Why Didn't Darth Vader Clone Himself? Star Wars Explained

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,9 тис.

  • @StarWarsTheory
    @StarWarsTheory  7 років тому +542

    Hey everyone! Should I do the fan-fiction at the end?
    Exlusive Graphic novel giveaway for this video on the fb page - winner announced this Sunday May 14th
    Winner of the Black Series Force FX Lightsaber will be revealed Monday May 15th!
    Good luck and as always...my fellow Jedi and Sith friends...thanks for watching and MAY THE FORCE BE WITH YOU!!!!!!!

    • @SkylierShepard
      @SkylierShepard 7 років тому

      Star Wars Theory f

    • @swiftflight7927
      @swiftflight7927 7 років тому +3

      Anakin in a clone in the 9th movie, that's why he was art the anniversary.

    • @Nonito2806
      @Nonito2806 7 років тому +1

      Star Wars Theory Are you still doing the Lightsaber giveaway couse i would love to enter and hopefully win a blue lightsaber from Anakin/Luke/Rey

    • @Paragon231
      @Paragon231 7 років тому

      Can you please tell me what's the song that starts at 4:00?

    • @matttmp
      @matttmp 7 років тому

      This is a huge long shot but if i do win the Lightsaber I would want would be a Graflex one.

  • @albedoyuriev31
    @albedoyuriev31 7 років тому +206

    What sense does this make? Sidious wants Vader to reach his full potential and now he's pissed because Vader can't. On the other hand Sidious doesn't like the outcome of Vader overthrowing him. Sidious can't have it both ways.

    • @Omegeddon
      @Omegeddon 6 років тому +24

      I think he just wanted a more powerful pawn. After Anakin's defeat he wouldn't see Vader as a proper Sith sucessor. Just an empty shell of what he could've been. Buuuuuut he could've fixed him so idk tbh. Maybe his connection to the dark wouldn't be as strong

    • @iwritechecksatthegrocerystore
      @iwritechecksatthegrocerystore 5 років тому +17

      What are you talking about? The rule of two is basically exactly that. The master is supposed to try and with hold some secrets and suppress the apprentice. It’s the apprentices role to learn those secrets and gain power until they can overcome and kill the master. If they can’t they die, and the master starts again. The rule of two doesn’t work if the master chooses a weak apprentice. So yea sidious would want the most powerful apprentice possible and to remain in charge if for no other reason then it would force him to remain strong and powerful and if he weakened at any moment: dead.

    • @SonofSethoitae
      @SonofSethoitae 5 років тому +7

      I am think he's mostly mad about the loss of prestige that would have come with having the dashing, heroic Chosen One as his apprentice than he was about the actual loss of power. I don't think Palpatine ever intended for there to be another Sith; he was trying to be the last one by figuring out Plagueis' immortality technique.

    • @submissivelover
      @submissivelover 5 років тому +3

      @@iwritechecksatthegrocerystore exactly, thus the courting of Luke in the original trilogy. He knew even Luke would go on to be more powerful than him and thus his interest was peaked and he pursued him...So why not afford Vader the same opportunity? all the years of manipulating Anakin and he'd say "fuck it" just like that?? Vader had 20+ years to get the cloning right, and find the proper limb with the proper force potential, he may have even gotten lucky on the first attempt, who knows? by why not give the most powerful force sensitive that chance?

    • @bigsleepy3211
      @bigsleepy3211 4 роки тому +2

      @@submissivelover Because Anakin's plan was to overthrow the emperor from the beginning. And especially after padme died, he had no use for him and the emperor knew that. If Anakin cloned himself and restored his potential the emperor would die sooner or later. He pursued Luke because Luke was a clean slate, he had no anger and no resentment towards him like Anakin did.

  • @darthvader8503
    @darthvader8503 7 років тому +599

    I could have had my limbs back.... welp, ain't that a kick in the sack.

    • @josephrobichaud2852
      @josephrobichaud2852 7 років тому +99

      coulda had your sack back too.....aint that a kick in the midichlorians....

    • @becauseimbatman1531
      @becauseimbatman1531 7 років тому +29

      Yup... but they caught fire.

    • @kenjongbill1797
      @kenjongbill1797 7 років тому +6

      66 likes

    • @jessevaneman473
      @jessevaneman473 6 років тому +6

      He could also have gotten his sack back

    • @KaiserMapper
      @KaiserMapper 5 років тому +1

      lord vader why did you want to destroy obi wan you can just be anakin skywalker

  • @leeswift2367
    @leeswift2367 7 років тому +391

    What if the First Order was able to bring Anakin/Vader back using his DNA that would be very interesting twist

    • @dylanw9030
      @dylanw9030 6 років тому +7

      Lee Swift well he was cremated

    • @jame1398
      @jame1398 6 років тому +30

      Dylan W He had a few limbs laying around Mustafar they could have cloned him from.

    • @dylanw9030
      @dylanw9030 6 років тому +23

      James R after like 20 years decomposing by fire

    • @jame1398
      @jame1398 6 років тому +53

      Dylan W It wouldn't surprise me if ole Palpy picked up those limbs for "reasons" .

    • @2bituser569
      @2bituser569 6 років тому +17

      During medical treatment some tissue could have been preserved.

  • @obi-wankenobi5145
    @obi-wankenobi5145 7 років тому +525

    He's more machine now then man.

  • @darthvader3472
    @darthvader3472 7 років тому +298

    I have one person to blame for that..... and his name is sand

  • @maledwarfwarrior
    @maledwarfwarrior 7 років тому +22

    These are good points, but I think the biggest reason was Palpatine kept information from vader and neither truly understood the process. A third and more practical option would be combining cloned tissue and cybernetics, recreating the bone, marrow, veins, & other tissue types while grafting on cybernetic modifications. A full life support system, power armor built into the suit, and most importantly a nerve/computer interface that would allow the user to experience pain without injury and cause agony on-demand. This would create a healthier, stronger, more resilient cyborg that could channel as much pain as the situation needed, while allowing leisure time to be painless & enjoyable.

  • @Ninjabot1994
    @Ninjabot1994 7 років тому +22

    "You cannot Clone the sexiness that is my Darkside"-Darth Vader

  • @Alias_Anybody
    @Alias_Anybody 7 років тому +206

    What if Luke actually joined the Imperial academy and became an imperial pilot (most likely IMHO), officer or Storm Trooper?
    Serious questions:
    There were some materials completely resistant against lightsaber strikes. Why wasn't there any attempt to build a complete set of armor out of these? Something like real life plate armor, or probably a "Power Suit" with mechanical support?
    Why aren't there counterparts of real life shotguns in Star Wars? Only powerful Jedi were able to manipulate objects with the force both quickly and effectively, so fast bursts of small bullets or fragments could probably kill Jedi easily. What's about "Blaster Shotguns"? Would they work?
    Less serious:
    What if Luke liked sand too?
    What if Ewoks were the dominant species of the Republic instead of humans?

    • @dragonlord498
      @dragonlord498 7 років тому +3

      the sith often made armors and clothing that were lightsaber resistant at least in the old republic and pre republic eras for example the armor darth malgus wore was made out of such a material. one isse much like why madolorians did make many full sets of full mando iron armors is the materials used were often quite heavy

    • @Alias_Anybody
      @Alias_Anybody 7 років тому +2

      Yeah, but some of that stuff isn't canon anymore, and why wasn't it used much more frequently? I'd go so far and question why nobody ever used a bracer or dagger made out of this stuff to parry blows while stabbing the opponent with the saber?

    • @Fion355
      @Fion355 7 років тому +2

      "There were some materials completely resistant against lightsaber strikes. Why wasn't there any attempt to build a complete set of armor out of these? Something like real life plate armor, or probably a "Power Suit" with mechanical support? "
      Well..for what should they use that kind of armor? Besides Vader and Sidious, there were no jedi. Hence no lightsabers. And if Vader wanted to kill you, you were screwed whatever you wore.

    • @Alias_Anybody
      @Alias_Anybody 7 років тому +2

      Fion Silberpfeil
      I'm talking more about the Clone Wars.

    • @Fion355
      @Fion355 7 років тому +1

      Would make more sense, but even then, it would be to costly. An armor for every Trooper, just because he COULD meet the count or ventres?

  • @Aramis75
    @Aramis75 7 років тому +21

    He would have killed Sidious and taken over the Empire and would have used the full power of the Empire to find Luke and Leia and turn them too ushering in a Skywalker dynasty.

  • @noahlat8478
    @noahlat8478 7 років тому +666

    What if Anakin had the high ground?!

    • @leithesocialistyuricon8981
      @leithesocialistyuricon8981 7 років тому +10

      Noah La Tronica lol

    • @mandalorethemaximum1408
      @mandalorethemaximum1408 7 років тому +9

      Someone saw the HISHE version

    • @czptv1193
      @czptv1193 7 років тому +16

      That's not the high ground way.. I mean the Jedi way.

    • @LBFlowers32
      @LBFlowers32 7 років тому +1

      Noah La Tronica then it would OVER!

    • @terryj7241
      @terryj7241 7 років тому

      Noah La Tronica you do realize that is covered in what if Anakin trained Luke and Leia?

  • @Necrolord76
    @Necrolord76 7 років тому +385

    How come Vader never cloned Padme?

    • @jaxusstormweaver2231
      @jaxusstormweaver2231 7 років тому +130

      Mark Dowling he doesn't want to love a shell of a memory or want synthetic love. How would you feel if your girlfriend or a member of your family died and you could clone them? you won't be bringing them back really.

    • @JJAG3
      @JJAG3 7 років тому +63

      Kieran McHale idk ask Juno eclipse

    • @emperorpalpatine3661
      @emperorpalpatine3661 7 років тому +19

      JJAG3 😂👌 good one

    • @KingOfShadows1500
      @KingOfShadows1500 7 років тому +30

      If he had, he would have had to wait for her to grow up and there would be a huge age gap between them.

    • @Carolus_B
      @Carolus_B 7 років тому +23

      Not to mention that it wouldn't really be her, just someone who happens to have the same DNA.

  • @vapenord2588
    @vapenord2588 7 років тому +31

    Please please please do what happened to the geonosians as you can see when Anakin is killing the leaders of the separatist (e.g. Gunray viceroy etc) you see a quick glimpse of anakin killing poggle the lesser

  • @bernardthompsonjr2347
    @bernardthompsonjr2347 7 років тому +9

    in the original canon, The Emperor did try to clone both Vader AND himself but was only successful with his own clones and made a few dozen of them while being unsuccessful with the Vader clones. One of his clones tried to regroup the remnants of Imperial Empire a few years after the destruction of The Second Death Star but was killed by Luke Skywalker.

  • @RepublicCommando
    @RepublicCommando 7 років тому +178

    What if Obi wan didn't didn't have the high ground

    • @obi-wankenobi3366
      @obi-wankenobi3366 7 років тому +27

      Ender Wolf it doesn't much matter, I would have won anyway.

    • @kaytee2251
      @kaytee2251 7 років тому +2

      Obi-Wan Kenobi well odvesly your a jedi

    • @TengenToppaTurtle
      @TengenToppaTurtle 6 років тому +4

      Ender Wolf he would purchase it In Battlefront 2

    • @zion795
      @zion795 4 роки тому +1

      Obi-Wan Kenobi you’re to dangerous to be kept alive

    • @IGDuarte
      @IGDuarte 3 роки тому

      @@obi-wankenobi3366 Master Kenobi... You are a bold one.

  • @Stormtimbers
    @Stormtimbers 7 років тому +22

    what the fuck why didnt the jedi just pump out like20 yodas then

    • @colekemper7383
      @colekemper7383 6 років тому +2

      Gregory Ensign they didn’t like clones they thought they were gay

    • @theevildrummingsithlord1492
      @theevildrummingsithlord1492 6 років тому +2

      It's really hard to clone Jedi. Some of them feel that cloning Jedi is against the will of the Force; others don't think it's practical.

  • @barney3268
    @barney3268 7 років тому +38

    Please do a theory on Vader cloning himself

  • @caspernibped
    @caspernibped 7 років тому +23

    yes please do what if Anakin Cloned himself

  • @drybowserman9091
    @drybowserman9091 7 років тому +1353

    What if Anakin fell in love with Ahsoka Tano?
    Edit: I made this comment 3 years ago, please stop telling me how gross this is now that I'm fully aware of the large age gap and why that makes it gross, because everyone else already has.

    • @leithesocialistyuricon8981
      @leithesocialistyuricon8981 7 років тому +56

      BarSoapSoup lol weird she is way younger right?

    • @lukeoliver9216
      @lukeoliver9216 7 років тому +94

      BarSoapSoup I think she's 5 years younger where Anakin is younger than Padme by about 5 years

    • @EvilSnips
      @EvilSnips 7 років тому +57

      No she was 14 when he was 19 so 5 years.

    • @AirbenderHawk
      @AirbenderHawk 7 років тому +38

      BarSoapSoup that would be cute.

    • @justinmayer6700
      @justinmayer6700 7 років тому +57

      BarSoapSoup smaller age gap then him and padme

  • @schellyebaldeo3188
    @schellyebaldeo3188 7 років тому +125

    What if the rebellion found the factory that created the clones

    • @garenbronce
      @garenbronce 7 років тому +7

      they still need the DNA of Jango Fett and they have to deal with the kaminoans

    • @Therapingunicorn1
      @Therapingunicorn1 7 років тому +22

      Schellye Baldeo the factory was destroyed by the empire

    • @theevildrummingsithlord1492
      @theevildrummingsithlord1492 6 років тому +2

      That happened in the Force Unleashed. But they went to a different area - Timira City, home of the Starkiller Clones. Now, if they went to Tipoca City, they'd be facing stronger resistance and wouldn't find much; the Jango Fett clones were no longer in service.

  • @BSingh-on4qr
    @BSingh-on4qr 7 років тому +87

    Lightsabres can be red,
    Lightsabres can be blue
    Idk what to say,
    but love these videos I do

  • @jemusushizao8780
    @jemusushizao8780 7 років тому +20

    Okay please do what if Vador cloned himself? (first going to the light side, than doing one about him staying in the dark side)

  • @mattb9471
    @mattb9471 7 років тому +11

    Suppose Darth Vader was succesful against Kenobi and ended up not needing the suit. What, if any, plan did Darth Sidious have for protecting himself from and controlling his powerful young apprentice?

  • @obi-wankenobi3426
    @obi-wankenobi3426 7 років тому +237

    What if Jar Jar was the chosen one?

    • @haydenleach677
      @haydenleach677 6 років тому +14

      Obi-Wan Kenobi noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo! You are going down a path I cannot follow

    • @PickleJuice76
      @PickleJuice76 6 років тому +18

      Obi-Wan Kenobi "messa thinks the jedi are evil!"

    • @bezkomentarza5622
      @bezkomentarza5622 6 років тому +6

      The question should be: what if he wasn't ?

    • @beebeenyneeee7692
      @beebeenyneeee7692 6 років тому +4

      What if general greivous added everyone's lightsabers to his collection? AND I MEAN EVERYONE. I guess everyone would be punching eachother to death

    • @Stormtrooper-ms1xq
      @Stormtrooper-ms1xq 6 років тому +2

      Vader FTW!

  • @Worsh7p
    @Worsh7p 7 років тому +142

    Has anyone else ever needed a nap after they wake up?

    • @seasmokeshand363
      @seasmokeshand363 7 років тому +5

      Flats That's lazy 😂

    • @OnlyTimefps9
      @OnlyTimefps9 7 років тому +3

      100th liker :)

    • @Mr.Postman866
      @Mr.Postman866 7 років тому

      i do...

    • @tman1095
      @tman1095 7 років тому +3

      if Padme clone herself

    • @OnlyTimefps9
      @OnlyTimefps9 7 років тому

      Tman 109 Padme, this is the assassin Jango. Jango, meet the beloved senator, Padme.

  • @kylebigelow5120
    @kylebigelow5120 7 років тому +1

    the theory you mentioned at the end would be absolutely amazing, I love your videos, keep up the great work

  • @robk1990
    @robk1990 7 років тому +4

    This exact question was something that Darth Bane explored. He discovered out that using the knowledge left behind by Darth Andeddu, Bane could clone himself & transfer his essence (or soul) from body to body with minimal reproductions.
    If Vader had been given access to Andeddu's holocron I strongly believe that he would have used the knowledge within along with the Empires resources to clone himself a new body & transfer his essence into a new healthy host.

  • @ArdytiBoltish
    @ArdytiBoltish 7 років тому +10

    Hello,
    I greatly enjoyed the video.
    However i have one note.
    The sith code goes:
    Peace is a lie, There's only passion.
    Through passion, I gain strength.
    Through strength, I gain power.
    Through power, I gain victory.
    Through victory, my chains are broken.
    The Force shall free me.
    There is no mention of pain.
    Whilst pain does strenghten the darkside greatly it is not mentioned in the code.

    • @obi-wankenobi3366
      @obi-wankenobi3366 7 років тому +6

      Mike Bolt I do believe peace is the word you were looking for. You said piece.
      So uncivilized.

    • @parkourisforwimps6985
      @parkourisforwimps6985 6 років тому +1

      Passion can be achieved through pain.
      Passion can come from different backgrounds, something that drives you and pushes you beyond your limits.
      Vader’s constant pain constantly pushed and taunted him, forcing him to battle through it, making him hostile, agitated, angry, all things he could vent into a violent passion. Through his own suffering, he could vent his frustration on others, which is often highlighted in the lore that pain and torment attack the more emotional sides of individuals, encouraging the dark side.

    • @parkourisforwimps6985
      @parkourisforwimps6985 6 років тому

      Thus, having the pain (passion) he meets all the other codes in perfect fashion. Continuously achieving greater power beyond what was thought he could achieve, and obtaining victory when it was thought impossible.

  • @elementaljedi9335
    @elementaljedi9335 7 років тому +163

    If you clone Anakin, wouldn't that mean cloning his hate for SAND too? life fact 😎😎😎

    • @jeneralgod
      @jeneralgod 7 років тому +3

      Edwin ZX when cloning, you can modify their generic DNA so cloned anakin wouldnt hate sand

    • @elementaljedi9335
      @elementaljedi9335 7 років тому +5

      You don't get the joke? right

    • @elementaljedi9335
      @elementaljedi9335 7 років тому +6

      And you can copy his hate for sand, Vader kept cloning Starkiller and all of Starkiller's copies had the same emotions as the original Starkiller.

    • @galagize9233
      @galagize9233 7 років тому +2

      What if Starkiller appeared in Rogue One

    • @elementaljedi9335
      @elementaljedi9335 7 років тому +3

      Kool-Wade Man then if he was with empire, the entire rebellion would of been doomed and if he was with the rebels then he would of probably train and made Luke so overpowered at a young age once Luke joined the rebellion. Probably even better than Obi-Wan could have.

  • @mega.5076
    @mega.5076 7 років тому +1

    your pun about Vader OVERTHROWING sidious was hilarious😂

  • @snowstorms5026
    @snowstorms5026 7 років тому +55

    Anyone seen the other Anakin?

    • @Luis-vy9bm
      @Luis-vy9bm 7 років тому +20

      Are you an angel?

    • @177SCmaro
      @177SCmaro 7 років тому +4

      Cameron Chauvin Don't forget snacks and lower gas prices!

    • @snowstorms5026
      @snowstorms5026 7 років тому +6

      +Anakin Skywalker, I'm not an angel, but I've heard the deep space pilots talk about them. They live on the moons of Iego, I think.

    • @scrubiam8439
      @scrubiam8439 7 років тому +1

      Star Wars Anakin Skywalker
      That would be one weird planet.

    • @darthvader746
      @darthvader746 7 років тому +4

      Star Wars Anakin Skywalker I see myself if u for some reason, or at least before I became a broken man...

  • @skittlezoreos8534
    @skittlezoreos8534 7 років тому +6

    I think the cloned Vader (assuming he eventually made a perfect clone of himself) would get the flashbacks of original Vader killing padme and would turn against him

  • @williamnewburn9286
    @williamnewburn9286 7 років тому +5

    Yes, please do what if Darth Vader cloned himself.

  • @novapanther2058
    @novapanther2058 6 років тому

    yes fan fiction love it
    and great video and i really cant believe how much this channel has grown

  • @elementaljedi9335
    @elementaljedi9335 7 років тому +146

    Do what if Starkiller had killed the Emperor? plzz

    • @Luis-vy9bm
      @Luis-vy9bm 7 років тому

      Edwin ZX have you never played the game? If you choose to kill Vader, Starkiller also tries to kill Sidious but gets crushed by him and becomes his new slave-apprentice. Starkiller wasn't able to kill him really.

    • @frankh.5942
      @frankh.5942 7 років тому +4

      +Anakin Skywalker Do you not remember Palpatine saying in the light side ending of TFU "You were always destined to defeat me. Do it" to Starkiller once he had been struck down? It was only because Kota stopped Starkiller from taking the bait that he didn't kill Palpatine right then and there. Now, whether or not Palpatine would've pulled some last-second trick in that instance is debatable... AND IT'S ALSO SOMETHING I HAVE BEGGED YOU TO COVER REPEATEDLY +STAR WARS THEORY. But, you have to remember that the Sith cared a great deal about the continuation of their Order. Just as Kota says to Starkiller in that moment "If you strike him [Palpatine] down in anger, you'll be right back where you started," I think it's feasible to infer that Palpatine may have actually let Starkiller kill him. Reason: The anger and aggression of that act would've consumed him, and Palpatine knew this. The Sith would live on through Starkiller. Also (another potential reason), it's worth noting that because this all happens in Legends continuity, the Dark Horse comics count... Therefore, Palpatine may very well have intended to let Starkiller strike him down and then return in a younger clone body to kill him in kind. What say you?

    • @frankh.5942
      @frankh.5942 7 років тому +3

      And even if you're going to take the angle of "Palpatine was going to pull a last-second trick to take out Starkiller in the light side ending," then you cannot deny the fact that Starkiller did have the potential to one day rival (and maybe even surpass) Palpatine. As Palpatine says to Starkiller in the dark side ending of TFU (which, mind you, you quoted), "You could've been my successor, my equal." Starkiller was only about 17 years old at the time of TFU, and to have bested Vader at such a young age is a feat no one else can boast (though I definitely belive Luke would've been able to as well, if he had been trained from birth). So you can't underestimate the power of Starkiller. Remember, in that dark side ending of TFU (which I would classify as Star Wars Infinities), he did kill you :) +Anakin Skywalker

    • @elementaljedi9335
      @elementaljedi9335 7 років тому +3

      Dude I know that, but it's not about if he had a chance or not, its about what would of happen if he had killed Palpatine.

    • @sneakybeaky2877
      @sneakybeaky2877 7 років тому +2

      Edwin ZX The Empire would be caught in a power struggle with Vader eventually taking over as the new emperor. Meanwhile, the new rebellion would use that time to have a much better head start to develop than in legends cannon. I can see episodes 4 and 5 playing out similarly, just with a stronger alliance. However episode 6 would be played out completely differently without Palpatine. I am not exactly sure how it would turn out from here on out. But Luke may possibly put aside his emotional attachments and kill Vader or join him. I can also see Starkiller training Luke, given that he would still be alive in this timeline.

  • @WhoaInControl
    @WhoaInControl 7 років тому +3

    I'd love to see the "What if Darth Varder cloned himself?" fanfic. Would be awesome

  • @sbbassslapper
    @sbbassslapper 7 років тому +20

    Fanfic, What is Anakin did clone himself, please!!!!

  • @ginantsfan5
    @ginantsfan5 7 років тому +2

    Most awesome vid!!!!! Would love to see a vid on what if Darth Vader Cloned himself??????!!!!!!!

  • @tobiastrust4232
    @tobiastrust4232 7 років тому +39

    In canon you can't clone midichlorians so a Vader clone would have had no connection to the force!

    • @Ghghost43
      @Ghghost43 6 років тому +21

      Tobias Trust in non cannon vader cloned starkiller
      Non canon is better then canon!

    • @VerdeMorte
      @VerdeMorte 4 роки тому

      Just give him a full blood transfusion

    • @reyskywalker5395
      @reyskywalker5395 3 роки тому +1

      It's possible, just look at my granddaddy :)

    • @Facade953
      @Facade953 3 роки тому

      @@reyskywalker5395 Too bad he was way too powerful and had to make new clone bodies all the time.😅

  • @Peter-gj4fy
    @Peter-gj4fy 7 років тому +1

    Yes do the next part about vader cloning himself.

  • @ANETERNALNEMESIS
    @ANETERNALNEMESIS 7 років тому +5

    It is possible to clone a Force sensitive individual, but those with high concentrations of Force power or midichlorians, whichever you prefer, are more difficult to clone perfectly. Since the Force is created naturally through eveything, it is harder to generate it through cloning since it is not a natutal process. That's why it took Darth Vader numerous times to get a perfect dark side clone of Galen Marek, or Starkiller, if you chose the dark side ending in the Force Unleashed 2. So I think you should do a fan fiction about Vader cloning himself, with Vader working tirelessly to create a perfect version of his former self. Have Vader realise he can transfer his consciousness into said clone, but while he is doing that the Emperor has caught word of what he is doing and interrupts Darth Vader. Vader manages to transfer memories and consciousness of all that was Anakin Skywalker, up to when he learned Padme was pregnant. This Anakin would have all the power, and flaws he had before, but most his darkness would be left in Darth Vader, making Vader conpletley rutheless and powerful. He started it like that to be able to bury his Anakin persona even further down in his knew body, but was unable to complete the process. Qui-Gon Jinn would reach out and wake this newly reborn Anakin, and guide him to escape while Vader and Palpatine have an epic duel. I would say this takes place 5 years after revenge of the sith. You can choose who of them wins. Anakin, having no idea what has happened or knowledge of what he did as Darth Vader, discovers what has befallen the galaxy and attempts to contacr Obi-Wan on their old comms. Obi-Wan, in disbelief, would agree to meet Anakin, intent on destroying him if he had to, but soon after seeing his former apprentice and best friend returned to his former self, he has hope for the future. He tells Anakin everything, how Palpatine tricked them all, nearly turned Anakin into a Sith Lord and how Padme passed away. He would hold back any information on the twins in fear that maybe Anakin was still linked to Vader, and that was precious knowledge that could doom them all if it was discovered by the Sith. He sends Anakin to Yoda to retrain and regrow his Force powers back to full power, in order to rebuild the Jedi Order out of the surviving Jedi after defeating the Sith, be it Sidious or Vader. I'd like to see Vader vs Anakin, but he might not be at his best to fight Sidious who would be angered by Vader's attempt to fix himself so I think it would be cool to see Anakin at full power fight against full powered Darth Sidious. Let me know what you think!!

    • @nopeace3689
      @nopeace3689 6 років тому

      William Martin
      Disney should call you or you should make a fan fiction find some people that will support you if an art or something bro cuz that's actually genius but that's just my opinion

    • @ANETERNALNEMESIS
      @ANETERNALNEMESIS 6 років тому

      Aaron Knight, Thank you bud! I really appreciate that, and if our friend at Star Wars Theory doesn't pick up my idea, I will definetly do a video about it and write a fan fiction of it. Thanks again!!

  • @dripchecklmao497
    @dripchecklmao497 7 років тому +2

    Please do a fan fic on Vader cloning himself that would be really cool

  • @KyngAllandin
    @KyngAllandin 7 років тому +4

    Right?! I think Vaders pain and regret made him as much of a juggernaut as he was.

  • @sdrewe99
    @sdrewe99 6 років тому +1

    Would love to see a what if Vader cloned himself scenario vid!

  • @v10_solar48
    @v10_solar48 7 років тому +5

    hey I got an idea of a new fan fiction would you like to use it what if Darth Vader was not burned on Mustafar but Obi-Wan still cut off his limbs

  • @frankh.5942
    @frankh.5942 7 років тому

    And do more about the dynamic between Obi Wan & Dooku, along with some stuff we know about the time Qui Gon & Dooku spent together. You mentioned the Obi Wan-Dooku dynamic in a previous video briefly, and I would love to see you tie together the Qui Gon-Obi Wan-Dooku thread.

  • @tyh6371
    @tyh6371 7 років тому +42

    Yes please do it and could I have a litsaber

    • @ohtosweg
      @ohtosweg 7 років тому +6

      shimon ganz it's lit fam

  • @deadmanwalks6018
    @deadmanwalks6018 7 років тому

    your videos are amazing man! thank you for all your time and effort you put into these!

  • @root9837
    @root9837 7 років тому +15

    do the wt if

  • @Observer-cp4if
    @Observer-cp4if 7 років тому

    These are very well done! Thank you!

  • @TheHalo171706
    @TheHalo171706 7 років тому +22

    why didnt Anakin clone Padme

    • @DropPodStudios
      @DropPodStudios 7 років тому +2

      Joshua Yates ummm that's not actually a bad idea

    • @supersaiyanjalil
      @supersaiyanjalil 7 років тому +1

      Joshua Yates oh shit

    • @riddledknight2755
      @riddledknight2755 7 років тому

      Joshua Yates because he was trying to save her life so that he wouldn't have to, at the time he never thought of it and never had possession of her body

    • @albertoswald8461
      @albertoswald8461 3 роки тому

      I think Vader had his fun toy burned off on Mustafar. So, why bother?😁

  • @Zephosnu
    @Zephosnu 7 років тому

    !!!!!! Another awesome video! I think a cloned Vader would be similar to a cloned Speedy in Young Justice. The clone would settle down with a family (maybe not knowing its a clone) while the original would drive himself mad with the idea of an unattainable better life out there

  • @DerSamalander
    @DerSamalander 7 років тому +15

    What is the name of the song playing at 1:51 ?

    • @obi-wankenobi3366
      @obi-wankenobi3366 7 років тому +10

      I believe it's called Sandstorm, by an artist named Darude

    • @zigzag0617
      @zigzag0617 7 років тому +4

      Obi-Wan Kenobi hello there

  • @nicholasadams5788
    @nicholasadams5788 7 років тому

    Thanks for making this video man

  • @BradSimkiss
    @BradSimkiss 6 років тому +3

    That was like cod aw zombies with Oz

  • @kharvey00
    @kharvey00 7 років тому

    I love that clip of starkiller and Vader @ 3:43 it looks like a revisioning of the original Ralph Mcquarrie concept art.

  • @digitaladventurer2142
    @digitaladventurer2142 7 років тому +5

    How did Maul relieve himself of "food waste" after being cut in half?

    • @jxmz_1357
      @jxmz_1357 3 роки тому +1

      He didn’t... that’s why he stayed with the dark side😔

    • @Facade953
      @Facade953 3 роки тому

      @@jxmz_1357 He was feeding of negative emotions.

  • @supremesystemlordra
    @supremesystemlordra Рік тому

    Oh this was 6 years ago but I wish you would do a full fan fic on this idea. A fully clone Anakin that may have some memories but not all and goes to find Obi-Wan... with the real Vader on his heels that would be very interesting and your fan fics are always top notch!

  • @hillisbenjamin5106
    @hillisbenjamin5106 7 років тому +17

    what if the death star destroy the rebel base

    • @warlordishere654
      @warlordishere654 7 років тому +1

      Hillis Benjamin there would be no kylo ren

    • @alexm6715
      @alexm6715 4 роки тому

      Hillis Benjamin It did...

  • @ghostdmodz7770
    @ghostdmodz7770 7 років тому

    hey luv your keep em coming I enjoy them alot

  • @nathanryan6050
    @nathanryan6050 7 років тому +29

    what if tuskin raiders never existed. pls make this vid.

    • @Polar349
      @Polar349 7 років тому +3

      Nathan Ryan There would be no star wars lol

    • @kuunami
      @kuunami 7 років тому +4

      Then we would have never seen Christian Hayden's stellar acting the "I killed them all" scene.

    • @tyrionlannister4920
      @tyrionlannister4920 7 років тому +3

      tatooine would be a better place
      racist?
      maybe
      its not racist if you belong to the dark side!!!

    • @Luis-vy9bm
      @Luis-vy9bm 7 років тому +8

      then I would like sand alot more.

    • @isaakpeters2735
      @isaakpeters2735 7 років тому

      Tyrion Lannister t

  • @jlyall84
    @jlyall84 7 років тому +1

    I would like to see a fan fiction on that. Vader cloning himself could have a neat story to it

  • @jaygon8656
    @jaygon8656 7 років тому +6

    I think you pronounce Galen like "Gay-len", at least, that's how Galen Erso's name is pronounced. I assumed he and Marek had the same name

  •  7 років тому

    finally happy this answers it, I asked this question about 7 days ago just saw it was released 4 days ago.

  • @danaripley1200
    @danaripley1200 7 років тому +4

    Who said he didn't? All that Kaminoan tech at Darth Vader's disposal
    the idea of cloning himself would be too good to pass up. He may still
    have his clone locked away somewhere waiting to be awakened.

  • @jonathanhillhouse9687
    @jonathanhillhouse9687 7 років тому

    YES!!!! Definitely do make that video of what if Vader cloned himself/had all new limbs grown and attached to himself and new lungs created to replace his badly damaged ones so he didn't have to wear his suit anymore. Or maybe even a video on what if Vader had a new suit created in secret made from the best materials and cybernetics available so he didn't have to have ANY of the old suit's features in or attached to it at all and he could function at the highest efficiency and power possible. Or maybe make both of those videos!!! I think it would be cool to see the outcomes of both possibilities/scenarios! I've always wondered how much more powerful, fast, vicious, deadly, and different he would be if he either had a totally different suit that was made with the highest quality top notch cutting edge tech and materials, as well as if he hadn't been so cocky, overly confident, and just flat out stupid trying to jump over Obi-Wan on the bank of the lava river, and instead had either just jumped to edge of the river in front of Obi-Wan, or let his little droid thing drift farther down the river and jumped off a little ways past where Obi-Wan was standing, and then continued to fight him, or just stayed there by the river if Obi-Wan had run away back to the ship and taken off from the planet. I also have wondered what would happen to Padme if Obi-Wan had done that and Vade just stayed there on Mustafar watching the ship leave, as well as what would happen to Anakin.... Maybe you could make a few videos, or 1-2 videos with multiple endings or something like that?? Anyway, thanks once more for yet another super awesome video! I can't wait to see what's coming up next, and if I won the latest saber giveaway so I can give it to my son for his birthday in 2 months!!! Thank you for doing yet another one of those as well man! It is so awesome that you do so much for the community/all of us fans, really. You do way more than you have to and that we deserve, so I just wanted to make sure you knew how much I really appreciate that and you. If there is ANY way that I can do something to give back to YOU for all that you do for us, don't hesitate to let me know man.... I am more that happy to do so! Well, until next time, have a great day, and may the force be with you always....

  • @a.m.p7807
    @a.m.p7807 7 років тому +3

    if Vader did clone himself would the clone have force ability

  • @brianplessas4009
    @brianplessas4009 7 років тому

    Seeing a fan - fiction on this would be totally SWEET please do it.

  • @johntucholski8808
    @johntucholski8808 7 років тому +12

    hello people and u reading this

  • @starwarsshorts235
    @starwarsshorts235 7 років тому

    vaders head passes through the shuttle 1:35 still gets me to this day!

  • @hidingman3578
    @hidingman3578 7 років тому +9

    What if Anakin said Hello There?

  • @carloscastanheiro2933
    @carloscastanheiro2933 7 років тому

    Another great video. Thanks.

  • @schellyebaldeo3188
    @schellyebaldeo3188 7 років тому +5

    What if 555555 never died

  • @CarbiesChronicles
    @CarbiesChronicles 7 років тому +1

    that would make great fan fiction, i would love to write a screenplay based on this theory...

  • @savvy2196
    @savvy2196 7 років тому +10

    What if anakin fell in love with Ashoka

  • @taunttitan1714
    @taunttitan1714 Рік тому +1

    When sith code never says through pain I gain strength
    This is the Sith Code
    Peace is a lie, there is only passion.
    Through passion, I gain strength.
    Through strength, I gain power.
    Through power, I gain victory.
    Through victory, my chains are broken.
    The Force shall free me.
    Nowhere does it mention pain

  • @noelgalloway3870
    @noelgalloway3870 7 років тому +3

    What is darth Vader did clone himself yes I want to see that

  • @NateLVBrown
    @NateLVBrown 7 років тому

    I like that FanFic idea !! 😅
    I would point to the Force Unleashed II novel for a basis of mindset. Starkiller's confusion, the extreme fixation on a single aspect of his memories (maybe Family in this case, or on being the Perfect Jedi), etcrera. 🤗

  • @timhutfless8135
    @timhutfless8135 7 років тому +42

    Snoke is Vader clone.

    • @carlosandleon
      @carlosandleon 7 років тому +6

      tim hutfless snoke is valkorion ihnabiting vaders body.

    • @stewiegriffen100
      @stewiegriffen100 7 років тому +25

      tim hutfless plot twist: the Vader that died was actually the clone, and snoke is the original Darth Vader (theory)

    • @timhutfless8135
      @timhutfless8135 7 років тому +5

      I certainly hope Vader is somehow tied to snoke.

    • @furges_the_lizard8240
      @furges_the_lizard8240 7 років тому +1

      Y'all stupid

    • @lemonchaos4785
      @lemonchaos4785 6 років тому +1

      Yo that makes some sense granted I didn't look into it still makes sense tho.

  • @dylangunn9845
    @dylangunn9845 7 років тому

    You should definitely cover that it sounds like a really good idea!!

  • @epm1012
    @epm1012 7 років тому +5

    Why would he?

    • @monsieurboks
      @monsieurboks 7 років тому +2

      To use essence transfer and get another body, if it even exists in Disney canon

    • @fireguy3217
      @fireguy3217 7 років тому +1

      How?

  • @jimmybisk
    @jimmybisk 7 років тому +1

    Definately would like to see a what if Vader cloned himself!!

  • @ashtonanolte
    @ashtonanolte 7 років тому +3

    Just an fyi, its through passion I gain strength not through pain I gain strength.

  • @flukeskywokker
    @flukeskywokker 7 років тому

    good video, definitely do if Vader cloned himself. I'd also love to see one about Vader with a grevious styled body (or more advanced robotics/suit)

  • @kevincalderon7349
    @kevincalderon7349 7 років тому +3

    do what if Darth Vader cloned himself

    • @Johnny_Serenity
      @Johnny_Serenity 7 років тому

      Lucass Cheese Factory how am i a Stupid?

  • @davidemascolo936
    @davidemascolo936 7 років тому

    Do that theory! I like it because two outcomes would be equally possible:
    1 - the clone is closer to how Anakin was just before losing to Obi-Wan, hungry with power, and goes rogue against the original or even against Palpatine too
    2 - Physically whole, without the lost limbs and painful armor, the clone has a clearer mind than the original, realizes "his" horrible mistakes and seeks redemption

  • @EvilSnips
    @EvilSnips 7 років тому +25

    Hello There. I'm early.

    • @EvilSnips
      @EvilSnips 7 років тому +1

      Woo thanks for the heart

  • @TheJaymanShow10
    @TheJaymanShow10 7 років тому

    Awesome video!

  • @surgeonslices9543
    @surgeonslices9543 7 років тому +3

    That's not how the sith code goes you noob, it's passion "trough passion I gain strength"

  • @ryang54712
    @ryang54712 6 років тому

    Omfg. I’ve Been asking this for so long! Thank u theory.
    U should do another version where What if Anakin was cloned?

  • @doctor1077
    @doctor1077 7 років тому

    The cloning story line sounds interesting. You should do that.

  • @franklindelanoroosevelt7467
    @franklindelanoroosevelt7467 7 років тому +1

    Do the what if Darth Vader cloned him self video please. Also do what if Count Duko was with Qui Gon Gin & Obi Wan Kenobi on Nabo fighting Darth Maul.

  • @onyyxxfirehazard8996
    @onyyxxfirehazard8996 7 років тому

    Hey, I would like to see where you found the line "Through pain I gain strength". The Sith Code is "Peace is a lie, there is only passion. Through passion I gain strength..." and so on. I haven't heard the version you're referencing before, and I couldn't find it on Wookieepedia.

  • @AzayBae
    @AzayBae Місяць тому

    I thought of this randomly.
    Like Vader had access to the technology and even made two successful Starkiller clones canonically (the main character of TFU2 and the dark apprentice that appears if starkiller tries to kill Vader)
    I think Vader may have preferred to keep the cybernetics because the pain gave him strength and helped him tap into the dark side.

  • @davidisho13
    @davidisho13 7 років тому

    Awesome episode

  • @holdenplayz8581
    @holdenplayz8581 7 років тому +1

    pleeeeease do what if Vader cloned himself. also, may the force, be with the best star wars UA-camr (you)

  • @Karagianis
    @Karagianis 7 років тому +1

    It strikes me, that the Emperor thought Lightsabres backwards, that the Sith were beyond them. Was perhaps making Vader's suit sub-standard meant to drive Vader more to using the dark side directly and to use a lightsabre less?

  • @RelleK41
    @RelleK41 7 років тому

    I would LOVE to hear your fan-fiction on a Vader/Anakin clone spin-off

  • @nicholashart2323
    @nicholashart2323 5 років тому

    Vader cloning himself was always my favorite what if scenario!

  • @gs3931
    @gs3931 7 років тому +1

    They could have just made a super advanced suit like grievous had, only with the gaps filled up with sand for the suffering.