he instead directly asks what she thinks of us because of what we did to her sister.
Throughout the whole msq, characters refer to our planet as "star" in EN, but in JP, 惑星 (wakusei, planet) can be colloquially abbreviated to 星 (hoshi, star). The characters are really still talking about the planet. Unless Renaissance era English also didn't make the distinction between star and planet, I consider this more mistake than anything.
my biggest gripe with endwalker is it didnt feel like i really had anything to do for large portions of the expansion. im a PVE players, so i do ultimates, savage, extremes, deep dungeons etc. Now savages/extremes/ultimates, yes, i never fully expect those to last long for me, i get my gear and i dip out, so its not like thats ALL i log in for. but this expansion im finding more often than not i just dont have any content i care to partake in left, and i just raid log for fun with friends, which is more spending time with them than me actually wanting to play the game.
Like i see the content is being put out. but none of it feels like its lasting very long. crystaline conflict was fun, for like a month. Criterian dungeons were cool at first, but the more i do them, the more im dissapointed because of what they could have been.
Maybe im just jaded, but none of the content has that replayability factor to me.
They won’t put the drg dot on full thrust, they’ll give them a stand-alone button that doesn’t interact with the rest of their kit like rpr :)
You mean like Heavy Thrust? Or Phlebotomize?
I will say that Bozja is amazing for grinding. When I finally unlocked Bozja I was so happy to not be forced to do tribal quests and go straight into roulette again. Yes, it's just as mindless, but at least you have a bunch of people around you rallying from FATE to FATE and just kill shit, which in itself is kinda fun in bursts.
I get why people like it, but I personally find it intensely dull. I really dislike having even a small chance to not get into an engagement, and I don't enjoy asking for party invites because people disband all the time for seemingly no reason. Bozja was alright, but I'm happy to never go back.
Unfortunately Bozja was a hard miss for me, the intention was there, the execution was almost there, but it didn't quite hit the mark. I even enjoyed Eureka far more than what I did with Bozja. But having nothing for a relic is just so incredibly stupid and a huge sign of laziness. Literally every single expansion including ARR has had better relic quests than what EW does.
I won't get on Xenos for forgetting Papalymo. He's the least developed Scion and you only really interact with him prior to that if you started in Gridania and during the Ramuh stuff. The only other one who's as forgettable at the end of HVW is Urianger, as you only interact with him in ARR to unlock the various primal trials and the WoD last bit. Urianger is just a guy who speaks weird until ShB, where he becomes interesting.
Imma say this. No other expansion tried more new innovative things than HW. Yes the expansion had big flaws but it paved the way for the rest of the expansions
This right here
Gotta be ambitious and flawed to let your successors pick up the pieces and refine, imo. It’s good to criticize HW because it was incredibly flawed but what you said is absolutely true.
hmm, let's see if this holds out, using EW as a comparison since this is what is all about
HW Innovations: 1-Deep Dungeons, 2-Crafting and Gathering reworks, 3-DC PF, 4-Diadem, 5-Custom Deliveries, 6-Aether Currents, 7-LoV
EW Innovations: 1-CC, 2-PVP Rework, 3-V/C Dungeons, 4-Island Sanctuary, 5-Non Grindy Relics, 6-DC Travel, 7-The 2 min META
While HW did pave the way for other Expansions by showing the devs what they shouldn't do 'cause they screwed pretty much anything they touched, in reality the things that ppl like the most i.e. story and raiding were paved outside of HW. The story structure and narrative cadence were paved in the latter patches of ARR, while modern raid design was established in SB. Even the "same old" EW tried as many significant innovations as HW did. Point of this being: HW wasn't as good or as innovative or as important as y'all remember it.
@@ronin1361 Not sure if I'd call 5 and 7 for EW "innovations", if nothing else they are heavily debated. And PVP is not without its issues either.
@ronin1361 HW is better because I say it is.
Endwalker has a problem with content replayability and longevity, not quantity. The reason people want forays and long relic grinds is because it gives you long term goals. On top of that players need daily incentives to engage with content. Why isn't there a Variant roulette now? How about a deep dungeon roulette with a randomly 10 selected floors from the middle of each of them? What about like a FATE roulette where you get dropped into a random zone with a 4/8 man group and you have to do 10 FATES to get the bonus at the end?
They want variant to stay as an option for branching story-based exploration content for the normal, and then difficult 4 man content for Criterion. Roulette would not work.
Deep dungeon requires the player to have armor and weapon levels to function well, queueing random levels would be ass. You can pretty much do this anyway with matching.
Fate Roulette sounds genuinely boring. They're designed around drop in and do it if you want, forcing a 10 clear to finish defeats that purpose.
They also quite literally added long term grinds in EW too. Bicolor gemstone grind for the mount/wings. Deep dungeon 4 clear mount. Variant path completions. Island sanctuary mounts. Treasure map mounts. 4 mil mgp mount. This is on top of the already massively long grinds still available to do in the game such as Mahjong Master, Big Fish, World-Class Troller... etc.
The content with the most longevity is the story. That’s basically all that’s left from Heavensward, so it’s really not as big of an issue as people say it is.
As far as daily incentives, why? Why do you feel the need to have a reason to play every day?
@@Salt_Mage cause people want a reason to keep paying for their sub? cause people actually like playing the game outside of watching cutscenes? cause people like having some form of goal to work towards?
@sDamon593 And yet when we had those in the past the vast majority of the community complained to high heaven. It's only when it's not there do people put on rose tinted glasses and say I miss this.
See, your first sentence is the main problem. The biggest complainers - and a lot of the parrots - are not saying that. Few people I've talked to are. They are saying there's nothing to do. Long term goals, short term goals, the rewards? Those are what are really are lacking. I think the litmus test would be something like Dragonsong Reprise. Is this not like, one of if not the best thing they've ever made? Would it be less quality if it had no reward? No. But you'd probably still lose some people. The title/weapon/plate flex is enough, and it's pretty understood we all like there being rewards.
"No activities to do" just means we'll get even more types of activity with even less rewards per activity. And longevity will likely take a hit too. Devs can't just go assuming you mean one thing when you say another if you're all saying the same incorrect line.
I also enjoy the last Nier raid the best. Puppets bunker is a second, but I am bored out of my mind in the first one. The machine life forms are just boring enemies to me. The puppets bunker can kind of suffer the same but the puppet bunker pvp at least makes it so I will sometimes get to deal with something interesting. The last tier I love getting to fight all the nier 1 bosses, so much so that I don't even mind how long it is because I enjoy the whole thing.
"who is Papalymo?" Lmao
7:40
Say what you want about the issues HW had, at least we tanks had stance dancing and enmity was a real mechanic. I feel like my brain only has to work at 10% efficiency nowadays, when I tank. It's sad, and not very engaging.
The thing about the 2 minute meta is alot of the downtime filler phase is really bad. You have jobs like rpr where the 1 minute burst is just gluttony, then you have something like sam that feels like its always got a good flow going on. Inbetween these 1-2mins your doing nothing though. So its really a 20 second burst, a 10 second burst and then a minute and 30 seconds of 1-2-3 spam with a resource being spent. Its incredibly boring
At times I hate Void Ark as much as CT too..if its not that, then Copied Factory, the other 2 NieR ones I liked
for me i want more DRS i want difficult content for free company's and we have friendly competition with other FC in our servers and then there is a leader board for the whole data center it can be a fun friendly FC rivalry
I don’t think people even want Eureka or Bozja particularly, they just want something similar and preferably something that’s even better. People like large scale content where you run around with bunch of random people. That’s what MMOs used to be about.
that dudes wesker mog should be a mnk , seeing him use a stick is weird
Xeems is right about the hildabrand shit. When I found out I had to go back just to get my relic I automatically hated it.
To the point where I was skipping most the hildi story just to get my shit and move on. It fuckin drags man
As someone who played through the entire MSQ in 2021-2022, Heavensward zones were amazing. Incredible visuals, music, and lore I could really get into. They're still probably my favorite overall group of zones.
I did the same but 2020 to 2021. Despite all the plot bits going nowhere the main HW story is still my favourite.
Max out the heavensward beast tribes and then come back to this comment.
@@ruily276 unlocking extremes were so FUN! Love doing a whle other quest just to unlock the harder version! I only ever did the moogles and holy fuck was that aids to do.
@@ruily276I did all of them and I generally like the zones still.
I generally play while I have yt or something on a second monitor, so I don’t mind some travel time.
Nanamo was brought back cause the story Andy's had a fit about her dying.
The only reason I have ever interacted with Lord of Verminion is because it has the Clockwork Twintania minion. Once I got that achievement done I never went back.
But yeah, I definitely agree. The FFXIV team has had a bad habit of not being able to write characters out of the story when they have nothing to do, let alone kill anybody. Thancred did very little in the 6.0 story and what he did accomplish could of vary easily been rewritten to not include him, and every expansion more and more of the characters join him in that pile. At this point I feel like he's only there because he's the only other NPC in the game (other being G'raha) that can tank in a duty support/trust.
Thancred had an entire solo duty where he and the people of bozja disable the garlean magitec when we first enter garlemald. He was the only one able to stop meteon because of his ability to hold his breath wad the only reason we did immediately die when getting to Ultima Thule. Like what more could yall want?
The writing team are just being very conserative and they are hesitant to do much with the main Scion team because they are very popular characters and they would probably face a lot of backlash from the community if they did something like try killing someone. I have no problems with the Scions, but they have really had all their character arcs completed at this point. Certain characters (like you said) like Thancred, Graha and Estinien have had their stories 'completed' for several expansions now and they are really just kept around because they are popular. I do agree that these characters need to take a backseat and they need to introduce newer characters for the sake of keeping the story fresh. At this point they have very little story relevance and are mostly just anime caricatures (Thancred is the dad of the party, Graha is the fanboy and Estinien is the sexy himbo)
I really really want you to make a video about the two minute meta. I disagree with you and I think 8 person raidbuffs are the crux of the issue, cause if you're not spending your highest potency abilities in a matter of 20 seconds once every two minutes, you're griefing. If your buff window is late, you're griefing. And most of the buffs in the game are just uninteractive "push one button to make damage increase" buffs. And the two minute meta has pushed dot jobs out of existence while limiting designs for jobs that can let you deal more damage by taking damage, deal more damage by protecting allies, having buffs that compound/decay over time (like old RDM embolden), etc.
I don't think having 8 person raidbuffs are bad as long as they fit the job fantasy (bard, dancer), but I think the fact that theyre on all but three dps jobs and half of the healers severely limits how much "harder", or at the very least, different job design can be. And they could use that button to add something new to the job.
The 3rd nier raid is still home to one of my absolute favorite non story moments in the game, i was healing the raid one time and my friend got hit by the building, i rezzed him and he happened to spawn on an unsafe train track and instantly died again
part 2 lets go
It's actually so funny seeing Wesker in these cutscenes
Please make a video on why the two minute meta is bad. I don't fully understand why it is so hated
Please yea
its bad because to make all the buffs, OGCD cooldowns, combos etc line up with eachother most classes had to be simplified so even average players can do the 2 minute meta without knowing their class intricately. And since most damage comes from the 2 minute burst window esp with tincs popped on 6/0 minute that means that optimal play outside of the 2 minute means less. As it is right now as soon as you pick up a level 90 class you can look at the abilities and based off cooldown time alone know your 2 minute burst, 1 minutes, and fillers
@@aydenmartin5650 Yeah but the "average players" have proven to us time and time again that no matter how simplified a job gets they will still mess everything up repeatedly. I don't think the 2min meta exists to help struggling players at all and if it does then it's definitely not working.
@@aydenmartin5650 That is a grossly insane overestimating the skill of the average playerbase to know and pick up all that information by just looking at the abilities/descriptions. Have you SEEN the people who play this game?
Its because a bunch of tryhards hate that people can play the jobs in high level content without thinking super duper hard about optimization. Most people that complain about the 2 minute Meta probably dont even raid.
I'm not the best when it comes to expressing my thoughts and feelings, but... Dark Knight honestly does feel like a lesser clone of Warrior.
Warrior self heals better than Dark Knight when Dark Knight used to be the better one because its whole gimmick used to be draining the enemies HP to restore its own back in HW and StB. Something it struggles to do now.
For whatever reason, Warrior's Shake it Off seems like something Dark Knight should have as a party wide defensive, minus the heal overtime. That healing overtime effect is too much, lol! Instead, I'd rather see Warrior have a party wide attack buff ability rather than Shake it Off. Never understood why it was given such an ability when it should be the selfish Tank; the main thing I really liked about Warrior back in ARR and HW.
Dark Knight spams just like Warrior, except it throws everything and the kitchen sink at the enemy(s) instead of just having one or two extremely powerful attacks. Think about how the WoL in the Shadowbringers cinematic opening basically two shoted that Sin Eater. While obviously, I wouldn't advocate for something that freaking powerful, Dark Knight in game should emulate that destructive power to a degree by having a build up gauge specifically meant for it to do a crap ton of damage with just 1 to 3 attacks, again, rather than spamming its attacks over and over again like a discount Fell Cleave Dark Knight. This way, it helps Dark Knight feel more powerful while also giving it a bit of its own identity compared to Warrior.
That's as much I can think of at the moment, as I'm having a bit of brain fart moment, but these were some of the things I felt Dark Knight has a serious problen with compared to Warrior. While I still absolutely love both job class for what they are (especially Warrior because I'm simple oonga boonga man), I just wany my former second favorite Tank job class to feel more like its old HW/StB self while also feeling more in line to what the Shadowbringers trailer tried to make it look like.
I'd rather have variant than regular dungeons, if they made them a bit harder.
Expert roulette is already easy, but last time I tried variant I just fell asleep, it's even more boring than the regular lvl 90 dungeons, I cba to do all the different paths for boring content like that, but if they upped it a bit where they are a little bit more engaging than regular lvl 90 dungeons, but not as crazy as criterion, that would be perfect.
That and add actual rewards to it.
I personally don't like the way this guy is comparing the two expansions as if they got released around the same time. Heavensward is 6 years older than Endwalker and in the world of game development, 6 years is a lot of time to develop new techniques and more sophisticated ingame systems. Another thing that must be kept in mind is that the dev team had literally just got off the mammoth task of rebuilding FF XIV and I can imagine them being fairly 'fatigued' when they started working on Heavensward. Maybe i'm wrong but i can see valid reasons as to why Heavensward is ''not as good'' as Endwalker.
Ya it's a garbage video without anything of substance to say except EW can't be the worst guys HW was way worse. Like sure I'll give him that but it doesn't change the fact Endwalker is mid as hell and lacking in middle player stuff or any sort of shenanigans happening in DF
Gamers:" Nooo, the open field areas are boring and grindy, we don't like it, please square enix make something better"
Square enix:" Ok, people don't like our Open field activities. let's try to make something solo for players like Island sanctuary"
Gamers:"Nooo, there is no Open field for endgame, why does Square Enix did this, is the game dying? We have nothing to do, it's boring noooo!"
I always said this and as a person who plays game I say this:"Most gamers are F stupid, they don't know what they want"
I didn’t like Sea of Clouds at first when I was getting the Aether Currents, but after hanging out there doing the tribal quests and hunting dhalmels for crafting it became one of my favorite zones. And I thought Azys La or whatever was awesome and didn’t really spend too much time there anyway.
I enjoy Dungeons, its just my preference, but l cant say Ive ever been of the opinion they are "Top quality" content, the be all and the end all.
Dungeons are fun to me because its easy and you can just do them, lol Im not an adrenaline junky like most Ultimate raiders, the one I cleared, DSR, was purely a from of closure against Throdan, finally killed the old bastard off! Being a Mentor on Materia is also a part of why l like dungeons, because the community is still growing its fun to help people and see how they are enjoying the story and learning the ins and outs of the game, jobs, rotations, crafting, dodging, PF & DF. Mentor roulette is a big help finding fun experiences in dungeons because there is generally a fun aspect to it.
You can get a fist timer and teach them or test them, you can get a bunch of Lvl 90 in a lvl 90 dungeon and go ham for 12 minutes pushing for a fast clear and you can meet assholes and great people like every 15 minutes. Hell when I play at work its great fun to just do a trust dungeon for 40 minutes, thats right a TRUST DUNGEON, its gets you tomes and you can do it at your own pace. Granted most people dont get to play at work so my experience is a little different, but doing Dungeon type 4 man content for the sake of it and thinking its fun? Yah I dont know about that.
Doing Dungeons for the sake of doing them as Baseline content is not that interesting outside of the first time, but doing them for the interactions and helping people, that my experience.
I started playing FFXIV a month ago and i am just about to start Heavensward, is it really as good as everyone says it is?
The story is somewhere below ShB, and above SB. The gameplay is nothing like it used to be.
It's all personal opinion, though.
The story is easily above ShB but thats my personal opinion
HW's story is either pretty good or really mid.
It depends on your tolerance for Cutscene Paralysis - an aberration that plagues JRPGs, and Squeenix's output particularly.
I have none, and HW destroyed my immersion about 3 times (SB and ShB for comparison had only minor infractions, until Bozja).
also IMO, EW's reworks of the old content frankly ruined a lot of its cooler moments - for example once you've cleared it, you may want to lookup what The Aery was like before 6.x.
first bow wow rawrr meow mrrrp awoooo arf nyaaaa~
Come to think of it, I'd love it if all leveling dungeons in an expansion were variant dungeons. It'd encourage interacting with things and give different mechanics if you prefer a different boss for your group's composition. Keep the rewards the same for each route and I'm in!
I think that the extra "hard mode" dungeons are more well regarded than Variant/Criterion solely because they expand the main lore of the game and feel less like optional content. That being said, Sildahn is absolutely exempt from this because Nanamo is in fact a main character and it expands her lore...but it's definitely a valid criticism for the other two.
Honestly though, I was so disappointed we didn't get stuff like Akademia or Anamnesis Hard because I loved those dungeons so much. They would have also fit in so well with the raid series in End Walker what with us spending so much time with Lahabread and Elidibussy.
I expect that a lot of people are going to be upset about the next expansion.
Even though we all know going into it that its supposed to be a step down from the grand story we just went through in Endwalker, i don't think it will take long before people start comparing the two and become upset that the new expansion isn't "one-upping" the previous one.
Maybe i will be proven wrong, but thats how people usually are. They never like taking a step backwards, even if its for the best in the long run.
Even though i enjoyed most of the story of Endwalker, i was actually really disappointed in the final ending.
The game has spent an entire decade building up Zodiark as an ultimate threat only for him to kind of just be a side-piece boss that gets barely any importance just so they can let some new threat out of nowhere take its place. It felt like they threw all of the story work they had done up to this point out the window just so they could make room for Zenos; a character who has basically no depth of personality at all and only existed just to be "a strong opponent."
Pointing out a wide variety of different things to do doesn't address the "There's nothing to do" issue. Of coarse there's something to do, and everyone is aware of it. Those other things simply hold zero value to people and thus they are effectively non content. I don't like fishing and mojong so you telling me my complaint is invalid because someone else ONLY plays fishing and mojong is just stupid.
That's my only problem with Wesk's video, the rest is well reasoned and portrayed, even the parts I disagree with. I'm not even saying he's wrong, just that his argument on that point is terrible.
"Who the fuck is Runar" Oh man, I knew chat was gonna lose it 😂😂😂
I mean its not like he is really all that important or memorable. At least not for me.
DRG already have a single combo, but it is 8 buttons long spread over 7 buttons...
does yoshi p saying they're only following players feedback, and they thus need to reach a consensus mean that there's a chance they might make classes harder ? if enough work to teach people to be better and realize how easy the game already is ?
Why should they do that? Square is a company there absolut goal is to make Money. With the amount of casuals the Game has now i think they make more Money then ever.
Also 24man Savage content is one my fav, would love just doing like atleast 1 fight 24man savage/trial per expansion, 8min doorboss 8min final boss? 24man to do with friends, or hear me out, 24man savage with an ultimate variant test
I’ll pass
I skipped out on eureka at pyros, but really enjoyed bojza since they had the actions in from the start
Honestly if I had a favorite extreme trial that gave me that feeling it’s cinder drift extreme? I think, Ruby weapon , before that I hadn’t even really did the extreme fights and i had to do it 76 times to get the mount I actually enjoyed doing it all day, than the warrior of light extreme I finally got to experience how it is being on discord with a group of actual people
People talked so much shit about Eureka I always double take when people get mad when we dont comparable content
this aged so fucking well with the new chaotic alli raids that are going to be added soon XD
on the topic of variant vs hard mode dungeon, i never thought too much about it but i think the reason i like hard mode dungeon is because it "simulated the passage of time" in a simple way (i know, pretencious wording). or more specifically, the quest around them to that. if Tam-tara deepcroft (and by extension Edda's story) became a variant dungeon, idk how i would feel about it...
I think the general sentiment behind the video is correct but flawed. It doesn't matter if HW had slightly less/worse content than EW since it was SB that set the standard. HW was an upward trajectory of content, whereas EW is on a downward trend. Psycologically, that is far worse. The bottom line is that EW should be held at a higher scrutiny since we are now 10 years into the game instead of 2, and we have also seen how the devs took the feedback from HW and made the best expansion in terms of content and battle systems (stormblood). Defending EW because HW was worse just gets us more EW. Critisising EW for its very real shortcomings gives us Stormblood 2.
I cleared Titan EX in DF and it was my first EX that I cleared, I actually believed it was easier than Ifrit and about equal to Garuda when I did it, and believe me, this was when I was still in ARR and terrible at the game during HW, it was pretty doable, that's where I learned to hold on damage and that was for the gaol, don't get your buddies knocked off the edge
On point of alliance raids, Nier is by far my favorites. The fact that they give same tomes/rewards when it takes close to double the time in comparison with other raids or triple the time if it's CT, is the problem. Raids themselves are the best.
where have you been this past patch cycle? the alliance roulette has been buffed to scale with the AR difficulty
120 tomes of TaPB, instead of 100 tomes of Orbonne Monastery is piss in the wind, when TaPB takes nearly twice as long to complete.@@Hugo-MTX96
The ghost of Haurchefant wants to have some words with you...
"They are gonna take dragoons combos away and give them to viper" bro you are foul for that.😂 I can already picture them doing that and even though i dont main drg i will cry for them.
Eureka is the only reason I stayed subbed for so long.
Lord of Verminion is THE BEST way to get MGP. Like 20k a week in 3 min of your time. And 40k during Make it rain event.
The Nier raid is probably my favorite one in the entire game and that's not just cause I'm biased towards butt robot. Good music, cool fights, top night presentation. Its great
Titan Extreme mate... we Sold that sht back in the day and I was our paladin maintank on a PS3 with 2,5 seconds delay and I still managed to solo tank it... Good old times. 😅
Sea of Clouds is pain when you have to do the Tribal Quests.
I think they should unlock all Unreals at the last patch of the expansion. You can still have the weekly lockout for Faux Hallows, but it would be nice to have all the Unreals available.
Then everyone would only do the easiest/quickest one and make all the other unreals pointless. I'd rather they be on rotation so people can get a taste of what they used to be like when relevant, even though it is still easier now with the jobs and skills we have.
@@theexiledones1 For clears, yes. But still give people the option to run the others for fun.
This game is in some serious need of some engaging Overworld content to get players out into the world instead of just sitting around Limsa. Things I'd personally love to see are Domain Invasions, Conquest(both FFXI Overworld content), and Hamlets. Just to comment on the first point in the video with the Zones/Overworld. The rest dude reminded me exactly why I was super pure casual from 1.0 all the way up through HW. SB was when I finally started to Raid and play other aspects of the game as well as catching up on content I left aside over the years. Also on his point of LoV, the devs swung and completely missed the mark with that, then forgot about it when it flopped....just like with a lot of other stuff...even things received well enough >.>
No one but me probably cares about this but I hate the new Shatter Frontline map. It is god awful and they should just put the old map back.
I think the new map can work. The real issue is that ice constantly respawns. Old map ice did not respawn so it would push the teams into conflict, but with respawning ice you can avoid conflict and still advance your score.
@@gamermasterL The playerbase in general almost seems to not understand how substantial killing each other in the kill-each-other gamemode is to your score. You steal 5 of the dead guy's points for a 10 point swing in your favor, murk an enemy alliance and be rewarded with 120 points while they lose 120 points. Not even factoring in Battle High's frankly absurd benefits. And yet they'd rather zerg 15 people over a single 70 point ice block instead of smushing an enemy team in a valley like a pimple for just as many if not more points while tearing down their standing.
@@gamermasterL Exactly. New map is just braindead ice damage simulator. So much so that if you dare to actually fight another person in this PvP map then you're throwing. Old map had room for actually PvP fighting and team strategy.
@@ambystomamexicanum3803 The problem is how long it actually takes to kill a person, and then if you fail to kill they can heal themselves full health instantly. Unless you vastly outnumber the enemy you're wasting your time and just helping the 3rd team win
@@MaximillionPegasus88 This is true. I'm fine with the fact that PVP is now balanced around CC and Frontlines will be getting more 'afterthought' adjustments since frontlines are kinda bad to begin with, but there is surely a better answer to 72 people having CC's killing power than a blanket by-class damage reduction that reaches the ridiculous heights of 60% for dragoon.
DUDE HE READ THE FUTURE. Difficulty of P9 but was a single fight. 24 man savage
Wait? What was wrong with Void Ark?I loved Void Ark, to this DAY I love void Ark.
I remember i payed 300k to get into clear party of titan extreme i do have a screenshot. The prog groups sucked so much bards dying to landslide, dragoons faced floor, whm healed in cleric stance and no swft cast raise cause lvlin thaumaturge is boring. Fun days
Azys lla is one of my favorite zones wtf...the music is a banger. Also I really think it's stupid to say a map is bad because of Aetheryte locations, it's about the actual design, quests and music.
Also they should improve Aetheryte spots in the old maps when possible.
I don't mind the zones, but the Aetheryte placements would fall under the actual design of the zone
@@biggestboss That's true. I should have specified visual design, as it's what I mean. But the overall layout/traversal is important. Especially before you can fly.
I finished HW like 2 days ago. I like HW maps more than Stormblood tbh
"Who is Papalymo?" YES! Finally! Finally there is someone like me! When I watched his death scene, and people were like sad and screaming his name, I was like: "Who the hell is that?"
I only played ff14 when Shadowlands was a mess, and honestly my favorite thing to do was farm the Nier raids for glams. I am surprised to see so many didn't like it, what was it about those raids that people hated? I though they were so cool and the mechanics stood out as more interesting than some of the others.
I don't think people *hate* the raids, just that it's really odd that such a large piece of content, usually used to expand on the world, was instead used for a crossover. The other ARs have an actual place in the world, expanding on or introducing elements that can or will be used later. The Nier raids are, afaik, purely fanservice, and are immersion/world breaking for a lot of people.
@@ThatGaymer Yeah it's pretty much this for me, I just didn't get invested at all in the story or the theme since I have no interest for Nier, it was a step down from the ivalice story/theme. But in terms of the actual content, they weren't bad raids at all, far better than the 24 mans from EW.
It's always been odd to me how much people fawn over Shadowbringers but then turn around and bash Endwalker when they perfectly complement and bolster each other.
I felt forced to do Hildy quest. I didn't like it or pay attention to them until I reached endwalker. Now I feel like i missed out
i can't believe that Xenosys is a skipper