STARLIGHT BOYS The Worst K-Pop Survival Show Ever?

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 22

  • @weareunitedasonefamily
    @weareunitedasonefamily Місяць тому +1

    For those just watching Starlight Boys and didn't yet to be a longtime viewer of the Idol Producer franchise, this survival program is actually the fifth season of Idol Producer or Youth With You. It was supposed to be titled as "Youth With You International" before it changed into "Starlight Boys", this said fifth season in 2024 is the first ever season that will produced outside Mainland China due to the ongoing ban on survival programs from the said nation after the controversial issue during season 4 in 2021 on the milk-wasting matter which is why they're circumvent the ban by bringing this fifth season in 2024 to produced in Korea instead.

  • @lostinthelightslostinthelights
    @lostinthelightslostinthelights Місяць тому +20

    I love Seungi as an actor but honestly his behavior caught me off-guard, he is an idol himself and knows well no one goes around performing for hours without a break

  • @Remerdre
    @Remerdre Місяць тому +5

    The last few seconds of this video made the point I wanted to make. K-pop concerts are not nonstop dancing. The groups dance nonstop for 2-3 songs, and then they stop to talk with the audience. During this time, they are catching their breath, drinking water, and cooling down. Several groups also do solo stages, where one group member performs while the others get a quick rest and change backstage. Making these trainees dance for hours is just pointless torture.

    • @SeoulScoop
      @SeoulScoop  Місяць тому +1

      Thank you for watching till the end and giving your input

  • @yoonlee2000
    @yoonlee2000 Місяць тому +4

    Lee seunggi is not an idol, to be more precise, he is a ballad singer. Pretty rich of him to judge on dancing when he can't even dance, and pretty rich of him to judge other people's faces when he's not even Cha Eun Woo's level of handsomeness. And for someone who never did idol concert, pretty rich of him to comment about idol concerts when he never had to dance for an hour straight anywhere else. Idol concerts don't even work that way.. they dance to hardcore songs for around 2-3 times and take a break with talk or video clips, and concerts also prepare oxygen masks, massagers, medic teams and etc, and they insert slow, medium tempo songs in between where sometimes they would just walk around, interact with their fans, wave to their fans or even collect gifts that fans threw on stage like plushies, flowers or placards. What kind of fucking concert dance to 20 songs straight with no rest, bruh?

  • @KVerse_KV
    @KVerse_KV Місяць тому +12

    One never knows, maybe incident was scripted to get all the attention it is getting

    • @Americarnaud
      @Americarnaud Місяць тому +2

      I think it was. It's great drama in the episode, it's a great moment for Sun Yinghao who's shown to be caring and not afraid to speak his mind, it's also a great moment for Ivan who proved his determination and great "I can do this all day if I have to" attitude, and it overall rewarded the trainees perseverance. It really feels like the whole situation was made to spark a reaction and great tv moments. And it did.
      And also the mentors are kind of right, if you can't dance 20 songs in a row with 30 seconds to rest, then maybe you're not ready for this. It pretty much was an endurance test. (And to be fair they didn't only have these 30 seconds, they probably had 5-15 minutes each time the mentors were deliberating before announcing who passed)
      Sure they kind of went overboard with it, like the first 2 rounds were really unnecessary since the judges didn't even move from their seats. Overall there could've easily been at least 5 less rounds, but the whole situation wasn't as bad as people say it was. Not it saying it was all perfect, but like come one... the actual trainee system that most of them go through is probably just as demanding and cruel as this mission was. People just didn't like being confronted to it on tv, cause then they can't pretend they don't know.

    • @sangailiupr7105
      @sangailiupr7105 29 днів тому +1

      ​@@AmericarnaudUmm that is also true, since they need attention for the show and therefore they are getting it now. Many people are curious to find out how far it will go n so they must have found another way to get viewers attention. The Korean music industry has always been doing things like this to get attention for the show.

  • @Bluesky9800
    @Bluesky9800 Місяць тому +6

    0:44 that's Jaehyun NCT 😅

  • @chaejennie7764
    @chaejennie7764 23 дні тому +2

    might as well cancel the show atp

  • @juliascarlet995
    @juliascarlet995 21 день тому +1

    Sebenarnya saya Airen fans Lee Seung gi, namun sekarang tidak lagi dikarenakan saya melihat dia telah berubah menjadi orang yang tidak berperasaan. Bahkan hanya melihat idol menari tanpa henti saya tidak tahan, bukannya terhibur malah terlihat tidak manusiawi. Tapi bagaimana bisa LSG menganggap itu hal biasa. Padahal dahulu LSG orang yang simpatik dan peduli pada kontestan, tapi sekarang dia sudah berubah dan saya sebagai fans sangat kecewa. Apa yang dia lakukan telah menghancurkan kerja kerasnya sejak dahulu.

  • @GirijaKadabgaon
    @GirijaKadabgaon Місяць тому +1

    But in starlight boys there are very talented boys we have to focus on them and we have to support to create best 9 idols

  • @GirijaKadabgaon
    @GirijaKadabgaon Місяць тому +1

    Now it's going very good

  • @nawalsiddique
    @nawalsiddique Місяць тому +1

    Why are these shows even a thing in 2024? 🙄

  • @jermainerodgers
    @jermainerodgers Місяць тому +2

    The most brutal

  • @ayeshafaiq
    @ayeshafaiq Місяць тому +1

    Lee Seungi himself is a idol....

  • @amnafaiq7909
    @amnafaiq7909 Місяць тому +1

    Lisa was so good as a mentor

  • @karinaapriani7559
    @karinaapriani7559 Місяць тому +1

    You say daesung, but you put jaehyun photos 😂

  • @ayeshafaiq
    @ayeshafaiq Місяць тому

    😢

  • @AyeshaFaiq-i1x
    @AyeshaFaiq-i1x Місяць тому

    😢