Anukul | Satyajit Ray | Sujoy Ghosh I Royal Stag Barrel Select Large Short Films
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2017
- What happens when a machine starts questioning our ways of the world? Watch the gripping tale of ‘Anukul’ by Sujoy Ghosh
based on Satyajit Ray’s short story.
Only on #barrelselect #largeshortfilms #makeitperfect #anukul - Розваги
Reel dekh kr kon kon aaya h😅
Me
Timing bhi match ho rhi
Teeno kisne dekhi
@@yadavdeve9450. Maine
Tu yha bhi pahuch gya.😂
There is possibly a dark ending to the story,
Mr.Nikunj knew that his brother was drunk and would attack Anukul but he did not strictly warn him against it(did not mention the consequence). Somewhere, in his heart, he wanted his brother to be electrocuted, so that he could get the property and money.
This is in line with Mahabharata's story (fight of cousin brothers over land). It was Nikunj's dharma to pay the bills and he would go to any extent (even killing his brother like in Mahabharata) to fulfil his dharma. In the end when Anukul hints towards his heart is a symbolic gesture to that.
or am I reading too much into it?
Yes, absolutely...that symbolic gesture was an allusion to their earlier exchange of "how do you know when it is appropriate to lie"...a very layered film and, as many have pointed out....more layered (and different) from the original story which is relatively straight forward.
Shounak Das And in some comments i see them trashing sujoy ghosh's take on this story.The original story was way too simple.This one is rather thought provoking.
SAPNO KI DAUR - A Middle Class Dream. A story of a middle class simple boy fighting with Education system's drawbacks & Parent's pressure. What will happen next?
ua-cam.com/video/H8CrC5as2wA/v-deo.html
That is correct, my understanding is same
@@shounakdas4654 Great analysis. I have a question : Don't you think the death of a human being should weigh heavier on the conscience as compared to being unable to pay house bills?
Satyajit Ray was a true visionary. This story was written in 1976... way way before Terminators, Transformers and iRobot... And the ones who are questioning the ending of the story or the motive of Nikunj should read the original story... that should give them a better perspective!!!
❤❤
Ray also wrote the ET script but no one in Hollywood bought it. Spielberg rehashed and made the movie. He simply let it go unlike directors nowadays who sue and complain.
ua-cam.com/video/yHTADwdDCpg/v-deo.html
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. My suggestion is read this book.
You realize, of course, that Asimov's "robot" stories were written between 1940 and 1950, then compiled and published as a book titled "I, Robot" in 1950? And that the publisher gave it that title against Asimov's wishes, as it was the title of a 1939 short story by Earl and Otto Binder? The plot of the movie with Will Smith has very little to do with either Asimov's or Binder's fiction, borrowing only the concept of Asimov's three Laws of Robotics, and leaving all nuance and subtlety behind. Asimov's robotics stories were psychological mysteries that explored how the workings of the three Laws might play out in actuality. We have yet to see a proper movie made of them.
There is book that has 101 short stories written by Satyajit Ray. I read this story from that book when I was 11 and I didn’t have any idea about androids. With time, I started to realise, how brilliant Ray was and he was undoubtedly way out of his time. Now every time I watch any episode of black mirror, I think to myself, Bengalis can make so much better short films with Ray's story that he wrote decades ago.
Can you please tell the name of that book ?
@@Abi-yu4vp golpo 101 ...you can get it from Flipkart or Amazon...
@@himashrinath7596 golpo 101 ...
@@subho07mitra thanku 🌼
ua-cam.com/video/yHTADwdDCpg/v-deo.html
I dont think brother attacked anukul, anukul killed him deliberately to serve his dharma of protecting his owner's interests. Saurabh also hoped bro gets killed, the reason he did not warn him much.
I think that's exactly how it went ....
But did the teacher deliberately ask Anukul to serve coffee to Ratan when he was not there..incase Ratan attacks Anukul and Anukul retailates....???
@@rdivakar6576 You are 100% right........
The brother has Actually reacted..........however Saurabh planted it by:-
a.) Ordering coffee for him (so that robot come across; he knew once robot come brother will try to kill him again)
b.) Not warning his brother about electric shock...........
Exactly
yeah.. actually that's happened.. u r very true.. 'm also think of this part,which you wrote
Exactly
World might have made the robot Sophia now but satyajit ray had done it a decade before..Hats off
Make that 4 decades Udit..The story Anukul was written by Mr. Ray in the late 70's or early 80's
Sophia Ka A.I. us level Ka Nahi h ....
UD true
Imagination is easy than science I guess
Ppl
These quarantine days made me realise that large short films has really awesome content films!!
But anukul was a clone according to original story.
@Ruchita Das thik kore poro,bolechilo clone baniye debe
ua-cam.com/video/yHTADwdDCpg/v-deo.html
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. My suggestion is read this book.
Amazing. The fine line between 'withholding' and 'warning' his brother of the potential threat is so discreetly shown! Kudus to Sujoy Ghosh (not surprising!) and ofcourse the legend Satyajit Ray!
Satyajit Ray had the brilliant visionary of things those are likely to happen in the coming and far future, beforehand...back at his days only a few could think of such futuristic concepts with such precisions.. His vision was his weapon.. his imagination was his strength.. Satyajit Ray was a creator himself!! Hats off to his imaginations & creativity!! Hail Satyajit Ray!!!
Addie Shiva absolutely true
Actually Mahabharata is something which was no less than a science fiction...long back veda Vyas thought about television through Sanjay...
@@aparajitamisra2475 একদম ঠিক।
"Murder mystery of Reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha is a wonderful book to read in the mystery detective genre. It has same flavour like Feluda. a must-read for mystery lovers. It has a feel good factor. Unlike normal crime thriller this book doesn't focus on brutality of the crime but it focuses on the mystery.
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. My suggestion is read this book.
*Satyajit Roy has created so many things that people can figure out new new concepts from them*.
IndiCoder 2V4u k.
I want to see those 494 peoples who pressed dislike button!!!! Weird.. They don’t realize who is Sattajit Roy..
did you know Steven Spielberg steal Satyajit Ray's story for ET? plagiarized from his 1967 hollywood movie script, The Alien. factordaily.com/satyajit-ray-mike-wilson-et-the-alien-hollywood-arthur-clarke/
Count it as 495.. I'm the 495th one. And it's not because I don't "realize" who Satyajit Ray is, it's because I probably have more "realization" about the man than someone like you who can't even spell his name. Let me ask you one simple question.... Have you read the story "Anukul"? Do you think this adaptation did justice to the piece? Do you really think Satyajit Ray made this bull-crap himself? No, he didn't. This is NOT a film made by the man himself. This is made by some dork who has simply re-interpreted Ray's story to cater the taste of the so called "youth" and "modern times". I.... someone who idolizes Ray, someone who grew up reading and watching "his" creation... find this "adaptation" DISGUSTING. I couldn't connect to a single frame of this entire film. That's my reason for pressing the "Dislike" button.
Here you have found one of those guys who pressed the 'dislike" button... Hope you'd find more
Hello, We have recently started the channel and made a short film called KAIZAD. I would really appreciate if you give it a look and provide a feedback, would really help us.
And if you see any spark in the work, please support us by subscribing, commenting or sharing. Thank You.
ua-cam.com/video/Ibm0vTvdM38/v-deo.html
i am not a bengali but idk why i have always felt a connection with bengal. whenever i see bengal in a movie or somewhere(the busy streets , yellow taxis, durga pooja ), it feels like home. Hope i visit there someday and when i do , it will probably be the best day of my life. #waiting
Always welcome
You can feel city of joy is not just another city, the city of culture himself is a character.. The city of palace have life... People can feel the soul of Kolkata. You must try bengali foods also.
Most welcome🤗..Where are you from?
@@MsPiu22 jammu 🙊
@@siddhantbucha8382 , hope I can visit Jammu and Kashmir once in my life..
Damn shocking ...Satayjit how precisely he linked geeta to futuristic world
orignal story from satyajit ray has nothing about geeta
Bro, in actual story there is nothing about geeta. Its the director of this short film who put geeta on this.
Actually satyajit ray was atheist and don't believed in a religion
@@sufiyantauheed691 that's wrong. You haven't read about him.
@@sr.137 there was a line on Geeta.
I came here right after watching ahalaya. Bongs got some great thinking
Lol thanks 😄😄
Both the stories are heavily derived from Hindu Mythology and it's Symbolism
Let's go bowling
*Wanna go bowling*
Nope bengalis got some real thinking, not bongs.
Sujoy ghosh again creates brilliance for the internet after Ahalya. Hats off to him. One of the best cast I have ever seen.
Wow.. this was a masterpiece.. the actor playing Ratan was too good.. I literally laughed when he said " switched off" in drunken state 😂😂 worth watching.
His name is Kharaj Mukhopadhyay. Indeed he is an excellent actor but very much underrated
@@sreejitaghoshdastidar1708 i watch all his bengali films... Especially comedy
@@sreejitaghoshdastidar1708 even kanchon was really good
@Debmalya Chakraborty khoob bhalo
he is one of the most funniest bengali actor ,he is like the poster boy of comedy in bengal
I read somewhere that the Terminator was actually plagiarised from a character by Satyajit Ray . And now seeing this , the man was way ahead of his time !!
didn't knew about the Terminator, but for sure Steven Spielberg's ET was actually a short story of Satyajit Ray.
Well its fine as both terminator and ET sucked as compared to satyajit rays original stories. They lost and he won
@@kart2542 I don't think so. Both the films are great so are his short stories.
@@WSTRNS yes bro...the story name was Bonkubabur bondhu
@@kart2542 lol they're worldwide blockbusters and two of the most famous movies to be ever created.
I read this story 15 years ago and I've imagined the whole scene back then and now seeing all those scenery live it feels magical. Satyajit Ray created magic in this story. Loved it. 😍
Can you tell me name of that story?
The projection crush my mind. i am in deep thinking, if we apply the same dharma in real life than what would be the consequence!
@@noshintasnimkhan3454 Anukul
I am very disappointed with the misunderstanding of Mahabharata chapter. Lord Krishna was encouraging Arjun to fight not for land and money but for a better society. Lord Krishna cannot fight for land and money. It is we (humans) who have a narrow mindset and use these words accordingly. This film can have a negative impact on the society.
What most people are forgetting to acknowledge is the writer of the story. Satyajit Ray has written so many sci-fi stories much before the creation of E.T. and other A.I. movies. It really feels bad that we Indians have very limited exposure to the works of such a genius with the exception of the Bengali people. Hope we can respect the genius and bring out more works from this great man in mainstream cinema.
If the non bengalees could read and would read Ray it would enlighten them in many ways.Literature is and was always strong for the Bengalees and as Voltaire had said "Literature takes the sharp edge out of man".
Very true
Ayon Dey e.t was written by Satyajit Ray himself.. Spielberg making it is a sheer case of plagiarism..
Dreams Gone Real yup... I know about that... I was just trying to be modest... Since I am a Bong, people would assume I am just bragging
Ayon Dey yes let's make this about bengalis why dont we
What a vivid imagination!!!
The very thought that this concept was thought of almost 8+ decades ago is surreal!!!
Satyajit Ray is universally known for his cinematic craft ... one of a realistic portrayal of life: human suffering, life's challenges-- poverty and illness, disadvantages of the rural folks, their aspirations, and sometimes even triumphs despite the adversities. It is almost inconceivable that the "Master of Realism" (the term "Parallel Cinema" had not yet been invented when his "Apu Trilogy" was screened) would even delve into fiction and fantasy. It is uncanny!
This story is written almost to perfection, with nuances ... Ahem... man-machine interface!
If you liked this movie, you should surely read ‘Adventures of Feluda’, it is a novel by Satyajit Ray, and trust me it is one of the finest novels I have ever read. 🌸
Amazing story...Hats off to Satyajit Sir👍👍
Feluda is a must must to be read short story book. Extremely interesting detective stories very very well written way back in 1960s and 1970s by satyajit ray
@@chalkabira5255 is it story of one detective or many detectives.
and is it just one story of collection of stories.
@@yashbhadouria5709Feluda is the main character. A private detective in the same strain as Holmes or Poirot.
@@kittycanary9802 👍🏻
Only few days Back I watched the robot human concept Short film " Carbon " and today this.
Man. What a difference between sheer perfection.
That was more of a commercial while this was more on the reality side.
Even the makers of " Anukul" chose the present setting to give the emphasis that we as humans will never change and our environment, locality, surrounding will remain as it is.
Take A Bow Sujoy Sir, Parambrata, Saurabh Sir n team.
And A Salute to the Legend Satyajit Ray.
Proud to be a part of this heritage.
With love,
A Kolkata Guy.
Ayush.
because it's satyajit ray....
This short film was great but I think you didn't get the real essence of the movie "Carbon". Try watching it once again. There was nothing wrong in that.
There is something special about Bengalis ,may be their genes infused with literary and intellecually vibrant seeds, what they produce is this beauty of a short film ,so enjoyable and ,so very moving at the same time .Loved every moment watching this little masterpiece
Seema Rawal
Read The hungry tide by Amitav Ghosh. You'll love it.
thnks...
Sala etne high tech robots ban gaye lekin yellow taxi band nhi hui kolkata main...
Very true
Seema Rawal based on a short story by Ray, one of the best science fiction authors of our times
wow!! what a story and the short film captures all the nuisance correctly.
Nikunj ji had to kill his brother just like Mahabharat. In his heart he felt that injustice is happening with him. An undeserving fellow was getting all the resources which are rightfully his, Just like Duryodhana in Mahabharata. He realized 'that ONE important thing' and stopped mid-sentence and ordered Anukul to get coffee for Niranjan. He knew what is about to happen. He had to fight and uphold his dharma.
What a brilliant story writer Ray sir was!
There was a smile on my face when Anukul hinted towards his heart in a symbolic gesture at the last...!😇
ua-cam.com/video/yHTADwdDCpg/v-deo.html
me also🙂
Sujoy Ghosh, Parambrata Chatterji, Satyajit Roy............ and a Kahani...Total Bangali nostalgia...... when in the last scene 'Anukul' keeps his hand on his heart and smiles, Nikunj ji's smile and smirk... I kept my hand in my heart and whispered God! God! and I was smiling :) Sujoy Ghosh makes actors express a lot through smile and how beautifully it works on us, we the audience. Loved............. it.
Awestruck. Flabbergasted.enchanted....no words to describe my feelings. I am definitely thunderstruck...
Antora Ali ditto :)
Add Kharaj Mukherjee as well in the iconic character list of Kahaani Part 1. He played the role of a policeman.
He is genius as always..
Antora Ali Omggg it's the great satyajit rays famous story anukul I heard it in sunday suspense
Those who are not Bengali let me tell you that it's a CLASSIC story by Mr. Satyajit Ray, he wrote this story more than 30 years ago... So You can can get an idea of his creativity... Nd honestly speaking I have like this one more than Ahalya... Supperb Acting by the whole cast nd the change in the plot from the original is also great!!!
The way Satyajit Ray linked Gita with the real story is fantastic 🔥
In the real story by Satyajit Ray
Gita is not linked like that
Its made linked like that by our story rewriter for cinema
Kolkata & Bengalis are love.....
I'm a resident of kolkata right from my birth & everything here is amazing except Mamta Banerjee
Watching streets & places of kolkata in movies gives me sheer happiness 😇
Who else from kolkata?
haha
I m also from Kolkata.. And the streets or glimpses of my city in any movie fill my heart with joy like you..But I love Mamta Banerjee too because she is a bold Lady ,a great leader and the CM who consider minorities as human beings.
@@prantikachakraborty7330 no it's not true... In fact there is no mob lynching in Muslim majority places....and ya we come from dessert...but inspite of that our religion is spread all over the world .... That is the beauty of my religion....NO MORE ARGUMENTS.OK.
I agree with you
Would you like to define why you not like Mamta Banerjee. I hope you will reply.
Reminds me of the game Detroit: Become Human. I am astonished to see how way ahead of his time Satyajit really was! Hats off!!
I thought I was the only one!!!
Detroit become Human one of my fav game! ❤️
All indians must realise that 'bonkubabur bondhu' by Mr. Ray came much before E.T and Bicentennial Man.Hats off to the Master!!
Unmesh Dutta Chowdhury
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
Nikunj never knew that his closest relative had expired. Also its a rule coded in the robot that a second violent attempt will be faced by electrocution from that robot. Having a conscience is a dimension of our brain to think in the most logical way. Logic is all that computer has. In the mid time Nikunj attempts to explain Gita as perceived by him. A rule and new learnings from Gita are the perfect match for self conscience. Artificial Intelligence, which has started with Machine Deep Learning is a death wish by us, Humans.
Anukul killed ratan to serve his Dharma towards his owner
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
Satyajit Ray was way ahead in his time!
Even his written story inspired the hollywood movie E.T.
Truely an amazing person!
Jivika Dhara ?? Story?
@@harshalmahajan3670 Bankubabur Bandhu
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
@@bookybooky2272 Thank you for recommendation
Thanks for Bring Back Legend Mr. Satyajit Ray in Our Lives in a certain way that much non bengali are not known That He is One of best Short story writer in the world.
Kishore Mukherjee... Truly said... Good to see such initiatives.
Satyajit Ray was undoubtedly one of the best short story writers in the world besides O'Henry,Chekov,Rabindranath and some others.
Kishore Mukherjee Omggg it's the great satyajit rays famous story anukul I heard it in sunday suspense
Satyajit Ray is Satyajit Ray, Awesome and Mind blowing, the Character played by Nikunj is brilliant, what a great artist.
I’m coming back to this film after a year and a half just because it’s one of the finest short films I’ve ever watched! Absolutely marvellous.
Just remind me of my school days when i was a book worm of satyajit small stories. Hope to see many more from sujoy
I am feeling very proud when see how Bengali director keep our heritage and carrying legacy.👌👍
অসাধারণ ❤। যুগের থেকে অনেক এগিয়ে ছিলেন বলেই তিনি legend. Satyajit Roy.
Very good short film,bachpan mein Satyajit Ray Sir ki yeh Kamal ki story pari thi,yes he could really think ahead of his times.Bachpan ki yad taza ho geyi.
What a story!
What a acting!
What a direction!
What a cinematography!!
What an piece of pure art! ♪♥♪
Prodipto saha Omggg it's the great satyajit rays famous story anukul I heard it in sunday suspense
Don't you feel that nowadays shaky camera movement is overused? Look at David Fincher's movies. He keeps the camera oh so integrated with the character he is showing. Here, in the starting, even when two people are sitting down, the camera is shaky. Kinda kills the effect and the scene.
*an acting
*a piece of pure art
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
Well said brother what a masterpiece
Imagine.. Satyajit Ray wrote this decades back!
Bedadutta Nag
I am surprised , mesmerized.!
Bedadutta Nag
aj sristi shuker ullase
Jivika Dhara
Bedadutta Nag reallly??
I am glad this short story was in our Bengali subject curriculum in class 12.
This is AI conceived way back in 1976 by the Maestro Mr. Ray. This is Epic..
anukul ne "gita" me padha. acche kam ke liye bura karna pade to wo 100 acche ke barabar he.
Ye maine point pkda bhau ne
ua-cam.com/video/yHTADwdDCpg/v-deo.html
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. My suggestion is read this book.
Story's gist is that Saurbh shukla cud hv told his brother about anukul's electric shock thing but he chose to remain silent for his own benifit as shown when he delibrately says nothing after saying "mat tang kar use , tujhe pata hai na ki woh...." and dat complements his situation with arjun that his dharma ,at present, is to get the property to secure his living ... AND Anukul on the other hand learned the fact from Geeta that to remain with his owner (anukul's dharma) in the time of his joblessness he must kill his brother ................ What a story... Or may be m just exagerrating it
what r u smoking?
dddd haha.. its old monk bro ..
Very true brother...amd may be his brother is playing kaurav who wanted to get all the wealth alone
indeed brthr...
U explained really well
Very different and out of the box idea. This is a movie showing future of humanity. In one hand robot is like more good human being than the real man. The way we r going a day may come when we won't get a good friend but a good robot.
SAVE HUMANITY SAVE HUMANS
Don't read my name This story was written more than 40 years back... What's amazing is the fact that this story makes even more sense in the present and in the near future scenario than what it made back then.
this story was written more than 40 years ago by satyajit ray..only credits goes to hin
Nice try......bt one think is very important in short film that is the dialogues......Satyajit roy always preferred #bangla....and there is many very Important lines in this story in #bangla...which is not so effective in hindi....!!!.....bt this try of making it for the larger audience is appreciable...!
Subhasish Bhattacharjee.... I think Sujoy did not get Bengali copyright. You know Sandip Ray's policy.
this is not the same story...
Sid-effects of new directors....
The previous version was much better....
The real story is always...The real story is available in Bengali audio-book made by Radio Mirchi (Sunday Suspense) with the same name...
It's never too late to catch up on good cinema. Here is an example I just chanced upon. My first introduction to Satyajit Ray was in school when we had to read Pather Panchali as a part of our English syllabus. It left a profound impression on my mind. Today, when I finished watching this brilliantly acted and directed film, I spent several minutes just reminiscing the brilliance of Satyajit Ray. Kudos to the director and the actors. Superb!!
Pather Panchali is not written by Satyajit Ray. Its written by Bibhutibhushan Bandhopadhyay and adapted and directed by Satyajit Ray as a film by the same name.
Saddest thing about this story is that you don't even need to think about robots. Already, children, teenagers, and young women are being used and abused as servants around the world, 24/7.
Watch out for Human rights first, only then you will see Humanity improves.
Thank you for sharing.
Humans are capable of converting humans to robots...as well as robots to humans...
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
Man I love these bengali type shows.. just came from watching Byomkesk Bakshi 👌
Same case.
Which one?
@@ratansaha3153 8
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
"It totally depend on us that how we see a thing" as every thing contain both good and bad side. So film shows how philosophy of Gita could also be misused.
How gita philosophy misused here???.. actually bhagvan unke sath tha isliye bizli giri aur murder accident hua aur vo bach gaye
Geeta designed for such a way that Bhramins can justify any criminal offence .....
@@LALITBHARTI999 fuck you rascal
If you have potential,do any crime prove/justify it by Geeta
1.Wealth in the wrong hands leads to disaster!
2. Anukul had all rights to give a high voltage shock to someone who tries to hit him and Ratan did hit him.
3. Anukul did what his dharma was.
We don't need geeta to justify his action. Gita is just a book and is full of life lessons. Any religion can read it and gain knowledge.
@@LALITBHARTI999 it means that you have never understood Gita. 🙄
Satyajit Ray is one of my favorite writer n then a director.....i came to know him as a sci fi writer first....my childhood fascination
i loved the production design and lighting of the film ..faces in shadow but light in scene
great.
ANUKUL....suits title, anukul, do whatever ur insight says, what ur heart says,
do what you find 'ANKUKUL' for u.
Wat a masterpiece by satyajit ray and the master himself.."sujoy ghosh" 👌👌👌👌
Wow, I'm really happy that such excellent films are created in a country where unfortunately every second commercial film is deemed as a mediocre one...Although no surprise, the story comes from a legendary director...
Man, this gave me entirely the 'Black Mirror' shivers...
I am very disappointed with the misunderstanding of Mahabharata chapter. Lord Krishna was encouraging Arjun to fight not for land and money but for a better society. Lord Krishna cannot fight for land and money. It is we (humans) who have a narrow mindset and use these words accordingly. This film can have a negative impact on the society.
Anukul is the badass character of this film.. But for a good reason. Finally something worth watching 😊😊
Finally....Some amazing story telling of Satyajit Ray short stories. Fan of Sujoy Ghosh! Please please please....Make Bhooto, Fritz and Batik Babu!
It was 1976 when Satyajit Ray thought of this concept. Not even TV was established properly, no internet, no personal computers, only old black wired telephones with round dials used to be there. He was born at least 50 years ahead of his time, if not more. A novelist with exceptional skills, classical musician with fantastic scores, an illustrationist to perfection, a film maker per excellence, and finally a visionary. His father and even grand-father were extremely talented as well, however, he outdone everyone. We lost him rather too early in 1992. মহারাজা, তোমারে সেলাম!!!
Came here after watching’Two’. I’ve now seen two of Satyajit’s films and they are both brilliant. Two for two. Can’t wait to watch another.
It's story in English text book when i was at my college 11th std.
And i am still remembered how beautifully the lecturer had explained.
11th Std. at college ❓❓🤔🤔
Stellar story 👌👌 Satya jeet Ray sir was genius 👌he was ahead of his time , just feel the deepest message of this story , excellent adaption by Sujoy sir 👍he is one of the best director indeed , do you remember masterpiece " Kahaani"..
Absolute masterpiece..this truely portraits that Gita is made for every little thing in universe it obeys every law. ❤❤
Darun. Eto din eta porechilam ba sunechilam aaj dekheo nilam. Parambrata is great always. And satyajit Roy is remarkable. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Satyajit Ray was a legend and always be one. No one has the capability of thinking like him. He's pride of our Bengal as well as India as a whole. We still love him.
Sunita Banerjee have you seen Vittorio de sica or Francis Ford Coppola or Akira Kurosawa or Ingmar Bergman ??
Have you even heard of these legends ??
Satyajit Ray was a great visionary, there's no doubt here, but certainly not greatest . 😊
Amit Jha
"The quiet but deep observation, understanding and love of the human race, which are characteristic of all his films, have impressed me greatly. … I feel that he is a “giant” of the movie industry. Not to have seen the cinema of Ray means existing in the world without seeing the sun or the moon. I can never forget the excitement in my mind after seeing it (Pather Panchali). It is the kind of cinema that flows with the serenity and nobility of a big river. People are born, live out their lives, and then accept their deaths. Without the least effort and without any sudden jerks, Ray paints his picture, but its effect on the audience is to stir up deep passions. How does he achieve this? There is nothing irrelevant or haphazard in his cinematographic technique. In that lies the secret of its excellence"
- Akira Kurosawa on Satyajit Ray
This this the best short film I have ever watched....and I know the reason....😄....bcz the writer is SATYAJIT RAY....the versatile and genius....🙏......and to all the actors and specially Sujoy Ghosh...hats off...they just nailed it....JOY BANGLA...😀😘
Bengali log ko to ayge he paasand na 🙈
@@gauravgupta7149 ,u have the liberty to go through the comment section to find out if only Bengalis have liked it or not..And let us remind you about Satyajit Ray who is known worldwide for his work..
We need more officers like this guy . Bless keep working to make Punjab a great place
Proud to be a bangali.....
I read the story about 20
there are many changes from original story..but it is really mindblowing directing
He (Satyajit Ray) will remain to the end of world.
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
গল্প টা সেই ক্লাস থ্রি তে পড়েছিলাম। অভিনয় টা এতো সুন্দর হবে আগে বুঝিনি। আরো চাই সত্যজিৎ এর গল্পে।
Who one after filmy 🇮🇳👳 Filmy Indian
Satyajit Ray was a man way ahead of his time. Salute to you Sir! Rest in peace ❤️❤️
In the last scene , 'Anukul ' seemed to be much taller in the background to his master in film, Sourav shukla; may we see it in that way that robots are becoming much smarter and higher than their makers in future....
Ultimately Anukul will become the owner of that inheritance and also justify it thru Gita....
Parambrata.... Great.. Bengali story.. and satyajit Roy jindabaad....
दिल व् दिमाग़ वाला रोबोट जो इंशान से शायद बेहतर आज की फ़ास्ट एडवांस life में.....अद्भुत Sir G... नमन बनाने वाले को....🌹🌹🌹
Sujoy ghosh naam dekh k aya tha ...or hmesa ki tarah naya concept mza agya...
What a beautiful short film it was, lot of love from Pakistan
Thank You Bro from india...
Ye kya chutiapa hai
Tum Pakistani bs atanki banao
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. My suggestion is read this book.
1.3 dislikes.
RIP knowledge😔😔😔
Satyajit ray sir a log kuch jante nahi hai in logo ko maff ka dena 🙏🙏🙏
i like kamasutra so you like that .? human is very difficulty .
Just wanted to know what are the chances of Mr Ray reading Saheb's comment and forgiving the less learnt ones
You can't make every one happy always
माफी भगवान से मांगी जाती है मुर्दे माफ नहीं कर सकते
Perception....I like d story...who cares somebody don't like ..
Theme was of story is truely shoked me
But at the site it is not joke
We have converted robort into dark mind..
It is in our control how to comand and use it..
Through out softwares
But some bad mind use them own bad aims...
Arslan Bhatti yes.and he has learnt also how to say lie
@@saminakhatun5994
It is a dark truth of our life ...
Classic actor acting wow....Nice story 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
The robot is the same guy who was the POLICE INSPECTOR with VIDHYA BALAN in KAHANI !!! He is a super actor !!~!
Rajat Dutta and also plays cop in AHALYA short film
Rajat Dutt a
Actually they both are in movie kahani the saurabh shuklas cousin ratan and the robot and they both are police inspectors in the movie .
Rajat Dutta it's Parambrata
He is parambrata ❤
Really amazing short film
Awesome and Mesmerizing background music tune
Very nice
Simply wonderful.
Satyajit sir,
U n ur creativity wll always remain in our heart.
It left so many questions to ponder on...Satyajit Ray was a master.
This is written by Great Satyajit Ray.. Awesome representation by Sujoy Ghosh.. Wonderful screenplay.. The mystery actually lied in the last scene.. Where it signified that Anukul can be hired forever.
Sabarna Chatterjee Hit like if you have already heard this story in kolkatas red fm sunday suspense in mirs voice ?'?
I read it long back. Later I heard it in Sunday Suspense
Mani Sarna Sunday suspense plays on radio mirchi not in red fm
No! The mystery was that the robot developed a conscience.
What a brilliant acting by Saurabh Shukla ji and Parambrata Chatterjee sir... great direction by Sujoy Ghosh and of course a great story by the master Satyajit Ray sir....
What a diverse idea and Saurabh Shukla played it with such ease and maturity. Just amazing!
Remember my 12th standard English lesson.
Beautiful story
Styajit Ray is my feb author!!!
Unki sb kitab ma por chuki hu!!
Anukul" is his one of best story!!!
And prambrat is my one of the best actor
According to me, there was some connection regarding his brother while saying kitne smart ho tum and later the robot proved that he was sMarter when he gave him an electric shock by performing his duty towards his master
Aishwarya Kulshrestha his brother was about to attack anukul then when anukul was about to give him an electric shock lightning struck very loudly outside when his brother suddenly heard it,he had a heart attack and then he died
Wonderful Film.Interestingly robot learn feelings and morals, but as humans we fail on every moment.
A big salute to late Satyajit Ray, the most admirable personality modern history has witnessed
what a Durga Puja Gift after puja,It's so special, From Sijou Gosh and his Team, Thanks
I had read this story in my school days.. Nicely picturised..
That Last smile ,by keeping his hand at heart was such awstruck moment. It reminded me the warm smile of lord Krishna in Mahabharata.
The guy playing anukul is Parambrata, an actor from Bengal....and he is one of the finest of actors ever..❤️😊
Thank you
10:40 ....glimpse of the future...... amazing work by satyajit ray👌👌
The robot killed the man very calculatively to save himself and his owner from accusation and also made its way to stay with that owner as he got the property
and therefore the robot fulfiled his own dharma
Self preservation is the dharma of Anukul...
I read a mystery thriller book "murder mystery of reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It was so compelling that I couldn't put it down. In words of feluda it was unputdownable. It's a must read.
What an amazing story.... My goodness!! All The actors performance were so damn good!! Loved it😍!!
This short film proves that even machines are better than human beings and they have heart too. Satyajit sir is great❤
I am addicted to these short movies..